Communities, Populations,
and Settings
Health Promotion: Individuals and Communities
Learning objectives for this lesson:
- Distinguish a community intervention from an intervention in a community, classify a program as universal, selected, or indicated prevention, and explain the trade-off between the size of an effect and the number of people it reaches.
- Describe the Minnesota Heart Health Program, COMMIT, the Long Beach AIDS Community Demonstration Project, and the Dr. Meg trial, and explain what each teaches about target group, dose, and channel.
- Explain how politics, funders, and community structures shape a community program, and why members of a community are the best experts on it.
- Define population-based health promotion, and apply the requirements of tailoring, the steps for adapting an existing program, and the steps for building sustainability to a program.
- Distinguish a setting from a channel, and explain why schools and worksites are used as settings, what makes programs in each difficult, and how comprehensive school and workplace health approaches developed.
- Apply a PRECEDE-PROCEED style assessment to a school or worksite, and identify the family of theory that fits each problem it reveals.
- Describe published theory-based school and worksite programs and Canada's National Standard for Psychological Health and Safety in the Workplace, and identify the theory behind each.
This course was developed by Dr. Kiffer G. Card, to accompany Edberg, M. Essentials of Health Behavior: Social and Behavioral Theory in Public Health. Jones & Bartlett Learning. This lesson follows Chapters 9 and 10 of the text.
Glossary: Key Terms, People & Concepts
📚 Reference page, available throughout the lesson
This glossary collects the key concepts, people, and ideas you will meet in this lesson. Use it as a reference while you work through the material, or as a review before assessments. Type in the search box to filter entries.
Community Intervention, or Intervention in a Community?
⏱ Estimated reading time: 18 minutes
Overview
Individuals are embedded in communities, cultures, and societies, so health promotion programs commonly happen in communities, the mixing pot where individuals, social groups, norms, economic patterns, politics, and resources combine to create the situation a program is trying to change. Most communities are geographic places, but online groups, which we can call virtual communities, count too. Your assessment (a PRECEDE-PROCEED style needs assessment) tells you which issues, factors, and people to target, and one of the first decisions it forces is a decision about scale. This section defines the two scales a program can take, ties them to the universal, selected, and indicated categories of prevention, works through the arithmetic that separates them, and then examines four classic trials that show what each scale can and cannot deliver.
Learning Objectives
- 1.1 Distinguish a community intervention from an intervention in a community, and classify a program as universal, selected, or indicated prevention, or as work on systems and policies.
- 1.2 Explain the trade-off between the size of an effect and the number of people it reaches, using percentage change and absolute numbers.
- 2.1 Describe the design, theory, and results of the Minnesota Heart Health Program, COMMIT, the Long Beach AIDS Community Demonstration Project, and the Dr. Meg trial.
- 2.2 Use the results of COMMIT and Long Beach to reason about target group, dose, and the choice of channel.
1.1 Community Intervention or Intervention in a Community
1.1.1 Two Scales and Three Categories
Once an assessment has identified a problem in a community, a planner has to decide how wide the program should be. Should you target the community in general with a broad-based or multilevel program, or reach a smaller setting and a specific population group? We call the first a community intervention and the second an intervention in a community. By this we mean that the two differ in whom they aim at, not in where they take place. A community intervention addresses everyone who lives in the community, usually through many channels at once, while an intervention in a community also happens within the community but singles out one group within it. The purpose of drawing the distinction is to make the choice of scale a deliberate decision, because, as 1.2 shows, the two scales produce very different kinds of results.
The two scales can be related to the way the Institute of Medicine classifies prevention, a scheme that began with Robert Gordon's 1987 operational classification. The scheme sorts programs by the risk of the people they target. A universal prevention intervention targets a general population, regardless of individual risk. In other words, no one is selected in or out, and the program is offered to all. A selected prevention intervention, by contrast, targets individuals or groups at high risk for a particular problem. The group is chosen because of that one elevated risk. An indicated preventive intervention goes a step further. It targets families, groups, or individuals with multiple risk factors, and combines several activities and treatments to address factors that occur together. For example, a family facing poverty, high diabetes risk, and poor diet at the same time would be offered several services together rather than one. Table 7.1 sets out the three categories, who each one targets, a Canadian example of each, and the label this lesson uses for it. The link to the two scales is simple: a universal program is a community intervention, and a selected or indicated program is an intervention in a community.
Table 7.1. The universal, selected, and indicated categories of prevention, with the group each targets, a Canadian example, and the label used in this lesson.
| Category | Who is targeted | Canadian example | Label used here |
|---|---|---|---|
| Universal prevention intervention | A general population, regardless of individual risk | A provincial sodium campaign; a smoke-free indoor air law | Community intervention |
| Selected prevention intervention | Individuals or groups at high risk for a particular problem | Peer outreach and needle distribution for people who inject drugs in Vancouver's Downtown Eastside | Intervention in a community |
| Indicated preventive intervention | Families, groups, or individuals with multiple risk factors, addressed with combined activities and treatments | Home visiting for young, low-income parents with a history of substance use, bundling parenting support, income help, and addiction referral | Intervention in a community |
The difference between selected and indicated is the one students most often blur, because both single out a group at risk. The way to tell them apart is to count. A selected program reaches a group because of one high risk for one problem, such as sharing injection equipment. An indicated program reaches people because several risk factors occur together, and it answers them with several activities at once. The term indicated also has a second, narrower meaning in the wider literature, which is worth knowing so that it does not cause confusion when you read outside this course.
Caution: two uses of "indicated"
The indicated row of Table 7.1 follows the usage of this lesson, in which the defining features are multiple risk factors occurring together and a combination of activities and treatments. Gordon and the Institute of Medicine reserve the term for people whom screening or examination has shown to have a risk marker or early signs of a disorder that has not yet developed, such as high blood pressure. Use the lesson's sense when you classify a program in this course, and check which sense is intended when you read a program description elsewhere.
Not every program targets people at all, and the next part turns to the programs that change systems and policies instead.
1.1.2 Working on Systems and Policies
The three categories all describe programs that reach people. A third possibility does not target individuals at all: you might work on systems or policies instead. By this we mean changing the rules, structures, or organizations that shape behaviour, so that the healthier choice becomes easier or the risky one harder for everyone at once. Laws on smoking in indoor spaces are the standard example, and every Canadian province now has one. Such a law does not try to persuade any one smoker; it changes the places where everyone smokes. Because it applies to everyone, it is also a universal intervention, and Table 7.1 lists it as one. In addition to changing policies, systems work can mean building the capacity a community lacks. Where a community has no system for prevention, building one is the intervention.
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention is well known for building a community focus into prevention. A good example is REACH (Racial and Ethnic Approaches to Community Health), which funds community coalitions and other capacity building and developed one of the few evaluation protocols aimed at nonmedical factors in minority health disparities. Its framework assumes five stages that build on one another: capacity building, targeted actions, community and systems change, widespread risk and protective behaviour change, and health disparity reduction. The idea that the stages build on one another is the important point. Each stage is a precondition for the next, so a program cannot expect widespread behaviour change before it has built a coalition and changed the systems around people. The purpose of naming the earlier stages is to give a program something it can measure and report long before the final outcome appears. Open each panel of the accordion that follows to see what happens at each stage, in order from capacity building to health disparity reduction.
1. Capacity building
Community coalition actions to reduce disparities. A program spends its first year here, which is why, as the next section warns, funding often runs out just as a program gets established.
2. Targeted actions
Intervention activities believed to bring about a desired effect. These are what programs are judged on, and, as the next section argues, they are almost never the whole picture.
3. Community and systems change
Changes to the community environment and to the knowledge, attitudes, beliefs, and behaviours of influential individuals and groups, who are expected to change before the general population does. By influential individuals and groups we mean people such as community leaders, providers, and the heads of organizations whose decisions and example shape what others do. The framework places them first because their change is the route to everyone else's: once a clinic changes its practice or a faith leader endorses a new norm, the people who look to them have a reason and an opportunity to change as well.
4. Widespread risk and protective behaviour change
Changes in rates of risk reduction behaviours among a significant percentage of community members.
5. Health disparity reduction
Narrowing gaps in health status, an outcome measured in years, which is why the framework names the process stages that come first.
Read in order, the five stages show that a community-level program works through coalitions and systems before it can expect widespread behaviour change, and that the outcome it is ultimately judged on, a narrower disparity, comes last and takes years. With the categories and the systems path in hand, the next part applies them to particular programs.
1.1.3 Classifying Programs
A program's category is decided by whom it targets and how it is delivered, not by the setting it happens in or by the group the planners most hope to help. This rule matters because two features of a program description often mislead. The first is the setting. For example, a policy delivered in every elementary school happens in one kind of place, but it applies to every student regardless of risk, so it is universal. The second is the planners' hopes. A community-wide campaign may be designed with heavy smokers in mind, but if it is delivered to every smoker through media and other broad channels, it remains a community intervention. Interactive 7.1 describes eight programs, among them a provincial sodium campaign, a supervised consumption site, and a nurse home visiting program. Decide whether each program is a universal community intervention or an intervention in a community, selected or indicated: click one label for each program and read the feedback, which explains the reasoning.
📊 Interactive 7.1: Which kind of program?
Click one label per program.1. A provincial ministry runs television and transit advertising asking all adults to check sodium on food labels.
2. A province prohibits smoking in all enclosed workplaces and on restaurant patios.
3. A supervised consumption site and needle distribution service serves people who inject drugs in one neighbourhood.
4. A nurse visits families with a newborn where the parent is under twenty, low income, and has a history of substance use, combining parenting coaching, income help, and addiction referral.
5. A provincial policy requires every elementary school to give all students in grades 1 to 8 twenty minutes of physical activity each day.
6. Peer workers offer rapid HIV testing to gay, bisexual, and other men who have sex with men at bathhouses and bars.
7. Adults with prediabetes, obesity, and low income join a program combining diet coaching, subsidized produce, and clinic follow-up.
8. A city forms a community board and runs quit messages through media, physicians, worksites, and cessation services, hoping mainly to reach heavy smokers.
Three patterns run through the answers. Policies and campaigns that apply to everyone are universal, even when they are delivered in one setting such as a school. Programs that reach a group because of its high risk for one problem are selected. Programs that bundle several activities for people with several risk factors occurring together are indicated. Once a program is classified, the next question is what kind of change it can be expected to produce.
1.2 Small Change for Many, or Big Change for Few
Choosing a scale has consequences for the kind of result a program can produce. Community interventions tend to produce smaller changes over a larger number of people. By this we mean that the percentage of people who change is usually modest, but because the percentage is taken of a very large base, the number of people who change can still be large. For example, suppose a mass media campaign produces a 3% decrease in smoking. Three per cent sounds small, yet over a whole community it might mean hundreds or thousands of people actually quit.
An intervention in a community works the other way. Because it concentrates its effort on one group, it can change a much larger share of that group, but the group itself is small. For example, an HIV program might focus on people who inject drugs, both because sharing equipment carries high risk and because the group can act as a multiplier or bridge for transmission to others. Working with a few social groups, the share who stop sharing might be 32%. That is a big change in percentage terms, but it occurs over a small subset of the community, so it is smaller in absolute numbers. Figure 7.1 sets the two cases side by side with illustrative numbers, so that the percentage who change and the number of people who change can be compared.
Figure 7.1. A community intervention, in which 3% of 100,000 adult smokers reached by a mass media campaign quit (3,000 people), set beside an intervention in a community, in which 32% of 500 people who inject drugs reached by a peer program stop sharing (160 people).
Figure 7.1 shows why a percentage alone can mislead: the 3% campaign changes the behaviour of 3,000 people, while the 32% peer program changes the behaviour of 160. However, this does not mean the campaign is the better program. Neither scale is automatically better. The choice depends on the problem and on what the assessment found. It also depends on whether the small group acts as a multiplier or bridge for harm to others. When it does, a large change within the group protects many people beyond it, so the 160 people in Figure 7.1 may prevent far more harm than their number suggests. The practical consequence for reading any program result is to ask two questions together: what share of the target group changed, and how many people does that share represent? The same trade-off appears in a classic argument about prevention strategy.
Connection: Rose's population strategy
The same logic underlies Geoffrey Rose's argument that many people at small risk may generate more cases than a few at high risk (Rose, 1985). By this we mean that a high-risk group, although each member is in more danger, is usually small, whereas the large majority at modest risk is so numerous that most cases arise among them. A population strategy, which shifts the whole community a little, can therefore prevent more cases than a strategy aimed only at the few. Rose also cautioned that such a strategy offers little benefit to each individual. Because any one person's chance of being helped is small, people see little reason to change, which makes a population strategy harder to motivate even when it does the most good overall.
Worked Example 7.1 applies the categories of 1.1 and the arithmetic of this subsection to a real Canadian program. As you read it, watch which yardstick its effect is judged against.
Worked Example 7.1: Insite as an Intervention in a Community
The case. Insite, North America's first legally sanctioned supervised injection site, opened in Vancouver's Downtown Eastside in 2003 to serve people who inject drugs in a few blocks of one neighbourhood. In 2011 the Supreme Court of Canada ruled unanimously that refusing to extend its exemption from drug laws violated its users' Charter rights (Canada (Attorney General) v. PHS Community Services Society, 2011). Which prevention category fits Insite, and how should its effect be judged?
Step 1: Identify the population and the delivery. Insite does not reach the general population of Metro Vancouver. It reaches people who inject drugs, in one neighbourhood, because of their high risk, and it delivers its service in a single place where they come.
Step 2: Classify the program. A program aimed at a group at high risk for a particular problem is a selected prevention intervention, so Insite is an intervention in a community. It is not universal, because it does not target everyone, and in this lesson's usage it would be indicated only if it bundled several treatments for people with several co-occurring risk factors.
Step 3: Apply the arithmetic. Against Metro Vancouver's population, the number who use the site is tiny, so the absolute number of people whose behaviour changes looks small. Against the neighbourhood's people who inject drugs, the share reached, and the change possible within that group, can be large.
Step 4: Account for the bridge. People who inject drugs can act as a multiplier or bridge for transmission to others, so a large change within this small group protects people outside it as well.
What the example shows. Judging Insite by the yardstick of a community intervention (how many people in the whole region changed) would make a well-chosen intervention in a community look like a failure. The right yardstick is the change within the group it serves and the role that group plays in harm to others.
The example shows that the arithmetic of 1.2 cuts both ways: a small absolute number can still be the right result when the group is small and acts as a bridge. The four classic trials that follow show both scales in practice.
2.1 Four Classic Trials
Four cases show the distinction in practice. The first two are classic community interventions from American trials of the 1980s and 1990s, and the second two are interventions in a community, one in a neighbourhood and one online. Reading them as two pairs makes the contrast between the scales easier to see.
The Minnesota Heart Health Program ran a five- to six-year, multiple-strategy program in three communities, with three reference communities for comparison. By multiple-strategy we mean that it worked through many channels at once: mass media, physicians as role models, risk factor screening, school programs, and engaged community leaders. The purpose of combining them was to shift population levels of cholesterol, blood pressure, smoking, and physical activity across the whole community, not in one group. COMMIT, the Community Intervention Trial for Smoking Cessation, followed the same community-wide logic for a single behaviour. It randomly assigned one community in each of eleven matched pairs, ten in the United States and one in Canada, to a four-year program run through a community board and four channels. Its primary target was heavy smokers. However, its main effect appeared among light and moderate smokers, a result that 2.2 examines closely.
The other two trials narrowed the audience. The Long Beach AIDS Community Demonstration Project is the classic intervention in a community. Its designers judged no single theory adequate for the group they served and built a composite theory instead. They spread role model stories through small media and peer volunteers, dropped mass media, and revised nearly every material in response to how the audience reacted. The Dr. Meg trial carried the same idea into a virtual community. It sent a single email from a physician's profile to adolescents who were displaying risk on a social networking site, and references to sexual risk fell more than in controls. In both cases, the program chose a specific group and a channel that reached that group directly.
The four tabs that follow give the design, theory, and results of each trial in detail. The first two describe the community interventions, the third the Long Beach project, and the fourth Dr. Meg. Open each tab in turn and note whom each trial targeted, how it was delivered, and what it found.
The Minnesota Heart Health Program: a community intervention
A five- to six-year individual-, group-, and community-level intervention in six upper-Midwest communities, three receiving the program and three serving as reference, aimed at health behaviours, population levels of cholesterol, blood pressure, smoking, and physical activity, and ultimately coronary heart disease. Its hypotheses were that a systematic, multiple-strategy, community-wide health education program was feasible and would change how people think about heart disease, produce environmental structures that support change, and change physiologic risk factors. It alerted people to health issues, offered behavioural alternatives, provided incentives and reinforcements, engaged community leaders, ran a high-intensity media campaign, recruited physicians as role models and opinion leaders, screened systematically, and delivered school programs to reach youth and parents. Evaluation used annual cohort surveys, cross-sectional samples, and surveillance of morbidity and mortality at ages 30 to 74. Canada's version was the Canadian Heart Health Initiative, a federal and provincial partnership begun in the late 1980s that funded community demonstration projects modelled on Minnesota, Stanford, and Pawtucket.
COMMIT: a second classic example
In the 1980s the National Cancer Institute funded the Community Intervention Trial for Smoking Cessation. One community in each of eleven matched pairs, ten in the United States and one in Canada (Brantford, Ontario, with Peterborough as comparison), was randomly assigned to a four-year intervention. Cohorts of about 10,000 heavy and 10,000 light and moderate smokers were followed by telephone. The aim was to involve diverse organizations in a comprehensive intervention that would maximize exposure to quit messages, focused solely on quitting. The primary target was heavy smokers (25 or more cigarettes a day), on the assumption that reaching them would affect lighter smokers too; quitting meant six months of cessation. Each community formed a board, and work ran through four channels managed by task forces: public education through media and events, health care providers, worksites and other organizations, and cessation resources. National uniformity was balanced against local tailoring. In other words, every intervention community had to deliver the same core activities so that the trial could be compared across sites, while each board was free to fit those activities to its own community. The receipt index measured how much of the intervention each person received, so quit rates could be read against exposure. This mattered because a community can be offered a program without every smoker in it actually receiving much of it.
The results were sobering: more variation across communities than by pairs; no significant decline among heavy smokers; and the main effect among light and moderate smokers, whose quit rate was 30.6% in intervention communities and 27.5% in comparison communities, about 3 percentage points higher, with a larger effect among the less educated because the college educated had already changed (COMMIT Research Group, 1995).
The Long Beach AIDS Community Demonstration Project: an intervention in a community
Long Beach, California, was one of five cities in the AIDS Community Demonstration Projects, which the CDC began funding in 1989 to address spread in specific populations (CDC, 1996), and Long Beach's project was based in storefront locations and relied on peer education. Its designers considered the Health Belief Model, the Theory of Reasoned Action, the Transtheoretical Model, Social Cognitive Theory, and diffusion of innovations and judged none adequate alone for risk driven also by social networks, illegal activity, stigma, and marginalization. The reason is that each of these theories explains part of a behaviour, mostly the part that sits inside the individual, while the risk in this population was also shaped by who people used and had sex with, by the fact that the behaviour was illegal, and by their exclusion from mainstream services. Their answer was a composite theory, meaning one built by combining constructs from several theories into a single model. It tied behaviour to perceived risk, anticipated results of change, perception that others are changing, self-efficacy, intention and commitment, and acquisition of skills. For example, a person might accept that sharing equipment is risky, but would still need to believe that change would pay off, see peers changing, feel able to change, commit to it, and learn how to do it. The goals were condom use among people who inject drugs, their female sex partners, and female street sex workers, and bleach disinfection of equipment, in a low-income Latino, Cambodian, Vietnamese, and African American neighbourhood.
The central component was the role model story, a concise vignette about a local person overcoming barriers, spread through small media, posters, mass media, and recordings under the identity Healthwise, with Road Dogs publications for men and Risky Business for women. Almost everything was revised in the field: mass media was dropped for covering too wide an audience; women disliked Risky Business and would not be seen with it, so it became For Women Only; Healthwise was dropped because nobody recognized it; bleach kits gained a water bottle. Peer staff recruited volunteers from the community, and local businesses served as distribution points. Against a comparison community, 77% of people who inject drugs in the intervention area reported exposure toward the end of the project, condom carrying rose from 10% to 27%, stage of change for condom use with nonmain partners moved forward while it fell in the comparison area, and people recently exposed had higher stage-of-change scores for condom and bleach use (Jamner, Wolitski, and Corby, 1997).
Dr. Meg: an intervention in a virtual community
Social networking sites are virtual communities where adolescents negotiate identity and display substance use and sexual risk. Researchers at Seattle Children's Research Institute and the University of Washington tested a very simple intervention with MySpace users from a single zip code. A team member created a profile as Dr. Meg; users displaying three or more risk references received an email noting the risky nature of such disclosures with a link to clinical resources, and a control group received nothing. The 190 profiles that qualified belonged to self-described 18- to 20-year-olds, about 58% of them male. At three months, all sexual references had been removed from almost 14% of profiles in the intervention group versus about 5% of profiles in controls; for substance references the figures were 26% versus 22%, suggesting other factors were also at work (Moreno et al., 2009). Modest as it is, the result shows promise for the virtual community as a setting.
Taken together, the tabs show that the two community interventions reached whole populations through many channels at once, while the two interventions in a community narrowed both the audience and the channel. The next part draws out what COMMIT and Long Beach teach about getting a program to the people it is meant for.
2.2 What COMMIT and Long Beach Teach About Target Group, Dose, and Channel
COMMIT's results were sobering, and they are instructive precisely because they did not match the plan. To begin with, effects varied more across communities than by matched pair. In other words, the differences from one community to another were larger than the differences between the program and comparison community within each pair, which tells us that the community itself shapes what a program does. In addition, the hoped-for decline among heavy smokers did not occur to a significant degree. The main effect was among light and moderate smokers, whose quit rate was 30.6% in intervention communities and 27.5% in comparison communities, about 3 percentage points higher, with a larger effect among the less educated because the college educated had already changed.
Why the heavy smokers did not respond is a question of target group and dose. By dose we mean how much of a program a person actually receives, as opposed to how much the program offers. COMMIT's receipt index measured how much of the intervention each person received or took part in. The purpose of doing so was to examine quit rates in relation to exposure rather than only community by community, so that analysts could ask whether a group that did not change had simply received too little. Other studies also find quitting very hard for heavy smokers, so two explanations remain: either the dose was too small, or a different type of intervention was needed. Either way, the practical point is that a target group named in a plan is not necessarily a group the program reaches.
Long Beach teaches the complementary lesson about channel, which is the route by which a program reaches its audience. Its staff dropped mass media because it covered too wide an audience for a program aimed at a specific population. Instead, they reached that population in the places where its members gathered, through small media, posters, peer volunteers, and local businesses that served as distribution points. They also revised materials whenever the audience rejected them, the ongoing evaluation that Section 2 describes as the third step of tailoring. The same logic explains why mass media would be the wrong channel for a program such as Insite. A program that serves people who inject drugs in a few blocks of one neighbourhood would spend most of a media budget on people it does not serve. Read together, the two trials show that a targeted program needs a channel matched to its target, and a broad program cannot be assumed to reach its hardest group.
Worked Example 7.2 returns to COMMIT's Canadian site and asks how its results should be read. Watch how the category is decided by delivery rather than by the hoped-for beneficiary, and how the receipt index bears on dose.
Worked Example 7.2: What Happened to the Heavy Smokers in Brantford?
The case. COMMIT assumed that a community-wide program reaching heavy smokers would move lighter smokers too. The opposite happened: light and moderate smokers quit at higher rates in intervention communities, including the Canadian site in Brantford, Ontario, while heavy smokers did not differ significantly from those in comparison communities. Was COMMIT a community intervention that produced the expected pattern, or a failed intervention in a community that never reached its target? What would you add for heavy smokers?
Step 1: Classify by delivery. COMMIT was delivered community-wide through public education, health care providers, worksites and other organizations, and cessation resources that reached every smoker. That makes it a community intervention (universal), even though heavy smokers were its primary target. The group the planners most hoped to help does not change the category.
Step 2: Read the results against the scale. A quit rate about 3 percentage points higher among light and moderate smokers (30.6% compared with 27.5%) is exactly the small change over many people that a community intervention is expected to produce. COMMIT did not fail as a community intervention; it worked the way such interventions usually work, but not on the group it aimed at.
Step 3: Ask about dose. The receipt index lets analysts ask whether heavy smokers received less of the program, or responded less to the same amount. Because other studies also find quitting very hard for heavy smokers, either the dose was too small or a different type of intervention is needed.
Step 4: Decide what to add. Reaching heavy smokers would mean adding a component aimed specifically at them, delivered, for example, through the health care provider and cessation resource channels. That added component would be an intervention in a community (selected), so the program as a whole would combine both scales rather than remain a pure community intervention.
What the example shows. A universal program cannot be assumed to reach its most dependent subgroup. The common mistake is to call COMMIT an intervention in a community because heavy smokers were its target; delivery, not the hoped-for beneficiary, decides the category.
The example shows that the two scales are often best used together, with a community intervention for the many and an intervention in a community for the group it cannot be trusted to reach.
Both trials point to the next section. COMMIT varied more by community than by pair, and Long Beach rewrote its materials on the street. The community itself, with its politics, structures, and expertise, is always part of the picture. This section has distinguished a community intervention from an intervention in a community, related the two to the universal, selected, and indicated categories of prevention and to the systems path illustrated by REACH, and set out the trade-off between the size of an effect and the number of people it reaches. It has also described four programs, the Minnesota Heart Health Program, COMMIT, Long Beach, and Dr. Meg, that show the distinction in practice. The key takeaways and knowledge check that follow review this material.
Key Takeaways
- 1.1 The first planning decision is one of scale. A community intervention targets the community in general with a broad-based or multilevel program, while an intervention in a community targets a smaller setting and a specific population group. Universal programs, aimed at a general population, are community interventions; selected programs, aimed at groups at high risk for one problem, and indicated programs, which combine several activities for people with several co-occurring risk factors, are interventions in a community. A third path works on systems and policies, such as smoke-free laws, which are also universal because they apply to everyone, and REACH's five stages show how such community and systems work builds toward reduced disparities. When you classify a case, ask who is targeted and how the program is delivered, not where it happens or whom the planners most hope to help: a school-wide policy is still universal, and selected differs from indicated by the bundling of several treatments for several risk factors.
- 1.2 Scale is a trade-off, not a ranking. A community intervention buys a small percentage change over a large number of people, and an intervention in a community buys a large percentage change within a small group: 3% of 100,000 smokers is 3,000 people, while 32% of 500 people who inject drugs is 160. The common trap is to compare the percentages and call the larger one better, so always convert to absolute numbers. Then ask whether the small group acts as a multiplier or bridge for harm to others, because that is what can justify a targeted program with modest absolute numbers. A strong answer names the scale, shows the arithmetic, and says what the assessment would need to show to justify the choice.
- 2.1 Four trials anchor this section. The Minnesota Heart Health Program and COMMIT were community interventions that used many channels at once; COMMIT ran for four years in eleven matched pairs (one pair in Canada) through a community board and four channels, and raised quitting among light and moderate smokers by about 3 percentage points without significantly moving heavy smokers. The Long Beach AIDS Community Demonstration Project was an intervention in a community built on a composite theory, role model stories, peer volunteers, and small media. After the Dr. Meg trial's single email, almost 14% of profiles removed all sexual references against about 5% of controls, while substance references fell in both groups, which suggests other factors were also at work. When a question describes a program, match it by its features: a community board and four channels point to COMMIT, role model stories and peers point to Long Beach, and a social networking site points to Dr. Meg.
- 2.2 COMMIT and Long Beach teach complementary lessons about reaching the right people. A community-wide program may move people other than its intended target, and its effects depend on the community, as COMMIT's variation by community rather than by pair showed. Because people in the same community receive different doses, COMMIT's receipt index measured how much of the program each person received, so outcomes could be read against exposure. A targeted program needs a channel that fits its audience: Long Beach dropped mass media because it reached too wide an audience, relied on peers, small media, and local businesses, and revised its materials on audience reaction. If a case assumes that a universal campaign will also reach a dependent subgroup, the answer drawn from COMMIT is that it cannot be assumed, and a targeted arm is usually needed.
1. A public health unit runs a peer-delivered program to reduce equipment sharing among people who inject drugs in one neighbourhood. Evaluation shows that 30% of participants stopped sharing. A colleague objects that a city-wide media campaign would have reached far more people. What is the best response?
2. A provincial program provides intensive support to families in which a parent is under twenty, lives in poverty, and has a history of substance use, combining parenting coaching, income assistance, and addiction referral. In the classification of prevention used in this lesson, this is best described as which type of intervention?
3. COMMIT's primary target group was heavy smokers, on the assumption that reaching them would also affect lighter smokers. What did the trial actually find?
4. The Long Beach AIDS Community Demonstration Project dropped its mass media component during implementation. What was the reason?
5. The COMMIT study developed a receipt index. What problem was it designed to solve?
6. A regional health authority in the British Columbia Interior finds that vaping is widespread among people aged 15 to 24, but that a smaller group who vape heavily and also smoke cigarettes accounts for most of the nicotine dependence seen in clinics. It plans a cessation program offered only to that smaller group. How is this program best classified?
7. The same health authority also plans retailer enforcement and regional media for the whole age group, and assumes that this universal arm will bring the heavy vapers to quit as well. Which finding from this section bears most directly on that assumption?
8. For its targeted arm aimed at the heavy vapers who also smoke, which design best applies the lessons of the Long Beach project?
✦ Pass the knowledge check with 100% to continue
Complex Communities, Populations, Tailoring, and Sustainability
⏱ Estimated reading time: 16 minutes
Overview
One truism for community interventions, large or targeted, is that the intervention itself is almost always just part of the picture. Because a community is involved, its interests, needs, politics, resources, and social structures will inevitably play a role; COMMIT varied more by community than by pair for exactly this reason. This section works through those factors: the politics of choosing a health issue and a population, the community structures a program runs through, and the expertise that only the community can supply. It then widens the lens from communities to populations and closes with two obligations, tailoring a program to the people it serves and making sure it survives its funding.
Learning Objectives
- 3.1 Explain why an intervention is only one part of a community program, and identify the political and funding forces that shape the choice of a health issue and a target population.
- 3.2 Describe the community structures through which programs are implemented and the motives and rivalries they may bring.
- 3.3 Explain why members of a community are the best experts on it, using community health outreach workers as the model.
- 4.1 Define population-based health promotion, and explain the caution about stigma and stereotyping that comes with it.
- 4.2 Describe the five requirements of a tailored program and the three steps for developing or adapting a program.
- 4.3 Describe the five steps that build sustainability, and apply them to a program plan.
3.1 The Politics of Choosing an Issue and a Population
In any community, several health issues matter at once. Imagine a rural mining community in West Virginia, call it Minerville, with low incomes and poor access to care, and five candidate issues: mine safety, lack of health insurance, cardiovascular health, youth drinking and driving, and tobacco-related cancer. How do you choose? It would be convenient if the choice could be made on data alone, but in practice two other forces shape it. The first is that each issue has a political dimension. By this we mean that every issue has advocates, people and organizations who care about it and push attention and resources toward it, so choosing one issue also means disappointing the advocates of the others. The second force is money. The issue may be dictated by the source of funds, because most funders have a mandate that fixes what their money can be spent on. For example, American maternal and child health money funds that mission, and substance use prevention money funds that one. Canadian planners face the same pattern through Health Canada's Substance Use and Addictions Program, Public Health Agency of Canada streams, provincial ministries, and foundations, each with a mandate that may clash with community wishes. The result is that the issue a program addresses is often chosen, at least in part, before the planner arrives.
Three scenarios show the pattern, and each puts the politics in a different place. In the first, an open-ended grant gives room to tailor a program to the community's needs. However, the same room invites lobbying from advocates of every competing issue, so freedom of choice brings political pressure with it. In the second, funds tied to a specific mandate settle the issue but not the politics. Other organizations may try to capture the money for their own work, and the organizations whose cooperation you need may refuse to take part. In the third, a coalition that looked ideal on the application may split once the money arrives, so the politics appear inside the program's own partnership. The accordion that follows sets out each scenario in Minerville. Decide what you would do in each one before opening it, then open all three and compare your answer with the guidance.
You receive an open-ended grant with no health issue specified. This is both a good and a difficult position. The good part is room to tailor efforts to community needs. The bad part is the same room: you may walk straight into the politics of competing issues, with individuals and organizations lobbying for their priority. You could, as in PRECEDE-PROCEED, decide on the epidemiological data, but it is not always that simple: some issues are pressing because of what might happen, not what already has. By this we mean that epidemiological data count harm that has already occurred, so a threat that has not yet produced many cases looks small in the numbers. For example, in a mining town a single serious accident can kill several people at once, and advocates for mine safety may argue, with reason, that the issue deserves priority even in a year when few injuries were recorded. The data are a starting point for the decision, not a substitute for judgment about risk.
Your federal funds are for assessing HIV risk as it relates to substance use among youth. Minerville has a tiny HIV program that distributes pamphlets and a much larger alcohol and drug department, and a vocal treatment providers' association, the MDAATP, wants your funds directed toward drug and alcohol use, including among adults. The schools want nothing to do with an HIV assessment, calling it too controversial. Your task is to negotiate these political waters: increase the willingness of schools or other youth-serving organizations to participate, because you need access to youth, and rein in the association's desire to dominate while still involving it.
You are running a smoking prevention effort in an apartment-building community through a coalition you assembled: small businesses, two churches, a tenant rights advocate, and two clinics. On the application it looked like a stroke of genius. After the funds arrive, splits appear: the churches are at odds, and the advocate treats the project as hers, building her power base and creating a wedge among those who dislike her. You have to manage this fractious coalition and keep the focus, resources, and activities on the prevention goal.
In none of the three scenarios does the planner get to choose the issue on technical grounds alone. The work is to keep the program aimed at its health goal while bringing in the organizations it needs and preventing any one of them from capturing it. Those organizations are the subject of the next part.
3.2 Coalitions and Structures of Power
A planner rarely delivers a program alone. When you implement a project you typically do so through, or in collaboration with, community structures. By community structures we mean the organized bodies through which a community already acts: government agencies or a specific leader, task forces, community advisory boards, grassroots organizations, professional groups, and community coalitions. Working through them gives a program access, credibility, and people. However, each of them is also an actor with interests of its own. Any of them may have motives tied to community politics, to preserving or enhancing their position, or to controlling an issue in order to set the agenda. In addition, any may carry internal conflicts from rivalries or different goals among its members. The practical consequence is that a partner's support for a program cannot be read as simple agreement with its goal; a planner should also ask what the partner wants from the program. Table 7.2 lists the six types of community structure, with a Canadian example of each and what each may want besides the program's goal.
Table 7.2. Types of community structure through which programs are implemented, with Canadian examples and the motives each may bring besides the program's goal.
| Type of community structure | Canadian example | What it may want besides your goal |
|---|---|---|
| Government agencies or a specific leader | A mayor, a band council, a chief medical health officer | Credit, control of the agenda, an election cycle |
| Task forces formed by government but including community leaders | A municipal overdose task force | Visible action on the issue that created it |
| A community advisory board of providers, population members, faith groups, businesses, and advocates | The advisory committee for a supervised consumption site | Representation for each constituency; a veto on what offends any |
| Grassroots community organizations | A tenants' association, a drug user union, a parents' group | Autonomy from institutions; recognition of their expertise |
| Professional groups and provider associations | A division of family practice, a treatment providers' association | Funding for their services; professional standing |
| Community coalitions | A regional healthy communities coalition | Continued existence of the coalition itself |
The fractured coalition in the third Minerville scenario is Table 7.2 in action: each member brought a motive of its own, and the planner's job became managing the coalition while keeping the focus, resources, and activities on the prevention goal. You may have but one issue in mind. Carrying it out in a community, however, means recognizing the social and political forces that intersect with it. By this we mean that a smoking prevention goal does not arrive in a neutral space: it lands among churches with their own disagreements, an advocate with her own ambitions, and businesses with their own interests, and each of these shapes whether the program gets done. Because these forces belong to groups and organizations rather than to individuals, theories of individual behaviour cannot help a planner manage them. Community organization and organizational change theories are the tools, since they explain how groups set priorities, share power, and change the way they work. Yet the same community that complicates a program is also its best source of knowledge, which is the subject of the next part.
3.3 Communities as Experts
Despite all this, there is no better expertise on the community than expertise from the community itself and the diverse groups in it. By this we mean that the people who live in a community know things an outside planner cannot easily learn: its habits, customs, values, attitudes, social groups, and where things happen. Surveillance data can tell a planner how common a problem is, but not how people talk about it or where they would notice a message. For example, suppose you were disseminating obesity prevention messages. You would need answers to four questions. What are the contributing factors here? Which themes should the messages emphasize? What are the best places to deliver them? How can key members of the community be brought in to reinforce them? Each of these depends on local knowledge, so community participation would be necessary to answer them.
The model for putting this principle into practice is the community health outreach worker, a member of a high-risk population employed to connect peers to a project, distribute information, and advise on how to reach the group. In HIV programs with people who inject drugs, this has been one of the best strategies. Outreach workers bring two things. The first is knowledge: they know local drug use patterns, how to talk about HIV, and the customs that relate to risk. The second, and even more important, is legitimacy. Because they are closely connected to the population, they are perceived as knowing how it is, so the same message carries more weight from them than from an outsider. Knowledge could in principle be learned by a planner over time, but legitimacy cannot be supplied by anyone outside the group, which is why it is the outreach worker's most important contribution.
Two Canadian cases show communities acting as experts on their own health. Worked Example 7.3 applies the outreach worker model to a drug user organization in Vancouver; watch how each of the four dissemination questions above is answered from inside the community.
Worked Example 7.3: VANDU and Peer Expertise in the Downtown Eastside
The case. The Vancouver Area Network of Drug Users, founded in 1997, is an organization of people who use or have used drugs. Its members ran alley patrols and an unsanctioned injection site before Insite opened, helped shape it, and have since staffed peer roles in overdose response across British Columbia, where health authorities now routinely hire people with lived experience of drug use as peer workers. Which of the four dissemination questions could a peer worker answer that a planner could not, and what would you predict for a program that consulted peers only after its materials were printed?
Step 1: Name the role. VANDU members working as peers are members of a high-risk population employed to connect others to a program, distribute information, and advise on reaching the group. In the vocabulary of this section they are community health outreach workers.
Step 2: Map their knowledge onto the four questions. A planner can read surveillance data, but peers know from inside the local contributing factors (how and where people use), the themes that will carry weight, the places where messages will actually be seen, and which respected members can reinforce them. All four questions are answered better by peers than by an outside planner.
Step 3: Add legitimacy. Because peers are perceived as knowing how it is, the same message carries more weight from them than from an outsider. Their legitimacy is the point, not a side benefit.
Step 4: Predict the late-consultation program. A program that consults peers only after its materials are printed has skipped community participation at the design stage, so its themes, language, and distribution points are likely to miss, and the materials will need revising, as Long Beach had to replace the Risky Business flyer that women would not be seen with.
What the example shows. Treating the community as the expert is a design decision made at the start, not a review step at the end.
VANDU shows community expertise at work in program delivery. Worked Example 7.4 extends the same principle to who governs health programs and who owns the information collected about a community.
Worked Example 7.4: Community-Driven First Nations Health Governance
The case. In 2013 the First Nations Health Authority took over programs the federal government had delivered to First Nations in British Columbia, under a vision described as community-driven and nation-based. Separately, the First Nations principles of OCAP (ownership, control, access, and possession), stewarded by the First Nations Information Governance Centre, assert that First Nations own information about their communities and control how it is collected, used, and shared. How do the OCAP principles extend the argument for community participation from program design to the assessment and evaluation steps of PRECEDE-PROCEED?
Step 1: Identify what the community controls. The First Nations Health Authority places program design and delivery under First Nations governance. OCAP places the information about First Nations communities under their ownership and control.
Step 2: Map OCAP onto the planning model. The assessment phases of PRECEDE-PROCEED collect information about the community, and the evaluation phases collect more. Under OCAP, the community decides how those data are collected, used, and shared, so assessment and evaluation become activities done with the community's consent and under its control, not only program design.
Step 3: Draw the implication for planners. A planner working with a First Nations community negotiates the assessment and evaluation plan through the community's governance from the start, and leaves the data with the community rather than with the funder or a university.
What the example shows. Both arrangements treat the community as the expert on its own health: assessment data belong to the community, and program design runs through its governance.
The politics of choosing an issue, the community structures a program works through, and the expertise of the community's own members all surround the intervention itself. The next part widens the lens from communities to populations.
HEAL connection: systems, services, and social construction
On the HEAL Framework for Wellbeing introduced in Lesson 1, a community program sits in health and social systems, and whether it reaches a given group is a question of services and supports, which are patterned by social position. Politics decides what is funded and for whom; in a discrete choice experiment with more than 3,000 participants, Card and colleagues (BMC Public Health, 2022) found that public funding preferences can disadvantage programs for marginalized groups.
HEAL calls the process by which collective behaviour reshapes the sociopolitical context social construction, and describes it as the place where change becomes possible. Treating communities as experts, building coalitions, and planning for sustainability all work through that process.
4.1 From Communities to Populations
Working with communities is one subset of the larger topic of working with populations. The difference lies in what holds the group together. Communities have a geographic component, a place with its own blend of people, resources, climate, economy, and social structure, although virtual communities without boundaries have become important too. A population is a wider idea. Health problems exist in aggregates of people at every level, and those aggregates may share a place, or they may already form a social group defined by something other than place: socioeconomic, ethnic, gender or age, virtual, or occupational. Population-based health promotion works with such aggregates, groups that share a place or a social characteristic linked to a health problem. By this we mean that the program is organized around whatever the members have in common that puts them at risk, whether or not they live near one another. Public health is by nature the business of population aggregates, so this way of working is central to the field rather than a special case.
The shared factor can take very different forms, and four examples show the range. For example, the factor may be biological, such as a genetic predisposition: sickle-cell anemia among African Americans or Tay-Sachs disease among Ashkenazi Jewish immigrants. It may be environmental, such as living where prevention services are limited and tobacco barely regulated. It may be a belief common to an age group, as when adolescents' beliefs about invulnerability raise the risk of alcohol-related crashes. Or it may be a shared activity, as with intense Internet gamers whose energy drink use and inactivity put them at risk. In each case, the aggregate is defined by the factor that links its members to the health problem.
However, defining a group by what its members share brings a risk with it, and this caution matters in Canada. Overemphasizing a group's shared characteristics stigmatizes and stereotypes, because it can make the shared factor seem to be the whole of who the members are. Still, a planner cannot simply ignore the shared factor, since it is the reason the group is at risk. To work with a population at risk because of factors common to the group, you have to gain familiarity with it and work with its environment, dynamics, social structures, and behaviour, as with a community. Familiarity, not emphasis on what members share, is the safeguard: knowing the group well lets a program address the shared risk without reducing the members to it.
Common confusion: population-based is not one-size-fits-all
Population-based does not mean one-size-fits-all. The word population describes whom the program is organized around, not how uniform the program must be. The aggregate could be a whole province or a few hundred occupational drivers, and in both cases the members share a factor that links them to a health problem. However, the way that factor shows up, and the messages, places, and times that will reach the members, still differ from one population to another. Either way, the next step is the same: tailoring.
Population-based health promotion, then, works with aggregates that share a place or a social characteristic, and it depends on familiarity with the population while avoiding the stigma that comes from overemphasizing what its members share. The two obligations named at the start of this section apply to communities and populations alike, and the next part takes up the first of them, tailoring.
4.2 Tailoring
4.2.1 Five Requirements of a Tailored Program
A key to health promotion in communities and populations is tailoring, which in a sense is what this whole course has been discussing. To tailor a program is to fit it to the particular population it serves, rather than delivering the same program everywhere. The purpose of doing so is that a health problem takes a different shape in each population, so a program that fits one group may miss another. A tailored program has five requirements. First, it is based on an assessment of the health problem as it takes shape in that population. Second, it includes the community in its design, which is the communities-as-experts principle of 3.3 put to work. Third, it refers to relevant situations and people, so that members see their own lives in it. Fourth, it uses appropriate language and materials that the audience understands and accepts. Fifth, it schedules activities so people can come, in hours and places that fit members' lives. The first two requirements concern how the program is planned, and the last three concern how it meets its audience. Each of the five cards that follow gives an example of one requirement, several of them drawn from Long Beach.
Based on
an assessment
The program is developed from an assessment and understanding of the health problem as it takes shape in a particular population, subgroup, or community. The same problem, say youth vaping, takes a different shape in a Surrey secondary school and a fly-in community in the north, and the assessment is what reveals the difference.
Inclusive
in design
The target community is included, as much as possible, in designing the program. This is the communities-as-experts principle applied at the design table rather than after the materials are printed.
Relevant situations
and people
The program refers, as much as possible, to situations, people, and issues relevant to the target community or population. Long Beach’s role model stories were written about local people overcoming local barriers for exactly this reason.
Appropriate language
and materials
The program uses language and materials appropriate for the audience. In Long Beach the women disliked the Risky Business title and would not be seen with it, so the program replaced it with a flyer whose name and content they accepted.
Scheduled so
people can come
Activities are scheduled, in hours and locations, so that members of the target population can participate. A parenting class at two in the afternoon on a weekday is tailored to nobody who works a day shift.
The five cards share a single test: would members of this particular population recognize the program as made for them and be able to attend it? A program can meet four requirements and still fail on the fifth, as a parenting class held at two in the afternoon fails every parent who works a day shift. Meeting the requirements rarely means designing from nothing, which is the subject of the next part.
4.2.2 Adapting an Effective Program
Tailoring does not mean starting from scratch. If every program had to be unique, enormous energy would go into design each time. In practice, there are usually commonalities across situations, and programs developed before that you can draw from. Tailoring therefore becomes a process of adapting an existing program as much as developing a new one. By adapting we mean keeping the core of a program that has worked elsewhere while changing what must change for the new population. The catch is that you want to adapt a program that is effective, since adapting an ineffective one only reproduces its failure. This is why so much weight now rests on best practice or evidence-based programs, and why registries that collect them are useful. American sources include federal clearinghouses, nonprofit associations, model program databases such as the CDC's Community Guide and the SAMHSA National Registry of Evidence-based Programs and Practices, and professional associations. Canadian planners can add McMaster University's Health Evidence database of rated systematic reviews, and for many years used the Public Health Agency of Canada's Canadian Best Practices Portal.
Developing or adapting a program usually involves three steps, and each answers a different question. The first is assessment of the problem, as in PRECEDE-PROCEED, which asks what the problem looks like in this population. The second is formative research with members of the population, through interviews and focus groups, which asks what adaptations are needed and which components, messages, and materials fit. The third is ongoing evaluation during implementation, which asks whether the program is working as delivered so that changes can be made while it runs, rather than only at the end. For example, Long Beach's repeated revisions of its materials were the third step in action. It is worth keeping the five requirements and the three steps distinct: the requirements describe what a finished tailored program looks like, while the steps describe the process of getting there. The word tailoring is also used in a narrower sense that you will meet in the health communication literature.
Targeting versus tailoring
In the health communication literature, Kreuter and Skinner proposed reserving targeting for adapting a message to a group and tailoring for adapting it to one individual based on that person's assessed characteristics (Kreuter and Skinner, 2000). This lesson uses tailoring in the broader sense, for adapting a program to a community or population. Both usages are common; when you read a program description, check which sense is intended.
Tailoring bases a program on an assessment of the population it serves, includes that population in design, and can adapt an effective existing program through formative research and ongoing evaluation. A tailored program still has to survive the end of its funding, which is the second obligation and the subject of the next part.
4.3 Sustainability
Most funding for community programs lasts three or four years, and it may take a year or more before a program is even established. In other words, a program may have only two or three working years before its money ends. So what happens when the funding dries up? It is very awkward to up and leave a community just when a needed program gets going, and it does not help relations with the community the next time a program is proposed. Sustainability is the capacity of a program to continue after its original funding ends. The answer to the funding problem is to plan for it from the start, rather than in the final year: add steps along the way that build community capacity to run the program and link with other funding. The idea behind all five steps is the same, namely to move responsibility for the program, and the means to pay for it, from the original funder to the community and its partners. Five steps do that work:
- Train and hire community members to operate the program.
- Bring in interest holders with a stake in keeping it going.
- Search for other sources of funds.
- Write applications, and train community members to write them.
- Link the program to others like it.
Interactive 7.2 lets you test a plan against these steps. It describes a three-year grant for diabetes prevention in a northern community and offers ten actions. Tick the actions you would build in, then press Assess the plan to see which of the five steps your choices cover and why the other actions do not help.
📊 Interactive 7.2: The three-year plan.
A health authority has a three-year grant for diabetes prevention in a northern community. Tick the actions you would build in, then assess.The actions that fail the test share a pattern: they add activity or reporting without leaving anyone in the community able to run the program, or anyone outside the original funder willing to pay for it. Worked Example 7.5 reads the five steps against a national case, ParticipACTION, which closed in 2001 after its federal funding ended; watch which steps transfer directly from a local program to a national organization and which need translating.
Worked Example 7.5: ParticipACTION's Funding Ended
The case. ParticipACTION, launched in 1971 and remembered for comparing a 30-year-old Canadian with a 60-year-old Swede, closed in 2001 after federal funding ended and was relaunched in 2007 with renewed government support. For six years the country's best-known physical activity brand did not exist. Which of the five sustainability steps apply to a national organization rather than a local program, and which would need translation?
Step 1: Diagnose the failure. ParticipACTION depended on a single funder, so when federal funding ended, the program ended. Read against the five steps, it was missing the steps that spread dependence: searching for other sources of funds and bringing in interest holders with a stake in keeping it going.
Step 2: Identify the steps that transfer directly. Searching for other funds, bringing in interest holders, and linking the program to others like it apply to a national organization exactly as they do to a local program.
Step 3: Translate the remaining steps. Training and hiring community members, and training them to write applications, assume a single community. For a national organization they translate into building the capacity of the partner organizations and communities that deliver its activities, so that those partners can carry the work and raise funds for it.
What the example shows. The five steps are a diagnosis as well as a plan: when a program ends with its funding, the missing steps usually explain why.
Whatever steps you take, the idea is to connect the program with the community and build its capacity to carry on. The next two sections apply that principle to schools and worksites.
This section has shown that the intervention is only part of the picture: the choice of issue is political, programs run through community structures with motives of their own, and the community is the best source of expertise about itself. It has widened the lens from communities to populations and set out the two obligations of tailoring and sustainability. The key takeaways and knowledge check that follow review this material.
Key Takeaways
- 3.1 In any community the intervention is almost always just part of the picture. Several health issues compete at once, each has advocates pushing for attention and resources, and the issue is often dictated by the funder's mandate, in Canada as in the United States. An open-ended grant gives room to tailor but invites lobbying; mandated funds settle the issue but not the politics. When a case describes competing demands, the strong answer keeps the funder's mandate as the core while bringing the competing groups in to shape how it is delivered, rather than ignoring the politics or handing the program to whoever is loudest.
- 3.2 Programs are implemented through community structures: government agencies and leaders, task forces, advisory boards, grassroots organizations, professional groups, and coalitions. Each may have motives of its own, such as credit, control of the agenda, funding for its services, or its own survival, and each may carry internal rivalries. The lesson of the coalition that split after the money arrived is not to avoid coalitions but to manage them while keeping the focus, resources, and activities on the program's goal. If a question asks what a fractured coalition teaches, look for the option about managing motives and rivalries, not the one that abandons community partners.
- 3.3 There is no better expertise on a community than the community's own. Community health outreach workers, members of a high-risk population employed to connect their peers to a program, know local patterns and customs, and, more important, they bring legitimacy because they are perceived as knowing how it is. VANDU's peer workers and First Nations health governance under OCAP show the principle at two levels, program delivery and ownership of data. In exam questions, the most important contribution of outreach workers is legitimacy, and community participation belongs at the design stage, not after materials are printed.
- 4.1 Population-based health promotion works with aggregates of people who share a place or a social characteristic, such as a genetic predisposition, a poorly regulated environment, an age group's beliefs, or a pastime like intense gaming. It does not mean one-size-fits-all: the aggregate can be a province or a few hundred drivers, and the next step is always tailoring. The caution is that overemphasizing a group's shared characteristics stigmatizes and stereotypes, so the safeguard is familiarity with the population's environment, dynamics, social structures, and behaviour. A good answer avoids both extremes, neither ignoring what the group shares nor defining the group by it.
- 4.2 A tailored program is based on an assessment of the problem in that population, includes the community in design, refers to relevant situations and people, uses appropriate language and materials, and is scheduled so people can come. Tailoring usually means adapting an effective existing program, found through evidence-based registries, rather than starting from scratch. Adapting follows three steps in order: assessment, formative research with the population through interviews and focus groups, and ongoing evaluation during implementation so changes can be made. Watch for options that skip formative research or push evaluation to the end; and remember that some writers use tailoring only for adapting a message to one individual, which is not this lesson's sense.
- 4.3 Funding usually lasts three or four years, and a program can take a year to establish, so sustainability has to be planned from day one. The five steps are to train and hire community members to run the program, bring in interest holders who want it to continue, search for other funds, write applications and train community members to write them, and link the program to others like it. Each step builds the community's capacity to carry on. When a case asks what to do with remaining money or time, choose capacity over activity: a bigger final campaign, an outside facilitator, or a final report alone leaves no one able to run the program next year.
1. A health promotion team receives an open-ended grant with no health issue specified. Why is this both a good and a difficult position?
2. A coalition of businesses, two churches, a tenant advocate, and two clinics agrees enthusiastically to a smoking prevention project, then splits once funding arrives, with one member using the project to build her own power base. What general lesson does this scenario teach?
3. An HIV prevention program hires people with lived experience of injection drug use as community health outreach workers. Beyond their knowledge of local drug use patterns, what is their most important contribution?
4. A health unit wants to adapt an evidence-based parenting program developed in Ontario for use in a Punjabi-speaking community in Surrey. Which sequence matches the three-step process for developing or adapting a program?
5. A three-year community program is in its final months and the team is deciding what to do with the remaining budget. Which choice best reflects the guidance on sustainability?
6. A regional health authority receives a three-year federal grant whose terms require nutrition education to reduce type 2 diabetes risk in a small northern community. On arrival, the band council wants the money spent on a youth recreation centre, the clinic physician wants screening and medication adherence, and the grocery co-op is worried about being blamed for food prices. Which response best reflects this section?
7. In the same northern community, which step most clearly treats the community as the expert on its own health?
8. A health unit describes its program for long-haul truck drivers as population-based, and a colleague concludes that it must therefore use identical materials across the whole province. What is wrong with the colleague's conclusion?
✦ Pass the knowledge check with 100% to continue
Settings for Intervention I: Schools
⏱ Estimated reading time: 18 minutes
Overview
The first two sections of this lesson concerned the communities and populations that programs serve; this section turns to the places and routes through which programs reach them, beginning with the school. It defines settings and channels and explains why the choice of setting narrows the choice of theory. It then explains why schools are the classic setting for health education and why they are nonetheless hard to work in, describes the comprehensive and coordinated approaches to school health, and shows how a PRECEDE-PROCEED style assessment of a school points to the family of theory a problem belongs to. It closes with three theory-based school programs and the Canadian school policies that act on the same problems.
Learning Objectives
- 5.1 Distinguish a setting from a channel, and explain why the choice of setting narrows the choice of theory.
- 5.2 Give the four reasons that schools are a classic setting for health education and the four reasons that school interventions are complex.
- 5.3 Describe comprehensive school health education, the eight components of the Coordinated School Health Program, and the four components of Canada's comprehensive school health framework.
- 6.1 Apply a PRECEDE-PROCEED style assessment to a school, naming what each phase examines and where its data come from.
- 6.2 Match a school problem to the family of theory that fits it.
- 7.1 Describe Life Skills Training, the South Windsor obesity prevention program, and Not On Tobacco, identify the theory behind each, and relate them to Canadian school policy.
5.1 Settings, Channels, and Theory
Whatever your intervention, it will be delivered somewhere and through something, and these are two different decisions. A setting is the specific place where program components are delivered: schools, hospitals, worksites, mobile units. A channel, by contrast, is the route through which a program reaches its audience: print media, community groups, the Internet, social media. One way to keep the two apart is to ask "where?" for a setting and "through what?" for a channel. For example, the Long Beach project in Section 1 was based in storefront locations (its setting) and reached its audience through small media and peer volunteers (its channels).
The distinction matters because settings and channels have characteristics of their own, and they draw on theoretical approaches that make sense for the setting and its population. In other words, once you know where a program will happen, some theories become more natural choices than others. The standard example is blunt: a school-based intervention is likely to be a curriculum delivered in a classroom, so community mobilization is probably not the approach you would reach for. This lesson pairs schools and worksites because they share a few characteristics. Both have an audience that is present for much of the day, and in both there is a synergy between health objectives and the organization's own goals, since healthy students learn better and healthy workers work better.
The setting narrows the theory; it does not forbid one
The classroom example is about fit, not a ban. Mobilization still has a place in schools when the problem is a school board, a budget, or a crumbling building, and Not On Tobacco combined community mobilization with classroom-style sessions. Read "probably not the approach you would use" as a first choice that the assessment can overturn.
The rest of this section applies that principle to the setting most often used for health education, starting with what makes schools attractive and what makes them difficult.
5.2 Why Schools, and Why They Are Hard
Schools are the classic setting for health education, for four reasons. The first is that health and education are intertwined: students cannot learn, and sometimes cannot attend, if they are not healthy, so a school has its own reason to care about health. The second is that students spend much of the day at school, which makes them a captive audience, one a program can reach regularly without having to recruit it. The third is that families interact with schools, so schools are a channel for reaching families too. The fourth is history: school health promotion dates from early in the 20th century, so infrastructure such as school nurses and health classes already exists. These reasons also explain the usual shape of school programs. Because school activities are classroom based, school health programs have typically been curricula, educational or skill-building in nature.
However, the same setting that makes schools attractive also makes them difficult, and school interventions are complex, also for four reasons. The first is the developmental stage of the young people involved, where social pressures, identity formation, group affiliation, and biological change all affect what you are trying to achieve. The second is the politics of social and health programs in schools. The third is the greatly increased demand on schools to act in a broader social capacity: schools are asked to take on much of the task of bringing up children, to educate children with high needs and from wider backgrounds, and, more recently, to take responsibility for security. The fourth is competing priorities with scarce resources. School health has typically been a low priority, and schools are not always welcoming to outside programs, so building a working relationship with a school is a normal part of the process.
Both lists matter on an exam: the first explains why a planner chooses a school, and the second predicts the obstacles the plan will meet. One response to those obstacles has been to treat school health as the work of the whole school rather than of one classroom, which is the subject of the next part.
5.3 Comprehensive and Coordinated School Health
Two American terms describe how far school health can reach, and they are easy to confuse because both sound like "the whole of school health." Comprehensive school health education, in the American usage, is classroom instruction that addresses the physical, mental, emotional, and social dimensions of health, develops health knowledge, attitudes, and skills, and is tailored to each age level. By this we mean that it is comprehensive in the topics it teaches, but it remains instruction delivered in the classroom. Broader still is the Coordinated School Health Program supported by the CDC and the American School Health Association. It treats health education as only one part of the picture and coordinates it with the services, food, environment, staff, and families around the student. It has eight components: health education, physical education, health services, nutrition services, counselling and psychological services, a healthy school environment, health promotion for staff, and family and community involvement. The eight cards that follow name these components, each with a short description and a Canadian example where one applies.
Health
education
A kindergarten to grade 12 curriculum covering a wide range of topics: nutrition, injury prevention, personal, family, and community health, sexuality, substance use, and more. This is the classroom component that most people picture when they hear school health.
Physical
education
Also a kindergarten to grade 12 curriculum. In Canada, provincial physical and health education curricula and policies such as Ontario’s daily physical activity requirement sit here.
Health
services
Services delivered at or through the school, from the school nurse to immunization clinics run by the public health unit. In British Columbia, school-based immunization for grades 6 and 9 is delivered by regional health authority nurses.
Nutrition
services
School meals, snacks, and the food environment. The South Windsor program below, Ontario’s school food and beverage policy, and Canada’s National School Food Program all belong to this component.
Counselling and
psychological services
School counsellors, psychologists, and mental health supports. Given the emphasis above on developmental stage, this component addresses the identity, affiliation, and social pressure issues that shape every other outcome.
Healthy school
environment
Facilities and social conditions at the school: heating that works, safe playgrounds, clean water, and a social climate free of hate speech and violence. The behavioural and environmental assessment below looks here.
Health promotion
for staff
Teachers and staff are also a population with health needs, and their morale and stability appear in the social assessment below. A school that promotes staff health is also modelling it for students.
Family and community
involvement
Parents and the surrounding community as partners. Because families interact with schools, this component turns the school into a channel for reaching households, and it is where community organization theory enters the school setting.
Taken together, the eight components reach well beyond the classroom, to the building, the food, the staff, and the families. If you consider the ecological model, these approaches make a lot of sense, because the ecological model holds that behaviour is shaped at several levels at once, and a coordinated program acts on several of those levels within one school. The drawback is that they require resources. Greenberg and colleagues at the Collaborative for Academic, Social, and Emotional Learning likewise advocate school health within a coordinated effort to develop students academically, socially, and in healthy behaviour and work habits.
Canada organizes the same territory under a different name, and a student should be careful not to confuse it with the American term above. The Pan-Canadian Joint Consortium for School Health, a partnership of federal, provincial, and territorial health and education ministries formed in 2005, promotes comprehensive school health. In the Canadian usage this is not classroom instruction but a whole-school framework, much closer in scope to the Coordinated School Health Program. It has four interrelated components drawn from the World Health Organization's health promoting schools approach: the social and physical environment, teaching and learning, healthy school policy, and partnerships and services. Figure 7.2 shows the four components around comprehensive school health.
Figure 7.2. The four interrelated components of comprehensive school health in Canada's framework (JCSH): social and physical environment, teaching and learning, healthy school policy, and partnerships and services; the CDC model uses eight.
The fit between the two models is close: the CDC's curricula sit in teaching and learning, its services and family involvement in partnerships and services, and its environment and staff health in the social and physical environment, while healthy school policy names the administrative level the CDC model leaves implicit. The Canadian framework puts policy on the diagram. Whichever model a school uses, the planner still has to find out which of its many problems to address, and that is the work of the assessment.
6.1 Assessing the School Setting
To decide which theory applies, run a brief PRECEDE-PROCEED style assessment of the school. By this we mean using the phases of the PRECEDE-PROCEED planning model, but applying them to one setting, so that each phase asks its question about this particular school. The purpose of doing so is to find out where a problem actually sits before choosing how to address it. The phases move from the broad context to the practical conditions for a program. The social assessment reads the climate around the school, such as safety, poverty, and teacher morale. The epidemiological assessment asks which health problems matter there. The behavioural and environmental assessment looks at what people do and at the condition of the building. The educational and ecological assessment asks what students, staff, and families know, believe, and can do, and which norms reinforce behaviour. Finally, the administrative and policy assessment maps the politics, from school board approval to the consent needed to evaluate anything. The five tabs that follow take the phases in turn and name the data sources for each, including Canadian ones. Open each tab and note, for each phase, one thing it examines and one place its data come from.
Social assessment: the climate around the school
Consider the community context, or what Jane Jacobs's work on cities would call environmental design: neighbourhood safety, recreation areas and libraries, poverty and family well-being, barriers to education (economic, linguistic, class size, resources for learning disabilities), teacher stability, pay, and morale, community participation, and whether students feel bonded to the school. A school where the economy is down, funding is tight, pay is low, violence is common, and teachers rarely stay is clearly problematic: not impossible, but a challenge. In Canada, census profiles and the Early Development Instrument feed this phase.
Epidemiological assessment: which health problems matter here
Use local public health data on school-age children, or data for the largest relevant unit with local estimates. Schools keep their own data (attendance, injuries, discipline, nurse visits, outbreaks, hazards such as mould or lead), but these are not easy to obtain, nor should they be: schools are very sensitive about data that might appear in public with a negative spin. Canadian sources include health authority child health reports and immunization coverage data.
Behavioural and environmental assessment: what people do and what surrounds them
Environmental risks include the condition of the school: failing heating, chemicals used in repairs, holes in the basketball court, nearby hazards. Behavioural risks are what personnel, students, and families do or do not do: bathrooms without soap, families who do not immunize, students who carry weapons, tolerated hate speech. The standard American sources are the CDC Youth Risk Behavior Survey, Monitoring the Future, and the Search Institute's surveys. Canada's counterparts are the Health Behaviour in School-aged Children study (Queen's University), the Canadian Student Tobacco, Alcohol and Drugs Survey, the Ontario Student Drug Use and Health Survey (Centre for Addiction and Mental Health, since 1977), and the BC Adolescent Health Survey (McCreary Centre Society, every five years since 1992). School-specific data remain hard to get.
Educational and ecological assessment: knowledge, attitudes, skills, norms
This phase touches most of the theoretical issues: what students, staff, families, and the community know; attitudes toward risk; which skills are common; the norms that reinforce behaviour. It matters especially in schools because education is the organizational purpose of the setting, so educational interventions fit most naturally. Such data are hard to come by outside specific studies, though youth surveys collect some.
Administrative and policy assessment: the political environment
Schools and school boards are political bodies, because education touches people's values about how children should be raised. Dental health may cause little trouble; HIV prevention, adolescent pregnancy, or substance use can be a political minefield. Board approval is typically needed, along with slow work to gain support within a school where health is rarely the top priority. Sometimes the opposition is elsewhere: think who would object to banning high-fat snacks at and around a school. Evaluation needs consent from schools, students, and parents, which stigma makes harder. Organizational and community advocacy may have to be part of the intervention. In Canada, elected boards and parent advisory councils are the arena.
Two points from the tabs recur in exam questions. School data are hard to obtain, and should be, because schools are sensitive about information that might appear in public with a negative spin. And the administrative and policy phase often decides whether a program happens at all, because school boards are political bodies and topics such as HIV prevention, adolescent pregnancy, and substance use can be a minefield. Once the phases have described the school's problems, the next step is to decide which family of theory each problem belongs to.
6.2 Which Theory Fits?
The assessment describes the school's problems; the next task is to decide which kind of theory each problem calls for. A useful starting point is to ask what a classroom can address. A classroom program can build knowledge of consequences, help students personalize risk, teach skills to counter risk, show students where to go for support, and build confidence through role-playing, and it can draw on supportive networks and the school's physical environment. However, interventions may not focus on classrooms at all, because some problems do not sit with students. For example, if the assessment finds crumbling facilities, the fix is funding, which is a political issue for the board or legislature rather than a lesson plan. Similarly, if the key is reaching families, other theories apply. The candidates fall into four families, each suited to a different place where a problem can sit:
- Individual knowledge and attitudes, such as the Health Belief Model and the Theory of Planned Behavior, for problems of what students know and believe.
- Interaction between person and environment, above all Social Cognitive Theory with its observational learning, skills, and self-efficacy, for problems of skill and confidence.
- Mobilization of communities and organizations, for problems that sit with a school board, a budget, or the community around the school.
- Approaches to the built environment, for problems with the building, the playground, or the cafeteria.
Interactive 7.3 presents six school problems and asks which family you would reach for first in each. Choose a family from each menu, then press Check my matches and read the note under each row, which explains the reasoning.
📊 Interactive 7.3: Match the school problem to the theory family.
Choose the family you would reach for first, then check all rows.1. Grade 9 students believe vaping is harmless and that most classmates vape, when surveys show a minority do.
2. Students know the risks but say they cannot refuse a cigarette from an older friend without losing face.
3. The gym has been closed for repairs for a year and the playground has no usable equipment.
4. The elected board has refused a sexual health curriculum and parent groups are publicly divided.
5. The cafeteria sells donuts for less than fruit, and the vending machines carry only chips and pop.
6. Students who want to quit smoking have nowhere to turn, and those caught are suspended.
The matcher shows that the family follows the problem, not the setting: a mistaken belief calls for an individual approach, a missing skill for Social Cognitive Theory, a refusing board for mobilization, and a broken gym or a cafeteria full of donuts for the built environment. Worked Example 7.6 applies the same reasoning to a provincial policy whose problem was not the students at all; watch which assessment phase would have predicted the trouble.
Worked Example 7.6: Ontario's Daily Physical Activity Requirement
The case. In 2005 Ontario's Ministry of Education issued Policy/Program Memorandum No. 138, requiring every elementary school to give students in grades 1 to 8 at least twenty minutes of sustained moderate to vigorous physical activity each school day during instructional time. Implementation studies have found delivery uneven, with teachers citing time, space, and competing curriculum demands. Which assessment phase would have predicted the implementation problem, and which family of theory would improve delivery?
Step 1: Classify the policy. The requirement applies to every student in grades 1 to 8, whatever their activity level, so it is a universal policy. It sits in the physical education component of coordinated school health, and it changed the rules rather than any student's knowledge.
Step 2: Find the phase that predicts the problem. Teachers' reasons (time, space, and competing curriculum demands) are findings of the administrative and policy assessment, which examines the policy environment and the reality that health competes with many other demands on a school and is typically a low priority. A policy that adds twenty minutes to a crowded instructional day without addressing time, space, and capacity is exactly the gap this phase reveals.
Step 3: Choose the family of theory. Teachers did not report a lack of knowledge or a negative attitude, so an individual knowledge and attitudes approach aimed at teachers would miss the problem. The obstacles are organizational (timetables, priorities, resources) and physical (space), which point to mobilization of the school organization and to the built environment.
What the example shows. A universal policy changes what schools are required to do, but delivery still depends on the organization that must carry it out. The common mistake is to answer an organizational problem with more education.
The example shows that the four families apply to policies as well as to classroom programs: the assessment says where the problem sits, and the family follows. The next part looks at three programs, each built on a different answer to the matcher.
7.1 Three Theory-Based School Programs
Three programs show the families in action, and each was built on a different answer to the question of where the problem sits. Life Skills Training, developed by Gilbert Botvin, locates the problem in students' skills. It is a three-year classroom program of fifteen 45-minute periods for middle school students that teaches self-management, social skills, and drug resistance skills. Its theory is Social Cognitive Theory together with the risk and protective factors model, which is why it rehearses skills rather than only presenting facts.
The South Windsor, Connecticut, obesity prevention program locates the problem in the food environment instead. It changed what the school sold, priced donuts above healthier snacks, marketed new menus to families, and enlisted food service staff. In theoretical terms, it combined social marketing, policy, and environmental change, so students' choices changed because the options around them changed. Not On Tobacco (N-O-T), from West Virginia, drew on three theories, each for a different job. It used diffusion of innovations to spread through schools, Social Cognitive Theory for skills and support, and community mobilization for participatory design. Students attended ten voluntary weekly sessions plus boosters, and participants were twice as likely to have quit at three months. The practical point for analysing any of these programs is to match each component to the theory that explains it, rather than giving one theory for the whole program. Each program is described in more detail below. Compare the theory behind each program with the problems in Interactive 7.3.
Life Skills Training: Social Cognitive Theory and risk and protective factors
A substance use prevention program developed by Gilbert Botvin in response to programs he argued failed because they either presented only facts about consequences or used discussion to enrich personal development. Life Skills Training addresses the psychosocial causes of early substance use: drug-related expectancies (knowledge, attitudes, norms), resistance skills, and general competence (self-management and social skills). Its theory is a person-environment interactionist approach, Social Cognitive Theory, with the risk and protective factors model. By person-environment interactionist we mean that behaviour is explained by the person and the surroundings acting on each other, so a student's skills and confidence matter alongside the peers and settings that offer drugs. The risk and protective factors model adds that some conditions raise the likelihood of substance use (risk factors) while others lower it or buffer against it (protective factors), so a program can work by strengthening protective factors such as social competence. The program also follows the developmental progression of drug involvement, including the rising emphasis on peers and the drive for autonomy in early adolescence. This is why it teaches resistance and self-management skills at the age when peer influence is growing, rather than waiting until use has begun. It is a three-year classroom program of fifteen 45-minute periods for middle school students, with boosters. Drug use has been cut in half in some instances.
South Windsor obesity prevention: social marketing, policy, and the food environment
The South Windsor, Connecticut, schools program used marketing and environmental actions to increase intake of lower fat, more nutritious foods. Its theory combined social marketing, regulations and policies, and environmental change: high-fat foods were made less available, better choices were marketed, and the cost of choosing better food was lowered. Components included vending machines with healthy options, better lunches, lower-value snacks such as donuts priced higher, colourful menus sent to families, coupons, and training for food service staff, who were enlisted in a catering service to increase buy-in. The program's own early reports described strong sales of healthier items, but no published evaluation of those results could be found, so the program serves here as an example of theory in program design, and its effect remains untested.
Not On Tobacco: diffusion of innovations, Social Cognitive Theory, and community mobilization
In the mid-1990s West Virginia led the United States in teen smoking. The West Virginia University Prevention Research Center, with state agencies, the American Lung Association, and others, developed N-O-T to enhance adolescent health, serve students who want to quit, reduce tobacco policy violations, and provide an educational alternative to punishment. Its theory begins with diffusion of innovations, because the program had to spread through the complex school environment. Diffusion of innovations holds that a new practice is adopted faster when potential adopters see it as having certain attributes, so dissemination stressed those attributes. Relative advantage means the program is seen as better than what schools already do, here an educational alternative to suspension. Compatibility means it fits the school's existing values and routines, low complexity means it is easy to understand and run, observability means its results can be seen by others, and trialability means a school can try it on a small scale before committing. Advocates served as change agents, the people who carried the program to schools and helped them adopt it. It also used Social Cognitive Theory (skills, social support, goal setting) and community mobilization through participatory design. Students voluntarily attend ten weekly hour-long sessions and four boosters in same-sex groups with same-sex facilitators, working on reasons for smoking, nicotine addiction, advertising ploys, relapse triggers, cognitive restructuring, coping, and assertiveness. One review of more than 6,000 youths in 489 schools found participants twice as likely as comparison youth to have quit at three months (Horn et al., 2005). It is a SAMHSA model program and a National Cancer Institute research-tested intervention.
The three programs answer three different problems: Life Skills Training builds individual skills and competence, South Windsor changes the environment in which students choose food, and Not On Tobacco serves students who want to quit while spreading itself through the school system. Canadian provinces and the federal government have since acted on the same school food problem through policy, and Worked Example 7.7 compares that policy route with South Windsor's design.
Worked Example 7.7: School Food Policy from South Windsor to Canada
The case. Ontario's School Food and Beverage Policy (Policy/Program Memorandum No. 150), in effect since September 2011, sets nutrition standards for food sold in publicly funded schools, limiting low-value products in cafeterias and vending machines. British Columbia's Feeding Futures fund (2023) gives districts money to expand school food programs, and the federal National School Food Program (2024) funds provinces and territories to extend meals. South Windsor combined environmental change with social marketing and food service buy-in. Which does a provincial standard supply on its own, and which must each school add?
Step 1: Identify what the policies act on. Each policy works on the environment rather than on what students know: what may be sold, and how much money is available for meals.
Step 2: Break South Windsor into its parts. South Windsor had three: environmental change (high-fat foods made less available and lower-value snacks priced higher), social marketing (healthier choices marketed to students, colourful menus and coupons sent to families), and buy-in from food service staff, who were trained and enlisted in a catering service.
Step 3: Compare. A provincial nutrition standard supplies the environmental change on its own, because it removes low-value products from sale. It does not market the healthier options or win over the staff who prepare and sell them, so each school has to add the social marketing and the food service buy-in.
What the example shows. Policy and environment are a strong first step, but South Windsor's results came from combining them with marketing and the people who run the cafeteria.
Schools have a captive audience, a purpose that favours education, and a political environment that must be assessed and sometimes changed. Next, the worksite, where the audience is adult and the purpose is productivity.
This section has defined settings and channels, given the reasons that schools are a classic setting and the reasons that school interventions are complex, and compared the CDC's Coordinated School Health Program with Canada's comprehensive school health framework. It has applied a PRECEDE-PROCEED style assessment to the school setting, matched theory families to school problems, and described three theory-based school programs. The key takeaways and knowledge check that follow review this material.
Key Takeaways
- 5.1 A setting is the place where program components are delivered, such as a school, hospital, worksite, or mobile unit, and a channel is the route to the audience, such as print media, community groups, the Internet, or social media. Each setting has characteristics that favour some theories over others, so a classroom curriculum is unlikely to be built on community mobilization. The principle is about fit, not prohibition: mobilization still belongs in a school when the problem is a board or a budget. If a question asks what the classroom example illustrates, the answer is that the setting shapes the theory, not that a theory is banned there.
- 5.2 Schools are the classic setting for health education because health and education are intertwined, students are a captive audience for much of the day, schools are a channel to families, and school health infrastructure has existed for a century. They are hard to work in because of the students' developmental stage, the politics of health programs in schools, the much broader social role now demanded of schools, and competing priorities with scarce resources. Learn the two lists as a pair: the first justifies choosing a school, and the second predicts the obstacles. When a principal says the timetable and budget are full, that is competing priorities with scarce resources, and building a relationship with the school is a normal part of the work.
- 5.3 Comprehensive and coordinated school health apply the ecological model to a whole school. Comprehensive school health education is age-appropriate classroom instruction across the physical, mental, emotional, and social dimensions of health. The CDC's Coordinated School Health Program has eight components: health education, physical education, health services, nutrition services, counselling and psychological services, a healthy school environment, health promotion for staff, and family and community involvement. Canada's comprehensive school health framework, promoted by the Joint Consortium for School Health, has four: social and physical environment, teaching and learning, healthy school policy, and partnerships and services. Keep the two lists distinct, since exam options often mix them, and remember that the Canadian model puts policy on the diagram.
- 6.1 A PRECEDE-PROCEED style assessment of a school runs through five phases. The social phase reads the climate around the school, from neighbourhood safety and poverty to teacher morale and student bonding; the epidemiological phase asks which health problems matter, using public health data and closely guarded school records; the behavioural and environmental phase looks at what people do and at the building, using youth surveys such as the BC Adolescent Health Survey; the educational and ecological phase asks what people know, believe, and can do and which norms apply; and the administrative and policy phase maps board approval, controversial topics, and consent. When a case mentions a nervous board, divided parents, or a topic such as substance use or sexual health, start with the administrative and policy phase, because it decides whether a program can go ahead at all.
- 6.2 The assessment tells you which of four theory families a school problem belongs to: individual knowledge and attitudes (Health Belief Model, Theory of Planned Behavior) for mistaken beliefs, person and environment (Social Cognitive Theory) for missing skills and self-efficacy, mobilization of communities and organizations for boards, budgets, and policies, and the built environment for buildings, playgrounds, and cafeterias. Read the problem, not the setting: a closed gym is a funding and political problem, so a curriculum on the benefits of exercise would miss it. Ontario's daily physical activity requirement shows the same reasoning for a policy, whose uneven delivery was an administrative problem of time, space, and competing demands rather than a gap in teachers' knowledge.
- 7.1 Three school programs show three theory choices. Life Skills Training is a three-year classroom program built on Social Cognitive Theory and the risk and protective factors model, teaching self-management, social, and drug resistance skills. The South Windsor program combined social marketing, policy, and environmental change to shift students toward healthier food. Not On Tobacco used diffusion of innovations to spread through schools, Social Cognitive Theory for skills and support, and community mobilization for participatory design, and offered students who want to quit an alternative to punishment. Canadian school food policies supply South Windsor's environmental change but leave each school to add the marketing and staff buy-in. To identify a program in a question, match its problem: prevention skills point to Life Skills Training, food environment to South Windsor, and quitting with an alternative to suspension to Not On Tobacco.
1. A health unit proposes a community mobilization strategy as the core of a grade 7 nutrition curriculum. Based on the relationship between settings and theory, what is the most likely problem with this choice?
2. A principal welcomes a proposed nutrition program in principle but says the timetable is already full of literacy and numeracy targets and there is no budget for anything new. Which of the reasons that school interventions are complex does this best illustrate?
3. A school's assessment finds that the gym has been closed for a year and the playground is unsafe. What kind of problem is this, and which theoretical approach follows?
4. Not On Tobacco was designed with diffusion of innovations theory as a central element. What did the developers use this theory for?
5. Ontario's Policy/Program Memorandum No. 138 requires twenty minutes of daily physical activity for all students in grades 1 to 8, yet studies found delivery uneven, with teachers citing time, space, and competing curriculum demands. Which PRECEDE-PROCEED assessment phase would most directly have anticipated this, and why?
6. Which statement best describes how the South Windsor obesity prevention program and Life Skills Training differ in their theoretical approach?
7. A Fraser Valley school district asks a public health unit for help with vaping. Students caught vaping are suspended, the board is nervous about anything that looks like condoning vaping, and several parents have complained to trustees. Which assessment phase should the team complete first, and why?
8. In the same district, the plan's first change is to replace suspension for vaping with an educational alternative. Which component of Canada's comprehensive school health framework does this change strengthen most directly?
✦ Pass the knowledge check with 100% to continue
Settings for Intervention II: Worksites
⏱ Estimated reading time: 16 minutes
Overview
There are a lot of good reasons to conduct health promotion in the workplace. More people are in workplaces than in most other accessible institutions, and they are there for most of their waking day; in the United States, many get their health benefits through work. Workplaces and schools share access to a population and a synergy between health objectives and organizational goals, but the worksite differs in ways that change the theory: its audience is adult and attends by choice, its purpose is productivity rather than learning, and its social life becomes the centre of attention. This section gives the reasons for workplace health promotion, traces how the field grew, names the barriers programs meet, applies the PRECEDE-PROCEED assessment to a worksite, matches theories to the workplace, and describes two model programs and Canada's national standard for psychological health and safety.
Learning Objectives
- 5.4 Give the reasons for workplace health promotion and the evidence on its costs and returns, and explain how the employer's stake differs in Canada.
- 5.5 Trace how workplace health promotion and employee assistance programs grew and changed.
- 5.6 Identify the barriers that workplace programs meet, including culture and the management-union relationship.
- 6.3 Apply a PRECEDE-PROCEED style assessment to a worksite, using Canadian data sources.
- 6.4 Identify the theories that fit a workplace's adult audience and its social and organizational character.
- 7.2 Describe the Healthy Workplace Program and Coping with Work and Family Stress, and identify the theory behind each.
- 7.3 Describe Canada's National Standard for Psychological Health and Safety in the Workplace, and explain the theory it relies on and the limits of a voluntary standard.
5.4 Why the Workplace
The central reason for working in the workplace is that health, work performance, safety, and productivity are intertwined. By this we mean that an employee's health is not separate from the employer's business: unhealthy workers miss time and have more accidents, so improving their health also serves the organization's goals. This is the synergy between health and organizational goals that 5.1 described for schools and worksites alike. It also explains why so much of the evidence on workplace programs is about money, since many studies find workplace health promotion cost-effective. The best-known figures are American. For example, at Procter and Gamble, employees who took part in the company's program had 29% lower health care costs than those who did not in its third year (Goetzel et al., 1998), and at Johnson and Johnson, inpatient costs rose more slowly at sites with its Live for Life program than at comparison sites (Bly, Jones, and Richardson, 1986). In addition, a CDC review reported returns of roughly $1.40 to $4.90 per dollar spent on worksite health management programs at nine organizations (Matson-Koffman et al., 2004). Beyond the financial case, workplaces share practical advantages with schools. Employees, like students, are a captive audience; workplaces have built-in communication and social support; and there is a long record of success. The CDC's Community Guide task force concluded that, in population health terms, workplace programs provided substantial benefits in health, awareness, and linkages to services. Those American cost figures do not carry over to Canada unchanged, for the reason the following callout explains.
In Canada, the employer's stake is different
In Canada the employer's stake differs, because hospital and physician care is publicly insured. By this we mean that when a Canadian employee is hospitalized or sees a physician, the provincial plan pays, not the employer, so an American figure such as Procter and Gamble's 29% difference in health care costs describes savings a Canadian employer would mostly not receive. What motivates Canadian employers instead is the set of costs they do carry: extended benefits such as drug and dental plans, disability claims, absenteeism, and compensation premiums paid to provincial boards such as WorkSafeBC. A business case for a Canadian program therefore has to be built on those costs. Occupational health and safety is regulated mainly by provinces and territories, with the Canadian Centre for Occupational Health and Safety, created by federal statute in 1978, as a national information body.
The reasons to work in the workplace are strong in both countries, but they did not appear all at once; the next part traces how workplace health promotion grew.
5.5 How Workplace Health Grew and Changed
The workplace has gained currency as a site for health promotion since the mid-1900s, for several reasons. The workforce itself changed, with more women and an aging workforce. Regulation and the rising cost of compensation and medical care gave employers a financial motive to prevent illness. Employee assistance programs rose, and the view of what counts as occupational health expanded. Each of these pushed employers to treat health as part of their concern.
Over the same period, the focus of workplace efforts evolved in three stages, each wider than the one before. It began with screening, meaning health appraisals and risk assessments that look for problems in individual employees. It then moved to environmental factors, the hazards and conditions at the worksite that affect health. Finally it broadened to health promotion and wellness, which addresses health in general rather than only work-related risks. Employee assistance programs evolved in parallel, from substance use treatment and drug testing to broad prevention. That change mattered for more than scope. A program known only for alcohol and drug problems carries a stigma, so employees avoid being seen using it; broadening the program reduced the stigma of being a program just for people with alcohol or drug problems. The four developments behind this growth are described below. The descriptions include the American legislation involved and the Canadian name for employee assistance programs.
A changing workforce: more women, older workers
The growing workforce of women prompted a need to address maternal health and child care, and an aging work population brought chronic disease into the workplace.
Regulation and cost: the Occupational Safety and Health Act, workers' compensation, managed care
The Occupational Safety and Health Act of 1970 created a federal agency to regulate workplace safety. Rising compensation and medical costs gave employers a motive to prevent health problems, managed care put employers closer to care delivery, and the Affordable Care Act of 2010 raised the stakes for prevention.
Employee assistance programs, from substance use to quality of life
Employee assistance programs rose as a vehicle for prevention and intervention with substance use, a major cause of accidents and absenteeism, and many now address family, workplace, and financial problems. They moved from treatment and drug testing to a much broader prevention focus, which took away some of the stigma that they were just for people with alcohol or drug problems. In Canada they are usually called employee and family assistance programs.
An expanded view of occupational health
Occupational health grew to include cardiovascular disease, high blood pressure, smoking, repetitive motion syndromes, and obesity. Workplace efforts evolved from screening (health appraisals and risk assessments) to environmental factors to broad wellness. Many employers now view health promotion as corporate social responsibility, though it is easier for larger firms. Published estimates of return on investment vary widely from study to study.
The four developments together explain why employers now treat health as part of their business, and why many view health promotion as corporate social responsibility. They also explain why programs aimed at sensitive problems such as substance use work better when they are folded into broader wellness, a point the model programs later in this section build on. Growth has not removed the obstacles, which are the subject of the next part.
5.6 Barriers to Workplace Programs
The barriers are as instructive as the reasons, because each one tells a planner what to look for before a program is launched. The first is personal: employees may be reluctant to mix personal health issues with work. The second is cultural. Wellness programs can clash with cultures whose messages about success include working very hard, not complaining, and not revealing personal information, so taking part in a program can feel like admitting weakness. The third is redundancy. For example, in hospitals or law offices the programs appear redundant to most employees, who already have access to the same information or services elsewhere. The fourth is practical: elsewhere employees simply lack the time or incentive to take part. The fifth barrier is structural, and it is often decisive. Participation tracks the support of both management and unions: there is frequently a strong relationship between management and union support of a program and participation in it. In other words, a program that one side does not back is unlikely to be used, however good its content.
Every barrier is a finding waiting to be made
Each barrier corresponds to something the assessment can discover before launch: reluctance and a culture of not complaining are educational and ecological findings, while redundancy, lack of time, and the state of management-union relations are administrative findings. A case that describes a program nobody uses is usually asking which barrier, and which phase, the planners missed.
Because each barrier can be found in advance, the assessment is where a workplace program succeeds or fails, and the next part runs it phase by phase.
6.3 Assessing the Worksite
6.3.1 The Five Phases at Work
Run the PRECEDE-PROCEED assessment again, and notice that the phases read differently at work. The phases are the same five used for the school in 6.1, but a worksite is a different kind of place, so each phase looks for different things.
The social assessment is unlike a community's. A community is usually one place, whereas workplaces can span several communities or be global, and they have their own culture and norms. Émile Durkheim, in The Division of Labor in Society, remarked on the differences between workplaces and communities. In addition, the workplace cares about productivity, hazards, and employee continuity more than general well-being. However, factors outside the workplace still matter. For example, a single employer in a down economy leaves workers under pressure to keep quiet about unsafe conditions, because losing the job would mean losing the only work in town.
The epidemiological assessment concerns work-related conditions, meaning the illnesses and injuries the work itself produces. The leading occupational illnesses and injuries include hearing loss, lung disease, cancer and lead poisoning, carbon monoxide poisoning, dermatitis, fertility and pregnancy abnormalities, infectious diseases, back and upper-extremity disorders, traumatic injuries, and adverse mental health outcomes.
The behavioural and environmental assessment looks at what workers do and at the conditions around them. On the behavioural side, it covers a truck driver or pilot who drinks before work, protective gear worn or not, and long hours without breaks. On the environmental side, it covers unsafe chemicals and equipment and environmental contributors to obesity. For example, if the only food is a vending machine of chips and donuts and a burger place down the road, with no time or place to walk, the environment will produce diet-related problems and eventually type 2 diabetes, whatever employees know about nutrition.
The educational and ecological assessment treats the workplace as a small, contained social setting where people spend a lot of time together. Because of that closeness, networks, support, and norms are the key issues, along with organizational culture and rewards. This phase also asks whether employees know a hazard exists, perceive it as a threat, and intend to act, since a hazard that workers do not take seriously will not be avoided. Finally, the administrative assessment maps policies, structures, and resources that a program could work through or would have to overcome: a wellness committee, benefits, an assistance program, gym discounts, screenings, unions, community organizations that offer workplace activities, and the regulations that govern the worksite.
Table 7.3 lists sources of data for three of the assessment's data needs, work-related injury and illness, substance use at work, and behavioural and environmental risks, with the United States sources and their Canadian counterparts.
Table 7.3. Data sources for a worksite assessment in the United States and their Canadian counterparts.
| Data need | United States sources | Canadian counterparts |
|---|---|---|
| Work-related injury and illness | Occupational Safety and Health Administration; National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health; Bureau of Labor Statistics injury survey | Provincial compensation boards (WorkSafeBC, WSIB); Association of Workers' Compensation Boards of Canada; Canadian Centre for Occupational Health and Safety |
| Substance use at work | Workplace Division of the Center for Substance Abuse Prevention; National Survey on Drug Use and Health | Canadian Alcohol and Drugs Survey; Canadian Centre on Substance Use and Addiction |
| Behavioural and environmental risks | OSHA and NIOSH, plus unions, chambers of commerce, business health coalitions, and workplaces themselves | Joint health and safety committee records, union safety representatives, employer benefit and absence data |
With the phases and their data sources in hand, the next part applies them to a single workplace.
6.3.2 Reading a Worksite
Cedar Ridge Forest Products runs a sawmill with about 240 unionized employees in a small town in the British Columbia Interior and has invited a public health unit to help. The mill returns later in this section as a running example. Interactive 7.4 lists eight observations from the site visit. Click an observation, then click the phase it informs, and read the feedback, which gives the reasoning for each placement.
📊 Interactive 7.4: Which phase does each observation inform?
Click an observation, then a phase.At Cedar Ridge the hearing problem shows up in four phases at once: in the claims data, in the skipped protection, in the belief that the noise is harmless, and in the crew leads whom new hires copy. An observation can feed two phases, as the unused assistance program does. The educational and ecological findings are where theory enters, which is the subject of the next part.
6.4 Which Theories Fit the Workplace?
Choosing theory for a workplace starts from two features of the setting: who the audience is, and what kind of organization surrounds them. Think first about the context for education. When would a workplace offer a program? At lunch, when employees want to eat, or after work, when they want to go home? Neither time is ideal, although health fairs have worked in many situations. More important, employees are adults who attend by choice. Unlike students in a classroom, they cannot be required to sit through a health lesson, so the approach should be engaging and hands-on, or should sell the benefits of the behaviour. The natural candidates for this adults-by-choice problem are therefore social marketing, which sells a behaviour by its benefits to the audience, the Health Belief Model, which works on how people perceive a threat and the benefits of acting, and diffusion of innovations, which explains how a new practice spreads.
The second feature is the organization. Workplaces are also organizations with cultures of their own, and four of their characteristics point to theory. There are leaders and influencers; there are groups of employees who are also friends; there are norms about what makes a good employee; and there are people who want to do well and be rewarded. Each characteristic suggests a different theory, because each describes a different way the organization influences behaviour. Leaders point to diffusion of innovations and Social Network Theory, since both explain how a practice spreads outward from people whom others watch and follow. Friendship groups point to Social Network Theory and Social Cognitive Theory, because friends pass on norms and support and learn by observing one another. Norms point to the Theory of Planned Behavior and culture theory, which explain how a shared sense of what a good employee does can encourage or discourage a behaviour. Rewards point to Social Cognitive Theory, whose reinforcement construct holds that people repeat what is rewarded. For example, if Cedar Ridge's crew leads start wearing hearing protection, diffusion and network theories predict that the practice will spread to the new hires who copy them. The four cards that follow each name one characteristic and the theories that speak to it, with an example from Cedar Ridge.
Leaders and
influencers
In organizations there may be individuals who are leaders or influencers. Diffusion of innovations supplies opinion leaders and change agents; Social Network Theory identifies who is central and who bridges groups. At Cedar Ridge, the crew leads are the place to start on hearing protection, whichever theory you name.
Employees who
are friends
Groups of employees may be friends. Social Network Theory and Social Cognitive Theory both apply: friendship ties carry norms and social support, and observational learning happens through them. Programs that recruit through existing friendship groups, as Long Beach recruited through peers, use this.
Norms about the
good employee
The workplace may have social norms about health-related behaviour, even tied to what people consider a good employee: working very hard, not complaining, not revealing personal information. Culture theory and the Theory of Planned Behavior’s subjective norm both speak to this, and changing such norms may require organizational change.
Wanting to do well
and be rewarded
People are at a job, and they want to do well and be rewarded. Social Cognitive Theory’s reinforcement and outcome expectations apply, and so does the organizational question of what the company rewards: if productivity bonuses reward skipping breaks, the reward structure is the intervention target.
To affect the culture itself, or build support for an intervention or policy, it may be necessary to engage in organizational change and bring influence from the surrounding community. Table 7.4 gathers the matches. Each of its five rows pairs a workplace problem with the theories that fit it and an example tactic.
Table 7.4. Workplace problems, the theories that fit each, and an example tactic.
| Workplace problem | Theories that fit | Example tactic |
|---|---|---|
| Adults attend by choice and need a reason to come | Social marketing, Health Belief Model, diffusion of innovations | A hands-on health fair that sells screening and makes it trialable on the spot |
| Influencers and friendship groups shape behaviour | Diffusion of innovations, Social Network Theory, Social Cognitive Theory | Recruit crew leads as change agents who model protective behaviour |
| Norms about the good employee discourage help-seeking | Culture theory, Theory of Planned Behavior, organizational change | Embed substance use content inside general wellness programming to defuse stigma |
| Rewards favour unhealthy behaviour | Social Cognitive Theory, organizational change | Change what bonuses reward |
| Management and union support decide participation | Organizational change, community organization | Run the program through the joint health and safety committee with both co-chairs involved |
Worked Example 7.8 uses Table 7.4 to diagnose and redesign a program that failed. Watch how each finding was a barrier from 5.6 that the assessment could have caught, and how the redesign names one theory for the audience and one for the organization.
Worked Example 7.8: The Program Nobody Uses
The case. A regional hospital in Ontario launches a wellness program: lunchtime yoga, an online health risk assessment with a gift card, and posters about the assistance program. Uptake after a year is under one in ten. Nurses get no lunch break most days, physicians say they can get any of this elsewhere, and evening-shift staff never see the classes. What would the administrative assessment have told the planners before launch, and how should the program be redesigned?
Step 1: Match the findings to the barriers. Each finding was named in advance. Nurses without a lunch break lack the time; physicians who can get it elsewhere illustrate that such programs appear redundant in hospitals; and evening staff who never see the classes show a program that was not scheduled so people can come, one of the five requirements of tailoring.
Step 2: Name what the administrative assessment would have found. Mapping policies, structures, and resources would have shown shift schedules, break practices, the existing benefits and assistance program, and whether management and the unions supported the program, before any money was spent.
Step 3: Choose a theory for the audience. Staff are adults who attend by choice, so social marketing fits: sell the benefit in the staff's own terms, make activities hands-on, and offer them at times and places each shift can reach.
Step 4: Choose a theory for the organization. A culture in which nurses routinely skip lunch is an organizational problem, not an individual one, so organizational change is needed to alter staffing and break practices, with culture theory to understand the norm of the good nurse who never stops.
What the example shows. A workplace program usually fails on the barriers, not on the content. The common mistake is to respond to low uptake with more promotion of the same program.
The example shows that a workplace program needs two theories at once, one for adults who choose whether to attend and one for the organization that shapes their choices. The next part describes two programs that were built that way.
7.2 Two Theory-Based Workplace Programs
Two model programs both come from the SAMHSA evidence-based program registry, and both show how theory is put to work for an adult audience. The Healthy Workplace Program embeds substance use prevention inside popular health promotion programming. The purpose of doing so is to defuse stigma: an employee can attend a general wellness program without being seen to have a drug or alcohol problem. Its components map onto two theories. Raising awareness of the benefits of healthful practices and the hazards of substances draws on the Health Belief Model. Teaching skills, and using carefully constructed videos to raise self-efficacy and model healthful practice, draws on Social Cognitive Theory.
Coping with Work and Family Stress takes a different route. It is a sixteen-session weekly group intervention that teaches coping strategies, built on Pearlin and Schooler's hierarchy of coping mechanisms and Bandura's social learning theory. In other words, it treats coping as something that can be learned, partly by observing others in the group. Participants showed significantly greater decreases in substance use and psychological symptoms than controls. The two tabs that follow describe each program in full. Open both and note, for each, which barrier from 5.6 its design answers.
The Healthy Workplace Program
A set of workplace substance use prevention interventions that reduce unsafe drinking, illegal drug use, and prescription drug misuse while improving the health practices of adult workers. Rooted in social-cognitive principles, it integrates substance use prevention material into popular health promotion programs to defuse stigma and remove barriers to help-seeking. It reaches mainstream workers through the positive vehicle of health promotion; raises awareness of the benefits of healthful practices and the hazards of alcohol, tobacco, and drugs (Health Belief Model); teaches skills for improving health and reducing use (Social Cognitive Theory); and uses carefully constructed videos to raise self-efficacy and model healthful practice (Social Cognitive Theory again). SAMHSA recognized it as a model program. Its design answers a barrier directly: reluctance to mix personal problems with work is met by hiding the sensitive content inside something ordinary.
Coping with Work and Family Stress
A sixteen-session weekly group intervention that teaches employees coping strategies for stressors at work and at home. The model derives from Pearlin and Schooler's hierarchy of coping mechanisms and Bandura's social learning theory, and grew out of the Yale Work and Family Stress Program. The curriculum emphasizes stress, coping, and social support in relation to substance use and psychological symptoms. Two studies found significantly greater decreases in substance use and psychological symptoms among participants than controls, with fewer stressors, more use of social support, changed meaning of stressful events, less avoidance coping, a wider range of stress management approaches, and less depression and anxiety. It too is a SAMHSA model program.
Each program answers a barrier. The Healthy Workplace Program meets employees' reluctance to mix personal problems with work by hiding the sensitive content inside something ordinary, and Coping with Work and Family Stress treats stress as a teachable skill rather than a personal failing. Both work on employees; the next part turns to a Canadian framework that works on the organization instead.
7.3 Canada's National Standard for Psychological Health and Safety
Canada's distinctive contribution to workplace health is the National Standard of Canada for Psychological Health and Safety in the Workplace, released in 2013 by CSA Group and the Bureau de normalisation du Québec and championed by the Mental Health Commission of Canada. It is voluntary, meaning that no law requires an organization to adopt it. It gives organizations a framework to assess and address thirteen psychosocial factors, among them psychological support, organizational culture, civility and respect, recognition and reward, workload management, and psychological protection. By psychosocial factors we mean features of how work is organized and how people are treated that affect mental health.
The key to classifying the Standard is to notice what it tries to change. Several of its factors are the organizational characteristics described in 6.4 under other names, and the Standard treats them as properties of the organization to be changed rather than of employees to be educated. This sets it apart from the two programs in 7.2, which work on employees' awareness and skills. Read against this section, the Standard is an administrative and educational assessment turned into a management system. By a management system we mean a routine the organization repeats: it assesses the psychosocial factors, acts on the ones that fall short, checks the results, and assesses again, instead of running a single program and stopping. For example, an organization that finds its workload management poor would change staffing or scheduling, not offer employees a course on time management. Its theory is therefore organizational change rather than employee education. However, being voluntary is also its weakness, and it is the one named among the barriers in 5.6. A voluntary standard depends on management and union support, so it is adopted first where the culture already permits it, which may not be where it is most needed.
Worked Example 7.9 applies the Standard to the Cedar Ridge mill. Watch how the management-union barrier decides where a voluntary standard takes hold.
Worked Example 7.9: The National Standard at Cedar Ridge
The case. A regional hospital has adopted the National Standard, and the health unit working with Cedar Ridge wonders whether the mill would do the same. At the mill, workers say nobody complains since the last closure, crew leads model leaving ear protection on the hook, almost nobody uses the assistance program for fear that management would find out, and the joint health and safety committee required by provincial law has not met in six months. Which theory family does the Standard rely on, which assessment phases does its factor assessment correspond to, why might it be adopted in a hospital but ignored at Cedar Ridge, and what does the management-union point suggest for the mill?
Step 1: Name the theory family. The Standard's thirteen factors, such as organizational culture, workload management, and recognition and reward, are properties of the organization, so its theory is organizational change rather than employee education.
Step 2: Match it to the assessment. Assessing culture, civility, support, and recognition corresponds to the educational and ecological phase, and assessing policies, structures, and resources corresponds to the administrative phase. The Standard turns those two phases into an ongoing management system.
Step 3: Explain the difference in adoption. The Standard is voluntary, and participation in workplace programs tracks the support of both management and unions. It is adopted first where the culture already permits it. At Cedar Ridge, a culture of not complaining, fear of management, and a joint committee that has stopped meeting all signal that neither side is yet invested.
Step 4: Draw the implication for the mill. The first step is to revive the joint health and safety committee and run any work on the Standard through it, with both the union and management co-chairs visibly involved, so that the structure both sides own carries the program.
What the example shows. A voluntary organizational framework succeeds or fails on the same management-union relationship that decides participation in any workplace program.
The example shows that the Standard is a strong tool where the organization is ready to use it, and that readiness is itself something the assessment measures.
Schools and worksites both offer a present population, an organization whose goals overlap with health, and structures that must be assessed and sometimes changed. In both, the method is the one the first two sections used for communities: assess, choose the theory the setting calls for, tailor, and build capacity. This section has given the reasons for workplace health promotion and the evidence on its costs and returns, traced its growth, named the barriers that programs meet, and applied a PRECEDE-PROCEED style assessment to a worksite. It has matched theories to the workplace's social and organizational character and described two theory-based programs and Canada's National Standard for Psychological Health and Safety in the Workplace. The key takeaways and knowledge check that follow review this material, and the final review then pulls the threads of all four sections together.
Key Takeaways
- 5.4 Workplaces are a strong setting because health, performance, safety, and productivity are intertwined, employees are a captive audience for most of their waking day, and workplaces have built-in communication and social support. The best-known evidence is financial and American: 29% lower health care costs among program participants than nonparticipants at Procter and Gamble, slower growth in inpatient costs at Johnson and Johnson sites with a program, and reported returns of about $1.40 to $4.90 per dollar spent. In Canada, where hospital and physician care is publicly insured, the employer's stake lies instead in extended benefits, disability claims, absenteeism, and compensation premiums. If a question asks a Canadian employer to expect American health care savings, the correct response points to this difference.
- 5.5 Workplace health promotion grew from the mid-1900s with more women and older people in the workforce, regulation and rising compensation and medical costs, employee assistance programs, and a wider view of occupational health that now includes heart disease, smoking, and obesity. Its focus moved from screening, to environmental factors, to broad wellness. Employee assistance programs moved in parallel from substance use treatment and drug testing to broad prevention, which reduced the stigma of being a program only for people with alcohol or drug problems. Remember the direction of travel: from narrow and stigmatized toward broad and ordinary, which is also the logic of the Healthy Workplace Program.
- 5.6 Workplace programs meet five barriers: reluctance to mix personal health with work, cultures that prize working hard, not complaining, and not revealing personal information, programs that seem redundant in places such as hospitals and law offices, lack of time or incentive, and the need for support from both management and unions. Each barrier is something an assessment can find before launch. When a case describes low uptake, first ask which barrier explains it; the fix is usually to change the program's design or the organization, not to promote the same program harder.
- 6.3 A worksite assessment reads differently from a community's. The social phase looks at the organization's own culture and at outside pressures, such as a single employer in a down economy; the epidemiological phase concerns work-related conditions, from hearing loss to mental health; the behavioural and environmental phase covers protective gear, long hours, hazards, and the food environment; the educational and ecological phase centres on networks, norms, organizational culture, rewards, and whether workers see a hazard as a threat; and the administrative phase maps committees, benefits, unions, and regulations. Canadian data come from compensation boards, national substance use surveys, and joint health and safety committees. Sort each observation by what it describes: a belief or a norm is educational and ecological, a structure or a policy is administrative, and an observation can feed two phases.
- 6.4 Because employees are adults who attend by choice, education must be engaging and hands-on or must sell the benefit, so social marketing, the Health Belief Model, and diffusion of innovations fit. Because workplaces have leaders and influencers, friendship groups, norms about the good employee, and reward systems, diffusion of innovations, Social Network Theory, Social Cognitive Theory, the Theory of Planned Behavior, and culture theory apply, and changing the culture itself takes organizational change. A strong answer to a workplace case names one theory for the audience and one for the organization, as Table 7.4 does. The common trap is to answer an organizational problem, such as a reward that encourages skipping breaks, with individual education.
- 7.2 The Healthy Workplace Program embeds substance use prevention inside popular wellness programming to defuse stigma, using the Health Belief Model to raise awareness of benefits and hazards and Social Cognitive Theory for skills and video modelling that build self-efficacy. Coping with Work and Family Stress is a sixteen-session weekly group program based on Pearlin and Schooler's hierarchy of coping mechanisms and Bandura's social learning theory, with significantly greater decreases in substance use and psychological symptoms than controls. Link each to the barrier it answers: the first hides sensitive content inside something ordinary, and the second treats stress as a teachable skill. If a case describes an assistance program nobody uses for fear of being seen, the Healthy Workplace tactic is the one to borrow.
- 7.3 Canada's National Standard for Psychological Health and Safety in the Workplace, released in 2013 by CSA Group and the Bureau de normalisation du Québec with the Mental Health Commission of Canada as champion, is a voluntary framework for assessing and addressing thirteen psychosocial factors, such as workload management, civility and respect, and recognition and reward. It treats the organization, not the employee, as the target of change, so its theory is organizational change, and it works like the educational and administrative assessment phases turned into a management system. Its limit is that, being voluntary, it depends on management and union support and is adopted first where the culture already permits it. In a case, the practical move is to run it through a structure both sides own, such as the joint health and safety committee.
1. A manufacturer offers a lunchtime nutrition lecture series and is disappointed that few employees attend. Which observation about the workplace setting best explains the problem, and what does it imply for theory?
2. The Healthy Workplace Program integrates substance use prevention material into popular health promotion programs. What is the main purpose of this design?
3. A worksite assessment finds that new hires copy respected senior workers, who rarely wear hearing protection, and that the company's productivity bonus rewards skipping breaks. In a PRECEDE-PROCEED assessment of the worksite, which phase produced these findings and which theories do they point to?
4. Canada's National Standard for Psychological Health and Safety in the Workplace asks organizations to assess and address thirteen psychosocial factors such as workload management and civility and respect. Read against this section, which statement is most accurate?
5. Employee assistance programs broadened from substance use treatment and drug testing to prevention, early intervention, and counselling on family, financial, and workplace problems. What effect did this change have?
6. A manager at an Ontario plant reads that participants in Procter and Gamble's workplace program had 29% lower health care costs than nonparticipants and expects the same saving on her company's hospital and physician bills. What should she understand?
7. A long-term care operator asks for help with injury claims and burnout among care aides, many of them recent immigrants working rotating shifts in a tight labour market. The assessment finds that aides are unwilling to complain about unsafe lifting practices for fear of losing their jobs. Which assessment phase does this finding belong to?
8. The same operator's employee and family assistance program goes almost unused because staff fear being seen as unable to cope. Which tactic from the model programs in this section answers this problem most directly?
✦ Pass the knowledge check with 100% to continue
Final Review & Assessment
⏱ Estimated time: 25 minutes
Bringing It All Together
This lesson moved the course from theory to the places where theory is used. The first section opened with a decision about scale: a community intervention targets a community in general and buys a small percentage change over a large number of people, while an intervention in a community targets a specific group or setting and buys a large change within a small subset. The Institute of Medicine's universal, selected, and indicated categories describe the same choice, and a third path works on systems and policies rather than individuals. The Minnesota Heart Health Program and COMMIT showed what community-wide programs can and cannot do; COMMIT moved light and moderate smokers but not its primary target, heavy smokers, and its effects varied more by community than by matched pair. The Long Beach AIDS Community Demonstration Project showed an intervention in a community built on a composite theory, peer volunteers, role model stories, and materials rewritten repeatedly on audience reaction, and the Dr. Meg trial showed that a virtual community can be a setting too.
The second section explained why the program is never the whole picture. The choice of health issue and target population is political and often funder-driven, the community structures a program works through carry motives and rivalries of their own, and the best expertise on a community comes from the community itself, as community health outreach workers show. Working with communities is one subset of working with populations, aggregates defined by place or by a shared characteristic, with the caution that overemphasizing shared characteristics stigmatizes. Two obligations follow: tailoring, usually by adapting an effective existing program on the basis of assessment, formative research, and ongoing evaluation, and sustainability, planned from day one because funding ends in three or four years.
The last two sections applied the method to two settings. Schools offer a captive audience, a channel to families, and a century of infrastructure, and are complicated by developmental stage, politics, expanded demands, and scarce resources; comprehensive and coordinated school health, eight components in the CDC model and four in Canada's, is the ecological model applied to a school, and a PRECEDE-PROCEED assessment tells you which of four theory families a problem belongs to, as Life Skills Training, South Windsor, and Not On Tobacco illustrate. Worksites offer a similar audience, adult and voluntary, with a business case, an evolving history, and barriers of culture, time, and management-union relations; their assessment centres on networks, norms, organizational culture, and rewards, the theories that fit follow from that, and the Healthy Workplace Program, Coping with Work and Family Stress, and Canada's National Standard for Psychological Health and Safety in the Workplace show three ways of acting on it.
Key Takeaways from this lesson
- You can now tell a community intervention from an intervention in a community and classify a program as universal, selected, or indicated, or as work on systems and policies. Classify by whom the program targets and how it is delivered, then weigh the trade-off in absolute numbers: a small percentage of many people against a large percentage of a few, remembering that a small group may be a bridge for harm to others.
- You can describe the Minnesota Heart Health Program, COMMIT, the Long Beach project, and the Dr. Meg trial and say what each teaches. The most useful reminder comes from COMMIT and Long Beach together: a community-wide program may miss its intended subgroup, so measure dose with something like the receipt index, and reach a specific group with peers, small media, and materials revised on its reaction rather than with mass media.
- You can explain why the intervention is only part of the picture: issues are chosen through politics and funders' mandates, programs run through community structures with motives of their own, and community members are the best experts on their community. In a case, keep the funder's goal at the core, bring competing groups in to shape delivery, and involve the community at the design stage, through outreach workers and formative research, not after the materials are printed.
- You can define population-based health promotion and apply tailoring and sustainability to a plan. Check a plan against the five requirements of tailoring and the three steps of adaptation (assessment, formative research, ongoing evaluation), avoid stigmatizing the population you serve, and build the five sustainability steps in from year one so that the community can run and fund the program when the grant ends.
- You can distinguish a setting from a channel and explain why schools and worksites are used as settings, what makes each difficult, and how comprehensive approaches developed. Remember that the setting narrows the theory without forbidding any, and pair each setting's attractions with its obstacles: for schools, developmental stage, politics, expanded demands, and scarce resources; for worksites, reluctance, culture, redundancy, time, and management-union support.
- You can run a PRECEDE-PROCEED style assessment of a school or worksite and let it point to a family of theory. Decide what each finding describes (a belief, a skill, a norm, a policy, or the building) before choosing a theory, start with the administrative and policy phase when a board or a union could block the program, and never answer an organizational or environmental problem with individual education alone.
- You can describe the school and worksite programs in this lesson and the theory behind each. Identify a program by the problem it answers: Life Skills Training for prevention skills, South Windsor for the food environment, Not On Tobacco for students who want to quit, the Healthy Workplace Program for stigma, Coping with Work and Family Stress for stress as a teachable skill, and the National Standard for changing the organization itself.
The four sections used one method throughout: decide the scale, accept that the community or setting is part of the picture, assess phase by phase, let the assessment choose the theory, tailor an effective program, and build the capacity that keeps it alive. Worked Example 7.10 runs that whole method on a single applied scenario that touches every section. Read it before the final assessment, and notice how each step draws on a different part of the lesson.
Worked Example 7.10: Running the Method on One Scenario
The case. A regional health authority in British Columbia receives three years of federal funding to improve youth mental health in a mid-sized city and the rural communities around it. The assessment shows rising anxiety and self-reported distress across all secondary students; a smaller group of young people, many of them working part-time in retail and food service, who are in crisis and not connected to any service; a school district whose board is divided about mental health programming; and employers who have never thought of teenaged staff as a population.
Step 1: Decide the scale. Both scales are needed. A universal community intervention across all secondary students, delivered as a comprehensive school health effort, would produce a modest percentage improvement across thousands of students, which in absolute numbers is the largest gain available. A selected or indicated intervention in a community for the disconnected young people in crisis would produce a large change within a small group that carries most of the acute risk. COMMIT's lesson is that the universal arm cannot be assumed to reach them.
Step 2: Choose the settings and the theory each calls for. In schools, the classroom calls for Social Cognitive Theory and individual knowledge and attitude approaches, while the divided board calls for mobilization and advocacy, found through the administrative and policy assessment. Not On Tobacco's structure of voluntary small groups with boosters, participatory design, and diffusion of innovations to spread through the district is a model to adapt. In retail and food service worksites, young workers attend by choice, so social marketing fits, and employers who have not yet seen teenaged staff as a population call for organizational change. The Healthy Workplace Program's tactic of embedding sensitive content inside ordinary programming, and the National Standard's psychosocial factors, give the employer conversations a frame.
Step 3: Treat young people as experts and tailor. Hire and train young people with lived experience as peer outreach workers in the role of community health outreach workers. Run formative research with students, young workers, and rural communities; refer to local situations and people; use the language and channels young people use; schedule around shifts and school hours; and evaluate continuously so that materials can be revised the way Long Beach revised its own. Define the high-risk group carefully, because overemphasizing shared characteristics stigmatizes.
Step 4: Build sustainability in year one. Train and hire community members and youth to run components, give the school district, employers, and rural communities a real stake, map other funding early, teach partners to write applications, and link the program to similar programs elsewhere in the province.
What the example shows. Every section of the lesson contributes one step, and a receipt index would let outcomes be read against how much of the program each young person actually received. The common mistake is to jump straight to a program before deciding the scale and running the assessment.
The example shows the method working as a whole: scale, setting, theory, tailoring, and sustainability each answer a different question about the same plan. The final assessment that follows samples every section and ends with three questions on this scenario.
Final Knowledge Assessment
This assessment covers all material from this lesson. You must score 100% to complete the lesson. Review the feedback for any incorrect answers and try again.
1. A provincial campaign reduces sugary drink consumption by 2% across the whole adolescent population, while a targeted clinic program reduces it by 35% among 300 adolescents with prediabetes. Applying the reasoning about scale, which statement is correct?
2. A city creates a coalition, task forces for four channels, and a four-year program to maximize smokers' exposure to quit messages, with heavy smokers as the primary target. This describes which program, and what happened to its primary target group?
3. The Long Beach project's designers considered five established theories and rejected each as inadequate on its own. What did they do instead, and why?
4. In the Dr. Meg trial, references to substance use were removed entirely from 26% of profiles in the intervention group and 22% of profiles in the control group. How should this pattern be interpreted?
5. A health promotion team with federal funds to assess HIV risk among youth finds that the schools refuse to participate, calling HIV too controversial, while a treatment providers' association wants to redirect the funds toward adult substance use. What is the team's task?
6. Which of the following best captures the reason for involving members of a high-risk population as community health outreach workers?
7. A health unit plans to run a diabetes prevention program for a specific immigrant community and wants to avoid stigmatizing it. Which approach is most consistent with the principles of population-based health promotion?
8. A team wants to bring a school nutrition program developed in Connecticut to Nova Scotia. Which statement about tailoring is correct?
9. Five steps build sustainability into a community program. Which option contains only steps from that list?
10. A school-based intervention is likely to be a curriculum delivered in a classroom, so community mobilization is probably not the approach you would use. What general principle does this illustrate?
11. Which set correctly lists components of the CDC's Coordinated School Health Program?
12. A school district wants a program for students who want to quit smoking and an alternative to suspension for those caught. Which program from this lesson most directly matches this need, and what theoretical combination did it use?
13. A worksite assessment shows that the only food available is a vending machine with chips and donuts and a burger restaurant down the road, with no time or place to walk. In a PRECEDE-PROCEED assessment of the worksite, what kind of finding is this and what does it predict?
14. There is frequently a strong relationship between management and union support of workplace programs and participation in them. Which program design decision best reflects this?
15. Coping with Work and Family Stress is a sixteen-session group intervention. Which pair correctly identifies its theoretical foundations and its main documented outcome?
16. In Worked Example 7.10, the assessment finds rising distress across all secondary students and a smaller group of young people in crisis who are not connected to any service. Which plan best fits the reasoning about scale?
17. In the same scenario, many of the young people in crisis work part-time in retail and food service, for employers who have never thought of teenaged staff as a population. Which theories fit the worksite arm of the plan?
18. Which step in the same plan most clearly treats young people and their communities as experts on their own situation?
✦ Pass every section knowledge check with 100% before submitting