Communications
Campaigns
Health Promotion: Individuals and Communities
Learning objectives for this lesson:
- Explain why the public media shape health behaviour, using identity models and observational learning, and how newer technologies have turned the sender-receiver path into a web of many senders and receivers.
- Define a communications campaign, describe its five elements, and explain why campaigns most often fall short on exposure.
- Apply audience segmenting, formative research, and sequencing to a campaign case, matching channels, pitch, and tone to each segment.
- Describe branding, the four-stage planning approach, the communications plan, and media advocacy, and explain what each contributes to a campaign.
- Classify campaign strategies using Hornik's individual, social diffusion, and institutional diffusion models and the newer virtual dissemination and networking models.
- Select theories and constructs to guide message development for a given population, and explain why a construct that suits one audience can fail with another.
- Compare the evaluation results of the National Youth Antidrug Media Campaign, the Truth Campaign, and Text2Quit, and evaluate campaign claims by the link they concern in the chain from exposure to behaviour.
This course was developed by Dr. Kiffer G. Card, to accompany Edberg, M. Essentials of Health Behavior: Social and Behavioral Theory in Public Health. Jones & Bartlett Learning. This lesson follows Chapter 11 of the text.
Glossary: Key Terms, People & Concepts
📚 Reference page, available throughout the lesson
This glossary collects the key concepts, people, and ideas you will meet in this lesson. Use it as a reference while you work through the material, or as a review before assessments. Type in the search box to filter entries.
Communicating Through the Public Media
⏱ Estimated reading time: 14 minutes
Overview
This is an application lesson. It takes health behaviour theories and asks how they are used in one of the most familiar forms of health promotion: the communications campaign. Before the lesson gets to campaigns, it pauses on a prior question. Why should messages in the public media change what anyone does? This section takes up that question. It sets out the argument that humans are creatures of communication and symbol, shows how media figures act as models through observational learning, describes the technologies that have reshaped communication since the 1990s, follows the shift from a single line between sender and receiver to a web of reactions, and ends by asking whether the media are a threat to health, a tool for it, or both.
Learning Objectives
- 1.1 Explain the claim that humans are creatures of communication and symbol, and why that makes the public media a storehouse of identity models that shape behaviour.
- 1.2 Explain how media models influence behaviour through observational learning in Social Learning Theory and Social Cognitive Theory.
- 1.3 Describe the roles the Internet, mobile and wireless technology, social media, and cable and satellite broadcasting have taken on in communication.
- 1.4 Explain how social media turn the sender-receiver path of communications theory into an interaction among many senders and receivers, and what that means for a campaign.
- 1.5 Distinguish the intended and unintended health effects of the media, and apply observational learning to a case in which the media are both a threat and a tool.
1.1 Creatures of Communication and Symbol
The argument starts from a claim about the species. As human beings, we are highly sophisticated creatures of communication and symbol, processors of symbolic information. By this we mean that people do not respond only to the physical world around them; they respond to what things mean, and those meanings are carried by words, images, gestures, and other symbols that are shared within a group. Communication is our primary tool in the basic process of interacting with other people, as it is for every social species, but the argument presses further. Human life is inseparable from the complex world that is represented, stored, transmitted, and altered through the range of communication processes we use. We live a life built around shared, and conflicting, meanings, ongoing social interaction, and group-related behaviour, much of which is encoded and acted on through the ways we communicate.
A deliberately small example makes the point. How do you know what clothing to wear at any given time? How do you know what is fashionable? Much of what you know comes through the communication of images in the media and through all the talk that occurs about clothing and dress. You know what it means to wear one thing versus another, and in which situations a particular kind of clothing will mean one thing versus another, or at least you know what it means for the social group you belong to. A behaviour that feels like personal taste turns out to be built from communicated meanings.
That is why the mass media, meaning television, film, video, DVDs, cable, the Internet, social media, radio, and print, have taken on such importance in contemporary society. What you see, read, and hear in the public media becomes a major storehouse of information influencing how you act, look, sound, and think about things. The language you hear, the patterns of social interaction you see, the way situations are presented and characterized, and the way symbols are used all shape your understanding of the world. People and characters in the media provide models for behaviour. The communication scholar Sheila McNamee says the same thing in a sentence: with a flip of the channel or a turn of the page, we have at our disposal an enormous array of possible identity models.
The next question is how, exactly, a figure on a screen becomes a pattern in someone's behaviour. Behaviour theory already has a name for the process.
1.2 Observational Learning and Media Models
The phenomenon of media models has a name. Social Learning Theory, and later Social Cognitive Theory, described observational learning, in which people model their own behaviour on the behaviour of others and on what happens to those others when they engage in the behaviour. By this we mean that people do not need to try a behaviour themselves to learn about it. They watch someone else do it, notice whether that person is rewarded, admired, ignored, or punished, and form their own expectations from what they saw. Two things are learned at once: what the behaviour looks like, and what tends to follow from it.
Media figures are a rich source of exactly this kind of learning, because they are seen often and by very large audiences. For example, models in the media help people develop an understanding of when it might be appropriate to use violence, or whether smoking is an attractive thing to do. A viewer who repeatedly sees an admired character smoke in stylish settings learns both the behaviour and its apparent reward, even though nobody set out to teach either one. In addition to watching others, people now take part. The mass media, especially the Internet in its many applications, can also be seen as a playing field for representing oneself and interacting with others. A person is therefore a viewer of models and also, increasingly, a model for other viewers, which means that ordinary users as well as celebrities supply the examples others learn from.
It matters to state the mechanism carefully, because a loose version of it is one of the most common misreadings of this lesson.
Common confusion: do the media cause behaviour?
Students sometimes read this section as a claim that a message injected into the media produces a behaviour in the audience. The argument here is more modest and more useful. The media supply models and meanings; behaviour follows through processes that behaviour theory describes, such as observational learning, expectations about outcomes, and the norms of the groups a person belongs to. This is why a campaign can be well designed and still fail, as the next section explains, and why the same image can carry different meanings for a nine-year-old, a sixteen-year-old, and a parent. Keep the mechanism in view: media influence works through observational learning and shared meaning, operating at scale.
The models people observe arrive through channels, and those channels changed dramatically from the 1990s onward.
1.3 Recent Technologies and Their Emerging Roles
By the early 2010s the traditional media, television, newspapers, magazines, and radio, remained important but no longer dominated. Four technologies were taking on new roles, and each changed communication in a different way, so it helps to take them one at a time.
The first is the Internet, which became, from the 1990s, a primary global means of both interpersonal and mass communication. By this we mean that the same network now carries a private message between two friends and a broadcast to millions, and that blogs became a major source of information and opinion alongside the traditional news. The second is mobile and wireless technology, which multiplied everything the Internet made possible by putting it in people's pockets. Its most important consequence for health promotion is that it became the primary communications channel for young people who grew up with it. The third is social media, which gave the members of a network constant, ongoing access to each other's lives. Whereas the Internet and mobile devices describe how messages travel, social media describe a way of living in a network in which everyone sees and responds to what everyone else posts. The fourth is cable television and satellite broadcasting, which, from MTV onward, created a global site for the dissemination of pop culture. The four cards below give a fuller description of each technology, with the examples and figures the text gives.
The Internet
Since the 1990s the Internet has become a primary, global means of both interpersonal and mass communication. Every major broadcast medium has a parallel Internet operation, and blogs became a major source of information and opinion. Email remained standard for work but was being eclipsed by text messaging and, for some purposes, Twitter. By one count there were more than six hundred million websites in 2013. Because so many media can be streamed, anyone with access can instantly see a video from across the globe or a photo posted in real time from an event, with profound implications for social and political engagement as well as for health communication.
Mobile and wireless
Everything the Internet made possible is multiplied a thousandfold by mobile phones, smartphones, tablets, WiFi hotspots, and whatever comes next. The photo posted online was probably taken with a phone camera and uploaded immediately, and the receivers are probably viewing it on a mobile device too. The constant and instant exchange of information through these devices forms the primary communications channels for young people who came of age during this period, a dramatic shift with significant implications for health communication.
Social media
Social media sites (MySpace, LinkedIn, and Facebook were the standard examples of the early 2010s) are designed for communication in groups or networks, so that members of a network have constant, ongoing access to each other’s lives, or at least the parts people make available. One way to put it is that Newton’s third law has gone ballistic: every action produces reverberating and linked reactions, where a post becomes the focus of comment, then comment on the comment, and so on. For communications theory, the sender-receiver path becomes a much more complex interaction among multiple senders and receivers.
Cable and satellite
Despite mobile innovation there is still a flourishing place for cable television and satellite broadcasting, including satellite radio. Even there, the array of channels far exceeds what people used to have. From the beginning, with MTV and other youth-oriented channels, cable created an entire programmatic style and a global site for the dissemination of pop culture, giving people around the world access to shared cultural symbols, language, and behaviour. But with so many channel options, people can also retreat into enclosed worlds as much as they can expand their worlds.
Two of these observations deserve emphasis because they matter for every campaign that follows. First, the constant exchange of information through mobile devices is the primary communications channel for young people who have grown up with it. The practical consequence is that the channel a planner chooses decides who actually receives the message. For example, a campaign that wants to reach youth through the evening news is in fact reaching their parents, because the parents are the ones watching. Second, an abundance of channels cuts both ways. On the one hand, cable and satellite gave people around the world access to shared cultural symbols, language, and behaviour. On the other hand, the same abundance lets people retreat into enclosed worlds in which they see only what they already prefer. That observation was first made about hundreds of cable channels. However, it applies with more force to feeds that are assembled for each viewer, where two people in the same household can live in different media environments. For a campaign, this means that no single channel can be assumed to reach everyone.
The card on social media raises a further point, about communications theory itself, which the next subsection develops.
1.4 From a Line to a Web
Communications theory traditionally described a path from a sender who encodes a message through a channel to a receiver who decodes it. In this classic picture, communication runs in one direction: a health agency (the sender) puts its idea into words and images (encoding), sends it by television or print (the channel), and an audience member takes the meaning from it (decoding). The purpose of the model is to show the points at which a message can succeed or go wrong.
The point about social media is that this one-way path is now potentially a much more complex interaction among multiple senders and receivers. One way to put it is that Newton's third law has gone ballistic. By this we mean that every action produces not one equal reaction but a chain of reverberating and linked reactions. For example, a message is posted, then commented on, then shared with someone's own commentary, then answered in a reply or a reaction video, and in the process it is reshaped. Each of those reactions is itself a new message with its own sender, and each reaches people the original sender never addressed. The receiver of the first message has become a sender of the next. Figure 8.1 contrasts the two pictures.
Figure 8.1. Above, the linear path of classic communications theory. Below, the picture of social media: every action produces reverberating and linked reactions, and each reaction is itself a message with its own senders and receivers.
Use Interactive 8.1 to watch a single post become a web. Click the button to post the message, then keep clicking to add each wave of reactions described above; the counters track how many people are now sending as well as receiving, and Reset starts again.
📊 Interactive 8.1: From one sender to many.
A public health unit posts a short video about sun safety. Add waves of reactions and watch the sender-receiver path turn into the web described above.By the last wave, most of the messages in play were written by someone other than the health unit. That is the practical meaning of the web for a campaign: the message you release is only the first of many messages about your topic, and you control only the first. It is also one more reason a campaign must know exactly which channels its audience uses and how that audience is likely to react. What remains is to ask what a health program should make of a medium that carries everyone's models at once, which the final subsection takes up.
1.5 Intended and Unintended Effects: A Threat, a Tool, or Both
A broader principle of health promotion applies here. Behaviour is action infused with intent and meaning, interconnected with the social and environmental spheres. The mass media are a major component of that social environment, and they affect the health of people in both intended and unintended ways. An intended effect is one that a sender set out to produce: a public service announcement is designed to change a health behaviour, and any effect it has on that behaviour is the effect somebody planned. An unintended effect is a health consequence of media content that was made for some other purpose. For example, a drama that makes smoking look sophisticated has a health effect that nobody planned, because the writers were telling a story rather than promoting a product or a behaviour. However, the mechanism is the same in both cases: viewers learn from the models they see, whatever the reason those models were put there. The question this lesson sets out to explore is how the media can be intentionally used to promote the public's health.
Canadian policy has long treated the media as part of the environment that shapes behaviour. Quebec's Consumer Protection Act has banned commercial advertising directed at children under thirteen since 1980, and the federal Tobacco Act of 1997 sharply restricted tobacco advertising and sponsorship. Both rest on the premise laid out in 1.2: images in the media act as models, so limiting the models is a health intervention. By this we mean that these laws do not try to change what children or smokers believe directly. Instead, they remove some of the images from which beliefs are learned in the first place. A child who never sees a cartoon character selling a sugary cereal, or a teenager who never sees a cigarette brand attached to a racing car or a music festival, has fewer attractive models of the product to learn from. The same premise runs the other way. If media models can make a product attractive, then deliberately placed models can make a healthy behaviour attractive in the same way. That is the wager every campaign makes: the mechanism that advertisers use to sell a product can be borrowed to promote health.
Everything in this section can therefore be read two ways. The media are a source of unintended health effects, because the models they supply were chosen by advertisers, producers, and other users for reasons that have nothing to do with health. They are also the largest set of channels a health program will ever have. Worked Example 8.1 applies observational learning to a case that asks you to hold both readings at once; as you read it, watch for the single mechanism that sits under both the threat and the tool.
Worked Example 8.1: Nicotine Pouches on a Grade 10 Feed
A school nurse in a Surrey secondary school notices that students are sharing short videos in which popular creators use flavoured nicotine pouches while gaming, joking about the head rush and showing the tins as part of their setup. Several students have started using pouches, and when asked why, they describe the creators rather than any craving. The regional health authority is divided. One group wants to treat the videos as a threat and press the platform and the province to restrict the content and the product. Another group wants to treat the same channel as a tool and commission videos from creators the students already follow, showing them declining pouches and being no less admired for it. A third group wants to do both.
Step 1, the behaviour and the population. The behaviour is starting to use flavoured nicotine pouches. The population is grade 10 students in one school who follow the same online creators.
Step 2, name the mechanism. The students point to the creators, not to a craving, so the best explanation is observational learning from Social Learning Theory, later Social Cognitive Theory. The students modelled their behaviour on the creators and on what happened to them in the videos: approval, a head rush, and a place in a setup other students admire. The creators are identity models in McNamee's sense, and the health effect is an unintended one, since nobody posted the videos to change students' health.
Step 3, read each proposal through the mechanism. The first group treats the media as a threat and works by removing the model, the same premise behind Canadian restrictions on tobacco advertising. The second group treats the same channel as a tool and works by replacing the model: a creator who declines pouches and is still admired supplies observational learning about the same behaviour with a different consequence. The third group's plan is coherent rather than a compromise, because both halves act on one mechanism.
Step 4, anticipate the web. A sponsored video can be recognized as a health campaign, mocked in the comments, and shared with commentary that reaches audiences the health authority never addressed. The authority controls only the first message. The way to find out in advance how students would react is to ask them, by showing draft videos to groups of students and asking whom they trust and what tone reads as patronizing, a step the next section introduces as formative research.
What the example shows. The threat and the tool are the same mechanism pointed in different directions. A common mistake is to treat the restriction and the counter-message as rival theories, when they are two uses of observational learning.
The example shows why a campaign planner needs to understand media influence before designing a single message: the mechanism that produced the problem is the one the campaign must use.
Carry two ideas into the next section, where the lesson gets to campaigns proper. The media matter because they supply models and meanings that people act on. And the channels that carry those models now form a web rather than a line, which is one reason a campaign must know exactly which channels its audience actually uses. The key takeaways and the knowledge check that follow review the section, from media models and observational learning to the web of reactions drawn in Figure 8.1.
Key Takeaways
- 1.1 We are creatures of communication and symbol: much of what we know about how to act, look, sound, and think, down to what counts as fashionable, reaches us through images in the media and the talk around them. That is why the public media are a major storehouse of information that shapes behaviour, and why people and characters in the media serve as what McNamee calls identity models. When an exam case describes a choice that looks like personal taste (a brand of shoe, a style of dress, a product shown on a feed), look for the communicated meaning behind it. The point is not that the media decide for people, but that the meanings people choose from are largely supplied by communication.
- 1.2 The process by which media figures become patterns of behaviour already has a name: observational learning, from Social Learning Theory and later Social Cognitive Theory. People model their behaviour on others and on what happens to those others when they act, which is why media models shape views on whether violence is appropriate or smoking is attractive. A common trap is to read the argument as saying the media cause behaviour directly; the stronger answer says the media supply models and meanings, and behaviour follows through observational learning, expectations about outcomes, and group norms. If a question asks which theory explains why people copy a media figure, the answer is Social Cognitive Theory (observational learning), not the Health Belief Model or the Transtheoretical Model, which the lesson uses later for message design.
- 1.3 From the 1990s onward four technologies took on new roles: the Internet as a primary global means of interpersonal and mass communication, mobile and wireless devices as the primary channel for young people, social media as constant access to a network's lives, and cable and satellite as a global site for pop culture. The practical lesson is about audiences: a campaign that tries to reach teenagers through the evening news is mostly reaching their parents. Remember also that abundance cuts both ways, since the same range of channels lets people share symbols across the world or retreat into enclosed worlds. When a question describes a youth campaign built on traditional adult channels, the weakness to name is a mismatch between channel and audience, not that television has stopped mattering.
- 1.4 Classic communications theory describes a line: a sender encodes a message, a channel carries it, and a receiver decodes it. Social media turn that line into a web of many senders and receivers, in which a post draws comments, comments on comments, shares with commentary, and reaction videos (Figure 8.1). Each reaction is itself a message that reaches people the original sender never addressed. For a campaign, the take-home message is that you control only the first message, so you need to anticipate how the audience will respond before you release it. If an exam item quotes the line that Newton's third law has gone ballistic, the point is the change in structure, not speed or a single equal and opposite reaction.
- 1.5 Because the media are a major part of the social environment, they affect health in both intended and unintended ways: a drama that makes smoking look sophisticated has an effect nobody planned, while a public service announcement has one somebody did. Policies such as Quebec's ban on advertising directed at children and the federal Tobacco Act treat the media as a threat by limiting harmful models; campaigns treat the same media as a tool by supplying healthy ones. Worked Example 8.1 shows that both responses act on one mechanism, observational learning, which is why removing a model and replacing it can sit in the same plan. In a case question, first name the mechanism, then judge each proposal by whether it removes, replaces, or adds a model.
1. A teenager starts wearing a particular brand of running shoe after seeing a basketball player wear it in highlight videos and hearing friends praise the player. According to the opening argument of this lesson, what is the best description of what happened?
2. Media models help people develop an understanding of when it might be appropriate to use violence or whether smoking is attractive. Which theory and construct explain this phenomenon?
3. A provincial health ministry plans a campaign to reach 15- to 17-year-olds through a series of segments on the six o'clock television news. Based on the discussion of recent technologies in this lesson, what is the main weakness of this plan?
4. One way to describe social media is to say that Newton's third law has gone ballistic. What point about communications theory does the joke make?
5. A popular streaming series shows its most admired characters vaping in stylish settings, and a provincial health authority separately runs advertisements showing young people declining to vape. How does this lesson describe the health effects of these two pieces of media?
6. In Worked Example 8.1, grade 10 students in a Surrey school start using flavoured nicotine pouches after watching creators they follow use them while gaming, and they explain their use by describing the creators rather than any craving. Which theory and construct best explain why the students copied the creators?
7. In the same case, one group wants to press the platform and the province to restrict the videos and the product, and another wants to commission videos from the same creators showing them declining pouches and still being admired. Which statement best describes the two proposals?
8. Before the health authority in Worked Example 8.1 releases its commissioned videos, what risk does the web of reactions pose, and how can the authority find out in advance?
✦ Pass the knowledge check with 100% to continue
Designing a Communications Campaign
⏱ Estimated reading time: 18 minutes
Overview
This section covers the core of the lesson: what a communications campaign is and how one is built. It defines a campaign and its five elements, and explains why campaigns most often fall short because they never reach their audience rather than because the message was poorly designed. It then works through a hypothetical obesity campaign to show how two audiences become four segments, how formative research reveals the channels and tone each segment responds to, and how the pieces are sequenced. It closes with branding, a four-stage planning approach from the National Cancer Institute, and the communications plan that documents the whole effort.
Learning Objectives
- 2.1 Define a communications campaign and describe the five elements of the coordinated process that produces one.
- 2.2 Explain why campaigns fall short more often because of inadequate exposure than because of poor message design.
- 3.1 Segment the audiences of a health campaign into groups that differ in what will reach and persuade them, and justify each split.
- 3.2 Describe formative research and use its findings to match channels, pitch, tone, and spokespersons to each segment.
- 3.3 Plan the sequence of a campaign, including whether to open with a kickoff event, and apply the five elements to revise a draft campaign plan.
- 4.1 Explain what branding contributes to a campaign, and why a brand needs to be tested with each segment.
- 4.2 Describe the four stages of the planning approach in Making Health Communication Programs Work and the contents of a communications plan.
2.1 What a Communications Campaign Is
A communications campaign is a planned process of disseminating messages to influence behaviour in a particular group or population, typically called a target audience, through a coordinated process. By this we mean three things. A campaign is planned rather than improvised; its purpose is to influence a behaviour rather than simply to share information; and its many messages are coordinated so that they work together on one audience. A single poster is therefore not a campaign, but a set of posters, news stories, events, and online messages designed together for one audience is. The coordinated process has five elements. The first is to identify key target audiences and the subgroups within them, which is called audience segmenting. The second is to identify the best communications channels for each audience and subgroup. The third is to determine the messages for each audience and channel, and the most effective way to present them in tone, language, and image. The fourth is to identify a sequence of activities, the specific unfolding of the campaign over time. The fifth is to use formative research with the target audiences to make sure the messages and channels will work. The five elements are not independent steps. Formative research supplies the information the other four depend on, since a planner cannot know which channels a segment uses or which tone it accepts without asking its members. Each element is described more fully below, including what counts as a channel and why formative research underpins the other four.
Within a target audience there are usually subgroups whose relationship to the behaviour differs. Dividing the audience into them is audience segmenting. By this we mean that the planner stops treating "adults" or "youth" as one group and asks which smaller groups inside it think, talk, and get their information differently. Segments can be defined by age, role, cultural background or language, region, or anything else that changes what a message must say and where it must appear. For example, parents and single adults are both adults, but a parent may care most about setting an example for children while a single adult cares most about an active personal life, so each needs a different message.
A communications channel is any route by which a message reaches people: a news broadcast, a blog, a social media feed, a note home from school, a pediatrician, a community event, or word of mouth. The best channels for each segment are found through research with the audience rather than assumed.
Messages are decided for each audience or subgroup and for each channel, together with the most effective format: tone, language, and image. The same objective can require a reassuring message for one segment and an irreverent one for another.
A campaign unfolds, with different activities and media products introduced over time to achieve the intended effect. Whether to begin with a kickoff event, which segment hears from you first, and when each product appears are strategic decisions.
Formative research with members of the target audience checks that messages and channels will be effective before the budget is spent on them. Almost every other decision in the list depends on it. This is because the planner cannot know from a desk which subgroups exist, which channels each one uses, or which tone each will accept. Those are facts about the audience, and the only reliable way to learn them is to ask the audience. A campaign that skips this step is therefore guessing at all of the other four elements at once.
Two points frame the definition. The first is that campaigns usually, and most effectively, combine channels, including public events and interpersonal communication alongside the mass media. For example, a parent may first see a story on the news, then hear the same idea from a pediatrician, and then talk about it with other parents at school; each channel reinforces the others. The second is that campaigns are most effective when they are heard and remembered against the din of competing messages, of which there are a great many. By the din we mean everything else competing for the audience's attention at the same time, from advertising to entertainment to the steady flow of posts in a feed. A health message has to stand out from all of it before it can do anything else. That second point leads directly to the most common reason campaigns fall short.
2.2 The Problem of Exposure
The din of competing messages leads to one of the most practical claims in this lesson. A major difficulty for campaigns is that they often do not adequately expose the target audience to the message. Exposure means that members of the audience actually encounter the message, and encounter it often enough to notice and remember it. The claim is that campaigns are less than effective because they do not reach their audience, and that the fault lies there more often than in message design. In other words, when a campaign fails, the more likely explanation is not that its message was weak but that too few of the intended people saw it, or saw it too few times. The claim, from Hornik's review of the evidence, reverses the instinct of planners who polish the message and give little thought to how many people will see it often enough to remember it. Interactive 8.2 makes the arithmetic visible; the numbers are illustrative, and the shape of the result is the point. Move its two sliders, which set the share of a segment of 100,000 older youth exposed to the message often enough to notice it and the share of those exposed who remember it, and then try the three preset buttons, which compare a polished message with low exposure, a plain message with high exposure, and both together.
📊 Interactive 8.2: Exposure and reach.
Your target segment is 100,000 older youth. Move the sliders to see how many a campaign reaches and how many remember the message.Whatever the sliders say about quality, a message seen by 15 percent of a segment cannot outperform a plainer message that most of the segment sees several times. Exposure is therefore a design variable. By this we mean that exposure is not a matter of luck that happens after the campaign is designed; it is decided by the planner's own choices of channels, of how often the message appears, and of the order in which pieces are released, as much as by the wording of the message. A planner who asks only "is this a good message?" has answered half the question; the other half is "will enough of this segment see it, often enough?" Reaching an audience often enough depends on knowing which channels each part of it actually uses, which is why the next step in planning is to divide the audience into segments.
3.1 Audience Segmenting: Two Audiences Become Four
Audience segmenting means dividing a broad target audience into smaller groups whose relationship to the behaviour differs. The purpose of doing so is to let the campaign say the right thing, in the right place, to each group, instead of sending one message that fits nobody well. The lesson's running example shows how this works in practice.
Here is a task: a campaign in a metropolitan area that will raise awareness among adults and young people about the need for exercise and better eating to address obesity, and convince them to adopt better habits. Is it sufficient to think of two target audiences, adults and youth? Probably not, because each of those groups contains people who think about eating and activity in quite different ways.
Consider the adults first. Adults who are parents think of their children as well as themselves and want to be good examples, so messages for parents should help them be those examples. Single adults, in contrast, may have more time to exercise, cook, or eat out, and their focus is on themselves and the quality of their personal lives. The same message would therefore land differently with each group. The youth divide in a similar way. Eating patterns differ between a nine-year-old and a sixteen-year-old, and sixteen-year-olds care about how they look in ways nine-year-olds do not yet grasp. Geography matters too: suburban and rural youth may have parks, while urban youth may have only a school playground, which changes what activity a message can realistically suggest.
Even this simple exercise yields four segments: single adults, adults who are parents, youth about 12 and younger, and youth about 13 and older. Other splits, by cultural background, language, or region, are possible. However, a split is not justified simply because two groups differ in some way. What justifies each split is a difference that changes what the message must say or where it must appear. When you are asked to segment an audience, then, the test for each proposed segment is whether it needs a different message or a different channel.
Segmenting tells you whom the campaign must reach. It does not yet tell you where to find each segment or what tone each will accept. Those answers come from research with the audience.
3.2 Formative Research: Channels, Pitch, and Tone
Which channels suit each segment? That is a question for formative research. Formative research is research done with members of the target audience before and during the design of a campaign, using interviews, focus groups (something like a group interview), or surveys. The word formative signals its purpose: it helps form the campaign, in contrast to evaluation research, which judges a campaign after it has run. The findings identify channels, the best tone for a message, themes to emphasize or avoid, potential spokespersons or influential social models, and the audience's knowledge and attitudes. Pause on the phrase influential social models and ask which theory it refers to: Social Cognitive Theory, since a spokesperson is a model for observational learning. Choosing a spokesperson is therefore a decision about whom the audience will imitate, and formative research is how a planner finds out whom a segment actually admires.
The research also shapes the pitch. The pitch is the angle from which a message approaches its audience, meaning the reason it gives them to care. Two messages can ask for exactly the same behaviour, such as eating more vegetables, while pitching it in very different ways: as a duty, as a way to look good, or as a way to be a good example. Which pitch works depends on what the segment already values, and that is what formative research uncovers. In the hypothetical, parents value being good parents, so information pitched as helping them achieve that goal may catch their attention, and hearing it again by word of mouth through parent groups adds a kind of peer pressure. Single adults respond to healthy diet and exercise as part of what active people do, and to a theme of newness. The two youth segments are harder. Younger youth do not want to be talked to like little kids; they attend to messages that are cool and fun, or that give guidance without being patronizing, and scare messages may have more effect on them than on older youth. Older youth blow off scare messages as transparent attempts to make them do what adults think is right. They respond to young people who eat well and are still approved of by peers, and to friends or admirable adults who are not trying to act like adults toward them.
The four tabs below set out what the research might plausibly find for each segment: the channels each one uses, what it thinks about activity and eating, and the pitch that follows. Open each tab in turn and compare the channels and the tone across the four segments.
Adults who are parents
Channels: health- and family-related stories on the morning or evening news and talk shows; blogs; communications from pediatricians and from schools; and word of mouth from other parents.
Findings and pitch: parents think of activity as exercise, know it matters for health, and value being good parents. Information pitched as helping them be good parents may catch their attention, and hearing it again by word of mouth, for example through school parent groups, adds a kind of peer pressure.
Single adults
Channels: health stories on the news and talk shows; blogs; websites and social media; fitness and lifestyle magazines and their online counterparts; information from work; and other single adults in activity-related settings.
Findings and pitch: single adults are most concerned with keeping healthy and being able to do a lot of activities. The pitch is healthy diet and exercise as part of what active people do, with a theme of newness, such as a new activity or food to try.
Younger youth, about 12 and under
Channels: parents; television programs, advertisements, and movies; websites and social media; teachers; celebrities; and older siblings.
Findings and pitch: young people do not think much about activity or worry about health; video games and social media take up much of what would be activity time. Younger youth do not want to be talked to like little kids. They attend to messages that are cool and fun, or that give guidance without being patronizing, a subtle balance. Scare messages may have more effect on them than on older youth.
Older youth, about 13 and over
Channels: social media, websites, and other Internet formats; blogs; television programs, advertisements, and movies; parents; friends and peers in similar activities; and celebrities.
Findings and pitch: boys and girls alike are very aware of how they look, and diet or activity matters in relation to appearance; some urban youth have nowhere to go but school playgrounds. Older youth blow off scare messages as transparent attempts to make them do what adults think is right. They respond to young people who eat healthy and are still approved of by peers, and to friends or admirable adults who are not trying to act like adults toward them.
Notice the pattern across the tabs. There is some overlap within the adult groups, since both parents and single adults watch health stories on the news, and some overlap within the youth groups, since both use websites and social media. Between youth and adult channels, however, there is very little overlap. This has a direct consequence for planning: a message placed where adults will see it will largely miss youth, and the reverse is also true, so the campaign needs separate channels for each side. A second pattern is that every segment's list combines three kinds of source: mass media, authority or admired figures, and interpersonal sources such as friends or other parents. For example, younger youth hear from television, from celebrities and teachers, and from parents and older siblings. A campaign that uses only one of these kinds of source therefore leaves out part of how each segment actually learns. Knowing each segment's channels and tone, the planner can decide what each segment hears first.
3.3 Sequence and Strategy
With the research in hand, you work with experts in social media, print, community events, news, and television advertising to design a package of messages and materials that fits the needs identified. Then you think strategy, and in particular about sequence. Sequence means the order in which the campaign's activities and products reach each segment over time, including what each segment hears first. It matters because the first contact shapes how the audience reads everything that follows.
For example, should there be a general kickoff event, such as a launch with officials covered by the news? Based on the research, perhaps not. Older youth might be alerted that this is a health campaign, which is exactly the signal that leads them to dismiss what follows. Younger youth might not pay attention at all. A kickoff would therefore serve only adults, who follow the news and are not put off by an official launch. For youth, a better opening is messages on websites or during sports broadcasts, the channels the research found they already use. The general point is that a sequencing decision is judged segment by segment: an opening that suits one segment can undermine the campaign with another. When the sequencing is worked out, you have a campaign.
Worked Example 8.2 applies the five elements, segmenting, formative research, and sequencing to a draft plan that skipped most of them. As you read it, watch how one missing element produces the flaws in the others.
Worked Example 8.2: A Vaping Campaign for the Fraser Valley
A health authority in British Columbia is planning a campaign to reduce vaping among young people in the Fraser Valley, a region of fast-growing suburbs, farming communities, and several First Nations. Its first draft names one audience, youth aged 12 to 18, opens with a launch event at a shopping mall with a provincial minister, and proposes one set of posters and radio spots warning about lung damage. A colleague objects that the plan skips segmentation, has done no formative research, and relies on a tone that older youth ignore. The budget is modest and the timeline is six months.
Step 1, the behaviour and the segments. The behaviour is vaping among young people, and the draft treats youth aged 12 to 18 as one audience. Following the obesity hypothetical, split them into youth about 12 and younger and youth about 13 and older, because the two groups use different channels and accept different tones. Add parents as a secondary audience, since parents were a main channel to younger youth in the hypothetical. A further split by community is justified in a region of suburbs, farming communities, and First Nations, where young people use different channels and admire different figures; work with First Nations youth should be planned with the communities and their health organizations.
Step 2, formative research questions. For each youth segment, ask which creators, apps, and friends they hear about vaping from, whom they would believe, what tone reads as patronizing, and whether they think of vaping as a health issue at all. For parents, ask where they get health information and whether word of mouth from other parents would move them.
Step 3, pitch and tone. A lung damage warning is a scare message, and older youth blow off scare messages as adults telling them what is right. The better pitch for them is peers who decline to vape and are still approved of. Scare messages may have more effect on younger youth, so the warning need not disappear everywhere; it needs to go to the segment it fits.
Step 4, sequence. A mall launch with a minister is a general kickoff. It alerts older youth that a health campaign is coming and passes younger youth by, so it would serve mainly adults. Drop it, or reposition it for parents and community leaders, and open the youth arm on the channels the research identifies.
Step 5, the weakest element. The draft is weakest on formative research, because it did none, and every other flaw (one audience, one tone, a kickoff) follows from that. The first task is focus groups in a few schools and with a parent group, before any poster is printed.
What the example shows. Segmenting, research, tone, and sequence are not separate items on a checklist; a plan that skips research tends to get the others wrong together. A common mistake is to settle the message first and leave the audience undefined.
The revision turned one campaign into several coordinated strands, each with its own segment, channel, and tone. Something has to hold those strands together so that the audience recognizes them as one effort, which is the job of a brand.
4.1 Branding
A big issue in applying communications theory is how to present the messages and the behaviour so that they represent something attractive and coherent across channels and segments. One approach from social marketing that has gained currency is branding. In commercial advertising, an advertiser links a product to an appeal attractive to a segment of consumers by creating a brand image that captures the appeal in a tagline, symbol, or personality. The brand is a shortcut. By this we mean that a consumer who sees the logo or hears the tagline grasps what the product stands for without wading through the details, and feels some of the appeal at the same moment.
Branding in health promotion borrows this logic by treating a health behaviour as the product. The task is then the same: to create a brand that links the behaviour to an appealing idea, so the population of focus can understand and take it up more easily, with the motivation of what it represents attached. The purpose of doing so is twofold. A brand holds the many strands of a campaign together, so that a poster, a video, and an event are recognized as parts of one effort, and it carries the appeal with it each time it appears, so that the audience does not need to be persuaded from scratch by every message.
Two Canadian examples show the idea. ParticipACTION, founded in 1971, made physical activity a recognizable idea for a generation, most famously through a 1973 advertisement claiming that the average 30-year-old Canadian was in about the same shape as the average 60-year-old Swede. Bell Let's Talk, launched in 2010 with the Olympian Clara Hughes as spokesperson, attached a tagline, a calendar date, and a personality to speaking openly about mental illness. Both are shortcuts in the sense described above, and both carry a caution.
Caution: a brand reads differently to different segments
A brand attractive to one segment can read as corporate or patronizing to another. For example, a cheerful tagline that appeals to parents may strike older youth as exactly the kind of adult voice they tune out. A brand also does not deliver exposure by itself or replace formative research. A memorable logo still has to be placed in the channels each segment uses, and often enough to be noticed, before it can do any work. Like any message, then, it should be pretested with each segment before it is attached to every product of the campaign.
Branding answers how a campaign presents itself. The next question is how the whole effort is organized, from the first plan to the final assessment.
4.2 The Four-Stage Planning Approach and the Communications Plan
4.2.1 The Four Stages
Thinking more systematically, the National Cancer Institute's guide Making Health Communication Programs Work, the pink book, describes a four-stage process for organizing a whole campaign. The first stage is planning and strategy development, in which the planner decides what role communication should play, identifies the audiences, carries out formative research, sets objectives, and plans activities, partnerships, and baseline surveys. The second stage is developing and pretesting concepts, messages, and materials. Here the research is turned into actual messages, and drafts are tried out with members of the audience before money is spent producing them. The third stage is implementing the program, which means beginning the activities, tracking whether the messages are reaching each audience, and adjusting along the way. The fourth stage is assessing effectiveness and making refinements, in which the planner judges what the campaign achieved and what to change next time.
The approach is very much like PRECEDE-PROCEED, a general planning model for health promotion programs, applied to communications. By this we mean that both move in order from assessment and planning, through design and implementation, to evaluation, so each stage of the communications process has a counterpart among the PRECEDE-PROCEED phases. The difference is that the four stages are written specifically for communication programs. Figure 8.2 draws the four stages as a cycle in which refinements feed the next planning round, and Table 8.1 lists what each stage includes and the nearest PRECEDE-PROCEED phase.
Figure 8.2. The four-stage process from Making Health Communication Programs Work, in summary. The baseline survey in stage 1 is what makes the assessment in stage 4 possible.
Table 8.1. The four stages of the process in Making Health Communication Programs Work, what each stage includes, and the nearest PRECEDE-PROCEED phase.
| Stage | What it includes | Nearest PRECEDE-PROCEED phase |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Planning and strategy development | Role of communications; intended audiences; formative research to set strategy and objectives; plans for activities, partnerships, and baseline surveys | The assessment phases |
| 2. Developing and pretesting concepts, messages, and materials | Relevant, meaningful messages built from the research; drafting; pretesting with members of the target audiences | Program design before implementation |
| 3. Implementing the program | Beginning activities as planned; tracking exposure among target audiences and adjusting; periodic review of all components | Implementation and process evaluation |
| 4. Assessing effectiveness and making refinements | Assessing the program and identifying refinements for future implementation | Impact and outcome evaluation |
Two rows of Table 8.1 deserve a second look. The baseline surveys planned in stage 1 are what make the assessment in stage 4 possible. And tracking exposure during implementation, in stage 3, is how a campaign discovers, while there is still time to adjust, that its messages are not reaching a segment, the problem described in 2.2. All of these decisions then need a single written home.
4.2.2 The Communications Plan
All of these decisions are documented in a communications plan, which summarizes the rationale for, elements of, and timetable for a campaign. Its purpose is to put every decision in one place, so that staff, partners, and funders can see why the campaign is designed as it is and what it will do when. The plan typically lists the campaign name; the agency; the health problem; the overall health objective; the communications campaign objectives; the primary and secondary target audiences; the formative research activities, purpose, and results; the messages by segment; the materials; the dissemination, meaning the channels, the materials by channel, and the rationale; the timeline; staff and resources; partners; and the evaluation plan.
Two entries are easy to skip and costly to omit. The first is the distinction between the health objective and the communications objective. The health objective names the change in health the agency ultimately wants, while the communications objectives name what the campaign's messages themselves are meant to accomplish with each audience. Keeping the two apart keeps a campaign honest about what messages alone can achieve. The second is the evaluation plan. Written at the start, together with the baseline survey from stage 1, it is what allows anyone to say later whether the campaign worked; written at the end, it has nothing to compare against.
This section has defined a communications campaign and its five elements, identified inadequate exposure as the most common reason campaigns fall short, divided the audiences of the obesity hypothetical into four segments, and followed the planning of a campaign through formative research, sequencing, branding, the four stages in Figure 8.2, and the communications plan. The next section turns to the theories that guide the messages, and to a kind of campaign whose target is policy rather than personal behaviour. First, the key takeaways and the knowledge check review this material.
Key Takeaways
- 2.1 A communications campaign is a planned process of disseminating messages to influence behaviour in a target audience through a coordinated process, and the definition comes with five elements you should be able to list: audiences and their segments, channels for each, messages and their format (tone, language, image), a sequence of activities, and formative research. Formative research feeds the other four, because it is how you learn which segments, channels, and messages will work. The most effective campaigns combine mass media with public events and interpersonal communication. In an exam, do not confuse the five elements with the four planning stages or with the contents of a communications plan; they answer different questions.
- 2.2 Campaigns are most effective when they are heard and remembered against the din of competing messages, and a major reason they fall short is that they never adequately expose their audience to the message. The fault lies more often in reach than in message design, which reverses the instinct to polish a message and give little thought to who will see it. Interactive 8.2 shows why: a polished message seen by few people reaches fewer minds than a plain one seen by most. When a case reports a well-pretested message that few people can recall, name inadequate exposure, and look for fixes in channels, frequency, and sequence rather than in the wording.
- 3.1 Audience segmenting divides a target audience into subgroups whose relationship to the behaviour differs. In the obesity hypothetical, adults split into parents, who think of their children and want to be good examples, and single adults, who think about themselves and an active life; youth split into those about 12 and younger and those about 13 and older, because eating patterns and concern with appearance differ by age. Geography, cultural background, and language can justify further splits. When you segment in an answer, justify each split by a difference that changes what the message must say or where it must appear.
- 3.2 Formative research (interviews, focus groups, and surveys with members of the audience) identifies channels, tone, themes to use or avoid, spokespersons or influential social models, and the audience's knowledge and attitudes. In the hypothetical, parents respond to help with being good parents and to word of mouth; single adults to what active people do and to something new; younger youth to cool, fun, non-patronizing guidance, with scare messages possibly effective; and older youth to approved peers and admirable adults, never to scare messages that look like adults telling them what is right. Remember that choosing a spokesperson is a Social Cognitive Theory decision about who will serve as a model. A classic exam trap is a scare message aimed at older youth; spot it and propose a peer model instead.
- 3.3 Sequence is the unfolding of the campaign over time, and it is a strategic decision rather than an afterthought. In the hypothetical, a general kickoff event may serve only adults, because it alerts older youth that a health campaign is coming and passes younger youth by; youth are better reached first through websites or sports broadcasts. Worked Example 8.2 shows how a draft that skipped formative research ended up with one audience, one tone, and a mall launch, all wrong together. When you revise a draft plan, start with the element it is weakest on, often formative research, and let the other decisions follow from what the research finds.
- 4.1 Branding, borrowed from social marketing, links a behaviour to an appealing idea captured in a tagline, symbol, or personality, so that people grasp what the behaviour stands for without wading through the details and take on the motivation it represents. ParticipACTION and Bell Let's Talk are Canadian examples. A brand does not guarantee exposure or replace formative research, and a brand attractive to one segment can read as corporate or patronizing to another. If a question asks what a brand does, the answer is a shortcut that carries motivation; if it asks about risks, the answer is that the brand must be pretested with each segment.
- 4.2 The National Cancer Institute's four-stage approach in Making Health Communication Programs Work runs from planning and strategy development, through developing and pretesting concepts, messages, and materials, and implementing the program while tracking exposure, to assessing effectiveness and making refinements; it works much like PRECEDE-PROCEED applied to communications (Figure 8.2, Table 8.1). The communications plan documents every decision, from the health objective and communications objectives to audiences, research, messages, channels, timeline, partners, and the evaluation plan. Two habits are worth carrying into any exam answer: keep the health objective separate from what messages alone can achieve, and plan the baseline survey and evaluation at the start, because without them stage 4 has nothing to compare.
1. A well-funded campaign to promote sunscreen use produced a message that scored highly in pretesting, but a follow-up survey found that few people in the target audience could recall seeing it and behaviour did not change. Which explanation does this lesson's discussion of exposure most directly support?
2. In the obesity hypothetical, why is the youth audience split into those about 12 and younger and those about 13 and older?
3. Formative research for a campaign identifies potential spokespersons or influential social models. Which theory does this phrase refer to, and why?
4. A health unit proposes opening its youth physical activity campaign with a large public kickoff event featuring local officials. Based on the reasoning about sequence in this lesson, what is the likely problem?
5. Which item in a communications plan is most directly responsible for making it possible to judge later whether the campaign worked?
6. In Worked Example 8.2, a draft vaping campaign for the Fraser Valley names one audience (youth aged 12 to 18), opens with a mall launch featuring a provincial minister, and relies on posters and radio spots warning about lung damage. Which of the five elements is the draft weakest on, in the sense that its other flaws follow from it?
7. The same draft warns young people about lung damage. Based on the formative research findings in the obesity hypothetical, which revision best fits youth aged about 13 and older?
8. A provincial physical activity campaign adopts a short tagline, a logo, and a recurring cartoon character across its posters, videos, and school materials. According to this lesson, what does this brand contribute?
✦ Pass the knowledge check with 100% to continue
Media Advocacy and Theory in Campaigns
⏱ Estimated reading time: 17 minutes
Overview
The previous section built a campaign aimed at what individuals eat and how much they move. This section adds two things. The first is media advocacy, a communications activity whose target is a policy rather than a person. The second is the central theory question for any campaign: which theories should guide a campaign's messages, and how do you tell? The answer comes in three parts: Hornik's three types of theoretical models, a mapping of familiar theories onto the obesity campaign, and a worked example in which a theory is chosen, rejected, and replaced as the audience changes.
Learning Objectives
- 4.3 Define media advocacy, state its three targets, and describe news outreach and the strategies and materials it uses.
- 5.1 Distinguish Hornik's individual, social diffusion, and institutional diffusion models, and the newer virtual dissemination and networking models.
- 5.2 Classify the Health Belief Model, the Transtheoretical Model, diffusion of innovations, social marketing, communications theory, culture theory, the social network approach, and targeting elite opinion by the model type each serves.
- 6.1 Explain why a message built on perceived susceptibility can fail with adolescents, and select an alternative from Social Cognitive Theory or culture theory that fits the population.
4.3 Media Advocacy and News Outreach
4.3.1 What Media Advocacy Is
Media advocacy is the strategic use of mass media to apply pressure to advance healthy public policy. By this we mean that the media are used not to tell individuals how to behave but to build pressure on the people who make policy. Its primary purposes are to influence three targets: public opinion, policymakers, and policy itself. Public opinion matters because policymakers respond to what the public appears to want, so a shift in opinion is usually a means to the policy rather than the end in itself.
The key contrast is with the campaigns in Section 2. An ordinary communications campaign tries to change the behaviour of the people who receive its messages, such as what a parent buys or whether a teenager vapes. Media advocacy campaigns aim at health behaviour change indirectly: they seek to change social institutions and their policies, and in doing so reach the environment that surrounds behaviour. For example, well-known cases of effective advocacy are smoking regulations such as clean indoor air ordinances, and increased funding for HIV/AIDS research and prevention. In both, the behaviour that changed first was a decision by a government, and individual behaviour followed from the new rules or resources. Like any communications effort, then, media advocacy begins with a goal, but the goal is the behaviour change of policymakers in a school, a city, or a state, on matters such as alcohol sales to minors, secondhand smoke, access to healthcare facilities in an urban neighbourhood, or the cleanup of polluted water. When you meet a case, ask whose behaviour the effort must change first: if the answer is a board, a council, or a legislature, the effort is media advocacy.
Canada's tobacco control record is largely a record of media advocacy. Groups such as the Non-Smokers' Rights Association and the Canadian Cancer Society spent decades supplying journalists with stories, human faces, and policy asks, and the policies followed: the Tobacco Act of 1997, picture warnings on cigarette packages from 2001, provincial bans on smoking in vehicles carrying children beginning in 2008, and plain packaging regulations in 2019. None of these was a message to smokers. Each changed the environment around smoking by changing the behaviour of legislators, the indirect route described above. Advocacy of this kind can run as a paid campaign or through the news, and the second route has its own techniques.
4.3.2 News Outreach
Media advocacy can take two forms. It can be a full-scale mass media campaign, with paid advertising to build public support for a policy or to move a vote. It can also work through access to the news media, which is called news outreach. The difference is one of resources and control: advertising is bought and says exactly what its sponsor wants, while news coverage costs little but is written by journalists, so the advocate must earn it and then shape it.
News outreach therefore has two steps. The first is to gain media access and adequate coverage, so that the public and policymakers know about the issue at all. The second, equally important, is to make sure the topic is covered in a particular way, shaped so that it advances public health. By this we mean that coverage alone is not enough; the story has to carry the advocate's point. For example, the story you supply should make the point that there are no healthcare facilities in certain sections of the city and the council is doing nothing about it, rather than merely reporting that some neighbourhoods are underserved.
Two strategies help with both steps. The first is to develop and maintain a relationship with news organizations. Because they work fast and go to known sources, an advocate who is already known to reporters is the one they call. The second is to provide information in a useful format: a headline with key supporting details, a story rather than an exposition, and a human face wherever possible, since a story about a real person carries a policy point further than a list of statistics. In addition to these strategies, news outreach relies on a familiar set of materials: press releases, letters to the editor, op-eds, presentations to an editorial board, interviews, and media events. The two strategies and the materials are described more fully below.
Strategy: develop and maintain a relationship
News organizations of every type often work fast, and they tend to go to known sources, or at least to sources they already have a relationship with. Making contact, providing background information, and establishing yourself or your organization as a source creates a foundation before you need it.
Strategy: provide information in a useful format
Broadcast and web-based media allot little time to any story, so package what you want reported with that in mind: a headline with key supporting details. The media are looking for stories rather than rambling expositions, and wherever a story can have a human face, showing its effect on people, so much the better.
Materials and activities typically used
Press or news releases to mainstream outlets and targeted blogs; letters to the editor; opinion (op-ed) pieces; presentations to an editorial board; interviews; and media events designed for news coverage and Internet dissemination. The American Public Health Association's media advocacy manual gives more detailed guidance.
Worked Example 8.3 applies the definition and the news outreach strategies to a local case. As you read it, watch for whose behaviour the effort really needs to change.
Worked Example 8.3: Smoke-Free and Vape-Free Parks
A coalition of a regional lung association, a parents' group, and two youth sports leagues wants a park board in a mid-sized British Columbia city to extend its smoking bylaw to cover vaping in parks, on beaches, and around playing fields. The park board has said it sees no public demand. The coalition has a small budget, a volunteer who once worked as a reporter, three families willing to talk about children exposed to vapour at games, and a summer of league play ahead. A member proposes spending the whole budget on a radio advertisement telling residents that vaping is harmful.
Step 1, the goal and the target. The goal is a change in the park board's policy, so the behaviour to change is the board members' vote. Public opinion matters because the board says it sees no demand, but it is a means to the policy rather than the end in itself.
Step 2, choose the form of media advocacy. A small budget, a former reporter, three families, and a season of games fit news outreach rather than a full mass media campaign with paid advertising.
Step 3, map the resources onto the strategies and materials. The former reporter is the relationship strategy in person: someone who can become a known source for local outlets. The families are the human face every story should have. Over the summer the coalition could issue a press release when it forms, place letters to the editor and an op-ed from a coach or a parent, arrange interviews at games where vapour drifts over the bench, hold a media event timed before the board's next meeting, and ask to present to the editorial board of the local paper. Each piece is packaged as a headline with supporting details and framed as children exposed at play, which is what shaping coverage in a particular way means.
Step 4, judge the radio advertisement. The advertisement aims at residents' personal vaping, an individual-level message, when the goal is a policy. It also spends the whole budget on one channel with no plan for exposure.
What the example shows. Media advocacy starts by naming whose behaviour must change. A common mistake is to aim a policy effort at the public's personal behaviour, which is the target of an ordinary campaign.
In the terms of the next subsection, the coalition is working on the longest of Hornik's three routes, from elite opinion to policy to individual behaviour.
5.1 Hornik's Three Types of Theoretical Models
Much of health behaviour theory is useful in communications and mass media campaigns. This lesson organizes that theory using Hornik's three general types of theoretical models, and then proposes a fourth. The purpose of the scheme is to sort campaigns by the route their messages take to behaviour, which is what each type describes.
Individual models focus on change in awareness, knowledge, and skills within the person. By this we mean that the message works directly on each audience member, one person at a time, by changing what that person knows, believes, or can do. Social diffusion models, in contrast, focus on processes of change in public norms, which lead to behaviour change among groups. Here the message works on what a group takes to be normal or admirable, and individuals change because the group around them has changed. The institutional diffusion model takes a longer route still. It emphasizes change in elite opinion, meaning the views of leaders such as board members, councillors, or the heads of professional associations, which is translated into institutional behaviour, including policy changes, which in turn affect individual behaviour. For example, if school principals resist a new obesity awareness component, a campaign that changes the opinion of key school board members might produce a local policy requiring schools to implement it, which would then shape the behaviour of principals, teachers, and ultimately students, without addressing a single student directly.
A fourth category, or at least a subcategory of social diffusion, is worth adding: virtual dissemination and networking models, which capture diffusion and uptake through social media, Internet video, and ultrarapid channels such as Twitter. These are close to social diffusion because they also spread behaviour through groups; the difference is the speed and the networked form of that spread online. The four cards below give a fuller description of each type and the obesity campaign example attached to it.
Individual models
Models that focus on change in awareness, knowledge, and skills within the person. The campaign’s message acts directly on what an audience member believes or can do. In the obesity example, the Health Belief Model guides messages that raise youth’s perceived susceptibility to consequences such as diabetes or that minimize the cost of preventive behaviour, and the Transtheoretical Model directs messages to the stage a segment is in: youth may be in precontemplation or contemplation, adults ready for action.
Social diffusion models
Models that focus on processes of change in public norms, which lead to behaviour change among groups. The message works by changing what a group takes to be normal or admirable. Diffusion of innovations and social marketing theory are highly applicable here, providing guidance on how to structure campaigns and on the processes by which people receive and implement information. Some specialized campaigns use a social network approach, spreading messages and alternatives to risk behaviour through close networks of individuals.
Institutional diffusion
A model that emphasizes change in elite opinion, which is then translated into institutional behaviour, including policy changes, which in turn affect individual behaviour. Campaigns that concentrate on reaching community leaders are targeting elite opinion, and media advocacy is often involved. An example: if school principals resist a new obesity awareness component, changing the opinion of key school board members or the leadership of a national principals’ association might produce local policy requiring schools to implement it, which would then shape the behaviour of principals, teachers, and ultimately students.
Virtual dissemination
A category worth adding to Hornik’s scheme, or at least as a subcategory of social diffusion. It would capture the special characteristics of diffusion and uptake that occur through social media, Internet video formats such as YouTube, and ultrarapid diffusion through Twitter and similar channels. New technologies are ripe for the application of theory: images and social models of behaviour can be disseminated instantly, and working through social networks for support or information has opened an entire subfield of study and practice.
The three models are three routes to the same destination, individual behaviour. Figure 8.3 draws them side by side. Notice that the further right you move, the longer the chain between the message and the behaviour, and the larger the number of people whose behaviour eventually changes if the chain holds.
Figure 8.3. Hornik's three types of theoretical models as three routes to individual behaviour. Virtual dissemination models sit within or beside social diffusion.
Because the routes are defined by what the message changes, one practical rule follows for classifying any campaign.
Exam tip: classify by mechanism, not by channel
A campaign belongs to a model type because of the route its message takes to behaviour, not because of the medium that carries it. A norms campaign delivered on social media is still a social diffusion model, and an advocacy story printed in a newspaper is still institutional diffusion. Ask what the message is meant to change first: a person's awareness, knowledge, and skills; a group's norms; or the opinion of the leaders who set policy.
With the three routes in place, familiar health behaviour theories can be sorted onto them.
HEAL connection: three routes, three places on the map
Hornik's three routes correspond to different parts of the HEAL Framework for Wellbeing introduced in Lesson 1. Individual models work on psychosocial state through reasoned action and learning. Social diffusion models work through acculturation, as norms spread through a group. The institutional diffusion model works on policy and on health and social systems.
A campaign that only urges individuals to change remains in the domains where inequity appears. A campaign with a policy arm reaches upstream, where HEAL places the most actionable lever.
5.2 Mapping Theories onto the Obesity Campaign
A wide variety of theoretical approaches can be mapped onto those general models, using the obesity campaign as the example. Mapping a theory onto a model type means asking which route that theory's constructs work through. The Health Belief Model and the Transtheoretical Model act on the individual. For example, the Health Belief Model guides messages that raise a young person's perceived susceptibility or lower the perceived cost of a healthy behaviour, and the Transtheoretical Model matches a message to the stage a segment is in; in both, the change happens inside each person. Diffusion of innovations, social marketing, communications theory, culture theory, and the social network approach, by contrast, act on how messages and norms spread through groups, so they serve the social diffusion route. Targeting elite opinion, often through media advocacy, is the institutional route. The same campaign can therefore draw on theories of all three types at once, each guiding a different part of the effort. Table 8.2 gathers the mapping, with what each theory contributes to the obesity campaign in the middle column and the model type it serves in the last column.
Table 8.2. Theories and approaches mapped onto the obesity campaign, with the type of theoretical model each serves.
| Theory or approach | How it applies to the obesity campaign | Model type |
|---|---|---|
| Health Belief Model | Guides messages for youth that increase perceived susceptibility to health problems such as diabetes as a consequence of obesity, or that minimize the cost of preventive behaviour | Individual |
| Transtheoretical Model | Directs messages to the stage of each segment and identifies the change process to emphasize; youth may be in precontemplation or contemplation, adults may be ready for action | Individual |
| Diffusion of innovations and social marketing | Highly applicable guidance on factors to consider in structuring campaigns and on the processes by which people receive and implement information | Social diffusion |
| Communications theory and culture theory | Highlight the role of channels, language, and the packaging, or encoding, of messages | Social diffusion |
| Social network approach | Used by specialized campaigns to spread messages and risk behaviour alternatives through close networks of individuals | Social diffusion |
| Targeting elite opinion, with media advocacy | Change the opinion of school board members or a national principals' association so that local policy requires schools to implement the program, which then shapes principals, teachers, and students | Institutional diffusion |
New communications technologies are ripe for the application of theory. By this we mean that the constructs already covered, such as modelling, social support, and self-efficacy, can be delivered through channels that reach a person directly and repeatedly, sometimes many times a day, rather than through an occasional broadcast. Several examples show this range. Email counselling had been used to change behaviours including weight loss and smoking. Internet support groups for women with breast cancer had been shown to reduce negative emotions, increase participation in health care, and increase information competence. Text messaging had potential to help people stay on track and quit smoking, which the Text2Quit example in the next section develops. Canadian quit services have followed the same path: QuitNow in British Columbia and the Canadian Cancer Society's Smokers' Helpline offer text and online support alongside telephone counselling.
Knowing which route a theory serves is not yet knowing which theory to use with a given audience. That choice is the subject of the last subsection.
6.1 Theory and the Development of Messages
What information should you communicate, and how should you package or encode it? These questions are informed by theory as it pertains to the situations and characteristics of particular populations. If you hope to influence behaviour in a group, your messages must have meaning for that group, which is what finding the right pitch meant in the previous section. The rule this lesson draws, as in so many other instances, is that the selection of applicable theory is very much tied to population and circumstance. By this we mean that no theory or construct is the right choice for every audience. A theory explains how a behaviour might change, but whether that route is open depends on who the audience is: their age and developmental stage, their culture, and what they already believe. The practical consequence is that the planner chooses a theory after learning about the audience, not before. A construct can be the obvious choice on paper and still be blocked for a particular audience, as the next callout explains.
The brick wall
Adolescents and young adults typically do not think themselves vulnerable across a whole range of health and other problems. A message that tries to raise perceived susceptibility may run into what we can call a brick wall related to the developmental stage of those youth. By this we mean that the message is not simply weak; it collides with a way of thinking that is typical of that age, so pushing harder does not get it through. The construct is real, because perceived susceptibility does influence behaviour, and the deficit is real, because these young people really do underestimate their risk. However, the audience's developmental stage blocks the route, so a message aimed at that deficit is unlikely to move them. Theory selection therefore has to respect the population, which means choosing a construct this audience can actually be moved along.
Worked Example 8.4 walks through the reasoning with the obesity campaign's older youth. It is the example the slides describe as a theory chosen, rejected, and replaced, and you should be able to reproduce its steps.
Worked Example 8.4: Older Youth, the Brick Wall, and the Peer Model
Recall the older youth in the obesity hypothetical. They will not attend to messages that seem to ask them, or scare them, into conforming to what adults think is right. Now suppose formative research shows that this age group does not think itself susceptible to obesity or its consequences.
Step 1, the tempting theory. A gap in perceived susceptibility sounds like the Health Belief Model, so the obvious message is one that increases perceived susceptibility. The answer is no, or at least not yet.
Step 2, why it fails. Adolescents and young adults typically do not think themselves vulnerable, so a susceptibility message runs into the developmental brick wall described above. It is also the kind of warning older youth already dismiss as adults telling them what is right.
Step 3, what is developmentally relevant. Adolescents and young adults in the United States look to peers for guidance on how to behave, so Social Cognitive Theory and its vicarious learning component fit. A message that employs a peer social role model to create value for exercise and healthy eating, without dwelling on scare tactics for the moment, may be more effective. This is still consistent with the Health Belief Model, because it plays up the benefits of the behaviour as young adults understand them. The construct has changed from susceptibility to benefits, and the mechanism from a warning to a model.
Step 4, change the population once more. Suppose the messages are for young adults from another country or culture, where the peer emphasis common in the United States is less important. In some cultures great respect is given to older adults. Culture theory tells us that people live and behave in subjective worlds of meaning, where behaviour and meaning are linked. By this we mean that the same act, such as going for a run or turning down junk food, can mean quite different things in different cultural settings, and people act on what it means to them. In one setting it may say "I fit in with my friends"; in another it may say "I am a credit to my family." A message works only if it attaches the behaviour to a meaning the audience already holds. If age-respect is important, and if young people are viewed as representing their family rather than asserting individuality, a common sentiment in many Asian cultures, then a message associating exercise and good eating with approval from elders and representing one's family well may be much more effective than a peer appeal.
What the example shows. Three audiences, three theories, one behaviour. The common mistake is to treat a deficit in a construct as proof that the construct should be the target; the better question is whether this population can be moved along that route.
Interactive 8.3 lets you run the same reasoning for yourself. Choose one option in each of its three columns (audience segment, theory construct, and channel); the workbench assembles a message strategy and rates the fit of each choice against what this lesson has said about that audience. Try older youth with perceived susceptibility first, then switch the construct to a peer model and compare the ratings.
📊 Interactive 8.3: Message-design workbench.
Choose an audience segment, the theory construct your message will act on, and a channel. The workbench assembles a message strategy and rates the fit of each choice against what this lesson has said about that audience.1. Audience segment
2. Theory construct
3. Channel
Make one choice in each column to assemble a strategy.
The workbench is a teaching device rather than a formula. What it should leave you with is the habit this lesson models: name the audience, ask what formative research says they believe and whom they listen to, and only then choose the construct and the channel.
This section has defined media advocacy and news outreach, set out Hornik's three types of theoretical models and the newer virtual dissemination models, mapped familiar theories onto the obesity campaign in Table 8.2, and shown in Worked Example 8.4 how the choice of theory changes as the audience changes. The next section asks whether that habit predicts which real campaigns worked. First, the key takeaways and the knowledge check review the section.
Key Takeaways
- 4.3 Media advocacy is the strategic use of mass media to apply pressure to advance healthy public policy; its targets are public opinion, policymakers, and policy, and it reaches individual behaviour indirectly by changing institutions and the environment around behaviour. It can run as a full mass media campaign or as news outreach, which has two steps (gain coverage, then shape how the issue is covered) and two strategies (be a known source before you need to be, and package information as a headline, key details, a story, and a human face). Canada's tobacco control record, from the Tobacco Act to plain packaging, is largely a record of this work. In a case question, ask first whose behaviour must change: if it is a council's or a board's vote, a message telling residents to change their own habits is aimed at the wrong audience, as Worked Example 8.3 shows.
- 5.1 Hornik's three types of theoretical models are three routes from a message to individual behaviour. Individual models change awareness, knowledge, and skills; social diffusion models change public norms, and groups follow; the institutional diffusion model changes elite opinion, which becomes institutional behaviour and policy, which then shapes individuals (Figure 8.3). Virtual dissemination and networking models, a newer addition or a subcategory of social diffusion, cover spread through social media and rapid online channels. Classify a campaign by what its message is meant to change first, not by the channel it uses: a norms campaign on social media is still social diffusion, and a school board strategy is institutional diffusion.
- 5.2 Familiar theories map onto Hornik's types (Table 8.2). The Health Belief Model and the Transtheoretical Model serve individual models, for example by raising susceptibility to diabetes or by matching messages to the stage of each segment. Diffusion of innovations, social marketing, communications theory, culture theory, and the social network approach serve social diffusion, by guiding how campaigns are structured, how messages are packaged, and how they spread through networks. Targeting elite opinion, often through media advocacy, serves institutional diffusion. When an exam item names a theory and asks for its model type, recall its row in Table 8.2; when it describes a mechanism, name the type first and then the theory.
- 6.1 Theory selection is tied to population and circumstance. A susceptibility message hits a developmental brick wall with adolescents and young adults, who typically do not think themselves vulnerable; Social Cognitive Theory's vicarious learning, through a peer role model who makes healthy behaviour valuable and is still approved of, is more developmentally relevant, and it still plays up benefits in Health Belief Model terms. Where elders are respected and young people represent their family, culture theory suggests that approval from elders and representing one's family well may work better than any peer appeal. The trap to avoid is assuming that a deficit in a construct makes that construct the right target; ask whether this audience can be moved along that route, and say which construct you would use instead.
1. A coalition runs a series of op-eds, interviews, and a media event to persuade a city council to require calorie labelling on restaurant menus. Whose behaviour is the immediate target, and what kind of communications activity is this?
2. A campaign aims to change what a community of young adults regards as normal drinking at parties, expecting individual behaviour to follow once the norm shifts. In Hornik's scheme, which type of theoretical model is this?
3. Formative research shows that older youth in a city do not believe they are susceptible to the consequences of obesity. A planner proposes messages that raise perceived susceptibility. What is the most likely problem with this plan?
4. A campaign for young adults in a community where great respect is given to elders links healthy eating to approval from elders and representing one's family well, rather than to peer approval. Which theory supports this choice?
5. In Worked Example 8.3, a coalition wants a park board to extend its smoking bylaw to vaping, and one member proposes spending the whole budget on a radio advertisement telling residents that vaping is harmful. Why is this advertisement aimed at the wrong audience?
6. The same coalition has a volunteer who once worked as a reporter and three families willing to describe children exposed to vapour at games. Which pairing of these resources with the news outreach strategies is correct?
7. Which of Hornik's model types best describes the park coalition's effort as a whole?
8. A planner says: "Our obesity campaign uses the Transtheoretical Model to send different messages to youth in contemplation and to adults ready for action, so it is a social diffusion campaign." What is wrong with this statement?
✦ Pass the knowledge check with 100% to continue
Program Examples: What Worked and Why
⏱ Estimated reading time: 16 minutes
Overview
The lesson closes with program examples: two national youth campaigns whose evaluations point in opposite directions, and a pilot of a text messaging program built directly from Social Cognitive Theory. This section lays out what each evaluation reported, works through theory-based answers to the question the first two campaigns raise (why did one succeed with youth and the other not?), shows how to read any claim of effect by the link it concerns in the chain from exposure to behaviour, and then turns the same lens on four Canadian campaigns. Throughout, the section separates what the evaluations found from what a campaign claimed, and marks where an explanation goes beyond the evidence.
Learning Objectives
- 7.1 Describe the National Youth Antidrug Media Campaign, the Truth Campaign, and Text2Quit, and summarize what each evaluation found.
- 7.2 Propose theory-based explanations for why the Truth Campaign succeeded with youth where the antidrug campaign did not, and explain why exposure cannot account for the difference.
- 7.3 Evaluate a claim that a campaign worked by identifying which link in the chain from exposure to reception, beliefs and norms, and behaviour the evidence concerns.
- 7.4 Analyze Canadian campaigns on tobacco and vaping, impaired driving, COVID-19 vaccination, and mental health by audience, appeal, theory and model type, exposure, and evaluation.
7.1 Three Program Examples
The National Youth Antidrug Media Campaign, funded by the United States Congress in 1998 and managed by the White House Office of National Drug Control Policy as a public-private partnership, was a coordinated, multi-component national campaign aimed at youth and parents. Its evaluation was mixed, meaning that it worked for one of its audiences and not the other. Recall of messages was relatively good for both groups, so the campaign did reach them. Parents changed: the evaluation found favourable effects on most of its parent measures, such as talking with their children about drugs, and the change varied with exposure, which means that parents who saw more of the campaign changed more. For youth, however, there was little evidence of effect, even though they too recalled the messages.
The Truth Campaign, launched in 2000 by the American Legacy Foundation, took a different approach to a similar audience. It avoided the ill-health effects of smoking and instead appealed to teens' need for independence by showing that the tobacco industry was out to manipulate them. In other words, rather than telling teens that smoking would hurt them, it told them that someone was trying to control them, and that refusing to smoke was a way of refusing that control. Its evaluations found evidence at several levels, meaning at several steps between seeing an ad and changing behaviour. Young people recalled the ads, so the campaign reached them. Their beliefs about the industry changed with the amount of exposure, so the message appears to have shifted what they thought. Finally, the campaign was credited with an estimated 22 percent of the 1999 to 2002 decline in youth smoking, which is a claim about behaviour itself.
Text2Quit is a different kind of example. Rather than a national mass media campaign, it is an automated, interactive text messaging program for smoking cessation that reaches each participant individually, and it was built directly from Social Cognitive Theory constructs. Its pilot with college students showed promise, alongside low abstinence and early drop-off, so it is best read as a promising design that still needed improvement.
The three tabs below give the detail behind that summary. Open each tab in turn; each sets out how the program was designed and then what its evaluation reported, so that the results can be read against the planning steps and theories of the earlier sections. In the Text2Quit tab, note the five Social Cognitive Theory constructs the messages were built on and the three pilot findings: the text function was used most, every participant made a quit attempt but only 14.3 percent reported not smoking in the previous seven days at four weeks, and almost half stopped responding to the program's text messages after their quit date.
A coordinated, strategic campaign at the national level
This was one of the most visible media campaigns of its time and a very good example of a coordinated, strategic campaign at national scale. Funded by the United States Congress in 1998 and managed by the White House Office of National Drug Control Policy, it was a public-private partnership: nonprofits such as the YMCA, Boys and Girls Clubs of America, and the National Education Association took part, and the Partnership for a Drug-Free America, a coalition of communications professionals working with pro bono help from major advertising agencies, developed the advertising.
Components: advertising on television, radio, print, and the Internet; news media outreach; websites for youth (Above the Influence), parents, and other influencers; entertainment outreach; multicultural outreach in several languages; partnerships with nonprofit agencies; and the @Work program for parents at worksites. Messages targeted youth and parents, to reach those involved in substance use, their peers and social norms, and the adults who could influence them.
Results, as the evaluations reported them: mixed. Exposure (recall of messages) was relatively good for parents and youth, particularly in recent waves. The campaign appeared to have a positive effect on parents, with favourable effects on most parent measures, such as talking with their children about drugs, and change varied with exposure; an effect on monitoring appeared only in the final survey round (Westat, 2006). For youth there was little evidence of effect: no statistically significant decline in marijuana use and only very small improvements in attitudes and beliefs between 2000 and 2004, no favourable relationship between exposure and change, and some evidence that youth with more exposure were later more likely to start using marijuana (Hornik et al., 2008).
One of the largest national youth-focused antitobacco campaigns
Launched in 2000 by the American Legacy Foundation. Rather than talking up the ill-health effects of smoking, Truth was designed to appeal to the need for independence among teens, reaching them in innovative ways and with cutting-edge style by letting them know that the tobacco industry was out to manipulate them through its marketing and manufacturing practices. The adversary in the message was the industry, and the behaviour on offer was defiance.
Evidence, as the evaluations reported it: substantial. Ten months after the launch, 75 percent of 12- to 17-year-olds could accurately describe one or more Truth ads, and exposure was associated with believing that cigarette companies lie and that taking a stand against smoking is important (Farrelly et al., 2002). The campaign was estimated to be responsible for 22 percent of the decline in youth smoking between 1999 and 2002, a finding from a dose-response study published by Farrelly and colleagues in the American Journal of Public Health in 2005.
A text messaging program for smoking cessation
Text2Quit is an automated, personalized, interactive mobile health program that sends text messages and emails timed around a participant's quit date over three months: pre- and post-quit educational messages, peer ex-smoker messages, medication reminders, and relapse messages. Users were prompted to respond and then received feedback and support for their goals, plus quitting tips on request. A web portal and emails supplemented the texts but were used less consistently.
Theory: constructs from Social Cognitive Theory. Messages sought to improve self-efficacy for quitting, describe outcome expectations, increase perceived social support, model effective quitting strategies and coping skills, and increase behavioural capability.
Evaluation, from the pilot: in a pilot with college students the text messaging function was used most. Participants found the program helpful, but perhaps not enough in its current form. All made at least one quit attempt, but only 14.3 percent reported not smoking in the previous seven days at the four-week follow-up, and almost half stopped responding to the program's text messages after their quit date, suggesting they had not quit and it was no longer relevant. The pilot showed promise and produced information for modifying programs of this kind.
Table 8.3 places the two youth campaigns side by side on the dimensions this lesson has used: sponsor, audiences, the appeal of the message, the theory implied, the channels, exposure, and the effects reported.
Table 8.3. The National Youth Antidrug Media Campaign and the Truth Campaign compared on sponsor, audiences, appeal, theory implied, channels, exposure, and effects reported.
| Dimension | National Youth Antidrug Media Campaign | The Truth Campaign |
|---|---|---|
| Sponsor and start | United States Congress and the Office of National Drug Control Policy, 1998; a public-private partnership | American Legacy Foundation, 2000 |
| Target audiences | Youth and parents, plus peers and other influencers | Teens |
| Central appeal | Drug prevention messages to youth; messages helping parents talk to and monitor their children | Independence: the tobacco industry is manipulating you |
| Theory implied | Individual models for youth (awareness, attitudes); parents as influencers of norms and monitoring | Benefits framed as autonomy; a social norm of taking a stand; branding with cutting-edge style |
| Channels | Television, radio, print, Internet, news outreach, entertainment outreach, worksites, multicultural partnerships | Mass media advertising with an innovative style |
| Exposure | Relatively good recall for parents and youth | Three quarters of 12- to 17-year-olds could describe an ad |
| Effects reported | Positive effects on parents that varied with exposure; little evidence of effect on youth; some evidence of later marijuana initiation among more exposed youth | Beliefs about the industry changed with exposure; an estimated 22 percent of the 1999 to 2002 decline in youth smoking |
Read across the exposure and effects rows of Table 8.3 and a puzzle appears: both campaigns reached their youth audience, but only one moved it.
7.2 Why Did One Succeed with Youth and the Other Not?
The question is left open, but the earlier sections supply candidate explanations. None is proven by the evaluations cited above; the exercise is to reason from theory to a testable hypothesis. Start by ruling out the explanation that most often accounts for campaign failure. Section 2 said campaigns usually fall short on exposure, but recall was relatively good for youth in the antidrug campaign, and the evaluation found no favourable relationship between exposure and change. When a campaign reaches its audience and still does not move it, the problem lies in the message and its fit with the audience.
Two theory-based explanations then carry the weight. The first concerns the pitch, meaning the angle from which a message approaches its audience. Older youth, in the formative research from the obesity hypothetical, blow off messages that look like adults making them do what adults think is right, and a government antidrug campaign announces exactly that source. Truth turned the pitch around. In its messages the adults manipulating young people are the tobacco industry, and refusing to smoke is the independent act. The same refusal that looked like obedience in one campaign looks like defiance in the other.
The second explanation concerns the construct, meaning the belief a message tries to change. Warnings about consequences work on perceived susceptibility and severity, the route that hits a brick wall with adolescents because they do not think themselves vulnerable. Truth, however, offered a benefit young people already valued, independence, and a norm, that taking a stand matters, and the evaluation found those beliefs changed with exposure. The two explanations are related but not the same: the pitch is about who seems to be speaking and why, while the construct is about which belief the message works on. The four explanations are set out below in turn, including a possible boomerang effect in the antidrug campaign.
The pitch: what adults think is right, versus independence
Older youth, in the formative research from the obesity hypothetical, blow off messages that look like adults making them do what adults think is right. A government antidrug campaign announces its source. Truth turned the pitch around: the adults manipulating you are the tobacco industry, and refusing to smoke is the independent act. The behaviour requested aligned with the audience's developmental need.
The construct: susceptibility versus benefits and norms
Warnings about consequences work on perceived susceptibility and severity, the route that hits a brick wall with adolescents. Truth avoided ill-health effects and offered a benefit young people already valued, independence, and a norm, that taking a stand matters, which the evaluation found changed with exposure. This is the Social Cognitive Theory and social diffusion route recommended for this audience in the previous section.
The boomerang: when exposure runs the wrong way
The evaluation reported some evidence that youth with more exposure to the antidrug ads later held weaker antidrug norms and were more likely to start using marijuana (Hornik et al., 2008). A boomerang effect is a result that runs opposite to the one a message intended. One theory-based reading offers two possible routes. The first is that heavy advertising about a behaviour can signal that it is common. If a young person sees anti-marijuana ads everywhere, she may conclude that many of her peers must be using it, which moves perceived norms the wrong way. The second is reactance, meaning the urge to resist when someone seems to be limiting our freedom to choose. An audience that resents being told what to do may respond to a forceful warning by doing the opposite. This is a hypothesis rather than a finding, but it is the kind of unintended effect Section 1 warned about.
What exposure cannot explain
Section 2 said campaigns usually fail on exposure. Here that does not fit: recall was relatively good for youth in the antidrug campaign, and the evaluation found no favourable relationship between exposure and change. When a campaign reaches its audience and still does not move it, the problem is the message and its fit, which is why the explanations above carry the weight.
The boomerang item is a hypothesis about an unintended effect, the kind Section 1 warned about, rather than a finding. Whether any of these explanations holds depends on what each evaluation actually measured, which is the subject of the next subsection.
7.3 Reading a Campaign Evaluation
The three evaluations measure different links in the same chain, drawn in Figure 8.4. The chain describes the order in which a campaign has to succeed. First comes exposure: can people recall the ad? Next comes reception: did those who saw it find it convincing? Then come beliefs and norms: do people's beliefs, or their sense of what is normal, shift with the dose of exposure? Last comes behaviour: reported use or quitting. Each link depends on the ones before it, since nobody can be convinced by an ad they never saw, but success at an early link does not guarantee success at a later one.
For example, the antidrug campaign succeeded at the first link with youth, because they recalled its messages, and yet showed little change at the last. A claim that a campaign worked is therefore only as strong as the link its evidence reaches. A further point concerns the phrase "with the dose". When a change is larger among people who saw more of the campaign, the evaluation has found a dose-response relationship, and that is stronger evidence than recall alone or a judgement that an ad was convincing. The reasoning is the same as for a medicine: if the campaign is really causing the change, then people who received more of it should change more, and people who received little should change little. Recall shows only that people saw the ad, and a judgement that it was convincing shows only that they liked it. A dose-response pattern, by contrast, links the amount of the campaign to the amount of change, which is much harder to explain away. For example, Truth found that beliefs about the tobacco industry shifted more among teens with more exposure, while the antidrug campaign found no favourable relationship among youth. The chain is worth memorizing as a checklist for reading any claim of success.
How to read a claim that a campaign worked
Recall of an ad is evidence of exposure and nothing more. Saying an ad was convincing is a belief about the ad. A change in beliefs that varies with exposure is a dose-response relationship, which is stronger evidence. A change in reported use is the outcome, and it is self-reported. This matters because people answering a survey about drug use or smoking may under-report it, especially after a campaign has told them it is unwelcome. When you read that a campaign worked, ask which link the evidence concerns, whether it varied with exposure, and whether anything else changed at the same time (prices, laws, other campaigns).
Figure 8.4. The evaluation chain from exposure (can they recall the ad?) through reception (was it convincing?) and beliefs and norms (do they shift with dose?) to behaviour (reported use or quitting), with a finding from the antidrug or Truth evaluation under each link.
Exposure cannot explain the difference between the two youth campaigns, and each claim about their effects concerns a particular link in the chain of Figure 8.4. The next subsection reads four Canadian campaigns in the same way.
7.4 Canadian Campaigns Through the Same Lens
Each case below is a real Canadian communications effort described in general terms, set out as a worked example that applies the lens of this lesson: the audience, the appeal, the theory and model type, the channels, and what an evaluation would need to show. Where a case makes no claim about effects, that is deliberate. Worked Example 8.5 covers tobacco and vaping messages from Health Canada; as you read it, watch which Health Belief Model constructs each message acts on, and for which audience.
Worked Example 8.5: Tobacco and Vaping Messages from Health Canada
Canada was the first country to require picture-based health warnings on cigarette packages, in 2001, a message every smoker sees at every purchase. A decade later, Health Canada and the Canadian Cancer Society ran Break It Off, a campaign for young adults that framed quitting as ending a bad relationship. More recently, Health Canada's Consider the Consequences of Vaping campaign has aimed at teens and their parents through paid advertising, school activities, and online material.
Step 1, the package warnings. A photograph of diseased tissue and a statement of what smoking does to the body act on perceived severity and perceived susceptibility, Health Belief Model constructs, and exposure is built in because every smoker sees the warning at every purchase. The route is most likely to fail with adolescents and young adults, who typically do not think themselves vulnerable: the brick wall from Section 3.
Step 2, Break It Off. Framing quitting as ending a bad relationship moves away from consequences and toward the benefits of quitting, described in terms young adults already use about their own lives. Like Truth, the campaign changes the construct for a young audience rather than pressing harder on susceptibility.
Step 3, the vaping campaign. Aiming at teens and their parents through advertising, schools, and online material is segmenting with parents as a second audience, much as the antidrug campaign did. A name that stresses consequences invites the questions this lesson has raised: formative research should check whether teens hear it as adults telling them what is right, and an evaluation should show more than recall.
What the example shows. Within one policy area, different messages act on different constructs, and the audience decides which construct a message should use.
The tobacco example turned on choosing a construct for each audience. Worked Example 8.6 turns to impaired driving, where two arms of one effort act on different beliefs and reach different segments.
Worked Example 8.6: Impaired Driving
Roadcheck programs such as British Columbia's CounterAttack and Ontario's RIDE, dating from the late 1970s, are heavily publicized before holiday periods, so the message is that checks are frequent and you may be stopped. MADD Canada's Project Red Ribbon campaign each winter asks drivers to display a ribbon as a pledge to drive sober, and MADD's school presentations feature the stories of victims and their families. The two arms work on different beliefs.
Step 1, publicized enforcement. The publicity raises the perceived chance of a consequence that drivers do feel susceptible to, being stopped and charged, and the seasonal timing works as a cue to action. A cue to action, in the Health Belief Model, is a prompt that moves a person from believing something to acting on it at a particular moment. Here the reminder that checks are under way, arriving just as people are heading to holiday parties, is that prompt. This is the susceptibility route aimed at a consequence the audience actually believes in. The contrast with a warning about crashes is useful: a driver may doubt that a crash will happen to them, but can readily believe they might be pulled over at a roadcheck that has been advertised all week.
Step 2, the red ribbon. A ribbon on thousands of cars makes sober driving a visible public norm. In Hornik's scheme that is a social diffusion route: change what the group sees as normal, and behaviour follows.
Step 3, the segments. The enforcement message is aimed at drivers who already drink, or might drink, and drive. The school presentations reach students who are not yet drivers, through the stories of victims and families, which supply models and meaning rather than a threat of arrest. Different segments, different channels, different constructs.
What the example shows. A single effort can run on more than one model type at once, each matched to a segment.
Worked Example 8.7 takes the question of who delivers a message, which mattered more during COVID-19 vaccination than in any other case here.
Worked Example 8.7: COVID-19 Vaccination Communication
During the 2021 rollout, the Public Health Agency of Canada ran multilingual advertising, while other efforts took different routes. This Is Our Shot, organized by physicians and other health workers with corporate partners, recruited well-known Canadians and local clinicians to speak for vaccination in their own communities. Provincial and Indigenous health authorities, including the First Nations Health Authority in British Columbia, worked with community leaders, Elders, and local clinics. Surveys during the rollout consistently found that people trusted their own health care providers more than distant sources.
Step 1, sort the efforts by model type. National multilingual advertising is mainly an individual-model route, informing people in their own languages. This Is Our Shot works by showing admired and familiar people choosing vaccination, a social diffusion route that changes what looks normal in a community. Work with community leaders, Elders, and local clinics also reaches people through the leaders their communities already follow.
Step 2, name the theories behind the messengers. Treating a well-known Canadian or a local clinician as a spokesperson is a Social Cognitive Theory decision about who will serve as a model. Matching messengers to a community's own meanings, as the work with Elders does, relies on culture theory. The survey finding that people trusted their own providers most supports both choices.
Step 3, the web of reactions. Vaccination was discussed intensely during the rollout, so any message released into the web of senders and receivers from Section 1 was answered, reshared, and reframed by others. A campaign controls only its first message, which is why trusted messengers inside each community, who are part of the web rather than outside it, matter more here than in the other cases.
What the example shows. Choosing the messenger is a theoretical decision, and the right messenger differs by community.
The last case is the one Section 2 introduced as a brand, and it is the clearest test of the evaluation chain from 7.3. Worked Example 8.8 asks what evidence a claim about stigma would need.
Worked Example 8.8: Bell Let's Talk
Launched in 2010 with the Olympian Clara Hughes as its first spokesperson, Bell Let's Talk attached a corporate brand, an annual day, and a tagline to a behaviour: talking openly about mental illness. Public figures described their own experiences on television and online, and the public was asked to share messages, each triggering a donation to mental health programs. Critics have argued that a telecommunications brand should not stand between people and mental health care, and that the campaign's reach was easier to measure than its effect on stigma or help-seeking.
Step 1, the model type. The campaign's logic is a change in public norms, so that talking about mental illness becomes ordinary: Hornik's social diffusion type, packaged as a brand.
Step 2, the role of the public figures. In Social Cognitive Theory terms the public figures are models for observational learning. Viewers see admired people describe mental illness and remain admired, which is the consequence the campaign wants others to expect for themselves.
Step 3, the evaluation chain. Messages shared and viewers reached are evidence of exposure, the first link. A claim that the campaign reduced stigma concerns the beliefs and norms link, and a claim about help-seeking concerns behaviour. The evidence needed is a change in stigma measures or in help-seeking that varies with exposure to the campaign, measured against a baseline, with attention to whatever else changed in the same years.
What the example shows. Without that evidence, the accurate statement is that the campaign achieved wide exposure and changed what public figures model, while its effect on stigma remains to be shown. Reach and effect are different claims.
Interactive 8.4 asks you to do quickly what this lesson has done slowly: read a campaign's central move and name the construct or model it acts on. It presents ten items one at a time, drawn from the campaigns in this section and the previous one. Choose an answer, read the feedback, which explains the reasoning, and press Next; Restart lets you try the set again.
📊 Interactive 8.4: Spot the construct.
Read the campaign's central move and choose the construct or model it acts on. The feedback explains the reasoning and, where it applies, what this lesson has said about the audience.You have now seen the whole arc of the lesson: why the media matter, how a campaign is planned, which theories guide its messages and its advocacy, and what evaluations of real campaigns have found. The key takeaways and knowledge check that follow review the three program examples, the evaluation chain in Figure 8.4, and the Canadian cases, and the final review then brings the pieces together.
Key Takeaways
- 7.1 The National Youth Antidrug Media Campaign (funded by Congress in 1998, managed by the Office of National Drug Control Policy as a public-private partnership) was a coordinated, multi-component campaign aimed at youth and parents, with mixed results: good recall, a positive effect on parents that varied with exposure, and little evidence of effect on youth. The Truth Campaign (American Legacy Foundation, 2000) appealed to teens' need for independence by exposing industry manipulation, and its evaluations found high recall, beliefs that changed with exposure, and an estimated 22 percent of the 1999 to 2002 decline in youth smoking. Text2Quit delivered Social Cognitive Theory constructs (self-efficacy, outcome expectations, social support, modelled quitting strategies and coping skills, behavioural capability) through timed, interactive texts; in its pilot every participant tried to quit, only 14.3 percent were abstinent at four weeks, and almost half stopped using it after their quit date. Keep the details attached to the right program: parents changed in the antidrug campaign, beliefs about the industry changed in Truth, and disengagement after a failed quit date is the Text2Quit lesson.
- 7.2 The difference between the two youth campaigns cannot be explained by exposure, because recall was good in both and the antidrug evaluation found no favourable relationship between exposure and change among youth. The explanations that fit come from earlier sections: the pitch (older youth reject what looks like adults telling them what is right, while Truth made the industry the manipulating adult and refusal the independent act) and the construct (warnings act on susceptibility and severity, which hit the developmental brick wall, while Truth offered a benefit and a norm). These are hypotheses from theory rather than findings, and a possible boomerang among more exposed youth is one more reason to pretest. In an answer, first rule out exposure with the evidence, then name the construct and the formative research finding that support each explanation.
- 7.3 Every claim that a campaign worked concerns a particular link in the chain from exposure (can people recall the ad?) to reception (was it convincing?), to beliefs and norms (do they shift with the dose of exposure?), to behaviour (reported use or quitting), as Figure 8.4 shows. Recall is evidence of exposure and nothing more; a change that rises with exposure is a dose-response relationship and stronger evidence; reported behaviour is the outcome but is self-reported. When someone says that shares, views, or recall prove a campaign changed attitudes or behaviour, answer that the evidence concerns exposure only, and ask for change in beliefs or behaviour that varies with exposure, measured against a baseline, with attention to anything else that changed at the same time.
- 7.4 The same lens reads Canadian campaigns. Picture warnings on cigarette packages act on perceived severity and susceptibility, while Break It Off reframed quitting for young adults; publicized roadchecks raise the perceived chance of being stopped, while MADD's red ribbons make sober driving a visible norm; COVID-19 vaccination communication relied on trusted local messengers, Elders, and community leaders; and Bell Let's Talk used a brand, a day, and public figures as models to change a norm about talking about mental illness. For any such case, name the audience, the construct or model type, and the link of the evaluation chain the evidence concerns. The habit to practise is keeping reach and effect apart, since reach is usually the easiest thing to show.
1. An evaluation finds that most youth can recall a campaign's ads, yet reported drug use has not changed and youth with more exposure are no more changed than those with less. Which conclusion is best supported by the evaluation of the National Youth Antidrug Media Campaign?
2. The Truth Campaign chose to tell teens that the tobacco industry was manipulating them rather than to emphasize the health effects of smoking. Which finding about older youth does this strategy respond to most directly?
3. Text2Quit's messages aimed to improve self-efficacy for quitting, describe outcome expectations, increase perceived social support, model quitting strategies, and increase behavioural capability. Which theory supplied these constructs?
4. A mental health campaign reports that millions of people shared its hashtag and that its television spots were widely seen. A colleague says this proves the campaign reduced stigma. Using the evaluation chain from this section, what is the most accurate response?
5. Besides the pitch, the lesson offers a second theory-based explanation for why Truth succeeded with youth where the antidrug campaign did not. Which construct-based explanation does it give?
6. Canada's picture-based warnings on cigarette packages show diseased tissue and state what smoking does to the body. Which constructs do they act on, and with which audience may that route fail?
7. Police and provincial agencies in British Columbia publicize CounterAttack roadchecks for weeks before the holidays, while MADD Canada asks drivers to display red ribbons as a pledge to drive sober. Which description fits the two arms?
8. During the COVID-19 vaccine rollout, health authorities recruited family physicians, Elders, and community leaders to speak for vaccination in their own languages and communities, and surveys found that people trusted their own providers more than distant sources. Which theories best explain this choice of messengers?
✦ Pass the knowledge check with 100% to continue
Final Review & Assessment
⏱ Estimated time: 25 minutes
Bringing It All Together
This lesson moved from the media to the message and back to the evidence. It began with a claim about people: we are creatures of communication and symbol, and what we see, read, and hear in the public media becomes a storehouse of information that shapes how we act, look, sound, and think. People and characters in the media are identity models, and the mechanism by which they influence behaviour is the observational learning of Social Learning Theory and Social Cognitive Theory. The media affect health in intended and unintended ways, and the Internet, mobile devices, social media, and cable and satellite broadcasting have multiplied the channels while turning the sender-receiver path into a web of many senders and receivers.
A communications campaign is the intentional use of that mechanism: a planned process of disseminating messages to influence behaviour in a target audience through a coordinated process of identifying audiences and segments, choosing channels, determining messages and their format, sequencing activities, and conducting formative research. The obesity hypothetical showed two audiences becoming four segments with different channels, different concerns, and different tolerances for tone, and showed why the obvious sequence, a public kickoff, can be wrong. Branding, the four-stage planning approach, and the communications plan give the effort coherence; media advocacy extends it to policy by changing the behaviour of policymakers rather than of individuals. The most practical warning in the lesson is that campaigns most often fail on exposure, because they never reach their audience against the din of competing messages.
Theory enters at the level of the message. Hornik's individual, social diffusion, and institutional diffusion models, plus the newer virtual dissemination models, organize the routes from a message to behaviour, and the familiar theories map onto them: the Health Belief Model and the Transtheoretical Model for individuals, diffusion of innovations, social marketing, communications theory, culture theory, and social networks for norms, and elite opinion through media advocacy for institutions. The worked example of older youth showed theory being chosen, rejected at a developmental brick wall, and replaced by a peer model and then by cultural meaning. The program examples closed the loop: a well-exposed antidrug campaign that did not move youth, a Truth Campaign that fit their need for independence and changed beliefs in proportion to exposure, and a text messaging pilot that put Social Cognitive Theory into a new channel. Canadian campaigns on tobacco and vaping, impaired driving, COVID-19 vaccination, and mental health can be read with the same lens, and every evaluation claim should be read by the link in the chain it concerns.
Key Takeaways from this lesson
- You can explain why the public media matter for health behaviour: we are creatures of communication and symbol, media figures serve as identity models, and people learn from them through observational learning, with effects that are both intended and unintended. You can also describe how the Internet, mobile devices, social media, and cable and satellite broadcasting have multiplied channels and turned the sender-receiver line into a web. The most useful reminder is that a campaign controls only its first message, so it must know which channels its audience uses and how that audience is likely to react.
- You can define a communications campaign as a planned, coordinated process of disseminating messages to influence behaviour in a target audience, and list its five elements: audiences and segments, channels, messages and their format, sequence, and formative research. You can also explain why campaigns most often fall short on exposure rather than on message design. When a case reports a good message that few people recall, name the exposure problem and look for fixes in channels, frequency, and sequence.
- You can segment an audience as the obesity hypothetical does, use formative research to match channels, pitch, tone, and spokespersons to each segment, and decide on a sequence, including whether a kickoff event helps or hurts. Keep the signature findings ready: parents respond to help with being good parents, single adults to what active people do, younger youth to cool and non-patronizing guidance, and older youth to approved peers rather than scare messages from adults.
- You can describe what branding, the four-stage planning approach, the communications plan, and media advocacy each contribute: a shortcut that carries motivation, a cycle from planning through pretesting and implementation to assessment, a documented rationale with an evaluation plan, and pressure for healthy public policy through mass media and news outreach. In a case, ask whose behaviour must change; if it is a policymaker's decision, the effort is media advocacy and its messages should be aimed at that decision.
- You can classify campaign strategies with Hornik's individual, social diffusion, and institutional diffusion models, plus virtual dissemination and networking models, and place familiar theories on them (Table 8.2). Classify by what the message is meant to change first (a person's knowledge and skills, a group's norms, or leaders' opinions and policy), not by the channel that carries it.
- You can select theories and constructs for a given population and explain why a construct that suits one audience fails with another: perceived susceptibility hits a developmental brick wall with adolescents, a peer model plays up benefits instead, and in an age-respect culture approval from elders may matter most. The reminder for any design question is that the selection of applicable theory is tied to population and circumstance.
- You can compare the evaluations of the National Youth Antidrug Media Campaign, the Truth Campaign, and Text2Quit, explain why exposure cannot account for the difference between the two youth campaigns, and read any claim of effect, including claims about Canadian campaigns, by the link it concerns from exposure to reception, beliefs and norms, and behaviour. Keep reach and effect apart: recall shows exposure, and only change that rises with exposure, measured against a baseline, begins to show effect.
Final Knowledge Assessment
This assessment covers all material from this lesson. Its last four questions follow one British Columbia health authority as it plans an influenza vaccination campaign, choosing segments, a theory and channel, a launch, and an evaluation. You must score 100% to complete the lesson. Review the feedback for any incorrect answers and try again.
1. What people see, read, and hear in the public media becomes a major storehouse of information influencing how they act, look, sound, and think. Which theoretical idea explains how media figures translate into behaviour?
2. A provincial campaign to reach 14- to 17-year-olds relies on morning news segments and a newspaper insert. Which observation about recent technologies most directly predicts a problem?
3. A health unit posts a video and, within hours, it has been quoted in mocking reaction videos that reach far more people than the original. Which point about social media does this illustrate?
4. Which list correctly names the five elements of the coordinated process that defines a communications campaign?
5. In the obesity hypothetical, formative research found that parents value being good parents and that hearing a message by word of mouth adds a kind of peer pressure. Which channel and pitch combination follows from this?
6. Which statement best captures why communications campaigns are often less effective than hoped?
7. Branding is an approach borrowed from social marketing. What does a brand do for a health behaviour?
8. Which of the following is the best example of media advocacy as defined in this lesson?
9. In news outreach, gaining coverage is only the first step. What is the second, equally important step?
10. A campaign changes the opinion of school board members so that a new policy requires schools to implement an obesity education component, which then changes what principals, teachers, and students do. In Hornik's scheme this is an example of which model type?
11. Why may raising perceived susceptibility not work as a message strategy for older youth, even when research shows they do not feel susceptible?
12. A campaign for young adults in a community where great respect is given to elders links healthy eating to approval from elders and representing the family well. This example makes which general point?
13. What did the evaluation of the National Youth Antidrug Media Campaign find for parents?
14. Which feature of the Truth Campaign was its central design choice?
15. In the Text2Quit pilot, almost half of participants stopped responding to the program's text messages after their quit date. How is this best interpreted?
16. A health authority in the British Columbia Interior plans a nine-month campaign to raise influenza vaccination among two named groups: adults aged 18 to 35 and the parents of children under five. Following the reasoning of the obesity hypothetical, which further split of the parents is best justified?
17. The same campaign's draft relies on a single poster warning adults aged 18 to 35 that influenza can be severe. Based on this lesson, which revision is best supported for this segment?
18. The draft launches the influenza campaign at a press conference with the medical health officer. How does the lesson's reasoning about sequence apply to this launch?
19. Midway through the influenza campaign, an evaluation reports that 70 percent of adults aged 18 to 35 in the region recall its message. Which link in the evaluation chain does this evidence concern, and what further evidence would show the campaign worked?
✦ Pass every section knowledge check with 100% before submitting