Social, Cultural, and
Environmental Theories II
Health Promotion: Individuals and Communities
Learning objectives for this lesson:
- Describe the technical model of communication (sender, encoding, channel, noise, receiver, decoding, feedback) and explain what it leaves out about context, relationship, and meaning.
- Apply encoding, message design, channel selection, and agenda setting to a health communication problem for a specific audience.
- Describe community mobilization, including its movement roots, key figures, three key issues, and empowerment, and explain why a setting sometimes has to change before behaviour can.
- Describe organizational development and the staged models of organizational change, and apply them to an organization adopting a health practice.
- Apply a political-economic analysis to a health problem using the concepts of syndemic, trajectory of risk, and structural violence, and explain how microcredit illustrates the approach.
- Contrast the adaptation and cultural readings of behaviour in anthropology, define culture and the ethnomedical system, and apply them to a program that is not being used.
- Evaluate the critiques of communication, community and organizational change, political-economic, and cultural approaches to health behaviour, and judge which approach fits a given situation.
This course was developed by Dr. Kiffer G. Card, to accompany Edberg, M. Essentials of Health Behavior: Social and Behavioral Theory in Public Health. Jones & Bartlett Learning. This lesson follows Chapter 6 of the text.
Glossary: Key Terms, People & Concepts
📚 Reference page, available throughout the lesson
This glossary collects the key concepts, people, and ideas you will meet in this lesson. Use it as a reference while you work through the material, or as a review before assessments. Type in the search box to filter entries.
Communications Theory: Encoding, Channels, and Meaning
⏱ Estimated reading time: 16 minutes
Overview
This lesson continues the tour of theories that locate the causes of behaviour outside the individual. It moves beyond theories in which behaviour spreads through models, networks, and markets, farther out to communication, to communities and organizations, to political and economic structure, and to culture. Each is a field in its own right that a single lesson can only sample, and each answers a question the individual-level theories could not: what happens to a message, an intention, or a program once it meets the social world. This first section is about the message. It sets out the technical model of how a message travels from a sender to a receiver, shows what that model leaves out, and turns the ideas of encoding, channel selection, and agenda setting into a method for designing and checking a health campaign.
Learning Objectives
- 1.1 Define communication, explain why human communication is symbolic, and describe the steps of the technical (Shannon-Weaver) model and Lasswell's definition of communication.
- 1.2 Explain what the technical model leaves out: context, relationship, the meaning of the channel, and the interpretive work of encoding and decoding.
- 2.1 Explain encoding and decoding as acts of meaning, and define message design.
- 2.2 Explain why channel selection and agenda setting matter, and apply them to a specific audience.
- 2.3 Apply the communications method (learn the audience's code, encode in it, use the audience's channels, check the decoding) to a health communication problem, and describe programs that have used it.
- 7.1 Explain why the effect of a communications effort is hard to measure, and how changing technology complicates the choice of channels.
1.1 Communication and the Technical Model
Start with a deliberately wide definition. Communication is the transmitting, receiving, and processing of information that matters for behaviour. By this we mean that any exchange in which information passes from one party to another and shapes what the receiver does counts as communication, and in that broad sense every organism does it: cells, genes, birds, and dogs all communicate. The purpose of starting so widely is to show what is distinctive about people. Human communication is almost unique because it is symbolic, which means that its meaning is carried by symbols that people assemble and rearrange. For example, a person can build a sentence from components of meaning, rearrange them, deliver it with humour or a picture, or compress it into a text message, and each of these changes alters what the message means to the person who receives it. This is why the same health information can work in one form and fail in another.
For health promotion, the forms of communication that matter most are interpersonal communication, Internet and wireless communication, and mass communication. Although these forms use very different technologies, the same questions run through all three: who is speaking, in what code, through what medium, to whom, and with what result.
The mechanical basics come from two mid-century sources. The communications theorist Harold Lasswell defined communication as who says what, in which channel, to whom, and with what effects (Lasswell, 1948). Claude Shannon, a mathematician at Bell Laboratories, laid out the process that has been known since as the Shannon-Weaver model (Shannon and Weaver, 1949). The model can be summarized in five steps:
- a sender encodes a message, packaging the content in text or symbols;
- the sender transmits it through a channel, such as speech, a telephone, or email;
- during transmission the message may encounter noise, meaning any interference;
- a receiver decodes it so that it can be used; and
- the receiver may send feedback to the sender.
Figure 5.1 draws these steps as boxes and adds annotations for the social dimensions that a fuller account of communication includes. Read the boxes first, as the technical model, and then the annotations, which preview the next subsection.
Figure 5.1. The communication process: the technical model with its social dimensions added. Boxes are the technical steps; the annotations are what a fuller account of communication adds.
A useful habit is to name each element when you meet a case. A garbled telephone line is noise; a public health unit is a sender; a parent reading a letter is a receiver decoding it; a reply card or a follow-up survey is feedback. Being able to label the parts is the starting point, but the model's own authors called it a technical description, and the next subsection explains why that word is a warning.
1.2 What the Technical Model Leaves Out
The five steps describe how a message moves, but on their own they say nothing about the factors that decide whether a message means to the receiver what it meant to the sender. The annotations in Figure 5.1 mark where those factors enter, and four omissions matter most. The first is the context of the communication, by which we mean whether the setting is formal or informal. The second is the relationship between sender and receiver, including whether one has authority over the other and whether there is a gender difference between them. Context and relationship shape how a receiver reads a message before the content itself is considered. The third omission is that the model treats the channel as a neutral pipe, although the channel itself carries meaning. For example, the same words arrive differently by letter than by telephone, and a vaccination reminder from a family physician of twenty years is a different communication from the same words in a mass email. The fourth is that the model treats encoding and decoding as mechanical steps, although both are acts of meaning-making: the sender chooses symbols for a purpose, and the receiver interprets them with their own background. Several thinkers filled these gaps, and their contributions are worth knowing by name. The four items below show what a fuller account adds; notice that each one describes something the receiver brings to the message that the sender cannot control.
Context, relationship, and the meaning of the channel
Is the setting formal or informal? Does one party have authority over the other, and is there a gender difference? Does the same sentence mean something different by letter than by telephone? A vaccination reminder from a family physician of twenty years is a different communication from the same words in a mass email.
Encoding and decoding as meaning-making (semiotics) and McGuire's additions
Packaging a message and reading it are both interpretive acts. By this we mean that the sender is not simply copying information into a channel but choosing words, images, and a tone that they expect to carry a particular meaning, and the receiver is not simply copying it out again but working out what those choices mean to them. The branch of communications theory that studies signs, symbols, and this kind of meaning-making is called semiotics. In addition to this interpretive view, William McGuire added a series of steps that a receiver must pass through before a message has any effect, including attention, comprehension, liking, and action. This changes how the diagram should be read. Instead of a single arrow from sender to receiver, there is a set of hurdles, and a message can fall at any one of them. For example, a smoking cessation poster may be noticed but not understood, or understood but disliked, or liked but never acted on, and in each case the message has failed even though it was delivered.
Speech communities and shared worlds
A conversation between longtime friends is full of gaps and unfinished sentences, because shared knowledge lets each receiver fill them in. Social linguists, including William Labov, John Gumperz, and Dell Hymes, describe a speech community as a setting in which speech styles and underlying knowledge are shared enough to sustain distinct communication patterns. By this we mean that the members of a speech community share not only a vocabulary but also a store of background knowledge, so they can leave a great deal unsaid and still be understood. The difficulty for a health communicator is that the gaps a community fills in automatically are invisible to an outsider. Because of this, a communicator outside the audience's speech community must learn its code first, or the message will be decoded with gaps filled in ways the sender never intended.
Discursive practices, institutions, and technologies
Michel Foucault pointed to prevailing discursive practices: the rules, tied to a society's assumptions about knowledge and truth at a moment in history, by which communication is judged credible or not and by which language sorts and values the social world. By this we mean that every society has unwritten rules about whose words count as knowledge, and those rules change over time. For example, whether "the science says" or "my grandmother says" carries authority is a discursive fact: in one group a statement backed by research settles the matter, while in another a statement backed by family experience does. A health message that relies on the wrong kind of authority for its audience can be decoded as not credible, however accurate it is. Institutions matter too. George Gerbner observed that television had become the dominant storyteller for children, and that its programs are products made to earn income. This means that what a channel carries is shaped by the interests of whoever owns it, so a communicator who uses that channel is working inside those interests rather than outside them.
Taken together, the four items explain why a message can arrive intact in the technical sense and still fail. McGuire's hurdles (attention, comprehension, liking, action), the shared knowledge of a speech community, the discursive practices that decide what counts as credible, and the institutions that own the channels all sit outside the five boxes. When an exam question asks why a technically sound message failed, the answer usually lies in one of these omissions rather than in noise. The most important of them, the interpretive work of encoding and decoding, is the subject of the next subsection.
2.1 Encoding, Decoding, and Message Design
Encoding deserves the most attention, because it is where health communicators most often lose the audience. Encoding means putting information into a code that will make sense to the recipient in the way you want. By this we mean that a sender never simply utters a string of information units: every message is packaged in words, symbols, a tone, and a route, and the packaging carries meaning of its own. Three everyday illustrations show the idea, and in each of them the real message lies in the code rather than in the literal content.
- Gossip. A rumour that a certain Mr. Smith goes to the dog races is really a message to Smith, carried by his peers, that the group will think less of him unless he behaves as it expects. The form (gossip) and the route (his peers) carry the real message, which is disapproval.
- Advertising. A luxury car paired with a rock anthem encodes an identity rather than a set of specifications. The music, not the engine details, carries the real message about what kind of person drives the car.
- Diction. Slang or polite speech, and whether you open with a formal greeting, encode the relationship before the content arrives. The same request reads as coming from a peer or from an authority depending on these choices alone.
Decoding is the mirror image of encoding. The receiver interprets the message with their own tools, which include cultural background, socioeconomic class, gender, and institutional connection. In other words, the receiver does not simply unpack what the sender packed; they read it through their own experience. If sender and receiver share an understanding of the symbols, the message survives the trip. However, if they do not, the sender has to encode the message so that it will be decoded as intended, and that requires knowledge of the recipient's interpretive patterns, which in turn requires research. Designing a message so that a receiver with a different background decodes it as intended is called message design. The purpose of message design is to close the gap between the sender's code and the receiver's, which is why it begins with research on the audience rather than with the sender's own wording.
Encoding for an Audience Is Not Simplifying
"Encode for the audience" is not a synonym for "simplify" or "translate." A simple message can carry the wrong code (a clinical tone that reads as condescension), and a word-for-word translation can still fail, because the symbols, the source, and the channel carry meanings translation does not touch. Message design starts with how the audience already talks about the issue.
Once the code is right, two further decisions remain: which medium will carry the message, and how to make the audience care enough to act on it. The next subsection takes them in turn.
2.2 Channel Selection and Agenda Setting
A channel is the medium through which a message travels. Broad channels include the Internet, social media, mobile phones, television, print, and rallies, while narrower outlets include community-language newspapers, college radio, and churches. Channel selection matters for two reasons. First, the channel is itself part of the meaning of the message, as Subsection 1.2 showed with the letter, the telephone call, and the mass email. Second, some channels reach a particular group far better than others, and with more credibility. For example, a magazine aimed at women is an unlikely route to men, and a tabloid will not make a message credible to highly educated men. The practical consequence is that reach in the general population says nothing about reach in the target group: a channel that very many people use may still miss the people a campaign needs. Finding the right channel is therefore a research task rather than a matter of choosing the largest audience.
The last idea in this overview is agenda setting. People act on information they see as important and relevant, and many issues compete for their attention at any one time. Agenda setting is the effort to move an issue higher on the public agenda, by which we mean higher among the things people regard as worth attending to and acting on, and health communication does this much as a political campaign does. The first step is to find where the issue currently sits on the agenda of the target population, which is again a research task. The second is to find the hook that raises it, often by pairing the health issue with something the audience already cares about. Agenda setting should not be confused with encoding. Encoding decides how a message is packaged so that it is understood as intended, whereas agenda setting decides whether the audience thinks the issue matters enough to act on at all. A message can be well encoded and still be ignored if the issue sits low on the audience's agenda.
Interactive 5.1 lets you try encoding, channel selection, and choice of receiver on a single message. It holds the content fixed (influenza vaccination is available, free, and recommended this fall) and lets the receiver, the channel, and the encoding vary across four audiences. Try at least two receivers, find the strongest combination for each, and watch how the likely decoding changes when only the receiver changes.
📊 Interactive 5.1: Send the same message to four audiences.
The content is fixed: a public health unit wants people to get an influenza vaccine this fall. Choose a receiver, a channel, and an encoding, then send. The simulator reports the receiver's interpretive tools, the fit of each choice, and the likely decoding. Find the strongest combination for each receiver, and notice how much changes when only the receiver changes.The simulator makes the central point of this section concrete: no combination of channel and encoding is best for everyone, because the receiver's interpretive tools decide what the message comes to mean. The next subsection turns these decisions into a method and shows it at work in real campaigns.
2.3 Using Communications Theory in Health Campaigns
The elements of the model become a method when they are applied to a particular audience. The method has four moves: learn the audience's code through formative research, encode the message in it from a source the audience respects, use the channels the audience already uses, and check the decoding with follow-up research. Worked Example 5.1 shows the method on a small scale. As you read it, notice that research appears at both ends, before the message is written and after it is sent.
Worked Example 5.1: An Anti-Smoking Message for a Star Wars Subculture
The case. A health promotion team wants to reduce smoking among young people who are deeply involved in a Star Wars subculture and who interact mostly at conventions and on social media.
Step 1: Identify the behaviour and the receivers. The behaviour is smoking; the receivers are young fans whose shared knowledge of the films makes them a speech community with a code of its own.
Step 2: Learn the code. Formative research at conventions found that film characters were used as everyday metaphors and in usernames. That is the code the message has to be written in.
Step 3: Encode the message in it. The anti-smoking message was tied to an admirable reference inside the culture, attributed to an authoritative source within it (a Jedi Master), and even phrased in Yoda's word order. This is message design: the content is ordinary, but the code and the source are the audience's own.
Step 4: Choose the channels. The channels were already known from the research: conference posters and a social media page, where the audience already gathers.
Step 5: Check the decoding. Follow-up research asked whether receivers read the message as intended, which is feedback built into the design.
What the example shows. Research the code, encode in it, use the audience's channels, check the decoding: the method in miniature. A common mistake is to treat the Yoda phrasing as a gimmick or as agenda setting; it is encoding, chosen because research showed it was how this audience already talks.
The same four moves scale up to national campaigns. The three tabs that follow describe programs that have used communications theory: the Partnership for a Drug-Free America media campaign, the Texas Tobacco Prevention Media and Community Campaign, and ParticipACTION in Canada. Open each tab and, for each program, identify which part of the method it illustrates: the choice of receivers, message design, channel selection, agenda setting, or the measurement of effect.
Partnership for a Drug-Free America media campaign
A nonprofit coalition of communications, health, medical, and educational professionals that, with advertising and public affairs organizations, disseminated national drug prevention messages through television, radio, print, and the Internet. Two features connect it to the theory: the messages were aimed at both those at risk (youth) and those who influence them (parents, doctors), a decision about receivers; and they were developed through research with the intended audiences, which is message design. Donated agency work and media time show institutions of communication being enlisted.
Texas Tobacco Prevention Media and Community Campaign
An adult campaign combining television, radio, newspaper, and billboard advertising with outreach and a telephone quitline, plus expanded counselling and pharmacological therapy through clinical and community programs. The evaluation compared areas that received different combinations of these elements. Areas combining cessation services with high-level media nearly tripled the smoking reduction seen where nothing was offered and nearly doubled that of media alone. In other words, the media messages did more when people who were moved by them had somewhere to turn for help in quitting. The evaluation also traced how the effect came about: exposure was related to processes of change in quitting, and those processes to the quitting observed (McAlister and colleagues, 2004). This matters because the evaluation measured exposure, then change processes, then behaviour, which are the levels the critique below warns are hard to connect. Rather than stopping at how many people saw the advertising, it followed the chain through to quitting itself.
ParticipACTION
Canada's longest-running physical activity communication effort began in 1971, and its 1973 television spot claiming that the average 30-year-old Canadian was about as fit as a 60-year-old Swede is still cited as a lesson in encoding (ParticipACTION). The literal content, Canadians are inactive, had been said many times; the encoding, national pride and a rival, gave it a hook that raised it on the public agenda. Wound down in 2001 and relaunched in 2007, its later work, including report cards on children's activity, shows the other half of the theory: channels (news media, schools, sport organizations) chosen for reach and credibility.
Across the three tabs the pattern is the same: the Partnership chose its receivers and designed messages through audience research, ParticipACTION found an encoding that raised an old message on the agenda, and the Texas campaign paired media channels with community services and measured effect beyond exposure. Worked Example 5.2 runs the method in reverse, as a diagnosis of a campaign that did not reach its audience. As you read it, watch for which element of the model each finding points to.
Worked Example 5.2: Drug-Poisoning Alerts in a Small BC City
The case. A regional health authority in British Columbia issues alerts when an unusually toxic batch of unregulated drugs is detected. The alerts go up on the authority's website and social media within hours, in careful public health language: the substance, the overdose risk, and advice to carry naloxone, use with someone present, and call 911. Six months in, an evaluation finds the alerts widely shared by agencies and journalists, but people who use drugs in one small city rarely see them, and those who do often read them as a sign that police attention is coming. The same people learn about bad batches quickly, from peers and from two outreach workers they trust.
Step 1: Identify the intended receivers and who actually received the message. The intended receivers are people who use drugs. The people who received it were agencies and journalists, so exposure looks high on paper while the intended audience is barely reached.
Step 2: Map the findings onto the model. The channel (an official website and social media feed) is not one the receivers use; their real channels are peers and outreach workers. Where the alert did arrive, the receivers decoded it with their own tools, including experience with police and distrust of institutions, so an official health authority alert meant "police are coming" rather than "stay safe." The source also matters: the authority lacks the credibility that the two outreach workers have. The careful public health language is an encoding that belongs to the sender's speech community, not the receivers'.
Step 3: Redesign the effort. Use the channels the receivers already trust, such as the outreach workers, peer networks, and harm reduction sites; let trusted peers and outreach workers be the visible source; and encode the alert in the receivers' own plain language, stating clearly that it has nothing to do with police.
Step 4: Build in follow-up research. Ask a sample of people who use drugs whether they received recent alerts, what they understood them to say, and who they believed sent them. That checks decoding, not only exposure.
What the example shows. A message can be technically delivered and widely shared yet fail, because the channel and the receivers' decoding were never designed for. The tempting wrong diagnosis is noise; nothing interfered with the alert in transit, and the problem lay in who received it and what it meant to them.
Both worked examples rest on research before and after the message, and the second shows how easily a campaign can mistake wide sharing for success. Judging success properly is the hardest part of communications work, which is the critique taken up next.
7.1 Critique: Why Campaign Effects Are Hard to Measure
The main critique of communications approaches is about evaluation. Assessing the effect of a communications effort is difficult because there are many levels of possible impact, by which we mean that a message can succeed at one level and still fail at the next. The first level is exposure, the share of the intended audience who report seeing the message. Exposure is the easiest level to measure, and it is where many evaluations stop. However, exposure does not translate automatically into behaviour change: a person can see a message, and even remember it, without thinking about changing anything. The next level is to find how many of those exposed thought about or made a change. Measuring this means tracking a sample of exposed people for a period after the campaign, and that is difficult. Table 5.1 sets out the levels of effect, from exposure to behaviour change, with the question asked at each level and how it is usually measured; notice that the middle rows follow McGuire's hurdles from Subsection 1.2.
Table 5.1. Levels of effect of a communications effort, the question asked at each level, and how each level is usually measured.
| Level of effect | Question asked | How it is usually measured |
|---|---|---|
| Exposure | How many intended receivers encountered the message? | Recall surveys, reach and audience data |
| Attention and comprehension | Did they notice it and understand it as intended? | Recall of content, decoding checks in follow-up interviews |
| Liking and acceptance | Was the message, and its source, credible and relevant to them? | Ratings of the message and source, agenda position |
| Intention and thinking about change | Did the message move them toward action? | Measures of change processes and intention in a followed sample |
| Behaviour change | Did they act, and did the action last? | Behaviour tracked over time, validated where possible |
The critique does not say that campaigns never work or that their effects cannot be measured. The Texas tobacco campaign in Subsection 2.3 measured exposure, then the processes of change in quitting, then quitting itself, which is exactly the chain Table 5.1 describes. What the critique demands is that an evaluation name the level it measured and not claim more.
A second consideration is technology. Formats change quickly enough to make last year's channel obsolete, and a message can go viral in hours. In addition, each new format attracts particular population segments, so a proliferation of channels also produces a proliferation of subgroups. By this we mean that every new platform divides the audience further, and each part of the audience may have its own code and its own preferred channels. The consequence is that the research step never becomes optional: the audience's code and channels have to be learned again for each campaign, even when the same organization is speaking to what looks like the same population.
This section has set out the technical model of communication and what it leaves out, the encoding and decoding on which message design depends, channel selection and agenda setting, programs that have used the theory, and the levels at which the effect of a campaign can be measured. The key takeaways and knowledge check that follow review this material, and the next section turns to the communities, organizations, and systems that can support or inhibit behaviour change.
Key Takeaways
- 1.1 Communication is the transmitting, receiving, and processing of information that matters for behaviour, and human communication is special because it is symbolic. Lasswell summed it up as who says what, in which channel, to whom, and with what effects, and the Shannon-Weaver model gives the steps: a sender encodes a message, transmits it through a channel where noise may interfere, and a receiver decodes it and may send feedback. In a case question, start by labelling these parts; a garbled phone line is noise, a reply or follow-up survey is feedback. Keep noise for interference in transit, and do not use it as a catch-all for any message that fails.
- 1.2 The technical model is a starting point, not an explanation of why messages succeed. It leaves out the context and the relationship between sender and receiver, the meaning carried by the channel itself, and the interpretive work of encoding and decoding that semiotics studies. McGuire's hurdles (attention, comprehension, liking, action), speech communities (Labov, Gumperz, Hymes), Foucault's discursive practices, and Gerbner's point about television as a storyteller run for income all fill those gaps. When a well-delivered message fails, look for the answer in one of these omissions, and name it.
- 2.1 You never send bare information; you send it in a code, as gossip about Mr. Smith, a car advertisement, or a choice between slang and formality all show. The receiver decodes with their own tools, including cultural background, class, gender, and institutional connection, so the message that arrives can differ from the one sent. Message design is the work of encoding a message so that a receiver with a different background decodes it as intended, and it depends on research into how the audience already talks. Remember that encoding for an audience is not the same as simplifying or translating.
- 2.2 The channel is part of the message and decides who is reached and with what credibility, so the most widely used channel in a population is not automatically the right one for the target group. Agenda setting is the competition to make a health issue seem important and relevant enough to act on, and its first step is research on where the issue currently sits for the audience. In an applied question, justify a channel by saying both what it means to the audience and whether it reaches them, and raise an issue on the agenda by pairing it with something the audience already cares about.
- 2.3 The communications method has four moves: learn the audience's code, encode the message in it from a source the audience respects, use the channels the audience already uses, and check the decoding. The Star Wars message shows the method in miniature, and the Partnership for a Drug-Free America, the Texas tobacco campaign, and ParticipACTION show it at scale. When diagnosing a failed campaign, as with the BC drug-poisoning alerts, ask whether the channel reached the receivers and how they decoded what arrived, before blaming noise or the receivers themselves.
- 7.1 The main critique of communications approaches is that effects are hard to assess, because exposure, attention and comprehension, liking, intention, and behaviour change are separate levels and only exposure is easy to measure. Tracking a sample of exposed people over time is the only way to reach the later levels, as the Texas campaign did. Fast-changing technology multiplies channels and audience subgroups, so research has to be repeated for every campaign. When you evaluate a claim of success, ask which level was actually measured, and do not accept exposure as proof of behaviour change.
1. A public health nurse leaves a vaccination reminder as a voicemail, but a poor telephone connection garbles half of it before the parent hears it. In the technical (Shannon-Weaver) model, what is the poor connection?
2. A health unit posts a carefully worded overdose alert on its website, but people who use drugs in the community hear about bad batches only from peers and outreach workers, and some read the official alert as a warning that police are coming. In the terms of the communication model, which two elements best explain the failure?
3. Encoding is illustrated in this lesson with gossip about a certain Mr. Smith. What point does the example make?
4. Which statement about channel selection matches the reasoning of communications theory?
5. In a campaign for young Star Wars fans, the anti-smoking message was phrased in Yoda's word order and attributed to a Jedi Master. Which principle does this illustrate?
6. A health unit's HPV vaccine consent letter gets few replies at a rural school where a local social media group regularly shares vaccine misinformation and is trusted more than the health unit. Which redesign best fits communications theory?
7. The effect of a communications effort is difficult to assess. Which of the following is the reason?
8. After redesigning its HPV consent materials, a health unit wants to know whether parents understood the new message as intended. Which evaluation checks decoding rather than only exposure?
✦ Pass the knowledge check with 100% to continue
Community Mobilization and Organizational Change
⏱ Estimated reading time: 16 minutes
Overview
The first section dealt with messages; this one deals with the settings that messages land in. Sometimes no message, however well designed, can change behaviour, because the barrier is a community, an organization, or a system. This section explains why those settings sometimes have to change first, and then sets out the two approaches for changing them: community mobilization, with its movement roots, founders, and three key issues, and organizational and systems change, with its staged models and the culture, climate, and capacity that shape them. It closes with programs that combined the two and with the critiques both face.
Learning Objectives
- 3.1 Explain why a change in a community, organization, or system is often a precondition for individual behaviour change, and define community mobilization and empowerment.
- 3.2 Describe the movement roots of community mobilization and the contributions of Saul Alinsky and Paulo Freire.
- 3.3 Apply the three key issues of community mobilization (defining the community, assessing capacity, and working with the community agenda) to a mobilization effort.
- 4.1 Explain why organizations and systems are targets of change, and describe organizational development and systems change.
- 4.2 Describe Lewin's three stages and the stages of adoption, define organizational culture, climate, and capacity, and apply the stages to an organization adopting a health practice.
- 4.3 Explain how community mobilization and organizational change can be combined in a single program, with reference to evaluated programs.
- 7.2 State the critiques of community and organizational change approaches and what they imply for planning.
3.1 Why the Setting Sometimes Has to Change First
Consider two situations no message could fix. People will not attend diabetes screening, however informed and motivated, if there is no facility to attend. People will not get tested for HIV if their community and its institutions exert strong pressure never to admit any risk. In both cases the barrier is a community, an organization, or a system, and the general point follows: these settings can support or inhibit behaviour change, so one area of theory and practice is about changing them. Community mobilization and organizational change are treated separately here, though both belong to a general community change effort.
Public health is activist by nature, and community mobilization is where that shows. The reason for changing a community is ecological: health depends on the settings people live in, not only on their own choices. By this we mean that many conditions that help or block health are community-level situations that no amount of individual change will remove. For example, a lack of health facilities for underserved populations, regulations that allow cigarette sales within easy reach of young people, a toxic waste site, and a lack of sidewalks and green space are all conditions that a single person, however motivated, cannot fix alone.
Community mobilization is the response to conditions of this kind. It means collective action by groups and community members to raise awareness of the problem, advocate for policy change, and act on the condition itself. In other words, the community, rather than an outside agency acting on its behalf, becomes the actor. The result to single out is empowerment: the community takes charge of the issue, defines the goals, and acts, and in doing so gains experience and a sense of efficacy that becomes a resource for the next problem. Empowerment is easy to confuse with self-efficacy, but the two differ in their unit. Self-efficacy is one person's confidence about a behaviour, whereas empowerment is a community's efficacy about solving its own problems. That is why practitioners judge a mobilization effort partly by what the community can do afterward, and not only by whether the original condition changed.
Mobilization did not begin with public health. It borrows its methods from a long tradition of social movements, which the next subsection describes.
3.2 Movement Roots and Two Founders
Community mobilization draws on the history of social and political movements. These include the labour movement, the civil rights and women's movements, anti-smoking activism, HIV/AIDS activism, the anti-abortion movement, and community-based movements such as Mothers Against Drunk Driving (MADD Canada is its counterpart here). The list is broad and includes causes that oppose one another, which shows that what mobilization borrows from these movements is a method rather than a political position: people organizing to change conditions they could not change alone. Two figures anchor the practice.
- Saul Alinsky, organizing in Chicago, pioneered many grassroots organizing and advocacy strategies now taken for granted (Alinsky).
- Paulo Freire, a Brazilian educator working for the liberation of poor and marginalized people in Latin America, founded an approach to participatory social change (Freire).
Their common thread is that the people affected by a problem organize to act on it, rather than waiting for an institution to act for them. Alinsky is associated with the practical tools of grassroots organizing and advocacy, and Freire with the principle that poor and marginalized people take part in the social change that affects them. That principle shapes the three questions any mobilizer has to answer before acting, which the next subsection sets out.
3.3 The Three Key Issues in Mobilizing a Community
There are three key issues in mobilizing a community: defining the community, assessing and working with its capacity, and understanding the community agenda and selecting the right issue. Once they are settled, collective action and empowerment follow. The stages below follow a mobilization effort from start to finish. The first three items are the three key issues, the fourth describes collective action through awareness and advocacy, and the fifth describes the result, a community that takes charge of the issue.
1. Define the community
The first key issue. Is the community a geographic area or a subpopulation? A lot of politics is involved. Defining the community as "the Downtown Eastside" produces different members, leaders, and opponents than "people who inject drugs in Vancouver," and each definition leaves some voices out. In Canada it also raises jurisdiction, since a First Nation, a municipality, a health authority, and a province may all claim a say.
2. Assess, and work with, the community's capacity
The second key issue. Capacity means the experience, organizations, and resources a community already has for acting together. Some communities have organizing experience and existing structures, such as task forces, committees, or associations, through which action can flow. Others have none, and in that case the first task is to build them before any campaign on the health issue can begin. For example, a community that has fought a mill closure brings organizers, meeting places, and a habit of turning out, so a mobilizer there can work through what already exists. A community without that history may first need a regular meeting, a small group of willing leaders, and some early success to show that acting together is worth the effort. Assessing capacity in this way tells the mobilizer whether to start with action or with building the means for action.
3. Understand the community agenda and select the right issue
The third key issue. A health problem may sit anywhere on a community's priorities, and a mobilizer who insists on their own issue finds no one turning out. Knowing the priorities lets the health issue be paired with something the community already cares about: sidewalks can be a traffic safety issue, a seniors' issue, and a physical activity issue at once.
4. Take collective action: awareness and advocacy
Once the three key issues are settled, the community acts. Action takes several forms: raising awareness of the health problem and of the environmental risks behind it, advocating for policy change and access to services, and involving the community throughout. Awareness and advocacy do different jobs. Awareness makes the problem visible to the community and the public, while advocacy presses those with authority, such as a council or a health authority, to change a policy or provide a service. The tactics for both come from the movement tradition described earlier: meetings, petitions, delegations to council, media work, and demonstrations.
5. Empowerment: the community takes charge
A community that has defined its own goals and acted on them gains experience and efficacy. By this we mean that the members have learned how to organize, have seen that their collective action can change a condition, and have come to believe that they can do it again. That belief and experience become a resource for the next problem the community faces, whether or not it is a health problem. This is why practitioners judge a mobilization effort partly by what the community can do afterward, and not only by whether the original condition changed.
The three key issues are the part of mobilization most often examined, so it helps to have a test for each. Defining the community asks who is in and who is left out, and by whose decision; assessing capacity asks what organizations and experience already exist; and working with the agenda asks how the health issue can be paired with something the community already cares about. Worked Example 5.3 applies all three to a Canadian mobilization effort. As you read it, look for where the affected people themselves made each decision.
Worked Example 5.3: Mobilizing for a Supervised Injection Site in Vancouver
The case. Through the 1990s, Vancouver's Downtown Eastside saw an epidemic of overdose deaths and HIV infection among people who inject drugs, and in 1997 a public health emergency was declared. People who used drugs organized as the Vancouver Area Network of Drug Users, holding meetings, staging public actions, and speaking as the affected community rather than through intermediaries, alongside neighbourhood housing and health organizations. Their advocacy, with support from the regional health authority and eventually the city, produced Insite, North America's first legally sanctioned supervised injection site, opened in 2003 and defended through a federal challenge that ended at the Supreme Court of Canada in 2011 (Insite).
Step 1: Identify the condition and the community. The condition is ecological: there was no safe, legal place to inject and no service designed for this population. The community was defined by the affected people themselves, as people who use drugs in the Downtown Eastside, rather than by outsiders. That definition is political, since "the Downtown Eastside" as a whole would have included residents and businesses opposed to the site.
Step 2: Assess capacity. Some capacity existed in neighbourhood housing and health organizations; what had to be built was an organization of people who use drugs, which the Vancouver Area Network of Drug Users became, with its meetings and public actions.
Step 3: Work with the community agenda. For the people affected, survival and dignity ranked far above abstract prevention goals. Pairing the health issue (overdose and HIV) with that priority, and with the declared emergency, gave the effort its urgency.
Step 4: Collective action and empowerment. The effort used the tactics of the movement tradition, especially HIV/AIDS activism: meetings, public actions, and advocacy for policy change. Empowerment shows in a group that defined its own goals, won a service, and then defended it all the way to the Supreme Court of Canada.
What the example shows. The three key issues are not a checklist done by planners on behalf of a community; in the strongest efforts, the affected people answer them. A common mistake is to treat Insite as only an organizational decision by a health authority, which misses the mobilization that made the decision possible.
Insite also shows that mobilization rarely succeeds alone: a health authority, a city, and eventually the courts had to change too. Organizations and systems are the second target of change, and the next subsection explains why.
4.1 Organizations and Systems as Targets of Change
The reason for changing organizations parallels the reason for mobilizing communities. Health promotion, prevention, and care are accomplished through organizations (agencies, hospitals, programs) and systems (healthcare systems, linked service systems, policy coordination systems), and any one may facilitate or block a health goal. The difference between the two is one of scale. An organization is a single body with its own staff and rules, whereas a system is a set of linked organizations whose work has to fit together for a person to be served well. A standard example is substance use, where prevention and treatment grew up as separate fields, one clinical and one community-based, funded by separate agencies. Because each field has its own funders, training, and ways of working, collaboration has been slow, and these entrenched differences run from the federal level down to the community. The practical result is that a person may receive prevention messages from one service and need treatment from another that does not connect with it. For this reason, improving that integration is a health promotion objective in itself, and not merely an administrative matter. Canadian readers will recognize the same silos between mental health and addiction services, or between a hospital and the agencies its patients are discharged into.
Organizational development, usually abbreviated OD, began with efforts to improve business performance and the quality of work life. The psychologist Kurt Lewin shaped it through his work on group dynamics, and Elton Mayo in the 1920s and 1930s, the Tavistock Institute of Human Relations in London, and Abraham Maslow were other influences. The names matter less than the idea they share. OD is both a philosophy and an approach that views organizations as systems of human beings. By this we mean that an organization is not a machine that changes when its rules change, but a group of people whose goals, relationships, and motivation decide whether a change takes hold. It follows that changing an organization means applying behavioural science to planned strategies and building shared goals and motivation among members. For example, a policy issued by memo so often fails because the people who carry it out have to move too, and a memo does nothing to bring them along.
The six cards below define the concepts you need for organizational change: organizational development, Lewin's three stages, the stages of adoption, organizational culture, climate and capacity, and systems change. The staged models on the second and third cards are explained in the next subsection, and the last card restates the systems idea from this one.
Organizational
development
A philosophy and approach to organizational change that treats organizations as systems of human beings. It grew out of efforts to improve business performance and the quality of work life, shaped by Kurt Lewin’s work on group dynamics, Elton Mayo, the Tavistock Institute, and Abraham Maslow. Change involves applying behavioural science to planned strategies and processes and building shared goals and motivation among members.
Unfreezing, movement,
refreezing
Unfreezing, movement, and refreezing. Unfreezing loosens the routines, assumptions, and impediments that hold an organization in its current state; movement is the change itself; refreezing embeds the new state so that it holds. Example: a hospital that documents entrance smoke and staff exposure (unfreezing), adopts smoke-free grounds with cessation support (movement), and writes the policy into orientation and budgets (refreezing).
From unsatisfied demand
to institutionalization
A second staged model runs from a point of unsatisfied demand, through determination of alternatives, decision, adoption, and institutionalization of the change. These stages describe both how an organization adopts a health policy or practice itself and how it moves toward advocating for change in policy, law, or regulation outside itself.
Organizational
culture
The features of an organization as a social unit: its purpose or mission as members understand it (a corporate self-image); values and norms about how the mission should be achieved; codes of behaviour, and how they relate to the self-image (dedicated, hard-working, fun-loving, people-friendly); and the standards by which activity is measured, such as quality, efficiency, service, productivity, or innovation.
Climate and
capacity
Alongside culture, organizational climate and capacity are factors in the change process. Climate is the prevailing mood and sense of support or threat within the organization at a given time; capacity is the staff, money, skills, and structures available to carry a change through. An organization with a supportive culture but no capacity, or ample capacity but a fearful climate, will stall at different stages.
Systems
change
Change across linked organizations rather than within one: healthcare systems, linked service systems, policy coordination systems. The substance use example shows the difficulty, since prevention and treatment are funded and staffed separately and integrate poorly from the federal level to the community level. Improving system integration is itself a health promotion objective.
The cards separate two ideas that are easy to blur: what an organization is (a system of human beings with a culture, a climate, and a capacity) and how it changes (in stages). The next subsection takes up the stages.
4.2 Staged Models of Organizational Change
The second approach treats organizational change as a staged process. By this we mean that an organization does not move from an old practice to a new one in a single step; it passes through recognizable stages, each with its own task, somewhat like stage models of individual behaviour such as the Transtheoretical Model, which traces a person from not yet considering a change through to maintaining it. Two versions are taught, and it helps to learn them side by side:
- Lewin's three stages: unfreezing (loosening the routines, assumptions, and impediments that hold an organization in its current state), movement (the change itself), and refreezing (embedding the new state so that it holds).
- The stages of adoption: unsatisfied demand, determination of alternatives, decision, adoption, and institutionalization of the change.
The two models describe the same process at different levels of detail: Lewin's version has three broad stages, while the stages of adoption break the process into five. Their endpoints line up. Institutionalization, the last stage of adoption, corresponds to Lewin's refreezing, because in both the change is built into routines, budgets, and policy so that it persists without continued effort. The stages describe both how an organization adopts a health policy itself and how it moves to advocate for change in policy, law, or regulation beyond its walls. In other words, the same sequence applies whether the change happens inside the organization or is something the organization presses for outside it.
Other factors shape how quickly, and whether, an organization moves through the stages. The first is organizational culture, the set of features that make an organization a social unit. It has four parts. The first is the organization's purpose or mission as members understand it, which amounts to a corporate self-image. The second is the values and norms about how the mission should be achieved. The third is the codes of behaviour and how they relate to the self-image, for example whether members see themselves as dedicated, hard-working, fun-loving, or people-friendly. The fourth is the standards by which activity is measured, such as quality, efficiency, service, productivity, or innovation. In addition to culture, two further factors matter. Climate is the prevailing mood and sense of support or threat at a given time, and capacity is the staff, money, skills, and structures available to carry a change through. Culture and climate are easily confused: culture is the organization's settled identity, whereas climate is its mood at a particular moment. The distinction matters because organizations stall for different reasons. For example, an organization with a supportive culture but no capacity, or ample capacity but a fearful climate, will stall at different stages, so identifying which factor is missing tells a planner where to direct effort.
Interactive 5.2 takes a regional hospital in Ontario through the stages. The hospital is considering smoke-free grounds with cessation support for every admitted patient and staff member. At each stage, choose the action that fits; the feedback names the concept at work, and the track at the top of the interactive shows where Lewin's three stages line up with the stages of adoption.
📊 Interactive 5.2: Take a hospital through the stages of change.
A regional hospital in Ontario is considering smoke-free grounds with cessation support for every admitted patient and staff member. At each stage, choose the action that fits. The feedback names the concept at work, and the track shows where Lewin's three stages line up.The stepper shows that each stage has a characteristic action: complaints and data make demand visible, a working group compares options, a decision needs a date, a budget, and a lead, adoption means training and communication, and institutionalization means writing the change into orientation, order sets, and reporting. Because these stages look like individual stage models, the callout below heads off a common confusion.
Organizations Are Not Individuals
Self-efficacy is an individual's confidence about a behaviour; empowerment here is a community's efficacy about solving its own problems. The staged models of organizational change resemble the Transtheoretical Model, but the unit differs: an organization "decides" through meetings, budgets, and votes, and "maintains" through policy and routine rather than willpower. When a question describes a hospital or an agency, use the organizational stages, not the individual ones.
Worked Example 5.4 applies the stages of adoption to a much larger change than a hospital policy: the transfer of a whole health system. As you read it, check that each stage has an observable event attached to it.
Worked Example 5.4: Moving a Health System to First Nations Control in British Columbia
The case. For decades, health programs for First Nations in British Columbia were delivered by a branch of the federal health department, separate from the provincial system, with the gaps that separation implies. After years of negotiation among First Nations leadership, the province, and the federal government, a tripartite framework agreement on First Nations health governance was signed in 2011, and in 2013 the federal programs, staff, and budgets were transferred to the First Nations Health Authority, the first province-wide health authority of its kind in Canada (FNHA). The new organization describes its work in terms of wellness, cultural safety, and community-driven, nation-based decision making.
Step 1: Unsatisfied demand. The demand was the gap left by a federal system separate from the provincial one, and the wish of First Nations to govern their own health services.
Step 2: Determination of alternatives. The years of negotiation among First Nations leadership, the province, and the federal government were the stage in which alternatives were worked out.
Step 3: Decision. The decision is marked by the tripartite framework agreement signed in 2011.
Step 4: Adoption and institutionalization. Adoption came in 2013, when programs, staff, and budgets were transferred. Institutionalization means the new authority's structures, budgets, and nation-based decision making become routine, which is Lewin's refreezing.
Step 5: Organizational culture and risks. The culture could not simply be inherited from a federal branch: the mission (wellness, cultural safety), the values and norms (community-driven, nation-based decisions), and the standards by which work is judged all had to be rebuilt. The uncontrollable factors named in the critique (Subsection 7.2), such as a change in leadership at any of the three governments or a budget crisis, are the main threats until the change is fully institutionalized.
What the example shows. The staged model works for systems as well as single organizations, and placing a dated event at each stage is the most reliable way to apply it. A common mistake is to call the signing of an agreement "adoption"; a decision is not adoption until resources and practice actually move.
Insite and the First Nations Health Authority each lean on one approach. In practice the strongest efforts combine community mobilization with organizational change, as the next subsection shows.
4.3 Using Community and Organizational Change Together
Table 5.2 sets the two approaches side by side, and the pairing is the point: changing a community without the organizations that serve it, or the reverse, usually stalls. Read across each row to see what the approach does and a Canadian illustration of it.
Table 5.2. What community mobilization and organizational change each do, with a Canadian illustration of each activity.
| Approach | What it does | Canadian illustration |
|---|---|---|
| Community mobilization | Increases community awareness of a health problem and of the environmental and other risks contributing to it | Residents documenting mould and overcrowding in northern housing and presenting the findings publicly |
| Advocates for policy change, increased access to services, or other needs | Municipal smoke-free bylaws of the 1990s and 2000s, driven by local coalitions, that preceded provincial laws such as the Smoke-Free Ontario Act (2006) | |
| Involves and empowers the community, proceeding through defining the community, assessing capacity, and working with the community agenda | People who use drugs organizing as their own voice in the Downtown Eastside | |
| Organizational change | Assesses and improves group dynamics (how people work together) | A primary care network bringing physicians, nurses, and agencies into shared case conferences |
| Encourages shared goals and missions; identifies impediments and "unfreezes" the organization or system | A hospital documenting the harm from entrance smoke before adopting smoke-free grounds | |
| Involves the organization or system in identifying and implementing new policies and practices | Transfer of federal First Nations health programs in BC to the First Nations Health Authority |
Take an applied scenario: a California county whose hospitals face an influx of patients with little or no English. The possible responses combine both approaches. The county could enlist community organizations in a public awareness campaign, perhaps pressing the county to create a task force (community mobilization). It could advocate directly with key units of the health system in terms they must take seriously, such as liability when a patient cannot read dosage instructions. And it could train providers in culturally competent care while helping them adopt practices such as bilingual staff or service hours that suit farm workers (organizational change). The third response is staged change in miniature: training unfreezes, new practices are the movement, and policy is the refreezing.
Three evaluated programs used these approaches. Open each of the three tabs below to read about a safe motherhood program in rural Uttar Pradesh, India; two hepatitis B catch-up vaccination campaigns for Vietnamese-American children; and school-based advocacy to reduce smoking in Northern California. For each, decide which part was community mobilization, which was individual or organizational change, and what was measured.
Safe motherhood, Uttar Pradesh, India
Mothers and home birth attendants in rural Uttar Pradesh were taught to recognize and act on specific life-threatening maternal and newborn problems, while community mobilization aimed at reducing delays in transport to emergency obstetric referral units and at increasing family planning. Knowledge and skills for recognizing maternal bleeding and newborn sepsis were retained better when pictorial depictions, a take-action message, or both served as memory aids (Fullerton and colleagues, 2005). Individual training was paired with a systems goal, faster referral, that training alone could not reach.
Hepatitis B catch-up vaccination, Vietnamese-American children
Chronic hepatitis B is endemic in Southeast Asian populations, and coverage among Vietnamese-American children aged 3 to 18 was low. Two catch-up campaigns were evaluated: a media-led campaign in Houston and a community mobilization strategy in Dallas, with Washington, D.C., as control. Telephone interviews before and after with about 500 households per site measured knowledge and vaccination dates, validated with providers where possible. Both interventions significantly improved parents' knowledge and children's catch-up vaccination compared with the control community (McPhee and colleagues, 2003): a rare direct comparison of a communications approach with a mobilization approach, and both worked.
School-based advocacy to reduce smoking
Students in Northern California high schools spent a semester on advocacy about the environmental effects of smoking. Compared with schools that focused on other issues, the advocacy schools reported a significant decline in smoking among regular smokers that continued six months after the program ended, with additional gains on Social Cognitive Theory constructs (Winkleby and colleagues, 2004). It is mobilization turned into a curriculum: students were mobilized to change their environment, and their own behaviour changed along the way.
The three programs reinforce the table. Uttar Pradesh paired individual training with a systems goal, faster referral, that training alone could not reach; the hepatitis B study is a rare direct comparison in which both a media campaign (Section 1's approach) and a community mobilization strategy improved knowledge and catch-up vaccination compared with a control city; and the school program turned mobilization into a curriculum, with smoking among regular smokers still lower six months after it ended. Promising as these results are, the approaches have limits, which the critique below states.
7.2 Critique: No Off-the-Shelf Solutions
The critique of these approaches is measured rather than dismissive. Mobilizing a community or changing an organization is complex, and there are typically no off-the-shelf solutions with clear evidence. By this we mean that a planner cannot pick up a proven package from elsewhere and expect it to work, because every community and organization differs. The critique has two practical implications. The first concerns where to aim. If a health promotion effort addresses a pressing problem, mobilization and organizational change may be best directed at the enduring factors around it, such as policies, regulations, and access to care, or combined with activities that address more immediate needs. By this we mean that these approaches are slow, so they are best spent on the conditions that will keep producing the problem over the long run, while other activities deal with the people who need help now. For example, during an overdose crisis, outreach and naloxone distribution can respond to the immediate danger while mobilization works toward lasting services, as the Insite case showed. In addition, even early mobilization can galvanize other work, by drawing attention, allies, and resources to the issue, so the effort is not wasted while larger changes take shape.
The second implication is humility. Change is often affected by factors nobody controls, including a sudden change in leadership, a budget crisis, or a disaster. For example, a plan that depends on one champion staying in post is not yet institutionalized, because the change is at risk as soon as that person leaves. The practical response is therefore to institutionalize early, writing the change into policy, budgets, and routine so that it no longer depends on any one person.
This section has shown why a community, an organization, or a system sometimes has to change before behaviour can. It has set out community mobilization with its movement roots, its three key issues, and the empowerment a community gains by acting on its own problems; described organizational development and the staged models of change; shown the two approaches working together; and stated the critiques of both. The key takeaways and knowledge check that follow review this material, and the next section goes one level further out, to the political and economic structures behind the conditions that communities and organizations face.
Key Takeaways
- 3.1 Sometimes the setting has to change before the behaviour can: nobody attends screening where there is no facility, and nobody gets tested where institutions enforce silence about risk. Community mobilization is collective action to raise awareness, advocate for policy change, and act on ecological conditions such as missing facilities, cigarette sales near young people, toxic sites, or a lack of sidewalks. Its signature result is empowerment, a community that takes charge, defines its goals, and gains efficacy for the next problem. When a case describes a structural barrier, resist answers that offer more education or motivation, and look for the option that changes the setting.
- 3.2 Mobilization borrows its methods from social movements: labour, civil rights and women's movements, anti-smoking and HIV/AIDS activism, the anti-abortion movement, and community-based movements such as Mothers Against Drunk Driving. Saul Alinsky pioneered grassroots organizing and advocacy strategies in Chicago, and Paulo Freire founded a participatory approach to social change with poor and marginalized people in Latin America. Their shared idea is that the people affected organize to act for themselves. Keep the two founders distinct from the organizational figures (Lewin, Mayo, Tavistock, Maslow), a pairing exams like to test.
- 3.3 Before mobilizing, answer three key issues: how the community is defined (geographic area or subpopulation, a political choice that includes some voices and leaves out others), what capacity it has (experience, task forces, committees, existing organizations, or none), and where the health issue sits on its agenda. Insite shows all three answered by the affected people themselves. In an applied question, the most useful move is usually the third: pair the health issue with a priority the community already holds, rather than insisting on your own.
- 4.1 Health promotion, prevention, and care are delivered through organizations and systems, and any of them can help or block a health goal, as the separate funding and poor integration of substance use prevention and treatment show. Organizational development, shaped by Lewin, Mayo, the Tavistock Institute, and Maslow, treats organizations as systems of human beings, so change means applying behavioural science to planned strategies and building shared goals and motivation. Systems change works across linked organizations rather than within one. If an answer option says a policy issued from the top is enough, it contradicts the OD view.
- 4.2 Organizations change in stages: Lewin's unfreezing, movement, and refreezing, or unsatisfied demand, determination of alternatives, decision, adoption, and institutionalization. Culture (mission as self-image, values and norms, codes of behaviour, standards of measurement), climate, and capacity decide where a change stalls. To place an event in a stage, ask what actually happened: complaints signal unsatisfied demand, a working group comparing options is determining alternatives, approval in principle is a decision, and only written routines, budgets, and indicators count as institutionalization. Do not confuse these organizational stages with the individual stages of the Transtheoretical Model.
- 4.3 The two approaches work best together, as Table 5.2 and the language-access scenario show: awareness and advocacy from the community, new practices and policies inside the organizations. The Uttar Pradesh safe motherhood program, the hepatitis B catch-up campaigns in Houston and Dallas, and the Northern California school advocacy program each combined them and were evaluated. Remember the hepatitis B result exactly: both the media-led and the mobilization strategies beat the control site, so neither approach "won."
- 7.2 The critique is that mobilization and organizational change are complex and have no off-the-shelf solutions with clear evidence, so for pressing problems they are best aimed at enduring factors (policy, regulation, access to care) or combined with more immediate activities. Change is also exposed to factors nobody controls: a sudden change in leadership, a budget crisis, or a disaster. The practical lesson is to institutionalize early, so the change does not depend on one champion. When asked how to protect a change, name a concrete form of institutionalization, such as a standing order, a budget line, or a reported indicator.
1. A health unit has a well-funded diabetes education program, but uptake of screening in a remote region is near zero because the nearest screening site is a four-hour drive away. What does this situation call for?
2. Two years after residents of a neighbourhood organized and won a safe crosswalk and a park, they organize again, this time for better bus service, with no help from the health unit. Which result of community mobilization does this illustrate?
3. A coalition wants to mobilize a neighbourhood around air pollution from a nearby plant, but residents' meetings are dominated by concerns about rents and evictions. Which of the three key issues of community mobilization does this most directly raise, and what does that issue suggest?
4. A health unit wants to raise HIV testing among young adults in a neighbourhood where stigma is strong. A community association exists but has focused on housing and policing, and planners propose defining "the community" as the association's members. What is the main risk of that definition?
5. Organizational development (OD) views organizations in a particular way. Which statement captures that view?
6. Which of the following is an example of institutionalization in the staged model of organizational change?
7. In the hepatitis B catch-up study described in this section, Houston received a media-led campaign, Dallas received a community mobilization strategy, and Washington, D.C., served as a control. What did the results show?
8. A clinic manager has championed drop-in HIV testing, and it is working. The health unit worries that the change could vanish if the manager leaves or the budget is cut. Which step best protects the change?
✦ Pass the knowledge check with 100% to continue
Political Economy: Structure, Power, and Syndemics
⏱ Estimated reading time: 15 minutes
Overview
This section turns to political economy, the third of the four theory families in this lesson, and moves one level further out than communities and organizations. It explains why political economy belongs in a course on health behaviour, follows Merrill Singer's analysis of HIV/AIDS and his idea of the syndemic, sets out the three steps of the political-economic approach and applies them to Canadian policies, and then describes two tested directions: microcredit, and the perspective of structural violence. It closes with an honest account of why this approach is funded less than behaviour-focused work, and why that is not a reason for fatalism.
Learning Objectives
- 5.1 Explain why political economy belongs in the study of health behaviour, and state the claim it makes about context.
- 5.2 Describe Merrill Singer's analysis of HIV/AIDS among the urban poor, and define syndemic.
- 5.3 State the three steps of the political-economic approach (rethink the problem, trace the trajectory of risk, address the relationships) and apply them to a health problem or policy.
- 5.4 Explain how microcredit produces a public health benefit by reducing poverty.
- 5.5 Define structural violence and health as a commodity, and identify the key figures associated with the structural violence perspective.
- 7.3 Evaluate why political-economic approaches are funded less than behaviour-focused ones, and explain why the analysis does not imply fatalism.
5.1 Why Political Economy Belongs in Health Behaviour
You might think this area belongs in a political science or economics course. The reply is that some of the issues gathered under political economy bear directly on why and how people do what they do, and therefore on how they change what they do. The central claim is that there will always be a political-economic context that affects what people do and what they can or cannot do, and an explanation of behaviour that leaves it out is incomplete. This claim is more careful than the aphorism that money changes everything. By this we mean that political economy does not say that money alone explains every behaviour; it says that a context of income, work, housing, and power is always present and is always part of the explanation. In the same way, a political-economic analysis does not deny that individuals choose. Instead, it insists that the range of choices, and the odds attached to each, are set by structures of income, work, housing, and power.
Political economy as a whole is a vast field about the links between politics and economics and their functions in society; this section touches only the part that has been applied to health behaviour. It follows that path from Singer's work on HIV/AIDS to microcredit and structural violence, and turns the analysis on Canadian policy along the way. The path begins with Singer.
5.2 Singer and the Syndemic
The main example is the medical anthropologist Merrill Singer, who follows an explanatory approach pioneered by Eric Wolf and Sidney Mintz (Wolf's Europe and the People Without History and Mintz's Sweetness and Power, a history of sugar, are the sources cited). Singer's question was why HIV/AIDS has had such a disproportionate effect on poor, minority, urban communities in the United States. The political-economic approach answers by first rethinking the disease as something more than a health problem: it is treated as a product of a larger set of social relationships, in particular relationships of socioeconomic structure, class, ethnicity, and gender. By this we mean that the question shifts from what an infected person did to what position that person occupied in society, and how that position shaped the risks they faced. A behaviour-focused account would look for the risky act, such as sharing needles or unprotected sex. The political-economic account accepts that those acts matter but asks why they were so much more common, and so much more dangerous, in some communities than in others. Its answer points to how jobs, income, housing, and power are distributed by class, ethnicity, and gender.
Singer then links HIV/AIDS with a list of other problems found disproportionately in the same populations, including tuberculosis, infant mortality, hypertension, diabetes, cirrhosis, and substance use, and calls the aggregate a syndemic: several epidemics that exist together because conditions promote their coexistence and that interact, each making the others worse (Singer, 1994; Singer et al., 2017). The definition has two parts, and both are needed. The first is that the epidemics share causes: they cluster in the same population because the same conditions promote all of them, not by coincidence. The second is that they interact: once present together, each epidemic makes the others worse. A set of diseases that simply happen to be common in the same place, without shared conditions and without interaction, is not a syndemic in Singer's sense. Figure 5.2 places HIV/AIDS and the other epidemics in Singer's list around the shared conditions that promote each of them.
Figure 5.2. A syndemic as Singer describes it: several epidemics cluster in the same population because a shared set of conditions promotes each of them, and the epidemics also interact, each worsening the others, although the figure draws only the links from the shared conditions. Treating any one epidemic without touching the conditions leaves the others, and the next one, in place.
What are the conditions? The list includes the prevalence of poverty and unemployment in core urban areas, including a lack of access to health care; deteriorated and substandard schools; economies of the street in communities with few links to economic resources, where the available jobs are more likely to involve drug trafficking and other illegal activity; the relationship between lack of employment and unstable family structures; and the overall relationships in society between minority and majority ethnic groups. Each condition raises the probability of several of the epidemics at once. That is why they cluster, and it is why a program aimed at one behaviour in one epidemic tends to be swamped by the conditions it leaves untouched.
The six cards that follow define the key terms of this section: political economy, syndemic, trajectory of risk, structural violence, health as a commodity, and microcredit. Return to these definitions as the trajectory of risk, microcredit, and structural violence are taken up in the subsections that follow.
Political
economy
The links between politics and economics and their functions in society. Applied to health behaviour, the claim is that a political-economic context always shapes what people do and what they can or cannot do, so it must be part of any full explanation. The claim is more careful than the slogan that money changes everything.
Syndemic
Merrill Singer’s term for several epidemics that exist together because conditions promote their coexistence and that interact, each making the others worse. His example links HIV/AIDS among the urban poor with tuberculosis, infant mortality, hypertension, diabetes, cirrhosis, and substance use, all shaped by poverty, unemployment, poor schools, street economies, and ethnic relations. Implication: the epidemics share causes, so a response to one that ignores the causes leaves the rest in place.
Trajectory
of risk
The second step of the political-economic approach: a health problem, or a set of co-occurring problems, can be seen as part of a trajectory of risk or exposure shaped by the larger social relationships in which it exists. The image is a path rather than a point: a person’s exposures accumulate along a route that structure has laid out, from schooling to work to housing to care.
Structural
violence
Systematic features of social structures, such as hierarchies, forms of inclusion and exclusion, discrimination, and inequities of wealth and resources, that harm some categories of people by denying them access to the benefits of society, including health. The perspective, associated with Johan Galtung, treats this injustice as a form of violence in itself and as a central cause of other violence, from war to domestic violence.
Health as a
commodity
A central example in the structural violence perspective: basic human needs such as health are treated as goods to be bought, so whether one gets them depends on whether one can pay. In Canada, hospital and physician services are publicly insured under the Canada Health Act, while dental care for many people, most prescription drugs outside hospital, and much mental health counselling sit outside medicare, so the commodity problem persists at its edges.
Microcredit
Small loans, pioneered by Muhammad Yunus and the Grameen Bank in Bangladesh, to women who otherwise have no access to credit, with members of the borrower’s social or community network as guarantors. The loan supports a small enterprise, which brings income and status; many studies find that women with more opportunity choose to have fewer children, so more attention and resources go to each child. The public health benefit arrives because poverty was reduced.
A syndemic describes what the clustering looks like; the political-economic approach describes what to do about it, in three steps.
5.3 The Political-Economic Approach in Three Steps
The political-economic approach turns Singer's way of seeing into a method that can be applied to any health problem. It reduces to three moves, taken in order:
- Rethink the health problem as a product of a larger set of social relationships, particularly socioeconomic structure, class, ethnicity, and gender.
- Trace the trajectory of risk: see the problem, or co-occurring problems, as part of a path of risk or exposure shaped by those relationships. The image is a path rather than a point, with exposures accumulating along a route that structure has laid out, from schooling to work to housing to care.
- Address the relationships themselves, such as economic patterns or relationships of ethnicity, as at least part of the solution.
The second step is the one students most often find abstract. A trajectory of risk means that a health problem is not treated as a single event or a single risky act, but as the end point of a path along which exposures have built up. By this we mean that a person's risk is shaped long before the moment of infection or diagnosis, by the schooling, work, housing, and care that structure has made available. The purpose of tracing the path is practical, because it shows where along the route an intervention could act, and that leads directly into the third step. The third step is what separates the approach from a description of inequality: it asks that the relationships themselves, and not only the individuals harmed by them, become part of the solution.
Table 5.3 applies the three steps to Singer's HIV/AIDS example and to a Canadian one, tuberculosis in Inuit Nunangat. Read down each column to see the three steps applied to one problem, then across each row to compare the two.
Table 5.3. The three steps of the political-economic approach applied to Singer's analysis of HIV/AIDS and to tuberculosis in Inuit Nunangat.
| Step | Singer's HIV/AIDS analysis | Tuberculosis in Inuit Nunangat |
|---|---|---|
| Rethink the problem as a product of social relationships | HIV/AIDS among the urban poor as a product of class, ethnicity, gender, and economic structure rather than of individual risk behaviour alone | Tuberculosis rates among Inuit, far above those of non-Indigenous Canadians, as a product of overcrowded and inadequate housing, food insecurity, and the history of relocation and sanatorium-era removals rather than of individual adherence |
| Trace the trajectory of risk or exposure | Poor schools, street economies, unemployment, and no access to care line up into a path along which HIV, tuberculosis, substance use, and other epidemics cluster | Crowded housing raises exposure; food insecurity and distance from care lower resistance and delay diagnosis; each strand raises the others |
| Address the relationships as part of the solution | Employment, schooling, housing, and health access alongside prevention and treatment | Inuit Tapiriit Kanatami's tuberculosis elimination framework (2018) pairs screening and treatment with action on housing, food security, and Inuit-led health systems, with a goal of elimination across Inuit Nunangat by 2030 |
The Canadian column shows the third step in practice: Inuit Tapiriit Kanatami's elimination framework pairs screening and treatment with action on housing, food security, and Inuit-led health systems, because decades of screening and treatment alone had not closed the gap.
A political-economic analysis is easiest to learn by tracing where resources and power move when a policy changes. Canada offers several policies that act on price, revenue, and access rather than on individual knowledge or motivation. A minimum price for alcohol, for example, raises the price of the cheapest, highest-strength products the most, so the analysis asks whose income the change bites into and whether treatment and harm reduction resources follow the people most affected. Interactive 5.3 offers four such policies (tobacco taxation, minimum alcohol pricing, the sugary drink levy that Newfoundland and Labrador applied from 2022 until its repeal in 2025, and Housing First through At Home/Chez Soi). Choose a policy and click through the chain: for each policy it reveals in turn the problem rethought, who holds the resource or power, where the policy moves it, which social relationship changes, and who pushes back, followed by a question.
📊 Interactive 5.3: Follow the resources.
Pick a Canadian policy. Each click reveals the next link in the chain: the problem rethought, who holds the resource or power, where the policy moves it, which social relationship changes, and who pushes back. A question follows the last link.Whichever policy you followed, the chain had the same shape as the three steps: a problem rethought in terms of price, income, or housing, a relationship that the policy changes, and someone with an interest in resisting it. Worked Example 5.5 applies the three steps in full to the last policy in the interactive. As you read it, notice which relationship the intervention changes.
Worked Example 5.5: Housing as a Health Intervention, At Home/Chez Soi
The case. Between 2009 and 2013 the Mental Health Commission of Canada ran At Home/Chez Soi, a federally funded randomized trial of Housing First in Vancouver, Winnipeg, Toronto, Montreal, and Moncton. Participants were adults experiencing homelessness and living with serious mental illness. Those in the Housing First arm received a rent supplement and a private-market apartment right away, with support teams, and were not required to be sober or in treatment before moving in; the comparison group received the usual services in their city. The trial reported that Housing First participants spent far more of their time stably housed than the comparison group (Mental Health Commission of Canada).
Step 1: Rethink the problem. A behaviour-focused reading treats homelessness, substance use, and illness as individual failings to be corrected before housing is earned. Housing First rethinks them as products of social relationships, above all a person's relationship to the housing market, along with income and access to care.
Step 2: Trace the trajectory of risk. Without housing, exposures accumulate: unsafe places to sleep, interrupted treatment, worsening illness and substance use, and contact with police and emergency services. Housing First intervenes early on that path, at the point of housing itself, rather than at the end, in the emergency department.
Step 3: Address the relationship. The rent supplement changes the relationship between the person and the housing market directly. Removing the treatment-first requirement matters to a political-economic reading because it stops making access to a basic need conditional on individual behaviour change; housing is treated as a starting point, not as a reward.
Why it is harder to fund. Rent supplements and support teams are a long-term commitment that touches housing markets and public budgets, which is slower and more controversial than funding a counselling program.
What the example shows. A health outcome (stable housing, with the health benefits that follow) was produced by changing a structural relationship rather than by persuading individuals. A common mistake is to classify Housing First as an individual-level program because individuals receive it; what makes it political-economic is the relationship it changes.
At Home/Chez Soi shows the third step at work in Canada. The best-known international example of the same logic is microcredit, which the next subsection describes.
5.4 Microcredit: A Tested Strategy
A tested example of the approach comes from the developing world. Microcredit, originally the idea of Muhammad Yunus and the Grameen Bank in Bangladesh, addresses the socioeconomic position of women and the effect of that position on population, reproductive health, and other outcomes (Grameen Bank). The mechanism runs in a chain:
- Women in the program usually have no access to credit at all, which is itself a political-economic fact.
- Small loans are structured so that people in the borrower's social or community network stand as guarantors and sign on to assure repayment.
- The loan supports a small economic enterprise, such as selling food or repairing clothes, which gives the borrower an alternate source of income and of status.
- Many studies have found that when women have more opportunities they choose to have fewer children, so more attention and resources, including health resources, go to each child they do have.
The chain is worth stating plainly: a health outcome changed because poverty was reduced, and poverty was reduced by changing a woman's relationship to credit, which is a relationship of economic structure and gender. That is the third step of the approach in action. Note what the loans did not include: no health education and no counselling about family size. If an answer explains the benefit through education or attitudes, it has missed the political-economic point. Microcredit acts on one inequity; the structural violence perspective, next, names the whole family of inequities.
5.5 Structural Violence
The second approach with a political-economic focus is the idea of structural violence, associated with the peace researcher Johan Galtung (Galtung, 1969). Structural violence refers to systematic aspects of social structures, such as hierarchies, forms of inclusion and exclusion, discrimination, and inequities of wealth and resources, that harm some categories of people by denying them access to the benefits of society, including health. By this we mean that the harm comes from the way a society is arranged rather than from one person's act against another. The perspective therefore lays blame on the inequities of the world system, both the gap between rich and poor nations and the gap between rich and poor within nations.
The central example is the treatment of basic needs such as health as commodities, available to those who can afford them. This is the health as a commodity problem: when health is something to be bought, whether a person receives it depends on whether they can pay. For example, in Canada hospital and physician services are publicly insured, but the problem persists at the edges of medicare, in dental care, most prescription drugs outside hospital, and much mental health counselling. Finally, the perspective views this injustice as a form of violence in itself, which is why the word violence is used. The reasoning is that if a social arrangement predictably causes some people to fall ill or die early, the harm is as real as a physical injury, even though no single person struck the blow and no one may intend it. In addition, the perspective treats structural violence as a central cause of other, more visible violence, including ethnic and racial violence, war, and domestic violence. In other words, exclusion, discrimination, and deprivation create the tensions and pressures from which open violence between groups and within households often grows.
Three figures are associated with the perspective. The descriptions below set out what Paul Farmer and Partners In Health, Nancy Scheper-Hughes, and Philippe Bourgois each contributed, and how their work connects structure to what shows up in clinics.
Paul Farmer and Partners In Health
A physician and anthropologist who co-founded Partners In Health, which delivers care in Haiti, Rwanda, and elsewhere, and whose book Pathologies of Power argues that the distribution of disease follows the distribution of power and that health is a human right rather than a purchase. His work is the clearest example of a clinician acting on a structural analysis: treating tuberculosis and HIV while also building the housing, food, and water systems that a trajectory of exposure runs through.
Nancy Scheper-Hughes
An anthropologist whose ethnography Death Without Weeping described how chronic scarcity in a Brazilian shantytown shaped even the most intimate behaviour, including how mothers responded to the illness and death of infants. It shows the political-economic claim at its most uncomfortable: what looks like individual attitude is often an adaptation to conditions that structure has imposed.
Philippe Bourgois
An anthropologist known for long-term ethnography with people who sell and use drugs in US cities. His concept of everyday violence refers to the routine, small-scale brutality and suffering of daily life in poor neighbourhoods, which comes to seem normal to the people living with it. The concept, together with his work with colleagues on hepatitis C among homeless young people who inject drugs in San Francisco, connects the structural violence of exclusion and poverty to the interpersonal violence and infection risk that show up in clinics. By this we mean that a clinician who sees an assault injury or a new hepatitis C infection is seeing the last link in a chain that began with exclusion from housing, work, and services. Two of his works are especially relevant here: a thirty-year retrospective on invisible violence, and that hepatitis C study.
Across the three, the common move is to trace what looks like individual behaviour or individual misfortune back to structural conditions: disease following the distribution of power for Farmer, intimate behaviour shaped by scarcity for Scheper-Hughes, and everyday violence and infection linked to exclusion for Bourgois. An analysis that locates causes so firmly in structure raises a hard practical question, which the critique below addresses.
HEAL connection: structure, power, and belief
Political economy and structural violence describe the upstream part of the HEAL Framework for Wellbeing introduced in Lesson 1. In HEAL, the -isms sort people into social positions, power and capital turn position into material circumstance, and politics and policy decide which health and social systems reach which people. HEAL's research on syndemics describes overlapping epidemics that converge on marginalized populations through structural stigma and material disadvantage, which is the convergence Singer described.
HEAL adds a process that is easy to overlook, acculturation: people absorb the norms and ideologies of their context, including the belief that health is a matter of personal effort rather than social condition. Card and Hepburn measured such system-justifying and neoliberal beliefs in surveys of Canadians (Frontiers in Public Health, 2022; International Journal of Social Determinants of Health, 2023).
7.3 Critique: Slow, Controversial, and Underfunded
It is worth being candid about why this approach is funded less than behaviour-focused approaches. Carrying it out ultimately means addressing significant social configurations, by which we mean the arrangements of income, housing, work, and power described in the earlier subsections. Changing those arrangements is neither a short-term project nor one free of controversy. However, many who have worked with health issues immersed in these conditions know that progress on the health problem is difficult without some change in the contributing conditions. The Canadian column of Table 5.3 shows both halves of this tension. On the one hand, the elimination framework is a long project involving federal, territorial, and Inuit governments; on the other, the reason it exists is that screening and treatment alone had not closed the gap. The key point for evaluating the critique is that the obstacle is scale and politics, not evidence. In other words, the approach is funded less because it is slow and controversial, not because it has been shown not to work.
Structure Is Not Fate
A political-economic analysis can slide into fatalism: if structure decides everything, why run a program at all? That conclusion does not follow. The examples in this section, microcredit, Partners In Health, Housing First, and the policy levers in Interactive 5.3, are all things that practitioners and governments can do. The lesson is about where to aim, and about being honest that a program aimed only at individuals is competing against the conditions it leaves in place.
This section has argued that a political-economic context always shapes what people do and what they can or cannot do. It has defined the syndemic and the three steps of the political-economic approach, traced how Canadian policies move resources and power, described microcredit as a tested strategy and structural violence as a second approach with a political-economic focus, and explained why the approach is harder to fund. The key takeaways and knowledge check that follow review this material, and the final section turns to anthropology, which reads behaviour as adaptation to an environment and as meaningful action within a culture.
Key Takeaways
- 5.1 Political economy belongs in a health behaviour course because there is always a political and economic context that shapes what people do and what they can or cannot do. The claim is more careful than "money changes everything": individuals still choose, but structures of income, work, housing, and power set the range of choices and the odds attached to each. If a classmate dismisses the approach as economics, the answer is that a full account of behaviour, and of behaviour change, cannot leave that context out.
- 5.2 Merrill Singer, following Eric Wolf and Sidney Mintz, rethought HIV/AIDS among the urban poor as a product of socioeconomic structure, class, ethnicity, and gender. He linked it with tuberculosis, infant mortality, hypertension, diabetes, cirrhosis, and substance use, and called the cluster a syndemic: several epidemics that exist together because shared conditions (poverty and unemployment, no access to care, poor schools, street economies, unstable families tied to joblessness, majority and minority relations) promote them, and that interact. When you see several health problems clustering in one population, think syndemic, and expect a response aimed at one disease to be swamped by the conditions it ignores.
- 5.3 The approach has three steps: rethink the problem as a product of social relationships, trace the trajectory of risk or exposure those relationships shape, and address the relationships as part of the solution. Table 5.3 runs the steps for Singer's HIV/AIDS case and for tuberculosis in Inuit Nunangat, and At Home/Chez Soi shows them for homelessness. To spot a political-economic response, ask whether it changes a relationship (to price, credit, housing, or access), not only a person's knowledge or motivation; a poster about sugary drinks is behavioural, while a levy that changes their price is political-economic.
- 5.4 Microcredit, from Muhammad Yunus and the Grameen Bank in Bangladesh, gives small loans, guaranteed by the borrower's social network, to women who otherwise have no access to credit. The enterprise brings income and status, and women with more opportunities choose to have fewer children, so more attention and resources go to each child. The health benefit arrives because poverty was reduced. In an exam answer, explain the benefit through the change in women's economic position, not through health education, which the loans did not include.
- 5.5 Structural violence, associated with Johan Galtung, names the hierarchies, exclusions, discrimination, and inequities of wealth and resources that harm some categories of people by denying them the benefits of society, including health. Treating health as a commodity, available to those who can pay, is its central example, and the injustice counts as violence in itself and as a cause of other violence. Paul Farmer (Partners In Health), Nancy Scheper-Hughes, and Philippe Bourgois are the key figures. Do not confuse structural violence with physical violence by institutions; the "violence" is the denial of access built into social structure.
- 7.3 Political-economic approaches are funded less than behaviour-focused ones because they mean addressing significant social configurations, which is slow and controversial, not because the evidence shows they fail. Practitioners working in these conditions know that progress is hard without some change in the conditions themselves. The analysis is not fatalism: microcredit, Partners In Health, Housing First, and tax and price policies are all things practitioners and governments can do. When asked to evaluate the approach, name both the practical obstacle and the reason it persists.
1. A classmate says: "Political economy is just the idea that money changes everything, so it belongs in an economics course, not a health behaviour course." What is wrong with this statement?
2. A health unit finds that HIV, hepatitis C, injection-related infections, and overdose deaths all cluster in the same low-income population. Which concept describes this pattern, and what does it imply for a response?
3. In a Prairie province, unstable housing raises exposure to shared injection equipment, distrust of services delays testing, and incarceration interrupts treatment, so risks build up along each person's life course. Which concept from the political-economic approach does this description illustrate?
4. A province's response to HIV among people who inject drugs consists mainly of testing campaigns and individual risk-reduction counselling. Which proposal applies the third step of the political-economic approach?
5. A province introduces minimum pricing for alcohol, which raises the price of the cheapest, highest-strength products the most. Following the resources as the political-economic approach suggests, which analysis is most consistent with political economy?
6. In the microcredit example, why is the resulting public health benefit described as political-economic rather than behavioural?
7. Which statement best matches the definition of structural violence?
8. Political-economic approaches have not been funded to the degree that behaviour-focused approaches have. What is the reason?
✦ Pass the knowledge check with 100% to continue
Anthropology and Cultural Theory: Adaptation and Meaning
⏱ Estimated reading time: 16 minutes
Overview
The last section argued that structure sets the range of choices open to people. This one asks what gives those choices their meaning. Anthropology is the in-depth, comparative study of human behaviour, and it reads the subject in two ways: as an adaptation that enabled survival in an environment, and as shaped by culture. This section sets out both readings, defines culture and the ethnomedical system, applies them to the behaviours behind obesity and to programs that people do not use, and states the two critiques of cultural approaches. It ends by bringing the four theory families of the lesson together.
Learning Objectives
- 6.1 Distinguish the two ways anthropology reads behaviour: as adaptation to an environment, and as meaningful and symbolic action within a culture.
- 6.2 Define culture, state the four elements most definitions share, and give the working definition of culture used for health behaviour.
- 6.3 Apply cultural questions to the behaviours behind obesity.
- 6.4 Define the ethnomedical system and explain how it guides prevention, healing, and stigma.
- 6.5 Use an anthropological approach to diagnose and redesign a program that is not being used, and describe the All Nations Breath of Life program.
- 7.4 State the two critiques of cultural approaches to health behaviour and what each implies for practice.
- 7.5 Compare communication, community and organizational change, political-economic, and cultural approaches with one another and with individual-level theories of behaviour.
6.1 Two Questions, Two Readings of Behaviour
Anthropology became a separate discipline in the nineteenth century, the era of Darwin's Origin of Species, of the discovery of prehistoric human remains, and of European colonial expansion into Africa, Asia, the Pacific, and the Americas. Two questions followed: how and when did we become the human beings we are today, and, given the diversity of ways of life, what makes us human and what is common across societies? The two readings of behaviour follow from the two questions.
- Behaviour as adaptation. Biological (or physical) anthropologists start from the first question and read behaviour as a species adaptation to, or interaction with, an environment. Behaviour or biology is explained by its fit, or misfit, with that environment. By this we mean that a practice or a bodily trait is understood as something that helped a population live in its conditions, or that no longer fits when the conditions change.
- Behaviour as meaningful. Cultural anthropologists start from the second question and assume that a large part of the answer is culture. A health behaviour is guided by an understanding of its meaning, or grows out of a pattern of living built around meanings, symbols, and values. In other words, the question here is not whether a behaviour fits an environment but what it means to the people who do it.
As anthropologists became involved in health, medical anthropology grew up as a subdiscipline that draws on both readings and explains behaviour without ever separating individuals from their sociocultural context. The three tabs below describe each tradition in more detail. Open each one, and in the first tab pay attention to the two health examples and to the caution about gene-and-diet explanations.
Biological anthropology: adaptation to an environment
Biological anthropologists read behaviour as a species adaptation to, or interaction with, an environment. Two health examples show the approach. Peter J. Brown studied how culture served as an adaptive strategy against malaria in Sardinia. Ritenbaugh and Goodby examined the idea that some American Indian peoples have a high incidence of diabetes because of an interaction between genetic makeup and modern diets high in carbohydrates and sugar. Gene-and-diet explanations of this kind extend the thrifty genotype hypothesis proposed by the geneticist James V. Neel in 1962. The hypothesis holds that genes which helped people store energy efficiently through cycles of feast and famine became a liability once food high in sugar and carbohydrates was always available. In other words, a trait that once fitted the environment is said to misfit a new one. Such explanations are contested: Neel wrote in 1989 that the data behind his hypothesis had largely collapsed, and later critics argue that such explanations attribute to biology the effects of colonialism, food insecurity, and other structural conditions (Hay, 2018). In both, behaviour or biology is explained by its fit or misfit with an environment.
Cultural anthropology: a pattern of living built on meaning
Cultural anthropologists begin from the second question and assume that a large part of the answer is culture, at once what is common to all humans and what is unique to each group. Their work is to build a descriptive inventory of cultural patterns and to examine culture's role in behaviour. From this angle a health behaviour is guided by an understanding of its meaning, or grows out of a pattern of living built around meanings, symbols, and values. The point is blunt: the behaviour cannot be separated from its context.
Medical anthropology
The subdiscipline that took shape as anthropologists became involved in health. It draws on both readings, so a medical anthropologist may ask both how a practice fits an environment and what it means to the people who carry it out. The subdiscipline has been used to engage Indigenous healers in HIV/AIDS prevention and treatment, to understand local practices to improve malaria prevention, and to map social networks among people who inject drugs. In each case the work starts from how people actually live and what they believe, and builds the health response around it. Its distinctive contribution here is the ethnomedical system, the set of shared beliefs about health and illness taken up in Subsection 6.4.
The tabs give a simple test for telling the readings apart. If an explanation turns on how well a body or a practice fits an environment, as with malaria in Sardinia or the contested gene-and-diet account of diabetes, it is the adaptation reading. Notice that classifying an explanation as an adaptation reading does not mean accepting it as correct; the gene-and-diet account is an example of the reading, not a settled finding. If it turns on what a practice means to the people who do it, it is the cultural reading. The cultural reading depends on a clear idea of what culture is, which the next subsection supplies.
6.2 What Culture Is
The word culture is common enough that its meaning can be fuzzy. Start with E. B. Tylor's classic 1871 definition of culture as a complex whole including knowledge, belief, art, morals, law, custom, and the other capabilities and habits a person acquires as a member of society. Four elements of that definition have persisted in most later ones:
- culture is a whole, an integrated pattern linking many aspects of life and social structure;
- it concerns the relationship between what people know and believe and what they do;
- it is acquired: you learn it in the course of life in society rather than being born with it; and
- it is shared, more or less, and transmitted to members over time.
Because culture describes a general human characteristic, it applies to any group that persists over time, from societies and regional and tribal groups to gangs and workplaces. For example, organizational culture, from Section 2, is the same concept at the scale of a hospital. Tylor's definition lists what culture contains, but health work needs a definition that points at what to look for in a behaviour. A working definition built for that purpose follows from the four elements. All people are cultural, and culture is the shared and learned part of cognition and behaviour that lets us interpret the world and take meaningful action: an ongoing collective framework, developed over time by human societies and groups, for integrating meaning with events, actions, and ways of life. By this we mean that culture is the framework a group uses to make sense of what happens to its members and to decide what to do about it, and that this framework is learned, shared, and built up over time rather than fixed at birth. It follows that a health behaviour is guided by an understanding of its meaning, or grows from a pattern of living built around meanings, symbols, and values connected to a larger social structure. For this reason the behaviour cannot be separated from that context, and a program that tries to change the behaviour while ignoring its meaning is working on only part of the picture.
The six cards below restate these ideas with an implication for practice on each. The first four cards give the four elements, and the last two give the working definition and the ethnomedical system, which Subsection 6.4 takes up.
A whole
Culture exists as an integrated pattern that links many aspects of life and social structure within a group or society. Food, work, family, religion, and health are connected, so a change in one pulls on the others. Implication: a program that treats eating as a stand-alone behaviour is pulling on one thread of a woven pattern.
Belief linked
to action
Culture concerns the relationship between what people know and believe and what they do. Beliefs about what a good meal is, what a healthy body looks like, or what causes illness are connected to the actions people take, which is why the cultural questions below always pair a belief with a practice.
Acquired,
not inborn
You are not born with a culture; you learn it during the course of life in society. This is what separates the cultural reading from the adaptation reading: an adaptation can be genetic, while culture is always learned, and therefore can be learned differently by different members and generations of the same group.
Shared and
transmitted
Culture is shared, more or less, among members of a group and transmitted to members over time. The phrase "more or less" matters: the first critique of cultural approaches is that culture is never homogeneous, and one group does not share every element to the same degree.
A working
definition
Culture is the shared and learned part of human cognition and behaviour that lets us interpret the world and take meaningful action: an ongoing collective framework, developed over time by human societies and groups, for integrating meaning with events, actions, and ways of life. The definition is built for health work, because it points at what a cultural anthropologist would look for in a behaviour.
Ethnomedical
system
The underlying set of beliefs, shared to one degree or another by most people in a cultural group, that answers what it means to be healthy, which conditions count as unhealthy, how someone becomes unhealthy (the causes), and how they become healthy again, including who they go to and what the remedies are. It guides prevention behaviour, healing behaviour, and whether a condition is stigmatized.
Two of the cards carry ideas that return later in the section: "acquired" means culture can be learned differently by different members and generations, and "more or less" shared is the root of the first critique of cultural approaches. With a definition in hand, the next subsection puts it to work on a single health problem.
6.3 Obesity Through Cultural Questions
Obesity is a good illustration, approached through questions a planner trained only in individual theories would not ask. What do people in a group think makes a good meal, and why, and how does that compare with what experts call healthy? What body types are expected and valued? In some cultures a large man is esteemed because size symbolizes doing well. How do gender and eating or exercise patterns relate? How does social structure shape eating and exercise, for example through the lack of fresh produce in high-poverty neighbourhoods? And who prepares food? Table 5.4 sets out the five questions, what each points to (the role of food, status and body image, gender roles, access, and social tasks), and a Canadian illustration of each.
Table 5.4. Five cultural questions about the behaviours behind obesity, what each points to, and a Canadian illustration of each.
| The cultural question | What it points to | Canadian illustration |
|---|---|---|
| What makes a good meal, and why? How does that compare with what experts call healthy? | The role of food; the gap between local and expert meanings | In many northern and Indigenous communities a good meal centres on traditional foods from hunting and fishing, which carry meanings of identity and sharing a food guide does not capture |
| What body types are expected and valued? | Status and body image; in some cultures a large man is esteemed because size symbolizes doing well | Body size messages designed for one population can read as accusations, or as nonsense, in another |
| How do gender and eating or exercise patterns relate? | Gender roles | Who eats first or most, and whether physical activity is coded as appropriate for women |
| How does social structure shape eating and exercise? | Access; high-poverty neighbourhoods typically have less access to fresh fruit and vegetables | Food prices in fly-in communities, and the Nutrition North Canada subsidy that exists because of them |
| Who prepares food? | Social tasks | A cooking-skills program for teenagers means something different where grandmothers prepare most meals |
All five questions treat the behaviours behind obesity as inseparable from the living and meaning systems they belong to. The fourth is where anthropology and political economy meet: the cultural reading asks what a food means, the political-economic reading asks who can afford it, and a full account needs both. The questions in Table 5.4 are about particular behaviours; the next subsection goes beneath them, to the beliefs about health itself.
6.4 Ethnomedical Systems
The other direction connects behaviour to underlying epistemologies of health. An epistemology is a system of knowing, that is, a set of beliefs about how we know things. Applied to health, this means that beneath everyday health behaviour sits a set of beliefs, usually taken for granted, about what health and illness are. These beliefs answer four questions:
- What does it mean to be healthy, and how do we recognize it?
- Which illnesses and conditions count as not healthy?
- How does someone become unhealthy: what are the causes? Many cultures understand at least some conditions as having spiritual causes, whereas Western cultures typically attribute most disease to biological causes.
- How does someone become healthy again, who do they go to, and what are the remedies?
Together the answers form what medical anthropology calls an ethnomedical system, a basic set of beliefs shared to one degree or another by most people in a cultural group. By this we mean that each cultural group carries its own answers to the four questions, and those answers, rather than expert advice alone, shape what people do when they want to stay well or when they feel unwell. The ethnomedical system guides both prevention and healing, and it decides whether a condition is stigmatized. It should not be confused with the cultural questions about obesity in Subsection 6.3. Those questions are about particular behaviours such as eating, whereas the ethnomedical system concerns the beliefs about health and illness that lie beneath all such behaviours. Three consequences follow, one for each kind of answer:
- Where a large body signals well-being, standard messages about body size make little sense; imagine members of such a group asking why anyone would want to look thin, and therefore poor.
- Where a condition is believed to have a spiritual cause, people consult a spiritual person rather than a physician.
- Where a condition is attributed to moral failure, it may be stigmatized, and the affected person may hide from any doctor or healer, as has happened with HIV/AIDS.
Interactive 5.4 shows how the four answers combine. It is set in a community for which a health authority is planning a diabetes prevention program. Answer the four questions as most people there would answer them, then click to predict the behaviour that follows, the standard messages that will not make sense, and what the program should do. Change one answer at a time to see how much a single belief shifts the prediction.
📊 Interactive 5.4: Build an ethnomedical system, then predict the behaviour.
A health authority is planning a diabetes prevention program for a community it knows little about. Answer the four questions as most people there would, then predict. The output gives the expected behaviour, the standard messages that will not make sense, and what the program should do instead. Change one answer at a time to see how much a single belief shifts the prediction.The interactive makes the practical point of this subsection: change the answer to a single question, especially the question about cause, and the expected behaviour, the messages that fail, and the program that fits all change with it. A program that does not correspond to the ethnomedical system will be decoded, in the terms of Section 1, as nonsense or as an insult. The next subsection uses this idea to diagnose and redesign real programs.
6.5 Using Anthropological Approaches in Programs
An applied scenario begins with a puzzle. Public money built clinics in urban, underserved areas, and a year later use is low. Research finds that in certain neighbourhoods people over 30 do not use them; that recent immigrant families live alongside longer-settled families from the same country; that recent immigrants are more likely to attribute some illnesses to spiritual causes; and that the clinics offer nothing that corresponds to those beliefs. Two responses suggest themselves:
- work with leaders from both segments so that recent immigrants hear the longer-settled families' experiences of the clinics; or
- co-locate traditional and spiritual healers so that services match the range of conditions as the community perceives them.
Both change the clinic to fit the ethnomedical system rather than trying to correct the beliefs or waiting for the system to change. Worked Example 5.6 applies the same reasoning to a Canadian community health centre. As you read it, watch for the step that identifies which part of the ethnomedical system the centre ignores.
Worked Example 5.6: A Clinic That Fits, or Does Not
The case. A community health centre opens in a Canadian city neighbourhood with many newcomer families. After a year, adults use it far less than expected, while their school-age children are seen regularly. Community leaders say many adults attribute chronic pain, fatigue, and some mental distress to spiritual imbalance or the strain of migration, and consult elders, faith leaders, and traditional practitioners before, or instead of, a clinic. The centre offers only biomedical services in English and French.
Step 1: Choose the reading. Nothing in the case turns on biological fit with an environment; the pattern turns on what illness means and who is consulted. This is the cultural (meaning) reading.
Step 2: Map the case onto the ethnomedical system. The adults' answer to "what causes illness?" includes spiritual imbalance and the strain of migration, and their answer to "who heals?" is elders, faith leaders, and traditional practitioners. The centre corresponds to neither answer, so for these conditions it is simply not where one goes.
Step 3: Decide what the centre should change first. Following the two responses from the clinic scenario, the centre could work with community leaders and with families who already use it (including through the children's visits) so that adults hear their experiences, and it could collaborate with or co-locate the elders, faith leaders, and practitioners the community already consults. Services in the community's languages would remove a further barrier, since the channel and the source are part of the message.
Step 4: Guard against the first critique. The children already use the centre, which shows that the neighbourhood is not culturally homogeneous: generations differ. The redesign should come from formative research on that variation, not from a single picture of "newcomer culture."
Pairing with another family. The meaning reading pairs naturally with communications theory from Section 1, because a service that does not fit the ethnomedical system is decoded as irrelevant, and with community mobilization from Section 2, because leaders from the community define the response.
What the example shows. Low use is a signal that the program does not correspond to the ethnomedical system, not proof that people do not care about their health. The common mistake is to respond with an education campaign that tries to correct the beliefs, which ignores the point that behaviour cannot be separated from its meaning system.
The same principle, design the program to fit the meaning system, shaped one of the most successful programs in this area. The program concerns smoking in an American Indian population, and it turns on a distinction Canadian readers will recognize from Indigenous tobacco programs here, which separate traditional from commercial tobacco. Among many American Indian peoples tobacco is a sacred plant used as a ritual symbol of peace and healing and for medicinal, religious, and instructional purposes; that use differs from cigarette smoking both culturally and physically. The All Nations Breath of Life program therefore targeted smoking and chewing tobacco, not tobacco use in general, and drew on the group-based, egalitarian features of American Indian culture. Its components were developed through a participatory process:
- facilitator-led group discussion (deliberately not a counsellor);
- telephone counselling for issues people did not want to raise in a group;
- culturally oriented materials; and
- pharmacological support where needed.
In preliminary results for the first 108 participants, the self-reported quit rate was 65 percent at program completion and 25 percent at six months after baseline, much better than other interventions with the same populations (Daley and colleagues, 2010). The First Nations Health Authority's Respecting Tobacco work in British Columbia makes the same distinction, for the same reason: a message that condemns tobacco as such condemns a sacred practice and is decoded, in the terms of Section 1, as an attack.
Worked Example 5.7 describes a Canadian program that goes one step further, with the community itself defining both the problem and the meaning of the solution. As you read it, look for each of the four elements of culture from Subsection 6.2.
Worked Example 5.7: The Kahnawake Schools Diabetes Prevention Project
The case. Since 1994, the Kanien'kehá:ka (Mohawk) community of Kahnawake, near Montreal, has run the Kahnawake Schools Diabetes Prevention Project, a community-driven effort to prevent type 2 diabetes among children through healthy eating and physical activity in the elementary schools and the wider community. It is guided by a community advisory board and operates under a community-written code of research ethics that sets the terms on which university researchers take part, and its programming is built around Kanien'kehá:ka values, language, and traditional foods and activities (KSDPP). It is described here schematically.
Step 1: Identify the elements of culture the program relies on. Building on language, traditional foods, and community values relies most on culture as a whole (food, school, family, and identity linked together) and on culture as shared and transmitted (passing values and practices to children). Because culture is acquired, a school program is a natural place to shape it.
Step 2: Connect it to defining the community. The community-written code of research ethics answers the warning from Section 2 that defining the community is political: here the community, not outside researchers, sets the terms of its own participation.
Step 3: Connect it to the critiques. The project's long life, since 1994, fits the critique that culture change takes time, and the advisory board lets the community's own diversity shape the program, which answers the critique that culture is not homogeneous.
Step 4: Ask what copying would lose. A health authority that copied the activities without the community's ownership would lose the meaning that makes them work: the same lessons on food and activity would come from outside the community's meaning system.
What the example shows. The strongest culturally grounded programs are not tailored for a community but defined by it. The common mistake is to treat culture as a set of surface features (a translated poster, a traditional image) rather than as the framework that gives the program its meaning.
All three programs in this subsection changed themselves to fit a meaning system. Cultural approaches still face two critiques, which the next subsection states.
7.4 Critique: Culture Is Not Homogeneous, and It Changes Slowly
Two critiques have been raised against cultural approaches to health behaviour. The first concerns the assumption that a culture is homogeneous, and the second the time that cultural change takes. Each critique is set out below with what follows from it for practice.
Critique 1: culture is not homogeneous
A common misperception is that culture is homogeneous, so that one approach fits an entire group. By this we mean the assumption that everyone who belongs to a cultural group holds the same beliefs and follows the same practices. In reality, one group does not typically share all elements to the same degree, and there may be factions and subgroups divided by age, generation, gender, religion, or length of time in a place. Because of this, a cultural approach used too easily may go right past part of the intended population. For example, in Worked Example 5.6 the children of newcomer families already used the clinic while many of their parents did not, so a program designed around a single picture of the group would have fitted one generation and missed the other. The remedy, as in the KSDPP case, is to let the community, in its own diversity, define the approach.
Critique 2: culture change takes time
Changes in how culture and behaviour interact may take time. This is because culture is learned over a lifetime and shared across a group, so the meanings attached to food, bodies, or tobacco shift gradually, often over generations, rather than in the course of a single program. Such changes are often necessary for long-term effect, but in the short term, changes in the environment, whether new laws, regulations, or a physical change such as sidewalks, may act faster, at least to start the process. For example, a smoke-free bylaw can change where people smoke before attitudes toward smoking have fully shifted, and the new routine can then help the attitudes change. In this sense policy and structure can move first, and culture can follow.
The two critiques lead to two practical habits. Map the variation within a group through formative research, by age, generation, and family, before assuming that everyone shares the same meanings; and pair cultural work, which is necessary for long-term effect, with environmental and policy changes, which may act faster at the start. With those cautions in place, the four theory families of the lesson can be set side by side.
7.5 How the Four Families Fit Together
Each family in this lesson answers a different question about the same behaviour, and each carries its own critique. The callout below states the four questions in a form worth memorizing.
Four Questions to Ask of Any Behaviour
Communications theory asks how the message travels and what it comes to mean; community and organizational change asks whether the settings will permit it; political economy asks who can afford it and who profits; anthropology asks what it means to the people doing it.
The critiques also point at each other. Communication effects are hard to measure, community and organizational change has no off-the-shelf solutions, political-economic change is slow and controversial, and culture is neither homogeneous nor quick to change. Because each family is weak where another is strong, they work best in combination. For example, policy can move before culture, and culture decides whether policy is accepted. A new law can change the setting quickly, which addresses the slowness of cultural change, but if the law conflicts with what the behaviour means to the people affected it may be resisted or ignored, which is where cultural understanding comes in. In the same way, a well-designed message is wasted if the setting gives people no way to act on it, and a new service goes unused if no one hears of it in a code they trust. This is why the strongest programs, such as the Texas tobacco campaign with its media and services or Insite with its mobilization and organizational change, use more than one family.
Compared with individual-level theories of behaviour, the main difference is the unit of analysis, by which we mean the thing whose change the theory describes. Several pairs of terms look alike but differ in exactly this way. Self-efficacy is an individual's confidence; empowerment is a community's efficacy. The stages of the Transtheoretical Model describe a person; the stages of adoption describe an organization. And where individual theories treat beliefs as attitudes to be changed, the cultural reading treats them as part of a meaning system to be worked with. In practice, then, when a question asks which family fits a situation, first identify where the barrier lies: in the message, the setting, the structure, or the meaning. Then choose the family that asks about that place. For example, if people do not attend diabetes screening because there is no facility to attend, the barrier is the setting, and community or organizational change fits better than a new message.
This section has set out the two readings of behaviour in anthropology, the definition of culture and its four elements, the cultural questions about obesity, the ethnomedical system and its use in diagnosing and designing programs, and the two critiques of cultural approaches, and it has set the four families of the lesson side by side. The key takeaways and knowledge check that follow review this material and lead into the final review of the lesson.
Key Takeaways
- 6.1 Anthropology reads behaviour in two ways. Biological anthropology treats it as a species adaptation to an environment, as in Peter J. Brown's work on malaria in Sardinia and Ritenbaugh and Goodby's contested gene-and-diet account of diabetes; cultural anthropology treats it as meaningful action within a culture. Medical anthropology draws on both and never separates the individual from the sociocultural context. To classify an explanation, ask whether it turns on fit with an environment (adaptation) or on what the behaviour means to the people doing it (culture).
- 6.2 From Tylor's 1871 definition onward, four elements of culture have persisted: it is an integrated whole, it links what people know and believe to what they do, it is acquired rather than inborn, and it is shared, more or less, and transmitted over time. The working definition for health behaviour calls culture an ongoing collective framework, developed over time by societies and groups, for integrating meaning with events, actions, and ways of life. If an answer option says culture is inborn or identical for every member of a group, it contradicts the elements "acquired" and "more or less" shared.
- 6.3 A cultural reading of obesity asks what counts as a good meal, which body types are valued (in some cultures a large man is esteemed because size symbolizes doing well), how gender shapes eating and activity, how social structure shapes access to food, and who prepares food. These questions point to the role of food, status and body image, gender roles, access, and social tasks. In an applied question, the cultural question is the one about meaning, not about calories, knowledge, or confidence, which belong to individual-level theories.
- 6.4 An ethnomedical system is a group's shared answers to four questions: what it means to be healthy, which conditions count as illness, what causes illness, and how one becomes healthy again and with whose help. It guides prevention, healing, and stigma: where a large body means doing well, body-size messages make no sense; where a cause is spiritual, people consult a spiritual healer; where illness is blamed on moral failure, people may hide, as with HIV/AIDS. To predict behaviour in a case, read off the community's answer to the question about cause first, because it decides who is consulted.
- 6.5 When a program is underused, check whether it corresponds to the ethnomedical system before blaming the people it was meant for. The two responses from the clinic scenario are to let longer-settled community members share their experience and to co-locate traditional and spiritual healers, both of which change the program to fit the system. All Nations Breath of Life targeted cigarettes and chewing tobacco, not sacred tobacco, and used participatory, group-based methods, and the Kahnawake project shows a community defining its own program. The trap to avoid is an education campaign that tries to correct people's beliefs about cause.
- 7.4 Cultural approaches face two critiques. Culture is not homogeneous: subgroups, factions, and generations differ, so one tailored approach can go right past part of the intended population. And culture change takes time: it is often needed for long-term effect, but laws, regulations, or physical changes such as sidewalks may act faster at the start. In a planning answer, show both remedies: formative research on variation within the group, and faster environmental measures alongside the cultural work.
- 7.5 Each family asks a different question of the same behaviour: how the message travels and what it means (communication), whether the settings permit it (community and organizational change), who can afford it and who profits (political economy), and what it means to the people doing it (anthropology). Compared with earlier individual-level theories, the unit changes from the person to the community, the organization, the structure, or the culture, as empowerment versus self-efficacy shows. To judge which family fits a situation, locate the barrier first, and expect the strongest plans to use more than one family.
1. A researcher explains high rates of type 2 diabetes in a population by an interaction between the population's genetic makeup and a modern diet high in refined carbohydrates and sugar. Which anthropological reading of behaviour is this?
2. A colleague argues that a group's eating habits are inborn, fixed in its members from birth. Which element of culture contradicts this claim?
3. A health authority is assessing the behaviours behind obesity in a community. Which question would a cultural anthropologist add that a planner trained only in individual-level theories would probably not ask?
4. In a community where a large body is read as a sign of doing well, standard prevention messages about body size and obesity are predicted to make little sense. Which concept explains the prediction?
5. A regional health authority drafts a diabetes prevention campaign for a coastal community where a large body is widely read as a sign of doing well. The slogan is "Small changes, smaller you." How is the slogan most likely to be decoded?
6. A new clinic is underused by recent immigrants who attribute some illnesses to spiritual causes. Which response matches the anthropological approach?
7. Why did the All Nations Breath of Life program target cigarette smoking and chewing tobacco rather than tobacco use in general?
8. A health unit designs a single "culturally tailored" nutrition program for all residents of a neighbourhood with a large immigrant population, and later finds that younger, locally raised residents ignored it. Which critique of cultural approaches does this illustrate?
9. A health authority plans a diabetes prevention program in a coastal community where body size and shared meals carry strong cultural meanings. Which plan best answers both critiques of cultural approaches?
✦ Pass the knowledge check with 100% to continue
Final Review & Assessment
⏱ Estimated time: 25 minutes
Bringing It All Together
This lesson went farther out into society than any lesson so far. It began with communication, where the technical model of a sender encoding a message, a channel carrying it through noise, and a receiver decoding it turned out to be only the skeleton. A fuller account added what the diagram omits: the context and relationship between the parties, the meaning carried by the channel itself, the interpretive work of encoding and decoding, the shared knowledge of a speech community, and the discursive practices and institutions that decide what counts as credible. The practical result was a method, learn the audience's code through formative research, encode in it, choose channels the audience already uses, and check the decoding afterward, together with a warning that exposure is the easiest level of effect to measure and the least informative.
The second and third sections asked what happens when the barrier is the setting rather than the message. Community mobilization brings collective action, drawn from the movement tradition and from Alinsky and Freire, to bear on ecological conditions, proceeding by defining the community, assessing its capacity, and working with its agenda, with empowerment as its signature result. Organizational and systems change treats organizations as systems of human beings that move through stages, from unsatisfied demand to institutionalization, shaped by culture, climate, and capacity. Political economy went one level further: there is always a political-economic context that sets what people can and cannot do, and a health problem is often one strand of a syndemic with shared causes in poverty, exclusion, and the treatment of health as a commodity. Microcredit and the structural violence perspective showed that the response reaches beyond the individual to credit, housing, price, and access.
The final section turned to meaning. Anthropology reads behaviour as adaptation to an environment and as meaningful action within a culture, an integrated, learned, shared framework linking belief to action. The ethnomedical system, the shared answers to what health is, what counts as illness, what causes it, and who heals, decides whether a program makes sense to the people it is for, as the underused clinic and the All Nations Breath of Life program showed. Two critiques close the lesson and connect the anthropological family to the others: culture is never homogeneous, and cultural change takes time, so environmental and policy change often has to move first. Held together, the four families give you four questions to ask of any behaviour: how is it talked about, will the setting permit it, who can afford it, and what does it mean.
Key Takeaways from this lesson
- You can describe the technical model of communication, in which a sender encodes a message, sends it through a channel where noise may interfere, and a receiver decodes it and may send feedback, and you can explain what it leaves out: context, relationship, the meaning of the channel, and the interpretive work of encoding and decoding. The most useful habit is to label the parts of a case first and then ask which omission explains why a message failed.
- You can apply encoding, message design, channel selection, and agenda setting to a real audience, using the four moves of the method: learn the code, encode in it from a credible source, use the audience's channels, and check the decoding. Remember that the channel is part of the message, and that encoding for an audience means using its code, not simply simplifying or translating.
- You can explain why a community sometimes has to change before behaviour can, and describe community mobilization through its movement roots, Alinsky and Freire, its three key issues (defining the community, assessing capacity, working with the community agenda), and empowerment as its result. In an applied question, the strongest move is usually to pair the health issue with something already on the community's agenda.
- You can describe organizational development, which treats organizations as systems of human beings, and apply Lewin's stages and the stages from unsatisfied demand to institutionalization to an organization adopting a health practice, with culture, climate, and capacity shaping the process. To place an event in a stage, ask what actually happened, and count only written routines, budgets, and indicators as institutionalization.
- You can run a political-economic analysis: rethink a health problem as a product of social relationships, trace the trajectory of risk, and address the relationships themselves, using Singer's syndemic, microcredit, and structural violence. The quickest test is whether a response changes a relationship to price, credit, housing, or access, rather than only a person's knowledge or motivation.
- You can distinguish the adaptation and cultural readings of behaviour, define culture by its four elements and the ethnomedical system by its four questions, and use them to diagnose a program that people do not use. When a program is underused, check whether it corresponds to the community's ethnomedical system before trying to correct anyone's beliefs.
- You can state the critique each family faces (effects are hard to measure; there are no off-the-shelf solutions; structural change is slow and controversial; culture is neither homogeneous nor quick to change) and compare the four families with each other and with individual-level theories. To judge which family fits, locate the barrier in the message, the setting, the structure, or the meaning, and expect the strongest plans to combine families.
Final Knowledge Assessment
This assessment covers all material from this lesson. You must score 100% to complete the lesson. Review the feedback for any incorrect answers and try again.
1. Which sequence correctly lists the steps of the Shannon-Weaver model?
2. A vaccination reminder from a family physician of twenty years and the same words in a mass email from an unknown office produce very different responses. Which omission of the technical model does this illustrate?
3. A public health unit's mailed letter about school vaccination, written in formal English, produces low response from recent immigrant parents. Which analysis best uses the communication model from this lesson?
4. The first step in agenda setting for a health issue is:
5. In the Texas tobacco campaign described in this lesson, which finding most directly answers the critique that communication effects are hard to assess?
6. A coalition wants to reduce youth vaping by changing where products are sold. Which of the following is the best reason to treat this as a community mobilization problem?
7. Which pairing of a founder and a contribution is correct?
8. A hospital's board approves a new policy "in principle" but assigns no budget, date, or lead, and a year later nothing has changed. In the staged model of organizational change, where did the process stall?
9. Organizational change is often affected by factors that cannot be controlled. Which list matches the factors named in this lesson?
10. Merrill Singer's political-economic analysis of HIV/AIDS among the urban poor begins by:
11. Which policy is best described as acting at the political-economic level in the sense this lesson intends?
12. What makes the microcredit example a public health intervention?
13. The structural violence perspective treats health as a commodity as a central problem. What does that phrase mean?
14. Which of the following is NOT one of the four elements that have remained consistent across definitions of culture?
15. A community attributes a particular illness to moral failure. Based on the discussion of ethnomedical systems in this lesson, what behaviour should a program planner expect?
16. A regional health authority is planning to reduce commercial tobacco use in a remote First Nations community where members describe traditional tobacco as sacred and cigarettes as a separate thing. Which element of a plan best respects the community's ethnomedical system?
17. In the same community, cigarettes are sold at the one general store and the health centre has a nurse three days a week. Which element of a plan addresses a political-economic condition?
18. The second critique of cultural approaches says that in the short term, changes in the environment may have a more immediate effect than cultural change. Which lesson-wide conclusion does this support?
19. A colleague says, "Empowerment is just self-efficacy under another name." Using this lesson's comparison with the individual-level theories, what is the best correction?
✦ Pass every section knowledge check with 100% before submitting