Global Health
Applications
Health Promotion: Individuals and Communities
Learning objectives for this lesson:
- Explain why global and domestic health are increasingly merged, using globalization and the examples of HIV/AIDS and avian influenza.
- Describe the five ecological factors that send health along different paths in different countries, and explain the epidemiologic transition and what blurs it.
- Identify the seven types of actor in the global health system, and predict which combinations come into play in a short-term crisis and in a long-term prevention effort.
- Apply a PRECEDE-PROCEED style assessment to a global health problem, naming a data source for each phase and the political constraints a planner must weigh.
- Explain how social and behavioural theories must be adapted before they are used in a global setting, and which families of theory fit which global health problems.
- Identify the theories used in four global health program examples, and explain how Trials of Improved Practices and participatory design fill in a theory's constructs locally.
- Describe Canada's contribution to global health promotion, from the Ottawa Charter to Global Affairs Canada, Grand Challenges Canada, and Canadian non-governmental organizations.
This course was developed by Dr. Kiffer G. Card, to accompany Edberg, M. Essentials of Health Behavior: Social and Behavioral Theory in Public Health. Jones & Bartlett Learning. This lesson follows Chapter 12 of the text.
Glossary: Key Terms, People & Concepts
📚 Reference page, available throughout the lesson
This glossary collects the key concepts, people, and ideas you will meet in this lesson. Use it as a reference while you work through the material, or as a review before assessments. Type in the search box to filter entries.
The Setting: Health in the Global Context
⏱ Estimated reading time: 15 minutes
Overview
This lesson is a brief and selective introduction to one arena in which social and behavioural theory is applied. Readers who want a full account of global health should turn to a dedicated global health course or to a source such as Richard Skolnik's Essentials of Global Health. The question here is narrower: how do theories of health behaviour and health promotion behave when the setting is a district in Cameroon or Albania rather than a school district in British Columbia, and what has to change on the way? This first section sets the scene. It explains why global and domestic health have merged, why health problems still follow different paths in different countries, and how the epidemiologic transition describes the changing pattern of illness as countries develop, and why that pattern has blurred.
Learning Objectives
- 1.1 Define globalization in its broad sense and describe its five implications for public health.
- 1.2 Explain why it is less and less useful to separate global health from domestic health, using HIV/AIDS and avian influenza as evidence.
- 2.1 Describe the five ecological factors that make health problems follow different trajectories in different countries, and classify an example under the right factor.
- 2.2 Explain the epidemiologic transition, what blurs it, and how migration can carry it across a border.
- 2.3 Describe how a global setting adds outer layers to the ecology of health.
1.1 Globalization: One Shirt, Six Countries
The first substantive claim of this lesson is that it has become less and less useful to think about global health as separate from domestic health. The evidence for that claim is epidemiological, and 1.2 sets it out. The mechanism behind it is globalization. Globalization is typically discussed as an economic term, yet it refers to much more. Movements of people, of images and information, of resources, and of environments have all reduced the distinction between what happens here and what happens somewhere else.
The definition of globalization is worth reading closely, because the example that illustrates it is deliberately ordinary. A clothing item is produced in a factory in the Philippines using cotton from Egypt, sold under different brand names in shopping malls in Tokyo, London, and Los Angeles, run by a company headquartered in the United States, with customer service and data processing outsourced to India. One shirt, six countries. In its narrow sense, globalization is this integration of production and markets across borders. By this we mean the economic fact that the making and selling of a single product no longer belongs to any one country. In its broader sense, the sense this lesson uses, the term also covers the social and political consequences of that integration, such as who works in the factory and under what conditions, and views differ on whether those consequences are positive or negative. The broad sense matters for public health because health is affected by those consequences, not by the trade itself, so a student who reads globalization only as trade will miss most of what follows.
For public health, globalization has five implications, and each one follows from the same feature of the shirt example: a product, a person, or a piece of information now passes through several countries, each with its own rules. The first three implications concern things that are made and traded. Workplace health and safety become harder to ensure, because a product made across several countries passes through factories that no single authority inspects. In addition, the safety of food and medical products becomes harder to guarantee, because a contaminated ingredient may cross several borders before it causes harm. Environmental responsibility is also fragmented, by which we mean that when production is split among countries with different rules, no one country answers for the pollution the whole process creates. The last two implications concern how fast things move. Infectious disease gains much more rapid routes of transmission, since people now travel between continents in less time than many infections take to show symptoms. However, the same speed works in public health's favour as well: communication and dissemination are also much faster, which makes rapid communication both a risk and a resource. Each implication is illustrated below with an example, several of them Canadian.
Workplace health and safety across globalized operations
When one product passes through factories in several countries, each under its own labour law and inspection regime, no single authority is responsible for the conditions under which it was made. The 2013 collapse of the Rana Plaza garment factory in Bangladesh, which killed more than a thousand workers producing clothing for Western retailers, is the case most students will know.
Safety of food and medical products
Food and pharmaceuticals are exported and imported across a wide range of countries and regions, and often transshipped through intermediate destinations, so the point of contamination can be several borders away from the point of harm. The Canadian Food Inspection Agency's import controls and Health Canada's drug inspections exist because of exactly this complexity.
Environmental responsibility across segmented production
When facilities and production are segmented and located in different countries under different regulations and conditions, pollution can be moved to wherever it is cheapest to produce. The health consequences land on the population nearest the facility, who may have had no say in its location.
Much more rapid routes of transmission for infectious disease
Air travel means an infection can cross the world inside its incubation period. Toronto learned this in 2003, when severe acute respiratory syndrome arrived from Hong Kong and produced the largest outbreak outside Asia. COVID-19 later made the same point to every reader of this lesson.
Much more rapid avenues for communication and dissemination
The same networks that carry a virus carry information about it. Health Canada's Global Public Health Intelligence Network, an early-warning system that scans news sources in many languages, picked up early signals of the SARS outbreak before it was formally reported. Communication channels are also the raw material of the behaviour change programs in Section 4.
Read together, the five implications show that globalization changes both the problems public health faces and the tools it has: the air routes that carried SARS to Toronto also carried the early warning about it. When a question describes a product, a pathogen, or a piece of information crossing borders, match it to the implication it illustrates rather than to globalization in general. The next subsection turns from the mechanism to the evidence that the two settings have merged.
1.2 Two Diseases, One Setting: HIV/AIDS and Avian Influenza
The HIV/AIDS pandemic and the influenza threats of the 2000s, avian flu and swine flu, show that global and domestic health have merged into one setting, at least in terms of epidemiology. By this we mean that the pattern of who gets sick, and where, can no longer be explained within the borders of a single country. The purpose of looking at two diseases is to see that argument from two sides: HIV/AIDS shows how the movements of the global economy carry an infection between people, and avian influenza shows how an infection can cross borders that people did not cross at all.
Consider first where HIV/AIDS is most prevalent. It is prevalent where there are international transportation and trade routes, along which people and goods move constantly. It is also prevalent where rapidly developing economies create a divide between urban and rural areas, so that people flow into cities to find income. In addition, it is prevalent where migrant worker flows separate men and women from their families for long periods, and where people travel to seek pleasure. These four conditions look different, but every one of them is a product of the global economy, which is why HIV/AIDS counts as evidence that the global and the domestic have merged. HIV is also prevalent in economies that are hard-pressed and lack the resources or capacity to mount prevention efforts or to provide antiretroviral therapies that are manufactured and controlled in wealthier economies, a situation that has been addressed in a number of countries through the United States President's Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief, PEPFAR.
Avian influenza makes the point from the other direction, because its spread follows poultry and wild birds as well as people. As a virus that could infect humans it first surfaced in Hong Kong in 1997 and then spread to Thailand, Vietnam, Indonesia, China, Japan, and South Korea, with later outbreaks in Europe. In some of those countries poultry is both a major export product and a cultural tradition: most rural homes keep chickens, and fighting cocks are prized possessions. And because the disease is carried by birds, its spread also follows the flight paths of migratory birds, which have nothing to do with national borders. A behaviour change program about poultry handling in rural Thailand is therefore also a program about what arrives in Vancouver.
The same argument bears on what the field is called. The callout below explains the move from the older term, international health, to global health, and relates the newer term to the opening argument of this lesson.
Definition: Why "Global" Rather Than "International"?
The older term, international health, usually meant health work that wealthy countries did in poorer ones: health somewhere else. Global health, as a group of practitioners proposed in a widely cited definition, is concerned with issues that transcend national boundaries and with the determinants and solutions that populations share (Koplan et al., 2009). The opening argument of this lesson is the same idea stated through epidemiology. If HIV, influenza, and the shirt on your back all move along the same routes, then the setting of this lesson includes Canada.
The two diseases show that the routes run both ways and run through Canada. Yet if globalization has merged the two settings, a puzzle remains: why do health problems still follow such different paths in different countries? The next subsection answers it.
2.1 Five Ecological Factors: Why Health Still Follows Different Paths
If globalization has merged the two settings, why do health problems still follow different trajectories in different nations and regions? The answer is ecological. By this we mean that the health of a population depends on the conditions around it, and countries vary in at least five kinds of such conditions, or factors. The purpose of naming the five separately is to give a planner a checklist: when a health problem takes a different course in one country than in another, each factor is a place to look for the reason.
The first factor, environmental risks, covers diseases carried or vectored in a particular place through contaminated water, insects, or pollution, together with climatic factors that cause food shortages or famine. These are risks that come from the physical surroundings. The second, system capacity and infrastructure, is the presence or absence of adequate health services, planning, and prevention functions. In practice this means asking whether a country can collect data on its health problems, whether it has facilities and trained staff within reach of the people who need them, and whether it has the transport, water, and power on which services depend. The third, socioeconomic conditions, refers to the nature of the economy, its relationship to the global economic system, and how wealth is distributed. For example, a country that depends on a few export crops has a health budget that rises and falls with world prices.
The last two factors concern how a society is governed and how its people live. Political conditions are instability, conflict, and factional rivalry, which can destroy health services outright or quietly divert resources away from them. Social patterns and cultural traditions include gender roles, social stratification, language, and beliefs about diet, alcohol, and drug use. These differ from the other four because they live in people's relationships and beliefs rather than in the economy, the state, or the physical environment. Each card gives a fuller definition and an example of one factor.
Environmental
risks
Diseases carried or vectored in a particular location through contaminated water, insects, pollution, or climatic factors that cause food shortages or famine. One major report attributed 24 percent of the global burden of disease to environmental causes, and up to 36 percent for children aged 0 to 14. Example: a severe cholera outbreak in Angola was traced to polluted water from the Bengo River trucked to slum dwellers in Luanda, together with garbage and sewage in and around standing water. In such a situation, people may or may not be aware of the need to wash hands, which can raise the risk further.
System capacity
and infrastructure
The presence or absence of adequate health services, planning, and prevention functions. For planning, that means at least the capacity to collect and analyze epidemiological data so that problems can be identified and resources allocated. For care: do the facilities exist, are there trained professionals to staff them, are they located where people can reach them, and do class, caste, religion, or ethnicity present barriers? The category also includes transportation and the availability of water and power. Sanitation is difficult when clean water is unavailable, and a substantial share of diarrhoeal disease is directly related to inadequate water, toilets, and sewers.
Socioeconomic
conditions
The nature of the economy, its relationship to the global economic system, and the effect of that context on social factors and system capacity. A country dependent on a few export crops subject to global price swings will have uncertain resources for health and less long-term planning. An economy shifting to urban industry or services, with wide gaps in income and education and shrinking resources outside cities, draws people into crowded conditions where disease spreads easily. A valued commodity such as diamonds, water, or oil may pay for better health care, or it may end up servicing debt or feeding conflict over resources.
Political
conditions
Instability or conflict, at worst armed conflict and civil war. Such conditions are devastating for health and for the ability of health systems to function, and political rivalries and factionalism can also divert resources and attention from pressing public health needs even where there is no fighting. The long civil wars in Sudan and Somalia are the standard examples of conflict as a determinant of health.
Social patterns and
cultural traditions
Gender roles affect HIV transmission because they may determine what prevention options a woman has. Social stratification by class, race or ethnicity, caste, or any other grouping determines the kind of health care people can reach. Language is in this category too: a country may have an official national language while 70 or 80 or more languages are actually spoken. Views about the relationship between diet and well-being, and about alcohol and drug use, for example where drinking is tied to being a man, can also produce what are viewed as public health issues.
Two of these categories deserve a second look because they will return in every later section. The first is system capacity. It is the reason the same theory-based program can succeed in one district and fail in the next, even when the people in both districts hold the same beliefs. By this we mean that every behavioural recommendation quietly assumes that certain resources are already in place. For example, a program that tells people to boil water assumes that they have fuel, time, and a stove; where those are missing, the message may be understood and accepted and still not be acted on, because the barrier lies in the infrastructure rather than in the person. The second is social patterns and cultural traditions. These are the reason the constructs of a theory have to be filled in locally. A construct such as perceived barriers or social norms names a kind of influence, but the particular barriers and norms that matter are supplied by the gender roles, languages, and beliefs of the population at hand, and that process of filling in is the subject of Section 3.
Common Confusion: Telling the Five Factors Apart
Questions often describe a case and ask which factor is at work, and three of the factors are easily confused. Ask what kind of cause the case describes. A health budget that rises and falls with world prices for a few export crops is socioeconomic, because it concerns the economy and its place in the global system. Clinics with no trained staff, facilities too far from villages, or no system for collecting mortality data are system capacity and infrastructure. Instability, armed conflict, or rivalries that divert resources are political. Contaminated water, insects, pollution, and climate are environmental risks, and gender roles, caste or class, language, and beliefs about diet or alcohol are social patterns and cultural traditions.
The five factors explain why problems take different courses in different places. The overall pattern of illness also differs between countries, and the next subsection describes how it shifts as countries develop.
2.2 The Epidemiologic Transition and What Blurs It
As countries develop in broad socioeconomic terms, life expectancy rises and the pattern of morbidity and mortality shifts from being mainly associated with infectious disease to lifestyle-related conditions such as chronic disease, heart disease, and cancer. By this we mean that the leading causes of illness and death change as a country develops. Where clean water, sanitation, nutrition, and basic health services are scarce, many people die young of infections. As those conditions improve, fewer people die of infection, more people live into middle and old age, and the conditions that take years to develop, such as heart disease and cancer, become the main causes of illness and death. This is the epidemiologic transition, also called the health transition, first described by the demographer Abdel Omran in 1971 (Omran, 1971). Interactive 9.1 presents the transition as three schematic bars, for the share of infectious disease, the share of chronic and lifestyle-related disease, and life expectancy, which change as a slider moves from a less developed to a more developed economy. Drag the slider to see the schematic shape of the transition, then press each of the two buttons to see what blurs it.
📊 Interactive 9.1: The epidemiologic transition.
Drag the slider from a less developed to a more developed economy. The bars are schematic, not data; they show the shape of the shift Omran described. Then press the two buttons to see what blurs the picture.The transition is no longer a clean line, and the two buttons show why. The idea of a transition assumes that a country moves from one pattern of illness to the other, so that knowing its level of development tells you which pattern to expect. Two developments have weakened that assumption, and they work from opposite ends. The first blurs the picture from the infectious side. Widespread diseases such as HIV/AIDS and several forms of influenza raise infectious disease at every level of development, so even a highly developed country cannot assume that infection is behind it. The second blurs the picture from the chronic side. Lifestyle-related diseases such as heart problems have increasingly appeared in the developing world, for two reasons. One is longer lifespans, since people who survive infectious disease live long enough to develop chronic conditions. The other is differential economic development among population sectors within countries, by which we mean that some groups in a country live in more developed conditions than others. For example, a single country can sit at two points on the slider at once, with an urban middle class facing diabetes while rural households still face diarrhoeal disease. When you meet a case like this, the transition is still useful, but it has to be applied to groups within a country rather than to the country as a whole.
A well-known example takes the transition across a border. By this we mean that a family can move from one end of the transition to the other in a single journey, without its home country having developed at all. When migrants or refugees move from a rural or less developed country to a more developed one, obesity can follow. In the home country food may be scarce, the diet may include few processed foods, and physical work is built into food preparation. Because food is scarce, the few people who are wealthy, eat plenty, and are large in stature may carry high prestige. When migrants arrive somewhere food is abundant, processed, and high in sugar and fat, and at the same time enter at a low socioeconomic level, a pattern of obesity may ensue, and the prestige attached to being large as a sign of well-being may be retained and contribute to it. Canadian research on the healthy immigrant effect describes a related pattern: newcomers often arrive healthier than the Canadian-born population, and the advantage fades with years in the country.
Worked Example 9.1 applies the five ecological factors and the migrant example to a newcomer family in Surrey, British Columbia. As you read it, watch which influences began in the home country, which in Canada, and which in the move between them.
Worked Example 9.1: A Newcomer Family in Surrey
The case. A family arrives in Surrey, British Columbia, from a rural district where they farmed and where food was sometimes short. Both parents take shift work at low wages. The nearest grocery store to their apartment is a convenience store; a supermarket is a bus ride away. Within three years, a community health nurse notes rapid weight gain in the children and the father's new diagnosis of type 2 diabetes. When the nurse raises diet, the grandmother says the children finally look well fed, which in the village was a sign of a family doing well.
Step 1, identify the health problem and the pattern. The problem is weight gain in the children and type 2 diabetes in the father, both chronic, lifestyle-related conditions, appearing within three years of a move from a setting of scarcity to one of abundance. This is the migrant example of 2.2: the family has carried itself across the epidemiologic transition.
Step 2, sort the case under the five ecological factors and note where each began.
- Social patterns and cultural traditions, carried from the home country: the grandmother's view that well-fed children look prosperous, the meaning a large body carried where food was scarce.
- Socioeconomic conditions, in Canada: low-wage shift work and entry at a low socioeconomic level.
- System capacity and infrastructure, in Canada: a convenience store close by and a supermarket a bus ride away, since access to food and transport is infrastructure in the broad sense.
- Political conditions, in the move between them: the immigration and settlement policies that determined where the family could live and work.
The abundance of processed food high in sugar and fat is the change of setting the migrant example describes, and it is what turns the retained meaning of a large body into a health risk.
Step 3, decide whether the global or domestic label helps the nurse. The family's risk was produced by the epidemiologic transition crossing a border, so the distinction between a global and a domestic problem is less and less useful here. The nurse needs both the home-country meaning of a large body and the Canadian food environment to design anything that works.
What the example shows. One case can involve several ecological factors at once, on both sides of a border. A common mistake is to treat the grandmother's belief as something only other people have: Canadians of every background attach meaning to body size, and the belief is the local content a program has to work with, not a deficit to correct.
The worked example showed the transition and the five factors operating in one Canadian household, with influences reaching it from far beyond Surrey. The next subsection gives those wider influences a shape.
2.3 More Layers of the Onion
Thinking about global health highlights the idea of an ecology of health, that is, the idea that a person's health is shaped by nested layers of influence, from the family outward to national policy. Such ecologies are always the case. However, in a global context there are more concentric circles, or layers of the onion, involved, because influences now reach a person from beyond the borders of their own country. Figure 9.1 draws the layers as nested rings, from the person at the centre out to the global economy and cross-border flows, with influences flowing inward. The diagram adds the outer layers to the ecological model. The person, family, community, and national policy layers are still there. Around them sit the global economy, the international agencies and funders of Section 2, and the cross-border flows of people, goods, pathogens, and information that this section has described.
Figure 9.1. The layers of the onion in a global ecology of health. The inner rings are the ecological model; the outer two are what a global setting adds.
Keep the onion in mind through the rest of the lesson. Section 2 describes the outer ring in detail, because the agencies and funders that occupy it decide which behaviour change programs get built. Section 3 asks what happens to a theory built for the inner rings of one country when it is carried to another. Section 4 shows four programs that made the trip.
This section has argued that global and domestic health have merged, at least in terms of epidemiology, and that five ecological factors still send health problems along different trajectories in different countries. It has also shown that HIV/AIDS, influenza, and uneven development blur the epidemiologic transition, that migrants can carry the transition across a border, and that a global setting adds outer layers to the ecology of health. The key takeaways below draw these ideas together, and the knowledge check asks you to apply them to short cases.
Key Takeaways
- 1.1 Globalization is more than an economic term. In the narrow sense it is the integration of production and markets across borders, one shirt made in six countries; in the broad sense this lesson uses, it includes the social and political consequences of that integration and the movement of people, information, resources, and environments. Its five public health implications are harder workplace safety, harder food and drug safety, fragmented environmental responsibility, faster disease transmission, and faster communication. When a case describes something crossing borders, name the specific implication it illustrates: a factory collapse is workplace safety, a contaminated import is food and drug safety, and an early-warning network is faster communication.
- 1.2 The lesson's opening claim is that it has become less and less useful to separate global health from domestic health, and HIV/AIDS and avian influenza are the evidence. HIV follows trade routes, urban migration, labour flows, and travel; avian influenza spread from Hong Kong across Asia and to Europe along poultry markets and migratory bird flyways that ignore borders. The routes run through Canada, so the setting of this lesson includes Canada. A common trap is to reduce the argument to trade or food safety alone; the point is that the two settings have merged epidemiologically, which is also why "global" has replaced "international" health.
- 2.1 Health still follows different paths in different countries because of five ecological factors: environmental risks, system capacity and infrastructure, socioeconomic conditions, political conditions, and social patterns and cultural traditions. To classify a case, ask what kind of cause it describes: export-crop prices are socioeconomic, unstaffed or distant clinics and missing data are system capacity, conflict and factionalism are political, water, vectors, pollution, and climate are environmental, and gender roles, stratification, language, and beliefs are social and cultural. Remember that system capacity and cultural tradition are the two factors that decide whether a theory-based program can work at all.
- 2.2 The epidemiologic transition, first described by Omran in 1971, is the shift from mainly infectious to mainly chronic and lifestyle-related disease, with rising life expectancy, as countries develop. HIV/AIDS and influenza have blurred it by keeping infectious disease high at every level of development, and longer lifespans and uneven development within countries have brought chronic disease to the developing world, so one country can show both patterns at once. Migrants can carry the transition across a border, as the Surrey family in Worked Example 9.1 shows, when a meaning learned in scarcity meets abundant processed food. If a case shows two patterns in one country, the answer is uneven development within it, not faulty data.
- 2.3 A global setting adds outer layers to the ecology of health. Around the person, family, community, culture, and national layers sit international agencies, funders, and NGOs, and beyond them the global economy and cross-border flows of people, goods, pathogens, information, and capital, all exerting influence inward (Figure 9.1). When you analyze a case, look for influences in these outer rings as well as the inner ones, because the agencies and funders there often decide which programs get built.
1. A shirt sold in Vancouver was sewn in a factory in one country from cotton grown in another, for a company headquartered in a third. A Canadian occupational health researcher points out that no single authority is responsible for the conditions under which it was made. Which public health implication of globalization does this illustrate?
2. A public health officer in Vancouver argues that a poultry-handling education program in rural Thailand is a Canadian concern. Which of the following arguments best supports her?
3. A country depends on two export crops whose world prices swing from year to year, so its health budget is unpredictable and long-term planning is rare. Under which of the five ecological factors does this fall?
4. In Worked Example 9.1, the grandmother of a newcomer family in Surrey tells the community health nurse that the children finally look well fed, which in the village was a sign of a family doing well. Under which ecological factor does this belief belong, and where did it begin?
5. A ministry of health finds that heart disease and diabetes are rising sharply in the capital's middle class while rural districts still lose children to diarrhoeal disease. How can a country show both patterns at once?
6. In the refugee and migrant example, why might the prestige attached to a large body contribute to obesity after migration?
7. The community health nurse caring for the Surrey family in Worked Example 9.1 asks whether she is dealing with a global health problem or a domestic one. Which answer best reflects this section?
✦ Pass the knowledge check with 100% to continue
The Global Health System and Assessing the Context
⏱ Estimated reading time: 18 minutes
Overview
Before asking which theory applies in a global setting, a planner has to read the setting. Interventions in global health are conducted or funded through a complex system with many levels, and a program designer who does not know that system will not know who pays, who delivers, or who decides. This section first sorts the actors of the global health system into seven types and shows which combinations come into play in different situations. It then walks through a PRECEDE-PROCEED style assessment of a global health problem, phase by phase, with the data sources for each phase and the political constraints that shape what a program can do before any theory is chosen.
Learning Objectives
- 3.1 Name the seven types of actor in the global health system and give an example of each, including Canadian counterparts.
- 3.2 Predict which combination of actors is likely to come into play in a short-term crisis and in a long-term prevention effort, and explain how the separation of funding from delivery shapes which programs get built.
- 4.1 Describe the five phases of a PRECEDE-PROCEED style assessment applied to a global health problem, and name a data source for each phase.
- 4.2 Explain why the educational and ecological assessment in a global setting calls for local partnership, research, and participatory collaboration.
- 4.3 Conduct an administrative and policy assessment for a proposed global health program, identifying the conditions, partnerships, and opposition that constrain it.
3.1 Seven Types of Actor
The global health actors sort into seven types. The purpose of sorting them is practical: the type of an actor tells a planner what kind of relationship it has with the country where a program runs, and so what kind of conditions it is likely to attach. The first three types are distinguished mainly by how many governments stand behind them. Government-level agencies carry out bilateral work, by which we mean work arranged between one donor government and one recipient government. The usual examples are the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, the National Institutes of Health, the United States Agency for International Development (USAID), Germany's GTZ, and the United Kingdom's DFID. Regional organizations, in contrast, focus on health in one region of the world and bring together the countries in it; the standard example is the Pan American Health Organization (PAHO). Public international or multilateral organizations go one step further and bring together many governments from around the world. They are the World Health Organization (WHO) in Geneva and the United Nations agencies, such as UNAIDS, UNICEF, the United Nations Population Fund, and the United Nations Development Programme.
The next two types are defined less by who belongs to them than by what they do with money. Public/private partnerships join government and private resources around a shared goal. By this we mean that governments, foundations, and sometimes companies pool their money and expertise in a single organization that works on one problem, such as a group of diseases or a vaccine that no single partner could develop alone. Examples include the Global Fund to Fight AIDS, Tuberculosis and Malaria, which pools donor money and passes it to programs in affected countries, and alliances that develop products, such as the International AIDS Vaccine Initiative. Financial institutions, such as the World Bank and the regional development banks, lend or grant money for development, including health. They differ from a public/private partnership in that health is only one of many sectors they finance, alongside roads, schools, and agriculture, and their support often comes as loans that a country must repay. For a planner, this means that the conditions attached to the money, and the reporting it requires, may come from an institution whose main concern is economic development rather than health.
The last two types sit outside the regular structure of government, though in different ways. Nongovernmental organizations, nonprofits, and foundations, such as CARE, Médecins Sans Frontières, and the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, are independent of government; some of them implement programs, some fund them, and some do both. Parastatal organizations are bodies created by a government but operating outside its regular departments. For example, the standard parastatal is the Millennium Challenge Corporation, founded by the United States Congress in 2004. A parastatal therefore differs from a government-level agency, which is one of the government's own departments, and from an NGO, which no government created.
Canada occupies the same boxes. Its bilateral work runs through Global Affairs Canada, which absorbed the Canadian International Development Agency (CIDA) in 2013, and through the International Development Research Centre (IDRC). The Public Health Agency of Canada's National Microbiology Laboratory is a public health actor abroad as well as at home. Canada is a member of WHO and PAHO and a donor to the Global Fund, and it has a large non-governmental sector, from CARE Canada and Cuso International to the Stephen Lewis Foundation and Nutrition International. Section 4 returns to Canada's contribution in 7.1.
Interactive 9.2 arranges the seven types as a map around a central node that stands for the country's own health ministry, local organizations, and communities. Click each node on the map to read a description of it, a Canadian counterpart, and what it means for a behaviour change program. Then use the two scenario buttons, which 3.2 explains, to see which actors come into play for a disaster and for a long-term infectious disease effort.
📊 Interactive 9.2: The global health actor map.
Click an actor type to see its description, a Canadian counterpart, and the implication for behavioural programs.Select an actor
Click a node on the map. The centre node is the country's own health ministry, local organizations, and communities, through which almost every program is finally delivered.
Two further things about the map matter for behaviour change programs. First, the outer actors change. Any list of agencies is a snapshot, and the names above date from the early 2010s. Germany's GTZ merged into GIZ in 2011, the United Kingdom's DFID was folded into the Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office in 2020, and in 2025 the United States government dismantled USAID, the funder behind at least two of the programs in Section 4, and moved its remaining functions into the Department of State. A planner has to know who is in each box this year. Second, the centre node is where behaviour actually changes, and the insistence on partnership with local organizations that runs through this lesson follows from that. The callout below clears up two common confusions about actors on the map.
Common Confusion: The Red Cross Bodies, and Funders Versus Implementers
Lists of global health NGOs often include the International Committee of the Red Cross and Red Crescent (ICRC). Strictly, the ICRC is the International Committee of the Red Cross, a Geneva-based body with a mandate under the Geneva Conventions; national societies, including the Canadian Red Cross, belong to a separate International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies. A second confusion: the Global Fund does not run programs. It finances them, and a funder and an implementer are different actors.
Knowing the seven types is the first step. The next subsection shows that which of them come together depends on the situation.
3.2 Which Actors, for Which Situation
Different combinations of these actors come into play depending on the situation. By this we mean that no single type of actor runs global health; instead, the kind of problem decides which types work together and what role each plays. The lesson contrasts two situations. In a disaster or short-term health crisis, the need is for people and supplies on the ground quickly, so NGOs such as the ICRC, CARE, or Médecins Sans Frontières do the work on the ground, with funding and logistical support from national agencies or regional bodies. In a long-term effort to prevent the spread of an infectious disease, however, the need is for coordination across countries over many years. There, WHO coordinates and collaborates with foundations, national health agencies, and the ministries of health of affected countries, while NGOs distribute medications and in some cases implement prevention programs. Notice that NGOs appear in both situations, but in the crisis they lead the response, whereas in long-term prevention they work within a structure that WHO coordinates. Table 9.1 sets out the typical actors in each case, with a Canadian illustration of each.
Table 9.1. Typical actors in a disaster or short-term health crisis and in a long-term effort to prevent the spread of an infectious disease, with a Canadian illustration of each.
| Situation | Typical actors | Canadian illustration |
|---|---|---|
| Disaster or short-term health crisis | The ICRC, CARE, or Médecins Sans Frontières on the ground, with funding and logistical support from national agencies such as USAID or regional bodies such as the European Union or the Association of Southeast Asian Nations. | The Canadian Red Cross deploys field hospitals and personnel to disasters abroad with Government of Canada funding; Global Affairs Canada often matches public donations to Canadian NGOs after a major earthquake or flood. |
| Long-term effort to prevent the spread of an infectious disease | WHO coordinates and collaborates with public/private actors such as the Ford Foundation and with national health agencies such as the NIH and the ministries of health of affected countries. NGOs such as CARE distribute medications and in some cases implement prevention programs. | The Public Health Agency of Canada's National Microbiology Laboratory in Winnipeg developed the Ebola vaccine later licensed as Ervebo and tested in a WHO-coordinated ring vaccination trial in Guinea in 2015, with Médecins Sans Frontières among the field partners. |
Notice what the second row implies for a behaviour change program. In a long-term prevention effort the money, the coordination, the approval, and the delivery all sit in different organizations: a bilateral agency or a public/private partnership funds, WHO coordinates, a ministry approves, and an NGO implements, each with its own reporting requirements and ideas about what works. The theory a program uses is therefore often negotiated among these parties rather than chosen by one planner, which is one reason global programs tend to be pragmatic and to combine theories. To predict the combination in a case, first ask whether the situation is an acute crisis or a long-term prevention effort, then ask who pays, who coordinates, who approves, and who delivers.
A planner who knows who is involved still has to find out what is going on. The next subsection describes how.
4.1 A PRECEDE-PROCEED Style Assessment of the Global Setting
What kinds of theory might apply in a global context? This is a complex question, because many of the theories in this course originated in a Western, industrialized setting. A theory built there carries assumptions about that setting, and those assumptions may not hold elsewhere. The approach taken here is therefore to run a brief assessment in the style of the PRECEDE-PROCEED planning model, which works backward from a population's social and health concerns to the behavioural, environmental, and organizational factors behind them, identifying the issues to address, and only then to discuss theory. The purpose of doing so is to let the setting tell the planner which theory is needed, rather than choosing a familiar theory first and hoping the setting fits it.
4.1.1 The Five Phases
Each phase of the assessment asks a different question about the setting, and in a global context each one also raises the question of where the information will come from. The social assessment describes the broad conditions of a population's life. In a global setting it faces all the situational diversity of one country multiplied a hundredfold. By this we mean that it has to take account of the division between rich and poor nations and within them, a global economy that shapes how resources are distributed, mobility that moves health problems from place to place, Western biomedicine as one of many competing medical paradigms, and the effects of conflict. Its sources include the United Nations Population Fund, the Population Reference Bureau, and the Demographic and Health Surveys.
The next two phases narrow the focus to risks and to the health problems themselves. The behavioural and environmental assessment identifies the behaviours and conditions that put people at risk, but it has no complete source of information. It therefore relies on the risk factors of the Global Burden of Disease study, now produced by the Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation (IHME), and on gray literature, by which we mean the unpublished reports of specific projects. The epidemiological assessment measures the health problems themselves. It can draw on WHO's World Health Report, the Global Burden of Disease study, the Demographic and Health Surveys, UNICEF's Multiple Indicator Cluster Survey, and ministry and university data. However, the quality of mortality and morbidity data varies greatly by country, and conditions are often not defined uniformly, so two countries' figures may not measure the same thing.
The last two phases are where this lesson places its main cautions. The educational and ecological assessment looks at the knowledge, attitudes, and norms behind behaviour. It has no key source, and it is where the lesson's central warning applies (4.2). The administrative and policy assessment maps the funders' rules, the partners' connections, and the political crosscurrents that decide what a program is allowed to do (4.3). Work through the five tabs below for the full account of each phase; each applies one phase to the global setting, and the first four name sources of information.
Social assessment
Take all the situational diversity you would find across communities in one country and multiply it a hundredfold. The division between rich and poor nations is a major structural factor, as is the division of wealth within nations. The character of the global economy, its patterns of production, labour, capital, finance, regulation, and markets, helps determine how resources are distributed and how industrial and agricultural production affects people and environments. High mobility and international flows of labour move health problems from place to place. Cultural traditions, health beliefs, and practices form part of the context: Western biomedicine, viewed globally, is one of many competing paradigms for understanding and treating illness, alongside Chinese medicine, the Vedic traditions of India, spiritist traditions from Africa, Latin America, and the Caribbean, and shamanic practices from Eurasia and the Americas. Sites of conflict such as Sudan and Somalia have their own effects. Data sources: demographic and health surveys from the United Nations Population Fund, Population Bulletins and fact sheets from the Population Reference Bureau, and the USAID-funded Demographic and Health Surveys.
Behavioural and environmental assessment
Risks vary widely by disease, region, and country, and there is no complete source of information. The risk factors in the Global Burden of Disease study, now produced by the Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation (IHME), are important indicators of broad global patterns, and gray literature, the unpublished reports from specific projects available through project or organizational websites, is another important source. A sampler of risks runs from industrial development without environmental control, limited rural access to care, flood, drought, and deforestation, through forced marriage and early childbearing, female genital cutting, injection drug use, unsafe sex, child labour and trafficking, tobacco, poor diet, poor water and sanitation, and immunization practices. A planner reads such a list for the items a program can reach and the items that are conditions to work around.
Epidemiological assessment
Getting data on global health is both easy and problematic. WHO compiles its World Health Report, and the Global Burden of Disease study, originally developed by researchers at Harvard University and WHO, is now produced by the Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation (IHME) at the University of Washington. The degree to which mortality and morbidity data are kept, however, varies greatly by country, and conditions are often not defined uniformly. The Demographic and Health Surveys are particularly useful, UNICEF collects data through its Multiple Indicator Cluster Survey, and ministries and university research centres are sources where surveillance exists. The major global issues include HIV/AIDS, tuberculosis, malaria, child survival, emerging chronic conditions, reproductive health, immunization, lower respiratory infection, cholera and diarrhoeal disease, and severe weather events. Immunization shows the stakes: in 2008 WHO estimated that 1.5 million deaths among children under five, 17 percent of all under-five deaths, were from diseases that routine vaccination could have prevented. And these risks interact to form a web. By this we mean that the problems on the list do not occur separately: HIV raises the risk of tuberculosis, poor water and sanitation drive diarrhoeal disease, and repeated diarrhoea in a child who is also poorly nourished makes other infections more dangerous. A planner who reads the list one condition at a time will therefore underestimate how much a single change, such as clean water or immunization, can reduce several problems at once.
Educational and ecological assessment
Here you face the diversity of knowledge, attitudes, norms, and cultural and social factors that influence behaviour around the world, and all their implications for applying theory. There is no key source: national ministries are one starting point, international health behaviour research another, and reports from NGOs that focus on a health area a third. A warning is needed here. In a short summary it is dangerously easy to stereotype examples of diverse attitudes and norms as something that other people have, as if diversity were not characteristic of all people. What matters is that you cannot make quick assumptions about the attitudes and knowledge that influence behaviour. Effective intervention on knowledge, belief, or norms means partnering with individuals and organizations familiar with local capacity, knowledge, beliefs, norms, and culture, taking the time to conduct research, and working with communities in a participatory collaboration. In that process you learn the structure of incentives and motivation, the predisposing, enabling, and reinforcing factors, so that you can build them into the program. Health promotion is inherently human; a willingness to learn, to understand, and to respect will take you a long way.
Administrative and policy assessment
Books have been written on the policy and administrative environment of global health. There are many layers in any intervention, and the complexity of the political situation is typically a factor. The illustration is the Country X scenario in Worked Example 9.2: two funders with different rules, two possible partner NGOs with different connections, and a vocal group of opponents. The lesson lies in two questions. How would you negotiate the situation? And what if you did not know about all these political crosscurrents? Canadian funders have rules too. Global Affairs Canada's Feminist International Assistance Policy, adopted in 2017, directs Canadian assistance toward gender equality, which shapes what a Canadian-funded program can propose in the same way that the restricted American funds in Country X shape what can be delivered.
The tabs show that each phase has its own questions and, apart from the educational and ecological phase, its own sources, and that the immunization figures alone justify careful epidemiological work: in 2008 about 17 percent of all deaths among children under five were from diseases that routine vaccination could have prevented. They also show that the social context of a health problem includes the economy and the division of wealth, which is the point of the argument that follows.
4.1.2 Poverty as Context: Farmer's Argument
The social assessment treats the division of wealth, conflict, and the global economy as part of the context of a health problem. Paul Farmer pushed that point further, arguing that the structure of poverty also shapes the emergence and spread of infectious disease. The callout below sets out his argument, with malaria and tuberculosis as examples.
Paul Farmer: Social Inequalities and Emerging Infectious Diseases
Pause here for Paul Farmer, founding director of Partners In Health, whose 1996 essay on social inequalities and emerging infectious diseases (Farmer, 1996) drew the connections between poverty and infectious disease. Look at the trajectory of a disease, Farmer argued, in terms of the conditions that contribute to its emergence rather than the agent alone, because human action has done so much to drive mutation, resistance, and spread. The structure of poverty is one of the key political ecologies of emergence. By this we mean that poverty is not simply a background condition but one of the arrangements of power, resources, and place that decide where a disease appears, who it reaches, and whether it is ever controlled. The two examples Farmer used show how this works. Malaria was once a disease of the United States, controlled as a by-product of agricultural development, better housing, drainage, repellents, and nets; those things were not available to the poor, so malaria lingered among them. Tuberculosis has effective therapies but was never eradicated in many poorer nations, because therapies still have to be delivered, stored, and used according to protocol, and it gained new prominence as an opportunistic infection in people with HIV. A behaviour change program that ignores the structure of poverty is treating the agent and leaving the conditions alone.
Farmer's reminder belongs to the assessment, not only to theory. The distinction he draws is between the agent, the parasite or bacterium that causes a disease, and the conditions, such as housing, drainage, access to treatment, and the means to complete it, that allow the agent to spread. A planner who reads poverty as background rather than as a cause will design a program for the agent and miss the conditions. For example, a tuberculosis program that teaches people to complete their course of treatment addresses a real behaviour, but if patients cannot afford to travel to the clinic each week or cannot store their medication safely, the program has located the barrier in their knowledge when it lies in their circumstances. Reading poverty as a cause in the social assessment is what allows the later phases to look for barriers of this kind.
4.1.3 The Data at a Glance
The tabs name one or more sources of information for most phases of the assessment, and several sources serve more than one phase. Table 9.2 gathers the sources in one place, with what each offers and the phases it serves.
Table 9.2. Sources of global health data, what each offers, and the assessment phase or phases each serves.
| Source | What it offers | Assessment phase |
|---|---|---|
| United Nations Population Fund; Population Reference Bureau | Demographic and health surveys; Population Bulletins and fact sheets | Social |
| Demographic and Health Surveys (the DHS Program) | Comparable national household surveys; one of the most comprehensive data sets. Long USAID-funded, and disrupted when USAID was dismantled in 2025. | Social, epidemiological |
| IHME Global Burden of Disease; WHO World Health Report | Risk factor rankings and mortality and morbidity estimates, with uneven data quality by country | Behavioural and environmental, epidemiological |
| UNICEF Multiple Indicator Cluster Survey (MICS) | Child and household indicators from numerous countries | Epidemiological |
| Gray literature; NGO reports; USAID project listings | Unpublished evaluations, often the only source on local knowledge, attitudes, and norms | Behavioural and environmental, educational and ecological |
| Country health ministries; university research centres | Surveillance data where surveillance exists; local studies | Epidemiological, educational and ecological |
Read Table 9.2 by phase when a question asks where a planner would look: the Demographic and Health Surveys serve both the social and the epidemiological phases, the Global Burden of Disease study serves the behavioural and the epidemiological phases, and gray literature is often the only source on local knowledge, attitudes, and norms. That last gap is the subject of the next subsection.
4.2 No Quick Assumptions: Partnership in the Educational and Ecological Phase
The educational and ecological phase is where behaviour change lives. By this we mean that it is the phase that identifies the knowledge, attitudes, norms, and cultural and social factors a program will actually try to change or build on. In a global setting, the diversity of those factors around the world is enormous, and there is no key source of information about them. National ministries, international health behaviour research, and reports from NGOs that focus on a health area are only starting points.
The lesson's central advice comes from this phase: you cannot make quick assumptions about the attitudes and knowledge that influence behaviour. A quick assumption is a belief about a population that a planner brings to the setting instead of finding out, and it is dangerous because a program built on it may address barriers that do not exist and miss the ones that do. The remedy has three parts. First, partner with individuals and organizations familiar with local capacity, knowledge, beliefs, norms, and culture. Second, take the time to conduct research. Third, work with communities in a participatory collaboration rather than designing for them from outside. The purpose of all three is to learn the structure of incentives and motivation, which in PRECEDE-PROCEED terms means the predisposing, enabling, and reinforcing factors, so that you can build them into the program.
Caution: Diversity Is Not Something Only Other People Have
In a short summary of global attitudes and norms it is dangerously easy to stereotype examples of diverse attitudes as something that other people have, as if diversity were not characteristic of all people. The beliefs you read about in this lesson are the local content of constructs that every population has, Canadians included. The remedy is the same advice as above: no quick assumptions, local partnership, research, and participatory collaboration.
Health promotion is inherently human, and a willingness to learn, to understand, and to respect will take a program a long way. The last phase of the assessment shows why that willingness has to extend to politics as well as culture.
4.3 The Administrative and Policy Assessment: Country X
Books have been written on the policy and administrative environment of global health. There are many layers in any intervention, and the complexity of the political situation is typically a factor. By this we mean that a program is shaped not only by the health problem but by the people and organizations around it: funders attach conditions, partners have connections, and some groups oppose what a program will say. The administrative and policy assessment exists to find these constraints before the program is designed, because each of them limits what the program can say, through which channels, and with whom. Canadian funders have rules too. Global Affairs Canada's Feminist International Assistance Policy, adopted in 2017, directs Canadian assistance toward gender equality, which shapes what a Canadian-funded program can propose. The standard illustration is the Country X scenario. Worked Example 9.2 analyzes it as an administrative and policy assessment; watch how much of the program is decided before any theory is named.
Worked Example 9.2: Sexually Transmitted Infections in Country X
The case. You are trying to address sexually transmitted infections in Country X, where a growing STI problem may raise the risk of HIV/AIDS if nothing is done. Funds are available from a United States agency, but they are restricted to parent education or school-based education. You also have funding from a global nonprofit without those restrictions, which requires that you partner with an in-country organization. Two NGOs in Country X address STIs among other issues. One is closely tied to family members of the Minister of Health. The other is independent and has better access to schools around the country, which would let you draw on funds from both sources. A small but vocal group of Country X medical professionals opposes any direct education of youth about sexuality, on moral grounds.
Step 1, identify the problem and the phases that supply the information. The health problem, a growing STI problem that raises HIV risk among youth, comes from the epidemiological assessment. Almost everything else in the case, the funders' conditions, the partners' connections, and the opponents, is the substance of the administrative and policy assessment.
Step 2, map the actors and their conditions. The United States agency is a bilateral funder whose money is restricted to parent or school-based education. The global nonprofit is a second funder whose condition is an in-country partner. The two NGOs are candidate implementers. The ministry approves programs. The vocal medical professionals are a political condition in the sense of Section 1: a factional opposition that can divert a program.
Step 3, weigh the partner choice. The independent NGO unlocks both funders, because its school access satisfies the American restriction and it is the in-country partner the nonprofit requires, so the program can be larger. Its cost is a ministry with family ties to the rival organization, which approves programs and can slow them or make a school-based program unwelcome. The ministry-linked NGO buys political protection at the price of the school channel and probably one funder.
Step 4, say what the constraints imply for theory and channels. The American restriction pushes the program toward communication and skills work delivered through schools and parents. The opponents make direct sexuality education risky, so the program may need advocacy and organizational change work with the medical community, and community mobilization with parents, before any individual-level theory can be applied. These families of theory are described in Section 3.
What the example shows. The scenario has no clean answer, and that is the point: funder rules, partner connections, and opponents shape what a program can say and through which channels long before a theory is chosen. The scenario's second question, what if you did not know about these political crosscurrents, names the most dangerous gap of all, because a planner who misses them designs a program that cannot be delivered.
The worked example showed the administrative and policy layer at work: the choice of partner, the channels available, and even the families of theory a program can use were constrained by politics before any theory was named. Section 3 asks which theories can survive those constraints.
This section has sorted the actors of the global health system into seven types, shown that different combinations of them come into play in a short-term crisis and in a long-term prevention effort, and walked through the five phases of a PRECEDE-PROCEED style assessment, with the data sources gathered in Table 9.2, the warning against quick assumptions, and the politics of Country X. The key takeaways below summarize what to carry forward, and the knowledge check asks you to apply it.
Key Takeaways
- 3.1 Global health actors sort into seven types: government-level (bilateral) agencies such as USAID, regional organizations such as PAHO, multilateral organizations such as WHO and the UN agencies, public/private partnerships such as the Global Fund, financial institutions such as the World Bank, NGOs and foundations such as CARE and Médecins Sans Frontières, and parastatal organizations such as the Millennium Challenge Corporation. Canada has counterparts in most boxes, from Global Affairs Canada and IDRC to CARE Canada and the Stephen Lewis Foundation. Two traps recur: the Global Fund finances programs but does not run them, and a parastatal body is created by a government but operates outside its regular departments. Remember too that any list of agencies is a snapshot, as the dismantling of USAID in 2025 showed.
- 3.2 The situation decides the combination of actors. In a disaster or short-term crisis, NGOs such as the ICRC, CARE, or Médecins Sans Frontières work on the ground with funding and logistics from national or regional bodies; in a long-term prevention effort, WHO coordinates foundations, national agencies, and ministries, while NGOs distribute medications and implement prevention. Because funding, coordination, approval, and delivery usually sit in different organizations, the theory a program uses is often negotiated rather than chosen by one planner. In a case question, first classify the situation as crisis or long-term, then name who funds, who coordinates, who approves, and who delivers.
- 4.1 A PRECEDE-PROCEED style assessment comes before any theory is named, and each phase has its own sources: the social phase uses UNFPA, the Population Reference Bureau, and the Demographic and Health Surveys; the behavioural and environmental phase uses the IHME Global Burden of Disease risk factors and gray literature; the epidemiological phase uses the World Health Report, the Global Burden of Disease, the Demographic and Health Surveys, UNICEF's Multiple Indicator Cluster Survey, and ministries. Data are both easy and problematic to get, because agencies compile them but countries keep and define them unevenly. Paul Farmer's argument belongs here too: the structure of poverty shapes the emergence of disease, and a program that ignores it treats the agent and leaves the conditions alone.
- 4.2 The educational and ecological phase carries the central advice of the lesson. There is no key source on local knowledge, attitudes, and norms, so you cannot make quick assumptions; instead, partner with people who know the local capacity, beliefs, norms, and culture, take time to do research, and work in participatory collaboration, which is how you learn the predisposing, enabling, and reinforcing factors. Watch for the trap of treating diversity as something only other people have. When a question asks for the remedy to a planner's assumption about a population, the answer is almost always local partnership and formative research.
- 4.3 The Country X scenario shows the administrative and policy assessment at work. Restricted American funds, a nonprofit that requires an in-country partner, one NGO tied to the minister's family and another with better school access, and vocal medical opponents together decide what the program can say and through which channels before any theory is chosen. Choosing the independent NGO unlocks both funders but risks obstruction from the ministry; choosing the ministry-linked NGO buys protection at the cost of schools and probably a funder. On an exam, place funder rules, partner connections, and political opposition in this phase, and say what they constrain.
1. A student's poster describes the Global Fund to Fight AIDS, Tuberculosis and Malaria as "the organization that runs HIV clinics in partner countries." What is wrong with this description?
2. A cholera outbreak follows an earthquake, and within days Médecins Sans Frontières and the Canadian Red Cross are running treatment centres with Government of Canada and European funding. Which situation type does this match, and which actor type is doing the delivery?
3. A planner needs comparable national data on fertility, child health, and household socioeconomic status across several countries for the social and epidemiological phases of an assessment. Which source stands out as one of the most comprehensive?
4. In Paul Farmer's account, why did malaria linger among the poor in the United States after it had been controlled elsewhere in the country?
5. A colleague summarizing a district's attitudes for a program plan writes, "People here are fatalistic about illness, unlike us." What error does this risk, and what is the remedy the lesson recommends?
6. A Canadian NGO's funding from Global Affairs Canada is tied to the Feminist International Assistance Policy, and a partner country's ministry is wary of any program that discusses sexuality with adolescents. In the assessment framework, where do these two facts belong, and what do they most directly shape?
7. In Worked Example 9.2, the program officer chooses the independent NGO. What does this choice gain, and what does it risk?
✦ Pass the knowledge check with 100% to continue
Theory in the Global Setting
⏱ Estimated reading time: 18 minutes
Overview
The answer to the question of which theories apply in a global context is neither that none of them travel nor that all of them do. Much of the theory reviewed in this course concerning knowledge, health beliefs, intentions, social norms, and culture is potentially applicable, at least in its basic form. The work lies in what we can call filling in the blanks with different kinds of information, and in noticing the assumptions a theory carries with it. This section first sets out the two adjustments an individual-level theory needs and the role of ethnomedical systems, then takes the families of theory in turn, from communication to political economy, looks at one multitheory model, and ends with a set of questions you can put to any program idea.
Learning Objectives
- 5.1 Explain the two adjustments needed before an individual-level theory is used in a global setting: filling in its constructs locally and checking who makes the decision.
- 5.2 Define an ethnomedical system, explain how it connects to the constructs of behavioural theory, and apply both adjustments to a case.
- 5.3 Describe Behavior Change Communication: its place in communication theory, its theoretical roots, its eight steps, and what it tries to change.
- 5.4 Match organizational change and advocacy, community mobilization, and political-economic theories to the kinds of global health problems they address.
- 5.5 Analyze the AIDS Risk Reduction Model as a multitheory approach and identify its parallels with earlier theories.
- 5.6 Apply a short sequence of questions to judge which family of theory fits a proposed global health program.
5.1 Two Adjustments: Fill In the Constructs, Check Who Decides
An individual-level theory needs two adjustments before it is used in a global setting. The first is called filling in the blanks. By this we mean that a theory's constructs, such as barriers, benefits, norms, and cues, are empty categories until research with a particular population supplies their content. The purpose of the adjustment is to make sure a program addresses the barriers and benefits that matter to the people it serves, rather than those that mattered to the population where the theory was first tested.
For example, take the Health Belief Model. If you use it to guide an intervention, what you address as barriers must be relevant to the population you are working with. That is always the case, but in a global context it may take extra effort to make the intervention meaningful and relevant. A barrier to condom use in one place is price; in another it is what a condom is understood to do to the body. In both places the construct, perceived barriers, is the same, but its content is local, and a program that addressed price where the real barrier was a belief about the body would miss its audience entirely. Filling in the blanks therefore means that the barriers, benefits, norms, and cues of a theory have to be found out for this population rather than carried over from another.
The second adjustment is deeper, because it questions the structure of the theory rather than its content. Much individual theory makes assumptions about individuals as decision makers that may not apply in societies where the individual is not understood as the primary social unit or primary decision-making unit, as it generally is in Western societies. A model built around one person weighing costs and benefits and forming an intention has to be rethought when the decision belongs to a couple, a household, elders, or a community. The two adjustments are easy to confuse, so it helps to ask which one a case calls for. If the theory is aimed at the right decision maker but uses the wrong barriers or benefits, the case calls for filling in the blanks; if it is aimed at the wrong decision maker, the case calls for checking who decides. Neither adjustment means abandoning the theory; both mean checking it against the setting before relying on it.
Where the content of a theory's constructs comes from is the question of the next subsection.
5.2 Ethnomedical Systems: Where the Constructs Already Live
Cultures and peoples across the world have varying ethnomedical systems: systems of knowledge and practice that tie together culturally shared ideas about what causes illness and disease, how to treat or cure it, and who the appropriate healers are. By this we mean that every population, Canadians included, has a shared way of explaining why people fall ill, what should be done about it, and whom to consult. These systems are closely tied to the elements of many behavioural theories, because they shape three things those theories care about: people's understandings and expectations about using health care, the norms for patient and healer behaviour, and the values and meanings attached to particular health outcomes. An ethnomedical system is, in the language of behavioural theory, where a population's perceived causes, perceived severity, and cues to action already live. This is why the concept matters for the first adjustment in 5.1: when a planner fills in the blanks of a theory, the ethnomedical system is where much of the local content will be found.
None of this is a deficit to be corrected. It is tempting to treat a population's beliefs about illness as obstacles standing between people and the correct biomedical message, but that view misreads what an ethnomedical system is. Cultural variety can instead be a strength from which to build interventions, because diverse living patterns are often the foundation of resilience, built on the experience of generations. By this we mean that the practices a community already trusts have usually helped it survive hardship, and a program that works through them starts with credibility it would otherwise have to earn. For example, Indigenous communications practices, breastfeeding, and other traditions have already been incorporated effectively into public health programs, so that the program builds on what people already value rather than asking them to set it aside. The callout below describes Two-Eyed Seeing, a Canadian frame for using Indigenous and Western knowledges together.
A Canadian Frame: Two-Eyed Seeing
Mi'kmaw Elder Albert Marshall of Unama'ki (Cape Breton) described Etuaptmumk, or Two-Eyed Seeing, as learning to see from one eye with the strengths of Indigenous knowledges and from the other with the strengths of Western knowledges, and to use both together. Canadian health researchers have adopted it for programs that work with an Indigenous ethnomedical system rather than around it. Offered here as a schematic teaching idea, it is one Canadian answer to the question of how a theory built in one knowledge system can be used respectfully in another.
Worked Example 9.3 brings the two adjustments of 5.1, and the beliefs of an ethnomedical system, to a single setting: a 2004 study of condom use among married couples in India. Watch for which beliefs fill in which constructs, and for the point at which the model's assumption about who decides breaks down.
Worked Example 9.3: Gender, Sexuality, and HIV Risk in India
The case. Consider a 2004 analysis of condom use among married couples in India (Bhattacharya, 2004), where most AIDS cases at the time were attributed to sexual transmission and the epidemic had spread into the general population. Several traditions cut across religious lines. Family name and inheritance pass through the male line, and a wife lives in her husband's father's house. Female purity before marriage is prized while men are encouraged to have premarital sex, so men may be infected before marriage, and a bride who knows about HIV prevention may be suspected of premarital sex. Because wealth is inherited by men, women find it hard to leave a marriage even where there is abuse or infidelity. The duty to bear children conflicts with condom use; condoms are stigmatized by association with sex workers, and sterilization is the more common contraceptive. Beliefs about the balance and flow of body fluids lead some to see condoms as a threat to male health. There is a strong belief that marriage itself protects a woman from HIV, an acceptance of fate as part of karma, and a pattern of married men having sex with men.
Step 1, identify the behaviour and the population. The behaviour is condom use; the population is married couples in a general-population epidemic in which a husband may have been infected before or outside the marriage. Suppose a program used the Health Belief Model unchanged, raising perceived susceptibility and severity, listing the benefits of condoms, and addressing the barrier of cost.
Step 2, fill in the constructs with local content. Perceived susceptibility is undermined by the belief that marriage itself protects a woman from HIV, and by the acceptance of fate as part of karma, so messages must address those beliefs rather than simply assert risk. Perceived barriers are stigma, because condoms are associated with sex workers; the conflict between condoms and the duty to bear children; the belief that condoms interrupt the flow of body fluids and threaten male health; and the danger that an informed bride will be suspected of premarital sex. Cost is a minor barrier by comparison. Perceived benefits have to be framed in terms the ethnomedical system accepts.
Step 3, check who decides. The decision about a condom belongs to the couple, within a household where inheritance passes through men, a wife lives in her husband's father's house, and leaving a marriage is hard. A model built around one person weighing costs and benefits misses the real decision-making unit.
Step 4, say what the program should add. Because the unit is the couple within the household, the program needs theories of gender roles and social norms, and communication that reaches husbands and mothers-in-law rather than wives alone. The families of theory in 5.3 and 5.4 supply such tools, and the Albania project in Section 4 uses exactly that kind of combination.
What the example shows. The Health Belief Model still applies in basic form, but only after both adjustments. A common mistake is to treat these beliefs as exotic; they are the local content of constructs that every population has.
The worked example made the two adjustments concrete: perceived barriers and susceptibility took local content from the ethnomedical system and the social structure, and the unit of decision moved from the individual to the couple and household. The next question is how to reach such audiences, which is the work of communication theory.
5.3 Communication and Behavior Change Communication
5.3.1 Encoding and Decoding for Diverse Audiences
Communications theories address the process of encoding, sending, receiving, and decoding messages. Encoding and decoding refer to how a message is packaged so that a particular group will understand its meaning as intended and find it intuitively sensible. By this we mean that the sender puts an idea into words, images, and symbols, and the audience turns those back into an idea; if the two sides do not share the same meanings, the idea that arrives is not the idea that was sent. In a global context this takes careful thinking and a decent knowledge of the many possible audiences, because the more audiences differ from the sender, the more ways the message can be decoded differently. For example, how would you target information to migrant Latina mothers in the United States? What would you need to know about themes, about words and symbols to use or avoid, and about channels? Replace the audience with newcomer mothers in Brampton or Richmond and the questions are unchanged. Those questions are the communication version of filling in the blanks: the content of the message has to be found out for the audience rather than assumed.
5.3.2 Behavior Change Communication
Communications programs are one of the areas of global health where theory is used most explicitly. Part of the reason is that a communication program has to make its choices visible: it must decide what to say, to whom, and through which channel, and each of those decisions calls on a theory about how messages are received and acted on. They draw on communication theory, social marketing, diffusion of innovations, and community mobilization. There is also a term used almost exclusively in global health: behavior change communication, or BCC. BCC is best understood as a planned communication process that combines several theories in order to change a behaviour, rather than as a single theory of its own. By this we mean that BCC does not propose new constructs of its own; instead, it supplies an orderly sequence of planning steps into which constructs from several theories, such as self-efficacy or stages of change, are placed where they fit the problem. It was developed primarily in the global health context, originally in nutrition and later widely in HIV/AIDS.
BCC borrows from several sources. Its roots are diffusion of innovations, stages of change from the Transtheoretical Model, self-efficacy from Social Cognitive Theory, social marketing, and the World Bank's Behavior Change Continuum. In addition to these roots, BCC has a characteristic sequence of eight steps. A program first states its goals, involves interest holders, and identifies its target populations. It then conducts formative BCC assessments, segments the target populations, and defines behaviour change objectives. Only after that does it design a BCC strategy, and finally it implements and evaluates the strategy. The order matters. The fourth step, formative research, comes before the strategy is designed, and it is where the local filling-in of 5.1 happens. A planner who skips it is writing messages for constructs whose content has not yet been found out. The parts below describe where BCC came from, what each step involves, and the processes through which a BCC program tries to change behaviour.
Where BCC came from
BCC was developed primarily in the global health context, originally in nutrition and later widely in HIV/AIDS. Its roots are in several theories from this course and some that are not: diffusion of innovations; stages of change from the Transtheoretical Model; self-efficacy from Social Cognitive Theory; social marketing and its consumer research; and the Behavior Change Continuum from the World Bank, which this course does not cover. Like many global health programs, it uses a combination of theories.
The eight steps
Very similar to any communications campaign: (1) state program goals; (2) involve interest holders; (3) identify target populations; (4) conduct formative BCC assessments, meaning formative research designed to understand risk behaviours, their context, attitudes, and understandings; (5) segment target populations; (6) define overall behaviour change objectives; (7) design a BCC strategy covering current behaviour, concepts and themes, key messages, channels, barriers and supports for change, implementation partners, and monitoring and evaluation; (8) implement and evaluate the strategy. The sequence is that of a standard health communication campaign, and step 4 is where the local filling-in happens.
What a BCC program tries to do
The goal is to change behaviour and so address a health problem, through these processes: increase knowledge; stimulate community dialogue; promote essential attitude change, for example regarding perception of risk; reduce stigma and discrimination; create demand for information and services; advocate; promote services for prevention, care, and support; and improve skills and sense of self-efficacy. Read against the theories: knowledge and risk perception belong to the Health Belief Model, dialogue to diffusion and mobilization, demand to social marketing, and skills and self-efficacy to Social Cognitive Theory.
The three parts show that BCC is a combination of theories organized as a campaign process, with formative research placed before strategy so that the constructs are filled in locally before a message is written. When a question lists a sequence that runs from goals and interest holders through formative research and segmentation to strategy, implementation, and evaluation, it is describing BCC. Messages, however, cannot move every obstacle, and the next subsection turns to the theories for obstacles no message can solve.
5.4 Organizations, Communities, and Political Economy
Three further families of theory address problems no message can solve on its own. What separates them is where the obstacle sits, so the useful question in a case is not "what should people be told?" but "what has to change first, and at what level?"
Organizational change and advocacy theories apply when the obstacle is an organization or a policy, so that an organizational or policy problem has to be solved before the health problem can improve. For example, an agency may have no system for identifying who is affected by a problem and feeding that information to decision makers, or a new system linking data to planning may meet internal resistance. In both cases the people at risk may be willing to change, but the system that should serve them is not doing its part. Community mobilization, in contrast, applies when change has to come from within a community. In the participatory tradition of Paulo Freire, the community collaborates in defining the problem and identifying solutions, and then acts collectively. The difference from organizational change is who acts: in mobilization the community itself is the agent of change, rather than the target of an agency's reform.
Political-economic theories apply when the cause is further upstream still, in the macro-level political and economic context. By this we mean decisions about the economy, such as which industries a government favours, that leave a whole population more vulnerable. These theories respond with approaches such as redirecting economic activity, organizing rural health collaboratives, passing compensatory laws, and microcredit. They differ from the other two families because they try to change the conditions people live in before they try to change what people know or do. Open each of the three tabs below for a fuller account of each family and the situation it fits.
When the problem is an organization or a policy
These approaches may be needed when an organizational or policy problem has to be solved before a health problem can improve. For example, resources may not be directed to a population that needs them because the public health agency, or network of agencies, has no system for identifying who is affected and feeding that information to decision makers. An organizational change effort is also needed when a new system linking epidemiological data to program planning is put in place and meets internal resistance. The same theories matter when change has to come from within a community: people have to be aware of a problem and motivated to take collective action, holding public awareness events, gathering signatures for a petition, or organizing a mail, telephone, or email campaign directed at a legislator.
Participation in the tradition of Freire
Advocacy and mobilization approaches are very much part of public health work in a global context, particularly the participatory approaches that come from Paulo Freire, in which there is a collaboration with the community in defining the problem and identifying solutions. This is the theory behind the advice repeated in Section 2: partner with local organizations, take the time to do research, and work with communities in a participatory collaboration. It is also the answer to the second adjustment above. Where the individual is not the decision-making unit, the community that is the unit has to be in the room.
When the cause is upstream
There is often a macro-level political-economic context that shapes the trajectory of a health condition. A country's pattern of economic development may create vulnerabilities in specific populations; the rural-to-urban transition may result from political decisions about which industries to favour. If those decisions create a geographic class of rural people with less and less access to work, cash income, resources, education, and medical care, an intervention targeting the political-economic context will identify the key elements of that context and then use a range of approaches, including community mobilization, advocacy, and direct programmatic action. The object might be to redirect economic activity to rural areas, organize rural health collaboratives to make the most of scarce resources, or pass a law that makes it hard for businesses to relocate from rural to urban areas without providing some compensatory service. The microcredit approach of the Grameen Bank, founded in Bangladesh by Muhammad Yunus, falls in this category: it changes what poor households can do before it changes what they know.
The tabs pair each family with a kind of obstacle: an agency or policy that is not doing its part, a community that has not yet acted, or an economy that has created a vulnerable population. Matching the theory to the obstacle is the skill a question will test, and in practice a program often needs more than one family at once, which is the subject of the next subsection.
5.5 Multitheory Approaches: The AIDS Risk Reduction Model
Global health programs are often pragmatic responses to real situations, and the emphasis on theory is not always as pronounced as in domestic programs. Because such programs are often designed quickly, negotiated among several funders and partners, and shaped by what the setting allows, they tend to borrow whatever ideas help rather than follow one theory from start to finish. Theory-based programs may therefore combine approaches or constructs from different approaches. This is what is meant by a multitheory approach: rather than applying one theory in full, the planner or researcher takes the constructs from several theories that together fit the problem. A good example is the AIDS Risk Reduction Model, or ARRM (Catania, Kegeles, and Coates, 1990). It focuses on sexual transmission of HIV and incorporates elements of the Health Belief Model and efficacy theory from Social Cognitive Theory, together with the role of emotion and interpersonal processes.
ARRM also shows the influence of stages of change, because the change process it envisions has three stages. In the first, a person recognizes and labels their own behaviour as high risk. In the second, the person makes a commitment to reduce high-risk contact and increase low-risk activities. In the third, the person takes action by seeking information, obtaining remedies, and enacting solutions. Each stage is a point at which a program can help, and each one corresponds to something you have already met in an earlier theory. Do these stages sound familiar? Table 9.3 sets out each stage beside its parallels in earlier theories.
Table 9.3. The three stages of the AIDS Risk Reduction Model, what happens at each stage, and parallels in earlier theories.
| ARRM stage | What happens | Parallels in earlier theories |
|---|---|---|
| Stage 1: Recognition and labelling | Recognizing and labelling one's own behaviour as high risk | Perceived susceptibility and severity in the Health Belief Model; the move from unaware and unengaged to deciding in the Precaution Adoption Process Model; precontemplation to contemplation in the Transtheoretical Model |
| Stage 2: Commitment | Making a commitment to reduce high-risk sexual contact and to increase low-risk activities | Intention in the Theory of Planned Behavior; the preparation stage of the Transtheoretical Model; outcome expectations and self-efficacy from Social Cognitive Theory |
| Stage 3: Taking action | Seeking information, obtaining remedies, and enacting solutions | The action stage of the Transtheoretical Model; enabling factors in PRECEDE-PROCEED; skills and self-efficacy in Social Cognitive Theory |
The table shows how much ARRM borrows, but its value lies in what it adds. The theories it draws on mostly describe one person thinking about risk and deciding what to do. What ARRM adds that its parents lack is emotion and the interpersonal: fear, desire, and the negotiation between two people. By this we mean that a person may recognize a risk and commit to reducing it, yet still fail to act, because sexual behaviour involves strong feelings and a partner who has a say in what happens. The India case in Worked Example 9.3 showed this to be decisive: a wife who perceives her risk still has to negotiate condom use with a husband, within a household, and the model of a single decision maker does not capture that step. That is the pattern of multitheory work in global health: the combination is chosen for the problem, and the theories are judged by whether they cover the situation. The last subsection turns that judgement into a set of questions.
5.6 Does This Theory Travel?
The questions of this section can be put to any program idea in order. The purpose of asking them in a fixed order is that each answer narrows the choice before the next question is asked, so that the theory is chosen to fit the obstacle rather than out of habit.
The first question is what mostly stands between people and the healthier behaviour: their knowledge and beliefs, the messages reaching them, an organization or community, or poverty and the structure of the economy. Each answer points to a different family of theory, because each family was built to explain change at a different level. For example, if people in a district already know that handwashing prevents diarrhoea but the clinic that should supply soap and water has no budget for it, a theory about individual beliefs will not help, and the obstacle is organizational. Knowledge and beliefs point to individual-level theory, and messages point to communication theory and BCC. An organization that is not doing its part points to organizational change, a community that has not acted points to mobilization, and the economy points to political-economic theory.
The second question applies only if an individual-level theory is a candidate, and it repeats the second adjustment of 5.1: who actually decides about this behaviour here? If a couple, household, elders, or community decides, change the unit before choosing the theory. The third question repeats the first adjustment: have the theory's constructs been filled in through local research? If you do not know who decides, or you are working from a theory's standard constructs, the answer is to stop and do formative research with local partners. In other words, an honest "I do not know yet" is itself an answer, and it leads to research rather than to a theory. Interactive 9.3 presents these questions as a decision tree, one question at a time, with seven possible endings. Work through it with a program idea in mind, and try to reach several endings.
📊 Interactive 9.3: Does this theory travel?
Answer each question about a program you have in mind. Seven endings are possible; try to reach several.Whatever ending you reach, the closing advice of Section 2 applies. Globally, as domestically, health promotion is inherently human, and a willingness to learn, to understand, and to respect will carry a program further than any single theory. Section 4 shows what that looks like in practice.
This section has shown that much of the theory in this course can be used in a global setting once its constructs are filled in with local content and its assumption about who decides has been checked. It has also set out the families of theory that address communication, organizations, communities, and the political-economic context, one multitheory model, ARRM, and a sequence of questions for choosing among them. The key takeaways below summarize the section, and the knowledge check asks you to apply it to short cases.
HEAL connection: the context travels with the theory
On the HEAL Framework for Wellbeing introduced in Lesson 1, a theory developed where the individual is the main decision-making unit was developed in a particular sociopolitical context and with particular health and social systems. When a program moves to another country, these upstream domains change, and so do the processes through which power and capital shape material circumstance and who decides.
HEAL credits its core commitments, namely interconnectedness, the inseparability of environment and wellbeing, and health residing in relationships among people, land, and community, to Indigenous knowledge systems and to Two-Eyed Seeing (Etuaptmumk), from Mi'kmaw Elders Albert and Murdena Marshall. The framework asks that this lineage be credited rather than renamed as new academic concepts.
Key Takeaways
- 5.1 Most of the theory in this course travels at least in basic form, but two adjustments come first. Fill in the constructs locally: the barriers, benefits, norms, and cues must be relevant to this population, so the construct stays the same while its content changes. Then check who decides: individual theory assumes the individual is the primary social and decision-making unit, which is not true where a couple, household, elders, or community decides. In a case, the clue to the second adjustment is anyone other than the person who acts holding the decision, such as a mother-in-law who decides when a pregnant woman may leave the house.
- 5.2 An ethnomedical system is a system of knowledge and practice that ties together culturally shared ideas about what causes illness, how to treat it, and who the appropriate healers are. It shapes expectations about health care, the norms for patients and healers, and the meaning of outcomes, so it is where a population's perceived causes, severity, and cues to action already live. Cultural variety is a strength to build on, not a deficit to correct, as Two-Eyed Seeing illustrates. In Worked Example 9.3, the belief that marriage protects a woman undermines perceived susceptibility while stigma and bodily-flow beliefs are perceived barriers; keep those two constructs apart when you analyze a case.
- 5.3 Communication theory is about encoding and decoding, packaging a message so that a particular group understands it as intended and finds it intuitively sensible. Behavior Change Communication is the working method of global health communication: developed first in nutrition and then in HIV/AIDS, rooted in diffusion of innovations, stages of change, self-efficacy, social marketing, and the World Bank's Behavior Change Continuum, and organized in eight steps with formative research at step four. It aims to increase knowledge, stimulate dialogue, change attitudes such as risk perception, reduce stigma, create demand, advocate, promote services, and build skills and self-efficacy. Recognize BCC by its sequence of steps, and remember that formative research comes before strategy.
- 5.4 When no message can solve the problem, match the theory to the obstacle. An agency with no system for getting data on who is affected to decision makers, or staff resisting a new data-to-planning system, calls for organizational change and advocacy. A community that must become aware and act collectively calls for Freire's participatory mobilization, in which the community defines the problem and the solutions. A population made vulnerable by political and economic decisions calls for political-economic approaches such as redirecting economic activity, rural health collaboratives, compensatory laws, or microcredit in the style of the Grameen Bank. A common trap is to answer a political-economic case with a hygiene or knowledge message, which treats the agent and leaves the conditions.
- 5.5 Global programs are pragmatic and usually combine theories, and the AIDS Risk Reduction Model is the lesson's example. ARRM joins the Health Belief Model and self-efficacy from Social Cognitive Theory with emotion and interpersonal processes, arranged in three stages: recognizing and labelling one's behaviour as high risk, committing to change, and taking action. Its stages echo earlier theories, as Table 9.3 shows: labelling parallels perceived susceptibility and the move to contemplation, commitment parallels intention and preparation, and action parallels the action stage and enabling factors. On an exam, match the stage described in a case to its parallel, and remember that emotion and the interpersonal are what ARRM adds.
- 5.6 To judge whether a theory fits a proposed program, ask in order: what stands between people and the behaviour, who decides, and whether the constructs have been filled in through local research. Each answer points to a family of theory, and an answer of "I do not know yet" points to formative research with local partners before any theory is applied. Interactive 9.3 walks through these questions. When a case describes a planner who has not learned the local barriers or the real decision maker, the right next step is research, not a message.
1. A planner imports a Theory of Planned Behavior questionnaire, validated in Ontario, to predict whether women in a rural district will attend antenatal care. Local staff report that mothers-in-law decide when a pregnant woman may leave the household. Which caution applies most directly?
2. Which statement best captures how ethnomedical systems relate to behavioural theory?
3. A draft program for married couples in the setting of Worked Example 9.3 tries to raise perceived susceptibility by presenting national HIV statistics. Which local belief most directly undermines perceived susceptibility in this setting?
4. The same draft treats cost as the main barrier and addresses each spouse as an individual decision maker. Which revision is most consistent with this section?
5. A campaign to promote oral rehydration solution follows these steps: state goals, involve interest holders, identify and segment target populations, run formative research on how caregivers understand diarrhoea, define objectives, design messages and channels with monitoring built in, then implement and evaluate. Which approach is this?
6. In the AIDS Risk Reduction Model, a man recognizes and labels his own behaviour as high risk. Which construct or stage from earlier theories is the closest parallel?
7. A rural district loses clinics and jobs after national policy favours coastal industry, and diarrhoeal disease rises among children left behind. Which family of theory should frame the intervention, and what might it aim to do?
8. A planner wants to use the Health Belief Model for a bed net program. She has not yet learned which barriers, benefits, and cues are real for this population, and she does not know who in the household decides whether children sleep under a net. Following the questions in this section, what should she do next?
✦ Pass the knowledge check with 100% to continue
Program Examples and Canada’s Role
⏱ Estimated reading time: 18 minutes
Overview
This lesson closes with a few examples of behaviour-related global health programs, none presented as a model to copy. Each shows theories chosen for a setting, channels chosen for an audience, and, usually, formative research that filled in the constructs locally. Read them with the questions of Section 3 in mind. The section describes the four programs and the theories behind them, looks closely at Trials of Improved Practices, the clearest method in the lesson for filling in a theory's constructs, compares a top-down and a participatory design within one program, and ends with Canada's part in the global health system.
Learning Objectives
- 6.1 Describe the components of four program examples (avian influenza communications, 100% Jeune in Cameroon, family planning in Albania, and the Freedom HIV/AIDS mobile games) and identify the theories each used and the evidence it reported.
- 6.2 Explain Trials of Improved Practices and why it learns more from what people cannot do than from what they can.
- 6.3 Compare a top-down and a participatory program design, and explain which is more likely to change behaviour and at what cost.
- 7.1 Describe Canada's contribution to global health promotion through the Ottawa Charter, government agencies, Grand Challenges Canada, and Canadian non-governmental organizations.
6.1 Four Programs That Made the Trip
6.1.1 The Four Programs
The four programs differ in setting, audience, and theory, and the purpose of studying them together is to practise identifying a theory from what a program actually does. Sometimes a program names its theory; sometimes the theory has to be recognized from its components. The first program shows the second case. A USAID communications program on avian influenza reached rural households through interpersonal, organizational and community, mass media, public relations and advocacy, and private sector channels. No theory is named, but its use of extension agents and peer farmers is diffusion of innovations in practice, because a new practice spreads through trusted people who adopt it first.
The next two programs name their theories more explicitly. Population Services International's 100% Jeune campaign in Cameroon used social marketing, built around a branded condom, together with entertainment-education and youth who helped design the messages. A family planning project in Albania, by contrast, used a Behavior Change Communication strategy based on cognitive anthropology, social interaction theory, commercial market research, and gender role and status theory. The fourth program shows a newer channel. Freedom HIV/AIDS, a pair of mobile phone games for East Africa, was based on Social Cognitive Theory. Open each of the four tabs below for the full account of each program, including its components or channels, the theories it drew on, and what its evaluation found.
Avian influenza communications program
USAID developed a communications program to inform target audiences about avian influenza and preventive strategies. Its components are the channels of a campaign. Interpersonal communication used agriculture and veterinary extension agents, counselling by clinic staff, and peer educators such as farmers and vendors. Organizational and community channels included workplaces, schools, village meetings, and affinity groups such as farmers' associations. Mass media covered television, radio, and print. Public relations and advocacy included leader conferences, press briefings, and training of public spokespersons. Private sector partnerships completed the set. Recall from Section 1 that the audience was rural households for whom poultry is both livelihood and tradition. Extension agents and peer farmers are diffusion of innovations in practice: trusted early adopters through whom a new practice spreads.
Social marketing for STI prevention in Cameroon
Population Services International ran a social marketing campaign against sexually transmitted infections and unwanted pregnancies among urban youth in Cameroon, aimed at about 600,000 young people aged 15 to 24 in Douala and Yaoundé (Neukom and Ashford, 2003). Young Cameroonian peer educators, journalists, comic-strip artists, radio personalities, and scriptwriters helped develop the messages. The campaign was built around the 100% Jeune (100% Young) condom brand, with messages promoting images of youth who challenged social norms and protected their health; more than 40,000 of these condoms were sold in 2002. A serial radio drama and a call-in talk show were part of the effort, and face-to-face sessions for youth in and out of school reached about 10,000 a month. Evaluation showed that knowledge increased, attitudes about buying condoms became more positive, and condom use rose with regular partners, although the evaluators found that factors besides the campaign also contributed to some of these improvements (Plautz and Meekers, 2007). A branded product, a price, distribution, and promotion are social marketing's four Ps; the drama and talk show are entertainment-education; the young message developers are participation as well as consumer research.
Albania family planning project
In Albania, the Manoff Group, a research and program consulting organization, took part in a USAID-supported family planning project led by John Snow, Inc. It designed a BCC strategy based on cognitive anthropology, social interaction theory, behaviour change theories derived from commercial market research, and gender role and status theory, to help Albanians adopt and use modern family planning methods. The work ran through twelve steps: a literature review; formative qualitative research; Trials of Improved Practices; a behaviour change strategy; a national baseline survey; two television spots portraying, symbolically and socially, the cognitive domains found in the research and advocating locally feasible behaviours from the TIPs results; broadcasting; a media recall survey; community outreach; a call-in show, because the research had shown that most modern methods were unknown; a press workshop for journalists; and a follow-up survey. The formative research elicited cognitive domains through a projective technique in ethnographic interviews, assuming that fertility and family planning are parts of culture inextricably linked to gender roles and status and to the couple's relationship. According to the project's account, most of the audience saw the spots, and the great majority discussed them with others. That last finding is the theory at work: models of culture change hold that discussing information with others is key to producing knowledge, and all BCC steps from design to evaluation were based on culture theories. By this we mean that, in these models, knowledge about something like family planning is not simply received by individuals from a television screen; it is built up as people talk the information over with spouses, relatives, and friends and decide together what it means. A spot that many people discussed has therefore done more than reach its audience, because it has entered the conversations through which shared understanding changes.
Mobile phone games for HIV/AIDS prevention
An example of mHealth, the use of mobile devices in health promotion, is Freedom HIV/AIDS, developed in Africa by ZMQ, an India-based social enterprise, with partners, building on an earlier effort in India, using two awareness games on mobile phones. AIDS Fighter Pilot is an adventure game about a village boy, Juma, and a village girl, Wanjiku, peer educators who spread knowledge about HIV/AIDS in every corner of their village using their glider. AIDS Penalty Shoot Out is based on soccer: players save and shoot penalties, receive messages on awareness, prevention, and myths, and the score reflects how much was learned and triggers feedback. For Eastern Africa the games were developed in English, Kiswahili, and Sheng, the urban mixed language of Nairobi. The approach is based on Social Cognitive Theory: the score measures knowledge change, and the interactive play is intended to build self-efficacy and motivation for prevention.
Interactive 9.4 is a theory spotter that lets you test what the tabs have shown. For each of the four programs it asks which of nine theories the program drew on, and its feedback marks each choice as named or clearly described in the program account, a defensible inference, or unsupported. Try each program before reading the comparison that follows.
📊 Interactive 9.4: Theory spotter.
Pick a program, select the theories it drew on, and press Check. Green: named or clearly described in the program account above. Amber: a defensible inference. Red: unsupported.The spotter rewards reading the program accounts closely: a theory counts as used when the account names it or clearly describes its mechanism, and a guess that merely sounds plausible is marked as such. Exam questions about these programs work the same way.
6.1.2 The Programs Side by Side
The tabs describe each program on its own terms. Table 9.4 sets the four programs side by side, with their lead actors classified by the actor types of Section 2, the theories each named or clearly used, and the evidence each reported.
Table 9.4. The four program examples compared by lead actors, theories named or clearly used, and evidence reported.
| Program | Lead actors (Section 2 types) | Theories named or clearly used | Evidence reported |
|---|---|---|---|
| Avian influenza communications | USAID (bilateral), with extension services, clinics, private partners | Communication theory; channels consistent with diffusion and mobilization | Components described; no outcome data |
| 100% Jeune, Cameroon | Population Services International (NGO) | Social marketing; entertainment-education; peer participation in message design | Knowledge up, attitudes to buying condoms better, condom use up with regular partners; factors besides the campaign also contributed |
| Albania family planning | Manoff Group and John Snow, Inc., with USAID support | Cognitive anthropology; social interaction theory; commercial market research; gender role and status theory; BCC; TIPs | Most of the audience saw the spots; most discussed them with others (project account) |
| Freedom HIV/AIDS mHealth games | ZMQ (social enterprise) with partners | Social Cognitive Theory: knowledge, self-efficacy, motivation | Score as a measure of knowledge change; no population outcomes |
Two patterns stand out. The first is that every program used several theories, as Section 3 predicted, which is the multitheory pattern of ARRM seen in practice. The second is that the most explicitly theoretical programs, Albania and Cameroon, are the ones with formative research and local participation in message design. This matters because a theory's constructs are empty until local research fills them in, so the programs that took theory most seriously were also the ones that had to spend the most time learning from their audiences. For example, young Cameroonians helped write the 100% Jeune messages, and Albanian households tested behaviours through TIPs before the television spots were made. In this sense the lesson's advice about partnership is restated as method: working with the community is not only a principle but the procedure by which a theory is made to fit the setting. The Albania project's third step, Trials of Improved Practices, shows that method most clearly, and the next subsection describes it.
6.2 Trials of Improved Practices
The Albania project's third step is the clearest example in this lesson of a method built to fill in a theory's constructs locally. Trials of Improved Practices, or TIPs, was developed by the Manoff Group and first used in 1979. Put simply, TIPs asks real households to try a small, improved behaviour for a week and then finds out what happened. The method begins with formative qualitative research, from which the researcher develops a menu of behaviours that would improve audience members' health or help them reach their fertility goals more safely. These behaviours may differ from the ideal recommendation, because they are tailored to local norms; the purpose is to offer steps people could realistically take rather than the textbook ideal.
The trial itself follows a set sequence. The researcher draws a sample of at least 15 people per audience segment and observes and interviews them at home or in clinics. Next, the researcher negotiates a behaviour for the person or couple to try during the coming week and obtains a commitment. Finally, the researcher returns after a week to learn how the trial went.
The line to remember is that the aim is to learn what behaviours are locally feasible, so researchers often learn more from what people were unable to do than from what they could do. By this we mean that a household that could not keep to the agreed behaviour has revealed a barrier the planner did not know about, which is exactly the information a program needs. Results are therefore analyzed as barriers and as supports or motivators, the same categories as the Health Belief Model's barriers and PRECEDE's enabling and reinforcing factors. TIPs is based on both culture theory and behaviour change theories, and it can be understood as a week-long, household-level test of whether a theory's construct has the content you assumed. A trial that fails is therefore not a failed household but a found barrier, and the next step is to adjust the recommended behaviour to something feasible. This distinguishes TIPs from a survey of knowledge or attitudes, which records what people say they think, whereas TIPs records what people could actually do. The next subsection shows what happens when a program uses this kind of method and when it does not.
6.3 Top-Down or Participatory: Two Districts, One Program
A top-down design and a participatory one can also be compared within a single program. A top-down design is built at head office from a package used elsewhere. By this we mean that its messages, channels, and assumptions about who decides were worked out for another population, so its constructs are filled in somewhere else. A participatory design, in contrast, fills them in locally, with formative research, methods such as TIPs, and community partners who help define the problem and the solution. The purpose of comparing the two within one program is to hold the funder, the goal, and the behaviour constant, so that any difference in results can be traced to the design. Worked Example 9.4 follows a handwashing program, funded through a bilateral grant to a Canadian NGO, that was designed at head office for District A and built on formative research and TIPs in District B. As you read it, look for each assumption District A made and how District B tested it.
Worked Example 9.4: Handwashing in Two Districts
The case. A Canadian NGO receives a bilateral grant to reduce diarrhoeal disease among children under five in two rural districts of a partner country. In District A, the program is designed at head office from a package used elsewhere: posters and a radio jingle on handwashing with soap after the latrine and before feeding children, translated into the national language, distributed through clinics, with a knowledge recall survey at six months. In District B, the field team spends two months on formative research with a local women's association, then runs TIPs with 20 households. They learn that soap is kept for laundry, that water is carried from a well twenty minutes away, that a local language is spoken at home, and that grandmothers, not mothers, decide how children are fed. The negotiated behaviours are washing with ash or soap at two key moments using a hanging water container made from local materials, promoted through the women's association, grandmothers' meetings, and local-language radio. At six months, District A's survey shows high message awareness; District B's household observations show more handwashing stations in use.
Step 1, identify the behaviour, the population, and the two designs. The behaviour is handwashing at key moments by the people who care for children under five in two rural districts. District A is a top-down message campaign; District B is a participatory program built on formative research.
Step 2, name the theories under each design. District A is a message campaign whose constructs were filled in somewhere else, with a theory of change that ends at knowledge. District B is Behavior Change Communication with formative research at its fourth step, TIPs to test feasible behaviours, community mobilization through the women's association, and the right decision-making unit, the grandmothers.
Step 3, check the assumptions against the assessment. District A assumes that soap is available for hands, that water is nearby, that the national language reaches the home, and that mothers decide. Each assumption is a barrier an educational and ecological assessment would have found, and District B's TIPs found every one of them.
Step 4, explain the measures. District A measured awareness because a message campaign aims at knowledge, and its survey shows that the message arrived. District B measured behaviour, handwashing stations in use, because TIPs negotiates behaviours. A recall survey can rise while behaviour does not, so District A's result does not show that children are safer.
Step 5, name the cost. District B's approach took two months of research, has a smaller reach, and cannot be copied to District C without repeating the research.
What the example shows. District B was more likely to change behaviour because it filled in the constructs locally, identified the real decision makers, and worked in participatory collaboration, so its program addressed actual barriers and supports rather than assumed ones. Its costs are real, and they are the price of changing behaviour rather than awareness.
The worked example showed the lesson's central advice as a comparison: the participatory design found the barriers that the top-down design assumed away, and it measured the outcome that mattered. The same advice runs through Canada's own contribution to the global health system, which the last subsection describes.
7.1 Canada in the Global Health System
Three of the program examples above were run by American organizations, and the fourth was developed by an India-based social enterprise. Canada, however, occupies the same boxes on the actor map, and its contribution to health promotion runs back to the document that defined the field. The Canadian contribution has four parts, and it helps to see each one as a different kind of role.
The first part is an idea rather than an organization. The first International Conference on Health Promotion met in Ottawa in 1986, and its charter became the reference point for a series of WHO conferences and for health promotion practice worldwide. The second part is government funding. Canada's bilateral agency, once the Canadian International Development Agency and now Global Affairs Canada, funds programs abroad, and the International Development Research Centre funds research. The third part is a funder with a particular condition. Grand Challenges Canada, founded in 2010, funds innovators, but it requires social and business innovation alongside scientific ideas, by which we mean that a new technology must come with the community and behavioural work that will get it used and the business innovation that makes it sustainable. The fourth part is delivery. Canadian non-governmental organizations, from CARE Canada to the Stephen Lewis Foundation and Nutrition International, implement programs. Each of these four parts of the Canadian contribution is described in more detail below. The last three correspond to boxes on the actor map of Interactive 9.2 in Section 2.
The Ottawa Charter's global influence
The first International Conference on Health Promotion, hosted in Ottawa in 1986 by WHO, Health and Welfare Canada, and the Canadian Public Health Association, produced the charter (WHO, 1986). Its definition of health promotion and its five action areas became the reference point for a series of WHO global conferences, from Adelaide in 1988 through Bangkok in 2005, whose charter addressed health promotion in a globalized world directly, to Shanghai in 2016. When Section 3 says that mobilization, advocacy, and policy change are part of global public health work, it is describing the Ottawa Charter's action areas in practice.
Government agencies: Global Affairs Canada, IDRC, and PHAC
Canada's bilateral agency was the Canadian International Development Agency, created in 1968 and merged into the foreign affairs department in 2013; its work now runs through Global Affairs Canada, whose priorities have included the 2010 Muskoka Initiative on maternal, newborn, and child health and the Feminist International Assistance Policy of 2017. The International Development Research Centre, a Crown corporation created in 1970, funds research in low- and middle-income countries. Canada is a member of WHO and, since 1971, of the Pan American Health Organization, and hosted the Global Fund's fifth replenishment conference in Montreal in 2016.
Grand Challenges Canada
Grand Challenges Canada, founded in 2010 and funded largely by the Government of Canada, funds innovators in low- and middle-income countries and in Canada. Its Integrated Innovation approach holds that a scientific or technological idea reaches people only when paired with social innovation, the community and behavioural work this lesson describes, and business innovation that makes it sustainable. Its programs have included Stars in Global Health and Saving Brains, and it co-founded Saving Lives at Birth in 2011. In the actor categories of Section 2 it is closest to a parastatal organization, and it shows how a funder can require theory-based behavioural work as a condition of support.
Canadian non-governmental organizations
Canadian NGOs occupy the implementation box on the actor map. CARE Canada was founded in 1946, a year after CARE itself. Cuso International, founded in 1961, places volunteers with partner organizations. The Stephen Lewis Foundation, founded in 2003, supports community-based organizations responding to HIV/AIDS in sub-Saharan Africa; its Grandmothers to Grandmothers Campaign, launched in 2006, is community mobilization on both sides of the partnership. Nutrition International, based in Ottawa, works on vitamin A supplementation and salt iodization, where a behaviour change component decides whether a technology is used. Right To Play, based in Toronto, uses sport and play in health and education programs. Médecins Sans Frontières and the Red Cross have Canadian sections, and Canadian James Orbinski accepted the 1999 Nobel Peace Prize on behalf of Médecins Sans Frontières as its international president.
The four parts show Canada at every stage of the chain: the charter that defined health promotion, the agencies that fund, a funder that makes behavioural and community work a condition of support, and the NGOs that deliver. For a student, the entry point to any of this is the advice that runs through this lesson: partner with people who know the local capacity, beliefs, norms, and culture, and do the research before designing the program. The final review draws the threads together: a global setting that includes Canada, a system of actors that decides what gets built, theories that travel with adaptation, and programs that succeed when they fill in their constructs locally and treat the community as a partner.
This section has described four programs that carried theory into new settings, the Trials of Improved Practices method for filling in constructs locally, the contrast between a top-down and a participatory design in Worked Example 9.4, and Canada's place in the global health system. The key takeaways below summarize the section, and the knowledge check asks you to apply it.
Key Takeaways
- 6.1 Each of the four programs combined theories chosen for its setting. The USAID avian influenza program used interpersonal, community, mass media, advocacy, and private sector channels, with extension agents and peer farmers as diffusion of innovations in practice. PSI's 100% Jeune campaign in Cameroon was social marketing, with a branded condom, entertainment-education, and youth in message design, and it raised knowledge, improved attitudes to buying condoms, and increased condom use with regular partners. The Albania project used a culture-theory based BCC strategy with TIPs, and most viewers discussed its spots, which models of culture change treat as how knowledge is produced; the Freedom HIV/AIDS games used Social Cognitive Theory to build knowledge, self-efficacy, and motivation. When asked which theory a program used, look for what the account names or clearly describes, such as a brand and price for social marketing or a score that builds self-efficacy for Social Cognitive Theory.
- 6.2 Trials of Improved Practices, developed by the Manoff Group and first used in 1979, builds a menu of locally feasible behaviours from formative research, negotiates one with each of at least 15 people per audience segment to try for a week, obtains a commitment, and returns to see what happened. Results are sorted into barriers and supports. Its key insight is that researchers learn more from what people could not do than from what they could, because each failure reveals a barrier the theory's constructs must include. In a case, treat a household that cannot carry out the recommended behaviour as the most useful finding, and adjust the recommendation rather than repeating it.
- 6.3 A top-down program fills in its constructs somewhere else, assumes the barriers and the decision maker, and tends to measure awareness; a participatory program fills in the constructs locally, identifies the real decision-making unit, works with community partners, and measures behaviour. In Worked Example 9.4, District B's research found that soap was kept for laundry, water was far away, a local language was spoken, and grandmothers decided, every one a barrier District A's package assumed away. The participatory design costs time, reach, and easy replication, and a good answer names those costs as well as the advantage. Remember that a recall survey shows only that a message arrived, not that behaviour changed.
- 7.1 Canada appears at every stage of the global health chain. The Ottawa Charter of 1986, from the first International Conference on Health Promotion, became the reference point for later WHO conferences and for health promotion worldwide. Global Affairs Canada (formerly CIDA) and IDRC fund programs and research abroad, Grand Challenges Canada, founded in 2010, requires social and business innovation alongside scientific ideas, and Canadian NGOs such as CARE Canada, Cuso International, the Stephen Lewis Foundation, and Nutrition International implement programs. On an exam, link each Canadian actor to its box on the actor map and to what it does: chartering, funding, requiring behavioural work, or delivering.
1. Which feature of the Cameroon campaign most clearly marks it as social marketing rather than a general health education program?
2. In the Albania project, television spots portrayed the cognitive domains found in ethnographic interviews, and the recall survey found that most viewers discussed the spots with others. Why does the discussion finding count as evidence that the theory worked?
3. A TIPs researcher recommends that a mother add an egg to her toddler's porridge daily and returns a week later to find she managed it twice, because eggs are sold for cash and the family keeps only two hens. What should the researcher do with this result?
4. Two districts receive a handwashing program. District A gets a translated poster and jingle package delivered through clinics and measures message recall. District B runs formative research and TIPs with local women's groups and measures observed handwashing. Which argument best explains why District B is more likely to change behaviour?
5. Which statement about Canada's place in the global health system is accurate?
6. A team designing a behaviour change component for a new low-cost water filter wants to borrow from the four program examples. Which pairing of a borrowed element and its source program is accurate?
7. Six months into the water filter program, the team proposes to evaluate it with a media recall survey alone. Why would that not be enough?
✦ Pass the knowledge check with 100% to continue
Final Review & Assessment
⏱ Estimated time: 25 minutes
Bringing It All Together
This lesson moved from a claim to a method. The claim is that it has become less and less useful to think about global health as separate from domestic health. HIV/AIDS travels along trade routes, urban migration, labour flows, and tourism; avian influenza followed poultry markets and migratory birds from Hong Kong across Asia to Europe; and the shirt on your back passed through six countries on its way to you. Health still follows different paths in different countries because of five ecological factors, environmental risks, system capacity and infrastructure, socioeconomic conditions, political conditions, and social patterns and cultural traditions, and because countries sit at different points of the epidemiologic transition, a line that HIV, influenza, longer lifespans, and uneven development within countries have blurred. The global ecology of health is the same onion as the domestic one, with more layers.
The outer layers are the global health system: bilateral agencies, regional and multilateral organizations, public/private partnerships, financial institutions, NGOs and foundations, and parastatal bodies, combined differently for a disaster and for a long-term prevention effort, and always delivering through a country's ministry, local organizations, and communities. Because funding, coordination, approval, and delivery sit in different boxes, the theory a program uses is often negotiated, and a PRECEDE-PROCEED style assessment comes before choosing one. The educational and ecological phase carries the central advice of the lesson: make no quick assumptions, partner with people who know the local capacity, beliefs, norms, and culture, take time to do research, and work in participatory collaboration. The administrative and policy phase, in the Country X scenario, shows funder rules and political opposition shaping a program before any theory is named.
The method follows. Most theories travel in basic form, but their constructs must be filled in locally and the assumption that the individual decides must be checked against the ethnomedical system and the real decision-making unit. Communication is where theory is most explicit, and Behavior Change Communication, with formative research as its fourth step, is the working approach. Organizational change, Freire's participatory mobilization, and political-economic theories address obstacles no message can move, and real programs combine several, as the AIDS Risk Reduction Model does. The four program examples, avian influenza communications, 100% Jeune in Cameroon, family planning in Albania with Trials of Improved Practices, and Social Cognitive Theory based mobile games, show the combination in practice, and Canada occupies every box on the map, from the Ottawa Charter to Grand Challenges Canada and Canadian NGOs.
Key Takeaways from this lesson
- You can now explain why global and domestic health have merged: globalization moves people, information, resources, and environments across borders, and HIV/AIDS and avian influenza travel the same routes, which run through Canada. When a case describes something crossing a border, name the specific implication of globalization it shows rather than "globalization" in general.
- You can describe the five ecological factors that send health along different paths and explain the epidemiologic transition, including how HIV/AIDS, influenza, longer lifespans, and uneven development blur it and how migrants carry it across a border. To classify a case, ask what kind of cause it describes; a country showing two patterns at once points to uneven development within it.
- You can identify the seven types of global health actor and predict their combinations: NGOs with bilateral or regional funding in a crisis, WHO coordinating foundations, agencies, ministries, and NGOs in long-term prevention. Always ask who funds, who coordinates, who approves, and who delivers, because a funder such as the Global Fund is not an implementer.
- You can apply a PRECEDE-PROCEED style assessment to a global problem, naming sources such as the Demographic and Health Surveys, the Global Burden of Disease study, the Multiple Indicator Cluster Survey, and gray literature, and placing funder rules and political opposition in the administrative and policy phase. The most useful reminder is the central advice of the lesson: make no quick assumptions, and partner, research, and collaborate before designing a program.
- You can explain how theories travel: fill in the constructs locally, check who decides, and respect the ethnomedical system, then match the obstacle to the family of theory, from Behavior Change Communication to organizational change, Freire's mobilization, political economy, and combined models such as ARRM. If you do not yet know the local barriers or the real decision maker, the next step is formative research.
- You can identify the theories behind the four program examples and explain why Trials of Improved Practices and participatory design change behaviour: they find the barriers a top-down design assumes away. Judge a program by whether it measured behaviour rather than recall, and treat what people could not do in a trial as the most useful finding.
- You can describe Canada's contribution, from the Ottawa Charter of 1986 to Global Affairs Canada, IDRC, Grand Challenges Canada, and Canadian NGOs such as CARE Canada and the Stephen Lewis Foundation. Link each Canadian actor to its box on the actor map and to what it does.
Final Knowledge Assessment
This assessment covers all material from this lesson. You must score 100% to complete the lesson. Review the feedback for any incorrect answers and try again.
1. Which of the following best states the reason for opening a lesson on global health with a discussion of globalization?
2. A country's rural clinics exist on paper, but most have no trained staff and are located far from the villages they serve, and there is no system for collecting mortality data. Under which of the five ecological factors does this cluster of problems fall?
3. What does it mean to say that HIV/AIDS and several forms of influenza have blurred the epidemiologic transition?
4. Which of the following is an example of a parastatal organization?
5. For a long-term effort to prevent the spread of an infectious disease, which actor is likely to coordinate, and with whom?
6. Why is getting data on global health both easy and problematic?
7. In the Country X scenario, a small but vocal group of medical professionals opposes any direct education of youth about sexuality. What does this most directly imply for the program?
8. In a global context, using the Health Belief Model may require extra effort. What specifically has to be done?
9. Which of the following are the theoretical roots of Behavior Change Communication?
10. A district health office collects good surveillance data, but the information never reaches the planners who allocate clinic staff, and the staff resist a new system that would link the two. Which family of theory fits this problem?
11. Which statement about the AIDS Risk Reduction Model is correct?
12. In the avian influenza communications program, agriculture and veterinary extension agents and peer educators such as farmers and vendors were used. Which communication channel category do they belong to, and which theory do they most resemble in practice?
13. What did the evaluation of the 100% Jeune campaign in Cameroon find?
14. The Albania project's formative research used a projective technique in ethnographic interviews to elicit cognitive domains. What assumption underlay this design?
15. Which feature of Grand Challenges Canada's approach most directly reflects the argument of this lesson that a technology reaches people only through behavioural and community work?
16. A ministry asks a Canadian NGO to reduce diarrhoeal disease among children under five in a rural region where grandmothers decide how children are fed and a local language rather than the national one is spoken at home. The NGO's first draft targets mothers with an individual-level model and national-language posters. What is the most important change?
17. In the same region, a group of local clinicians argues that the real problem is that mothers are ignorant, and proposes to judge the program by a knowledge survey. What is the strongest response based on this lesson?
18. The NGO's program in this region is funded by Global Affairs Canada, approved by the partner ministry of health, and delivered by the NGO with a local women's association. How does this arrangement fit the actor map of Section 2?
✦ Pass every section knowledge check before submitting