Social, Cultural, and
Environmental Theories I
Health Promotion: Individuals and Communities
Learning objectives for this lesson:
- Explain why the line between individual and social/environmental theories of behaviour is arbitrary but useful, and describe the layers of a person's social/environmental context.
- Trace the evolution of Social Cognitive Theory from behaviourism to its present form, and explain how self-efficacy, agency, and reciprocal determinism make it a social/environmental theory.
- Define the constructs of Social Cognitive Theory and Bandura's four sources of self-efficacy, and apply them to analyze a case and design program components.
- Describe how Social Network Theory explains behaviour through relationships, identify network types and qualities, and apply the two steps for using the theory in a program.
- Describe the diffusion of innovations process, including its key processes, adopter categories, diffusion context, and the innovation attributes that set the speed and extent of adoption.
- Apply the four Ps of social marketing, market segmentation, and targeting to plan a health campaign.
- Evaluate the critiques of Social Cognitive Theory, Social Network Theory, diffusion of innovations, and social marketing, and judge which approach, or combination, best fits a given health problem and population.
This course was developed by Dr. Kiffer G. Card, to accompany Edberg, M. Essentials of Health Behavior: Social and Behavioral Theory in Public Health. Jones & Bartlett Learning. This lesson follows Chapter 5 of the text.
Glossary: Key Terms, People & Concepts
📚 Reference page, available throughout the lesson
This glossary collects the key concepts, people, and ideas you will meet in this lesson. Use it as a reference while you work through the material, or as a review before assessments. Type in the search box to filter entries.
From the Individual to the Social Context
⏱ Estimated reading time: 14 minutes
Overview
Even in theories that focus on the individual, the line between a person and his or her surroundings keeps blurring. This lesson crosses that line on purpose and looks at the same behaviour from a different vantage point: the social/environmental context and the way it interacts with individuals. This section sets up that vantage point by asking what a context contains and how far out from the individual it reaches. It then introduces the lesson's first and best-known theory, Social Cognitive Theory, by following how it grew out of the study of learning. The history matters, because the theory as it stands today is built from constructs added at different times, and those layers explain both its usefulness and its critiques.
Learning Objectives
- 1.1 Explain why the line between individual and social/environmental theories is arbitrary, and why the terms are still useful.
- 1.2 Describe the five layers of a person's social/environmental context, connect them to Bronfenbrenner's image of a person's ecology, and identify how different disciplines answer the question of how far out context reaches.
- 2.1 Trace the evolution of Social Cognitive Theory from behaviourism and operant conditioning through Social Learning Theory and vicarious learning to its renaming in the mid-1980s.
- 2.2 Define self-efficacy and agency, explain why adding them moved the theory beyond conditioning, and distinguish self-efficacy from perceived behavioural control.
- 2.3 Define reciprocal determinism and explain why it makes Social Cognitive Theory a social/environmental theory.
1.1 An Arbitrary but Useful Line
One tidy way to sort theories is to say that individual theories address internal factors, such as a person's beliefs, perceptions, and confidence, while social/environmental theories address external factors, such as other people and the setting in which a person lives. By this we mean that the two families of theory are told apart by where they look first for the causes of behaviour: inside the person or outside. The distinction is worth offering, but it has to be withdrawn almost as soon as it is made. Given how blurred the lines are, it is clearly not an adequate way to characterize the difference, because there is no definitive way to separate a person from his or her context. For example, the habits and meanings a person carries "inside" were learned from a family and a setting "outside," and the setting shapes behaviour partly through the way the person perceives it. We therefore make do with arbitrary terms like internal/external or individual/social. The purpose of using them is not to describe a real boundary but to position our thinking, so that we know which part of a tangled picture a given theory examines first.
The labels are best treated as filing categories, and the theories reach across them. By this we mean that placing a theory in the "individual" or the "social/environmental" drawer tells you where it puts its emphasis, not that it ignores everything in the other drawer. Aristotle wrote in the Politics that "man by nature is a social animal"; we would now say man or woman, or just people. The point behind the quotation is that people live among other people, and much of what they do is done with, for, or in view of others. Any account of why people do what they do that leaves out other people is therefore incomplete. For example, a student's decision to start running is partly a matter of her own confidence and partly a matter of whether her roommates run, whether there is a safe route nearby, and whether anyone notices. The theories in this lesson build other people, and the wider setting, into the explanation. Social Cognitive Theory, the first of them, contains constructs that live inside the person and constructs that live in the environment, and its central claim is about the traffic between them: how the person acts on the setting and how the setting acts back on the person.
Exam trap: "individual" and "social" are not opposites
A question may ask you to classify a theory as individual or social/environmental. Classify it by its main focus, and be ready to say why the line is arbitrary: no theory in this lesson ignores the person, and the individual theories do not ignore the setting completely. Avoid writing that social/environmental theories deal only with external factors; that is the inadequate internal/external distinction the lesson sets aside.
If the line is arbitrary, the next question is what lies on the far side of it: what does a social/environmental context actually contain?
1.2 The Layers of a Person's Context
Talking about context raises questions that have taken up more writing space than a hundred sets of encyclopedias. What counts as a meaningful definition of context, and how far out from the individual do we go? Different disciplines answer differently, and their answers preview the theories of this lesson and the next.
1.2.1 How Far Out Do We Go?
Three answers are worth knowing, and they differ mainly in where they draw the outer edge of a person's context. Political economists draw it furthest out. They say that the choices open to a person are constrained by his or her position within an economic and political system, and that this system defines the "spaces" in which people can act. By this they mean that what a person can choose depends first on things such as wages, prices, and policy, and only then on preference. Social network theorists and proponents of Social Cognitive Theory draw the edge much closer in: they look at the social networks and groups a person actually belongs to, the people he or she watches and is tied to. Cultural anthropologists, in contrast, point to systems of meaning and living patterns shared across one or more societies or peoples. For them, context is less a position or a group than a shared way of understanding what foods, bodies, and risks mean. Open each of the three tabs below to see an example of each vantage point.
Spaces defined by the system
Political economists argue that the choices available to individuals are constrained by their position within an economic and political system that defines "spaces" within which people can act. Asking why a person in a remote community eats few vegetables begins with freight costs, wages, and food policy, and only then with preference. This vantage point is the basis of political economy theory.
Closer networks and groups
Social network theorists and proponents of Social Cognitive Theory would focus on closer social networks and groups: the people a person watches, learns from, is rewarded by, and exchanges information with. This is the vantage point of the present lesson, which starts somewhat close to the individual and works outward.
Systems of meaning
Cultural anthropologists point to systems of meaning and living patterns shared across one or more societies or peoples. What a food, a drink, a body, or a risk means is learned, and the meaning shapes the behaviour. This vantage point is the basis of cultural theory; in this lesson it appears wherever a program must fit the meanings a group already holds, as with the bikers and helmets in Section 4.
The tabs show that each discipline draws the boundary of context in a different place. This lesson takes the middle answer: it starts somewhat close to the individual, with the people a person watches and is tied to, and works outward one step at a time.
1.2.2 A Life Story in Five Layers
The most useful answer to "what is a context?" is a life story rather than a definition. The purpose of telling it as a story is to show that the layers accumulate over a lifetime, and that each stage of the story names a layer that a later theory will try to work with. The story begins when you are born into a family in a certain setting, where you learn habits, routines, and what they mean. Over time you add friends and networks at school, at work, and perhaps through marriage into a new family. Throughout, you live in a physical space, with its climate and geography, and in a political-economic space, with its rules, jobs, products, and health laws. In addition to being influenced by all of these, you learn from your own experience of interacting with them, and that experience is the fifth layer. Each layer below pairs a general description with a Canadian illustration.
The family and setting you are born into
Description: you are born into a family in a certain setting, suburban or rural, well-off or not, ethnically homogeneous or diverse. Growing up you learn habits and their meanings: routines like brushing your teeth, but also what is good and bad, what kind of life you should or can lead, and the codes of behaviour for different situations. Some comes from family, some from screens and social media, and some is woven into the language you speak.
Illustration: two children born the same week, one in a Surrey townhouse to parents who arrived from Punjab, the other on a farm outside Prince George, learn different meanings for food, alcohol, physical work, and asking for help. Part of that socialization is unique to each household and part is shared across Canadian society.
Friends, schools, workplaces, and new families
Description: over time you develop friends and social networks at school and at work, and perhaps marry into a new family, which is a new network in its own right. Each of these networks brings its own habits and expectations. Because you spend so much time with these people, they become the ones you watch, compare yourself with, and seek approval from, so what they do and reward begins to shape what you do. In this way the second layer adds to, and sometimes competes with, the meanings learned in the family you were born into.
Illustration: a student who moves from Kelowna to Burnaby for university loses daily contact with one network and joins several new ones: a residence floor, a lab section, a club. Section 3 treats those networks as the unit of analysis.
The physical space
Description: the physical space is the natural and built environment you live in, including its climate, geography, and hazards. Examples include the hot Southwest United States, northern Minnesota with its long winters and no mass transit, a town downwind of chemical plants whose pollutants tinge the sunset brown, and a coast prone to flooding and hurricanes. Each of these settings makes some behaviours easy and others hard. For example, walking to work is a simple choice in a mild climate with sidewalks, but a much harder one in a long winter with no transit and few safe routes.
Illustration: a Yellowknife winter that shapes what daily activity can mean, a Fraser Valley farm flooded in the atmospheric river of November 2021, a summer of wildfire smoke in the Interior. Physical space sets the terms of routine before any motive has a say.
The political-economic space
Description: a space governed by a political system with its rules, values, procedures, and allocations of power, where employment, industries, and available products belong to a general system that includes the regulations and laws affecting health.
Illustration: whether a pharmacist in your province can hand you a free naloxone kit without a prescription, whether a school district funds a meal program, and whether your workplace is unionized. None is a personal characteristic; each changes what behaviour is possible.
Your own experience of interacting with all of it
Description: in addition to being influenced by all these things, you learn from your own experience of interacting with the environment you live in. All of these pieces form your social/environmental context, and all influence what you do.
Illustration: this last layer is the hinge on which Social Cognitive Theory turns. A person is shaped by the layers, acts on them, and learns from the response. Urie Bronfenbrenner called the whole arrangement a person's ecology, "something like layers of an onion," because what an individual thinks and does cannot help but involve an ongoing interaction with these factors.
Taken together, the five layers are what the psychologist Urie Bronfenbrenner called a person's ecology, "something like layers of an onion," because what an individual thinks and does cannot help but involve an ongoing interaction with them. The story ends with the practical question that drives this lesson: if you are trying to understand what influences behaviour, how do you untangle all of this, much less do something about it? Each theory in the lesson is one answer, and each chooses a piece of the onion to work on. The last layer, the person's own experience of interacting with the rest, is the hinge on which Social Cognitive Theory turns, so the section now follows that theory from its origins.
2.1 From Behaviourism to Social Learning Theory
Because this lesson starts close to the individual and works outward, it begins with Social Cognitive Theory, perhaps the best-known and most productive theory of its kind in public health because of its specific focus on the interaction between individuals and their immediate environment. Its evolution matters, because the theory as it stands integrates constructs that were added at different times and never removed.
The starting point is behaviourism, a theory of learning that treats individual behaviour as a response to conditioning. Its central principle is operant conditioning. By this we mean that people learn a behaviour through positive and negative reinforcement: a behaviour that is rewarded tends to be repeated, and a behaviour that is punished tends to be dropped. In this view the person is shaped from outside, and the learning happens to the person who receives the reward or the punishment.
Social Cognitive Theory began as a theoretical offshoot of this tradition. In the 1960s Albert Bandura and others proposed that operant conditioning also works when the reinforcement is directed at other people. For example, Johnny learns not to touch the hot stove when he sees his sister Mary get burned, and he learns to raise his hand in class when he sees the teacher reward other students who do. In both cases the reward or punishment does not have to happen to Johnny himself; seeing it happen to someone else is enough. This first version of the theory was called Social Learning Theory, and its key principle was learning by observation, or vicarious learning. The person being observed serves as a model, which is why vicarious learning is also called modeling. The step from behaviourism to Social Learning Theory therefore changes where learning can come from: not only from the consequences of one's own behaviour, but also from the consequences one sees other people receive.
The five cards below follow the whole sequence, from behaviourism and operant conditioning through Social Learning Theory, self-efficacy and agency, and reciprocal determinism to the renaming of the theory in the mid-1980s. Read the cards in order and note what each stage added.
1. Behaviourism and
operant conditioning
The starting point. Behaviourism is a theory about how people learn that treats individual behaviour as a response to conditioning. Its principle of operant conditioning holds that a person learns behaviour through positive and negative reinforcement: what is rewarded is repeated, what is punished is dropped. Social Cognitive Theory began as a theoretical offshoot of it.
2. Social Learning Theory:
vicarious learning
In the 1960s Albert Bandura and others proposed that operant conditioning also worked when the reinforcement was directed toward other people. Johnny can learn not to touch a hot stove when he sees his sister Mary get burned. He can learn to raise his hand in class when he sees the teacher reward others who do. The rewards or punishments do not have to happen to Johnny. This original formulation was called Social Learning Theory, and its key principle was learning by observation, or vicarious learning.
3. Self-efficacy
and agency
Not long after, Bandura expanded the theory by introducing self-efficacy, a person’s confidence that he or she can perform a behaviour. The construct has since been adopted by a number of other behavioural theories, including the Theory of Planned Behavior and the Transtheoretical Model. Treating self-efficacy as a key element of change moves the theory beyond the mechanistic conditioning of behaviourism and gives individuals a role in their own processes of change. Having that role is called agency.
4. Reciprocal
determinism
As self-efficacy and other constructs were added to the vicarious learning core, the process was described as reciprocal determinism: behaviour is part of a continuous interactive cycle that includes individuals and their social and physical environments. A person acts, receives a response from the environment, adjusts, and acts again. This interactive process is the reason the theory is filed among social/environmental theories rather than individual ones.
5. Renamed Social
Cognitive Theory
In the mid-1980s Bandura renamed the theory Social Cognitive Theory, to move it once and for all away from its behaviourist roots and to position it as a theory about individuals consciously operating within an environment. The word cognitive signals that people think, plan, and expect; the word social signals that they do so among other people. In recent years Bandura and others applying the theory have come to focus even more on self-efficacy.
The cards make the pattern of growth visible: each stage added something, and nothing was taken away. In the mid-1980s Bandura renamed the theory Social Cognitive Theory to move it away from its behaviourist roots; the word cognitive signals that people think, plan, and expect, and the word social signals that they do so among other people. The two additions that made the renaming necessary, self-efficacy and reciprocal determinism, are taken in turn next.
2.2 Self-Efficacy and Agency
Not long after Social Learning Theory took shape, Bandura introduced self-efficacy, a person's confidence that he or she can perform a behaviour, including the confidence to overcome obstacles to doing it. His 1977 paper introducing the construct remains among the most cited in psychology (Bandura, 1977), and self-efficacy has since been adopted by a number of other theories, including the Theory of Planned Behavior and the Transtheoretical Model. Bandura himself is a Canadian story: born in 1925 in Mundare, a small town east of Edmonton, he did his undergraduate degree at the University of British Columbia before a career at Stanford (Bandura biography).
A child learning to ride a bicycle shows what the construct means. The child is not confident at first: the thing rides on two wheels and has to be balanced. A child with high self-efficacy for physical activity feels the same concern, but past experience mastering other difficult physical tasks gives the extra push needed to get on and try, even with a few falls, and that push produces the speed that keeps the bike up. A child with low self-efficacy hesitates, pedals reluctantly for fear of falling, and is therefore more likely to fall; it takes more time and more help. Once this child gets it, self-efficacy is gained and may carry over to the next task. Notice that the example is about confidence rather than skill: Section 2 calls the skill itself behavioural capability. Bandura applies the idea to any behaviour in which confidence is one of the keys to change.
Self-efficacy matters to the theory for a second reason. Treating confidence as a key element of change moves the theory beyond the mechanistic conditioning of behaviourism, in which people are simply shaped by rewards and punishments, and gives individuals a role in their own processes of change. Having that role is called agency. By this we mean the capacity to act on purpose: a person with agency does not merely respond to reinforcement, but forms plans in light of what has been observed and expected, and then carries them out. The difference is easiest to see by comparing two accounts of the same behaviour. In a strict behaviourist account, the child on the bicycle keeps trying only because earlier attempts were rewarded. In Bandura's account, the child also judges whether he or she is able to succeed, decides to try, and chooses how hard to push, so the child's own confidence and intentions become part of the explanation. This changes how a program is designed, because a program can now work on what people believe they can do and on the plans they make, not only on the rewards and punishments around them. In recent years Bandura and others applying the theory have come to focus even more on self-efficacy.
Because self-efficacy has travelled into other theories, it is easily confused with a similar construct in the Theory of Planned Behavior, as the callout below explains.
Common confusion: self-efficacy and perceived behavioural control
Students sometimes treat self-efficacy and the perceived behavioural control of the Theory of Planned Behavior as the same thing. They are close relatives: Ajzen borrowed from Bandura, and both describe a person's sense of being able to carry out a behaviour. The difference is where the construct sits. In the Theory of Planned Behavior it is one of three predictors of intention in an individual model, and it can also predict behaviour directly. In Social Cognitive Theory it is one construct inside a cycle that also contains modeling, reinforcement, and the situation, and it is built and rebuilt through that cycle.
With self-efficacy and agency in place, the theory had a person who acts on plans. What remained was to describe how that person and the environment keep acting on each other, which is the idea of reciprocal determinism.
2.3 Reciprocal Determinism
As self-efficacy and other constructs were added to the vicarious learning core, the process they describe together came to be called reciprocal determinism. The term means that behaviour is part of a continuous interactive cycle. By this we mean that a person acts on the basis of individual factors, such as confidence, and social/environmental cues, such as what others nearby are doing; the person then receives a response from the environment, adjusts, and acts again, so that each turn of the cycle changes the starting point for the next. The person, the behaviour, and the environment therefore all act on one another, and none of them is simply the cause of the others. This is what separates reciprocal determinism from the operant conditioning of 2.1. In conditioning, the environment rewards or punishes and the person responds; in reciprocal determinism, the person's behaviour also changes the environment, and the person adjusts by planning rather than only by being rewarded or punished. This interactive process is the reason Social Cognitive Theory is filed among the social/environmental theories rather than the individual ones: the explanation of any behaviour runs through the environment's response to it.
Later writers often draw reciprocal determinism as a triangle whose corners are the person, the behaviour, and the environment, with influence running along every edge in both directions. Interactive 4.1 presents that triangle, illustrated with a first-year student deciding whether to join an intramural team. Click each corner and each edge to see what it means; the counter records how many of the six you have visited.
📊 Interactive 4.1: The reciprocal determinism triangle.
Click a corner to see what belongs there, or an edge to see how the two corners act on each other. Try to visit all six.Select a corner or an edge
The triangle is a summary device. Underneath it is a cycle: act, receive a response, adjust, act again.
The triangle is a summary device, and underneath it is the cycle: act, receive a response, adjust, act again. Worked Example 4.1 applies the constructs traced in this section to a campus program. As you read it, watch where the reinforcement comes from and the point at which the student begins to act on her own plan.
Worked Example 4.1: Peer Health Educators on a Canadian Campus
The case. Most Canadian universities, SFU among them, train student volunteers as peer health educators. A first-year student who has never used a naloxone kit attends a residence workshop where a trained peer, someone visibly like her, assembles the kit, talks through what an overdose looks like, and describes the time she used one at a party. The leader praises each participant who practises the steps. Afterwards the student notices that several people on her floor now carry a kit, and she picks one up at the campus pharmacy the next day.
Step 1: Identify the behaviour and the person. The behaviour is carrying a naloxone kit and being ready to use it. The person is a first-year student with no experience of the kit.
Step 2: Find the constructs from the theory's earliest stage. Watching a peer like herself assemble the kit, and hearing that the peer used one successfully, is vicarious learning: the student learns from someone else's behaviour and its consequences. The leader's praise for practising the steps is reinforcement, a positive response to her own behaviour.
Step 3: Find the later constructs. Practising the steps successfully, and seeing that someone like her could do it, builds self-efficacy, her confidence that she could use a kit in an emergency. Picking up a kit the next day on her own initiative is agency: she is acting on a plan, not simply responding to a reward.
Step 4: Explain why the explanation is social/environmental. The sequence is a cycle of reciprocal determinism. Her characteristics (inexperience, then growing confidence) shaped how she took part; the environment responded (praise, then a floor where kits are visible and normal); and she adjusted and acted again. No step can be explained by her internal factors alone, which is why the case belongs with the theories of this lesson.
What the example shows. One short program can engage every construct traced in this section. The common mistake is to name only self-efficacy; a full explanation also needs vicarious learning and reinforcement, and the cycle that links them.
The case folds the theory's history into one sequence: the vicarious learning of the 1960s, the self-efficacy and agency of 1977, and the cycle that gave the theory its present name. Section 2 lays out the full set of constructs in a single table, follows a 16-year-old named Theresa through the cycle, and builds an intervention from the pieces. The origins traced here explain why the list is as long as it is: nothing was ever removed.
This section has positioned social/environmental theories against individual ones, described the layers of a person's context, and traced Social Cognitive Theory from behaviourism to reciprocal determinism. The key takeaways below draw these points together, and the knowledge check that follows tests them.
Key Takeaways
- 1.1 It is tempting to sort theories neatly into those about the inside of a person and those about the outside world, but the lesson asks you to hold that line loosely. There is no definitive way to separate a person from his or her context, so internal/external and individual/social are arbitrary labels we use to position our thinking, not real boundaries. On an exam, classify a theory by its main focus and, if asked why the classification is imperfect, say that the theories reach across the line; Social Cognitive Theory, for example, has constructs on both sides of it. Avoid writing that social/environmental theories deal only with external factors.
- 1.2 A person's context is easiest to understand as a life story in five layers: the family and meanings you are born into, your networks of friends, school, and work, the physical space you live in, the political-economic space with its rules, jobs, products, and laws, and your own experience of interacting with all of it. Bronfenbrenner called this a person's ecology, like layers of an onion, because what people think and do is always in interaction with those layers. When a case lists influences, sort each one into its layer: prices and laws are political-economic, weather and geography are physical, and a group of friends is a network. Remember also the three answers to "how far out do we go?": political economists look to the economic and political system, network and Social Cognitive theorists to closer groups, and cultural anthropologists to shared systems of meaning.
- 2.1 Social Cognitive Theory grew by accretion, and its history is easiest to remember as a sequence. It began as an offshoot of behaviourism, in which people learn through rewards and punishments (operant conditioning). In the 1960s Bandura proposed that people also learn when the reinforcement happens to someone else, as when Johnny watches Mary get burned; this was Social Learning Theory, and its key principle was vicarious learning, or modeling. Self-efficacy and reciprocal determinism followed, and the theory was renamed Social Cognitive Theory in the mid-1980s. If a question describes someone learning from another person's consequences, the answer is vicarious learning, from the theory's earliest stage.
- 2.2 Self-efficacy is a person's confidence that he or she can perform a behaviour and overcome obstacles to it, and Bandura's 1977 addition of it changed the theory's character. Because that confidence belongs to the person, it gave individuals a role in their own change, called agency, and moved the theory beyond mechanistic conditioning. The bicycle is the example to remember: past mastery gives the confident child the push to try, and success builds confidence for the next task. Keep self-efficacy apart from skill (behavioural capability) and from perceived behavioural control, its close relative in the Theory of Planned Behavior, which predicts intention in an individual model rather than sitting inside a cycle.
- 2.3 Reciprocal determinism is the cycle at the heart of the theory: a person acts on individual factors and environmental cues, the environment responds, and the person adjusts and acts again, so person, behaviour, and environment all shape one another. It is the reason Social Cognitive Theory is filed among the social/environmental theories. To spot it in a case, look for a sequence in which a response from other people or the setting changes what the person does next, and in which the person adjusts by planning rather than simply being rewarded or punished. A common mistake is to call any single reward reciprocal determinism; one reward is reinforcement, and the cycle also needs the person's adjustment.
1. One way to sort theories says that individual theories address internal factors while social/environmental theories address external ones. Why is this distinction rejected as inadequate?
2. A grade 4 student watches a classmate get sent to the office for shoving another child in line, and afterwards keeps his hands to himself. Which principle, and which stage of the theory's evolution, does this illustrate?
3. What is the main reason Social Cognitive Theory is placed among social/environmental theories rather than individual-oriented theories?
4. The bicycle example is used to explain self-efficacy. Which statement best captures the point of the example?
5. Which discipline would answer the question "how far out do we go?" by pointing to the position of individuals within an economic and political system that defines the spaces in which they can act?
6. A student analyzing her habit of cycling to campus lists four influences on it. Which one belongs to the political-economic layer of her social/environmental context?
7. A student cycles to campus in November, has a near miss on an unlit road, buys lights and plans a better-lit route, and keeps cycling. Why is this sequence better described as reciprocal determinism than as simple operant conditioning?
8. A classmate says, "Self-efficacy is just perceived behavioural control under another name." Which response best corrects the claim?
✦ Pass the knowledge check with 100% to continue
Social Cognitive Theory: Constructs, Programs, and Critiques
⏱ Estimated reading time: 18 minutes
Overview
Section 1 followed Social Cognitive Theory's growth. This section takes the theory as it stands and asks what it claims and how it is used. After the history it may not be clear how the many constructs relate to one another, so the section clusters them: changing a behaviour is a function of individual characteristics, environmental factors, and the interactive process that links them. It then applies the constructs to a single case, a 16-year-old named Theresa, sets out where self-efficacy comes from, builds programs from the constructs, and closes with two critiques that every user of the theory should be able to state.
Learning Objectives
- 3.1 Define the ten constructs of Social Cognitive Theory, sorted into individual characteristics, environmental factors, and the process of reciprocal determinism, and distinguish expectations from expectancies.
- 3.2 Analyze a case of health behaviour change by naming the Social Cognitive Theory constructs at work at each point.
- 3.3 Describe Bandura's four sources of self-efficacy and match program tactics to each.
- 3.4 Design program components that target specific Social Cognitive Theory constructs, using published programs as models.
- 7.1 Explain the two critiques of Social Cognitive Theory: the grab-bag problem and the problem of construct integration.
3.1 The Ten Constructs
According to the theory, changing a behaviour is a function of three things: individual characteristics, environmental factors, and reciprocal determinism. By this we mean that the theory's ten constructs fall into three groups according to where each one sits. Six constructs are individual ("internal") characteristics, because each describes something about the person: self-efficacy, behavioural capability, expectations, expectancies, self-control, and emotional coping. Three are environmental ("external") factors, because each describes what the person encounters in the people and setting around him or her: vicarious learning, situation, and reinforcement. The tenth, reciprocal determinism, is not a characteristic of either kind. It is the process that links the other nine, the cycle described in 2.3. The purpose of grouping the constructs in this way is to make a long list manageable, and also to show that the theory works on both sides of the arbitrary line drawn in 1.1. Table 4.1 lists all ten with their definitions, marks each group with a heading row, and adds a third column showing how a program would work on each construct, drawn from the intervention proposed for Theresa in 3.4.
Table 4.1. The ten constructs of Social Cognitive Theory, grouped as individual characteristics, environmental factors, and the process that links them, with a definition and a program handle for each.
| Construct | Definition | Program handle |
|---|---|---|
| Individual ("internal") characteristics | ||
| Self-efficacy | A person's confidence that he or she can perform a behaviour, including confidence to overcome obstacles (barriers). | Assign each girl a task or project she will lead, such as putting on a small event, so that success builds confidence. |
| Behavioural capability | A person's level of knowledge and skill in relation to a behaviour. | Social skills training in communication, self-presentation, and leadership. |
| Expectations | What a person thinks will happen if he or she makes a behaviour change. | An education component on the risks and outcomes of heavy drinking and risky sex. |
| Expectancies | Whether a person thinks the expected outcome is good or likely to be rewarded. | The same component, aimed at the value placed on those outcomes and on the alternatives. |
| Self-control | How much control a person has over making a change. | Goal setting and tracking within the group (the church-based study below calls this self-regulation). |
| Emotional coping | A person's ability to deal with the emotions involved in a behaviour change. | Group discussion of the anxiety of trying new ways to gain approval. |
| Environmental ("external") factors | ||
| Vicarious learning | A person learns by observing the behaviour of others and the consequences of that behaviour. | A college-age mentor who involves the mentee in an activity she is doing successfully, such as theatre; the mentor is the social model. |
| Situation | The social and physical environment in which the behaviour takes place, and the person's perception of those factors. | A group setting in which nonrisky behaviour is the route to approval, changing what the situation rewards. |
| Reinforcement | Positive or negative responses to a person's behaviour. | Peer feedback and reinforcement inside the group as skills are learned. |
| The process | ||
| Reciprocal determinism | The iterative process in which a person makes a change based on individual characteristics and social/environmental cues, receives a response, adjusts, and so on. | The whole program is a new environment that responds differently to the same goal of popularity. |
Read Table 4.1 one row at a time, and test yourself by covering the definition column. Two of the individual characteristics, expectations and expectancies, have similar names and are easily merged, so they are worth separating carefully.
Common confusion: expectations versus expectancies
The two words look alike and students often merge them. Expectations are predictions: if I quit smoking, I will gain weight. Expectancies are valuations: gaining weight is bad, or a healthy baby is worth a great deal. A program that only corrects predictions leaves the valuations untouched, and one that only praises the outcome leaves the predictions untouched. Later writers combine the pair as outcome expectations, the term used in the church-based study in 3.4.
A natural question follows from a list this long: how much does each factor weigh in during the process of behaving? By this we mean, for a given behaviour, how much of the change is due to self-efficacy, how much to reinforcement, how much to the situation, and so on. The candid answer is that it is not clear in the sense of precise science. Many of these relationships are still being investigated, and the roles of self-efficacy and observational learning are better understood than the rest, largely because they have been studied most often. For example, the theory can tell a program planner that a teenager's confidence and the behaviour of her friends both matter for whether she vapes, but it cannot say which matters more or by how much. That candour is the seed of the critiques in 7.1, because a theory that does not weigh its own parts leaves the weighing to the person using it. Before then, the constructs are put to work on a real case.
3.2 Analyzing a Case: Theresa
The constructs earn their keep when you can find them in a person's story. Worked Example 4.2 follows Theresa, in a case adapted from field research on risk behaviour among runaway youth, and stops the story to name the constructs at work. Watch for the moment at which her behaviour stops being a response to conditioning and becomes a plan.
Worked Example 4.2: Theresa, Age 16
The case. Theresa comes from an immigrant family that is strict in both the social and the religious sense. She attends a private religious school until about 12, then a public middle school, where she is shy, does not know how to behave around the other students, and comes to feel like an outsider. By high school she decides to make a change. She forms a plan to be "bad," "get a reputation," drink and be known for it, and take sexual risks and be known for that too, with little thought for HIV, pregnancy, alcoholism, or drunk driving. Her family objects; peer approval is so compelling that she perceives the family as a barrier, and she runs away. When interviewed she was living part-time with people from the pool halls where she hung out, and spent much of the interview describing how bad she was, exaggerating, the interviewer realized, so that her behaviour would match the reputation she was building.
Step 1: Identify the behaviour and the setting, and stop the action. The behaviours are heavy drinking and sexual risk taking, chosen to win a reputation and peer approval. Stop the story at the move from one social environment (a strict family and a religious school) to another (a public school where she is an outsider), because that is where the constructs can be seen.
Step 2: Name the individual characteristics. She lacks the behavioural capability to win peer approval: she does not know how to behave around the other students. She is also short on self-efficacy about how to get that approval, and good grades have not been enough.
Step 3: Name the environmental factors. Her behaviour so far has earned little positive reinforcement. She has, however, done a lot of vicarious learning about which behaviours seem to make other girls popular, and that observation, not personal experience, supplies the content of her plan.
Step 4: See agency and the cycle. Because she has agency, she forms a plan from what she has observed. Once she acts, the environment responds: peers give her a reputation, her family objects, and she adjusts by running away and, even in the interview, by exaggerating to match the reputation. Her behaviour was formulated, a cognitive process, in an interaction among her characteristics and perceptions, her behaviour, and the environment, including the social response to her behaviour. That is reciprocal determinism.
What the example shows. The analysis points straight to the program. Popularity and peer approval motivated her risky behaviour, so a program that ignores that goal will fail; a sound program keeps the goal and gives her other routes to it, emphasizing self-efficacy, behavioural capability, and vicarious learning. The common mistake is to treat Theresa as someone who simply lacks knowledge of risks, when knowledge is only a small part of what the constructs reveal.
The analysis turns a troubling story into a list of program targets. Before building that program, it helps to know where the most important of those targets, self-efficacy, actually comes from.
3.3 Where Self-Efficacy Comes From
Because programs lean so heavily on self-efficacy, it helps to know Bandura's own account of where it comes from. His 1977 paper named four sources, and each is a different kind of evidence a person can draw on when judging whether he or she can perform a behaviour. The first is mastery experiences, by which Bandura meant past success at the behaviour or at something like it. He considered mastery the strongest source, because the evidence comes from the person's own performance. The second is vicarious experiences, which come from seeing someone like you succeed: because the model resembles you, the model's success suggests that you could succeed too. In addition to these two sources, which rest on doing and on watching, two rest on interpretation. Verbal persuasion is being told credibly that you can do it. Physiological and emotional states refer to how you read your own nerves and feelings, since the same racing heart can be read as readiness or as a sign of inability. For example, the bicycle in 2.2 is a mastery story, because the confident child's past success with other difficult physical tasks gave the push to try, while the peer educator in Worked Example 4.1, who had used a kit herself, supplied a vicarious one. Notice that a vicarious experience, as a source of self-efficacy, is closely related to vicarious learning from 2.1, but the two answer different questions: vicarious learning concerns what a behaviour leads to, while a vicarious experience concerns whether you are able to do it.
Interactive 4.2 turns each source into a program tactic for three behaviours: responding to an opioid overdose with a naloxone kit, managing type 2 diabetes day to day, and quitting vaping. Choose a behaviour, click each of the four sources in turn to read its tactic, and add the tactics you would use to your build.
📊 Interactive 4.2: Self-efficacy source picker.
Choose a target behaviour, then choose a source of self-efficacy to see a program tactic built on it. Add tactics to your build; a complete program usually draws on several sources.Pick a source
The tactic will appear here, with a note on how strong Bandura considered that source.
A complete build usually draws on several sources at once, because each source supplies a different kind of evidence that the behaviour is possible. When a question describes a program feature, ask what evidence of ability it gives the participant: her own success (mastery), someone like her succeeding (vicarious experience), a credible voice (verbal persuasion), or a calmer reading of her own body and feelings (physiological and emotional states). With the constructs and the sources in hand, the next step is to build a program.
3.4 Building a Program from the Constructs
A program built on Social Cognitive Theory chooses constructs and attaches an activity to each. For Theresa, a sound answer emphasizes self-efficacy, behavioural capability, and vicarious learning, and keeps her goal intact: the general aim is to give her the tools to reach popularity and peer approval in less damaging directions. The proposed intervention has four components. Each component below is described with the construct it targets.
Social skills training in a group (behavioural capability, reinforcement, self-efficacy)
Theresa and girls like her gain behavioural capability in nonrisky behaviours that build good peer relationships: communication, self-presentation, and leadership. The group supplies peer feedback and reinforcement, and as skills are learned and rewarded, self-efficacy may grow as well. Three constructs engaged by one activity is typical of the theory in practice.
A leadership task for each girl (self-efficacy)
Each girl is assigned a task or project she will lead, such as putting on a small event or raising money for a youth-serving organization. This is a mastery experience: she succeeds at something visible and the success is hers.
An education component (expectations and expectancies)
Education about the risks and outcomes of the behaviours the group had been involved in, such as heavy drinking and sexual risk taking, aims at their perceptions of those situations. In the theory's terms, it works on expectations, what the girls think will happen if they keep behaving this way, and on expectancies, how much they value those outcomes. This component belongs in the context of the other activities, and the reason lies in Theresa's goal. Her risky behaviour was a route to peer approval, so information about harm, offered alone, asks her to give up the approval she wants. Learning about negative consequences might affect the value placed on the behaviour, but only alongside a route to the same social reward, which the skills training, the leadership task, and the mentor supply.
A college-age mentor (vicarious learning)
Each girl is paired with a relatively young mentor who involves her in an activity the mentor is doing successfully, theatre for example. The mentor is the social model, and time with someone succeeding at various activities provides behavioural examples the participant can draw on.
Notice that several components engage more than one construct, and that the leadership task supplies a mastery experience while the mentor supplies a vicarious one, the first two sources of self-efficacy in 3.3. The education component on its own would do little; it works only alongside a route to the same social reward.
Published studies show the same logic at work, and they are worth reading as evidence about which constructs carry weight, because they do not all point the same way. The first three tabs below describe a risk-reduction program for adolescent mothers, Internet-based obesity prevention, and a test of the theory for healthy eating in churches; the fourth describes the Chronic Disease Self-Management Program as offered in British Columbia, in whose session plan every construct of Table 4.1 can be found. Open each tab and note which constructs each program targeted or measured.
Adolescent Mothers HIV Risk-Reduction Program
Adolescent mothers in a tailored HIV/AIDS prevention program, built on Social Cognitive Theory and other theories, were compared with mothers who received health education only. Women in the tailored program improved more, including greater self-efficacy and subjective norms supporting protected sex, and fewer partners. The authors concluded that the results supported a relationship among constructs from Social Cognitive Theory and the Theory of Reasoned Action and later sexual risk behaviour, and that programs should include these constructs and address the contextual factors in the mothers' lives (Koniak-Griffin and Stein, 2006). Notice how freely the study mixes two theories.
Internet-based obesity prevention
Research points to long-term prevention of weight gain in normal weight, overweight, and moderately obese people as an alternative to prioritizing weight loss, because population-level annual weight gain is small (about 0.8 kilograms a year) and preventing it appears to require only a modest change in activity or intake. The Internet and mobile platforms offer a vehicle for accessible, long-term programs tailored on the theory's principles, and such programs have produced changes in nutrition practices, physical activity, and weight for up to a year (Winett and colleagues, 2005).
Testing the theory for healthy eating
Among 712 participants from 14 Baptist and United Methodist churches in southwestern Virginia, purchases of fat, fibre, fruit, and vegetables were affected by a combination of constructs: self-regulation, self-efficacy, outcome expectations, and social support. Self-regulation was the strongest factor, which has implications for which constructs must be included in interventions of this type. It is a useful corrective to the assumption that self-efficacy always leads (Anderson, Winett, and Wojcik, 2007).
Chronic disease self-management in British Columbia
The Chronic Disease Self-Management Program, developed at Stanford by Kate Lorig and colleagues, is built explicitly on self-efficacy theory. Trained lay leaders who live with a chronic condition run the sessions (vicarious experience), participants set weekly action plans and report back (mastery and reinforcement), and the group problem-solves symptoms and emotions together (emotional coping and verbal persuasion). In British Columbia it is offered through Self-Management BC, coordinated by the University of Victoria's Institute on Aging and Lifelong Health, with versions for chronic conditions generally, diabetes, and chronic pain. Every one of the ten constructs can be found in its session plan.
Two lessons come from the tabs. First, programs mix the theory freely with others, as the adolescent mothers study did with the Theory of Reasoned Action. Second, the construct that matters most varies: in the church study, self-regulation, close to what Table 4.1 calls self-control, was the strongest factor, not self-efficacy. Worked Example 4.3 applies the same design steps to a new Canadian problem; watch how each component is tied to a named construct and a named source of self-efficacy.
Worked Example 4.3: A Vaping Program for a Youth Clinic
The case. A youth clinic in Surrey, British Columbia, wants a program for 15- to 17-year-olds who have recently started vaping heavily, most of whom say they do it because "everyone at lunch does."
Step 1: Analyze the situation as the Theresa case was analyzed. The lunch group is the situation, and the approval that follows vaping is reinforcement. Watching peers vape without visible harm is vicarious learning that shapes expectations (nothing bad happens) and expectancies (belonging is worth it). A teenager who has tried to stop and failed has low self-efficacy for refusing an offered vape and little behavioural capability for doing so gracefully. As with Theresa, the goal of belonging at lunch is legitimate, and the program should preserve it.
Step 2: Attach a component to each chosen construct. Refusal-skills practice in a group, with role play and feedback, builds behavioural capability and supplies reinforcement, and succeeding in role play is a mastery experience. A peer leader a year or two older who quit and still sits at the same table provides vicarious learning; seeing someone like you succeed is a vicarious experience. Short-term quit goals tracked on a phone with clinic check-ins work on self-control (self-regulation), using verbal persuasion and small mastery experiences. A component on managing withdrawal jitters addresses emotional coping and draws on the physiological and emotional states source.
Step 3: Plan for the theory's weak point. Because the theory gives no weights to its constructs, the designer must state in advance which construct each component targets and measure each one separately; otherwise an evaluation that finds the program worked cannot say which construct did the work (7.1.2).
What the example shows. The design follows the Theresa pattern: keep the person's goal, change the route, and name a construct for every component. The common mistake is a program made only of information about the harms of vaping, which works on expectations alone and leaves the situation and reinforcement untouched.
Every program in this subsection required its designer to choose which of the many constructs to emphasize. That need to choose is exactly what the theory's critics point to.
7.1 Critiques of Social Cognitive Theory
The constructs, the Theresa intervention, and the published programs show how the theory is put to use. Two critiques concern the theory itself, and both follow from the history traced in Section 1.
7.1.1 A Theory or a Grab-Bag?
The first critique concerns the theory's shape as it stands today. The theory is very complex, and because it includes so many constructs said to be related to behaviour, it can be viewed as less a theory than a generally related "grab-bag." By this critics mean that the constructs are gathered in one place but are not organized into a statement of how they work together. One way to see the problem is to try to state the theory as a hypothesis: "Person A is likely to engage in Behaviour B if ________." No such clarity is possible, because there are no relative weights for the factors and no clear statement of the role of each or of when it comes into play. For example, the theory does not say whether self-efficacy or reinforcement matters more for a teenager deciding whether to vape with friends. Compare an individual theory such as the Health Belief Model, which can be written as a sentence. The grab-bag critique therefore does not claim that the constructs are wrong; it claims that the theory leaves the designer to decide which of them matter in a given case.
7.1.2 Old Clothes in the Closet: Construct Integration
The second critique concerns the theory's history rather than its present shape. The theory has gone through several evolutions, and the emphasis moved from a behaviourist variant through Social Learning Theory to the current focus on self-efficacy, yet every component ever included is still "hanging around." Think of saving old clothes: you wore them once, but do they define you now, and on what occasions could you wear them? In the same way, the older constructs, such as reinforcement from the behaviourist stage, may still be useful, but the evolution has created a problem of construct integration. By this we mean that it is not clear how the old and new pieces fit together into one account. You can see the critique at work in the research. When one study reports self-regulation as the strongest predictor, as the church study in 3.4 did, and another reports self-efficacy, the theory itself offers no way to say which result reflects how its parts are meant to fit together.
Telling the two critiques apart
The grab-bag critique is about the theory's shape now: too many unweighted constructs to state as a single hypothesis. The construct integration critique is about its history: constructs added over decades were never removed or fitted together. If a question mentions the theory's evolution or its leftover constructs, it is pointing at construct integration; if it mentions the lack of weights or of a testable hypothesis, it is pointing at the grab-bag.
Treat the critiques as a practitioner's warning rather than a reason to abandon the theory; the studies in 3.4 show programs that worked. They mean that you, the designer, must choose which constructs to emphasize and justify the choice, because the theory will not choose for you. The Theresa intervention did exactly that. Section 3 moves one step further out, to a theory in which the unit of analysis is no longer the person but the ties between people.
This section has defined the ten constructs, applied them to Theresa, described the four sources of self-efficacy, built programs from the constructs, and set out two critiques. The key takeaways below summarize these points, and the knowledge check that follows tests them.
Key Takeaways
- 3.1 The theory's ten constructs make sense once you sort them into three groups. Six are individual characteristics: self-efficacy (confidence), behavioural capability (knowledge and skill), expectations (predictions of what will happen), expectancies (whether that outcome is good or rewarding), self-control, and emotional coping. Three are environmental factors: vicarious learning, situation (the social and physical setting and the person's perception of it), and reinforcement; reciprocal determinism is the process that links them all. The pair most often confused is expectations and expectancies, so ask yourself whether a statement is a prediction or a valuation. Remember too the lesson's candid admission that the weight of each factor is unclear, with self-efficacy and observational learning the best understood.
- 3.2 Analyzing a case with the theory means stopping the story and naming the constructs at work at each point, as the Theresa case does. Theresa had earned little reinforcement, lacked the behavioural capability and self-efficacy to win approval, and had done a lot of vicarious learning about what made other girls popular; with agency, she formed a plan to be "bad." Her behaviour was formulated, a cognitive process, in an interaction among her characteristics, her behaviour, and the social response to it. In a case question, name both individual and environmental constructs and tie each to a specific detail of the story; the common mistake is to see only a lack of knowledge about risks.
- 3.3 Bandura named four sources of self-efficacy, and each suggests a kind of program tactic. Mastery experiences, past success at the behaviour or something like it, are the strongest; vicarious experiences come from seeing someone like you succeed; verbal persuasion is being told credibly that you can; and physiological and emotional states are how you read your own body and feelings. When a question describes a program feature, ask what evidence of ability it gives the participant: achieving her own action plan is mastery, a lay leader with the same condition is vicarious experience, and encouragement is persuasion. Strong programs, like the builds in Interactive 4.2, usually draw on several sources at once.
- 3.4 A program built on the theory chooses constructs and attaches an activity to each. The Theresa intervention keeps her goal of peer approval and changes the route: group social skills training builds behavioural capability with reinforcement, a leadership task gives a mastery experience for self-efficacy, an education component works on expectations and expectancies, and a college-age mentor supplies vicarious learning as a social model. Published programs show that the theory is often mixed with others and that the most important construct varies; in the church study, self-regulation, not self-efficacy, was strongest. When asked to design or critique a program, name the construct each component targets and check that the person's own goal is respected.
- 7.1 Two critiques follow from the theory's history. The grab-bag critique says the theory has so many unweighted constructs that it cannot be stated as a single hypothesis: "Person A is likely to engage in Behaviour B if..." cannot be completed. The construct integration critique says that every construct added over the decades is still hanging around, like old clothes in a closet, without a clear account of how the pieces fit, which is one reason different studies find different constructs strongest. To tell them apart, link the grab-bag to the lack of weights and the old clothes to the theory's evolution. The practical lesson is that the designer must choose and justify the constructs to target, and measure each one.
1. A pregnant smoker believes that if she quits she will gain a lot of weight, and she considers that outcome very bad. Which two constructs of Social Cognitive Theory are described, in order?
2. In the proposed intervention for Theresa, pairing each girl with a college-age mentor who involves her in an activity the mentor does successfully is designed to work through which construct?
3. The church-based healthy eating study in southwestern Virginia is a useful corrective to common program assumptions because it found that:
4. Which statement best expresses the first critique of Social Cognitive Theory?
5. A diabetes program in British Columbia has participants set a weekly action plan, report back to the group on whether they achieved it, and receive encouragement from a lay leader who also lives with diabetes. Which pairing of program feature and self-efficacy source is correct?
6. Teenagers at a Surrey youth clinic say they vape because "everyone at lunch does." Having watched friends vape every day with no visible harm, they predict that nothing bad will happen to them. Which constructs describe how they arrived at that prediction?
7. The clinic's vaping program combines refusal-skills practice, a peer leader, and quit goals tracked by phone. An evaluation finds that vaping fell, but the team cannot say why. Which critique of Social Cognitive Theory best explains the difficulty, and what should the team have done?
8. When Theresa's story is stopped at her move to public school, she does not know how to behave around the other students, and her good grades have not won their approval. Which construct names her lack of the skills needed to win peer approval?
✦ Pass the knowledge check with 100% to continue
Social Network Theory
⏱ Estimated reading time: 16 minutes
Overview
Social Cognitive Theory kept the individual in view and added the immediate environment. Social Network Theory takes the next step out and changes the unit of analysis altogether. It holds that the specific characteristics of individuals, such as their attitudes, beliefs, or gender, are not so important, because the focus is on the relationships between and among people and on how the nature of those relationships shapes beliefs and behaviour. This section explains that claim, shows how networks are drawn and what to look for in them, sets out the two steps for using the theory in a program with published and Canadian examples, and closes with two critiques.
Learning Objectives
- 4.1 Explain how Social Network Theory's account of behaviour differs from that of an individual theory such as the Health Belief Model, and describe the roles networks play in health.
- 4.2 Read a sociogram, distinguish the ego from the alters, and compare ego-centred and full relational networks.
- 4.3 Define the six network qualities and identify them in a network diagram or case.
- 4.4 Apply the two steps for using Social Network Theory to plan a health promotion program.
- 7.2 Explain the two critiques of Social Network Theory: limited scale and labour intensity.
4.1 Relationships, Not Characteristics
The key claim of Social Network Theory is a real departure from the individual theories. The theory holds that the specific characteristics of individuals, such as their attitudes, beliefs, or gender, are not so important for explaining behaviour. What matters instead are the relationships between and among people, and the way the nature of those relationships shapes beliefs and behaviour. The contrast with an individual theory is sharp. For example, the Health Belief Model asks what a person perceives: susceptibility, severity, benefits, and barriers. Network theory instead asks whom the person is tied to, how often, in how many ways, and who else those people are tied to. The consequence for interpretation is that two people with identical beliefs may behave very differently because they sit in different networks, so an explanation that looks only at their beliefs would miss the reason for the difference.
Social Network Theory is a broad area whose applications run from sociology and health to communications, political opinion, and mathematical and systems theory. It first surfaced in theoretical form among sociologists in the 1950s, in John Barnes' study of a Norwegian island parish, and has since expanded in many directions, including social network analysis handbooks and research on communication networks. By relationships the theory means the sets of relationships an individual participates in: family and kin networks, work networks, and any other social group of which the person is a member.
Concerning health, networks can play an important role in three ways. They influence whether someone acts in a risky way (smoking, no exercise) or a healthy way (eating well, exercising); they shape what health information a person is exposed to; and they determine what social support is available for adhering to treatment, coping with a difficult condition, or quitting smoking. A network can therefore be looked at from two angles. It can be read with respect to health risks: for example, a group of injection drug users who share needles creates a shared situation of high risk for HIV, hepatitis, and tuberculosis. It can also be read with respect to its supportive role: for example, a smoking cessation group that meets regularly and socializes together gives its members support for quitting. Which angle a program takes depends on whether it is trying to reduce a shared risk or to strengthen support.
Whether a network is read for risk or for support, the same tools serve. The first of them is a way of drawing the network.
4.2 Sociograms and Types of Network
Networks are usually drawn as a social network diagram, or sociogram: a map of people, drawn as nodes, and the ties between them, drawn as lines. The purpose of drawing the network is to make relationships visible, because a list of names says nothing about who is connected to whom. The simplest sociogram places a focus individual, called the ego, in the centre, with lines to the other people in the network, called alters. For example, if a first-year student is the ego, her alters might be her roommate, two classmates from a lab section, a teammate, and her mother at home, each joined to her by a line. Once the lines are drawn, you can begin to ask the questions the theory cares about: how many ties she has, which of them run both ways, and whether any of her alters also know one another.
There are many types of network, and two of them matter most for health work. The most common in health research and interventions is the ego-centred network, a map of the social relations surrounding one individual. It is built from that person's perspective: you interview him or her and map the relationship data the person gives you. A full relational network, by contrast, includes reciprocal information from all or a significant number of the other members. By this we mean that ties are described from both ends, which requires interviewing most of the network rather than one person. The difference matters for two reasons. The first is cost, since interviewing one person is far quicker than interviewing most of a group. The second is what you can see, since an ego-centred map shows only the ties the ego reports, while a full relational map can reveal cliques and confirm whether ties run both ways. Table 4.2 compares the two types on point of view, data collection, what each can show, and main limitation.
Table 4.2. Ego-centred and full relational networks compared by point of view, data collection, what each can show, and main limitation.
| Feature | Ego-centred network | Full relational network |
|---|---|---|
| Point of view | One ego describes his or her alters and ties | All or a significant number of members describe their ties to one another |
| Data collection | Identify one or more individuals for an activity where a network seems involved, interview them, and map the relationship data | Interview most of the network; more difficult and time-consuming |
| What you can see | The ego's ties, their types and reciprocity as the ego reports them | Cliques, bridges, and whether ties are confirmed from both sides |
| Main limitation | Only the ego's perspective | Confidentiality concerns can be a barrier, since each person names others |
The last two rows of Table 4.2 carry the practical lesson: an ego-centred map is cheaper and safer but shows only one person's view, while a full relational map reveals cliques and confirms ties from both sides at a much higher cost. Whichever map you build, the next question is what to look for in it.
4.3 Six Network Qualities
To use the theory you need research on the network of interest. Take exercise at a worksite as an example. You would want to know who is in the network, how often they interact, what kinds of interaction they have (only work, or social and exercise too, such as a group that jogs or plays basketball at lunch), who plays key relational roles such as organizing activities or belonging to several kinds of interaction, and whether there are cliques. The sociogram in Interactive 4.3 is a made-up worksite built to that description. Click each person to see his or her ties, then use the buttons to reveal the three subgroups and the density of the whole network.
📊 Interactive 4.3: A worksite sociogram.
Solid lines are two-way ties; dashed lines are one-way. Click a person to see the number, type, and reciprocity of his or her ties and what that position means for influence. Use the buttons to reveal the three subgroups and the whole-network density.Select a person
Ten employees, eighteen ties. Three kinds of interaction are recorded: work, social, and exercise.
The lesson of the worksite is about a person like Ed. Suppose Ed is an important member of the subgroup that jogs at lunch and also belongs to several of the subgroups that socialize outside work. Ed is then "a real gold mine in terms of influence." If you worked with Ed and asked him to help, he could bring others into the jogging network or distribute information about obesity prevention to every network he belongs to. The diagram tells you something about social influences on exercise, and also about channels of communication and channels of influence if you wanted to change it.
Six qualities are worth looking for in assessing a network's role in the health behaviour of its members, and each answers a different question about the network. The first is centrality versus marginality, which asks how many people an individual interacts with and how important a role he or she plays in network activities; a central person is tied to many others, while a marginal one sits at the edge. The second is reciprocity, which asks whether ties are one-way or two-way. For example, if Jane's relationship with Bill involves no more than receiving her mail when he drops it off, the tie is largely one-way; if she also processes paperwork he gives her and jogs with him at lunch, it is two-way. The third is complexity or intensity, which asks whether relationships are multiplex, combining several kinds of interaction, and whether the overall pattern of ties is dense. In addition to these three, a network can be assessed for its homogeneity or diversity, that is, whether its members are all of one type or of many types, and for its subgroups, cliques, and linkages, that is, whether interaction is concentrated among some members and whether any members link the network to other networks. Finally, communication patterns describe how information circulates and whether some members have more credibility than others. Each of the six cards below pairs the definition with the feature of the worksite sociogram in Interactive 4.3 that shows it.
Centrality vs.
marginality
The degree to which an individual has interactions with many people in the network or plays an important role in network activities. In the diagram: Ed has the most ties and sits in all three subgroups; Sam has two one-way ties and belongs to no subgroup. Ed is central, Sam is marginal.
Reciprocity
Are relations one-way or two-way? An example: if Jane’s relationship with Bill involves no more than receiving her mail when he drops it off, it is largely one-way. If she also processes paperwork he gives her and jogs with him at lunch, the tie is two-way and more complex. In the diagram: dashed lines are one-way ties.
Complexity or
intensity
Is the network mostly one-way relations, or primarily multiplex relationships that combine several kinds of interaction? Do all the people have relations with several alters, making a very complex or dense pattern? In the diagram: Ed and Bill share work, social, and exercise ties, a multiplex relationship; the Whole network button shows density, the share of possible ties that exist.
Homogeneity or
diversity
Are all members family? All male, or all female? Or is there a diversity of types of members? A homogeneous network circulates the same information and norms; a diverse one carries more kinds of information but may share fewer assumptions. In the diagram: the carpool is a parents-only subgroup; the joggers cut across roles.
Subgroups, cliques,
and linkages
Are there concentrations of interaction among some members? What is their nature? Are any members linked to other social networks? In the diagram: three subgroups exist, and only Ed links all three, which makes him the bridge along which information and influence travel between them.
Communication
patterns
How does information circulate through the network? Is it viewed equally coming from anyone, or do some members have more credibility? In the diagram: a message about lunchtime jogging would be more credible from Ed or Bill, who already jog, than from a memo sent by Tom.
Read together, the cards explain why Ed matters: he is central, his ties are two-way and multiplex, he links all three subgroups, and as a jogger his word about jogging is credible. When a question describes a person in a network, check each quality in turn and name the one the description actually shows; a person with many ties is central, while a person who connects two groups is a linkage between subgroups. Knowing where influence sits is the first of the two steps in using the theory.
4.4 Using the Theory in Two Steps
The theory is most useful as a strategy for relatively limited or defined groups; it is not a mass or large population intervention. The reason follows from what the theory needs in order to work. Because it explains behaviour through particular ties between particular people, a program can only use it once those people and ties are known, and they can only be known in a group small enough, or bounded enough, to study. A worksite, a congregation, or a network of people who use drugs in one city can be mapped; the whole population of a province cannot. Using it involves two steps, not counting evaluation. The first step is research to identify the important characteristics of the network. For an ego-centred network, this means identifying one or more individuals around an activity where a network seems to be involved, interviewing them, and building a map; for a full relational network, it means interviewing all or a significant number of members. The purpose of this research is to find where influence sits, using the qualities described in 4.3.
The second step is to develop an intervention that works with the network as a facilitator. By this we mean that the program does not go around the network to reach people one at a time, but uses the existing ties to carry the change. This can be done in two ways. One is to use the network to distribute information. For example, consider blues musicians and smoking cessation: the musicians appeared to be a network, so information might be best and most credibly disseminated through one of them. The other way combines the theory with the modeling construct of Social Cognitive Theory: you work with influential members to introduce risk-reducing behaviour by modeling it to the others, as when the lunchtime joggers begin recruiting the rest of their social network. In both cases the research from the first step decides whom the program works through.
Three published programs show the two steps at work. The three examples are described below: contraceptive adoption among married women in Bangladesh, the Multicultural AIDS Prevention Project in Flagstaff, Arizona, and the natural helpers of the Black Churches Project. For each, ask which network quality guided the design.
Social networks and contraception in Bangladesh
A home visit model was tested against a social network model for promoting contraceptive adoption among married women. In the network approach, government field workers were trained to organize group discussion sessions at the homes of community opinion leaders who were central to the community's network. The effect of the network intervention was almost double that of home visits, even after controlling for prior contraceptive use, prior home visits, and sociodemographic characteristics (Kincaid, 2000). Centrality was the design principle: the sessions went where the ties converged.
The Multicultural AIDS Prevention Project (MAPP)
Robert Trotter II and colleagues at Northern Arizona University first identified networks of injection drug users in semirural Flagstaff, Arizona. By uncovering the highest-risk relationship patterns in those networks, the team could direct targeted educational and other interventions to those "relational subsets" (Trotter, Bowen, and Potter, 1995). This is a risk network read for its structure: the intervention went to the ties along which needles travelled.
Natural helper interventions: the Black Churches Project
Communities and social groups often contain people with ongoing roles as natural helpers. The Black Churches Project identified such helpers in congregations and trained them as health promoters. Their presence within an existing network provided an important, accessible, and effective source of health information and support (Eng, Hatch, and Callan, 1985). The lay health advisor model that grew from this work is one of the most widely copied network interventions. Canada has a long-standing parallel in the Community Health Representatives who work in many First Nations communities, local people trained to carry health information and support through networks they already belong to.
Each program worked with an existing network as a facilitator: Bangladesh through central opinion leaders, Flagstaff through the highest-risk relational subsets, and the Black Churches Project through natural helpers, people who already have an ongoing role helping others. Canada's Community Health Representatives, local people in many First Nations communities trained to carry health information and support through networks they already belong to, are the natural helper model by another name. Worked Example 4.4 applies the two steps to a Canadian harm reduction program; watch which type of network is mapped and which qualities decide whom to train.
Worked Example 4.4: Take-Home Naloxone Through a Peer Network
The case. British Columbia's Take Home Naloxone program, run by the BC Centre for Disease Control since 2012, distributes kits and training free of charge through sites across the province (Toward the Heart). Distribution through clinics and pharmacies reaches many people, but a harm reduction coordinator in a mid-sized Interior city notices that the people at highest risk, those who use alone or in encampments, rarely visit either. Peer-run organizations such as the Vancouver Area Network of Drug Users, founded in 1997, have shown that people who use drugs already form dense networks of mutual aid. The coordinator proposes to map the local network by interviewing a few well-connected peers about whom they use with, share supplies with, and would call in an emergency, then to train the most central and credible people to carry kits and teach others.
Step 1: Research the network, and know what the map can show. Interviewing a few peers about their own contacts is an ego-centred approach: a few egos describe their alters and ties. It is faster and safer than a full relational map, but it shows only the informants' perspective, so cliques they do not enter, ties they do not know about, and whether the named ties are reciprocated all stay invisible.
Step 2: Decide which qualities matter most. For choosing whom to train, centrality and communication patterns rank highest: a kit carrier must be tied to many people at risk and must be someone whose advice about safer use is believed, which is why Ed and the Bangladesh opinion leaders were chosen. Subgroups and linkages come next, because a carrier who bridges encampments reaches people the clinic never sees. Reciprocity and complexity show which ties are strong enough to carry training rather than a rumour. Homogeneity matters least here, though it warns that an all-male network may not reach women who use alone.
Step 3: Work through the network. Train the most central and credible people to carry kits and teach others. The network becomes the facilitator, and, borrowing modeling from Social Cognitive Theory, trusted peers model the safer behaviour for the rest.
Step 4: Weigh the critiques. Mapping a network defined by illegal and stigmatized behaviour asks each person to name others, which is an ethical problem before it is a logistical one: names could expose people to police or to loss of housing. The problem can be reduced by keeping the map ego-centred, recording roles rather than names, having peers rather than staff conduct the interviews, and letting the peer organization hold the data, which is how peer-run groups such as the Vancouver Area Network of Drug Users have worked since 1997.
What the example shows. The two steps translate directly into practice: map the network, then work through the people the map shows to be central and credible. The common mistake is to choose carriers by willingness or job title rather than by their position in the network.
The naloxone case shows the theory at its best, and also where it strains: it reaches a defined group that clinics miss, but only through slow and sensitive work. Those two limits are the theory's critiques.
HEAL connection: the social environment as the determinant
Reciprocal determinism resembles the two-way processes of the HEAL Framework for Wellbeing introduced in Lesson 1: learning carries the results of action back into a person's beliefs and expectations, and conditioning describes environments that reinforce behaviour. A person's network is part of their social position and of the services and supports that reach them.
The research program on social connection that HEAL organizes treats social environments, rather than personal sociability, as the modifiable determinant of loneliness, so that equity work consists of building the systems and supports that make connection reachable for everyone. Network analysis is one way to see where those supports are missing.
7.2 Critiques of Social Network Theory
Social Network Theory, like Social Cognitive Theory, has limits that a program designer must weigh. The first concerns scale: it is a limited theory and approach, primarily useful for small or defined group interventions. By this we mean that the theory's method, finding the actual people and ties that carry influence, only works where those people can be found. If the aim is behaviour change in a larger population, it is not feasible except as, for example, one of several approaches to disseminating information. For example, the Bangladesh program worked village by village, organizing sessions in the homes of known opinion leaders; it could not have been a national television campaign, because a broadcast reaches everyone at once and does not travel along anyone's ties. A large program can still borrow from the theory, but only in pieces, such as recruiting central members of particular communities to pass a message along.
The second concerns labour: the approach is labour intensive and difficult. Identifying networks and conducting interviews is time-consuming, because each tie has to be learned from someone who knows about it, usually one conversation at a time. The burden grows with the kind of map you want. An ego-centred map needs only a few interviews, but if you want full relational data, information from all or a significant number of members, you must reach most of the group, and confidentiality can then become a barrier, since each person is being asked to name and describe others who have not agreed to be named. In a network defined by illegal or stigmatized behaviour, such as injection drug use, asking each person to name the others is an ethical problem before it is a logistical one, as Worked Example 4.4 showed.
Notice how the two theories so far divide the work. Social Cognitive Theory explains what a person learns from the people around her; Social Network Theory explains who those people are, how they are tied, and which of them can carry a message or a model to the rest. Both are built for groups you can name. Section 4 turns to two approaches designed for the opposite situation, where the goal is to move a behaviour or a technology through a whole population that no one can interview.
This section has set out the theory's focus on relationships, the sociogram and the two types of network, the six network qualities, the two steps for using the theory, and its two critiques. The key takeaways below summarize these points, and the knowledge check that follows tests them.
Key Takeaways
- 4.1 Social Network Theory changes the question from "what does this person believe?" to "whom is this person tied to?" Its key claim is that individual characteristics such as attitudes, beliefs, or gender are not so important, because the nature of a person's relationships shapes beliefs and behaviour. That is the basic difference from the Health Belief Model, which is built entirely from perceptions. Networks matter for health because they shape risky or healthy behaviour, the information people see, and the support they can draw on, and a network can be read for its risks, like people who share needles, or for its supportive role, like a cessation group that socializes together.
- 4.2 Networks are drawn as sociograms, with the focus person, the ego, at the centre and the other members, the alters, linked by lines. An ego-centred network maps relations from one person's account and is the most common type in health research because it is quicker and cheaper; a full relational network adds information from most members, revealing cliques and confirming ties from both sides, but it is harder to build and raises confidentiality concerns. When a case describes interviewing a few people about their own contacts, it is ego-centred, and its limit is that you see only their view. When time and staff are limited, the ego-centred map is the realistic choice.
- 4.3 Six qualities show how a network might carry influence: centrality versus marginality, reciprocity, complexity or intensity, homogeneity or diversity, subgroups, cliques, and linkages, and communication patterns, including who has credibility. Ed at the worksite shows several at once: he is central, has multiplex ties, links all three subgroups, and is credible on jogging, which makes him "a real gold mine in terms of influence." In an exam case, match each detail to one quality: a one-way tie is reciprocity, many ties is centrality, a person who bridges groups is a linkage, and whose word is believed is communication patterns. When choosing people to work through, centrality and credibility usually matter most.
- 4.4 Using the theory takes two steps, not counting evaluation: research to identify the network's characteristics, then an intervention that works with the network as a facilitator, either distributing information through it or, borrowing modeling from Social Cognitive Theory, having influential members model a safer behaviour. The examples follow this pattern: Bangladesh held discussions at the homes of central opinion leaders and nearly doubled contraceptive adoption compared with home visits, MAPP aimed at the highest-risk relational subsets, and the Black Churches Project trained natural helpers, as Community Health Representatives and peer naloxone carriers do in Canada. When asked to plan a network program, say how you would map the network, whom you would work through, and why their position makes them effective.
- 7.2 Social Network Theory has two critiques that mirror its strengths. It is limited to small or defined groups and is not a mass intervention, except as one of several ways of disseminating information. And it is labour intensive: identifying networks and conducting interviews takes time, and confidentiality is a barrier to full relational data, especially in networks defined by illegal or stigmatized behaviour, where naming others is an ethical problem before it is a logistical one. On an exam, use these critiques to explain why the theory would not suit a province-wide campaign, and suggest ways to soften the confidentiality problem, such as recording roles rather than names.
1. What is the basic difference between how Social Network Theory explains behaviour and how the Health Belief Model explains it?
2. In the worksite example, Jane receives her mail from Bill when he drops it off, and that is the extent of their interaction. Which network quality does this illustrate, and how should the tie be described?
3. A health unit wants to use Social Network Theory but has limited time and staff. Which choice is most consistent with the approach as described in this section?
4. In the Bangladesh contraception program, what feature of the intervention drew on Social Network Theory?
5. Which of the following is one of the two main critiques of Social Network Theory?
6. A harm reduction coordinator plans to interview a few well-connected peers about whom they use drugs with, share supplies with, and would call in an emergency, and to map the results. Which type of network is she building, and what will it fail to show?
7. The same coordinator must choose which peers to train to carry naloxone kits and teach others. Which two network qualities should weigh most heavily in her choice?
✦ Pass the knowledge check with 100% to continue
Diffusion of Innovations and Social Marketing
⏱ Estimated reading time: 18 minutes
Overview
Section 3 closed on the difference between a group whose members can be named and a whole population that no one can interview. The first two theories in this lesson are built for groups you can name; the last two are built for populations. This section reviews diffusion of innovations and social marketing together, sets out the processes, adopter categories, and attributes of diffusion, applies the four Ps of social marketing with segmentation and targeting, and shows how the two approaches combine. It ends with the critique the two approaches share and with a comparison of all four approaches in the lesson, so that you can choose among them for a given problem.
Learning Objectives
- 5.1 Explain why diffusion of innovations and social marketing are treated as descriptions of a process, distinct from theories built on constructs, and describe the origins of diffusion of innovations and Rogers' definition of diffusion.
- 5.2 Describe the five key processes of dissemination, including the stages of adoption and the three types of knowledge.
- 5.3 Distinguish the adopter categories, define diffusion context, and use the innovation attributes to predict how quickly something will spread.
- 6.1 Define social marketing and apply the four Ps to a health behaviour.
- 6.2 Apply market segmentation and targeting, and show how social marketing and diffusion of innovations combine in a single campaign.
- 7.3 Explain the critique about evaluating social marketing and diffusion efforts.
- 7.4 Compare Social Cognitive Theory, Social Network Theory, diffusion of innovations, and social marketing, and choose the approach that best fits a given health problem and population.
5.1 Process, Not Constructs: Origins of Diffusion of Innovations
Diffusion of innovations and social marketing are reviewed together because both are less theory driven and more a description of a process for how behaviour tends to change in groups of people or communities. By this we mean that neither offers constructs inside a person, as Social Cognitive Theory does with self-efficacy or expectancies. Instead, both describe how something new travels through a population, from the people who take it up first to those who take it up last or not at all. This difference changes how you use them: rather than asking which construct a program feature targets, you ask which part of the process it supports. However, the two approaches do not ignore the individual. Both borrow from earlier theories, such as self-efficacy, vicarious learning, and perceived costs and benefits, wherever it helps, as the implementation process in 5.2 and the price of social marketing in 6.1 show.
Diffusion approaches have roots in rural sociology, in studies such as Ryan and Gross' account of hybrid seed corn spreading among Iowa farmers, and in the 1920s and 1930s anthropology of how cultural practices diffuse. Everett M. Rogers set out the general theory in 1962 in a book revised through several editions that remains a classic (Rogers, 1962). Its concern is the process by which a behaviour or technology makes its way into a population and is, or is not, adopted. In Rogers' definition, "diffusion is the process by which an innovation is communicated through certain channels over time among members of a social system," with a goal of maximizing exposure and reach. The innovation is whatever the target population perceives as new, whether a technology or a behaviour. By this Rogers meant that newness is judged by the audience rather than by the planner: a practice that is routine in one place is still an innovation for a group that has not yet taken it up. Note also the resemblance to stage models of individual behaviour change, such as the Transtheoretical Model. Because diffusion happens "over time," dissemination has a chronological element built in, and an innovation moves through steps in order.
The definition has four parts worth remembering: an innovation, channels, time, and a social system. The process that moves an innovation through them has five steps.
5.2 Five Key Processes of Dissemination
There are five key processes in disseminating an innovation: innovation development, dissemination, adoption, implementation, and maintenance. The five processes are described below; together they follow an innovation from its development to the point at which it no longer depends on the program.
1. Innovation development
Planning, formative research, and testing of the innovation itself, which can be a technology, such as oral rehydration packets for children with diarrhea, or a behaviour, such as exercise or HIV testing.
2. Dissemination
"Active knowledge transfer from the resource system to the user system." By this we mean that the people who developed the innovation (the resource system, such as a health agency or research team) deliberately carry it to the people who are meant to use it (the user system, such as a community or a group of clinics), rather than waiting for word to spread on its own. It involves identifying communication and dissemination channels: who will carry the innovation, through what media and relationships. For example, oral rehydration packets might be carried to mothers through community health workers and local clinics, while information about HIV testing might travel through radio, peer educators, and social media.
3. Adoption (the stage-model parallel)
Uptake by the intended audience, moving through knowledge of the innovation, persuasion or attitude development, decision, implementation, and confirmation; notice the parallels to the Transtheoretical Model and the Precaution Adoption Process Model. The decision is influenced by three types of knowledge: awareness knowledge (it exists), procedural knowledge (how to use it), and principles knowledge (how it works).
4. Implementation
Implementation is the initial use of the innovation by those who have decided to adopt it. Deciding to use something and actually using it are different steps, because first attempts are where people discover they are unsure how to proceed. For this reason program focus is often on the self-efficacy and skills of those who have adopted, a construct borrowed from Social Cognitive Theory. A linkage agent, such as an outreach educator, can help by connecting the new users to the people and resources behind the innovation, answering questions, and supporting those first attempts until the behaviour or technology is in regular use.
5. Maintenance
Keeping the pattern going after first use. The focus is sustainability, which can also mean institutionalization: building the behaviour or technology into routines, budgets, and rules so that it no longer depends on the program.
Two parts of the sequence repay a second look. Adoption itself has stages, knowledge, persuasion, decision, implementation, and confirmation, and the decision is influenced by three types of knowledge: awareness knowledge (the innovation exists), procedural knowledge (how to use it), and principles knowledge (how it works). Implementation is where programs often work on the self-efficacy and skills of those who have adopted, borrowing from Social Cognitive Theory, with the help of a linkage agent such as an outreach educator.
Common confusion: processes, stages, and types of knowledge
Keep three lists apart. The five key processes describe the whole program: development, dissemination, adoption, implementation, and maintenance. The five stages of adoption describe the audience's uptake: knowledge, persuasion, decision, implementation, and confirmation; they parallel the Transtheoretical Model's stages without being the same list. The three types of knowledge, awareness, procedural, and principles, influence the decision. Someone who knows a screening kit exists but not how to take the swab has awareness knowledge and lacks procedural knowledge; "confirmation" is a stage, not a type of knowledge.
The processes describe what a program does. The next subsection describes who adopts, in what order, and what makes an innovation spread quickly or slowly.
5.3 Adopters, Context, and Attributes
5.3.1 Adopter Categories and the S-Curve
Innovations are not taken up by everyone at once. They are adopted in stages by different categories of adopters: early adopters, early majority, late majority, and laggards. Rogers' full scheme adds a small group of innovators in front and estimates each category's share of a population; when those shares are added up over time, they produce the S-shaped curve of cumulative adoption. The purpose of identifying the categories is practical. Once you know who is likely to adopt first and who last, you can plan a strategy for each. For example, consider getting fine-restaurant chefs to introduce low-fat dishes. The early adopters might be up-and-coming chefs trying to make a name for themselves, so you target them first and let publicity about their adoption spur the rest. The example shows the logic of the categories: each group responds to a different push, and the visible adoption of one group becomes part of the push for the next. Interactive 4.4 plots cumulative adoption over time as an S-shaped curve, shades Rogers' adopter categories with his estimated shares, and explains what a program does at each stage. Drag the slider slowly from left to right and read the panel at each stage.
📊 Interactive 4.4: The diffusion S-curve.
Drag the slider through time. The curve shows cumulative adoption; the shaded bands are Rogers' adopter categories with his estimated shares. The panel explains what a program does at each stage.Before launch
Innovation development: planning, formative research, and testing. Nobody has adopted yet.
The curve rises slowly while only innovators and early adopters have taken up the innovation, steeply as the early and late majority follow, and flattens as the laggards are reached last. The shape follows from the fact that the curve is cumulative: it adds each new group of adopters to everyone who adopted before. Because the first two groups are small, the total grows slowly at first. Once the much larger majority groups begin to adopt, partly because they can now see the early adopters using the innovation, the total climbs quickly. Finally, because only a small group of laggards remains, there are few people left to add and the curve levels off. The practical point is the one the chefs example makes: reach the early adopters first, and let their visible adoption carry the innovation to the rest.
5.3.2 Diffusion Context and Innovation Attributes
Two further concepts complete the picture, and they answer different questions. The first is the diffusion context, the complex of factors in the target population and in the program itself that may facilitate or hinder diffusion. By this we mean the surroundings into which an innovation is introduced, as opposed to the innovation itself. For example, a centralized state may force dissemination through one gateway, or local political and social structures may inhibit a new behaviour. The second concept is the set of product attributes, the features of the innovation itself that determine the speed and extent of diffusion. The five most often cited are relative advantage, compatibility, complexity, trialability, and observability. Keeping the two concepts apart helps when you analyze a case: the attributes tell you what to change or emphasize about the innovation, while the context tells you what in the population and the program will help or get in the way. Table 4.3 lists those five and several additional attributes, with the question each asks, applied to a real Canadian innovation: in January 2024 British Columbia became the first province to offer at-home HPV self-screening in its cervix screening program. Notice that many attributes are really about barriers to adoption.
Table 4.3. Attributes that determine the speed and extent of diffusion, the question each asks, and how each applies to at-home cervix self-screening kits in British Columbia.
| Attribute | The question it asks | At-home cervix self-screening kits, British Columbia |
|---|---|---|
| Relative advantage | Is the innovation better than what it replaces? | A swab at home replaces a speculum exam at a clinic: a clear advantage for many. |
| Compatibility | Does it fit with the intended audience? | Fits people without a family doctor or with past trauma; less so for those who trust only a clinician's exam. |
| Complexity | Is it easy to use? | A few steps and a mail-back envelope; instructions in several languages matter. |
| Trialability | Can it be tried before deciding to adopt? | One kit is one trial; the decision is small. |
| Observability | Are the results observable and easily measurable? | Weak: a normal result is invisible to others, so word of mouth must do the work. |
| Effect on social relations | Does it disrupt the social environment? | Minimal. |
| Reversibility | Can it be reversed or discontinued easily? | Yes; clinic screening remains. |
| Communicability | Can it be understood clearly and easily? | Yes, once the HPV link is explained. |
| Time | Can it be adopted with minimal time? | Minutes, versus an appointment. |
| Risk and uncertainty | Can it be adopted with minimal risk? | Doing the swab correctly is the main worry. |
| Commitment | Can it be used with modest commitment? | Once every few years. |
| Modifiability | Can it be modified and updated over time? | Kits, instructions, and eligibility can be revised. |
Read down the third column of Table 4.3: the kit is strong on four of the five main attributes and weak on observability, because a normal result is invisible to others. That tells a program where to put its effort, into stories and word of mouth that make an invisible result visible. Worked Example 4.5 applies the same concepts, the diffusion context, the attributes, and the adopter categories, to an ordinary object and a small audience, where every step is easy to see.
Worked Example 4.5: Diffusion at a Small Scale
The case. A diffusion strategy for a simple object, such as coloured pens, offered to an audience split into early adopters, majority adopters, and laggards, assesses the diffusion context, emphasizes product attributes, and seeks early adopters and change agents. Here the object is a refillable water bottle, offered to the forty residents of one floor of a student residence as a replacement for vending machine drinks.
Step 1: Assess the diffusion context. The floor has a shared kitchen with a tap, a vending machine by the stairs, and a floor group chat that most residents read. The tap makes refilling easy; the vending machine is the competing habit.
Step 2: Rate the five main attributes. The bottle has a clear relative advantage (refills are free, and machine drinks cost money), fits the habit of carrying a bag every day (compatibility), needs no instructions (low complexity), can be borrowed for a week before buying (trialability), and is carried in plain view (observability).
Step 3: Find the early adopters and a change agent. The early adopter is the resident who already organizes floor events, because others watch what that person does and an organizer has a reputation to build. The residence advisor, who can keep spare bottles in the kitchen, serves as change agent.
Step 4: Match a channel to each adopter category. A personal invitation to try a bottle reaches the early adopters; photos of their bottles in the group chat reach the early majority; a refill station beside the vending machine reaches the late majority; and for the laggards, the new norm itself does the work once most of the floor carries a bottle.
What the example shows. Every diffusion concept in this section can be used as a checklist. The common mistake is to rate the attributes and stop; the attributes tell you what to emphasize, but the adopter categories tell you whom to reach first and how.
Diffusion of innovations asks how something new travels through a population. Social marketing asks how to make the new thing attractive enough that people choose it.
6.1 Social Marketing and the Four Ps
Social marketing applies the principles of marketing to health aims. It treats behaviour change as a "product" that you, the health promotion professional, are trying to market, and it treats the target population as consumers who weigh that product like any other product choice. The goal is voluntary adoption: people take up the behaviour because they come to see it as in their interest, not because they are required to. For this reason the word marketing can mislead. What social marketing borrows from commercial marketing is the voluntary choice and the need to present the behaviour as attractive in its costs and benefits. Notice the resemblance to diffusion of innovations, which also asks what makes something new attractive, and even to the Health Belief Model, which weighs perceived benefits against perceived barriers.
Kotler and Zaltman introduced the approach in the late 1960s and early 1970s (social marketing); it has since been used widely, especially in reproductive health and HIV/AIDS programs internationally. Canada's landmark is ParticipACTION, founded in 1971, whose advertising and later Body Break segments made physical activity a marketed product for a generation (ParticipACTION).
The principles are summarized as the four Ps: product, price, place, and promotion. Open each of the four tabs below to see how one P applies to a running example, smoking cessation among pregnant women.
Product: what are you offering, and what are its benefits?
Several elements: the behaviour of quitting, which may include a program or product such as the patch or nicotine gum; the idea of a healthy baby; and the idea that the mother will live to see her child grow up. A key formative research task is to identify which benefits matter most to the target population, because those, and not the ones the professional finds obvious, are the product.
Price: what does adoption cost the target population?
In social marketing, price means more than money. It is everything a person gives up or puts up with in order to adopt the behaviour. Smoking may have benefits of its own, such as being the glue for social interaction, and so quitting can cost a pregnant woman her breaks with co-workers or time with friends who smoke, in addition to the discomfort of withdrawal. For this reason the perceived costs of quitting may be high, even when the health benefits seem obvious to a professional. Understanding the costs as a specific population perceives them is a research task, because a program cannot lower a price it has not identified. Price is where the Health Belief Model's perceived barriers reappear under another name.
Place: how do you make the behaviour easily available?
Access and availability. Cessation programs would have to be easily available, possibly in-home, or located where an expectant mother already goes, such as her prenatal clinic. With condoms, a second example, place means putting them where they will be available for last-minute use.
Promotion: how do you make people aware of the other three?
The campaign must make expectant mothers aware of the benefits, that the price is not so bad, and that programs are available and attractively located. As in commercial marketing, multiple channels and repeated or sequenced messages work best: a slogan, and a dissemination plan through media, interpersonal methods such as community presentations, and print materials.
In short, product is the behaviour or technology and the benefits that matter to the population; price is the costs of adoption as the population perceives them, which may be social as well as financial; place is access and availability; and promotion is making people aware of the other three through multiple, repeated channels. A common error is to treat social marketing as promotion alone: a campaign of posters with no attention to price and place leaves most of the four Ps untouched.
6.2 Segmentation, Targeting, and Combining the Approaches
Two further terms come from marketing, and they are easy to confuse because they work as a pair. Market segmentation divides a target population into meaningful subgroups so that messages and campaigns can be channelled appropriately. For example, messages and channels for expectant teen mothers may differ significantly from those for adult expectant mothers, so a campaign for pregnant smokers would treat the two as separate segments. Targeting is the step that follows: it develops campaigns closely tailored to the needs, attitudes, beliefs, and behaviours of a specific segment. In other words, segmentation decides who the subgroups are, and targeting decides what to offer one of them. A question that describes dividing an audience into groups is about segmentation; a question that describes shaping a campaign for one chosen group is about targeting. Interactive 4.5 works the four Ps and segmentation through three Canadian campaigns: organ donor registration in British Columbia, carrying a take-home naloxone kit, and sun safety for outdoor workers. For each campaign, answer each P's question yourself before revealing the planner's answer, then read the segmentation note that appears once all four Ps are open.
📊 Interactive 4.5: Four Ps planner.
Choose a Canadian campaign, answer each P's question yourself, then click to reveal how a planner might fill it in. The segmentation note appears once all four are open.Product
Price
Place
Promotion
The planner shows that the same four Ps produce quite different campaigns for different audiences, which is why segmentation comes before targeting. Diffusion of innovations and social marketing can also be applied to the same problem at once. Worked Example 4.6 does so for helmet use among bikers; watch for the points at which a diffusion concept and a marketing P turn out to be the same move.
Worked Example 4.6: Helmet Use Among Serious Motorcycle Riders
The case. Imagine an effort to increase helmet use among "bikers," the social group of serious Harley-Davidson riders. Not wearing a helmet is the norm. From the biker viewpoint, required helmets impinge on the freedom to ride the way they want, and being a biker means freedom, "one of the last free ways of life left"; bikers are skilled riders who do not need protection; and a helmet gets in the way of your senses and the feel of the road.
Step 1: Develop the innovation, which is also the product. Using diffusion of innovations, treat the helmet as an innovation and redesign it to fit the biker image: black, with biker decals and emblems, perhaps endorsed by Harley-Davidson. This raises its compatibility with the group. Developing the innovation is similar to the product in social marketing, and both approaches promote benefits.
Step 2: Address price. Price is one category of cost and benefit, so you might seek a government subsidy to lower the cost of the redesigned helmet.
Step 3: Recruit an early adopter. A well-known biker who wears a helmet becomes an early adopter whose visible adoption can spur the rest, as the up-and-coming chefs did for low-fat dishes.
Step 4: Choose credible channels, which are also promotion and place. Information would flow through channels credible to bikers: repair shops, dealers, and biker events. In diffusion terms these are dissemination channels; in marketing terms they are promotion, and they put the helmet where bikers already buy gear.
Step 5: Account for the context. In Canada motorcycle helmets are required by law across the country, with religious exemptions in some provinces. The law changes the diffusion context: for most riders the question is no longer whether to wear a helmet but which helmet and how willingly. The objection about freedom survives the law, so a helmet designed to fit the biker image still matters.
What the example shows. The two approaches overlap almost completely: developing the innovation is the product, and credible dissemination channels are promotion. Diffusion adds adopter categories and attributes; social marketing adds an explicit look at price and place. The common mistake is to list tactics without saying which concept each one applies.
Two published examples follow the same logic. A survey of 58 family physicians, analysed with diffusion of innovations, found that Internet use began when physicians were not constrained by heavy patient volume and could see its benefits, and that as they experienced its usefulness, searching became easier and quicker and their use grew (Chew, Grant, and Tote, 2004). And the National Cancer Institute's "5 A Day for Better Health" campaign, with the Produce for Better Health Foundation, repeated one message, eat five or more servings of vegetables and fruit daily, through produce bags, in-store displays, packaging, recipe cards, brochures, magazines, news, Internet and social media, radio and television, billboards, schools, health fairs, cookbooks, and more, increasing knowledge of the product and of how to fit it into daily life. The first shows implementation supported by self-efficacy and skill; the second shows promotion at full scale, one message through dozens of channels. Campaigns of this size raise a hard question, which is how anyone can tell whether they worked.
7.3 The Evaluation Critique
Diffusion of innovations and social marketing share a critique that concerns evaluation: assessing the effect of a campaign can be difficult. The reason lies in what the campaign is trying to change. If behaviour change is the goal, it is not always easy to track who was exposed to the campaign and how far their behaviour, or at least their attitudes, changed. However, some social marketing campaigns, and most diffusion efforts, introduce a technology as the behaviour change, such as condoms for HIV and STI prevention or oral rehydration packets for child survival. That is easier to track, simply because a technology is more tangible and observable than a behaviour. In this sense the critique is the observability attribute of 5.3.2 turned on the program itself: an innovation whose results are easy to see spreads more readily, and a program whose product is easy to see is easier to evaluate.
The at-home HPV self-screening kits of Table 4.3 show the contrast. Every kit ordered, returned, and processed is counted by the laboratory, so uptake by segment can be measured directly, whereas a campaign to increase physical activity must estimate minutes of activity that no one counts. The critique does not mean that behaviour campaigns cannot be evaluated, only that it is harder. With the critiques of all four approaches now in view, the lesson can compare them.
7.4 Choosing Among the Four Approaches
That completes the lesson's four approaches: a theory of learning from others, a theory of the ties along which learning travels, and two descriptions of how something new moves through a population. Choosing among them starts with two questions: how large and how nameable is the group, and what has to change? Table 4.4 compares the four approaches on what each explains, the scale at which it works best, how a program uses it, and its main critique.
Table 4.4. The four approaches in this lesson compared by what each explains or describes, the scale at which it works best, how a program uses it, and its main critique.
| Approach | What it explains or describes | Works best for | How a program uses it | Main critique |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Social Cognitive Theory | Learning from others in a cycle of reciprocal determinism among person, behaviour, and environment | Individuals and groups in a defined setting | Targets chosen constructs, such as self-efficacy, behavioural capability, and vicarious learning | A grab-bag with no weights; construct integration |
| Social Network Theory | Behaviour through the ties between and among people | Small or defined groups that can be mapped | Maps the network, then works through central, credible people or natural helpers | Limited scale; labour intensive, with confidentiality barriers |
| Diffusion of innovations | How an innovation is communicated through channels over time in a social system | Communities and populations | Develops the innovation, reaches early adopters first, and works on weak attributes | Hard to evaluate when the innovation is a behaviour |
| Social marketing | Behaviour change as a product chosen voluntarily | Populations, divided into segments | Plans product, price, place, and promotion for each targeted segment | Hard to evaluate when the goal is a behaviour |
Table 4.4 suggests a rule of thumb rather than a formula. For a group you can name and interview, Social Network Theory finds the people through whom to work, and Social Cognitive Theory says what those people should model and build. For a whole population, diffusion of innovations and social marketing describe how to make something new attractive and how to move it through channels. Most real programs combine approaches, and a sound answer to "which theory fits?" names the feature of the problem, its scale, its setting, or what must change, that justifies the choice. Worked Example 4.7 makes that choice for one community program; watch how each approach is matched to a specific finding from the community.
Worked Example 4.7: Choosing Approaches for a Northern Physical Activity Program
The case. A First Nations health organization in northern British Columbia and the regional health authority are co-designing a program to increase physical activity among adults in three communities, one road-accessible and two fly-in. Formative work found that people are motivated by family and community more than by personal fitness, that a few well-known community members already run walking groups and hockey nights, that the winter is long and facilities are few, and that a previous poster campaign changed nothing.
Step 1: Read the problem. The communities are small enough that their members can be named, influential people already exist, the motivation is collective, the climate and geography shape what is possible, and promotion alone has already failed. Each finding points to a different approach.
Step 2: Social Cognitive Theory for what to build. Target self-efficacy through mastery (short, achievable winter walks and gradual goals), vicarious learning through visible models who already walk or play, reinforcement and the situation through group activity in which showing up is recognized, and expectancies framed around family and community benefit rather than personal fitness.
Step 3: Social Network Theory for whom to work through. Use ego-centred mapping led by community members, starting from the people who already run walking groups and hockey nights; identify who is central, who bridges households and age groups, and whose word carries credibility. Those people, along with Community Health Representatives, are the natural helpers to train and support. The community should own the data, and the plan must budget for the time that mapping takes.
Step 4: Diffusion of innovations for how the activity spreads. Treat the walking group as an innovation. It rates high on compatibility (it fits existing patterns), trialability (anyone can come once), and observability (people are seen walking), moderate on relative advantage in winter, and low on complexity. The group leaders are early adopters and change agents whose visible participation can draw in the early majority, and the fly-in geography and long winter are the diffusion context.
Step 5: Social marketing for one segment. For parents of school-age children: the product is time outdoors with family and a stronger community; the price is cold, darkness, and the awkwardness of joining; the place is activities that start at the school or band office at pickup time, with indoor options in the coldest months; and the promotion is invitations carried by the walking-group leaders and community radio rather than posters, sequenced through the season.
Step 6: Choose under constraint. If resources were cut, a well-reasoned plan might drop social marketing, because the communities are small enough that network-based and modeling approaches reach everyone directly, and the failed poster campaign shows that promotion without attention to place and price changed nothing. Alternatively, it might drop full network mapping in favour of simply working with the known leaders, citing the labour-intensity critique. Either choice is defensible if the reasoning uses the critiques.
What the example shows. The four approaches are complementary, and the choice among them follows from the problem's scale and from the critiques. The common mistake is to name a theory without saying which feature of the problem it fits.
Holding all four approaches at once, and choosing among them for a stated reason, is the skill the final review asks for. This section has described the origins and key processes of diffusion, the adopter categories, the diffusion context and the attributes of an innovation, the four Ps of social marketing with segmentation and targeting, the evaluation critique, and a way to choose among the lesson's four approaches. The key takeaways below summarize these points, and the knowledge check that follows tests them.
Key Takeaways
- 5.1 Diffusion of innovations and social marketing are grouped because both are less theory driven and more descriptions of a process by which behaviour changes in groups and communities; neither offers constructs inside a person, and both borrow from earlier theories. Diffusion of innovations has roots in rural sociology, such as the spread of hybrid seed corn among Iowa farmers, and in 1920s and 1930s anthropology, and Everett Rogers set out the general theory in 1962. His definition is worth knowing well: diffusion is the process by which an innovation is communicated through certain channels over time among members of a social system. An innovation is whatever the target population perceives as new, whether a technology or a behaviour.
- 5.2 The five key processes follow an innovation from start to finish: innovation development (planning, formative research, testing), dissemination (active knowledge transfer through chosen channels), adoption, implementation (initial use, often supported by work on self-efficacy and skills and by a linkage agent), and maintenance (keeping it going, including institutionalization). Adoption has its own stages, knowledge, persuasion, decision, implementation, and confirmation, which parallel individual stage models such as the Transtheoretical Model. The decision depends on awareness knowledge (it exists), procedural knowledge (how to use it), and principles knowledge (how it works). The usual trap is mixing these lists, so check whether a question asks about the program's processes, the audience's stages, or a type of knowledge.
- 5.3 Innovations are taken up by adopter categories in turn, innovators and early adopters, then the early majority, the late majority, and laggards, producing the S-shaped curve of cumulative adoption. Identifying the categories lets you plan a strategy for each, such as reaching up-and-coming chefs first and letting their publicity spur the rest. The diffusion context is the set of factors in the population and the program that help or hinder spread, and the attributes, above all relative advantage, compatibility, complexity, trialability, and observability, set the speed and extent of adoption, mostly by naming barriers. When given a case, rate each attribute, find the weakest, and say how the program would make up for it, as with the invisible result of a cervix self-screening kit.
- 6.1 Social marketing borrows the logic of commercial marketing for health: behaviour change is a product, the population are consumers, and the goal is voluntary adoption because people come to see the behaviour as in their interest. Planning follows the four Ps: product (the behaviour or technology and the benefits that matter to the population), price (the costs as they perceive them, social as well as financial), place (access and availability), and promotion (making people aware of the other three through multiple, repeated channels). In a case, sort each detail into one P; the social role of smoking for a pregnant woman, for example, is part of the price of quitting. Remember that a campaign of posters alone is promotion only and leaves the other three Ps untouched.
- 6.2 Market segmentation divides a population into meaningful subgroups, such as expectant teen mothers and adult expectant mothers, and targeting develops campaigns closely tailored to one segment's needs, attitudes, beliefs, and behaviours; segmentation comes first. Social marketing and diffusion of innovations overlap so much that they are often used together, as the biker helmet example shows: redesigning the helmet is both innovation development and product, a subsidy addresses price, a well-known biker is an early adopter, and credible channels such as shops, dealers, and biker events are both dissemination and promotion. When a question asks how the approaches relate, name the specific points of overlap and what each adds: diffusion contributes adopter categories and attributes, and marketing contributes price and place.
- 7.3 The critique shared by diffusion and social marketing concerns evaluation. When the goal is a behaviour, it is hard to track who was exposed to a campaign and how far behaviour, or at least attitudes, changed. When the program introduces a technology, such as condoms, oral rehydration packets, or a self-screening kit, evaluation is easier because the technology is tangible and observable and its uptake can be counted. On an exam, explain the contrast in those terms, and avoid overstating it: behaviour campaigns can be evaluated, only with more difficulty.
- 7.4 Choosing among the four approaches starts with the scale of the problem and what has to change. For a group you can name and interview, Social Network Theory shows whom to work through and Social Cognitive Theory shows what those people should model and build; for a whole population, diffusion of innovations and social marketing describe how to make something new attractive and move it through channels. Most real programs combine approaches, as the northern walking-group plan in Worked Example 4.7 does. A strong answer names the feature of the problem that justifies each choice and uses the critiques to say what the chosen approach cannot do.
1. Why are diffusion of innovations and social marketing reviewed together?
2. A public health unit wants family physicians to adopt a new electronic referral system. The physicians know it exists but say they do not understand how to use it. In the adoption stage of diffusion of innovations, which type of knowledge is missing?
3. A cervix self-screening kit is easy to use, clearly better than a clinic exam for many people, can be tried once at low cost, and fits people without a family doctor, but a normal result is invisible to others. On which innovation attribute does it score weakest?
4. In a social marketing campaign to reduce smoking among pregnant women, the finding that smoking serves as "the glue for social interactions" belongs under which of the four Ps?
5. Why is the effect of a diffusion effort that introduces a technology, such as oral rehydration packets, easier to assess than a social marketing campaign aimed at a behaviour?
6. Planners of an at-home HPV self-screening rollout decide that newcomers whose first language is not English need different messages and channels from long-time residents who avoided screening after a bad experience. Dividing the target population in this way is:
7. After people order a self-screening kit, pharmacists and community health workers help them learn how to take the swab correctly. In diffusion of innovations, these helpers are acting as:
8. Two planners ask for advice. One wants to raise uptake of a new free vaccine among all adults in a province. The other wants to reduce needle sharing among about forty people who use drugs together in one neighbourhood and are known to an outreach worker. Which pairing of approaches best fits the two problems?
✦ Pass the knowledge check with 100% to continue
Final Review & Assessment
⏱ Estimated time: 25 minutes
Bringing It All Together
This lesson crossed the blurred line between a person and his or her surroundings that individual theories keep pointing at. The opening admission set the terms: there is no definitive way to separate an individual from his or her social/environmental context, so internal/external and individual/social are arbitrary labels that help us position our thinking. That context includes the family and meanings a person is born into, friendship and work networks, the physical space, the political-economic space with its rules and products, and the person's own experience of interacting with all of it, the layers of an onion that Bronfenbrenner called a person's ecology. The lesson then worked outward from the individual. Social Cognitive Theory began as an offshoot of behaviourism when Bandura proposed in the 1960s that reinforcement directed at other people also teaches the observer (vicarious learning). Self-efficacy and agency were added in 1977, the cycle of reciprocal determinism followed, and the theory was renamed in the mid-1980s. Its ten constructs sort into individual characteristics, environmental factors, and the process that links them; the Theresa case showed the cycle in motion and an intervention built from chosen constructs; Bandura's four sources of self-efficacy turned into program tactics; the published programs showed which constructs carried weight; and the critiques, the grab-bag and the old clothes, showed why a designer must choose.
Social Network Theory changed the unit of analysis from the person to the tie. Individual characteristics are not so important to it; what matters is who is connected to whom, how often, in how many ways, and with what credibility. Its tools are the sociogram, the distinction between ego-centred and full relational networks, and six qualities: centrality, reciprocity, complexity or intensity, homogeneity, subgroups and linkages, and communication patterns. Its practice is two steps, map the network and then work through it, as the Bangladesh opinion leaders, the Flagstaff relational subsets, the Black Churches natural helpers, and Canadian peer-based naloxone distribution all illustrate. Its limits are the mirror of its strengths: it suits groups you can name, and mapping them is labour intensive and raises confidentiality concerns.
Diffusion of innovations and social marketing are built for populations and describe a process rather than a set of constructs. Rogers defined diffusion as the communication of an innovation through certain channels over time among members of a social system; the five key processes run from innovation development through dissemination, adoption, implementation, and maintenance, and adoption itself has stages that parallel the stage models. Adopter categories allow a strategy for each group, the diffusion context can help or hinder, and attributes such as relative advantage, compatibility, complexity, trialability, and observability set the speed of spread. Social marketing packages a behaviour as a product with a price, a place, and a promotion, segments the market, and targets each segment, aiming at voluntary adoption because people come to see the behaviour as in their interest. The bikers and their helmets showed the two approaches overlapping almost completely, and the evaluation critique reminded you that a behaviour is harder to count than a kit. Finally, choosing among the four approaches starts from the scale of the group and what has to change, as Table 4.4 and the northern walking-group plan in Worked Example 4.7 showed.
Key Takeaways from this lesson
- You can now explain why the line between individual and social/environmental theories is arbitrary but useful, and describe a person's context as the layers of an onion that Bronfenbrenner called an ecology: family and meanings, networks, physical space, political-economic space, and personal experience. The most useful habit is to sort each influence in a case into its layer, and to classify a theory by its main focus while acknowledging that the theories reach across the line.
- You can trace Social Cognitive Theory from behaviourism through Social Learning Theory and vicarious learning to self-efficacy, agency, reciprocal determinism, and the mid-1980s renaming. Remember that reciprocal determinism, the cycle of acting, receiving a response, adjusting, and acting again, is what makes the theory social/environmental, and that self-efficacy is confidence, not skill.
- You can define the ten constructs, sorted into individual characteristics, environmental factors, and the linking process, together with Bandura's four sources of self-efficacy, and use them to analyze a case like Theresa's and to design program components. In every application, tie each construct to a detail of the case or a component of the program, and keep the person's own goal in view while changing the route to it.
- You can explain how Social Network Theory accounts for behaviour through ties rather than characteristics, read a sociogram with its ego and alters, distinguish ego-centred from full relational networks, identify the six network qualities, and apply the two steps of mapping a network and then working through it. When choosing whom to work through, look first for centrality and credibility, as with Ed, the Bangladesh opinion leaders, and natural helpers.
- You can describe diffusion of innovations: Rogers' definition, the five key processes, the stages of adoption and the three types of knowledge, the adopter categories, the diffusion context, and the attributes that set the speed of spread. The practical habit is to rate an innovation's attributes, find its weakest one, and reach the early adopters first.
- You can apply the four Ps of social marketing, product, price, place, and promotion, with market segmentation and targeting, and show how they overlap with diffusion of innovations, as in the biker helmet example. Remember that price is the cost as the population perceives it, and that a campaign of promotion alone leaves most of the plan untouched.
- You can evaluate each approach's critiques, the grab-bag and construct integration for Social Cognitive Theory, limited scale and labour intensity for Social Network Theory, and the difficulty of evaluating behaviour campaigns for diffusion and social marketing, and use them to choose an approach for a given problem. Start every choice by asking how large and nameable the group is and what has to change, and justify the choice with a feature of the problem.
Final Knowledge Assessment
This assessment covers all material from this lesson. Complete all 18 questions below with 100% accuracy to finish the lesson; the Submit button unlocks once you have passed every section knowledge check. Review the feedback for any incorrect answers and try again.
1. The terms internal/external and individual/social are best described as:
2. Urie Bronfenbrenner's image of a person's ecology as "layers of an onion" makes which point?
3. In the 1960s Bandura and others proposed that operant conditioning also worked when:
4. Which construct did Bandura introduce that moved the theory beyond the mechanistic conditioning of behaviourism and gave individuals a role in their own processes of change?
5. A worksite program teaches employees the correct technique for lifting heavy boxes and gives them practice until they can do it. Which Social Cognitive Theory construct is this component primarily building?
6. Theresa's decision to be "bad" and "get a reputation" was formed from what she had observed about which behaviours made other girls popular. Which construct explains where her plan came from?
7. Which statement about the two critiques of Social Cognitive Theory is accurate?
8. In Social Network Theory jargon, the focus individual whose network is being mapped and the other people in that network are called, respectively:
9. In the worksite example, Ed, who is an important member of the lunchtime jogging subgroup and also belongs to several social subgroups outside work, is "a real gold mine in terms of influence." Which network qualities make him so?
10. A health promoter wants to work with a smoking cessation support group that meets regularly and socializes together. In network terms this is:
11. The Multicultural AIDS Prevention Project in Flagstaff, Arizona, used Social Network Theory by:
12. In diffusion of innovations, adoption of an innovation requires movement through which sequence of stages?
13. A health unit trying to get restaurant chefs to introduce low-fat dishes decides to approach up-and-coming chefs first, expecting publicity about their menus to influence the rest. This strategy is based on:
14. A campaign places free naloxone kits in pharmacies without a prescription, at harm reduction sites, and at venues where overdoses occur, so that a kit is always within reach. Which of the four Ps does placing the kits in these locations address?
15. Which statement best captures the relationship between diffusion of innovations and social marketing in the biker helmet example?
16. In three northern First Nations communities, formative work finds that a few well-known community members already run walking groups and hockey nights. A planner proposes to identify who is central and credible in each community and to train and support those people, alongside Community Health Representatives, to bring others in. Which approach and step does this proposal apply?
17. The same planners treat the walking groups as an innovation. Anyone can come once without committing to more, and people out walking are seen by everyone in the community. On which two innovation attributes does this description show the walking groups scoring high?
18. An earlier poster campaign urging adults in the same communities to be more active changed nothing. Using social marketing, what is the most likely explanation?
✦ Pass every section knowledge check with 100% before submitting