HSCI 312 · Lesson 10

High-Risk Populations, Culture,
and Health Disparities

Health Promotion: Individuals and Communities

Learning objectives for this lesson:

  1. Explain what it means to call a population high risk, how circumstances shape that risk, and why working issues such as trust must be addressed before any program.
  2. Describe how output theories (the Health Belief Model, the Theory of Planned Behavior, and the risk and protective factors model) conceptualize risk behaviour, and where they fall short in high-risk contexts.
  3. Explain how harm reduction meets people where they are, and apply it to a case by naming the most pressing threat, what is left for later, and the service's place on the Canadian continuum.
  4. Explain the generative approach and the generative schema, distinguish a generative account of behaviour from a predictive one, and use the approach to derive intervention ideas from a case.
  5. Explain why health disparities exist, using the trajectory of health (circumstance, vulnerability, and response) and the ecological range of contributing factors from mistrust to missing data systems.
  6. Compare the CLAS standards' approach to cultural competence with the critique of competence as a checklist and with cultural safety as it is used in Indigenous health in Canada.
  7. Apply individual, community, multilevel, and organizational theory to resolving a disparity, using the CDC sociocultural framework and distinguishing culturally appropriate, adapted, and grounded programs.

This course was developed by Dr. Kiffer G. Card, to accompany Edberg, M. Essentials of Health Behavior: Social and Behavioral Theory in Public Health. Jones & Bartlett Learning. This lesson follows Chapters 13 and 15 of the text.

Reference

Glossary: Key Terms, People & Concepts

📚 Reference page, available throughout the lesson

This glossary collects the key concepts, people, and ideas you will meet in this lesson. Use it as a reference while you work through the material, or as a review before assessments. Type in the search box to filter entries.

High-risk populations and output theories
High-risk population A group, rather than an individual, whose risk for one or more health problems is particularly high, or who is difficult to reach with ordinary programs. The high risk is almost always tied to circumstances (poverty, exclusion, hazardous work, illegal or marginalized activity), and treating the label as a person's primary identity limits both understanding and intervention.
Shared benefits One of the seven working issues that almost always matter in work with high-risk populations: the population at risk has a voice in the desired outcomes of a program. The others are building and sustaining trust, gaining access, finding the right way to communicate, a willingness to learn, confidentiality, and honesty about what you are doing and why.
Output theories Shorthand for theories that conceptualize behaviour as the output of a set of inputs (factors) or thinking processes (stages of readiness, cost-benefit decisions). The Health Belief Model, the Theory of Planned Behavior, and the risk and protective factors model are the examples given. Their strength is measurability; their weakness is that the health behaviour is assumed to be the object of the person's attention.
Risk and protective factors model The framework developed by Hawkins, Catalano, and colleagues in which exposure to risk factors increases, and exposure to protective factors decreases, the likelihood that a youth will engage in violence, delinquency, substance use, school dropout, or HIV risk behaviour. It is, in effect, an epidemiological exposure model: easy to program and measure, but silent on how the factors link to meaning and intent.
Protective factors Exposures and characteristics that reduce the likelihood of problem behaviour. In the Hawkins and Catalano model they are less well specified than the twenty risk factors and are grouped into individual attributes (gender, intelligence, temperament), social bonding to prosocial people and groups, healthy beliefs, and clear standards for behaviour in families, schools, and communities.
Clustering of risk factors The observation that risk factors, and problem behaviours, tend to occur together in the same young people, so that their combined presence means more than the sum of the parts. Researchers such as Jessor have read clustering as evidence of an oppositional or nonconventional worldview, which the exposure model itself does not describe.
Harm reduction and generative approaches
Harm reduction An approach that focuses on the specific behaviours posing the greatest public health threat (for example, sharing injection equipment) while not immediately addressing other risky or unhealthy behaviours a person may engage in. It meets people where they are, without judging or overcategorizing the person as a whole, and the trust it builds becomes an opening for change in other areas of life.
Needle exchange program A program that allows people who inject drugs to exchange used syringes and equipment for sterile equipment, cutting a leading route of HIV transmission. In Canada such services are usually called needle and syringe distribution programs and have operated since the late 1980s; in the United States, a long-standing federal funding ban meant that programs seeking federal funding could not support this activity.
Drug substitution treatment Medically supervised treatment of drug dependence using a substitute drug such as methadone or buprenorphine that reduces craving without most of the negative consequences of the drug being replaced. In current Canadian practice this is called opioid agonist treatment.
Community health outreach worker A worker, often in recovery from addiction and from the community being served, who distributes risk reduction kits, provides education, and staffs needle exchange programs. Their role draws on Social Network Theory, Social Cognitive Theory (the worker as a model), and the Transtheoretical Model (matching the approach to readiness to change).
Supervised consumption site A health service where people can use pre-obtained drugs under observation, with sterile equipment and staff who can respond to overdose. Insite, opened in Vancouver's Downtown Eastside in 2003, was the first legally sanctioned site of its kind in North America and operates under an exemption from the Controlled Drugs and Substances Act.
Generative approach An approach that works with the organizing and motivating processes through which people generate behaviour over time, rather than with inputs and outputs. It draws on ideas from anthropology, social psychology, and sociology (cultural models, narratives, scripts, discourses, frames, schema) that remain largely untapped in public health.
Generative schema An internalized model of how things are supposed to be, such as a status construct or a gender construct, that organizes and guides actions, reactions, and emotions and so generates behaviour. A schema is generative but not predictive in the positivistic sense, because people assemble their behaviour in varying ways to carry out its organizing theme.
Habitus Pierre Bourdieu's term for the integration of socioeconomic constraints, life patterns, and associated values and beliefs. It explains why generative schema develop within a framework of what is understood to be possible: a group that expects short, precarious lives develops values that support short-term gain and survival strategies.
Possible selves A term from social psychologists Oyserman and Markus for the identities a person imagines they could become. In a generative approach, adding possible selves and less risky behaviours to a person's inventory offers other ways to satisfy a schema such as mastery or status, so that stopping a risk behaviour does not leave them with nothing around which to build an identity.
Culture, diversity, and disparities
Health disparities Differences in health status and in the quality of and access to health care between populations. This lesson focuses on disparities affecting racial and ethnic minority populations, while noting that disparities also arise from socioeconomic status and geography alone. Canadian reporting often distinguishes health inequalities (any difference) from health inequities (differences that are unfair and avoidable).
Heckler Report The 1985 report of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services Secretary's Task Force on Black and Minority Health, named for Secretary Margaret Heckler. It made minority health disparities a public policy issue, identified six causes of excess deaths (cancer, cardiovascular disease and stroke, chemical dependency, diabetes, homicide and accidents, and infant mortality), and reported roughly a thirty-year lag in health status improvement for African Americans.
Trajectory of health A way of thinking about disparities: historical circumstances produce, for a population, a combination of vulnerability and exposure to disease together with the systems of knowledge, attitude, and practice that developed in response to that vulnerability and experience. Vulnerability, circumstance, and response together form the forces that produce disparities.
Ethnomedical system A cultural system of knowledge and practice that defines illnesses and diseases, their causes, appropriate treatments, and appropriate treatment providers. Where such a system differs from Western biomedicine and a population adheres to it strongly, a gap in understanding and use of standard medical care can result, as in the case of Lia Lee.
Cultural competence The capacity of providers and organizations to deliver care that is compatible with patients' cultural health beliefs, practices, and preferred language. The CLAS standards define it in practice; critics such as Kleinman and Benson argue that it should not be treated as a list of traits or a technical checklist, because individuals within cultures vary and cultures are not static.
CLAS standards The U.S. national standards for Culturally and Linguistically Appropriate Services in health care, first issued by the Office of Minority Health in 2000. The original fourteen standards are organized into three themes: culturally competent care, language access services, and organizational supports for cultural competence; enhanced standards with a different structure replaced them in 2013.
Cultural safety A concept developed in nursing in Aotearoa New Zealand and widely used in Indigenous health in Canada. Where cultural competence asks what the provider knows, cultural safety asks whether the person receiving care feels safe and respected, and it directs attention to power, racism, and the history of the health system rather than to a list of cultural traits.
Vulnerable populations Groups, defined by socioeconomic status, race and ethnicity, or other characteristics, whom poverty and social marginalization leave with poor access to the interrelated systems of health, economic, and social resources. This access-poor position generates patterns of living focused on survival and social goals within a limited sphere, rather than on maximizing health.
Community mobilization Organizing a community to act on its own behalf, for example to gain access to health care or remove an environmental risk. Mobilization and advocacy are recommended for structural causes of disparities; they build community capacity and empowerment, and the CDC Community Guide recommends mobilization for tobacco control.
Multilevel program A program that ties several strategies together across ecological levels. Examples are the CDC REACH program (Racial and Ethnic Approaches to Community Health), which links community organizational capacity, targeted action, knowledge and behaviour change, and health outcomes, and THRIVE, which strengthens four community clusters: built environment, social capital, services and institutions, and structural factors.
Sociocultural framework The CDC model, adapted from the Community Guide's model for linking the social environment to health, that traces a pathway from determinants (equity and social justice, social resources, the physical environment, natural resources) through six intermediate outcomes (neighbourhood living conditions, community development and employment, civic engagement, community norms, opportunities for learning, and health promotion and care opportunities) to the impact of healthier communities.
People
Hawkins and Catalano J. David Hawkins and Richard F. Catalano, University of Washington researchers whose risk and protective factor approach organizes twenty risk factors into individual, peer, family, school, community, and society domains and underlies the Communities That Care system used in violence and substance use prevention.
Pierre Bourdieu French social theorist (1930 to 2002) whose concept of habitus the generative approach borrows to describe how socioeconomic constraints, life patterns, and values become integrated into the dispositions that generate behaviour.
Oyserman and Markus Daphna Oyserman and Hazel Markus, social psychologists who used the constructs of self-concept and possible selves to explain the internal dynamic behind clusters of youth risk behaviour and delinquency. Their work is an exception to public health's general neglect of generative constructs.
Lia Lee The Hmong child whose severe epilepsy, understood by her family as qaug dab peg (the spirit catches you and you fall down), is the subject of Anne Fadiman's book The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down. Her case illustrates the collision of an ethnomedical system with Western biomedicine.
Kleinman and Benson Arthur Kleinman and Peter Benson, medical anthropologists whose 2006 essay argued that cultural competence should not be a technical skill or a checklist of traits, and proposed instead attending to how individual patients subjectively experience the intersection of culture and health.
No matching entries. Try a different search term.
Section 1

High-Risk Populations: Looking Beyond the Behaviour

⏱ Estimated reading time: 17 minutes

Section 1 of 4

High-Risk Populations: Looking Beyond the Behaviour

What the label means, what it hides, and how far output theories can take you.

Defining the term

Populations, not individuals

A high-risk population is a group whose risk for one or more health problems is particularly high, or who is difficult to reach with ordinary programs.

Hazardous work or living conditionsLimited access to careParticularly risky behaviourIllegal or marginalized activity

The behaviour looks abnormal only when viewed solely in the context of health.

Preconditions

Seven things that almost always matter

Trust

Built slowly, lost quickly.

Access

Go where people already are.

Communication

The right words, channel, and messenger.

Willingness to learn

The population is the expert.

ConfidentialityHonesty: what you are doing and whyShared benefits: a voice in the outcomes
The central argument

The behaviour is usually about something else

Their primary identity becomes a high-risk population. If that is all we focus on, we limit our understanding of health risk among these populations and, as a result, the appropriate use of theory and the development of effective interventions.The cost of a risk label

An IDU, or an uncle, a cook, a mechanic, a person coping with a difficult living situation?

Output theories

Inputs in, behaviour out

Decision models

Health Belief Model and Theory of Planned Behavior: a narrow, linear process in which the behaviour and its health consequences are the object of attention.

Exposure model

Risk and protective factors: twenty risk factors across individual, peer, family, school, community, and society domains; the balance of exposures predicts the output.

Here is the rub: what if the behaviour is about gender roles, status, or survival, and not about health at all?

The evidence

Violence versus HIV

Youth violence

The behaviour is the health problem. Programs reduce risk factors, but links to less violence are weak. Many programs found ineffective (Surgeon General, 2001; NIH, 2004).

HIV/AIDS

Specific behaviours are routes of transmission. Change sharing of equipment, condom use, or number of partners and the route is cut. The record is better.

Carry forward

What to take into the next section

  • High risk is shaped by circumstances; trust, access, communication, learning, confidentiality, honesty, and shared benefits come first.
  • Output theories treat behaviour as the output of inputs; they are measurable but assume health is the object of attention.
  • Short funding cycles bias the literature toward what is easy to measure.
  • Next: harm reduction and the generative approach.

Overview

Public health interventions, as a whole, target everyone who has or is at risk for a health problem. Sometimes, though, it is necessary to focus on particular populations, as opposed to individuals, who are said to be at high risk or who are difficult to reach. This section asks what that label means, what has to be in place before a program can work with such a population, and how well the theories you have studied so far, which we will call output theories, explain behaviour in these settings. The answers matter because a program built on the wrong picture of a population will fail however carefully it applies its theory.

Learning Objectives

  • 1.1 Explain what it means to call a population high risk, why public health sometimes directs programs at whole populations, and how circumstances shape that risk.
  • 1.2 Identify the seven working issues that almost always matter with high-risk populations and what each means in practice.
  • 1.3 Explain why high-risk behaviour is often about something other than health, and what is lost when a risk label becomes a person's primary identity.
  • 2.1 Describe how the decision models (the Health Belief Model and the Theory of Planned Behavior) and the risk and protective factors model treat behaviour as the output of inputs.
  • 2.2 Explain where output theories fall short in high-risk contexts, why short funding cycles favour them, and why the evidence record is weaker for violence prevention than for HIV prevention.

1.1 What "High Risk" Means

The ecological approach, which places influences on health at several nested levels from the individual to the community and wider society, gives the first answer to what "high risk" means: people can be at high risk for many different reasons, and those reasons sit at several levels of influence. Some people face hazardous conditions at work or in the places where they live. Others have limited access to health care or to prevention information. Some are involved in particularly risky behaviour, such as unprotected sex with multiple partners, and some are involved in illegal or marginalized activities, such as the commercial sex trade or gangs. For example, youth involved in substance use, tobacco use, and early sexual activity are said to be at high risk for HIV, sexually transmitted infections, delinquency, and violence, and people who inject drugs and their partners are said to be at high risk for HIV.

In each of these cases, the risk behaviour tends to be treated as a kind of abnormal behaviour. However, it looks abnormal only when it is viewed solely in the context of health. By this we mean that if health is the only lens we use, any behaviour that threatens health seems irrational or deviant; once we look at the rest of a person's life, the same behaviour often makes sense as a response to the situation the person is in. This qualifier matters because it changes where a program looks for the cause of the risk.

Indeed, for populations whose risk is particularly high, the risk is almost always related to specific circumstances that shape it. The standard examples read as a list of circumstances rather than behaviours: migrant workers who do not speak the majority language and have little access to care; youth from high-crime communities and histories of family dysfunction; rural populations with few jobs, low income, and limited care; youth who drop out of school; people returning from prison; people in high-poverty communities where street income (drug sales, sex for money, theft) is common; and historically excluded communities, including ethnic and religious minorities, sexual minorities, and in some cases Indigenous peoples in rural, reserve, or urban settings.

We can now put the definition together. A high-risk population is a group, rather than an individual, whose risk for one or more health problems is particularly high, or who is difficult to reach with ordinary programs. By this we mean that the label describes a shared situation, not a personal failing: the risk is almost always shaped by circumstances rather than by some defect in the people concerned. This also explains why public health sometimes targets the population rather than individuals. The purpose of doing so is to act on what the members of the group have in common, because the circumstances that produce the risk are shared, and so are the barriers to reaching people with ordinary programs. When you meet a case, then, the first question to ask is not "What is wrong with these people?" but "What circumstances do these people share?"

The populations on this list have been described in more than one vocabulary, and the words chosen are part of the argument of this section.

A note on language

Older public health vocabulary, still found across much of the research literature on high-risk populations, says "injection drug users" and "IDUs", "addicts", and "substance use". This lesson keeps those terms where they name an established literature or a named model, and otherwise uses the people-first language now standard in Canadian public health: people who inject drugs, people involved in the sex trade, substance use. The complaint made in this section, that a risk label becomes a person's primary identity, is the argument for the change. Canadian agencies also tend to say "priority populations" or "key populations".

Because high risk is a matter of circumstance, the first questions for any program are practical ones about how to work with people in those circumstances, and 1.2 sets them out.

1.2 Seven Things That Almost Always Matter

Because of these circumstances, seven issues are almost always important in working with high-risk populations. We will call them working issues. By this we mean that they are not part of any one theory; they are preconditions for any program, whatever theory it uses, and a program that neglects them is unlikely to reach anyone long enough for its theory to matter.

The first three concern the relationship itself. Building and sustaining trust comes first, because marginalized populations have usually had reasons to distrust institutions. Gaining access matters because the people concerned are often hard to reach: they may have no fixed address, or they may avoid clinics. Finding the right way to communicate means fitting the language, tone, channel, and messenger to the population, since a message that makes sense in a health unit may make none on the street.

In addition to these, four issues concern how the program behaves once it is in contact with people. A willingness to learn means accepting that the population knows its own world better than any outsider, so the program team enters as a learner rather than as an expert. Confidentiality matters because information about illegal or stigmatized activity is never neutral; if it reaches the wrong person, it can lead to arrest, violence, or the loss of housing. Honesty has a specific meaning here: the population you are working with knows what you are doing and why. By this we mean that a program does not conceal its purpose, its funder, or what it will do with what it learns, because populations that have been studied or managed without their knowledge have good reason to suspect any program that is vague about its aims. Shared benefits, finally, means that the population at risk has a voice in the desired outcomes of the program, rather than having its goals set entirely by a funder. Trust heads the list for a reason: the next section argues that it is the building block on which every other change rests.

Each card names one issue, explains why it matters with these populations, and ends with what it means in practice.

Building and
sustaining trust

Marginalized populations have usually had reasons to distrust institutions, including health institutions. Trust is built slowly, through people who are known in the community, and it is lost quickly. The next section argues that trust is the building block on which every other change rests. In practice: hire from the community, keep promises, stay after the grant ends.

Gaining
access

Many high-risk populations are, by definition, hard to reach: people without fixed addresses, people whose activities are illegal, people who avoid clinics. Access often depends on outreach, on peers, and on going where people already are rather than expecting them to come to you. In practice: street outreach, drop-in services, peer workers.

Finding the right
way to communicate

Messages that make sense in a health unit may make no sense on the street. Language, tone, channel, and messenger all have to fit the population. In practice: test messages with the people they are meant for; use the channels they already use.

A willingness
to learn

The program team is the outsider. The population knows its own world, its risks, and its reasons far better than any needs assessment can capture. The story of the man in the wheelchair, below, is a lesson in how wrong first impressions can be. In practice: ask before assuming; treat the population as expert.

Confidentiality

When a population’s activities are illegal, stigmatized, or dangerous, information is not neutral. A breach of confidentiality can mean arrest, violence, loss of housing, or loss of children. In practice: clear rules about what is recorded and who can see it, explained up front.

Honesty

The definition is specific: making sure that the population you are working with knows what you are doing and why. Research and programs that conceal their purpose have a long and damaging history, which the later sections return to. In practice: say who funds you, what you will do with what you learn, and what you cannot offer.

Shared
benefits

The population at risk has a voice in the desired outcomes. A program whose goals are set entirely by the funder will pursue outcomes the population may not value, and will be experienced as one more thing done to them. In practice: advisory groups with real authority, peer-led organizations, outcomes the community helped choose. In Vancouver, the Vancouver Area Network of Drug Users, founded in the late 1990s, is an organization of people who use drugs that has shaped local harm reduction services on exactly this principle.

Read together, the cards describe a relationship more than a technique. A program that skips them, for example by setting its outcomes without the population or by waiting at a clinic for people who avoid clinics, will struggle whatever theory it uses. That is why 1.3 asks what the risk behaviour is actually about for the people involved.

1.3 The Behaviour Is Usually About Something Else

Throughout the course, we have argued that much behaviour with implications for health is not motivated by health concerns, or at least not solely by them. This is typically true of high-risk behaviour too. The problem is that public health tends to categorize people by their risk behaviours, without always considering the context or the other aspects of who they are. When this happens, a person's primary identity becomes "a high-risk population". By this we mean that the risk label stops being one fact about the person and becomes the main way the program sees them. If that is all we focus on, we limit our understanding of the risk itself and, as a result, we also limit the appropriate use of theory and the development of effective interventions.

Why would the label limit our understanding? Marginalized and socioeconomically segregated populations often engage in risk behaviour with goals that relate to situations of limit, threat, alienation, and mistrust. Because their goals are shaped by those situations, they also have a different understanding of what is and is not a risk. Consider, as an illustration drawn from ethnographic work of this kind, runaway youth who believe they will not live beyond, say, age 25. Why should people who do not expect a long life worry about an infection that may take ten years to become AIDS, when there are more immediate concerns? In the same way, a fieldworker in such a setting might hear people describe extreme violence, drug use, exploitation, and transience as if they were as ordinary as eating a sandwich. In both cases the health risk is real, but it is not what the person is paying attention to. To be more effective, then, a program may need to step back from the behaviour and understand the world it comes from.

This raises the central question of the section: how well does current theory really explain high-risk behaviour? Consider the person categorized as an IDU. He may also be a car mechanic, and a good one, or a cousin, an uncle, a very good cook. He may be helping to raise a child in a small apartment shared with two other families. Each of these descriptions is true, and each points to different motives, relationships, and resources that a program could work with. Which, then, is the most meaningful way to understand this person? A theory that sees only the injection behaviour has already answered that question, and it may have answered it wrongly.

Worked Example 10.1 applies this argument, together with the seven working issues of 1.2, to a single encounter on the street. As you read, watch for the gap between what a first impression suggests and what the outreach workers knew.

Worked Example 10.1: The Man in the Wheelchair

A researcher walked the streets with community health outreach workers on an HIV risk reduction project for people who injected drugs, people who used crack cocaine, and their partners. The workers, almost all in recovery and from the neighbourhoods where they worked, distributed prevention information and bleach kits. One day both stopped to greet an older man in a wheelchair: apparently homeless, dirty, dressed in torn rags, both legs lost to frostbite, and very drunk. They spoke with him for a while and treated him with kindness and a great deal of respect. Asked who he was, they explained that the three of them had been in prison together. The older man had become a mentor, keeping the two younger men out of trouble and encouraging them to read books from the prison library. He had got them through their sentences, and his condition now changed nothing.

Step 1, the first impression. Seen through a risk lens, the man is a cluster of labels: homeless, disabled, heavily drinking, perhaps a drug user. A program designed from that impression would categorize him by his behaviour and reach for a familiar model, for example trying to raise his perceived susceptibility to the harms of drinking under the Health Belief Model.

Step 2, what the workers knew. The researcher's conclusion was that, without being told, he would have had no idea of the man's character or past, and that any assumptions about him and his risk behaviour would have been ill-informed, narrow, and in no way sufficient to address his situation. The workers knew him as a mentor who had kept them out of trouble.

Step 3, which working issues are at work. The relationship rests on trust built over years, and it gives the workers access that no clinic could buy. It also shows a willingness to learn and the right way to communicate: workers from the same neighbourhoods, almost all in recovery, treated the man with respect rather than as a case, and could speak with him at all because of who they were.

Step 4, what a program built on the first impression would get wrong. It would treat drinking and homelessness as the whole person, assume that health is the object of his attention, and miss both his history and the relationships through which change could actually happen.

What this example shows: the risk label hides most of what matters about a person, and the working issues (trust, access, a willingness to learn) are how a program finds out what the label hides. A common mistake is to treat the outreach workers' respect as a pleasant extra rather than as the precondition for any program at all.

The story sets the task for this lesson: to expand thinking beyond health behaviour as such, toward the socioeconomic constraints, social and cultural factors, motivations, and meanings that shape it. With that task in mind, 2.1 sets out the theories most often used with high-risk populations and how they picture behaviour.

2.1 Output Theories: Inputs In, Behaviour Out

Theoretical approaches to violence, HIV risk, substance use, and other risk behaviours typically conceptualize behaviour as the output of a set of factors (inputs) or thinking processes (stages of readiness, cost-benefit decisions). We can call these output theories. By this we mean theories in which something goes in, whether a set of exposures or a set of beliefs and calculations, and a behaviour comes out at the other end. The purpose of naming them as a group is to see what they share, because what they share is also what limits them with high-risk populations. There are two families.

The first family is the individual decision models. Under the Health Belief Model, people weigh perceived susceptibility, perceived severity, the costs and benefits of action, a cue to action, and self-efficacy. Under the Theory of Planned Behavior, decisions follow from attitudes toward the behaviour, subjective norms, and perceived control. The constructs differ, but the picture of the person is the same. In both, a relatively narrow, linear process takes place in which the contemplated behaviour and its health consequences are the primary object of attention. In other words, the models assume that the person is thinking about the health behaviour and its health effects when deciding what to do.

The second family is the risk and protective factors model of Hawkins, Catalano, and colleagues (1992), widely used in violence and substance use prevention. In this model, risk factors are exposures and characteristics that predict high-risk behaviour, and youth face multiple, cumulative exposures over the course of their development. Exposure to risk factors raises the likelihood of problem behaviour, while exposure to protective factors lowers it. The model identifies twenty risk factors grouped into individual, peer, family, school, and community domains, and sometimes a society or environment domain; its protective factors are less well specified. In contrast to the decision models, this model does not ask what the person is thinking at all. Instead, it treats behaviour the way an epidemiologist treats disease, as the result of accumulated exposures. The first two list the risk factor domains and the protective factor domains, and the third sets out what the model does well and what it leaves out.

Risk factor domains (twenty identified factors)

  • Individual: biological and psychological dispositions, attitudes, values, knowledge, skills, problem behaviours.
  • Peer: norms, activities, attachment.
  • Family: function, management, bonding, abuse and violence.
  • School: bonding, climate, policy, performance.
  • Community: bonding, norms, resources, poverty level, crime, awareness and mobilization.
  • Sometimes society or environment: norms, policy and sanctions.

Protective factor domains (less well specified)

  • Individual: gender, intelligence, temperament.
  • Social bonding: attachment and commitment to positive, prosocial individuals and groups.
  • Healthy beliefs: low value attached to drug use; high value attached to school success.
  • Clear standards for behaviour: in families, schools, and communities.

What the model does well, and what it leaves out

This is, in effect, an epidemiological exposure model. By this we mean that it treats each risk factor much as an epidemiologist treats exposure to a pathogen: the more exposures a young person has, the more likely the outcome. The strength of this approach is practical. It suits programs that target specific factors, such as school bonding or family management, because a change in each factor can be tracked and measured relatively easily, and funders can see whether the target moved. What the model addresses less well is the interrelationship of the factors and what that interrelationship says about context. In other words, the model can tell us that poverty, failing grades, and friends who use drugs are present together, but not how they connect: where are the linkages between socioeconomic forces, motivation, meaning, and individual intent? This matters because multiple risk factors in one person mean more than their sum. The clustering of factors has been read as a sign of an oppositional or nonconventional worldview, and many of the twenty factors are common to delinquency, substance use, and violence, which suggests that something shared lies beneath them. However, getting at that worldview has not been a focus of intervention research, because it is much harder to translate into a program or an evaluation design than a single, countable factor.

The discussion of what the model does well names the trade-off that runs through this section: the exposure model is easy to program and measure, but it is silent on how the factors connect to meaning and intent. Figure 10.1 draws the process implied by both families of output theory, the exposure model in the upper panel and the decision models in the lower. Both end in the same box.

Risk factor models Exposure to risk factors Exposure to protective factors + / − Output of behaviour Decision models specific to risk behaviour • Cost-benefit analysis • Calculation of outcome values • Other processes Output of behaviour Inputs in, behaviour out. Where is the meaning?

Figure 10.1. Output theories of risk behaviour: in risk factor models, exposure to risk factors and to protective factors (+ / −) produces an output of behaviour, and in decision models specific to risk behaviour, cost-benefit analysis, calculation of outcome values, and other processes do the same (inputs in, behaviour out).

Interactive 10.1 is a schematic version of the upper panel of Figure 10.1. Build a profile for a hypothetical fifteen-year-old, Jordan, in a mid-sized Canadian city by clicking any of its seven risk factors and five protective factors, which are drawn from the domains described in 2.1, and read both the needle and the note that appears beneath it.

📊 Interactive 10.1: Try the exposure model.

Click factors to add them to Jordan's profile. The needle shows what an exposure model would output.

Risk factors (exposure raises likelihood)

Protective factors (exposure lowers likelihood)

Lower likelihood of problem behaviourHigher likelihood
No factors selected. The model has nothing to compute.

Whatever profile you build, the model returns a count of exposures to target and to measure, and nothing about what Jordan's circumstances mean to him or what his behaviour is for. That silence is the starting point for 2.2.

2.2 Where Output Theories Fall Short

Output theories have real strengths: they are measurable, fundable, and sometimes effective. It would be a mistake, then, to read this subsection as a rejection of them. However, three limits matter when these theories are used with high-risk populations. The first is the assumption that health is the object of attention; the second is a bias in what gets funded and studied; and the third is an uneven evidence record. Each is taken in turn below.

2.2.1 When Health Is Not the Object of Attention

Here is the rub for the decision models. As 2.1 showed, they assume that the behaviour and its health consequences are what the person is attending to. What if a health-related behaviour is not the object of the person's attention at all, but one of many actions related to motives and needs that have nothing to do with health? For example, consider gender roles. The large age difference in arranged and other traditional marriages in India, parts of Africa, and elsewhere raises HIV risk in two ways: through the power difference between partners, and through the likelihood that the older man has, and will continue to have, multiple partners. To the people involved, however, the marriage and what follows from it are about gender roles, not health. A linear decision model about health therefore has little to work with, because the weighing of health costs and benefits that it expects is not the process that is actually producing the behaviour.

The exposure model has a parallel limit, even though it does not rely on the person's thinking. Multiple risk factors in one person mean more than their sum. By this we mean that risk factors and problem behaviours tend to cluster in the same young people, and that this clustering has been read as a sign of an oppositional or nonconventional worldview; in line with this, many of the twenty factors are common to delinquency, substance use, and violence. The model can count the factors, but it does not describe the worldview that may connect them. Getting at that worldview has not been a focus of intervention research, because it is much harder to translate into a program or an evaluation design. The decision models and the exposure model thus fall short in the same place: neither tells us what the behaviour means to the person.

2.2.2 Why Programs Stay at the Inner Levels

The second limit concerns what gets funded and studied. The ecological model acknowledges broader influences on behaviour, yet most actual interventions have difficulty addressing factors at the outer levels (community, society) and the interaction of factors across levels. There are two reasons. The first is that measuring success at those levels is hard. A program can count how many young people completed a skills session, but it is far more difficult to show that a neighbourhood's norms or its economic conditions have changed, or that the program caused the change. The second reason is time: the change needed at those levels usually takes longer than the three to five years allotted to most funded programs. As a result, the need for quick, measurable results has favoured theories that meet the shorter-term need, such as the decision models and the risk factor model, whose targets can be measured within a grant. Because these are the programs that get funded, they are also the programs that get evaluated and published, and this has created a bias in the research literature. By this we mean that the literature contains more evidence about inner-level programs not necessarily because they work better, but because they are easier to fund and to study. The practical consequence for you as a reader of that literature is this: when a theory is called "well supported", the support may say as much about what is easy to fund and measure as about what explains behaviour.

2.2.3 The Evidence: Violence Versus HIV

The third limit is the evidence record itself, and one problem is built into the design of the evaluations. If a program targets specific risk factors, its evaluation measures change in those factors, and a substantial literature shows effects of this kind. Whether the behaviour itself changed, however, is a separate question. The factors a program targets are precursors, by which we mean conditions that are expected to come before the behaviour and make it more likely, and a change in a precursor is only a step toward a change in the behaviour. A program might raise school bonding, for instance, without reducing violence, because the link between the two is a prediction that the program assumes rather than a result that it has shown. For youth violence in particular there is less evidence of direct links between risk factor reduction and less violence. The 2001 U.S. Surgeon General's report concluded that little was known about the effectiveness of the hundreds of violence prevention programs in use and that many were ineffective; a 2004 National Institutes of Health consensus conference agreed, while noting that some programs had reduced precursors and some had reduced violence and arrests in the short term. For HIV the record is better, and Table 10.1 shows why.

Table 10.1. Youth violence and HIV/AIDS prevention compared: what each program tries to change, how the behaviour relates to the health problem, and the evidence record.

Youth violenceHIV/AIDS
What the program tries to changeViolence itself, a broad category of behaviourSelected behaviours: sharing injection equipment, condom use, number of partners
Behaviour and health problemThe behaviour is the health problem, so the behaviour is the ultimate targetThe behaviours are routes of transmission; changing them cuts off the route
Evidence recordWeak; many programs found ineffectiveBetter; in some cases easier, because a change in specific factors reduces transmission

Table 10.1 locates the difference between the two records: an HIV program can tie a change in selected behaviours to a route of transmission, while a violence program has to change a broad category of behaviour that is itself the health problem. The conclusion for output theories as a whole follows. They are measurable, fundable, and sometimes effective, especially when a specific behaviour can be tied to a specific route of harm, but they say little about the world a behaviour comes from or what it is for. When you assess a program built on one of them, ask two questions: is the behaviour it targets a route to the health problem or the problem itself, and does the program know what the behaviour means to the people who engage in it?

This section has moved from what makes a population high risk, and what any program needs before it begins, to the output theories and the record of the programs built on them. The key takeaways and knowledge check that follow review this material, and the next section presents two responses to the limits of output theories: harm reduction and the generative approach.

Key Takeaways

  • 1.1 Calling a population high risk means that, as a group, its risk for one or more health problems is particularly high, or it is hard to reach with ordinary programs, and public health sometimes focuses on such populations rather than on individuals for exactly that reason. The risk is almost always tied to circumstances: hazardous work or living conditions, limited access to care, poverty, exclusion, or involvement in illegal or marginalized activity. The behaviour looks abnormal only when it is viewed solely in the context of health. When a case describes a high-risk group, look first for the circumstances behind the risk (migrant work, life after prison, a high-poverty neighbourhood) rather than for a flaw in the people, and describe the population in people-first language.
  • 1.2 Seven working issues almost always matter with high-risk populations: building and sustaining trust, gaining access, finding the right way to communicate, a willingness to learn, confidentiality, honesty about what you are doing and why, and shared benefits, meaning that the population has a voice in the outcomes. They are preconditions, so they come before any theory or service. When a question describes a program that is struggling, check it against the list: a workshop at a health unit for people who avoid institutions has skipped access, and goals set entirely by a planner or funder have skipped shared benefits. Remember that honesty has a specific meaning here: the population knows what you are doing and why.
  • 1.3 Much high-risk behaviour is not motivated by health, or not only by health; it often serves goals tied to limit, threat, alienation, and mistrust, as with the runaway youth who did not expect to live past about twenty-five. When a risk label becomes a person's primary identity, understanding of the risk narrows, and so do the appropriate use of theory and the design of effective interventions. Worked Example 10.1, the man in the wheelchair, shows how little a first impression reveals. In an answer, say what the label hides (the person's roles, relationships, and circumstances) and what a program loses by ignoring it.
  • 2.1 Output theories treat behaviour as the output of inputs. The decision models, the Health Belief Model and the Theory of Planned Behavior, picture a narrow, linear process in which the person weighs the behaviour and its health consequences, while the risk and protective factors model of Hawkins and Catalano is an epidemiological exposure model in which exposure to risk factors raises, and exposure to protective factors lowers, the likelihood of problem behaviour. Their shared strength is that the inputs can be targeted and measured. To tell the families apart in a case, ask whether the theory describes a decision (beliefs, attitudes, norms, perceived control) or a balance of exposures across domains such as peer, family, school, and community.
  • 2.2 Output theories fall short when the health behaviour is not the object of the person's attention, as when HIV risk in marriages with a large age difference is about gender roles rather than health, and they say little about how factors at different levels link together or what a behaviour means. Short funding cycles of three to five years have favoured them, which biases the literature toward what is easy to measure. Their evidence record is weak for youth violence, where the behaviour is itself the health problem, and better for HIV, where changing specific behaviours cuts off routes of transmission. A common trap is to read a change in targeted risk factors as proof that the behaviour changed, so always ask whether the outcome itself was measured.
Knowledge Check: this section

1. A provincial agency describes seasonal migrant farm workers, many of whom do not speak English or French and have little access to care, as a high-risk population for heat illness and injury. In this lesson's terms, what best explains why the group is high risk?

This locates the risk in personal choices, the reading the lesson rejects. In 1.1 the risk is almost always shaped by shared circumstances, and the behaviour looks abnormal only when it is viewed solely in the context of health.
Section 1.1 defines a high-risk population as a group whose risk is shaped by circumstances it shares. Hazardous farm work, not speaking the majority language, and little access to care are exactly the circumstances listed for migrant workers.
Illegal or marginalized activity is only one of several circumstances listed in 1.1, and nothing in the case involves it. These workers are high risk because of hazardous work, language, and limited access to care.
Section 1.1 says public health sometimes targets populations rather than individuals, precisely because the circumstances that produce the risk, and the barriers to reaching people, are shared by the group.
Correct answer: the risk is tied to circumstances such as hazardous work, language, and limited access to care. The information needed is the account of high risk in 1.1: for populations whose risk is particularly high, the risk is almost always related to specific circumstances, and migrant workers who do not speak the majority language and have little access to care are a standard example. The first option is tempting because it sounds like ordinary risk behaviour, but it locates the problem in the people rather than in their circumstances, and the behaviour looks abnormal only when it is viewed solely in the context of health. (Section 1, 1.1 What "High Risk" Means; Objective 1.1)

2. A regional health authority in northern British Columbia plans a six-session Health Belief Model workshop, held at the health unit, for young people who have recently aged out of the child welfare system and whose rates of hepatitis C are rising. The planner chose the outcomes alone. Which two working issues has the proposal most clearly skipped?

Perceived susceptibility and severity are Health Belief Model constructs, not working issues. The seven working issues in 1.2 are preconditions for any program, whatever theory it uses.
Clear standards for behaviour and social bonding are protective factors from the Hawkins and Catalano exposure model, not working issues. The case describes a program that skipped preconditions, not missing protective factors.
Confidentiality and honesty are working issues, but nothing in the case mentions recording or hiding the program's purpose. The details point to the venue and to who chose the outcomes.
A workshop at a health unit for young people who avoid institutions skips gaining access, which means going where people already are. A planner choosing outcomes alone skips shared benefits, the population's voice in the desired outcomes (1.2).
Correct answer: gaining access and shared benefits. The information needed is the list of seven working issues in 1.2 and what each means in practice. Many high-risk populations are hard to reach, so access depends on going where people already are, and shared benefits means that the population at risk has a voice in the desired outcomes, which a planner choosing outcomes alone has not given. Perceived susceptibility and severity are tempting because the workshop is built on the Health Belief Model, but they are constructs of that model, not working issues, and clear standards and social bonding are protective factors from the exposure model. (Section 1, 1.2 Seven Things That Almost Always Matter; Objective 1.2)

3. A community program describes the people it serves as "IDUs" in every document, and its needs assessment records only injection practices. What is the main cost of this way of working?

Section 1.3 argues that when a risk label becomes a person's primary identity, understanding of the risk narrows, and so do the appropriate use of theory and the design of effective interventions. Calling people only IDUs and recording only injection does exactly that.
Confidentiality is one of the seven working issues, but the case describes no disclosure of information. The problem is what the label does to the program's understanding of the people it serves.
Nothing in a risk label points to one decision model over another. The complaint in 1.3 applies whatever theory is used, because the label limits understanding before any theory is chosen.
A program that records injection practices can still measure risk factors. The cost the lesson names is not lost measurement but a narrowed understanding of the people and their risk (1.3).
Correct answer: it makes the risk label the population's primary identity. The information needed is the central argument of 1.3: public health categorizes people by their risk behaviours, and if that is all we focus on we limit our understanding of the risk and, as a result, the appropriate use of theory and the development of effective interventions. Confidentiality is tempting because it is one of the seven working issues, but the problem described is what the label does to understanding, not a breach of information; the label is also compatible with measuring risk factors and with either decision model. (Section 1, 1.3 The Behaviour Is Usually About Something Else; Objective 1.3)

4. Which statement best describes what the risk and protective factors model does well and what it leaves out?

This reverses the model. It is easy to measure, and it does not describe the worldview behind clustering; that reading of clustered risk comes from researchers outside the model (2.1).
The discussion of what the model does well in 2.1 calls it an epidemiological exposure model suited to targeting specific, measurable factors, while leaving out the linkages between socioeconomic forces, motivation, meaning, and intent.
The model is widely used to design programs, such as Communities That Care. What it handles poorly is the interrelationship of factors and how they link across levels and to meaning (2.1, 2.2.2).
The lesson makes no such claim; many of the twenty factors are common to delinquency, substance use, and violence. The model's limit is its silence on meaning, not a narrow source.
Correct answer: it targets and measures specific factors well but does not address how they link to socioeconomic forces, motivation, meaning, and intent. The information needed is the description of the model in 2.1, including what it does well and what it leaves out: it is in effect an epidemiological exposure model, suited to programs that target specific factors whose change can be tracked, while the interrelationship of the factors and what it says about context are left out. The first option is tempting because clustering has been read as a nonconventional worldview, but that reading comes from outside the model, which does not describe the worldview itself. (Section 1, 2.1 Output Theories: Inputs In, Behaviour Out; Objective 2.1)

5. In arranged or traditional marriages with a large age difference, the older husband's multiple partnerships raise HIV risk. Why is this example used in criticizing the Health Belief Model and the Theory of Planned Behavior?

The example is not a recommendation to raise perceived susceptibility. It questions whether a health-centred decision model fits at all, since the behaviour is about gender roles (2.2.1).
The example says nothing about subjective norms favouring condom use. Its point is that the marriage and its partnerships are about gender roles to the people involved, not about health decisions.
In 2.2.1 these marriages show a health-related behaviour that is not the object of attention: to those involved it concerns gender roles. A linear model that expects a weighing of health costs and benefits has little to work with.
The example compares no models' predictive accuracy. The exposure model has a parallel limit in 2.2.1, since it counts factors but does not describe what the behaviour means.
Correct answer: the behaviour is primarily about gender roles rather than health, so a linear health decision model has little to work with. The information needed is the point in 2.2.1 that a health-related behaviour may not be the object of the person's attention at all, but one of many actions related to motives and needs unrelated to health. The perceived susceptibility option is tempting because it names a Health Belief Model construct, but the example questions whether the model's health-centred process fits at all; it does not recommend a target for education. (Section 1, 2.2.1 When Health Is Not the Object of Attention; Objective 2.2)

6. A youth violence prevention program in a Canadian city reports success because participants' bonding to school and self-efficacy scores rose over two years. Which criticism applies most directly?

Section 2.2.3 notes that risk-factor evaluations measure change in the targeted factors, and for youth violence there is less evidence that such change means less violence. Higher bonding and self-efficacy scores do not show that violence fell.
The model includes protective factors, such as social bonding, that programs can strengthen, since exposure to them lowers the likelihood of problem behaviour. The real weakness is that violence itself was not measured.
Two years falls within, not beyond, the three-to-five-year funding cycle in 2.2.2, and nothing prevents comparison. The criticism is that the outcome measured was a factor, not violence.
Nothing in the lesson forbids a program from drawing on constructs from more than one theory. The problem is the evaluation's outcome: targeted factors rose, but violence itself was not shown to fall.
Correct answer: evaluations measure change in the targeted factors, and for violence there is less evidence that such changes reduce violence. The information needed is 2.2.3: when a program targets specific risk factors its evaluation measures change in those factors, but for youth violence there is less evidence of direct links between risk factor reduction and less violence, and the 2001 Surgeon General's report and the 2004 NIH conference found many programs ineffective. The protective factor option is tempting because bonding to school is a protective factor, but the model allows programs to build protective factors as well as reduce risk factors. (Section 1, 2.2.3 The Evidence: Violence Versus HIV; Objective 2.2)

7. Why is the evidence record for HIV prevention better than for youth violence prevention?

The lesson does not attribute the HIV record to longer funding. Table 10.1 explains it by how the targeted behaviours relate to the health problem.
Violence programs have also been evaluated, and many were found ineffective, so harm reduction is not the only evaluated approach. The difference in Table 10.1 lies in how behaviour relates to the health problem.
The lesson does not explain the gap by people's beliefs. Table 10.1 explains it by whether the targeted behaviour is a route of transmission or the health problem itself.
Table 10.1 shows that HIV programs target selected behaviours, such as sharing equipment or condom use, that are routes of transmission, so changing them cuts the route. Violence is itself the health problem, a broad category of behaviour to change.
Correct answer: HIV programs change selected behaviours that are routes of transmission, whereas violence is itself the health problem. The information needed is Table 10.1 in 2.2.3: HIV prevention aims to change sharing of injection equipment, condom use, or number of partners, so a change in those behaviours cuts off a route of transmission, while a violence program must change a broad category of behaviour that is itself the problem. The perceived susceptibility option is tempting because it sounds like a reason people might change, but the lesson explains the difference by how the behaviour relates to the health problem, not by people's beliefs or by how long programs are funded. (Section 1, 2.2.3 The Evidence: Violence Versus HIV; Objective 2.2)

8. Return to the northern British Columbia workshop in question 2, which aims to raise perceived susceptibility and severity so that the young people decide to use sterile equipment and condoms. Using the critique of output theories, what does the workshop assume, and what may it have missed?

Protective factors belong to the exposure model, but the workshop is built on the Health Belief Model. The critique in 2.2.1 concerns its assumption that health is what the young people are attending to.
Stage matching belongs to the Transtheoretical Model, which the workshop does not use. Its flaw is its picture of what the behaviour is about, not the stage it targets.
Decision models assume the behaviour and its health consequences are the object of attention (2.1, 2.2.1). Like the runaway youth in 1.3, young people facing shelter, income, and belonging may give a slow infection little weight.
The lesson argues the opposite: in high-risk contexts the health behaviour may not be the object of attention, so raising perceived severity has little to work with. Nothing in 2.2 says it reliably changes behaviour.
Correct answer: it assumes the behaviour and its health consequences are the primary object of their attention. The information needed is the critique of decision models in 2.2.1 together with the runaway youth in 1.3: decision models picture a narrow, linear process centred on health, but for people facing immediate threats the behaviour may be about survival, status, or loyalty to friends, just as the runaway youth who did not expect to live past twenty-five had little reason to worry about a slow infection. The stage-matching option is tempting because readiness matters in outreach, but the workshop's flaw is its picture of what the behaviour is about, not the stage it targets. (Section 1, 2.2.1 When Health Is Not the Object of Attention; Objective 2.2)

✦ Pass the knowledge check with 100% to continue

Section 2

Harm Reduction and Generative Approaches

⏱ Estimated reading time: 18 minutes

Section 2 of 4

Harm Reduction and Generative Approaches

Two responses to the limits of output theories.

Harm reduction

Meeting people where they are

Focus on the behaviours that pose the greatest public health threat, without judging or overcategorizing the person as a whole.

Needle exchange

Used equipment out, sterile equipment in.

Risk reduction kits

Information, condoms, bleach and instructions.

Drug substitution

Methadone or buprenorphine under medical supervision.

Theories inside the approach

Outreach workers and the theories behind them

Social Network Theory

Workers are inside the networks where sharing happens.

Social Cognitive Theory

A worker in recovery is a model; similarity is the point.

Transtheoretical Model

Match the ask to readiness. Trust precedes movement toward change.

Canadian examples

A harm reduction continuum

Take-home naloxone (BC, 2012)Overdose prevention and drug checkingInsite, Vancouver (2003)Needle and syringe distribution (late 1980s)Managed alcohol programsOpioid agonist treatmentHousing and income

From keeping people alive now, to making the behaviour safer, to changing the behaviour, to changing the conditions.

Generative approach

The meaning behind behaviour

A schema is generative of behaviour, but not necessarily predictive in the positivistic sense, because individuals assemble their behaviour in varying ways to carry out an organizing theme.Generative, not predictive
Status constructsGender constructsPerformance of a schemaHabitus (Bourdieu)
Cases

Name the need, then supply alternatives

Drug users

Mastery, status, stories to tell.

Runaway youth

Independence; friends as family.

Border youth

Being something; a corrido of your own.

Oldest daughter

Family obligation; supply the income and the behaviour follows.

Carry forward

What to take into the next section

  • Harm reduction: the most dangerous behaviour first, no judgment of the whole person, trust before change.
  • Generative approach: name the schema and the need; supply alternatives, including real resources.
  • Familiar theories operate inside both: networks, modelling, readiness, social marketing, diffusion.
  • Next: why health disparities exist, and whether current theories are relevant.

Overview

Output theories can change specific behaviours, but they assume the health behaviour is what the person is thinking about, and they say little about how the pieces of a life fit together. Two approaches respond to those limits. Harm reduction changes what a program asks for first; the generative approach changes what a program tries to understand. This section takes harm reduction first, with the components of a program, the theories at work in outreach, and the Canadian services that apply it, and then the generative approach, with cases from ethnographic fieldwork and the intervention ideas that follow from them. Together they give you two ways to analyse a case that output theories handle poorly.

Learning Objectives

  • 3.1 Define harm reduction and explain how it meets people where they are without accepting drug use.
  • 3.2 Describe the components of a harm reduction program for people who inject drugs, the theories at work in outreach, and the claim that trust precedes movement toward change.
  • 3.3 Place Canadian harm reduction services on a continuum from keeping people alive to changing the conditions of use, stating what each addresses first and leaves for later.
  • 4.1 Define the generative approach and a generative schema, distinguish generative from predictive accounts of behaviour, and explain how a schema forms under socioeconomic constraint (habitus).
  • 4.2 Derive intervention ideas from a case by naming the schema and the need beneath a behaviour and proposing alternatives that satisfy the same need.

3.1 Harm Reduction: Meeting People Where They Are

The harm reduction approach has proved effective with high-risk populations for HIV and substance use. It has stirred controversy, but experience and data show that it "meets people where they are". By this we mean that it focuses on the key health effects of a person's behaviour while not judging or overcategorizing the person as a whole. The reasoning behind the approach is practical. People at high risk usually have multiple problems that they cannot change all at once. Rather than demanding change on every front, harm reduction programs therefore focus on the specific behaviours that pose the greatest public health threat, while not immediately addressing other behaviours that are also risky or unhealthy. The purpose of doing so is to make the most important change possible now, instead of waiting for a complete change that may never come.

Although the approach is best known from injection drug use, it applies well beyond it. For example, alcohol policy can accept that drinking will occur and target the most dangerous related behaviours, such as drinking and driving. In the same way, programs for people in the sex trade can teach skills for safer sex and personal safety before any attempt to end involvement, because stopping may be difficult and even dangerous as a short-term goal. In this case, ending involvement remains a goal, but it is understood as a longer-term process. In each application the pattern is the same: name the most dangerous behaviour, act on it first, and keep the larger goal for later. The approach is nonetheless easy to misread, and the most common misreading is worth stating directly.

Common confusion: harm reduction is not giving up on treatment

Harm reduction is sometimes described as "accepting drug use" or "giving up on treatment". The logic of the approach is the opposite: it is a sequence, with the most pressing threat first and the harder conversations later, on the trust that the first step creates. Reducing or ending the risky activity remains a goal. Insite in Vancouver, described in 3.3, builds that sequence into one building, with a stabilization and recovery service, Onsite, next door. Nor is harm reduction a theory; the theories at work inside it are set out in 3.2.

The best-developed application of the approach is the program for people who inject drugs, which 3.2 takes apart component by component.

3.2 A Harm Reduction Program for People Who Inject Drugs

The standard application is injection drug use and HIV. Injecting drugs is extremely damaging to the person. From a public health point of view, however, a serious consequence is HIV transmission through shared equipment, which is a leading cause of infection. A harm reduction program therefore makes the practices that transmit HIV its primary focus, in recognition that some people just cannot quit in the near future. It must be stressed that this does not mean ignoring or accepting drug use, a criticism often made of the approach. Instead, it sets an order of priorities: the first priority is to cut off transmission, and addressing drug use often becomes much easier once a nonjudgmental relationship exists. Three components might be part of such a program, and each acts on transmission in a different way:

  • Needle exchange programs: used syringes and equipment exchanged for sterile ones. In the United States, a long-standing federal funding ban meant that federally funded programs could not support this.
  • Risk reduction kits: prevention information, condoms, and bleach for disinfecting needles, with instructions.
  • Drug substitution treatment: medically supervised methadone or buprenorphine, which reduce craving without most of the negative consequences.

The components matter, but so do the people who deliver them. Such programs typically employ people in recovery as community health outreach workers, because they can relate to people who inject drugs in a knowledgeable and nonjudgmental way. It is worth noticing that harm reduction is not itself a theory. Rather, it is an approach, and the role of the outreach worker draws on three established theories of health behaviour. Open each of the three tabs below. They take Social Network Theory, Social Cognitive Theory, and the Transtheoretical Model in turn, and each shows what the theory explains about the outreach worker's role.

Outreach through networks

Outreach workers come from the communities they serve and already sit inside the networks through which drugs, equipment, and norms travel. Kits and messages move along those ties with more credibility than anything mailed from a health unit, and they reach the people who share equipment with one another, which is where transmission happens.

The worker as model

The outreach workers, as people who have used drugs and stopped, are models in the Social Cognitive Theory sense. They show that change is possible for someone from this world, demonstrate how to clean equipment or refuse a shared needle, and raise self-efficacy in a way no health professional could. Observational learning depends on similarity between model and observer, and here similarity is the point.

Matching the ask to readiness

People are addressed according to their readiness to modify specific HIV risk behaviours, or even their drug use; someone in precontemplation about quitting may be ready to stop sharing equipment tomorrow. There is a twist: because harm reduction does not immediately judge or challenge everything about a person's existence, it establishes trust and rapport, and that bond becomes the building block for interaction about other risk behaviour. In the model's terms, trust precedes movement toward change.

The third tab holds the idea that ties the approach together. Because harm reduction does not immediately judge or challenge everything about a person's existence, it establishes trust and rapport, and that bond becomes the building block for conversations about other risk behaviour, including drug use itself. In the terms of the Transtheoretical Model, trust precedes movement toward change.

Worked Example 10.2 applies the approach to a Canadian case. As you read, notice how each step answers one of two questions: what is the most pressing threat, and what is deliberately left for later?

Worked Example 10.2: Designing a Response to Shared Injection Equipment

A public health unit in a mid-sized Canadian city sees a rise in new hepatitis C and HIV diagnoses among people who inject drugs. Most of those diagnosed have no fixed address, several say they share equipment when supplies run out, and few have been in contact with any health service. A council member asks whether the unit should simply focus on getting people into treatment.

Step 1, name the most pressing threat. The serious public health consequence here is transmission of HIV and hepatitis C through shared injection equipment. Stopping drug use is a real goal, but some people cannot quit in the near future, so the sharing practices, not drug use as a whole, become the first focus.

Step 2, choose components that act on that threat. Needle and syringe distribution replaces used equipment with sterile equipment; risk reduction kits add prevention information, condoms, and bleach with instructions; and drug substitution treatment, called opioid agonist treatment in current Canadian practice, is offered to people who want it, to reduce craving.

Step 3, decide who delivers it, and why. The unit hires community health outreach workers in recovery from the same neighbourhoods. They sit inside the networks where sharing happens (Social Network Theory), they are credible models of change (Social Cognitive Theory), and they can match what they ask of each person to that person's readiness (Transtheoretical Model). Going to people, rather than waiting at the unit, also answers the working issue of access from Section 1.

Step 4, say what is left for later, and answer the council member. The program deliberately does not require anyone to stop using before receiving equipment. That is not acceptance of drug use: the first priority is cutting transmission, and the nonjudgmental relationship the workers build makes it much easier to talk about treatment afterward. Treatment enters the sequence when a person is ready, often on the trust that the earlier services created.

What this example shows: a harm reduction analysis is a sequence of decisions (threat first, then components, then messengers, then what waits). The common mistake it avoids is making abstinence a condition of help, which would lose the people at greatest risk before the most pressing threat had been addressed.

The same two questions, what comes first and what waits, can be asked of any harm reduction service, and 3.3 uses them to arrange the Canadian services along a single line.

3.3 Harm Reduction in Canada: A Continuum

Canada has one of the longest harm reduction records anywhere. Vancouver opened a needle exchange in the late 1980s. Insite, the first legally sanctioned supervised injection site in North America, opened in the Downtown Eastside in 2003 under an exemption from the Controlled Drugs and Substances Act, and in 2011 the Supreme Court of Canada ordered it kept open (Insite). British Columbia launched take-home naloxone in 2012 and declared a public health emergency over overdose deaths in 2016.

These services can look like an unrelated collection, but they share a logic. Every service answers the same two questions: what is the most pressing threat, and what is left for later? The answers arrange the services on a continuum, by which we mean a single line along which each service can be placed according to the threat it addresses first. The line runs from keeping people alive, through making the behaviour safer and changing the behaviour, to changing the conditions of use.

At the first point on the line are take-home naloxone and drug checking, which keep people alive in the next few minutes. Next come supervised consumption at Insite, needle and syringe distribution, and managed alcohol programs, which do not ask anyone to stop but make the behaviour safer. Further along are opioid agonist treatment, and safer sex and safety skills with people in the sex trade, which begin to change the behaviour itself. At the far end are housing and income, such as the Housing First approach tested in the At Home/Chez Soi trial, which change the conditions of use. Moving along the line, then, the threat addressed first shifts from immediate death toward the circumstances that produce the risk. Interactive 10.2 sets out all eight. Click each numbered stop, or step through with the buttons, and for each service read the threat it addresses first, what it deliberately leaves for later, and the theory at work.

📊 Interactive 10.2: The harm reduction continuum.

Click a numbered stop or step through with the buttons. Every stop is a Canadian service.
Keep people alive
Make it safer
Change the behaviour
Change the conditions

Select a stop to begin

From services that prevent death in the next few minutes to those that change the conditions of use. All are harm reduction; they differ in which threat comes first.

The continuum shows that every service on it is harm reduction and that the services differ only in which threat comes first. When a case asks you to place a service, ask what would happen without it: if the answer is death in the next few minutes, it belongs at the left end, and if the answer is that little would change until the person's housing or income changed, it belongs at the right.

This part of the section has shown that harm reduction targets the behaviours that pose the greatest public health threat, builds trust through outreach workers from the community, and leaves other risky behaviours for later. The second response, the generative approach, changes what a program tries to understand: the meaning that a behaviour has for the people who engage in it.

4.1 The Generative Approach: The Meaning Behind Behaviour

The second approach grew out of ethnographic fieldwork with high-risk populations. In a generative approach, the focus shifts away from behaviour as inputs and outputs. Instead, it turns to the organizing and motivating processes through which individuals generate behaviour over time. By this we mean the ideas a person carries about how life works and who they are trying to be, which they draw on, again and again, when deciding what to do. Anthropology, social psychology, and sociology call these processes by several names: cultural models, narratives, scripts, discourses, frames, or schema. However, these ideas remain largely untapped in public health, with exceptions in HIV and substance use research and in the work of Oyserman and Markus (1990) on possible selves. Figure 10.2 shows how this differs from the output picture of Figure 10.1: a generative scheme, shaped by social and cultural influence and carried out through practical knowledge, produces a range of behaviours, some risky and some not.

The generative process Social and cultural influence Generative scheme gender, status, life path, obligation shaped by what is understood to be possible Practical knowledge: the life material at hand Behaviour A (risky) Behaviour B Behaviour C One scheme, many behaviours: the scheme generates, it does not predict which one.

Figure 10.2. The generative process: social and cultural influence shapes a generative scheme (gender, status, life path, obligation), and the scheme, working through practical knowledge, the life material at hand, generates behaviours A (risky), B, and C without predicting which one.

Generative approaches start from an assumption about people: a very important human process is to make meaning out of what we do. By this we mean that people do not simply react to inputs; they try to act in ways that make sense to them and to the people around them. We are geared toward behaving in ways that feel coherent and purposeful within a way of life, and that way of life is itself shaped by structural, social, and economic constraints, such as the work available, the money a family has, and the dangers of a neighbourhood. A way of life carries expectations about almost everything, from the life paths that seem possible to what it means to go on a date. For example, a young person may carry a clear sense of who pays, who makes the first move, and what each partner is supposed to want, without ever having been taught these rules in so many words. These expectations take shape as internalized models of how things are supposed to be, and the models guide our actions, reactions, and emotions. These models are what we call generative schema. They are called generative because they produce, or generate, behaviour: a person draws on them, often without noticing, each time they decide how to act.

Two kinds of schema appear repeatedly in this lesson. For example, status constructs define what makes for high status and what that status signifies. Gender constructs work in a similar way: "being a man" or "being a woman" is a bundle of meaning that cultural practice ties to particular behaviours, which are then said to represent being a man or a woman. In both cases the schema is not a behaviour; it is an idea about who one is supposed to be, and many different behaviours can express it.

Two features follow from this definition. The first is performance. We may engage in many behaviours, all related to pursuing and defending a gender role, and we can call this the performance of the schema. The second feature is harder to grasp: a schema is generative of behaviour but not necessarily predictive in the positivistic sense. By this we mean that knowing a person's schema tells you what the person is trying to achieve, but it does not tell you exactly which behaviour they will choose. The reason is that individuals assemble their behaviour in varying ways to carry out an organizing theme. Models are internalized, interpreted, and used, and a person pulls from whatever life material is available to perform them. For example, the pursuit of status can take one form today and another tomorrow, depending on what is at hand. This is the point of Figure 10.2: one scheme, many possible behaviours.

In addition to performance and generativity, the approach explains where schema come from. Schema develop within socioeconomic constraints. By this we mean that the ideas people hold about how life works are learned from the lives they and those around them have actually lived. For example, a group that expects short, precarious lives develops values that support short-term gain and survival strategies, some of them risky. The illustration in 1.3 of runaway youth who do not expect to live past 25 makes the point: if the future seems short, it is sensible to value what can be had now, and a risk that matters only in ten years carries little weight. Pierre Bourdieu called this integration of constraints, life patterns, and values a habitus. In other words, a habitus is the way that a person's circumstances become part of how the person sees the world and what feels natural to do. The idea of habitus connects the generative approach back to Section 1, because it shows how circumstances shape not only what people can do but also what they come to value.

The contrast with Section 1 is worth holding on to, because the two ideas are easy to confuse. A risk factor is an exposure whose presence raises the likelihood of a behaviour; the person's own purposes play no part in it. A schema, in contrast, is a meaning that a person works to carry out, in whatever form the circumstances allow. Defined this way, a schema is something a program can work with rather than against, and 4.2 shows how.

4.2 From Schema to Intervention: Name the Need, Supply Alternatives

4.2.1 Three Cases from the Field

The cases below come from ethnographic fieldwork, and each ends with the same move: name the need that the schema expresses, then ask what else could satisfy it. The purpose of this move is to keep the motivation while changing the behaviour through which it is expressed. The cases below describe fieldwork with people who inject drugs in Washington, DC, with runaway youth, and with youth on the border in Ciudad Juarez, and each names the schema at work before stating the idea for intervention.

Injection drug users in Washington, DC: mastery and stories to tell

Two older men on a corner reminisce about "the life", one baiting the other: I used to take this much and still be able to do that. The possible schema is a drive toward mastery: drug use as the vehicle for fending off the drug's challenge, as if it were a rival, without losing a step as a man. The life was an arena for playing out one's story, perhaps the most accessible one available, and it gave people stories to tell and so a way to negotiate status. When someone overdosed, others would rush to get what he had been using; the one who overdosed might be called incompetent.

The need: mastery, status, stories to tell, none of them necessarily risky. In other words, what these men valued was being seen as capable and having a life worth talking about, and drug use happened to be the arena in which they pursued it. The idea: other choices of behaviour that satisfy the same motivation. This matters for treatment as well as prevention. If the schema stays attached solely to drug use, what would motivate treatment? Stopping might leave nothing around which to build an identity, because giving up the drug would also mean giving up the stage on which a man proved himself.

Runaway youth: independence, and friends who are family

In a youth shelter, a fifteen-year-old from a poor part of Washington listed his jobs in the street economy, smiled, and said, "See, I know how to make money without carrying people's bags." The schema: pride in obtaining resources without subordination; he was on top for a change. The idea: other work that produces the same independence and status.

Among mostly European American runaways who relied on peer networks rather than extended family, an eighteen-year-old punk praised friends who would share half their dinner, take the blame if the police came, and never leave her for dead. The schema: the world is against us, my friends are all there is, and no risk is too great to preserve that unit. Because loyalty to friends is the organizing theme, sharing with them, including sharing risks, expresses who she is. The idea: channel HIV prevention through the informal punk houses that had become centres of activity, with messages about protecting friends. In this way the program works with the schema rather than against it: protecting yourself becomes a way of staying there for the friends who depend on you.

Border youth in Ciudad Juarez: the narcotrafficker and being something

Youth in a Ciudad Juarez youth prison showed a remarkable cynicism about ordinary roles that carry esteem, and a desire to be the kind of narcotrafficker who has corridos written about him. Corridos are a traditional Mexican hero-song form turned pop genre; narcocorridos celebrate traffickers and an attitude of braving any risk. In the high-poverty colonias of the border, having a corrido means "you are something", and dying or using violence to earn one may matter less than the recognition. The schema tied to violence was about being something, to offset the facelessness of concentrated poverty.

The idea: it has to be admitted that in serious poverty alternative paths to recognition are hard to find, which is why the applications listed below include mobilization for real resources alongside new messages.

Across the three cases the schema differ (mastery and stories to tell; independence and loyalty to friends; being something in the facelessness of concentrated poverty), but none of the needs is unusual or risky in itself. The risk comes from the narrow range of behaviours through which the need can be met, and that range is what an intervention can widen.

4.2.2 Putting a Generative Approach to Work

The applications of a generative approach follow from that move, and they come in a natural order. The first two are kinds of research. A program first needs research to identify the generative schema and the socioeconomic setting that shapes them, and then research on other identities, roles, and behaviours that could satisfy the same schema. Once alternatives are known, the next application is to add less risky behaviours and possible selves to a person's "inventory of behaviors". By this we mean widening the range of behaviours a person can draw on, for example through social cognitive modelling and positive youth development. However, alternatives are only realistic if the resources for them exist, so community mobilization and advocacy are needed to generate those resources. Finally, social marketing and diffusion can spread the alternatives through a population.

Worked Example 10.3 applies these ideas to a young woman in the Bangkok sex trade, and Worked Example 10.4 to a schematic land-based program for young men in a small northern community. In each, look for the schema, the need beneath it, and the alternative that satisfies the same need, and notice where harm reduction still belongs alongside it.

Worked Example 10.3: The Oldest Daughter

A young woman in the Bangkok sex trade is the oldest daughter of an impoverished family from rural northern Thailand, and came to the city to support them.

Step 1, name the schema. As the oldest child she bears the most responsibility for family support, and she will meet that obligation even at the cost of sacrificing herself. The schema is family obligation; sex work is the way she currently performs it.

Step 2, name the need beneath it. The need is enough income to support her family. Nothing about that need is risky in itself.

Step 3, supply an alternative that satisfies the same need. An HIV program could incorporate the schema and direct its motivational force toward nonrisky behaviour, through microcredit or other income-producing components that let her support her family. Other prevention modalities may not even be necessary, because a simple substitution of behaviour, relative to the schema, takes her out of the risk situation.

Step 4, set it beside harm reduction. Harm reduction for the same young woman (condoms, skills for safer sex and personal safety) acts first and protects her now, while the generative component acts on the cause of her involvement and takes longer. A real program would probably need both: harm reduction buys time, and the generative work changes what the behaviour is for.

What this example shows: the generative move does not argue against the schema; it gives the schema another outlet. The common mistake it avoids is treating a family obligation as a knowledge deficit that education about HIV could correct.

Worked Example 10.4: A Land-Based Program in the North

A schematic teaching example. A health team in a small northern community is concerned about young men's alcohol-related injuries and violence. Interviews suggest that what the young men value is being seen as capable, tested, and respected by older men, and that drinking contests and fights are among the few arenas for that. Working with Elders and hunters, the community builds a program in which young men learn hunting, wayfinding, and safe travel on ice from experienced men, with roles and recognition that grow over time. Alcohol is one of the program's outcomes, not its subject.

Step 1, name the schema. Being seen as capable, tested, and respected by older men is a status construct of the kind described in 4.1, tied to what it means to be a man in this community.

Step 2, name the need and the current arena. The need is recognition as capable and tested. Drinking contests and fights are among the few arenas for meeting it, so the risk lies in the narrow range of arenas, not in the need.

Step 3, identify the applications used. The program adds less risky behaviours and possible selves to the young men's inventory (hunter, wayfinder, safe traveller on the ice), with experienced men as models in the Social Cognitive Theory sense and in the spirit of positive youth development. Building it with Elders and hunters draws on community mobilization and supplies real resources: mentors, roles, and recognition.

Step 4, place harm reduction alongside it. Because alcohol is an outcome rather than the subject, the program changes drinking slowly. For young men who are drinking now, the harm reduction logic of 3.1 still applies: accept that drinking will occur in the near term and target the most dangerous related behaviours, such as drinking and driving or travelling on the ice while drunk.

What this example shows: a generative program can look as if it has nothing to do with the risk behaviour, because it works on the need rather than the behaviour. When a case describes such a program, name the schema and the alternative arena before judging whether it addresses the risk.

Table 10.2 sets the two responses beside the output theories of Section 1 and compares what each takes behaviour to be, the first move each makes, and the weakness or criticism each faces.

Table 10.2. Output theories, harm reduction, and the generative approach compared: what behaviour is, the first move, and the weakness or criticism of each.

Output theoriesHarm reductionGenerative approach
What behaviour isThe output of inputs or decisionsOne of several risky things a person does, some more dangerous than othersThe performance of a schema that gives a way of life meaning
First moveChange the inputs: beliefs, norms, risk and protective factorsCut the most dangerous behaviour first; leave the rest for laterIdentify the schema and the need behind the behaviour
Weakness or criticismAssumes health is the object of attentionCriticized as accepting drug use (a reading its proponents reject)Easier said than done; needs research and real resources

Read down the generative column and you have the procedure for any case: identify the schema and the need, then supply alternatives, with research and real resources behind them. The table's last row is a fair summary of the approach's weakness: it is easier said than done, especially in serious poverty, where alternative paths to recognition are hard to find, as the Ciudad Juarez case admits.

This section has set out two responses to the limits of output theories, one that changes what a program asks for first and one that changes what it tries to understand. The key takeaways and knowledge check that follow review this material, and the next section turns from high-risk populations to culture, diversity, and health disparities.

Key Takeaways

  • 3.1 Harm reduction meets people where they are: it focuses on the specific behaviours that pose the greatest public health threat, without judging or overcategorizing the person as a whole, and it does not immediately address other risky behaviours. It applies beyond injection, to alcohol policy that targets drinking and driving and to safety skills for people in the sex trade before any attempt to end their involvement. It does not mean accepting drug use; it is a sequence in which the most pressing threat comes first and reducing the risky activity remains a longer-term goal. If a question quotes the claim that harm reduction gives up on treatment, answer with the sequence and with the trust that the first step creates.
  • 3.2 A harm reduction program for people who inject drugs can combine needle exchange, risk reduction kits, and drug substitution treatment, delivered by community health outreach workers who are often in recovery and from the community. Three theories operate in their role: Social Network Theory, because they sit inside the networks where sharing happens; Social Cognitive Theory, because they are credible models; and the Transtheoretical Model, because they match the request to each person's readiness. Because the approach does not challenge everything about a person at once, it builds trust, and trust precedes movement toward change. To tell the theories apart in a case, look at the mechanism: a demonstration or a personal story is modelling, a message passed along existing ties is the network, and a smaller request for someone not ready to quit is stage matching.
  • 3.3 Canadian services form one continuum, and every point on it is harm reduction. Take-home naloxone and drug checking keep people alive now; supervised consumption such as Insite, needle and syringe distribution, and managed alcohol programs make the behaviour safer; opioid agonist treatment and safety skills with people in the sex trade change the behaviour; and housing and income, as in Housing First, change the conditions of use. To place any service, ask two questions: what is the most pressing threat it addresses first, and what does it deliberately leave for later? Worked Example 10.2 shows the same two questions applied to a single program.
  • 4.1 The generative approach works with the organizing and motivating processes through which people generate behaviour over time, rather than with inputs and outputs. A generative schema is an internalized model of how things are supposed to be, such as a status or gender construct, that organizes actions, reactions, and emotions. A schema is performed in many different behaviours, and it is generative but not predictive, because people assemble their behaviour from the life material at hand. Schema form within socioeconomic constraints, so a group that expects short, precarious lives develops values favouring short-term gain and survival, which Bourdieu called habitus. A common trap is to treat a schema like a risk factor whose presence forecasts a behaviour; the point is that it motivates, not that it predicts.
  • 4.2 The intervention move in a generative analysis is always the same: name the schema and the need beneath the behaviour, then supply other behaviours and possible selves that satisfy the same need. In the fieldwork the needs were mastery and stories to tell, independence and loyalty to friends, and being something; for the oldest daughter in Worked Example 10.3 it was family obligation, which microcredit could satisfy without sex work. The applications include research on schema and alternatives, social cognitive modelling and positive youth development, community mobilization for real resources, and social marketing and diffusion. In an answer, avoid arguing against the schema; propose another arena for it, and note that harm reduction may still be needed alongside it while the slower change takes hold.
Knowledge Check: this section

1. A city councillor argues that a needle distribution program "accepts drug use and gives up on treatment". Which response best reflects the logic of harm reduction?

This concedes the councillor's premise that the program gives up on treatment. Section 3.1 rejects that reading: harm reduction is a sequence, and reducing or ending the risky activity remains a goal.
Treatment remains a goal in harm reduction, as a later step in the sequence. The point in 3.1 about stopping being dangerous as a short-term goal refers to leaving the sex trade, not to drug use in general.
The Transtheoretical Model matches what is asked to a person's readiness; it does not forbid discussing drug use. Harm reduction is an approach, not a requirement of any theory (3.1, 3.2).
Section 3.1 describes harm reduction as a sequence: the most pressing threat first, harder conversations later. The nonjudgmental relationship built in the first step often makes addressing drug use easier afterward, so treatment is not abandoned.
Correct answer: harm reduction targets the most threatening behaviour first, and the relationship it builds often makes addressing drug use easier afterward. The information needed is the definition in 3.1 and the common confusion it addresses: focusing on transmission does not mean ignoring or accepting drug use, because the approach is a sequence in which reducing or ending the risky activity remains a longer-term goal. The first option is tempting because it sounds balanced, but it concedes the councillor's premise that the program has given up on treatment, which is exactly the reading the approach rejects. (Section 2, 3.1 Harm Reduction: Meeting People Where They Are; Objective 3.1)

2. An outreach worker who once injected drugs demonstrates how to clean equipment and talks about her own recovery. Which theory does her role most directly draw on in this moment?

Nothing in the case involves raising perceived severity. Demonstrating a skill and telling a story of recovery are modelling, which belongs to Social Cognitive Theory (3.2).
Social Network Theory explains how kits and messages move along existing ties. Demonstrating a skill and telling a recovery story are observational learning from a similar model, which is Social Cognitive Theory.
In 3.2 outreach workers who have used drugs and stopped are models in the Social Cognitive Theory sense. Demonstrating how to clean equipment and showing that change is possible work through observational learning, which depends on similarity.
The worker is not an exposure in the Hawkins and Catalano model. Her role draws on theories of networks, modelling, and readiness, and in this moment modelling is the mechanism.
Correct answer: Social Cognitive Theory, because she is a model for observational learning. The information needed is the second tab in 3.2: outreach workers who have used drugs and stopped are models in the Social Cognitive Theory sense, showing that change is possible for someone from this world and demonstrating skills such as cleaning equipment, and observational learning depends on similarity between model and observer. Social Network Theory is tempting because it also operates in outreach, but it explains how kits and messages travel along existing ties, while a demonstration and a personal story are modelling. (Section 2, 3.2 A Harm Reduction Program for People Who Inject Drugs; Objective 3.2)

3. A managed alcohol program provides regulated doses of alcohol to people with severe alcohol dependence and unstable housing. Which principle does this most clearly apply?

This reverses the sequence. Trust built through services such as managed alcohol precedes movement toward change; the program does not wait for treatment, and abstinence is available but not required.
Interactive 10.2 places managed alcohol at the make-it-safer point: it acts first on non-beverage alcohol, withdrawal seizures, injuries, and emergency department use, and leaves drinking itself for later. That is the harm reduction principle of 3.1.
Alcohol is not a protective factor in the Hawkins and Catalano model, and the program is not balancing exposures. It applies harm reduction by addressing the most dangerous drinking-related harms first.
The mastery schema comes from the fieldwork with older drug users in 4.2.1, not from managed alcohol. This program is harm reduction, focused on the harms that pose the greatest immediate threat.
Correct answer: focus first on the harms that pose the greatest immediate threat while not immediately addressing the drinking itself. The information needed is the definition of harm reduction in 3.1, which applies to alcohol policy as well as to drugs, and the managed alcohol stop of Interactive 10.2 in 3.3, where the threats addressed first are non-beverage alcohol, withdrawal seizures, injuries, and emergency department use, and drinking itself is left for later. The trust option is tempting because trust does precede movement toward change, but it reverses the sequence: the program does not wait for treatment before acting. (Section 2, 3.3 Harm Reduction in Canada: A Continuum; Objective 3.3)

4. Coroners' data in a Canadian province show that many people dying of drug poisoning are employed men in the trades who use alone at home after work and rarely visit harm reduction services. Applying harm reduction, which response addresses the most pressing threat first?

For people who use alone, the most pressing threat is death from an unwitnessed overdose or a supply of unknown strength. Drug checking and take-home naloxone sit at the keep-people-alive end of the continuum in 3.3 and leave the decision to use for later.
Requiring abstinence makes stopping a condition of help, the mistake Worked Example 10.2 says would lose the people at greatest risk. Harm reduction addresses the most pressing threat, here death, first.
Needle distribution targets transmission through shared equipment, but people who use alone are not sharing. Their most pressing threat is an overdose that nobody witnesses.
Delaying services for a campaign leaves the most pressing threat unaddressed and returns to an output theory. Harm reduction acts first on the threat that could kill people in the next few minutes.
Correct answer: keep people alive with drug checking and take-home naloxone, leaving the decision to use for later. The information needed is the continuum in 3.3: the first question is what the most pressing threat is, and for men using alone it is death from an overdose that nobody witnesses or from a supply of unknown strength, which the services at the keep-people-alive end address while leaving drug use itself for later. Needle distribution is tempting because it is the classic harm reduction service, but people who use alone are not sharing equipment, so transmission is not their most pressing threat. (Section 2, 3.3 Harm Reduction in Canada: A Continuum; Objective 3.3)

5. A generative schema is described as "generative of behavior, but not necessarily predictive in the positivistic sense". What does this mean?

The lesson does not say schema operate only in populations. A schema is internalized by individuals, who assemble their own behaviour from it in varying ways (4.1).
This is the exposure logic the generative approach sets aside. A risk factor is an exposure whose presence raises likelihood; a schema is a meaning a person works to carry out (4.1).
Section 4.1 explains that a schema motivates and organizes behaviour, but people pull from the life material at hand to perform it. Knowing the schema tells you what someone is trying to achieve, not which behaviour they will choose.
The lesson does not call schema unconscious or unstudiable; the first application in 4.2.2 is research to identify them. Not predictive refers to the varied forms behaviour takes, not to whether schema can be studied.
Correct answer: a schema motivates and organizes behaviour, but individuals assemble it in varying ways from the life material available. The information needed is 4.1: models are internalized, interpreted, and used, and a person pulls from the life material at hand to perform them, so the pursuit of status takes one form today and another tomorrow. The option comparing a schema with a risk factor is tempting because both are said to shape behaviour, but it is exactly the exposure logic the generative approach sets aside. (Section 2, 4.1 The Generative Approach: The Meaning Behind Behaviour; Objective 4.1)

6. In the case of the oldest daughter from rural Thailand working in the Bangkok sex trade, why might traditional HIV prevention modalities "not even be necessary"?

Worked Example 10.3 makes no claim about condom use in the Thai sex trade. Its point is that the need behind the behaviour can be met another way.
The lesson says the opposite: Step 4 of Worked Example 10.3 keeps harm reduction alongside the generative component, and 3.1 applies safety skills to people in the sex trade.
The example does not use the Theory of Planned Behavior or measure intention. It works through her schema of family obligation and the need for income beneath it.
In Worked Example 10.3 her schema is family obligation and the need is income for her family. Microcredit directs the schema's motivational force to a substitute behaviour, so other prevention may not be needed.
Correct answer: her schema is family obligation, and microcredit or another income-producing component lets her satisfy it through a substitute behaviour. The information needed is Worked Example 10.3: the program incorporates the schema and directs its motivational force toward nonrisky behaviour, so a simple substitution of behaviour, relative to the schema, removes the risk. The condom option is tempting because condoms are the usual HIV tool, but the example makes no claim about condom use; its point is that the need behind the behaviour can be met another way, and Step 4 notes that harm reduction would still be useful alongside it. (Section 2, Worked Example 10.3; Objective 4.2)

7. A generative reading of the men in question 4 proposes that using alone and avoiding services perform a schema of being a capable provider who works through pain and does not ask for help. Which intervention idea follows from this reading?

The generative approach works with a schema's motivational force rather than against it. Telling the men their schema is outdated argues against the need instead of giving it another outlet (4.2).
Following 4.2, this names the need beneath the schema, being a competent, respected provider, and offers a less risky way to meet it. Carrying naloxone and looking after a crew mate become ways to perform the schema.
Measuring exposures in the peer and community domains returns to the risk and protective factors model, an output theory. It ignores the schema the generative reading has just identified.
Raising perceived severity is a Health Belief Model move that assumes health is the object of attention. The generative reading says the behaviour performs a provider schema, which graphic images do not address.
Correct answer: name the need beneath the schema and offer a less risky way to meet it. The information needed is the intervention move in 4.2: name the schema and the need, then supply other behaviours and possible selves that satisfy the same need, as microcredit does for the oldest daughter; here safer practice becomes an expression of being a capable provider rather than a betrayal of it. Arguing against the schema is tempting, but the generative approach works with a schema's motivational force rather than against it, and the risk factor and severity options return to output thinking. (Section 2, 4.2.2 Putting a Generative Approach to Work; Objective 4.2)

8. In the land-based program of Worked Example 10.4, young men learn hunting, wayfinding, and safe travel on ice from experienced men, and alcohol is "one of the program's outcomes, not its subject". Why does the program work this way?

The lesson does not present time outdoors as a protective factor, and treating the program as an exposure misses the schema it is built around. The program works with the need for recognition (Worked Example 10.4).
Harm reduction does not forbid discussing drinking; Step 4 of Worked Example 10.4 applies it to drinking and driving or travel on the ice. Alcohol is an outcome because the program targets the need behind it.
Worked Example 10.4 names the schema as being seen as capable, tested, and respected by older men, currently met through drinking contests and fights. Hunting, wayfinding, and ice travel supply a new arena for the same need.
The program is not built on the Theory of Planned Behavior or on keeping the men busy. It supplies roles and recognition that satisfy the status schema behind the drinking.
Correct answer: it works with the schema behind the drinking and offers another arena in which to meet the need. The information needed is Worked Example 10.4: interviews suggested that the young men value being seen as capable, tested, and respected by older men, and drinking contests and fights were among the few arenas for that, so the program supplies a new arena with roles and recognition that grow over time. The protective factor option is tempting because a mentoring relationship looks like social bonding, but that reading treats the program as a unit of exposure and misses the schema it is built around. (Section 2, Worked Example 10.4; Objective 4.2)

✦ Pass the knowledge check with 100% to continue

Section 3

Culture, Diversity, and Why Disparities Exist

⏱ Estimated reading time: 18 minutes

Section 3 of 4

Culture, Diversity, and Why Disparities Exist

Vulnerability, circumstance, and response, across an ecological range of causes.

Why the focus

Diversity and disparity

43%growth of both the Asian and the Hispanic populations of the United States, 2000 to 2010
2.2xinfant mortality rate of African American babies relative to non-Hispanic white babies, 2010 (about 1.6x for American Indian and Alaska Native babies)
>7xHIV death rate among African Americans relative to white Americans, 2010

Not every disparity is about race or culture: socioeconomic status and geography produce their own.

A policy issue

From the Heckler Report to today

1985: Heckler Report

Six causes: cancer, cardiovascular disease and stroke, chemical dependency, diabetes, homicide and accidents, infant mortality. A thirty-year lag.

2011: Disparities Report

Quality improving for all groups; access and disparities not improving for most minority and low-income groups.

Canada: health inequalities (any difference) versus health inequities (unfair and avoidable).

A trajectory of health

Vulnerability, circumstance, response

Circumstance

Discrimination, exclusion, poverty, environmental risk, and for many, the experience of being studied or treated without consent.

Vulnerability

Exposure to disease, lack of insurance or access, a history of coping outside the mainstream system.

Response

Knowledge, attitudes, and practice that developed in reply: mistrust, reliance on family, avoidance.

Ethnomedical systems

Two coherent systems, one child

Biomedicine

Severe epilepsy; anticonvulsant medication; the family's adherence as the problem.

Hmong ethnomedicine

Qaug dab peg: a wandering soul, a soul calling by a txiv neeb, and a quality of distinction.

Both parties eventually came to some understanding of how the other viewed the situation.

Competence and its critics

CLAS, checklists, and cultural safety

Culturally competent careLanguage access servicesOrganizational supports
Cultural competence should not be viewed as a technical skill or a checklist for clinician behaviour, because individuals within cultures vary and cultures are not static.After Kleinman and Benson (2006)

Cultural safety: does the person receiving care feel safe, and what is the system doing about its own history?

HEAL connection

Disparities on the HEAL map

Structured upstream

Social position, produced by context; power and capital; services and supports that reach some groups.

Compounding over time

Sensitivity (weathering), compounding consequences, and selection running the other way.

Carry forward

What to take into the next section

  • Disparities arise from trajectories: circumstance, vulnerability, response, pattern.
  • Causes span every ecological level, from mistrust to missing data systems.
  • Cultural competence matters, but it is a relationship and a system, and it cannot be reduced to a checklist of traits.
  • Next: what to do, and which theory reaches which level.

Overview

Are current theories relevant to culture, diversity, and health disparities? That question runs through the rest of this lesson. This section covers the first half of it: what health disparities are, why they became a policy issue, and why they exist, with a Canadian counterpart for each idea. It ends with the main response offered so far, cultural competence as the CLAS standards define it, and with the critique of that response, which in Canada has led to the idea of cultural safety. The next section takes up what to do.

Learning Objectives

  • 5.1 Define health disparities, explain how they became a policy focus, and distinguish a health inequality from a health inequity as Canadian reporting does.
  • 5.2 Explain the trajectory of health (circumstance, vulnerability, and response) and why mistrust is a rational part of it.
  • 5.3 Describe the ecological range of factors that contribute to disparities, from ethnomedical systems and differential treatment to socioeconomic status, neighbourhood, and missing data systems.
  • 6.1 Summarize the three themes of the CLAS standards and what each requires.
  • 6.2 Explain the critique of cultural competence as a checklist of traits, and how cultural safety develops that critique in Canada.

5.1 What Health Disparities Are and How They Became a Focus

Health disparities are differences in health status, and in the quality of and access to health care, between populations. By this we mean that a disparity is a comparison between groups: one population is sicker, dies younger, or receives less or poorer care than another. The call for "culturally competent" interventions has usually accompanied the larger issue of disparities among racial and ethnic minority populations. In the United States, eliminating disparities was the second major goal of Healthy People 2010 and one of four major goals of Healthy People 2020, and it remains an overarching goal of Healthy People 2030 as of November 2026. It is important to note, however, that not all disparities involve minority populations: some relate solely to socioeconomic status or geography. Even so, the connection between diverse minority populations and disparities is a primary aspect of the problem, and it is the aspect this section concentrates on.

Two reasons explain why disparities among minority populations became a focus. The first is demographic: the populations concerned are growing. For example, the Asian and Hispanic populations of the United States each grew by 43 percent between 2000 and 2010. The second reason is that minority populations have historically fared worse in health. This is a truism that is not always true, but where the gaps exist they are large. For example, in 2010 the infant mortality rate of African American babies was more than twice that of non-Hispanic white babies, and the rate of American Indian and Alaska Native babies was about 1.6 times as high (Mathews and MacDorman, 2013); in the same year the HIV death rate among African Americans was more than seven times the white rate (Murphy, Xu, and Kochanek, 2013); and Vietnamese American women have had one of the highest cervical cancer incidence rates of any group in the United States.

Disparities became a policy issue with the 1985 Heckler Report, named for Health and Human Services Secretary Margaret Heckler, which identified six causes of the gap: cancer, cardiovascular disease and stroke, chemical dependency, diabetes, homicide and accidents, and infant mortality, and found about a thirty-year lag in health improvement for African Americans. Twenty-five years later, the 2011 National Healthcare Disparities Report found quality improving for all groups but access and disparities not improving for most minority and low-income groups.

These reports describe the United States. Canadian reporting frames the same problem with two terms that are easy to confuse and worth learning precisely.

The Canadian frame: inequalities and inequities

The Public Health Agency of Canada's inequalities reporting (first major report, 2018) documents systematic differences by income, education, Indigenous identity, immigrant status, sexual orientation, and place. Canadian reporting distinguishes a health inequality, any measurable difference, from a health inequity, a difference that is unfair and avoidable. By this we mean that every inequity is an inequality, but not every inequality is an inequity. For example, older adults have more chronic disease than young adults, which is a measurable difference that follows largely from age; a gap in diabetes or infant mortality that follows from poverty, crowded housing, or exclusion from care is an inequity, because it arises from conditions that society could change. The largest inequities involve First Nations, Inuit, and Métis peoples: gaps in life expectancy, a tuberculosis burden among Inuit many times the non-Indigenous rate, and higher diabetes and infant mortality. Newcomers show a second pattern: they arrive healthier than the Canadian-born and lose that advantage over years of residence, the "healthy immigrant effect".

Describing disparities is the easier task. 5.2 asks why minority populations have fared worse, and answers with the idea of a trajectory.

5.2 A Trajectory of Health

Why have minority populations fared worse? The reasons are hard to separate from each population's historical experience. Discrimination, exclusion, lack of access, environmental risk, and poverty have produced patterns of living, by which we mean the everyday routines of work, food, housing, and family that people adopt in order to get by. The health beliefs, attitudes, and behaviour of a population evolved within those patterns rather than apart from them. As a result, they cannot help but reflect that experience. For example, a community that was long excluded from hospitals will have learned to manage illness at home and within the family, and that habit does not disappear simply because the hospital doors are now open. This is why a population's present beliefs about health cannot be understood, or changed, without knowing the history that produced them.

One useful way of thinking about this is the idea of a trajectory of health. Historical circumstances produce a trajectory of health, made up of a population's vulnerability and exposure to disease together with the systems of knowledge, attitude, and practice that developed in response. By this we mean that a population's present health is the end point of a path that history set it on. The path has three parts. Circumstance is what happened to the population; vulnerability is the exposure to disease and the lack of protection that those circumstances created; and response is what people came to believe and do as a way of living with them. Vulnerability, circumstance, and response together produce disparities. The purpose of thinking in this way is to stop treating a population's present beliefs and behaviour as if they had appeared from nowhere.

Mistrust is the clearest example of a response. For example, public knowledge of the Tuskegee study, which from 1932 to 1972 left poor African American men with syphilis untreated in order to observe the disease, still shapes reluctance to be tested for HIV. In Canada, residential schools and segregated "Indian hospitals" produced a comparable trajectory for First Nations peoples. Read this way, mistrust is a rational response to history, not a knowledge deficit. This distinction matters for practice: a knowledge deficit could be fixed with information, but a rational response to history can only be changed by changing the relationship, which brings us back to trust, the first of the working issues in Section 1.

Interactive 10.3 builds such a trajectory one link at a time for two populations, in an American example about HIV testing and a Canadian example about First Nations peoples. Press the button to add each of its five links in turn, from historical circumstance through vulnerability and exposure, response, and the present-day pattern to what a program must do, and compare the two columns as they grow.

📊 Interactive 10.3: How a trajectory forms.

Each step adds one link for two populations. Both are schematic summaries, not full histories.
1. Historical circumstance
2. Vulnerability and exposure
3. Response
4. Present-day pattern
5. What a program must do

An American example: HIV testing

Press the button to add the first link.
Historical circumstanceSlavery, segregation, and exclusion from care; from 1932 to 1972 the Tuskegee study left poor African American men with syphilis untreated to observe the disease (Tuskegee study).
Vulnerability and exposureHigher poverty, less insurance, and a long history of dealing with health problems outside the mainstream system.
ResponseDocumented mistrust of doctors, scientists, and government; in one HIV prevention pilot project, HIV was widely viewed as a conspiracy and people refused blood tests at a public clinic.
Present-day patternReluctance to use HIV testing; lower use of doctors even in poor health; an HIV death rate more than seven times the white rate in 2010.
What a program must doTreat mistrust as a rational response to history; work through trusted institutions; be honest about purpose; offer testing outside settings that carry the history.

A Canadian example: First Nations peoples

Press the button to add the first link.
Historical circumstanceColonization, the Indian Act, residential schools (the last closed in the 1990s), segregated "Indian hospitals" into the 1980s, and nutrition experiments on children in the 1940s.
Vulnerability and exposureLoss of land and livelihoods, crowded housing, unsafe water, and disputes over who pays for care.
ResponseWell-founded mistrust of institutions that separated families; reliance on family, community, and traditional healing; avoidance of hospitals where racism is expected (In Plain Sight, 2020).
Present-day patternGaps in life expectancy, chronic disease, and infant mortality; later presentation and worse experiences of care.
What a program must doCultural safety rather than a list of traits; Indigenous governance of services (the First Nations Health Authority in BC since 2013); honesty about the history; the Truth and Reconciliation Commission's Calls to Action.
Two chains, one shape: circumstance produces vulnerability, vulnerability produces a response, and the response becomes the pattern a program meets. A program that does not know the chain will read mistrust as a knowledge deficit and fail.

The two chains have one shape: circumstance produces vulnerability, vulnerability produces a response, and the response becomes the pattern a program meets. The same shape appears in other populations. Migrant workers from Central America, for example, have often arrived reluctant to trust government agencies after years of civil conflict at home, where contact with the state could be dangerous. When that mistrust is combined with a history of dealing with health problems outside the mainstream system, it is not surprising that African American and Latino men are less likely than Caucasian American men to see a doctor, even in poor health. In each case the reluctance is a learned response to past experience, not a lack of concern about health.

In addition to mistrust, patterns of living shape behaviour. For example, African Americans and Hispanics are less likely to exercise, and it would be easy to read this as a matter of personal choice or motivation. The explanation, however, is historical rather than moral. Exercise as a discrete activity, something done for its own sake and set apart from work, is a recent and largely middle- or upper-class phenomenon. For people whose work has long been physically demanding, or whose time and neighbourhoods leave little room for it, the idea of exercise as a separate leisure activity simply did not develop in the same way.

Mistrust and patterns of living are only the first of the factors behind disparities. 5.3 sets out the full range, level by level.

5.3 The Ecological Range of Contributing Factors

The factors that contribute to disparities span every level of the ecological model, which is why no single program can address all of them. At the individual and cultural levels are the mistrust and patterns of living described in 5.2, together with ethnomedical systems. Within the health system itself is differential treatment. In the wider environment are socioeconomic status, segregation, and neighbourhood. Finally, at the level of systems are the data, leadership, and coordination needed to act at all. This subsection takes them in that order, and the practical lesson is to ask, for any disparity, which of these levels a proposed response actually reaches.

5.3.1 Ethnomedical Systems and Differential Treatment

Health knowledge is also organized by ethnomedical systems. An ethnomedical system is a cultural system of knowledge and practice that defines illnesses, their causes, appropriate treatments, and appropriate providers. By this we mean a complete way of understanding sickness and healing, of which biomedicine is itself one example. Where a population's ethnomedical system differs from biomedicine, and people adhere to it strongly, a gap in understanding and in the use of standard care can result. The important point is that such a gap does not arise because people lack knowledge; it arises because they hold a different, coherent body of knowledge.

Worked Example 10.5 recounts the case of Lia Lee, a Hmong child diagnosed with severe epilepsy, from Anne Fadiman's book, and Worked Example 10.6 is a schematic example of prenatal care for a family resettled after years in a refugee camp. In both, watch for how a coherent system of knowledge, rather than ignorance, produces the gap in care.

Worked Example 10.5: Lia Lee and Two Ways of Understanding Epilepsy

Anne Fadiman's book The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down (1997) tells the story of Lia Lee, a young girl diagnosed with severe epilepsy. The Hmong come mainly from the mountains of Laos; many were resettled in the United States after the Vietnam War because of their support for U.S. efforts there. In the Hmong ethnomedical system, one cause of illness was a soul lost and wandering after a sudden event, returned by a shaman's soul calling. Epilepsy was qaug dab peg, "the spirit catches you and you fall down", and was seen as evidence of a power to perceive what others cannot, a quality of distinction. What followed was a story of tragedy and conflict between two ways of understanding and treating her condition.

Step 1, identify the two systems. Her physicians acted within biomedicine: severe epilepsy, treated with anticonvulsant medication, with the family's adherence seen as the problem. Her parents acted within the Hmong ethnomedical system: a wandering soul, a soul calling by a shaman (txiv neeb), and a mark of distinction. Each is a coherent system that defines the illness, its cause, its treatment, and the right provider.

Step 2, see how the same constructs carry different content. Read through the Health Belief Model, perceived severity differs: to the physicians the seizures were a danger to be controlled, while to the family the condition also carried spiritual distinction. Perceived benefits differ too: the physicians expected benefit from medication, the family from soul calling. And the barriers to following the medical regimen included a system of care that did not share the family's understanding of what was wrong.

Step 3, draw the implication for care. The gap in understanding and in use of standard care was not a lack of information that a leaflet could fix. Closing it required each side to learn how the other understood the situation; in the story both parties eventually came to some understanding of the other, but only after tragedy and conflict.

What this example shows: an ethnomedical system is a reason for a gap in care, not an error to be corrected. A common mistake is to read the family's choices as noncompliance; 6.2 returns to the case to show why a list of "Hmong beliefs" would not have been enough either.

Worked Example 10.6: Prenatal Care after Resettlement

A schematic example. A family resettled after years in a refugee camp is expecting a child. The mother's previous births were attended by relatives and a traditional birth attendant; in the camp, clinics were for weighing and vaccinating children, and pregnant women did not go. In the new city, prenatal appointments require a bus transfer, a phone booking in English, and an unfamiliar male physician. Coverage under the Interim Federal Health Program is real but unexplained, and a neighbour has said the visits cost money. The nurse records "late presentation for prenatal care".

Step 1, sort the factors by level. Ethnomedical system: births attended by relatives and a traditional birth attendant, so a clinic visit during pregnancy is unfamiliar. Perceived barriers rooted in a health trajectory: years in a camp where clinics were for children, the belief that visits cost money, and discomfort with an unfamiliar male physician. System design: a bus transfer, an English-only phone booking, and coverage that nobody has explained.

Step 2, ask what a translated pamphlet would address. A pamphlet in the family's language could explain what prenatal care is and state that visits are covered, which touches the belief about cost. It would not change the birth practices the family knows, build trust, provide a female physician, remove the bus transfer, or change an English-only booking line.

Step 3, read the nurse's note again. "Late presentation for prenatal care" records the result of all three levels as if it were one woman's lateness. A program that responds to the note alone will treat a systems problem as a personal one.

What this example shows: contributing factors sit at several levels at once, and a single response, especially a translated document, usually reaches only one of them. When a case offers one intervention, sort the factors first and then ask which level it touches.

Ethnomedical systems describe the patient's side of the encounter. However, the gap in care can also open on the provider's side. Even when people do have access to care, differential treatment inside the health system has been documented repeatedly. For example, the Institute of Medicine's Unequal Treatment described such disparities, including a lack of culturally and linguistically competent care and provider bias. In other words, two patients with the same condition may receive different care because of who they are, which means that explaining a disparity only by what patients believe or do will always leave part of it out.

5.3.2 Socioeconomic Status, Segregation, and Neighbourhood

Moving outward from the health system, socioeconomic status is itself a key factor. Minority populations are overrepresented in lower socioeconomic groups, so the consequences of low status fall harder on them. These consequences include poor nutrition, smoking, injuries, pollution, unemployment, psychosocial stress, community violence, and limited recreational space. In addition to income, where people live matters. Housing segregation by race and ethnicity, regardless of income, is associated with health risks, and neighbourhood characteristics affect obesity, violence, and substance use. This means that two families with the same income can face different risks because of the neighbourhoods they live in. Several organized efforts have focused on these factors. The first two describe the California Campaign and PolicyLink's three domains of community effects on health, and the third sets out a synthesis that links poverty and marginalization to access-poor groups and vulnerable populations.

The California Campaign: eight sources and twenty community factors

The California Campaign named eight nonmedical sources of disparities: housing, education, labour, economics, technology, criminal justice, transportation, and environmental risk, and twenty community factors under four categories: the built environment, social capital, services and institutions, and social-structural factors, the same four that reappear in THRIVE.

PolicyLink: three domains of community effects on health

  • Social and economic environment: cultural characteristics, norms, networks, community organization, civic engagement, the "reputation of the neighborhood".
  • Physical environment: physical features and spaces, public safety, physical access to opportunities.
  • Services: access to and quality of services, including transit, public safety, community institutions, and commercial services.

A Canadian illustration: a northern community where food arrives by air at several times southern prices and the nearest hospital is a flight away. No individual theory explains the resulting diet; the domains do.

The synthesis: access-poor groups and vulnerable populations

Poverty and social marginalization create groups, defined by socioeconomic status, race and ethnicity, and so on, with poor access to the interrelated systems of health, economic, and social resources. The word interrelated is important here: poor access to jobs tends to bring poor access to housing, insurance, and care as well, so the gaps reinforce one another. This access-poor relationship generates patterns of living focused on survival and social goals within a limited sphere, as opposed to maximizing health. By this we mean that when the next meal, the rent, or one's standing among friends is in doubt, those goals take priority, and long-term health becomes one concern among many rather than the main object of attention. The view appears in the literature on vulnerable populations and in the work of medical anthropologists such as Dressler, and it echoes the runaway youth's view of risk in the first section of this lesson.

The synthesis in the third part is the one to hold on to: poverty and marginalization create vulnerable populations whose patterns of living focus on survival and social goals within a limited sphere rather than on maximizing health, the same survival logic found among the high-risk populations of Section 1.

5.3.3 The Systems That Are Missing

Finally, there are the systems that do not exist. This factor is different from the others, because it concerns not what causes a disparity but whether anyone can see it and act on it. Before disparities can be addressed, they must be identified, and identifying them requires data by population. Often such data are not collected. In addition, many populations are lumped under designations such as "Asian", which obscure large differences; for example, people from Vietnam and from India both fall in that category, although their health may differ greatly. Even once a disparity is identified, the information has to reach someone designated to act, with leadership, a mission, coordination, and resources. Canada has had this problem in acute form: race-based health data were rarely collected until the COVID-19 pandemic. A disparity that is not measured, or that no one is responsible for, will persist however well its causes are understood.

With the causes laid out, the section turns to the main response that has been offered for one of them, a lack of cultural competency in care.

HEAL connection: how a disparity is produced

On the HEAL Framework for Wellbeing introduced in Lesson 1, a disparity begins with social position, which is relational and produced by context rather than a personal trait. Power and capital turn position into material circumstance, and services and supports reach some groups and bypass others. Over time the harm compounds: sensitivity means that the same exposure produces more harm after years of disadvantage (weathering), and compounding consequences means that poor health can push people further down the hierarchy. Selection runs in the opposite direction, which is why causes and consequences must be separated.

The trajectory of health in Section 5.2 can be read as a path through the framework, and the move from cultural competence to cultural safety in Section 6 as a change in how one system meets the people it serves.

6.1 Cultural Competence and the CLAS Standards

Lack of cultural competency in care has been identified as one cause of disparities, as the discussion of differential treatment in 5.3.1 showed. One response in the United States was the national standards for Culturally and Linguistically Appropriate Services, the CLAS standards, first issued by the U.S. Office of Minority Health in 2000 (Office of Minority Health, 2001). The purpose of the standards is to define what cultural competency looks like in practice, so that an organization can tell whether it is providing it. In their original form, which this subsection describes, they do so under three themes. The first is culturally competent care (Standards 1 to 3), which concerns the care itself and the staff who give it. The second is language access services (Standards 4 to 7), which concerns whether patients can communicate with the service at all. The third is organizational supports (Standards 8 to 14), which concerns the planning, data, and partnerships that keep the first two in place. Open each of the three tabs below to read the standards under each theme.

Standards 1 to 3

Patients should receive from all staff effective, understandable, and respectful care compatible with their cultural health beliefs, practices, and preferred language; organizations should recruit and promote a diverse staff and leadership representative of the service area, and train staff at all levels.

Standards 4 to 7

Organizations must offer bilingual staff and interpreters at no cost at all points of contact; must notify patients of that right in their preferred language; must ensure interpreters are competent, and not use family and friends except at the patient's request; and must provide materials and signage in the languages of the service area. These are the only standards written as "must".

Standards 8 to 14

Organizations should have a strategic plan with accountability; conduct self-assessments; collect data on each patient's race, ethnicity, and language; maintain a demographic and epidemiological profile of the community; develop participatory partnerships with communities; make grievance processes culturally sensitive; and report their progress publicly.

In short, the first theme asks for care that is effective, understandable, respectful, and compatible with patients' cultural health beliefs, practices, and preferred language, delivered by a diverse and trained staff. The second requires interpreters and bilingual staff at no cost, competent interpreters rather than family and friends, and materials in the languages of the service area, and its standards are the only ones written as "must". The third asks organizations to plan, assess themselves, collect data, profile the community, partner with it, and report their progress. Notice that most of the standards describe what an organization does, which is where the critique begins. In 2013 the Office of Minority Health replaced the original standards with enhanced ones, which as of October 2026 comprise fifteen standards: a principal standard and three themes, namely governance, leadership, and workforce; communication and language assistance; and engagement, continuous improvement, and accountability (U.S. Office of Minority Health, n.d.).

6.2 The Critique of Cultural Competence and Cultural Safety

Here the critique enters, and it has two parts. The first concerns the CLAS standards specifically: they may focus on organizational behaviour without enough emphasis on the role of culture in health. In other words, an organization could meet every standard on paper and still misunderstand the people it serves. For example, a clinic could hire interpreters, translate its signage, and collect data on each patient's language, and yet still have no idea why a family prefers to treat an illness at home before coming in. The second part concerns cultural competence more generally. Kleinman and Benson (2006) argue that cultural competence should not be viewed as learning a list of traits that supposedly represent a culture. Their reasoning is that individuals within cultures vary and that cultures are not static. A list of traits assumes the opposite, that everyone in a group thinks alike and always will. For this reason, competence should not be a technical skill or a checklist for clinician behaviour. What matters, instead, is how individuals subjectively experience the intersection of culture and health. For example, Lia Lee's family were not "the Hmong"; they were particular people with a particular history, and a list of Hmong beliefs could not have told her physicians how this family understood her illness.

Indigenous health in Canada reached the same conclusion by another route, the concept of cultural safety. Cultural safety moves attention from what a provider knows about a culture to whether the person receiving care feels safe and respected. This is a change in who judges the care: under competence, the provider's knowledge is the measure, while under safety, the patient's experience is. Because the patient's experience is the measure, a provider cannot declare their own care culturally safe. Instead, safety depends on how the provider's assumptions, the power difference between provider and patient, and the history of the health system are felt by the person in the room, which is why cultural safety asks providers to examine themselves and their institutions rather than only to learn about others.

Cultural safety: the Canadian development of the same critique

Indigenous health in Canada has largely moved from cultural competence to cultural safety, a concept developed by Māori nurse educator Irihapeti Ramsden in Aotearoa New Zealand in the 1990s. Where competence asks what the provider knows about a culture, safety asks whether the person receiving care feels safe and respected, and makes the provider's assumptions, the power imbalance, and the history of the system the subject of attention. British Columbia's San'yas Indigenous Cultural Safety training has run for more than a decade, and the 2020 In Plain Sight review recommended cultural safety and humility across the system after documenting widespread Indigenous-specific racism. The Truth and Reconciliation Commission's Calls to Action 22 and 23 ask the system to recognize Indigenous healing practices and to train all health professionals (TRC, 2015).

The difference to carry into exam questions is the direction of attention. Cultural competence treated as a checklist asks what the provider knows about a group; cultural safety asks how this person experiences the care, and what the provider and the system bring to the encounter, including power and history. A one-page profile of "Hmong beliefs" would have answered the first question and failed the second.

This section has defined health disparities, traced how they became a policy focus in the United States and how Canada reports them, and set out the range of reasons they exist, from the trajectory of health that history produces to missing data systems. It has also set the CLAS standards beside the critique of cultural competence as a checklist and beside cultural safety. The key takeaways and knowledge check that follow review this material, and the next section asks what to do.

Key Takeaways

  • 5.1 Health disparities are differences in health status, and in the quality of and access to care, between populations. In the United States they became a policy focus through the Healthy People goals, rapid demographic change, and the 1985 Heckler Report, which named six causes of the gap (cancer, cardiovascular disease and stroke, chemical dependency, diabetes, homicide and accidents, and infant mortality) and a thirty-year lag for African Americans; the 2011 Disparities Report found quality improving but access and disparities not improving for most minority and low-income groups. Canadian reporting distinguishes a health inequality, any measurable difference, from a health inequity, a difference that is unfair and avoidable, and finds the largest inequities affecting First Nations, Inuit, and Métis peoples. When a question uses these two words, check whether the difference is simply measured or is judged unfair and avoidable.
  • 5.2 A trajectory of health is the combination, for a population, of vulnerability and exposure to disease with the knowledge, attitudes, and practices that developed in response to that vulnerability and to historical experience; circumstance, vulnerability, and response together produce disparities. Mistrust is the clearest example: Tuskegee in the United States, and residential schools and Indian hospitals in Canada, left well-founded mistrust that still shapes the use of services. The practical lesson is that low use of a service by a community with this history should be read as a rational response, not as a lack of awareness, so a program has to work through trusted people and be honest about its purpose.
  • 5.3 The factors behind disparities span every ecological level: mistrust and patterns of living; ethnomedical systems, like the one at work in Lia Lee's case, that define illness, cause, treatment, and provider; differential treatment within the health system; socioeconomic status, segregation, and neighbourhood; and missing systems, from data fine enough to reveal a disparity to someone designated to act on it. Because the factors sit at several levels at once, a single response such as a translated pamphlet usually reaches only one of them, as Worked Example 10.6 shows. In a case question, sort the factors by level before choosing a response, and remember that broad categories such as "Asian" can hide the very disparities a program needs to see.
  • 6.1 The original CLAS standards of 2000, replaced by enhanced standards in 2013, define cultural competence in practice under three themes: culturally competent care (Standards 1 to 3), language access services (Standards 4 to 7), and organizational supports (Standards 8 to 14). The language access standards are the only ones written as "must": interpreters and bilingual staff at no cost, notice of that right, competent interpreters rather than family and friends except at the patient's request, and materials and signage in the languages of the service area. On an exam, match each requirement to its theme, and watch for distractors that swap the three CLAS themes for THRIVE's clusters or for the organizational characteristics of Section 4.
  • 6.2 Critics such as Kleinman and Benson argue that cultural competence should not be a list of traits or a technical checklist, because individuals within cultures vary and cultures are not static; what matters is how a particular person experiences the intersection of culture and health. Cultural safety, developed in Aotearoa New Zealand and now central to Indigenous health in Canada, takes the critique further: it asks whether the person receiving care feels safe and respected, and it makes the provider's assumptions, power, and the history of the system the subject of attention. When a case offers trait sheets or one-off training as the answer to culture, name the checklist critique, and when it involves Indigenous patients, name cultural safety as the Canadian response.
Knowledge Check: this section

1. A provincial report shows that average life expectancy differs between two regions, and an analyst describes every such difference in the report as a "health inequity". Using the distinction in Canadian reporting, what is wrong with this wording?

Canadian reporting distinguishes the two terms (5.1). An inequality is any measurable difference; an inequity is one judged unfair and avoidable.
As 5.1 explains, a health inequality is any measurable difference and a health inequity is a difference that is unfair and avoidable. Labelling every difference an inequity skips the judgement the term requires.
The distinction does not turn on what kind of difference it is. Either term can describe health status or access; inequity adds the judgement that the difference is unfair and avoidable.
The Heckler Report is a 1985 American report on six causes of excess deaths, unrelated to the Canadian terms. An inequity is a difference that is unfair and avoidable.
Correct answer: a health inequality is any measurable difference, while a health inequity is one that is unfair and avoidable. The information needed is the Canadian frame in 5.1, which distinguishes the two terms in exactly this way. The access option is tempting because disparities involve both health status and access to care, but the inequality and inequity distinction turns on whether a difference is unfair and avoidable, not on what kind of difference it is. (Section 3, 5.1 What Health Disparities Are and How They Became a Focus; Objective 5.1)

2. A clinic notes that members of a community with a long history of exclusion from the health system rarely come for screening, and concludes that they "lack awareness". Which idea from this section most directly challenges this conclusion?

Population growth is one reason disparities became a policy focus in 5.1, but it says nothing about why this community avoids screening. It leaves the awareness conclusion unchallenged.
The Heckler Report listed causes of excess deaths and says nothing about why a community avoids screening. It does not challenge the clinic's reading of low use as a lack of awareness.
Language access may matter, but pointing to missing signage accepts that the problem is information. It does not address the history of exclusion the case describes.
Section 5.2 shows that a population's knowledge, attitudes, and practices develop in response to its history, so mistrust is a rational response, not a knowledge deficit. A community excluded from care may avoid screening for well-founded reasons.
Correct answer: the trajectory of health. The information needed is 5.2: historical circumstances produce vulnerability and a response of knowledge, attitudes, and practice, and documented mistrust after the Tuskegee study, with reluctance to be tested for HIV, is the standard example, so low use may reflect well-founded mistrust rather than a knowledge gap. The CLAS signage option is tempting because language access may also matter, but it does not challenge the clinic's conclusion that the problem is awareness. (Section 3, 5.2 A Trajectory of Health; Objective 5.2)

3. In the case of Lia Lee, her parents understood her seizures as qaug dab peg, treated by a shaman's soul calling and regarded as a mark of distinction. This is an example of:

An ethnomedical system defines illness, cause, treatment, and provider (5.3.1). Qaug dab peg names the illness, a wandering soul is its cause, soul calling is the treatment, and the shaman (txiv neeb) is the provider.
Worked Example 10.5 uses Health Belief Model constructs, but it warns against treating a coherent system as an obstacle education can remove. The gap came from a different body of knowledge, not a lack of it.
The family's understanding is not an exposure in the Hawkins and Catalano model. It is a complete cultural system for understanding sickness and healing.
The distinction attached to qaug dab peg is part of the Hmong understanding of the illness, not a status schema the family performed. The case illustrates an ethnomedical system meeting biomedicine.
Correct answer: an ethnomedical system. The information needed is the definition in 5.3.1 and Worked Example 10.5: an ethnomedical system is a cultural system of knowledge and practice that defines illnesses, their causes, appropriate treatments, and appropriate providers, and the Hmong understanding of qaug dab peg does all four. The perceived barrier option is tempting because Worked Example 10.5 uses Health Belief Model constructs, but it treats a coherent system as an obstacle that education can remove, which is the misreading the case warns against. (Section 3, 5.3.1 Ethnomedical Systems and Differential Treatment; Objective 5.3)

4. Many populations are lumped together under designations such as "Asian", which places people from Vietnam and India in the same category. Why is this point raised?

The example makes the opposite point: lumping people from Vietnam and India together hides large differences. It concerns data categories, not ethnomedical systems.
Section 5.3.3 does not call for abandoning categories. It argues that data must be fine enough to reveal disparities, so categories need to be finer.
Section 5.3.3 treats broad categories as a missing-systems problem: a disparity must be identified before it can be addressed, which needs data fine enough to reveal it and someone designated to act on it.
The 43 percent growth figure in 5.1 applies to both the Asian and the Hispanic populations and supports the demographic argument. The lumping point in 5.3.3 is about data systems.
Correct answer: it illustrates a systems problem. The information needed is 5.3.3: before disparities can be addressed they must be identified, which requires data collected at a level fine enough to reveal them, and once identified the information has to reach someone designated to act, with leadership, a mission, coordination, and resources. The option about abandoning categories is tempting because the example criticizes a category, but the point is that categories need to be finer, not that they should be dropped. (Section 3, 5.3.3 The Systems That Are Missing; Objective 5.3)

5. A public health unit in an Ontario city has resettled several hundred refugee families. Women from these families present late for prenatal care, and the unit's response is to translate its prenatal pamphlet into three languages. Which statement best describes what the pamphlet can and cannot do?

Language is not the root of every level. Worked Example 10.6 sorts the factors into an ethnomedical system, perceived barriers rooted in a trajectory, and system design, and a translation touches only part of one.
Cultural safety asks whether the women feel safe and respected and attends to power and history (6.2). A translated pamphlet improves delivery at the surface and does not achieve that.
Explaining biomedical prenatal care does not change the birth practices the women know, attended by relatives and a traditional birth attendant. Describing one system does not make care fit the other.
Worked Example 10.6 shows that a pamphlet can explain prenatal care and that visits are covered, touching the belief about cost. It cannot build trust, fit birth practices, or fix the bus transfer, English-only booking, or male physician.
Correct answer: it can explain prenatal care and coverage but cannot reach trust, the ethnomedical system, or system design. The information needed is Worked Example 10.6, which sorts the factors behind late prenatal care into an ethnomedical system, perceived barriers rooted in a health trajectory, and system design, and shows that a translated document touches only part of one level. The ethnomedical option is tempting because the pamphlet explains biomedical care, but explaining one system does not make care fit the other. (Section 3, Worked Example 10.6; Objective 5.3)

6. At a hospital clinic, a newcomer patient's twelve-year-old son is asked to interpret during a discussion of her diagnosis, because no interpreter was booked. Which CLAS theme does this fall under, and what does it require?

Language access services (Standards 4 to 7) require free, competent interpreters and rule out family and friends except at the patient's request. A twelve-year-old interpreting a diagnosis because none was booked breaches these must standards.
Public progress reporting is an organizational support, but it does not govern who interprets. Interpreter use falls under language access services.
The standards do not prefer family interpreters; family and friends should not be used except at the patient's request. Sharing a culture does not make a child a competent interpreter.
The CLAS standards cover far more than printed materials, including care, interpreters, and organizational supports. Interpreter use falls under language access services.
Correct answer: language access services. The information needed is the second tab in 6.1: Standards 4 to 7 require bilingual staff and interpreters at no cost at all points of contact, notice of that right, competent interpreters, and no use of family and friends except at the patient's request, and these are the only standards written as "must". The culturally competent care option is tempting because a family member shares the patient's culture, but the standards treat family interpreters as a problem, not a solution. (Section 3, 6.1 Cultural Competence and the CLAS Standards; Objective 6.1)

7. A hospital gives every clinician a one-page "cultural profile" of the five largest ethnic groups it serves and declares itself culturally competent. Which point from this section applies?

A trait profile does not engage the meanings particular people attach to illness. It is the checklist Kleinman and Benson reject, not a generative approach.
Kleinman and Benson argue in 6.2 that cultural competence is not a list of traits, because individuals within cultures vary and cultures are not static. A one-page profile per group is exactly that checklist.
The CLAS standards do not require trait profiles. They ask for a demographic and epidemiological profile of the community, an organizational data task, not trait sheets for clinicians.
Cultural profiles say nothing about income, neighbourhood, or other socioeconomic causes. The relevant point is the critique of competence as a list of traits.
Correct answer: this treats cultural competence as a list of traits, which the critique rejects. The information needed is 6.2: Kleinman and Benson argue that cultural competence should not be viewed as learning a list of traits that supposedly represent a culture, because individuals within cultures vary and cultures are not static; what matters is how individuals subjectively experience the intersection of culture and health. The CLAS option is tempting because the standards do ask for a demographic and epidemiological profile of the community, but that is an organizational data task, not trait sheets for clinicians. (Section 3, 6.2 The Critique of Cultural Competence and Cultural Safety; Objective 6.2)

8. The Ontario health unit in question 5 decides it needs to understand the refugee families better. Which plan best follows the critique of cultural competence as a checklist?

A fact sheet on each nationality's traditions is a list of traits, the checklist the critique in 6.2 rejects. It assumes that everyone in a group thinks alike.
The CLAS language access standards rule out family interpreters except at the patient's request. Relying on husbands and children also ignores how these women themselves experience care.
Section 6.2 directs attention to how particular people experience culture and care, so asking the women and working through their communities follows the critique. Women providers and non-family interpreters also meet the CLAS language access standards.
Better data matter (5.3.3), but waiting five years does nothing to understand these women now. The critique calls for attention to individual experience, not delay.
Correct answer: learn how these particular women experience culture and care. The information needed is the critique in 6.2, which rejects trait lists because individuals vary and cultures change and directs attention to how each person experiences the intersection of culture and health, together with the CLAS language access standards in 6.1, which rule out relying on family interpreters except at the patient's request. The fact sheet is tempting because it looks thorough, but it is exactly the checklist the critique warns against. (Section 3, 6.2 The Critique of Cultural Competence and Cultural Safety; Objective 6.2)

✦ Pass the knowledge check with 100% to continue

Section 4

What to Do: From Theory to Healthier Communities

⏱ Estimated reading time: 18 minutes

Section 4 of 4

What to Do: From Theory to Healthier Communities

Which theory reaches which part of the web, and how the pieces fit together.

Individual approaches

Fill the constructs with the population

Which norms? What perceived barriers? A theory is useful only when its categories carry the specifics of the people you serve.

Mistrust

The individual face of the trajectory.

Not understood

Family consultation, herbal medicinals, examination customs.

Physical

Transportation, distance.

Language

The provider does not understand the patient.

Social, community, group

Three families of action

Mobilization and advocacy

Access to care, environmental risk, policy change; builds capacity and empowerment.

Norms and communication

Social marketing, mass media, key influencers, social networks with meaning for the group.

Political-economic

Employment and socioeconomic issues; health insurance; the Boston Disparities Project.

Multilevel programs

From determinants to healthier communities

Determinants

Equity and social justice; social resources; physical environment; natural resources.

Intermediate outcomes

Living conditions; employment; civic engagement; norms; learning and capacity; prevention and care.

Impact

Healthier communities.

REACHTHRIVE: four clustersTobacco: the best documented case
Organizational theory

Six characteristics and one barrier

Clear purposeCommitted leadershipCollaboration, public and privateGathering and sharing knowledgeDesignated resourcesEvaluation

The barrier: coordination. Overlap, silence between agencies, no consensus framework, and gaps nobody addresses.

Three kinds of cultural work

Appropriate, adapted, grounded

Culturally appropriate

Delivery: interpreters, respectful care, CLAS standards.

Cultural adaptation

Surface structure (people, places, language) and deep structure (meanings, history, forces behind the behaviour).

Culturally grounded

Designed from within a community’s own knowledge and governance.

Carry forward

What to take into the final review

  • High risk is circumstance; behaviour is usually about something else; harm reduction and generative approaches answer what output theories miss.
  • Disparities arise from trajectories, and their causes span every ecological level.
  • Theories are relevant when their categories are filled with a population’s specifics; otherwise they produce cookie-cutter programs.
  • Next: the final review, then Lesson 11 on evaluation.

Overview

Resolving the issues behind racial and ethnic disparities is not easy, and national strategies are often caught in politics (think of the administrative and policy assessment phase of planning), because the choice among social factors, economic factors, and individual behaviour is hard to separate from political viewpoints. The areas of action amount to far more than competent programs and translated materials. This section answers the question raised in Section 3, whether current theories are relevant, by moving from individual approaches through social and community, multilevel, and organizational ones to the kinds of cultural work a program can do, with Canadian cases along the way.

Learning Objectives

  • 7.1 Explain why the ecological model applies to disparities, and apply individual theories by filling their constructs with population-specific content.
  • 7.2 Describe social, community, and group approaches: mobilization and advocacy, communication through key influencers and networks, and political-economic strategies.
  • 7.3 Describe multilevel programs (REACH, THRIVE) and trace the CDC sociocultural framework from determinants through intermediate outcomes to healthier communities.
  • 7.4 Identify the six organizational characteristics that make a difference to disparities, and explain the coordination barrier.
  • 7.5 Distinguish culturally appropriate, culturally adapted (surface and deep structure), and culturally grounded programs, and use the adaptation questions to judge a program.

7.1 Picking Battles and Filling Individual Theories with the Population

The general ecological model applies to disparities, because the causal factors are many and varied and form an interrelated web. By this we mean that the factors set out in Section 3 do not act one at a time; poverty, neighbourhood, mistrust, and the design of services all affect one another. Since no program can act on the whole web at once, it becomes necessary to pick your battles. The choice depends on the population, because a precise set of factors may matter more for one population than for another. What follows is a tour of the theories that reach each part of the web, starting with the individual.

Because individuals are "behavers", there is always a role for individual-oriented approaches, even while individuals function within a larger social context. The difficulty is that many theories contain categories, such as social norms or perceived barriers, that are useful only when filled with specifics for a population. By this we mean that a theory tells you to look for barriers or norms, but it cannot tell you which barriers or which norms matter for a particular group; only knowledge of the population can. The questions to ask are therefore: which norms, and what barriers? The Health Belief Model shows how this works. For example, for a minority population, the perceived barriers to using health services include mistrust; concern that providers will not understand cultural practices, such as the need to consult family before decisions, the traditional use of herbal medicinals, and customs for examining older people, women, and men; physical difficulties such as transportation; and language. Each names one of these barriers and states what it implies for a program, with a Canadian example.

Mistrust

The first perceived barrier to the use of health services. It is the individual-level face of the trajectory described in the last section. Program implication: the barrier cannot be argued away with information; it is lowered through trusted messengers, honesty about purpose, and services in settings that do not carry the history. In British Columbia, the First Nations Health Authority’s cultural safety commitments are an attempt to lower this barrier at the level of the whole system.

Concern that providers
will not understand

Specific examples: the need to consult family before decisions, traditional use of herbal medicinals, and differing ways of appropriately conducting examinations with older people, women, and men. Program implication: offer family consultation as normal, ask about other treatments without judgment, and match provider and patient where custom requires it. Canadian interpreter services and community health broker programs for newcomers exist largely to address this barrier.

Physical
difficulties

The standard example is lack of transportation. Program implication: in Canada the scale of this barrier is unusual: people in remote First Nations and Inuit communities may fly hundreds of kilometres for specialist care, and the federal Non-Insured Health Benefits program funds medical transportation for eligible First Nations and Inuit clients. Whether that program works smoothly is itself a determinant of use.

Language

The barrier that the health provider does not understand a patient’s language. Program implication: the CLAS language access standards, the only ones written as "must": interpreters and bilingual staff at no cost at every point of contact, notice of the right to them, competent interpreters rather than family members, and materials and signage in the languages of the service area.

Each card turns a general construct into something a program can act on, which is the whole point: a perceived barrier is useful only when you know which barrier, for whom.

Attitudes and intentions work the same way. Under the Theory of Planned Behavior, a person must intend to change, believe there is a valued outcome, and believe they are capable of it. Here, too, the constructs have to be filled with the population's specifics. For example, if a risk behaviour is tied to norms for "being a man", such as drinking or not talking to health professionals about personal matters, intention to change may be low, because changing would mean going against what a man is expected to do. That norm may then become the focus of an effort. Notice the link to Section 2: the norm for being a man is also a generative schema (4.1), and a program that only argues against it will fare worse than one that offers another way to perform it.

Individual approaches reach the person. 7.2 turns to the social, community, and group contexts in which disparities are produced.

7.2 Social, Community, and Group Approaches

Individual approaches leave out the contexts in which people live, and those contexts vary by community and by health problem. Approaches that act on them fall into three families, and the way to tell them apart is to ask what each one is trying to change. The first family, community mobilization and advocacy, tries to change access or the environment: it creates better access to care or removes an environmental risk, and it builds the community's capacity and empowerment as it does so. The second family, health communication strategies such as social marketing and mass media campaigns, tries to change shared norms, attitudes, and beliefs. Because these belong to a group rather than to one person, the strategies work through key influencers and social networks that carry meaning for that group. The third family, coordinated community strategies, tries to change the longer-term political-economic context of employment, income, and insurance. Open each of the three tabs below for the detail of each family and a Canadian example.

Creating access and removing environmental risk

To create better access to care, or remove an environmental risk affecting a minority community, community mobilization and advocacy may be useful, and they may increase the community's capacity and empowerment as well. Mobilization is among the strategies the CDC Community Guide recommends for tobacco control, and policy change and improved access can result from mobilization, advocacy, social marketing, and media advocacy. A Canadian example is the decades of organizing by Grassy Narrows First Nation in northwestern Ontario over mercury contamination of the English-Wabigoon river, which eventually secured a federal commitment to a mercury care home.

Addressing shared norms, attitudes, and beliefs

To address norms shared by a group, health communication strategies, including social marketing and mass media campaigns, disseminate information and maximize the likelihood that people adopt healthy behaviours. Addressing group norms is a different task from individual change. A norm is held in common, so persuading one person at a time leaves the shared expectation in place; the program has to reach the people and channels through which the group sets and passes on its expectations. This means working with key influencers (community leaders, early adopters) and social networks, which first requires identifying the influencers, networks, and themes that have meaning for the group. For example, networks for some immigrant populations centre on sports leagues or faith organizations, so a message carried by a coach or a faith leader may travel further than one from a health unit.

Reducing socioeconomic disparities

Reducing socioeconomic disparities is a longer-term issue, but some coordinated community strategies have tried. One example is the Boston Public Health Commission's Disparities Project, which addresses employment and socioeconomic issues and was recognized as a promising practice by the National Association of County and City Health Officials. Access to health insurance also belongs here. In Canada, where hospital and physician care are publicly insured, the equivalent gaps are in what is not covered (prescription drugs, dental care, counselling) and who is excluded (some temporary residents and people without status).

The tabs show that each family reaches a different part of the problem, and that the norms strategy has a first step that is easy to skip: identifying the influencers, networks, and themes that have meaning for this particular group. Worked Example 10.7 shows a Canadian program that works at the individual and group levels at once; as you read, sort each of its functions by level.

Worked Example 10.7: Multicultural Health Brokers in Edmonton

The Multicultural Health Brokers Co-operative in Edmonton, formed in the 1990s, employs workers from the immigrant and refugee communities they serve. Brokers accompany families through perinatal care, early childhood programs, and the wider service system, explain how coverage and appointments work, interpret culture in both directions, and advocate when families are treated badly. They also carry what the communities need back to the health system.

Step 1, individual approaches. The brokers lower several of the perceived barriers in 7.1. Explaining how coverage and appointments work addresses practical barriers and fears about cost; interpreting culture in both directions addresses language and the concern that providers will not understand; and being known in the community lowers mistrust.

Step 2, group approaches. The brokers are both key influencers and network nodes: respected people within their communities, through whom information about care travels along existing ties. Advocating when families are treated badly, and carrying community needs back to the health system, add an element of mobilization and advocacy.

Step 3, the seven working issues. The role builds trust, gains access to families who would not come to a clinic, finds the right way to communicate, and gives the health system a way to learn from the communities. Carrying community needs back to the system moves toward shared benefits.

Step 4, what would be lost if the role were filled from outside. A worker from outside the communities might interpret language but would lack the trust, the place in the network, and the lived knowledge that make the role work. The program would shrink to a translation service.

What this example shows: one well-designed role can act at several levels at once. In an answer about a program like this, name the level of each function rather than describing the program as a whole.

Programs such as the brokers act at one or two levels. 7.3 turns to programs designed to tie the levels together.

7.3 Multilevel Programs and the Pathway from Determinants to Healthier Communities

A multilevel program is one that ties the individual, social, and community strategies of 7.1 and 7.2 together, so that they work on several parts of the web at once rather than on one. Several programs do this, and each organizes the levels in its own way. For example, the CDC REACH program (Racial and Ethnic Approaches to Community Health) links community organizational capacity, targeted action, knowledge and behaviour change, and improved health outcomes, so that it reads as a chain running from building a community's capacity to the health result. THRIVE (Toolkit for Health and Resilience in Vulnerable Environments), from the Prevention Institute, works differently: rather than a chain, it strengthens four community clusters, namely the built environment, social capital, services and institutions, and structural factors. Tobacco control is the best documented coordinated effort of this kind, because it combines policy, cessation services, changing norms, and mobilization.

The CDC sociocultural framework, adapted from the Community Guide's model linking the social environment to health, maps how these pieces connect. Its purpose is to show the path from broad social conditions to community health, and so to show where along that path a given program acts. The framework reads from left to right in three columns. On the left are four determinants: equity and social justice; social resources (standard of living, culture and history, social institutions, built environments, political structures, economic systems, and technology); the physical environment; and natural resources. In the middle are six intermediate outcomes: neighbourhood living conditions; community development and employment opportunities; civic engagement and participation in decision making; community customs, norms, and processes; opportunities for learning and developing capacity; and health promotion, prevention, and care opportunities. On the right is the impact: healthier communities. The difference between the first two columns is the one most easily confused. By determinants we mean the broad conditions that shape a community's health, which a single program rarely controls; by intermediate outcomes we mean the more specific community conditions that programs can actually change, and through which the determinants reach health. Interactive 10.4 presents the framework. Click each of its eleven boxes to open a description with a Canadian example, and notice where each approach from 7.1 and 7.2 acts.

📊 Interactive 10.4: The CDC sociocultural framework.

Determinants, six intermediate outcomes, impact.
DETERMINANTS INTERMEDIATE OUTCOMES IMPACT Equity and social justice✓ Social resources• Standard of living• Culture and history• Social institutions• Built environments• Political structures• Economic systems• Technology✓ Physical environment✓ Natural resources✓ 1 Neighbourhood living conditions✓ 2 Community development andemployment opportunities✓ 3 Civic engagement and participationin decision making✓ 4 Community customs, norms,and processes✓ 5 Opportunities for learning anddeveloping capacity✓ 6 Health promotion, prevention,and care opportunities✓ HEALTHIERCOMMUNITIES✓ Modified from the Community Guide model (Anderson et al., 2003)

Click a box to begin

Determinants are conditions a program rarely controls; intermediate outcomes are where most programs act.

0 of 11 boxes explored

Equity and social justice

Fairness heads the pathway: how a society distributes resources, power, and protection.

Canadian example: Jordan's Principle: a First Nations child receives needed services first, and payment disputes are settled afterward.

Social resources

Standard of living, culture and history, institutions, built environments, political and economic systems, technology. The trajectory of health sits here.

Canadian example: the healthy immigrant effect and its fading.

Physical environment

Air, water, housing, and exposure to hazards.

Canadian example: drinking water advisories in First Nations communities; crowded housing and tuberculosis in Inuit Nunangat.

Natural resources

Land, water, and food sources.

Canadian example: traditional foods in the North; mercury at Grassy Narrows removed a food source and a livelihood at once.

Neighbourhood living conditions

Safety, housing, food access, transit, pollution: THRIVE's built environment cluster.

Canadian example: Nutrition North Canada subsidies; low-income transit passes.

Community development and employment opportunities

Jobs, income, and investment: the longer-term political-economic level.

Canadian example: social enterprises employing people with histories of homelessness or drug use in the Downtown Eastside.

Civic engagement and participation in decision making

Whether the community has a voice: where mobilization and shared benefits live.

Canadian example: the First Nations Health Authority; peer-run organizations of people who use drugs.

Community customs, norms, and processes

Shared norms and beliefs, addressed through social marketing, key influencers, and networks; also where generative schema sit.

Canadian example: Indigenous-led programs that treat connection to culture, language, and land as protective.

Opportunities for learning and developing capacity

Education, skills, and the capacity of community organizations: REACH's emphasis.

Canadian example: training Indigenous health professionals (TRC Call to Action 23) and community health brokers.

Health promotion, prevention, and care opportunities

Access to and quality of prevention and care: the CLAS standards and harm reduction services act here.

Canadian example: San'yas training; supervised consumption sites; the Interim Federal Health Program.

Healthier communities

The impact the pathway aims at, and the outcome evaluation looks for last; the time needed usually exceeds a funding cycle.

Canadian example: the measurable goals to close health gaps that TRC Call to Action 19 asks governments to set and report.

Determinants are conditions a program rarely controls; intermediate outcomes are where most programs act; and the impact, healthier communities, is what evaluation looks for last, usually after more time than a funding cycle allows. When a case asks where a program acts, place it in one or more of the six intermediate outcomes, and then ask which boxes it leaves alone.

7.4 Organizational Theory: Putting the Pieces Together

The approaches in 7.1 to 7.3 describe what can be done; organizational theory asks whether the organizations involved are able to do it. Organizational development theory applies to problems in the health system that affect disparities. By this we mean the work of putting the pieces together at a local, regional, provincial, or national level, so that the right organizations act on the right parts of the problem. Six characteristics are likely to make a difference. An organization needs a clear purpose and committed leadership to keep it on track. It needs collaborations that include public and private partners, and effective gathering and sharing of knowledge about the disparities and their causes. Finally, it needs resources designated for the effort, and evaluation to show whether it is having the desired effect. Table 10.3 lists the six, with what each involves and a question a program can ask about each.

Table 10.3. Six organizational characteristics likely to make a difference to disparities, with what each involves and a question to ask.

CharacteristicWhat it involvesQuestion to ask
Clear purposeGoals, mission, and values aimed at eliminating disparities define the standards for evaluation (the SAMHSA Strategic Prevention Framework is the example)Is eliminating disparities in the mission, and are we evaluated against it?
Committed leadershipKeeps the organization on track; Boston's Disparities Project rests on mayoral commitment and a Mayor's Task ForceWho, with authority, will still be pushing this in year four?
Collaborations, public and privateNearly all model systems feature public-private partnerships; Boston channels private funding to community organizationsWho is missing from the table, and who holds the money?
Gathering and sharing knowledgeWhat the disparities are, their causes, and what best practices existDo we have fine enough data, and does it reach the people who act?
Effective use of resourcesNo program can function without resources designated for the effortIs there a budget line, or only a commitment?
EvaluationTo make sure the organization is having the desired effectWhat would tell us this is not working, and would we hear it?

Even organizations that have all six characteristics face a general barrier, which is coordination. So many organizations have roles that there is often overlap, or there are organizations working on the same problem without communication or a consensus framework. The result is gaps that nobody addresses. In other words, the coordination barrier is not a weakness inside one organization but a failure in the relationships among them, which is why it can persist even when each organization is doing its own job well. For example, Canada's division of responsibility for Indigenous health among federal, provincial, territorial, and First Nations governments is a standing illustration, and the First Nations Health Authority in British Columbia, analysed in Worked Example 10.8, is one attempt to solve the problem by design.

Organizational theory explains how the pieces are held together. The last question is what kind of cultural work the pieces do, which 7.5 takes up.

7.5 Culturally Appropriate, Adapted, and Grounded Programs

It helps to sort the kinds of cultural work a program can do. This distinction goes a step beyond the frameworks presented so far, and its purpose is to let you say precisely how a program takes culture into account, rather than simply calling it "culturally sensitive". There are three kinds, and they differ in how deeply culture shapes the program.

First, a program can be culturally appropriate in its delivery. By this we mean that the cultural work lies in how the program is delivered, so that the service fits the people it serves, for example through the CLAS standards, interpreters, and respectful care.

Second, a program can be a cultural adaptation of an existing program, and here there are two levels. Resnicow and colleagues (1999) distinguished surface structure adaptation from deep structure adaptation. Surface structure adaptation matches the people, places, language, and materials to the audience; for example, a program might use staff from the community and translate its materials. Deep structure adaptation goes further: it engages the cultural, social, and historical forces behind the behaviour, such as the generative schema of 4.1 or the trajectory of 5.2. The difference matters because a program can look culturally matched at the surface while still ignoring the reasons the behaviour exists.

Third, a program can be culturally grounded. A culturally grounded program is designed from within a community's own knowledge, values, and governance, so that culture is the source of the program rather than a layer applied to it. In contrast to an adaptation, which starts from an existing program and changes it, a grounded program starts from the community. Indigenous-led health promotion in Canada is increasingly of this third kind. When you classify a program, then, ask two questions: was the program designed elsewhere and changed, or designed from within the community, and if it was changed, did the changes reach only the surface or the deep structure?

It turns these distinctions into six questions for judging the cultural work of a program, from who asked for the program to who holds the evidence, and several draw on earlier parts of the lesson: shared benefits (1.2), generative schema (4.1), and the trajectory of health (5.2).

1. Who asked for this program, and who defines success?

Shared benefits, from the first section of this lesson. This question comes first because the answer reveals where the program's purpose came from. If the funder set the outcomes and the community was consulted afterward, the program is at best appropriate, not grounded, however respectful its delivery. A grounded program, in contrast, starts from what the community itself wants to change and how it would recognize success.

2. Surface structure: do the people, places, language, and materials fit?

Are staff and models from the community, the setting one the population already uses, and the materials in the right languages? Most adaptations stop here.

3. Deep structure: does the program engage the meanings behind the behaviour?

Has anyone identified the generative schema at work, the norms for being a man or a good daughter, the ethnomedical understanding of the condition? Does the program offer ways to satisfy those meanings, or only argue against them? A pamphlet is surface; microcredit for the oldest daughter is deep.

4. Trajectory: does the program know the history it is walking into?

Has the team learned how this population came to its relationship with the health system, and are services offered in settings and by people that do not carry that history? Cultural safety training is a starting point, not a certificate.

5. Levels: which boxes of the sociocultural framework does the program touch?

A program that acts only in box 6 (care opportunities) while the disparity is produced in boxes 1 and 2 (living conditions, employment) has picked a battle it cannot win alone. Who will reach the other boxes?

6. Data, ownership, and evaluation: who holds the evidence?

Are data fine enough to show the disparity, and does the community govern them? First Nations in Canada assert the OCAP principles (ownership, control, access, possession) over their data. Does evaluation report to the community as well as the funder?

Most adaptations stop at the second question. A program that can also answer the first, third, and fourth questions well has moved from surface toward deep structure, and toward being grounded in the community it serves. Worked Example 10.8 applies these questions, together with the organizational characteristics of 7.4 and the framework of 7.3, to Indigenous-led health governance in British Columbia.

Worked Example 10.8: Indigenous-Led Health Governance in BC

In 2013 the First Nations Health Authority (FNHA) took over the health programs previously delivered to First Nations in British Columbia by the federal government, under a tripartite agreement among BC First Nations, the province, and Canada, the first province-wide authority of its kind. It places First Nations perspectives on wellness at the centre, treats connection to land, family, community, and culture as determinants of health, funds community-designed programs, has made cultural safety and humility a commitment for the whole provincial system, and reports its own health data.

Step 1, organizational characteristics. The authority supplies a clear purpose (First Nations perspectives on wellness at the centre), committed leadership through First Nations governance, collaboration across levels through the tripartite agreement, and its own knowledge base through reporting its own health data. Bringing federal programs under one province-wide authority is also a direct answer to the coordination barrier.

Step 2, intermediate outcomes. First Nations governance and community-designed programs act on civic engagement and participation in decision making (outcome 3); treating connection to land, family, community, and culture as determinants acts on community customs, norms, and processes (outcome 4); and system-wide cultural safety acts on health promotion, prevention, and care opportunities (outcome 6).

Step 3, kind of cultural work. This is a culturally grounded program, not an adaptation: it is designed from within First Nations knowledge, values, and governance, so culture is the source of the program rather than a layer applied to it.

Step 4, why that matters for evaluation. Because the communities define what success means and govern their own data, evaluation has to report to the communities as well as to funders, in line with the OCAP principles of ownership, control, access, and possession, and it may count outcomes, such as connection to culture, that an imported program would never measure.

What this example shows: a culturally grounded program can be analysed with the same tools as any other (organizational characteristics, intermediate outcomes, adaptation questions), and the analysis shows where it differs. A common mistake is to call any program with Indigenous staff "grounded"; the test is who designed it and who defines success.

The question that opened Section 3, whether current theories are relevant to culture, diversity, and health disparities, can now be answered, and the answer is worth stating plainly.

So, are current theories relevant?

The answer is yes, on one condition. Every theory in the course has categories that must be filled with the specifics of a population: which barriers, which norms, which networks, which schema, which history. Filled in, the Health Belief Model reaches mistrust, Social Network Theory reaches the soccer league, and organizational theory reaches the coordination gap. Left empty, the same theories produce cookie-cutter programs. The theories are relevant. The work is in the filling.

This section has shown that the ecological model applies to disparities, that individual theories are useful once their constructs are filled with a population's specifics, that social, community, multilevel, and organizational approaches reach the parts of the web beyond the individual, and that cultural work can be appropriate, adapted at the surface or the deep structure, or culturally grounded. The key takeaways and knowledge check that follow review this material and complete the four sections of the lesson.

Key Takeaways

  • 7.1 The ecological model applies to disparities because their causes form an interrelated web, so a program has to pick its battles, and the right battles depend on the population. Individual theories still have a role, since individuals are behavers, but their constructs are useful only when filled with population-specific content: for the Health Belief Model, the perceived barriers to using services include mistrust, concern that providers will not understand cultural practices, physical difficulties such as transportation, and language; for the Theory of Planned Behavior, norms for being a man can keep intention low. When an exam asks how to use an individual theory with a particular population, name the specific barrier or norm, not just the construct, and remember that such a norm may also be a generative schema better offered an alternative than argued against.
  • 7.2 Social, community, and group approaches come in three families. Community mobilization and advocacy create access to care or remove environmental risks and build capacity and empowerment, as in the CDC Community Guide's tobacco recommendations and Grassy Narrows' organizing over mercury. Communication strategies such as social marketing address shared norms through key influencers and networks, which first have to be identified for the particular group (for some immigrant communities, sports leagues or faith organizations). Political-economic strategies, such as the Boston Disparities Project, take on employment, income, and insurance. To classify an approach in a case, ask what it is trying to change: access or environment, shared norms, or socioeconomic conditions.
  • 7.3 Multilevel programs tie strategies together: REACH links community organizational capacity, targeted action, knowledge and behaviour change, and health outcomes, and THRIVE strengthens four clusters (built environment, social capital, services and institutions, and structural factors). The CDC sociocultural framework traces the pathway from four determinants (equity and social justice, social resources, the physical environment, and natural resources) through six intermediate outcomes (neighbourhood living conditions; community development and employment; civic engagement and participation in decision making; community customs, norms, and processes; opportunities for learning and capacity; and health promotion, prevention, and care opportunities) to healthier communities. A common trap is to mix these lists up, so learn which belongs to which, and when placing a program, name the intermediate outcomes it acts on and the ones it leaves alone.
  • 7.4 Organizational theory names six characteristics that make a difference to disparities: clear purpose, committed leadership, collaborations that include public and private partners at all levels, effective gathering and sharing of knowledge, resources designated for the effort, and evaluation. The general barrier is coordination: many organizations working on the same problem without communication or a consensus framework, leaving gaps nobody addresses, as with Canada's divided jurisdiction over Indigenous health. In a case, check the six characteristics one by one against what the scenario supplies, and treat overlap and silence between agencies as the sign of a coordination gap.
  • 7.5 Cultural work comes in three kinds. A culturally appropriate program gets delivery right (interpreters, respectful care, the CLAS standards); a cultural adaptation changes an existing program at the surface structure (people, places, language, and materials) or at the deep structure (the cultural, social, and historical forces behind the behaviour); and a culturally grounded program is designed from within a community's own knowledge and governance, as with the First Nations Health Authority in Worked Example 10.8. The adaptation questions ask who defined success, whether the deep structure and the trajectory are engaged, which levels the program touches, and who holds the evidence. Hiring staff from the community or translating materials is surface structure; to call a program grounded, check who designed it and who defines success.
Knowledge Check: this section

1. A health unit wants to use the Health Belief Model to increase cancer screening among a newcomer community. What must it do before the model is of any use?

Section 7.1 says categories such as perceived barriers are useful only when filled with population specifics. For a minority population these include mistrust, concern that providers will not understand, transportation, and language.
Section 7.1 says there is always a role for individual approaches, because individuals are behavers. Individual theories apply once their constructs are filled with the population's specifics.
Language is only one of several barriers, so translation alone does not fill the construct. Mistrust, concern about cultural practices, and transportation would remain.
The Health Belief Model is a decision model, not an exposure model. Risk and protective factors belong to the Hawkins and Catalano model (2.1).
Correct answer: fill the model's categories with specifics for this population. The information needed is 7.1: because individuals are behavers there is always a role for individual approaches, but categories such as social norms or perceived barriers are useful only when filled with population-specific content, and for the Health Belief Model the barriers include mistrust, concern that providers will not understand cultural practices, physical difficulties such as transportation, and language. Translating the pamphlet is tempting because language is one of the barriers, but translation alone falls far short of filling the construct. (Section 4, 7.1 Picking Battles and Filling Individual Theories with the Population; Objective 7.1)

2. In one community, men rarely talk to health professionals about personal matters, because doing so is seen as unmanly. Applying the Theory of Planned Behavior as this lesson does, what should a program recognize, and what does Section 2 add?

Perceived susceptibility belongs to the Health Belief Model, not the Theory of Planned Behavior, and the case concerns a norm, not a belief about risk. Statistics do not address what being a man requires.
Protective factors belong to the exposure model, not the Theory of Planned Behavior. The case describes a norm that keeps intention low.
Treating the norm as a community-domain risk factor returns to the exposure model. Section 7.1 reads it through intention and links it to the generative schema of 4.1.
Under the Theory of Planned Behavior, norms for being a man can keep intention low (7.1). Section 2 adds that such a norm is a generative schema, better offered another way to be performed than argued against.
Correct answer: norms for being a man may keep intention low, and the norm is also a generative schema. The information needed is 7.1: under the Theory of Planned Behavior a person must intend to change, and if a risk behaviour is tied to norms for being a man, such as not talking to health professionals about personal matters, intention may be low and can become the focus of an effort; the same subsection links the norm to the generative schema of 4.1. The perceived susceptibility option is tempting because it names a familiar construct, but it belongs to the Health Belief Model and does not address the norm. (Section 4, 7.1 Picking Battles and Filling Individual Theories with the Population; Objective 7.1)

3. A program discovers that health information in a Somali-Canadian community moves mainly through a mosque and a men's soccer league, and it decides to work through respected people in both. Which family of approaches is this, and what first step does it require?

Working through respected people in a mosque and a soccer league acts on shared norms, not on individual beliefs. Raising perceived susceptibility is an individual move.
The norms and communication tab in 7.2 says group norms are addressed through key influencers and social networks, which for some immigrant communities centre on sports leagues or faith organizations. The first step is identifying them and the themes with meaning.
Political-economic strategies target employment, income, and insurance. This program works through influencers and networks to reach shared norms.
Organizational theory concerns whether organizations can act together, and CLAS strategic plans are organizational supports. This program acts on community norms through influencers.
Correct answer: a group norms approach using key influencers and social networks, whose first step is to identify them. The information needed is the norms and communication tab in 7.2: addressing group norms is a different task from individual change, it works through key influencers (community leaders, early adopters) and social networks, which for some immigrant populations centre on sports leagues or faith organizations, and it first requires identifying the influencers, networks, and themes that have meaning for the group. The organizational option is tempting because the CLAS standards include strategic plans, but the program described is acting on shared norms, not on its own organization. (Section 4, 7.2 Social, Community, and Group Approaches; Objective 7.2)

4. A regional health authority in British Columbia offers a diabetes education class in Punjabi at the hospital, using recipes from South Asian cuisine, to reduce complications of type 2 diabetes among South Asian residents. Which addition would extend the plan to group norms?

Another class at the hospital changes timing, not shared norms. It remains individual education delivered in the same setting.
More translations extend delivery but do not touch shared norms. Group norms are reached through key influencers and networks (7.2).
In 7.2, addressing group norms means working with key influencers and networks that carry meaning for the group, which for some immigrant communities centre on faith organizations and sports leagues. Messages about family food practices act on shared norms.
Individual counselling on perceived severity is a Health Belief Model approach at the individual level. It does not reach norms shared by a group.
Correct answer: work through respected people in faith organizations and sports leagues, with messages that carry meaning for the group. The information needed is the norms and communication tab in 7.2: addressing group norms means working with key influencers and social networks, which first requires identifying the influencers, networks, and themes that have meaning for the group, and for some immigrant populations networks centre on sports leagues or faith organizations. Translating more handouts is tempting because it extends the program's reach, but it remains a change in delivery that does not touch shared norms. (Section 4, 7.2 Social, Community, and Group Approaches; Objective 7.2)

5. Which set correctly lists the four clusters of community factors that the THRIVE program aims to strengthen?

Section 7.3 lists THRIVE's four clusters as built environment, social capital, services and institutions, and structural factors, the same four categories the California Campaign used (5.3.2).
This resembles PolicyLink's domains of community effects on health (5.3.2): social and economic environment, physical environment, and services. They are not THRIVE's clusters.
These are domains from the Hawkins and Catalano risk and protective factors model (2.1). They describe exposures for youth, not THRIVE's community clusters.
These are the four determinants of the CDC sociocultural framework (7.3). THRIVE's clusters are built environment, social capital, services and institutions, and structural factors.
Correct answer: built environment, social capital, services and institutions, and structural factors. The information needed is 7.3, where THRIVE, from the Prevention Institute, is described as strengthening these four community clusters, the same four categories the California Campaign used for its twenty community factors (5.3.2). The option listing equity, social resources, physical environment, and natural resources is tempting because it also has four parts, but those are the determinants of the CDC sociocultural framework; the second option resembles PolicyLink's domains and the third comes from the risk factor model. (Section 4, 7.3 Multilevel Programs and the Pathway from Determinants to Healthier Communities; Objective 7.3)

6. On the CDC sociocultural framework, where does the diabetes class in question 4 mainly act, and what does it leave alone?

Serving a minority group does not make a class act on a determinant; determinants are broad conditions a program rarely controls (7.3). The class also leaves several intermediate outcomes untouched.
No single class acts directly on the impact. Programs act through intermediate outcomes, and healthier communities is what evaluation looks for last (7.3).
Civic engagement means the community has a voice in decisions. Teaching in Punjabi matches language but gives the community no role in deciding what the plan is for.
A class at a hospital is a prevention and care opportunity, intermediate outcome 6 (7.3). Neighbourhood food access, employment, and shared food norms sit in outcomes 1, 2, and 4, which it leaves largely alone.
Correct answer: it acts mainly on health promotion, prevention, and care opportunities. The information needed is the framework in 7.3 and Interactive 10.4: a class delivered at a hospital is a prevention and care opportunity (intermediate outcome 6), while walkable streets and food access (outcome 1), work and income (outcome 2), and shared food norms (outcome 4) sit elsewhere. The civic engagement option is tempting because language matching looks like inclusion, but civic engagement means the community has a voice in decisions, which the plan does not give. (Section 4, 7.3 Multilevel Programs and the Pathway from Determinants to Healthier Communities; Objective 7.3)

7. A provincial disparities initiative has a strong mission statement, a committed deputy minister, a broad public-private coalition, and good data. Three years in, the funded projects are ending and nobody can say whether health outcomes changed. Which organizational characteristics are missing?

The scenario supplies a strong mission statement and a committed deputy minister, so clear purpose and committed leadership are present.
A broad public-private coalition and good data supply collaboration and knowledge sharing, so these are not missing.
Table 10.3 lists six characteristics, and the scenario supplies purpose, leadership, collaboration, and knowledge. Funding that simply ends points to missing designated resources, and nobody knowing whether outcomes changed points to missing evaluation.
Short funding cycles (2.2.2) are an argument for sustained resources and evaluation, not against them. The scenario lacks two of the six characteristics.
Correct answer: designated resources and evaluation. The information needed is Table 10.3 in 7.4, which lists clear purpose, committed leadership, collaborations, gathering and sharing knowledge, effective use of designated resources, and evaluation; the scenario supplies the first four, while funding that simply ends and the absence of any judgement about outcomes point to the last two. The option that three years is too short is tempting because success often takes longer than a funding cycle (2.2.2), but that is an argument for evaluation and sustained resources, not against them. (Section 4, 7.4 Organizational Theory: Putting the Pieces Together; Objective 7.4)

8. A smoking cessation program for an Indigenous community is adapted by adding Indigenous artwork to its materials and hiring an Indigenous facilitator, while its content and goals stay unchanged. In the terms of 7.5, this is:

A grounded program is designed from within the community's own knowledge and governance. Hiring an Indigenous facilitator for a program whose content and goals were set elsewhere does not make it grounded.
Section 7.5 defines surface structure adaptation as matching people, places, language, and materials to the audience. Artwork and a facilitator change only those, while the content, goals, and forces behind smoking are untouched.
Deep structure adaptation engages the cultural, social, and historical forces behind the behaviour. Adding artwork changes materials, which is surface structure.
The CLAS standards do not prohibit changing materials; they ask for materials in the languages of the service area. The case is about the depth of adaptation.
Correct answer: a surface structure adaptation. The information needed is 7.5: Resnicow and colleagues distinguished surface structure adaptation, matching people, places, language, and materials to the audience, from deep structure adaptation, which engages the cultural, social, and historical forces behind the behaviour, and a culturally grounded program is designed from within the community's own knowledge and governance. The grounded option is tempting because the facilitator is Indigenous, but the content and goals were set elsewhere and left unchanged, so culture is a layer, not the source. (Section 4, 7.5 Culturally Appropriate, Adapted, and Grounded Programs; Objective 7.5)

✦ Pass the knowledge check with 100% to continue

Section 5

Final Review & Assessment

⏱ Estimated time: 25 minutes

Bringing It All Together

This lesson paired two topics that ask the same question from different directions: are the theories of this course adequate when the people a program serves are not the people the theories were built around? The first half began with high-risk populations. The label is almost always a matter of circumstance (poverty, exclusion, hazardous conditions, illegal or marginalized activity), and seven working issues come before any theory: trust, access, communication, a willingness to learn, confidentiality, honesty, and shared benefits. The central claim is that risk behaviour is usually about something other than health, so the output theories (the Health Belief Model, the Theory of Planned Behavior, and the risk and protective factors model), which assume the health behaviour is the object of the person's attention, explain less than their measurability suggests. The man in the wheelchair and the runaway youth who did not expect to live past twenty-five are reminders of how much a label hides.

Two approaches respond. Harm reduction focuses on the behaviour that poses the greatest public health threat, without judging or overcategorizing the person, and the trust it builds precedes movement toward change; its Canadian record, from needle distribution and Insite to take-home naloxone and managed alcohol programs, forms a continuum from keeping people alive to changing the conditions of use. The generative approach asks what a behaviour is for, names the generative schema (mastery, independence, loyalty, being something, family obligation) and the need beneath it, and adds less risky behaviours and possible selves that satisfy the same need, with real resources where the schema formed under constraint, which is Bourdieu's habitus.

The second half widened the frame to whole populations that fare worse in health. Disparities arise from trajectories in which historical circumstance produces vulnerability, and populations develop knowledge, attitudes, and practices in response, so that mistrust rooted in Tuskegee, or in residential schools and Indian hospitals, is rational rather than a knowledge deficit. The causes span every ecological level, from ethnomedical systems and differential treatment to socioeconomic status, neighbourhood, and the data systems that are missing, and cultural competence, though necessary, cannot be a checklist of traits; cultural safety is the Canadian expression of that critique. The answer to the question is that current theories are relevant on one condition: their categories must be filled with the specifics of a population. Individual theories then reach mistrust and language; community mobilization reaches access and environmental risk; social marketing and networks reach norms; multilevel programs and the sociocultural framework trace the path from determinants to healthier communities; and organizational theory supplies the purpose, leadership, collaboration, knowledge, resources, evaluation, and coordination without which nothing scales.

Key Takeaways from this lesson

  1. You can now explain what makes a population high risk: a group whose risk is particularly high, or who is hard to reach, almost always because of circumstances such as poverty, exclusion, hazardous conditions, or illegal or marginalized activity. You can name the seven working issues that come before any program, above all trust and shared benefits. The practical reminder: much high-risk behaviour is about something other than health, so look past the risk label to the person and the circumstances before choosing a theory.
  2. You can now describe how output theories picture behaviour, either as a linear decision about health (the Health Belief Model and the Theory of Planned Behavior) or as a balance of exposures (the risk and protective factors model), and explain where they fall short: they assume health is the object of attention and say little about meaning or the links between levels. Keep the evidence contrast in mind: weaker for youth violence, where the behaviour is the health problem, and better for HIV, where specific behaviours are routes of transmission.
  3. You can now explain how harm reduction meets people where they are and apply it to a case: name the most pressing threat, choose services that act on it, say who delivers them and which theories are at work in outreach, and say what is deliberately left for later. You can place Canadian services on the continuum from keeping people alive to changing conditions. The most useful reminder is that harm reduction is a sequence, not acceptance of drug use, and that trust precedes movement toward change.
  4. You can now explain the generative approach, define a generative schema as an internalized model of how things are supposed to be, explain why a schema is generative but not predictive, and connect schema to socioeconomic constraint through Bourdieu's habitus. In a case, name the schema and the need beneath the behaviour, then propose other behaviours and possible selves that satisfy the same need, with real resources where the schema formed under constraint.
  5. You can now explain why health disparities exist, using the trajectory of health, in which circumstance produces vulnerability and populations develop knowledge, attitudes, and practices in response, and the ecological range of contributing factors, from mistrust and ethnomedical systems to socioeconomic status, neighbourhood, and missing data systems. The practical reminder: read low use of services by a community with a history of mistreatment as a rational response rather than a knowledge deficit, and sort the factors by level before choosing a response.
  6. You can now summarize the three themes of the CLAS standards, explain the critique that cultural competence should not be a checklist of traits because individuals vary and cultures change, and describe cultural safety as the Canadian development of that critique in Indigenous health. When a case offers trait sheets or translation as the answer to culture, name what is missing: attention to how this person experiences care, and to power and history.
  7. You can now apply theory at every level to a disparity: fill individual constructs with a population's specifics, choose among mobilization, norms, and political-economic strategies, place a program on the CDC sociocultural framework, check the six organizational characteristics and the coordination barrier, and say whether its cultural work is appropriate, adapted at the surface or deep structure, or grounded. The answer to the lesson's question is that current theories are relevant on one condition: their categories must be filled with the specifics of the population.

Final Knowledge Assessment

This assessment covers all material from this lesson, and its last four questions follow one applied scenario that brings the two halves of the lesson together. You must score 100% to complete the lesson. Review the feedback for any incorrect answers and try again.

Final Assessment: High-Risk Populations, Culture, and Health Disparities (19 Questions)

1. Focusing only on a population's health risk behaviours makes "high-risk population" their primary identity. What consequence follows from this?

Section 1.3 argues that a narrow focus on the risk behaviour is the problem, not an efficiency. It limits understanding and the design of effective interventions.
The lesson does not say evaluation becomes impossible. The cost it names is a narrowed understanding of risk, which limits theory and interventions.
Nothing in 1.3 links the label to funding or easier access. The label hides the person's roles, relationships, and circumstances.
Section 1.3 states that when the risk label becomes a primary identity, we limit our understanding of the risk and, as a result, the appropriate use of theory and the development of effective interventions.
Correct answer: understanding of the risk is limited, and so are the use of theory and the design of interventions. The information needed is the central argument of 1.3: public health categorizes people by their risk behaviours, and if the label is all we focus on, we limit our understanding of health risk and, consequently, the use of theory and the development of effective interventions. The efficiency option is tempting because a single target sounds simpler, but the lesson argues that the narrow focus is the problem, not a gain. (Section 1, 1.3 The Behaviour Is Usually About Something Else; Objective 1.3)

2. Which of the following is one of the seven working issues that are almost always important with high-risk populations?

Shared benefits is one of the seven working issues in 1.2: the population at risk has a voice in the desired outcomes, rather than having its goals set entirely by a funder.
Rapid evaluation within the funding cycle is not a working issue; 2.2.2 treats the push for quick, measurable results as a source of bias.
Readiness matters in the Transtheoretical Model and in outreach, but screening before enrolment is not a working issue, and it would turn away people who are not yet ready (3.2).
Avoiding relationships contradicts the first working issue, building and sustaining trust. Confidentiality is a working issue, but it protects information within a relationship.
Correct answer: shared benefits. The information needed is the list in 1.2: building and sustaining trust, gaining access, finding the right way to communicate, a willingness to learn, confidentiality, honesty about what you are doing and why, and shared benefits. Screening for readiness is tempting because readiness matters in the Transtheoretical Model and in harm reduction outreach, but it is not one of the working issues, and anonymous data collection to avoid relationships contradicts the emphasis on trust. (Section 1, 1.2 Seven Things That Almost Always Matter; Objective 1.2)

3. Runaway youth interviewed in one ethnographic study believed they would not live beyond about age 25. Why is this example raised?

In 1.3 the runaway youth show that goals shaped by limit, threat, and mistrust change what counts as a risk. An infection that may take ten years to become AIDS competes poorly with immediate concerns.
The example is not about enrolling youth in risk-factor programs. It questions whether a health-centred view of risk fits their world at all.
The HIV and violence comparison in 2.2.3 rests on routes of transmission, not on the runaway youth. The youth show how a population's view of risk can differ from the agency's.
The example is not used to illustrate a single construct. It questions whether a health-centred decision model fits people who do not expect to live past twenty-five.
Correct answer: to show that a population's understanding of risk can differ sharply from the agency's. The information needed is 1.3: marginalized populations often engage in risk behaviour with goals tied to situations of limit, threat, alienation, and mistrust, so an infection that may take ten years to become AIDS competes poorly with more immediate concerns. The perceived severity option is tempting because the example concerns how serious HIV seems, but the lesson uses it to question whether a health-centred decision model fits at all, not to illustrate one construct. (Section 1, 1.3 The Behaviour Is Usually About Something Else; Objective 1.3)

4. Why has the need for measurable results within three to five years created a bias in the research literature?

The lesson does not call long studies less rigorous. Its claim in 2.2.2 is that short cycles favour theories that meet the shorter-term need.
Risk factors can be measured within a short cycle; that is the exposure model's strength. It is change at the outer levels that takes longer than three to five years.
The lesson says nothing about funders preferring harm reduction. The bias favours output theories, which meet the shorter-term need.
Section 2.2.2 explains that outer-level change is hard to measure and takes longer than three to five years, so the need for quick, measurable results favoured theories that meet the shorter-term need and biased the literature.
Correct answer: it favours theories that meet the shorter-term need, so the evidence base overrepresents what is easy to measure. The information needed is 2.2.2: most interventions have difficulty addressing outer-level factors and the interaction of factors across levels, measuring success there is hard, and the time needed exceeds the three to five years usually allotted to funded programs, so the need for quick, measurable results has biased the literature. The option about cost is tempting because long studies are expensive, but the lesson's claim concerns what gets funded and measured, not the rigour of long studies. (Section 1, 2.2.2 Why Programs Stay at the Inner Levels; Objective 2.2)

5. A harm reduction program for people who inject drugs distributes sterile equipment and bleach kits but says nothing, at first, about stopping drug use. What is the reasoning?

Harm reduction does not place drug use outside public health; ending use remains a longer-term goal. The approach sets an order of priorities.
The lesson gives no funding explanation, and drug substitution treatment is itself a component of such programs. The sequence is deliberate.
In 3.2 and Worked Example 10.2, transmission through shared equipment is the most pressing threat, and some people cannot quit soon. The nonjudgmental relationship then makes addressing drug use easier.
The Transtheoretical Model matches what is asked to readiness; it does not forbid talking about quitting. Someone in precontemplation about quitting may still be ready to stop sharing equipment (3.2).
Correct answer: the first priority is cutting off HIV transmission, and addressing drug use becomes easier once a nonjudgmental relationship exists. The information needed is 3.1 and Worked Example 10.2: harm reduction focuses first on the specific behaviours that pose the greatest public health threat, recognizing that some people cannot quit in the near future, and this does not mean accepting drug use. The Transtheoretical Model option is tempting because readiness shapes what outreach asks of each person, but the model does not forbid talking about quitting; it suggests matching the request to readiness. (Section 2, Worked Example 10.2; Objective 3.1)

6. Which statement about the outreach workers in a harm reduction program is accurate?

Section 3.2 says such programs employ people in recovery as community health outreach workers, and its three tabs show Social Network Theory, Social Cognitive Theory, and the Transtheoretical Model at work in their role.
Outreach workers are typically from the community and in recovery, not health professionals delivering the Health Belief Model. Their credibility comes from similarity to the people they serve.
Outreach workers distribute kits, provide education, and staff needle exchanges; collecting surveillance data is not their main task.
Outreach workers come from the communities they serve and are not police. Their role rests on trust and nonjudgmental relationships.
Correct answer: they are typically people in recovery whose role draws on Social Network Theory, Social Cognitive Theory, and the Transtheoretical Model. The information needed is 3.2: such programs employ people in recovery as community health outreach workers because they can relate to people who inject drugs knowledgeably and without judgement, and the three tabs show the network, modelling, and readiness mechanisms at work in that role. The option describing health professionals is tempting because it sounds more formal, but the lesson stresses that workers from the community are credible in ways that professionals are not. (Section 2, 3.2 A Harm Reduction Program for People Who Inject Drugs; Objective 3.2)

7. Two older drug users trade stories about how much they could take and still perform. A generative reading sees this as a schema of mastery. What intervention idea follows?

Graphic warnings argue with the behaviour and assume health is the object of attention. The generative move gives the mastery schema another outlet instead.
Removing the men from their network breaks relationships without meeting the need for mastery and status. The generative approach supplies alternatives that satisfy the same need.
In 4.2.1 the need for mastery, status, and stories to tell is not risky in itself. If the schema stays attached solely to drug use, stopping may leave nothing around which to build an identity, so alternatives are needed.
Reducing peer exposure returns to the exposure model and ignores the schema. The generative reading calls for other ways to satisfy mastery and status.
Correct answer: develop other choices of behaviour and identity that satisfy the same need. The information needed is the first fieldwork case in 4.2.1: the needs of mastery, status, and stories to tell are not unusual or necessarily risky, and if the schema stays attached solely to drug use, stopping might leave nothing around which to build an identity. Graphic warnings are tempting because overdose is the visible danger, but they argue with the behaviour instead of giving the schema another outlet. (Section 2, 4.2.1 Three Cases from the Field; Objective 4.2)

8. What does it mean to say that generative schema develop "within a framework of socioeconomic constraints", and what term is borrowed for this?

Schema are shaped by constraint, not determined by income, and the borrowed term is habitus. Socioeconomic status names a position, not how constraint shapes meaning.
Weighing costs and benefits is the decision-model picture the generative approach moves away from. Schema form within what is understood to be possible.
Treating schema as risk factors returns to exposure logic. A schema is a meaning a person works to carry out, and the borrowed term is habitus.
Section 4.1 says schema form within socioeconomic constraints, so a group expecting short, precarious lives values short-term gain and survival. Bourdieu called this integration of constraints, life patterns, and values a habitus.
Correct answer: what becomes meaningful is shaped by what is understood to be possible, and the term is Bourdieu's habitus. The information needed is 4.1: schema develop within socioeconomic constraints, so a group that expects short, precarious lives develops values supporting short-term gain and survival strategies, and Bourdieu called this integration of constraints, life patterns, and values a habitus. The socioeconomic status option is tempting because constraint involves income, but the claim is about how constraint shapes meaning, not that income determines schema. (Section 2, 4.1 The Generative Approach: The Meaning Behind Behaviour; Objective 4.1)

9. Which of the following best states the idea of a health trajectory?

This matches 5.2: historical circumstances produce vulnerability and exposure to disease together with the knowledge, attitudes, and practices that developed in response. Circumstance, vulnerability, and response together produce disparities.
The trajectory is historical and social, not genetic. It traces how circumstances produced vulnerability and a response.
A trajectory is not a set of stages toward Western medicine. It is the path history set a population on, including responses such as mistrust.
The thirty-year figure is the Heckler Report's lag in health improvement for African Americans (5.1). A trajectory describes how history produced vulnerability and response.
Correct answer: the combination of vulnerability and exposure to disease with the knowledge, attitudes, and practices that developed in response. The information needed is 5.2: historical circumstances produce a trajectory of health, and vulnerability, circumstance, and response together produce disparities. The thirty-year option is tempting because a thirty-year figure appears in the lesson, but that is the Heckler Report's lag in health improvement (5.1), not a trajectory. (Section 3, 5.2 A Trajectory of Health; Objective 5.2)

10. The 1985 Heckler Report identified six health issues as the major causes of disparities between minority and majority populations. Which option lists three of them correctly?

None of these appears among the Heckler Report's six causes of excess deaths (5.1).
Cancer, diabetes, and infant mortality are three of the six causes in the 1985 Heckler Report, alongside cardiovascular disease and stroke, chemical dependency, and homicide and accidents (5.1).
Epilepsy appears in the Lia Lee case, not in the Heckler Report, and none of these three is among its six causes.
These are familiar health issues, but none is on the Heckler Report's list. Its six causes are cancer, cardiovascular disease and stroke, chemical dependency, diabetes, homicide and accidents, and infant mortality.
Correct answer: cancer, diabetes, and infant mortality. The information needed is 5.1: the 1985 Heckler Report identified six causes of the gap between minority and majority populations, namely cancer, cardiovascular disease and stroke, chemical dependency, diabetes, homicide and accidents, and infant mortality, and found about a thirty-year lag in health improvement for African Americans. The option with obesity, depression, and low birth weight is tempting because these are familiar disparities, but none of them is on the report's list. (Section 3, 5.1 What Health Disparities Are and How They Became a Focus; Objective 5.1)

11. The original CLAS standards, issued in 2000, are organized into three themes. Which option names them?

These are three of THRIVE's four community clusters (7.3), not the CLAS themes.
Individual, community, and policy resemble ecological levels, not the CLAS themes. CLAS is organized around care, language access, and organizational supports.
Section 6.1 groups the fourteen CLAS standards into culturally competent care (Standards 1 to 3), language access services (4 to 7), and organizational supports (8 to 14).
Purpose, leadership, and evaluation are organizational characteristics from Table 10.3 (7.4), not CLAS themes.
Correct answer: culturally competent care, language access services, and organizational supports. The information needed is the three tabs in 6.1, which group the fourteen CLAS standards under these themes. The first option is tempting because it has a community flavour, but those are THRIVE clusters (7.3), and purpose, leadership, and evaluation are organizational characteristics from 7.4. (Section 3, 6.1 Cultural Competence and the CLAS Standards; Objective 6.1)

12. A nursing student says that after completing a cultural competence module she now "knows how Hmong patients think". Which response best reflects the critique made by Kleinman and Benson and others?

Basing a module on CLAS does not make trait knowledge accurate; the critique in 6.2 applies to competence as a checklist in general. Individuals within cultures vary.
The lesson does not dismiss cultural competence; it says competence matters but cannot be a checklist. Socioeconomic status is one contributing factor among many in 5.3.
Memorizing a fixed system repeats the checklist error, since cultures are not static. Lia Lee's family were particular people with a particular history.
Kleinman and Benson argue in 6.2 that individuals within cultures vary and cultures are not static, so competence cannot be a list of traits. What matters is how a particular patient experiences culture and health.
Correct answer: individuals within cultures vary and cultures are not static, so competence should not be a list of traits. The information needed is 6.2: Kleinman and Benson argue against learning a list of traits supposed to represent a culture and propose attending to how individuals subjectively experience the intersection of culture and health, and Lia Lee's family were particular people with a particular history, not "the Hmong". The option to memorize the Hmong ethnomedical system is tempting because that system mattered in Lia Lee's case, but treating it as fixed repeats the checklist error. (Section 3, 6.2 The Critique of Cultural Competence and Cultural Safety; Objective 6.2)

13. Which strategy is recommended for creating better access to health care or removing an environmental risk that affects a minority community, on the grounds that it also builds community capacity and empowerment?

The first tab in 7.2 recommends community mobilization and advocacy to create access or remove an environmental risk, noting that they build capacity and empowerment and can produce policy change, as at Grassy Narrows.
Individual counselling acts on one person's intentions. It neither creates access nor removes an environmental risk, and it does not build community capacity.
Drug substitution treatment is a harm reduction component for people who use opioids (3.2). It does not create community access to care or remove an environmental risk.
Collecting race and ethnicity data identifies disparities (5.3.3), but it does not itself create access, remove a risk, or build community empowerment.
Correct answer: community mobilization and advocacy. The information needed is the first tab in 7.2: to create better access to care or remove an environmental risk, mobilization and advocacy may be useful, they may increase the community's capacity and empowerment, the CDC Community Guide recommends mobilization for tobacco control, and policy change and improved access can result. Collecting race and ethnicity data is tempting because missing data are a cause of disparities, but data collection identifies a problem rather than creating access or removing a risk. (Section 4, 7.2 Social, Community, and Group Approaches; Objective 7.2)

14. In the CDC sociocultural framework, which of the following is an intermediate outcome rather than a determinant?

Equity and social justice is a determinant, the first in the framework's left column (7.3).
Natural resources is a determinant in the framework's left column (7.3).
Civic engagement and participation in decision making is the third of the six intermediate outcomes in 7.3. Intermediate outcomes are the community conditions that programs can actually change.
Political structures is listed under social resources, which is a determinant. It sounds like civic engagement but sits in the framework's left column.
Correct answer: civic engagement and participation in decision making. The information needed is the framework in 7.3: the determinants are equity and social justice, social resources (which include political structures), the physical environment, and natural resources, while the six intermediate outcomes are neighbourhood living conditions; community development and employment opportunities; civic engagement and participation in decision making; community customs, norms, and processes; opportunities for learning and developing capacity; and health promotion, prevention, and care opportunities. Political structures is tempting because it sounds like civic engagement, but it is listed under social resources, a determinant. (Section 4, 7.3 Multilevel Programs and the Pathway from Determinants to Healthier Communities; Objective 7.3)

15. One general barrier can prevent disparities from being addressed effectively even when purpose, leadership, and resources exist. What is it?

Language is a perceived barrier at the individual level (7.1). The general organizational barrier is coordination.
Section 7.4 names coordination as the general barrier: overlap, or organizations working on the same problem without communication or a consensus framework, leaving gaps nobody addresses. It persists even when each organization has the six characteristics.
Healthy People is the American goal-setting plan mentioned in 5.1, not the barrier named in 7.4. That barrier is coordination among organizations.
The lesson notes that national strategies get caught in politics, but the general barrier named in 7.4 is coordination, not disagreement about whether disparities exist.
Correct answer: coordination. The information needed is 7.4: beyond the six organizational characteristics, the general barrier is coordination, because so many organizations have roles that there is overlap, or organizations working on the same problem without communication or a consensus framework, leaving gaps that nobody addresses. Language is tempting because it is a real barrier, but it is a perceived barrier at the individual level (7.1), not the general organizational barrier. (Section 4, 7.4 Organizational Theory: Putting the Pieces Together; Objective 7.4)

Applied scenario for questions 16 to 19. A mid-sized Canadian city with a large Indigenous population and a growing community of resettled refugees has recorded a sharp rise in drug poisoning deaths, most of them among people using alone in private housing, and a persistent gap in prenatal care among newcomer women. City council has asked the regional health authority for one integrated plan.

16. Before choosing any service, the planning team asks what must be in place for the plan to work with these communities at all. Which first step best applies the seven working issues?

A perceived susceptibility survey is a Health Belief Model step chosen without the communities. It skips trust, honesty, and shared benefits, which come first (1.2).
Section 1.2 makes trust, honesty about what you are doing and why, and shared benefits preconditions for any program. Giving the communities real roles in deciding the plan's purpose, and being honest about funding and limits, applies them.
Choosing outcomes centrally skips shared benefits, the population's voice in the desired outcomes. Doing so to speed evaluation repeats the funding-cycle bias of 2.2.2.
Confidentiality protects information about people, not the existence of a plan. Keeping the plan secret violates honesty, under which the population knows what you are doing and why.
Correct answer: give the communities real roles in deciding what the plan is for, and be honest about its funding and limits. The information needed is the seven working issues in 1.2, especially building trust, honesty about what you are doing and why, and shared benefits, meaning that the population has a voice in the desired outcomes. Choosing outcomes centrally is tempting because it speeds evaluation, but it skips shared benefits and repeats the funding-cycle bias of 2.2.2. (Section 1, 1.2 Seven Things That Almost Always Matter; Objective 1.2)

17. For the deaths among people using alone, which pair of services sits at the "keep people alive now" end of the harm reduction continuum, and what do they leave for later?

Opioid agonist treatment changes the behaviour and housing changes the conditions of use, so both sit further along the continuum. Neither leaves nothing for later.
Managed alcohol and needle distribution make the behaviour safer but do not address overdose death among people who use alone. Overdose is the threat to address first, not later.
Abstinence-based treatment and employer drug testing are not on the harm reduction continuum. Requiring abstinence would make stopping a condition of help.
Interactive 10.2 places take-home naloxone and drug checking at the keep-people-alive end. They address death in the next few minutes and poisoning from an unpredictable supply, and leave the decision to use, and what is used, for later.
Correct answer: take-home naloxone and drug checking, which leave the decision to use for later. The information needed is the continuum in 3.3 and Interactive 10.2, where these two services address death in the next few minutes and poisoning from an unpredictable supply while deliberately leaving drug use itself for later. Opioid agonist treatment and housing are tempting because they matter for this population, but they sit further along the continuum, at changing the behaviour and changing the conditions. (Section 2, 3.3 Harm Reduction in Canada: A Continuum; Objective 3.3)

18. The Indigenous community's relationship with the health system was shaped by residential schools, segregated Indian hospitals, and documented racism in care. What does this trajectory imply for who should deliver the plan's services for that community?

The trajectory in 5.2 makes mistrust a rational response to history, and cultural safety in 6.2 asks whether people feel safe. Indigenous-led services from trusted people, in settings that do not carry that history, follow from both.
Reading mistrust as a knowledge deficit is the error 5.2 warns against. The main hospital is itself a setting that carries the history behind the mistrust.
A one-page trait profile is the checklist the critique of cultural competence rejects (6.2). It does not address power, history, or whether people feel safe.
A trajectory shapes the present: the response to history becomes today's pattern of service use (5.2). Who delivers services, and where, matters for that reason.
Correct answer: services should be Indigenous-led and culturally safe. The information needed is the trajectory of health in 5.2, which treats mistrust as a rational response to history, and cultural safety in 6.2, which asks whether the person receiving care feels safe and makes power and the system's history the subject of attention. The trait profile is tempting because it looks like preparation, but it is the checklist that the critique of cultural competence rejects. (Section 3, 5.2 A Trajectory of Health; Objective 5.2)

19. Two years in, federal, provincial, municipal, Indigenous, and settlement agencies are each serving some of the same families without talking to each other, and some needs are met by nobody. Which barrier is this, and what response does the lesson point to?

Interpreters address a language barrier at the individual level. Agencies serving the same families without talking to each other is a failure among organizations.
Nothing in the scenario concerns perceived susceptibility. The problem is agencies working with the same families without communication.
Section 7.4 names coordination as the barrier when organizations work on the same problem without communication or a consensus framework, leaving gaps. The First Nations Health Authority shows one accountable body as an answer by design.
Each agency already has a purpose, and another mission statement would leave them still not talking. What is missing is the link between agencies, which is coordination.
Correct answer: coordination. The information needed is 7.4: the general barrier is coordination, when many organizations working on the same problem lack communication or a consensus framework and leave gaps that nobody addresses, and Canada's divided jurisdiction over Indigenous health is the standing example, with the First Nations Health Authority as one attempt to solve it by design. A new mission statement is tempting because clear purpose is one of the six characteristics, but each agency already has a purpose; what is missing is the link between them. (Section 4, 7.4 Organizational Theory: Putting the Pieces Together; Objective 7.4)

✦ Pass every section knowledge check with 100% before submitting