Individual Health
Behavior Theories
Health Promotion: Individuals and Communities
Learning objectives for this lesson:
- State the three assumptions shared by individual theories of health behaviour, and explain why the line between a person and their context is hard to draw.
- Describe the origin of the Health Belief Model in Hochbaum's tuberculosis screening research, define its six constructs, and explain what makes it a value expectancy model.
- Distinguish attitude toward a behaviour, subjective norm, behavioural intention, and perceived behavioural control, and explain why the Theory of Reasoned Action was revised into the Theory of Planned Behavior.
- Describe the stages of the Transtheoretical Model and the Precaution Adoption Process Model, and distinguish stage models from point-in-time theories.
- Apply individual health behaviour theories and stage models to a health promotion case by mapping its details onto constructs or stages, and explain how research with the intended population avoids the EZ program structure illusion.
- Evaluate the main critiques of individual health behaviour theories and stage models, and judge which approach best fits a given behaviour, population, and stage of readiness.
This course was developed by Dr. Kiffer G. Card, to accompany Edberg, M. Essentials of Health Behavior: Social and Behavioral Theory in Public Health. Jones & Bartlett Learning. This lesson follows Chapter 4 of the text.
Glossary: Key Terms, People & Concepts
📚 Reference page, available throughout the lesson
This glossary collects the key concepts, people, and ideas you will meet in this lesson. Use it as a reference while you work through the material, or as a review before assessments. Type in the search box to filter entries.
What Is an Individual? Setting the Scene
⏱ Estimated reading time: 12 minutes
Overview
This lesson takes up specific theories, beginning with the theories that treat the individual as the primary source of behaviour: the Health Belief Model, the Theory of Reasoned Action and its revision, the Theory of Planned Behavior, the Transtheoretical Model, and the Precaution Adoption Process Model. Before introducing any of them, this section pauses on a question that sounds too obvious to ask: what is an individual? The answer shapes how every theory in the lesson should be read. The section then names the three assumptions the five theories share, reads a first health decision through that lens, and sorts the five approaches into two families.
Learning Objectives
- 1.1 Explain why some theories of health behaviour are called individual theories, and describe why the line between a person and their context is hard to draw.
- 1.2 Summarize Louis Dumont's distinction between societies built from individuals and societies that are the source of individuals, and explain what it means for a health promoter.
- 1.3 State the three assumptions that the individual theories share.
- 1.4 Identify, in a health decision, which elements belong to the person's thought process and which come from the social, physical, and cultural environment.
- 4.1 Classify the Health Belief Model, the Theory of Reasoned Action, the Theory of Planned Behavior, the Transtheoretical Model, and the Precaution Adoption Process Model as point-in-time theories or stage models, and explain why the stage models are called models.
1.1 Individual Theories and the Blurred Line Around the Self
The theories in this lesson are called individual theories because they treat the individual as the primary source of behaviour. Each one focuses on the thought processes a person goes through before taking a health-related action: what the person believes, how they weigh the action, what they intend, or how ready they are. The label does not claim that the social world is irrelevant. It describes where the theory looks, and this subsection shows why that focus needs a companion reminder about what lies outside it.
1.1.1 Back to Sam
Begin by conceding the obvious: of course individuals generate their own behaviour, because we are not robots. Then consider Sam, a friend who has started brushing his teeth with unusual care. Sam was certainly making decisions and acting as an individual. However, the information he used to make those decisions, the situation that was motivating him, and the parts of his family upbringing that shaped his toothbrushing habit all involved connections with a social world. In other words, the decisions were his, but much of the material he decided with came from outside him. The same holds for the theories in this lesson. They focus on the thought processes individuals go through before taking a health-related action, and that focus is legitimate. The task is simply to remember the context while you study them, because the decisions people make to take or not take an action are based on cues, references, and information from their social, physical, and cultural environments. No person, as John Donne wrote in 1624, is an island.
That context appears in Figure 3.1 as three environments (social, physical, and cultural) that feed the thought process inside the individual before an action.
Figure 3.1. The shape shared by every theory in this lesson. The theory describes the box in the middle; the arrows from the left supply what the box works with, and are mostly taken for granted.
Figure 3.1 shows the shape of every theory in this lesson. The box in the middle is where the theory does its work: it names the beliefs, attitudes, intentions, or stages that come before an action. The arrows from the left are what the theories mostly take for granted. They supply the raw material of a decision without being part of the model, and the critiques you will read in later sections nearly all turn on that arrangement. If the environments supply the material, the next question is how much of the person is left once that material is traced to its source.
1.1.2 Taking the Self Apart
The best way to answer the question "what is an individual?" is to take the everyday answer apart and ask where each piece came from. In everyday speech, an individual is an autonomous self with a distinct body, a personality, a way of talking and walking, goals, motivations, and the ability to plan and carry out action. By this we mean you, the person reading this sentence, understood as someone separate from everyone else. The purpose of taking the definition apart is to see how much of that separate self was supplied by other people. For example, your body is genetic; it came from your parents and ancestors, so it is you and also, in part, them. Your personality may have genetic influences as well, but your way of talking, walking, and dressing was assembled from pieces you did not invent. Consider a musician praised as a unique saxophone player. He is unique, but his uniqueness lies in the way he combines riffs he learned from others rather than in inventing every riff himself. In the same way, what makes you distinct is the particular way you have combined influences that came from outside you.
Interactive 3.1 holds six pieces of the everyday definition of an individual, from the body to personal style. Click each piece in turn to trace it to its source, and keep going until all six are traced and the conclusion appears.
📊 Interactive 3.1: Where did "me" come from?
Click each piece of the everyday definition of an individual to trace it to its source.Tracing all six pieces leads to one conclusion: it is not easy to draw a clear line between yourself and everyone else. The exercise does not make individuals disappear. You take these influences, shape them, and inhabit them as your own life. What it shows is that the process connects you to your world in ways that complicate any simple description of individual behaviour and motivation. When a theory in this lesson says that a person weighs benefits against barriers, ask where that person's sense of what counts as a benefit came from. Where the line falls is not only a puzzle about one person; whole cultures draw it in different places.
1.2 Dumont's Two Ways of Drawing the Line
There is great variety across cultures in how the idea of the individual is conceptualized, a point developed by the anthropologist Louis Dumont. Dumont distinguished two kinds of society. The first is said to be constructed of individuals: the individual is the key, autonomous unit, and society is what those individuals make together. The second is understood as the source from which individuals come: society is viewed as more important than the individual, and a person is understood through the relationships and obligations that produced them. By this we mean that the two views disagree about which comes first, the person or the group. The distinction matters for this lesson because the theories you are about to study were written in the first kind of society and carry its assumptions. However, the contrast is a spectrum rather than a way of sorting countries into two boxes. For that reason, whose approval matters to a person, or who actually makes a health decision, is an empirical question to be answered for the people in front of you rather than assumed from where they live.
The three tabs below set out the two views and their practical meaning. Open the first two tabs to compare the views, then open the third to see what the difference means for a public health nurse in Metro Vancouver.
The individual as the key unit
In this view the person is the unit that holds rights, makes choices, and signs consent forms. Health promotion in this frame speaks to a person: know your risk, weigh your options, decide. The five theories in this lesson are built this way. Each places a belief, an attitude, an intention, or a stage inside one person's head and predicts what that person will do. Programs that follow them deliver information, reshape attitudes, build confidence, or match a message to a stage, and they measure success one person at a time.
The person understood through relationships
In this view the person is understood first through relationships and obligations. A decision about screening or vaccination may be a household's decision, an elder's, or a community's, and a program that addresses only the person may be talking to the wrong decision-maker. Dumont developed the contrast from his study of caste in India and of Western individualism, and he is cited here only to note the variety. Treat the contrast as a spectrum rather than a sorting of countries: every society contains both understandings, and a single family can move between them depending on the decision.
A practical matter for a health promoter
In Metro Vancouver a public health nurse may see, in one afternoon, a family whose health decisions are made collectively and a patient who expects to decide alone. Many Indigenous frameworks for wellness in Canada describe the person as inseparable from family, community, nation, and land; the First Nations Health Authority's schematic of wellness places the individual at the centre of those rings and treats the rings as part of the person rather than as background. None of this says the individual theories are wrong. It says that the constructs they use, such as attitude or perceived barrier, must be specified for the people in front of you, and that the question of whose approval matters to a person is empirical.
Read together, the tabs make one practical point. The individual theories are not wrong, but they assume the first view, so a health promoter has to find out, rather than assume, whether a decision belongs to a person, a household, an elder, or a community. With the line around the individual drawn, the five theories can be described by what they assume about the person inside it.
1.3 What the Individual Theories Assume
Reading across the five, you can see that the individual theories share three assumptions. The first is that behaviour follows a thought process. By this we mean that something happens inside the person before the action, and that this something can be described and measured: a belief, an attitude, an intention, or a stage comes first, and the behaviour follows from it. The second assumption is that the process is largely rational and cognitive. In other words, people are pictured as assessing risk, weighing benefits against costs, forming intentions, and moving through stages in an orderly way, which is why later sections will note that emotion, habit, and gut instinct fit awkwardly into these theories. The third assumption is that the person is both the unit of analysis and the unit of intervention. The theory studies what one person believes or intends, and a program built on it then tries to change what a person believes, intends, or is ready for, expecting behaviour to follow. The purpose of naming these assumptions now is that they give you a way to read every critique that follows, as the callout below explains.
Three assumptions to watch
Behaviour follows a describable thought process; that process is largely rational and cognitive; and the person is the unit of analysis and of intervention. Every critique in this lesson lands on one of these three, so when you meet a critique, ask which assumption it challenges.
These assumptions are easiest to see when they meet a real decision, which is where the lesson turns next.
1.4 Inside the Person and Around the Person
The theories in this lesson are easier to compare when each is applied to the same decision, and Worked Example 3.1 presents that decision before any theory is introduced. It applies the shape of Figure 3.1: sort the details of the case into the thought process inside the person and the environments around her. Watch for details that look personal but were supplied by someone else.
Worked Example 3.1: A Flu Shot on the Way to Class
The case. Priya is a third-year student at a university in Burnaby. In late October the pharmacy on her bus route puts up a sign offering the seasonal influenza vaccine at no charge, with no appointment needed. Priya lives with her parents and her grandmother, who is being treated for a heart condition. Two of her closest friends have told her that the flu shot made them feel sick for a week last year. Her mother had the shot at work and mentioned, without pushing, that the pharmacist said the whole household should get one. Priya works two part-time jobs and has a midterm on Friday. She has never had a flu shot as an adult. On Tuesday she walks past the pharmacy and stops for a moment at the door.
Step 1, the behaviour and the person. The behaviour is getting the seasonal influenza vaccine, today, at this pharmacy. The person is Priya, a young adult who has not had the shot before.
Step 2, what happens inside her head. These are the elements an individual theory would describe: her sense of whether she is at risk of influenza; how serious she thinks it would be, for herself and for her grandmother; her expectation that the shot might make her sick for a week; her weighing of that week against her midterm and her shifts; and her sense of whether she can simply walk in now.
Step 3, the context she did not choose. The physical environment supplies a free vaccine, no appointment, and a pharmacy on her bus route. The social environment supplies her friends' stories, her mother's remark, and the pharmacist's advice that the household be vaccinated. Her grandmother's illness and a household that may treat health as a shared matter connect the decision to Dumont's second view: it may not be hers alone. Her two jobs and her midterm set the shape of her week.
Step 4, where the line blurs. Several beliefs in Step 2 came from Step 3. The fear of a week in bed came from her friends; the idea that the household should be protected came from the pharmacist through her mother. The decision is Priya's, and its raw material is social, physical, and cultural, exactly as Figure 3.1 draws it.
A common mistake is to file her friends' stories only under context. They are context that has become a belief inside her head, which is why the line between the person and the environment is hard to draw.
The example showed that even a moment at a door is built from beliefs supplied by others. Keep Priya in mind: each of the next three sections picks up her decision with a different theory, and the differences in what each theory notices are the content of this lesson. For every theory you will see the same four things: where it came from and who built it, the constructs it uses and how each is defined, how a program puts those constructs to work, and the critiques raised against it. You will also meet, in the next section, a name for what goes wrong when a program is built from a theory's constructs without first studying the people it is meant to serve. Before any theory is applied to Priya, it helps to see the five side by side.
4.1 Five Approaches in Two Families
The five theories sort into two families, and Table 3.1 previews them. The first family is the point-in-time theories: the Health Belief Model, the Theory of Reasoned Action, and its revision, the Theory of Planned Behavior. By this we mean that each describes a decision as a single process occurring at one point in time, so the theory asks what a person believes or intends now and predicts whether they will act. The second family is the stage models: the Transtheoretical Model and the Precaution Adoption Process Model. These describe change that takes place in stages over time, so the question they ask is not whether a person will act but where the person is in a process of change. The two families are less rivals than views at different scales. The stage models treat the point-in-time theories as descriptions of what happens within particular stages; for example, the weighing of benefits and barriers that the Health Belief Model describes is the kind of process that goes on while a person is aware of a problem and deciding whether to act.
Table 3.1. The five theories and models in this lesson, with who developed each and when, its central idea, and the family to which it belongs.
| Theory or model | Who and when | Central idea | Family |
|---|---|---|---|
| Health Belief Model | Hochbaum, Rosenstock, and Kegeles, United States Public Health Service, 1950s | A person acts when they feel susceptible to a severe problem, believe the action helps, see few barriers, receive a cue, and feel capable | Point in time (value expectancy) |
| Theory of Reasoned Action | Fishbein, late 1960s, then with Ajzen | Attitude toward a behaviour and subjective norms produce an intention, and intention predicts behaviour | Point in time |
| Theory of Planned Behavior | Ajzen, revising the Theory of Reasoned Action | Adds perceived behavioural control for behaviours a person cannot fully control | Point in time |
| Transtheoretical Model | Prochaska and DiClemente, from research on smokers who were quitting | Change occurs in six stages, each with its own processes and applicable theories | Stage model |
| Precaution Adoption Process Model | Weinstein and Sandman, from home radon testing | Taking a precaution occurs in seven ordered stages, including deciding not to act | Stage model |
Table 3.1 places two of the five among the stage models and the Health Belief Model among the point-in-time theories, although all three names contain the word model. The callout below explains how this lesson uses the words theory and model.
Common confusion: theory or model?
Be careful about the words theory and model. The Transtheoretical Model and the Precaution Adoption Process Model are not theories per se. They are complex descriptions of a process that incorporate various theories as explanations for movement through it, which is why they are called models. The Health Belief Model carries the word model in its name by convention, but it is listed among the individual theories and treated as one: a set of constructs with stated relationships that can be tested.
The two families also suggest a first rule of thumb for choosing between them. A one-off decision, such as whether to walk into a pharmacy for a flu shot today, suits a point-in-time theory, because the question is whether the person will act. A habit a person has been meaning to change for months, such as sleep or alcohol use, suits a stage model, because the useful question becomes where the person is in the process, and the intervention that fits depends on the answer. The final section of the lesson returns to this choice once all five approaches have been described.
This section has argued that the individual theories describe a thought process inside the person and mostly take for granted the social, physical, and cultural environments that supply its material, and that cultures differ in where they draw the line around the individual. It has named the three assumptions the theories share, read Priya's decision through that lens, and previewed the five approaches in two families. The key takeaways and knowledge check that follow review this material, and the next section takes up the first of the theories, the Health Belief Model.
Key Takeaways
- 1.1 The theories in this lesson are called individual theories because they treat the person as the primary source of behaviour and focus on the thought processes that come before a health action. That focus is legitimate, but Sam's story and the saxophone player's riffs show that the material of those thoughts, from body and personality to style and values, was assembled from family, stories, and people we chose to emulate. When a question asks why the theories are "individual", the answer is about where they look, not a claim that context does not matter. A useful habit for any case is to ask where the person's sense of a benefit or a barrier came from.
- 1.2 Louis Dumont contrasted societies constructed of individuals, where the person is the key autonomous unit, with societies understood as the source of individuals, where the person is known through relationships and obligations. The five theories were written in the first kind. Treat the contrast as a spectrum, not a sorting of countries. In a case where a household, an elder, or a community makes the decision, Dumont is the idea to reach for: a program aimed only at the individual may be speaking to the wrong decision-maker, and who decides is something to find out.
- 1.3 All five approaches share three assumptions: behaviour follows a describable thought process, that process is largely rational and cognitive, and the person is the unit of analysis and of intervention. Learn them as a list of three, because every critique in the lesson lands on one of them. When you evaluate a critique on an exam, name the assumption it challenges; for example, a sign on a clinic door that blocks a willing patient challenges the third.
- 1.4 Any health decision can be read as Figure 3.1 draws it: beliefs, attitudes, intentions, and readiness inside the person, fed by social, physical, and cultural environments outside. In Priya's case, her sense of risk and her fear of a week in bed are inside; the free walk-in pharmacy, her friends' stories, and her mother's remark are context. The trap is that many inside beliefs came from outside, so when a question asks you to sort elements, place each by where it now sits and then note where it came from.
- 4.1 The five approaches fall into two families. The Health Belief Model and the Theory of Reasoned Action and its revision, the Theory of Planned Behavior, are point-in-time theories that describe one decision as a single process. The Transtheoretical Model and the Precaution Adoption Process Model are stage models that describe change over time. The stage models are called models because they describe a process and draw on several theories to explain movement through it; do not be misled by the word "model" in the Health Belief Model's name, since it is treated as a theory. As a rule of thumb, a one-off decision suits a point-in-time theory and a long-running habit suits a stage model.
1. Why are the theories in this lesson called individual theories?
2. This lesson compares an individual to a saxophone player praised as unique. What is the point of the comparison?
3. A public health team in Surrey is designing a screening program and learns that in several of the families they serve, decisions about health care are made by the household as a group. Which idea from this section best explains why the team should not assume that persuading the individual patient is enough?
4. Which pairing correctly matches an approach from this lesson with its family?
5. A colleague says: "These individual theories all treat behaviour as the end of a thought process, treat that process as largely rational, and treat the person as the target of the program." Which response is most accurate?
6. A student skips her morning run. Just before, she thought the rain would make it miserable and that missing one run did not matter. She learned that running in rain is unpleasant mostly from friends who never run in it, and her early shift that day was set by her employer. Which statement best sorts these elements?
7. A health promoter is planning two projects: one to get people to accept a one-time free blood pressure check at a community fair, and one to help residents reduce heavy drinking they have been meaning to cut down on for months. Which pairing of project and family of approaches fits the rule of thumb in this section?
✦ Pass the knowledge check with 100% to continue
The Health Belief Model
⏱ Estimated reading time: 16 minutes
Overview
The Health Belief Model comes first for two reasons: it is the oldest of the individual behavioural theories used in public health, and one of the most widely used. It also began with a practical puzzle, which makes its origin a good first lesson in how a theory gets built. This section traces the model from a tuberculosis screening program in the 1950s to its six constructs, then uses a smoking cessation campaign for blues musicians to show what goes wrong when a program is built straight from those constructs. It closes with programs that used the model and two critiques of it.
Learning Objectives
- 2.1 Describe the origin of the Health Belief Model in Hochbaum's research on a free tuberculosis screening program in the 1950s, and how its four original constructs grew to six.
- 2.2 Define the six constructs of the Health Belief Model and explain what it means to call it a value expectancy model.
- 5.1 Explain the EZ program structure illusion and how research with the intended population avoids it.
- 5.2 Assign the components of a health promotion program to the Health Belief Model constructs they are meant to influence.
- 6.1 Evaluate two critiques of the Health Belief Model and the evidence behind them.
2.1 Origins: Free X-rays and Empty Clinics
In the 1950s the United States Public Health Service sponsored free tuberculosis screening by x-ray in mobile clinics placed right in neighbourhoods. Because the screening was free, convenient, and aimed at a feared disease, attendance should have been high. However, very few people came. Godfrey Hochbaum, a social psychologist with the Service, set out to learn why turnout was so low given the easy access, and the larger issue he investigated was motivation: if access was not the problem, something in the way people thought about the screening must be. His initial conclusions were that people were most likely to get an x-ray if they thought they were susceptible to tuberculosis and if they believed there was a benefit in early detection. That pairing, perceived susceptibility and perceived benefits, was the nucleus of the theory, by which we mean the core to which the later constructs were added. Hochbaum, Irwin Rosenstock, and Stephen Kegeles developed it into the Health Belief Model (Rosenstock, 1974).
In its early formulation the model held that health behaviour was motivated by four factors: perceived susceptibility, perceived severity, perceived benefits of an action, and perceived barriers to taking it. These four fall into two pairs. The first two are beliefs about the health problem, that is, whether the person thinks they could get it and how bad it would be. The second two are beliefs about the action, that is, what good the action would do and what it would cost. As the model was applied to treatment adherence, prevention, and screening, two components were added. The first was cues to action, the idea that some event was needed as direct motivation to act, because belief alone did not explain when people acted. The second, added in 1988 under the influence of what was then called Social Learning Theory, was a person's belief in their own ability to take the action, commonly referred to as self-efficacy. The idea came from the psychologist Albert Bandura. Notice how the model began: with a practical question about a program that should have worked and did not, rather than with an abstract idea. The six constructs it produced are best learned together, as one statement about a person.
2.2 Six Constructs, One Statement
Read the six components as parts of a single theoretical statement about a person we will call Jane. Jane will engage in a preventive behaviour given that she thinks she is susceptible to the health problem; she thinks the problem is severe; she thinks taking the action will do some good; she thinks there is not a lot standing in the way; something gives her a push to act; and she believes she is capable of acting. The six cards below give each construct with its definition and an example. Notice which constructs are about the problem and which are about the action.
Perceived
susceptibility
The degree to which a person feels at risk for a health problem. Example: Jane believes she is potentially at risk of the condition the behaviour prevents. In Hochbaum’s screening research, this was the first of the two beliefs that separated people who came for an x-ray from people who stayed home.
Perceived severity
The degree to which a person believes the consequences of the health problem will be severe. Example: Jane believes that if she gets the condition, the consequences will be serious. Severity is about the problem, not about the action; what counts as severe depends on what the person most fears losing.
Perceived benefits
The positive outcomes a person believes will result from the action. Example: Jane thinks that taking the preventive action will do some good. In Hochbaum’s research this was the belief that early detection of tuberculosis had value, the second half of the theory’s nucleus.
Perceived barriers
The negative outcomes a person believes will result from the action: cost, time, discomfort, embarrassment, or loss. Example: Jane thinks there is not a lot standing in the way. The blues musicians later in this section show that a barrier can be a real fact, such as no insurance or a lost gig, that no brochure can remove.
Cues to action
An external event that motivates a person to act. Example: a friend is diagnosed with the disease, Jane sees a television program about it, a reminder letter arrives, or a sign goes up in a pharmacy window. Added to the model after the four original constructs, because belief alone did not explain the timing of action.
Self-efficacy
A person’s belief in their ability to take the action: that they have the skills, the will, and whatever else is necessary. Example: Jane believes she is capable of doing what the behaviour requires. Added in 1988 under the influence of what was then called Social Learning Theory, and the construct that later behavioural theories build on most.
The cards separate two constructs that students often confuse. Perceived severity is about the problem (how bad the disease would be), while perceived barriers are about the action (what it costs to take it). By this we mean that the two constructs point in different directions: severity describes what the person stands to lose by not acting, and barriers describe what the person stands to lose by acting. For example, Jane may believe breast cancer would be devastating (high severity) and still dread the time off work and the discomfort of a screening test (high barriers). Self-efficacy differs from barriers in a similar way. A barrier is something standing in the way, such as cost or distance, while self-efficacy is the person's belief that they can do what the behaviour requires. The difference matters for a program, because lowering a barrier means changing the task or the service, whereas raising self-efficacy means changing the person's confidence in their own ability to carry the task out.
Finally, the Health Belief Model is described as a value expectancy model. By this we mean that it predicts behaviour from two things together: the value a person places on an outcome, and their expectation that a behaviour will produce it. In the model's terms, people will engage in healthy behaviour if they value the outcome related to the behaviour, being healthy, and if they think the behaviour is likely to result in that outcome. Both halves matter, and the absence of either one is enough to predict inaction. For example, a person who values health but doubts that a screening test will change anything is predicted to stay home, and so is a person who trusts the test but does not much value what it protects. The label is therefore a reminder that a program has to address both what people want and whether they believe the action will deliver it.
Return to Priya at the pharmacy door. The model would ask whether she feels susceptible to influenza (young and healthy, so perhaps not), whether she thinks it severe (for her grandmother, yes), whether she believes the vaccine helps, what she counts as barriers (a week in bed, her midterm), what cue is acting on her (the sign, her mother's remark), and whether she feels able to walk in. It has to be told which of these is loudest for Priya. That gap, between the constructs in the abstract and what they mean for real people, is the subject of the next subsection.
5.1 The EZ Program Structure Illusion
To use the model in a program, think of the six constructs as levers, that is, as points where a program can push in order to change behaviour. They provide guidance, but they cannot be used as is. The reason is that a theory is presented in the abstract: it says that perceived barriers matter, for example, but not which barriers matter for a particular group of people. Its constructs therefore need to be shaped by real-world information about the people a program serves before you can use them or know whether they are effective. When a planner skips this step, the mistake has a name, defined in the callout below.
Definition to remember: the EZ program structure illusion
The EZ program structure illusion is the mistake of building a program by plugging a theory's abstract constructs straight into program components, without first researching what those constructs mean for the intended population. The cure is research on the people you are trying to help, and treating the theory as a tool, a guideline, and a framework rather than as the complete story. The warning applies to every theory in this lesson.
Worked Example 3.2 is the case this lesson returns to in every section: a smoking cessation campaign for serious urban blues musicians who smoke heavily. It applies the six constructs twice, first straight from the theory and then after research. As you read, watch which constructs change meaning once the musicians' circumstances are known.
Worked Example 3.2: A Cessation Campaign for Blues Musicians
The case. You want a group of serious urban blues musicians who are heavy smokers to quit, and you build a cessation campaign from the Health Belief Model.
Step 1, the first campaign, built straight from the constructs. Brochures carry clear information on the risks and severity of lung and throat cancer, with graphic pictures: susceptibility and severity covered. Flyers, text messages, and radio spots advertise inexpensive or insured quit programs promising a smoke-free client in a month, with testimonials from happy ex-smokers: barriers and benefits covered. A famous musician has died of cancer, and his widow's words go up in the clubs: a cue to action. A booklet titled One, Two, Three, Quit and free demonstrations by trained quit coaches: self-efficacy.
Step 2, the result and the diagnosis. Three months later, not one musician has quit or even tried, the materials have been tossed, and barely a handful came to the demonstrations. Every construct was addressed and nothing moved. This is the EZ program structure illusion: the constructs were specified from the abstract theory, not from the musicians' lives.
Step 3, the research. Interviews reveal that hardly any of the musicians have insurance, and that a regular gig is so precious that losing a month of playing time could set someone back for many months with the club owners who pay them and the audiences who come to hear them. Time in the clubs shows that smoking is a social ritual, part of how musicians talk, play, and present themselves. The flyers had advertised the risk of participating in a quit program rather than the risk of smoking.
Step 4, the constructs respecified. Table 3.2 sets the two versions side by side, construct by construct.
Table 3.2. The blues musicians' cessation campaign, construct by construct: the first attempt built from the abstract theory, what the interviews revealed, and the revised approach.
| Construct | First attempt (from the abstract theory) | What the interviews revealed | Revised approach |
|---|---|---|---|
| Perceived severity | Cancer and emphysema information with graphic pictures | The most immediate feared loss is a career, not a diagnosis | Themes about losing gigs: "Got throat cancer? Can't get gigs." Charles the blues man, three packs a day, whose only audience is now a couple of nurses |
| Perceived barriers | Programs described as inexpensive or covered by insurance, taking about a month | No insurance; a month away from playing is a real and immediate cost | Modalities a working musician can use, such as the nicotine patch from a local grocery store or pharmacy, which takes no time away from performing |
| Perceived benefits | Testimonials from healthy, smoke-free ex-smokers | Smoking is a social ritual; the smoke-free image feels irrelevant | Benefits tied to voice, stamina on the road, and career longevity |
| Cues to action | A widow's quotes after a famous musician's death | Untested in the story; the cue may have been fine | Keep it, and place it where musicians actually congregate |
The constructs did not change; what they meant for these people did. The most important shift is in severity and barriers, where the research replaced a diagnosis with a career and a month-long program with a patch from the corner pharmacy.
The example showed the illusion and its cure in one case. The first campaign was not lazy: it covered all six constructs. It failed because severity, barriers, and benefits were defined by the planner rather than by the musicians, and only research could supply what each meant for them. The next subsection turns from diagnosing a failed campaign to the first practical step in building a sound one, deciding which construct each program component is meant to move.
5.2 Assigning Program Components to Constructs
The first practical step in using the model is to say which construct each part of a program is meant to influence. Interactive 3.2 mixes ten components from the musicians' campaign and from a Canadian cervix screening program. Click a component, then click the construct you think it is designed to move, and read the feedback, which explains the reasoning and names the research question that remains. Work through all ten components.
📊 Interactive 3.2: Build the campaign.
Click a program component, then the Health Belief Model construct it is designed to move. The feedback explains the reasoning and the research question that remains.Perceived susceptibility
Perceived severity
Perceived benefits
Perceived barriers
Cues to action
Self-efficacy
Sorting the components shows a pattern worth remembering. Some components are messages, and a message works by changing a belief: a severity theme changes what people think the problem would cost them, a reminder prompts people who already lean toward acting, and a testimonial changes what people expect to gain. Other components are changes to the service itself, and these can remove a barrier directly rather than persuading anyone. For example, a patch that needs no program enrolment, or a kit that is returned by mail, makes the action cheaper whether or not anyone's beliefs have changed. The feedback also shows that assigning a component to a construct is only a beginning. Knowing that a reminder letter is meant to act as a cue does not tell you whether this population reads its mail, so whether a lever works for a given group is still an empirical question that research has to answer.
A well-documented example of a program that used the model is a mammography screening intervention in Baltimore, Maryland, where outreach had failed to engage low-income African American women. A culturally targeted intervention based on the Health Belief Model promoted a no-cost mammography program and collected data from women aged 40 and older on their screening history and their knowledge and beliefs about breast cancer. A 50 percent screening rate was achieved among 119 eligible participants, which the authors describe as unprecedented for that population, and the significant predictors of screening were perceived barriers, lack of insurance, and limited knowledge (Garza and colleagues, 2005). Notice which constructs did the work: barriers, and a structural fact, insurance, that the model files under barriers. This is worth pausing on, because the model calls the construct a perceived barrier, which suggests something inside the person's head. Lack of insurance, however, is not a mistaken belief that better information could correct; it is a fact about the woman's circumstances. A barrier is often a fact about the world in this way, and when it is, a program may need to change the service, as the Baltimore program did by offering mammography at no cost, rather than try to change the belief.
Worked Example 3.3 applies that idea in British Columbia, where the cervix screening program addresses barriers through the service itself. It assigns the program's main component to constructs and then asks what the program still needs to learn. Watch for the constructs the kit leaves untouched.
Worked Example 3.3: Cervix Screening You Can Do at Home
The case. British Columbia's cervix screening program offers self-screening: an eligible person can request a kit, collect their own sample at home, and return it by mail to be tested for the types of human papillomavirus (HPV) that cause most cervical cancers. Self-screening was introduced in part because many people due for screening were not attending clinics; the reasons people give include discomfort with the pelvic exam, past trauma, having no regular care provider, distance, and difficulty taking time off work. A regional health authority asks you to raise uptake among people who have never been screened, in two groups: residents of a small community four hours from the nearest clinic, and recent newcomers to Canada in the regional centre.
Step 1, the behaviour and the population. The behaviour is completing a first cervix screen. The population is never-screened people in two settings that differ in distance and in experience of organized screening.
Step 2, what the kit does on its own. The kit is a barrier lever built into the service: it removes the clinic visit, the pelvic exam, the travel, and the time off work at once. It does nothing, by itself, for susceptibility, severity, benefits, or cues, and it creates a new task, collecting the sample correctly, which makes self-efficacy matter.
Step 3, the constructs to target next, by group. For the remote community, where the kit has already removed the largest barrier, the next levers are likely cues to action (a mailed invitation or a phone call when the kit is due) and self-efficacy (a clear demonstration of how to collect the sample). For newcomers, perceived susceptibility and perceived benefits may come first, because some arrive from health systems without organized screening and may not know that a person who feels healthy can carry a persistent HPV infection, or that early detection changes the outcome.
Step 4, the research before any materials. Interviews or focus groups with never-screened people in each group should ask what they believe about cervical cancer, what stops them, and whom they would trust to tell them about a kit. Only that research can confirm which barriers the kit actually removes for them.
Skipping Step 4 would repeat the blues musicians' mistake: a campaign might advertise convenience to people whose real barrier is not knowing the test exists, or distrust of what happens to the sample.
The example showed that the same model points to different constructs for different groups, and that a well-designed service can remove a barrier that no message could. It also showed the model's limit: some of what stops people lies in circumstances the model does not describe. That limit is the first of the critiques.
6.1 Critiques of the Health Belief Model
No theory is without its critique, and the longest-running health behaviour theory has its share. Two are central, and they are different in kind. The first is a critique of what the model leaves out: it focuses on individual decisions and does not address social and environmental factors, so the circumstances that limit what a person can do appear only as beliefs inside that person. The second is a critique of how the model works as a whole: it is not always clear how all six constructs operate together, since research tends to find that only some of them predict behaviour. Each critique is set out below with its evidence.
Critique 1: The model focuses on individual decisions and does not address social and environmental factors
In large measure this is true. The model assumes an internal, rational process in which individuals assess their risk and make a cost-benefit calculation about whether to act. Those calculations contain some social influence, since external rewards such as looking better or avoiding medical costs enter the calculation of benefits. But they may pale beside a social reality that restricts what a person can actually do, no matter what they calculate. Consider the era of Jim Crow segregation laws in the United States: an African American might have calculated that a doctor's visit for nasty stomach pains was a good idea, and felt quite capable of making it, but if the sign on the door read Whites Only, that person was stuck. Every belief the model names pointed toward action, and the action still could not happen, because the obstacle was a law rather than a belief. The model does not place much emphasis on external context of this kind. At most it can record the sign on the door as a perceived barrier, which treats a social structure as though it were one more item in a personal calculation. The Eastern Arctic screening story in the callout below makes the same point from Canadian history.
Critique 2: It is not always clear how all six constructs operate in changing behaviour
This is a comment on how the model has been used in practice and tested in research. Many programs use some constructs and not others, and a fair amount of research finds that one or two constructs carry a specific behaviour change. One meta-analysis of longitudinal studies using the model found that perceived benefits and barriers were the most consistent predictors of later behaviour, while perceived severity and susceptibility were weak predictors, and that cues to action and self-efficacy were less often tested at all (Carpenter, 2010). A study of people at risk of stroke found that the perceived benefits of exercise and self-efficacy for exercise were the factors most related to a person's intention to exercise (Sullivan and colleagues, 2008). The positive side is that specific constructs do seem to have an effect. The negative side is that it is unclear how much such studies test the model as a whole. By this we mean that the model makes a claim about six constructs working together to produce behaviour, but a study that measures only benefits and barriers, or only benefits and self-efficacy, cannot tell us whether the other constructs add anything, or how the six combine. Finding that two pieces predict behaviour is therefore evidence for those pieces rather than for the full statement about Jane. This is a problem that will recur with every theory that has many constructs, because the more constructs a theory names, the harder it becomes to test all of them, and all of their relationships, in a single study.
Canada offers its own example of the first critique. The callout below describes the mass chest x-ray surveys for tuberculosis in the Eastern Arctic, where screening itself could cost a person their family and home.
A Canadian counterpoint: screening that carried its own risk
Canada ran mass chest x-ray surveys for tuberculosis in the same decades. In the Eastern Arctic, screening took place aboard the government supply ship C.D. Howe, and Inuit who tested positive were often taken south to sanatoria with little warning, sometimes for years; some families were never told where relatives who died there were buried. The federal government apologized in 2019. Read through the model's constructs, the barrier to screening in that setting was not inconvenience. Screening itself could cost a person their family and home. A perceived barrier is only as meaningful as the circumstances it refers to, and those are set by history and policy rather than by the person.
The advice is to use theory as appropriate and keep a critical eye on the match between the theory and what you see: find out which constructs matter for these people before building materials, remember that a barrier may be a fact about the world that no message can change, and measure the constructs you claim to be moving, so that a program that fails teaches you why.
This section has traced the Health Belief Model from Hochbaum's tuberculosis screening research to its six constructs, shown through the blues musicians' campaign how a program built from those constructs without research falls into the EZ program structure illusion, assigned program components to constructs, and set out two critiques of the model. The key takeaways and knowledge check that follow review this material, and the next section turns to a second point-in-time theory, the Theory of Reasoned Action and its revision, the Theory of Planned Behavior.
Key Takeaways
- 2.1 The Health Belief Model began with a puzzle: in the 1950s the United States Public Health Service offered free, convenient tuberculosis x-rays in mobile clinics, and very few people came. Godfrey Hochbaum found that people came when they felt susceptible to tuberculosis and believed early detection had a benefit, and that pairing, susceptibility and benefits, became the nucleus of the model he developed with Irwin Rosenstock and Stephen Kegeles. The model then grew: four original constructs (susceptibility, severity, benefits, barriers), then cues to action, then self-efficacy in 1988 under the influence of Social Learning Theory. If a question asks about the order, remember "two at the core, four at first, six in the end".
- 2.2 The six constructs read as one statement about a person: she will act if she feels at risk, thinks the problem is serious, believes the action will help, sees little in the way, gets a push, and believes she can do it. Severity and susceptibility are beliefs about the problem; benefits and barriers are beliefs about the action; a cue is an external event that prompts action; self-efficacy is belief in one's own ability. The model is a value expectancy model, meaning people act when they value the outcome and expect the behaviour to produce it, so both halves are needed. A common trap is to confuse barriers (something in the way) with self-efficacy (confidence in oneself); ask whether the program changes the task or the person's belief in their ability.
- 5.1 The EZ program structure illusion is the mistake of plugging a theory's abstract constructs straight into program components. The blues musicians' campaign covered all six constructs and moved no one, because nobody had learned that the musicians lacked insurance, could not afford a month away from gigs, and smoked as a social ritual. After research, severity became "Got throat cancer? Can't get gigs." and barriers became a patch from the corner pharmacy. When a case describes a well-built campaign that failed, look for missing research on the people served; the cure is always to research first and treat theory as a tool, a guideline, and a framework.
- 5.2 Using the model starts with saying which construct each program component is meant to move: a severity theme, a reminder letter as a cue, a demonstration for self-efficacy, a mail-back kit for barriers. In the Baltimore mammography program the predictors of screening were perceived barriers, lack of insurance, and limited knowledge, and British Columbia's at-home cervix self-screening kit shows that a barrier is often a fact about the world that the service, not a message, has to change. On an exam, name the construct by what the component changes, and remember that an assignment is only the start: which constructs matter for a given group has to be found out.
- 6.1 Two critiques matter. First, the model assumes an internal, rational cost-benefit calculation and says little about the social and environmental context that can block action regardless of belief; the Jim Crow sign on the clinic door and the Eastern Arctic tuberculosis evacuations are the examples. Second, it is unclear how all six constructs operate together: a meta-analysis found benefits and barriers the most consistent predictors of later behaviour, severity and susceptibility weak, and cues and self-efficacy rarely tested. To tell the critiques apart, ask whether the case shows a person who wants to act and cannot (the first) or a study that tests only some constructs (the second).
1. Hochbaum's research on the tuberculosis screening program identified two beliefs that distinguished people who came for an x-ray. Which pair of constructs did those beliefs become?
2. A campus health service posts a sign reading "Flu season starts now. Walk in today." next to a story about a student who was hospitalized with influenza last winter. In Health Belief Model terms, the sign is best described as targeting which construct?
3. In the blues musicians example, why did the first campaign's flyers advertising inexpensive, insured, month-long quit programs fail?
4. A meta-analysis of studies using the Health Belief Model (Carpenter, 2010) supports which of the following statements about the model's constructs?
5. Which situation best illustrates the first critique of the Health Belief Model, that it does not address social and environmental factors?
6. A health unit offers mail-back cervix self-screening kits to residents of a community four hours from the nearest clinic. Which statement best describes what the kit does in Health Belief Model terms?
7. A planner wants to raise cervix screening among recent newcomers and proposes to start designing posters about convenience right away, using the six Health Belief Model constructs as a checklist. Which first step would best protect the program from the EZ program structure illusion?
✦ Pass the knowledge check with 100% to continue
The Theory of Reasoned Action and the Theory of Planned Behavior
⏱ Estimated reading time: 16 minutes
Overview
The second individual theory comes in two versions. The initial version, the Theory of Reasoned Action (TRA), was supplanted by a revised version, the Theory of Planned Behavior (TPB). The revision addressed a key critique of the original, but both are versions of one overall theory, often written as TRA/TPB. Like the Health Belief Model, it assumes a rational, cognitive decision-making process. Unlike it, the theory is organized around a question social psychologists had struggled with for decades: do attitudes predict behaviour? This section follows the theory's answer, from attitudes and subjective norms to intention, then to the perceived behavioural control added by the revision, before applying the constructs to programs and setting out three critiques.
Learning Objectives
- 3.1 Explain the problem of predicting behaviour from attitudes that the Theory of Reasoned Action was built to solve, and why behavioural intention was separated from general attitudes.
- 3.2 Define attitude toward a behaviour and subjective norm, including the two parts of each, and explain how they produce a behavioural intention.
- 3.3 Explain why perceived behavioural control was added to create the Theory of Planned Behavior, and define its two parts, control beliefs and perceived power.
- 5.3 Apply attitude, subjective norm, and perceived behavioural control to a health promotion program and to a vaccination decision.
- 6.2 Evaluate three critiques of the Theory of Reasoned Action and Planned Behavior.
3.1 Do Attitudes Predict Behaviour?
Think about the gap between an attitude you have expressed and what you actually do. If you agree on a survey that honesty is the best policy, will you be honest in every circumstance? Probably not. If a robber asks how much money you have, honesty may not seem the best policy; nor will it if the truth would hurt someone. The issue is predictability. Do attitudes predict behaviour, and in what ways? This is the problem Martin Fishbein took up in the late 1960s, and then, with Icek Ajzen, addressed through the TRA and later the TPB (Ajzen, 1991).
After reviewing previous research, Ajzen and Fishbein concluded that the general construct of attitudes had to be separated from what they called behavioural intentions. By this we mean that a general attitude, such as believing that honesty is good or fearing a disease, is a different thing from a person's readiness to perform one specific behaviour, and the first does not reliably predict the second. There may not always be a link between attitudes and behaviour. However, when the process is looked at more carefully, people move from general attitudes to attitudes about specific behaviours, and to assessments of how others view the behaviour, before they act. These steps culminate in an intention, and intention, according to the theory, is much more predictive of behaviour than attitude alone. The purpose of the separation is to predict behaviour better: if general attitudes are a weak guide to what people do, the theory needs a construct closer to the action, and intention is that construct. The original version of the theory names the two things that produce an intention.
3.2 The Theory of Reasoned Action: Attitude, Subjective Norm, and Intention
In the original formulation, a behavioural intention follows from two things: a person's attitude toward a specific behaviour, and their perception of the subjective norms associated with it. Attitude toward the behaviour is the person's own evaluation of doing it. Subjective norms, by contrast, are perceptions about whether the behaviour would be approved or disapproved by the social groups that influence the person. By this we mean that the norm in this theory is not what a group actually thinks but what the person believes the group thinks. Because it brings other people into the decision, the theory does a little better than the Health Belief Model at accounting for social context, although that context still enters only as a perception inside the person.
An illustration adapted from Montano and Kasprzyk brings back Jane. Jane may have a fearful attitude about breast cancer as a disease. That attitude does not predict what she will do to prevent it, such as getting a mammogram. For that you have to look at her attitude about the mammogram itself and the social consequences she expects. Jane fears breast cancer but is skeptical about the overuse of expensive medical testing, and she believes her equally skeptical friends might ostracize her if she got one. The result is a low behavioural intention, despite her concern about the disease.
Each construct is built from two parts, and the parts matter because a program can work on either one. Attitude toward a behaviour results from a belief about what will happen if the person does it, combined with an assessment of whether that outcome is good or bad. For example, Jane expects the mammogram to mean overused, expensive testing and judges that outcome to be bad, so her attitude toward the mammogram is negative even though she fears the disease. Subjective norm results from beliefs about what people in the social group will think, combined with the person's motivation to conform. The second part is easy to overlook. A person confident of the group's acceptance may not feel much need to take its norms into account, so even a clearly disapproving group exerts little pull on their intention. In other words, a belief that friends would disapprove shapes intention only to the degree that the person cares about what those friends think.
The subjective norm draws on the wider idea of social norms, defined in the callout below.
Definition: social norms
Social norms are customary codes of behaviour in a group or culture, together with the beliefs about what those codes mean. A norm that you do not steal candy from children is both a guide to behaviour and an affirmation of the meaning behind it, that it is wrong to take from those who cannot defend themselves. They are norms because they are generally adhered-to standards about what should be normal. A subjective norm is one person's perception of what their own groups approve.
Attitude and subjective norm explained Jane's low intention well. What they could not explain was a person who intends to act and still does not, and that gap produced the revision.
3.3 The Theory of Planned Behavior: Adding Perceived Behavioural Control
Not long after the TRA was tested in programs, a significant flaw was revealed. Someone could form an intention and still not be able to do the behaviour, because factors outside their cognitive process, and outside their control, prevented them. Suppose Jane has a favourable attitude toward the mammogram and will not be swayed by her friends. She also works on a small farm; the nearest clinic is hours away by bus because her car is not running; and if she leaves for a few hours, tasks will go undone that could cost her the milk shipment. She intends to go and does not feel that she can. Intention alone is not a sufficient predictor.
The element added to address such situations is perceived behavioural control: the degree to which someone believes they have control over whether they can take the action, and the strength of that belief. By this we mean the person's own judgment of whether the behaviour is within their power, which may or may not match the facts. The construct is separated into two parts. Control beliefs are beliefs about factors that will make the behaviour easy or difficult. For example, if Jane thinks it would be easy to get a ride, that is a facilitating control belief, and if she thinks she could not get one, it is a constraining control belief. Perceived power is the power of those control beliefs, that is, how much weight each one carries in her decision. If a ride is the only possible way to the facility, her belief about the ride carries a great deal of weight; if there are other ways to get there, the same belief matters less. The labels are confusing, so here is a commonsense summary. If Jane has a positive attitude toward the mammogram, if her friends approve or she does not much care what they think, and if she thinks she can get a ride or, failing that, take the bus or a bike, then the likelihood is high that she will go.
Figure 3.2 draws the constructs of both versions of the theory and the paths that connect them to intention and action, with the constructs of the Theory of Reasoned Action in teal and the additions made by the Theory of Planned Behavior in red.
Figure 3.2. The constructs of the theory and how they connect. Intention is most predictive of behaviour; perceived behavioural control feeds intention and bears on behaviour directly.
Figure 3.2 shows the full chain: behavioural, normative, and control beliefs feed attitude, subjective norm, and perceived behavioural control; those three produce an intention; and intention predicts the behaviour, with perceived control also bearing on the behaviour directly. The three tabs below gather all three constructs in one place. Open each tab to see the construct's two parts, how it applies to Jane, and the program lever that follows from it.
Attitude toward the behaviour
Two parts: beliefs about what will happen if the person performs the behaviour, and a judgment of whether that outcome is good or bad. Jane: she expects the mammogram to be overused, expensive testing and regards that as bad, so her attitude toward the behaviour is negative even though she fears breast cancer. Program lever: materials that feed accurate, valued beliefs about the outcomes of the specific behaviour.
Subjective norm
Two parts: beliefs about what people in the person's social group will think of the behaviour, and the person's motivation to conform. Jane: she believes her skeptical friends would disapprove, and she cares; if she cared less, the same belief would matter less. Program lever: work on the group rather than the person, after first finding out which group is the reference group. For the musicians, is it fellow players or family, or both?
Perceived behavioural control
Two parts: control beliefs about the factors that make the behaviour easy or difficult, and perceived power, the weight those factors carry. Jane: a belief that she could get a ride is facilitating, a belief that she could not is constraining, and if a ride is the only route, that belief decides the matter. Program lever: change the constraining facts and make sure people know they changed.
The tabs make one difference clear: attitude and subjective norm are about whether a person wants to act, while perceived behavioural control is about whether they believe they can. Both kinds of construct feed the same intention, but they fail in different ways. Jane with skeptical friends does not want to go, so her problem lies in attitude and norm, and a program would work on her beliefs about the test and about her friends. Jane on the farm wants to go and doubts that she can, so her problem lies in control, and no amount of persuasion about the benefits of mammography will get her to the clinic until the ride is sorted out. Interactive 3.3 lets you see the chain at work. Set the three constructs with the sliders, or load one of the four scenarios from this section's account of Jane, and watch the two gauges, one for behavioural intention and one for the likelihood of the behaviour. Then move the two sliders below the dashed line, actual control and the days until the appointment, which come from the critiques in 6.2.
📊 Interactive 3.3: The intention calculator.
Set Jane's constructs for getting a mammogram, or load a scenario from this section. The gauges are a teaching simplification.What the theory predicts
The calculator is a teaching simplification, but its scenarios repeat the section's argument: Jane with skeptical friends has low intention, Jane on the farm has intention without control, and Jane with a ride is likely to go. With the three constructs defined, the next step is to put them to work in a program.
5.3 Using the Theory in a Program
To use the theory in a program, again think of the constructs as levers that must be in place, and again remember that they are not sufficient in themselves; every term must be specified for the group in focus. Set out to help the blues musicians quit using the three constructs straight from the theory, and you are shooting in the dark. You do not know what norms influence a musician's intention to quit, which social group matters most, or what factors shape a musician's sense of control over quitting.
With the research from Worked Example 3.2, a program takes shape. Brochures feed positive beliefs about the outcomes of quitting: better health, a stronger singing voice, and the stamina to withstand the road (attitude). Group sessions near the blues clubs work on the norms of fellow musicians, the key social group, so that a musician considering quitting can factor positive norms into their intention (subjective norm). And the program removes constraining factors: the union expands insurance coverage and musicians hear about it, and club owners promise never to drop a performer who takes time off to quit, in exchange for free advertising (perceived behavioural control). Each component targets a construct, and each is built from what the interviews revealed. The first task is always to find out which reference group matters.
One example of a program that used the theory is a school study of physical activity: 366 high school students, divided into intervention and control groups, with a 12-week intervention of posters and lectures (Tsorbatzoudis, 2005). It improved attitudes toward physical activity, perceived behavioural control, intention, and self-reported behaviour, but was less effective in other respects. For Priya, the theory would look past her general worry about influenza to her attitude toward this shot (a week unwell against her grandmother's protection), the norm she perceives (friends against, mother mildly for), and her control (she is at the door, so high). Because her control is already high, the theory directs attention to the other two constructs, and in particular to the norm. Her friends and her mother pull in opposite directions, and the theory says that each group's opinion matters only to the extent that Priya is motivated to conform to it. Her decision therefore turns on which reference group carries more weight for her: if she cares most about her friends' view, her intention is likely to stay low, whereas if her family's shared concern for her grandmother counts for more, her intention is likely to rise.
Worked Example 3.4 applies all three constructs, each in its two parts, to a parent deciding whether to sign a school consent form for the HPV vaccine. Watch for the competing reference groups and for the difference between the parent's general attitude and his attitude toward the specific behaviour.
Worked Example 3.4: The Grade 6 Consent Form
The case. School-based immunization programs in British Columbia offer the HPV vaccine to students in grade 6, and a consent form goes home with each child. Daniel's daughter brings hers home on a Monday. Daniel believes vaccines prevent cancer and wants his daughter protected, but a parents' group he follows online has been sharing stories about side effects, and he is unsure. His mother, who lives with them, says the vaccine is unnecessary at that age. Two parents he trusts at the school have signed. The form is due Friday, his daughter is frightened of needles, and the clinic runs during school hours, so he will not be present.
Step 1, the behaviour. The behaviour is specific: signing and returning this consent form by Friday. Daniel's general attitude (vaccines prevent cancer) is not yet his attitude toward this behaviour.
Step 2, attitude toward the behaviour. His belief about the outcome is mixed: protection against cancer, but possibly side effects, as the online group claims. His evaluation is that protection is good and the feared side effects are bad. The balance of the two parts sets his attitude toward signing.
Step 3, subjective norm. At least three reference groups pull in different directions: the online parents' group and his mother disapprove, and the two trusted parents at the school have signed. The second part, his motivation to conform to each, decides which group counts, and that is an empirical question a program should find out rather than assume.
Step 4, perceived behavioural control. His control beliefs include that he cannot attend the clinic, that his daughter fears needles, and that the form is due Friday. Perceived power is the weight of each; if the needle fear is the decisive obstacle, that belief weighs most.
Step 5, what a program could do. To address control, offer a nurse to talk with the child about needles or let a parent attend. To address the norm, make visible how many parents at the school have signed, since a perceived majority shifts the subjective norm. To find the reference group that matters, ask parents like Daniel whose opinion they weigh.
The common mistake is to treat Daniel's support for vaccines in general as a high intention to sign. The theory predicts from the attitude toward the specific behaviour, the norm, and control, and here all three are uncertain.
The example showed that the theory's power lies in separating the pieces: a parent who supports vaccines can still have a weak intention to sign this form this week. It also left a question hanging. Daniel's intention on Monday may not be his intention on Friday, and the theory does not say how long an intention lasts. That is one of three critiques.
6.2 Critiques of the Theory of Reasoned Action and Planned Behavior
Three critiques are commonly raised against the TRA and TPB. The first concerns the assumption of rational, linear decision-making; the second, the clarity of the constructs, especially perceived behavioural control and subjective norms; and the third, the time between intention and action. Each critique is set out below with its examples.
Critique 1: The theory assumes rational, linear decision-making
Like the Health Belief Model, the theory assumes that behaviour is the output of a rational, linear process. Rational does not mean correct by some objective standard. A person can reason carefully from beliefs that are mistaken and still be acting rationally in the theory's sense. What the word does imply is a certain kind of thinking in a mechanistic order: beliefs first, then attitude, norm, and control, then intention, then behaviour. Do people actually go through such processes? Much everyday behaviour seems to bypass that sequence. A person may reach for a cigarette out of habit, skip a screening test out of fear, or act on gut instinct without ever forming anything that resembles an intention. In addition to these, factors such as gender, culture, education, and income shape what people do. Some of these could be subsumed under attitudes, norms, or control factors; for example, income could be treated as one of the control beliefs that make a behaviour hard. But if so, the theory begins to lose its usefulness, because it now tells us only that something about attitudes, norms, or control matters. What does it offer beyond some very general ways to think, if everything of importance has to be filled in for each group?
Critique 2: The constructs are not clear
Perceived behavioural control is a very unclear construct, and so is its relationship to the actual control a person has. Because this is a theory about attitudes and intentions rather than social conditions, the construct is a perception, which may have little to do with a person's ability to exercise control. By this we mean that two people facing the same bus schedule and the same broken car could report very different levels of control, and the theory measures the report rather than the schedule. So many things go into beliefs about control that the construct is hard to assess, and its difference from self-efficacy, a person's belief in their own ability to act, is hard to define. Personality and culture complicate it further. What if a person has low self-esteem and discounts their control regardless of the facts? What if fatalism is common in their culture, so that Jane feels fate decides whether she gets breast cancer and whether a mammogram would make any difference? In each case a low score on perceived control would mean something quite different, and a program would need to respond differently. The same problems attach to subjective norms (Armitage and Conner, 2001). A person belongs to many groups at once, so there are religious, peer, workplace, and parental norms. Which of these matter for a given behaviour? Jane may know that religious relatives would object to a behaviour, but if they will never even know about it, their disapproval may carry little weight. And if she does not much care what others think, the norm may barely enter her intention at all. The theory names the construct but leaves all of these questions to be answered by research on the people in question.
Critique 3: Time between intention and action is not considered
Suppose someone has an intention and perceived control. How long is that good for as a predictor? Interview Jane on a Monday, find both high, and suppose her mammogram is three weeks away. Will the likelihood of her going be the same as with a same-day appointment? Common sense says probably not, because a great deal can happen in three weeks: her friends may raise their doubts again, the farm may get busy, or her resolve may simply fade. The theory, however, has nothing to say about the gap. It treats the intention measured on Monday as the predictor, as though the decision were made once and then held constant until the moment of action. The stage models in the next section are, in part, an answer to this problem, because they treat time and readiness as central rather than assuming them away.
Each critique points to something a program can do. The first warns that emotion, habit, and demographics must be studied rather than assumed away. The second asks a program to specify which norms and which control factors it means. The third suggests shortening the gap between intention and action: in Daniel's case, collecting forms the next morning or allowing online consent. The third critique also opens the door to the stage models of the next section, which treat time and readiness as central.
This section has followed the theory from the question of whether attitudes predict behaviour, through the attitude, subjective norm, and intention of the Theory of Reasoned Action, to the perceived behavioural control added by the Theory of Planned Behavior, and has applied its constructs to the blues musicians, to Priya, and to Daniel's consent form. The key takeaways and knowledge check that follow review this material, and the next section turns to the stage models.
Key Takeaways
- 3.1 The theory grew from a long-standing puzzle: attitudes often fail to predict behaviour, as anyone who believes honesty is the best policy but lies to a robber knows. Fishbein and Ajzen's answer was to separate general attitudes from behavioural intentions. People move from general attitudes to an attitude toward a specific behaviour and a reading of how others view it, and the resulting intention predicts behaviour far better than attitude alone. When a case shows someone with a strong general attitude who does not act, the first thing to check is whether their attitude toward the specific behaviour, and their intention, match it.
- 3.2 Each construct of the Theory of Reasoned Action has two parts. Attitude toward a behaviour is a belief about what will happen if the person does it, combined with a judgment of whether that outcome is good or bad. Subjective norm is a belief about what the social group thinks, combined with the person's motivation to conform. Jane fears breast cancer and still has a low intention to get a mammogram because her attitude toward the test and her friends' expected disapproval are against it. A frequent exam trap is a person who knows the group disapproves but does not care: that is low motivation to conform, the second part of subjective norm.
- 3.3 The Theory of Planned Behavior added perceived behavioural control after programs found that people could intend a behaviour and still be prevented from doing it, like Jane on the farm with a broken car. Its two parts are control beliefs, about factors that make the behaviour easy (facilitating) or hard (constraining), and perceived power, the weight those beliefs carry. In Figure 3.2, control feeds intention and also bears on the behaviour directly. To keep the constructs apart, ask whether a detail is about wanting to act (attitude, norm) or about believing one can (control).
- 5.3 Using the theory means specifying attitude, norm, and control for a particular group. For the blues musicians that meant materials tying quitting to voice and stamina (attitude), group sessions near the clubs (norm), and union insurance plus club owners' promises (control). For Daniel's consent form it means separating his general support for vaccines from his attitude toward signing this week, naming competing reference groups, and finding his decisive control belief. The first task is always to find out which reference group matters; when answering a case, name the construct, its part, and the program component that fits.
- 6.2 Three critiques: the theory assumes rational, linear decision-making and leaves emotion, habit, gut instinct, and demographics to be filled in, which raises the question of what it adds; its constructs are unclear, since perceived behavioural control may differ from actual control, is hard to separate from self-efficacy, and can be distorted by low self-esteem or fatalism, while subjective norms raise the question of which norms count; and it says nothing about the time between intention and action. Match a case to a critique by its key detail: an appointment weeks away points to time, a confusion over which group matters points to clarity, and a decision made on impulse points to rationality.
1. Jane is frightened of breast cancer, yet the Theory of Reasoned Action predicts a low intention to get a mammogram. Which explanation is consistent with the theory?
2. What flaw in the Theory of Reasoned Action led to the addition of perceived behavioural control?
3. A program persuades club owners to promise that they will never drop a performer who takes a short time off for a smoking cessation program, and makes sure musicians hear about the promise. Which construct is the program targeting?
4. A researcher measures a group's intention to attend a screening appointment three weeks away and finds it high, but attendance turns out to be low. Which critique of the theory does this illustrate most directly?
5. A person who feels very confident of their acceptance by a social group may not feel much need to take that group's norms into account. Which part of which construct does this describe?
6. A survey finds that most adults agree "regular exercise is important for health", yet few of them exercise regularly. According to Fishbein and Ajzen, what is the best explanation?
7. Daniel must return his daughter's grade 6 HPV vaccine consent form by Friday. He cannot attend the school clinic, and his daughter is frightened of needles; he thinks the needle fear is the obstacle that will decide whether she gets the shot. In Theory of Planned Behavior terms, how are these facts best described?
8. In Daniel's case, a parents' group he follows online and his mother disapprove of the HPV vaccine, while two parents he trusts at the school have signed. What should a school immunization program do first, according to the theory?
✦ Pass the knowledge check with 100% to continue
Stage Models: The Transtheoretical Model and the Precaution Adoption Process Model
⏱ Estimated reading time: 16 minutes
Overview
This section discusses the Transtheoretical Model (TTM) and the Precaution Adoption Process Model (PAPM) together because they represent one basic approach, change occurring in stages over time. It begins with the difference between point-in-time theories and stage models, describes the six stages of the TTM with its processes of change and the seven stages of the PAPM, and sets out the three requirements for using either model in a program. It closes with two critiques of stage models and with the question that runs through the whole lesson: which of the five approaches best fits a given problem.
Learning Objectives
- 4.2 Explain what is meant by point-in-time theories, and why Prochaska and DiClemente's research on smokers led to a stage approach.
- 4.3 Name and define the six stages of the Transtheoretical Model, explain what makes it transtheoretical, and describe how processes of change move people between stages.
- 4.4 Name the seven stages of the Precaution Adoption Process Model and state how they differ from the stages of the Transtheoretical Model.
- 5.4 Describe the three requirements for using a stage model in a program, and apply them by assigning stages and matching interventions to a target group.
- 6.3 Evaluate two critiques of stage models.
- 6.4 Judge which individual theory or stage model best fits a given behaviour, population, and spread of readiness.
4.2 Point-in-Time Theories and Many Little Decisions
The other individual theories in this lesson are point-in-time theories. By this we mean that they treat the attitudes, beliefs, and decision about a behaviour as a single process that happens once. For example, the question of whether Jane will get a mammogram is answered by checking her beliefs at one moment: if she feels susceptible, if the risk seems severe, and if the barriers are low, she does it or she does not, and the theory is done. A number of researchers began to question that structure. James Prochaska and Carlo DiClemente studied change processes among people who were quitting smoking and found a dimension missing from other theories: change takes place in stages, over time (Prochaska and DiClemente, 1983). In other words, people do not go through one process of decision but many, and each of those smaller decisions belongs to one part of a continuum of change. The difference matters because a point-in-time theory asks whether a person will act, while a stage approach asks where the person is in a longer process, and the answer to that second question shapes what kind of help they need.
Consider Jane, whose car was not running in the last section, buying a new one over the course of a week. The account below follows her through five moments. Read each day in order and notice the stage it represents.
Monday: the old car
Jane looks at her car and asks what she is going to do. She phones repair shops, hears that the fix will cost about 800 dollars, sighs, and books an appointment. Stage: trying to make the old car run, and coming to appreciate the size of the problem.
Tuesday: the newspaper on the floor
A tow to the garage will cost another 150 dollars. Head in her hands, she sees a newspaper on the floor with a bright clearance-sale advertisement from a car dealer. A new car? She had not thought of it. She does not call the tow truck back. Stage: first entertaining a novel idea.
Friday: savings and phone calls
Having skipped the repair appointment, Jane thinks for a few days, looks at her savings, calls the dealer about prices, asks them to hold two wagons, and arranges a ride from her friend Ben. Stage: preparation, investigating finances and options, then setting up the visit.
Saturday morning: the test drive
At the lot she opens and shuts a door, hears the dense click, and takes the grey wagon out. Firm seats, a crisp surge from a stop. Stage: trying the new behaviour, and finding it very good.
Saturday afternoon: the papers
Jane signs a great many papers and drives home in her first new car in years. Stage: action completed. Keeping up the payments is what the health models call maintenance.
Her decision was many processes, not one: appreciating the problem, entertaining a new idea, preparing, trying, and acting, with keeping up the payments still to come. Each of those moments involved a different question for Jane, and something different was needed to move her on: a repair quote made the problem clear, an advertisement introduced a new idea, and a phone call to Ben made the visit possible. A note on vocabulary follows from this. Neither the TTM nor the PAPM is a theory per se. By this we mean that they do not propose one set of constructs that explains behaviour throughout; instead, they describe the sequence of a change process and borrow various theories to explain how people move from one part of it to the next. In this sense they are models, maps of a process into which theories are fitted. The first of them gives those moments names.
4.3 The Transtheoretical Model
Prochaska and DiClemente reasoned that changing behaviour is often like the car scenario: at each stage something different is going on, so different theories apply at different stages. For example, where a person is aware of a problem and deciding about action, the Health Belief Model or the Theory of Planned Behavior may apply, because weighing beliefs and forming an intention is what those theories describe. However, where the person does not know there is a problem, it first has to get on their agenda, and other theories describe how people become aware. Because describing change from start to finish requires many theories, the model was called transtheoretical, meaning that it draws on several theories rather than being a single one; it is also called stages of change for short. A person may enter the process at any stage. The six stages are precontemplation, contemplation, preparation, action, maintenance, and termination. The six cards below give the definition of each stage and the kind of program that fits it.
Precontemplation
A person does not intend to take action. This may be because they do not know there is a problem with what they are doing (say, eating high-fat food and not exercising), or because they are not interested or motivated to change for other reasons. Program fit: consciousness raising and education about the problem itself.
Contemplation
A person is thinking about changing sometime in the future (say, within six months) and is weighing the pros and cons. This can take time, and people here are not yet ready to act. The weighing is called the decisional balance, and it determines whether the person keeps moving toward change. Program fit: helping the balance tip.
Preparation
A person is ready to do something. They intend to act soon (the intention construct from the Theory of Planned Behavior reappears here) and have some kind of plan or idea about what they want to do. Program fit: programs that provide action steps, such as a weight loss, fitness, or stress reduction program.
Action
A person has recently taken action toward change. Not every action counts: only those known to be steps that prevent or reduce the risks for the health problem being addressed. Program fit: support for the new behaviour and substitutes for the old one.
Maintenance
A person has made a significant change and is focused on keeping it going and not slipping back. This often takes serious work: for a smoker who has quit, the hardest task for a good long while is to withstand the strong temptation to smoke again. Here people are developing self-efficacy for the specific change. Most people who change stay somewhere in this stage.
Termination
A person has truly completed the change. This is the smoker who has got past any further temptation, for whom smoking is no longer part of their behaviour at all, as if they had never smoked. Reaching this stage is not typical. When a person reaches it, they have self-efficacy.
Three details on the cards are easy to miss. In contemplation, the weighing of pros and cons is called the decisional balance, and it determines whether the person keeps moving toward change. In action, only actions known to reduce the risk count. And self-efficacy runs through the later stages: in maintenance people are developing self-efficacy for the specific change, and in termination, which few people reach, they have it. Most people who change stay somewhere in maintenance.
Through all six stages, processes of change move people from one stage to the next. By this we mean whatever carries a person forward, whether a change in how they think or a change in what they do. Because the processes describe what produces movement, they also serve as guides for interventions: a program chooses the process that fits the stage people are in. The list is long, so two processes will serve as examples, and they are worth comparing because they work in different ways. Environmental reevaluation is a cognitive process in which a person considers how their behaviour affects others. For example, a mother who smokes hears about secondhand smoke and thinks of her children. Counter-conditioning, in contrast, is a learned stimulus-response process in which a substitute behaviour counters the impulse toward the old one, such as exercising instead of smoking. The first changes how a person thinks about the behaviour, while the second changes what the person does when the urge arrives, which is why the first suits people who have not yet acted and the second suits people who already have.
Interactive 3.4 gives you practice in assigning stages. It holds eight statements from quitline callers. Click a statement, then the Transtheoretical Model stage it belongs to, and read the feedback, which adds a process of change for that caller and the matching stage of the Precaution Adoption Process Model, the second stage model, described in 4.4.
📊 Interactive 3.4: The stage matcher.
Each statement comes from a quitline caller. Click a statement, then the Transtheoretical Model stage it belongs to. The feedback adds the matching Precaution Adoption Process Model stage and a process of change.Precontemplation
Contemplation
Preparation
Action
Maintenance
Termination
The matcher shows that a single sentence from a caller is usually enough to place them: no intention, weighing, a plan, a recent change, effort to keep it, or no temptation left. It also shows the PAPM sorting some callers differently, which is where the next subsection begins.
4.4 The Precaution Adoption Process Model
The PAPM applies the same idea to a general category of behaviour: taking a precaution against something, such as installing smoke detectors. Neil Weinstein and Peter Sandman developed it to understand people's willingness or unwillingness to test their homes for radon, a naturally occurring radioactive gas (Weinstein and Sandman, 1992). Like Prochaska and DiClemente, they found that existing theories did not adequately represent how people react to hazards. Drawing on the TTM, they defined seven stages: unaware of the issue, unengaged by the issue, deciding about acting, deciding not to act, deciding to act, acting, and maintenance. Table 3.3 sets them beside the six stages of the TTM.
Table 3.3. The six stages of the Transtheoretical Model beside the seven stages of the Precaution Adoption Process Model, and what the PAPM changes.
| Transtheoretical Model | Precaution Adoption Process Model | What the PAPM changes |
|---|---|---|
| Stage 1: Precontemplation | Stage 1: Unaware of the issue | Splits precontemplation. People who have never heard of the problem need information. |
| Stage 2: Unengaged by the issue | People who know but are not engaged enough to act need a different intervention. | |
| Stage 2: Contemplation | Stage 3: Deciding about acting | Resembles intention forming, but the model also accounts for deciding against acting. |
| Stage 4: Deciding not to act | No counterpart in the TTM. It takes people out of the loop. | |
| Stage 3: Preparation | Stage 5: Deciding to act | The decision to act, which is not the same as acting. |
| Stage 4: Action | Stage 6: Acting | Taking the action for the first time. |
| Stage 5: Maintenance | Stage 7: Maintenance | Adopted from the TTM, but continued effort is not separated from a post-temptation termination stage. |
| Stage 6: Termination |
Table 3.3 shows four changes. First, the PAPM splits the TTM's precontemplation into unaware (people who have never heard of the problem) and unengaged (people who know but are not engaged enough to act), because the two need different interventions. Someone who has never heard of radon needs to be told what it is, whereas someone who has heard of it but thinks it has nothing to do with their own house needs the hazard made personal. Second, it adds deciding not to act, a stage with no counterpart in the TTM. This stage takes people out of the loop: a person who has considered the precaution and rejected it is no longer moving toward action, and they are not the same as someone who has simply never thought about it, so a program has to reopen a decision rather than start one. Third, it separates deciding to act from acting, since a decision is not yet an action; a homeowner who has decided to test but has not ordered a kit needs help with the doing, not more reasons. Finally, it does not separate maintenance from a termination stage, so continued effort and the end of temptation fall within the same final stage.
As in the TTM, many processes move people between stages in the PAPM, and some of them involve beliefs about benefits and costs, social norms, and confidence or skills. These are the material of the nonstage theories, which shows how the stage models incorporate the point-in-time theories rather than replace them. Weinstein and Sandman stress that the variables important at one stage are not necessarily those that matter at another. For example, information about a hazard may matter a great deal to someone who is unaware of it and very little to someone who has already decided to act, as Worked Example 3.5 shows. The PAPM also states explicitly that the stages occur in order. This is a stronger claim than the TTM makes, although order is inherent in the TTM as well, and it is the claim that the first critique of stage models in 6.3 questions.
The PAPM was built around home radon testing, and radon is a hazard in Canadian homes too. Worked Example 3.5 assigns PAPM stages to groups of Canadian homeowners and matches an intervention to each. Watch how the split between unaware and unengaged, and between deciding to act and acting, changes what each group receives.
Worked Example 3.5: Radon Testing in the BC Interior
The case. Health Canada's guideline sets 200 becquerels per cubic metre as the level above which a home should be remediated, and testing means leaving a low-cost detector in place for several months, usually over winter (Health Canada). Each November a national campaign promotes testing. A health authority in the BC Interior, where levels above the guideline are common, surveys homeowners and finds three groups: some have never heard of radon; some have heard about it in the news but have never thought of it as something to do with their own house; and some have decided to test but have not ordered a kit.
Step 1, the behaviour and the population. The behaviour is testing one's home for radon. The population is homeowners in a high-radon region, spread across stages.
Step 2, assign each group a PAPM stage. Those who have never heard of radon are in stage 1, unaware of the issue. Those who have heard but never connected it to their house are in stage 2, unengaged by the issue. Those who have decided but not ordered a kit are in stage 5, deciding to act.
Step 3, match an intervention to each stage. Stage 1 needs basic information and consciousness raising about what radon is and why it matters. Stage 2 needs the issue made personal, for instance local risk information showing that homes like theirs often exceed the guideline. Stage 5 needs a low-effort route to action, such as a free or discounted kit with simple instructions and a return envelope; more risk information would not help this group.
Step 4, why the PAPM rather than the TTM. The TTM would place the first two groups together in precontemplation and would not separate deciding to act from acting, so it would point to the same intervention for people who need different ones.
Most Canadians who have never tested are unaware or unengaged, and the model predicts that a risk message moves the undecided while a how-to message moves those who have decided. The home radon study described in 5.4 tested that prediction.
The example showed the practical payoff of finer stages: three groups, three interventions, where a coarser model would have offered one. Doing this well in a real program depends on three requirements, which the next subsection sets out.
5.4 Using Stage Models in a Program
Using stage models can be a little complex, because the aim is not simply to produce a behaviour but to move a target group from one stage to another, and that requires three things. The first requirement is to assess what stage the group is in, using a measure that fits the behaviour. The measure has to fit because the stages of smoking cessation look different from those of changing diet. People in a group will also differ in stage, so you may need more than one intervention, or you may decide to focus on the subset at highest risk. The second requirement is to draw on the processes of change relevant to that stage. For example, if most people are unaware of a problem, consciousness raising about the problem itself is appropriate, whereas a program of action steps would come too early. The third requirement is to have criteria for judging whether the group moved. By this we mean measuring movement to the next stage rather than only counting the final behaviour, since a program for people who were unaware can succeed by making them aware even if nobody has yet acted. As for every theory, research is what connects the abstract model to actual people.
Three requirements: assess, match, measure
Assess the stage of the target group with a measure that fits the behaviour. Match the intervention to the processes of change relevant to that stage. Measure whether the group moved to the next stage. For a group that is unaware or unengaged, success means reassessed stage (have they heard of the problem, do they now see it as relevant, have they decided), not yet the number of people who acted.
Return one last time to the blues musicians and choose the PAPM, because it separates unaware from unengaged. Suppose surveys find that half the musicians know the cancer risks but are unengaged, and half are deciding about acting, between the TTM's contemplation and preparation. Two interventions are needed. For the first group the task is to make the issue matter: tie cancer risk to singing, career longevity, and getting an audience; reduce barriers through unions and club owners; and put materials where musicians congregate. Then measure engagement before and after. For the second group the task is to make action easy: quit groups at music stores, made up of musicians so that social pressure runs the other way. Then assess whether they moved to action.
Three program examples follow the same logic. A community-wide Imagine Action campaign enrolled volunteers in a six-week physical activity program, with one registration question to assess stage; afterwards, 62 percent of those who began in contemplation and 61 percent who began in preparation had become more active (Marcus and colleagues, 1992). A 14-week nutrition intervention for undergraduates, with 11 lessons sequenced to TTM stages and processes, reduced dietary fat intake and held the change at one year, most strongly for students who began in pre-action stages; students without the intervention did not sustain their reductions (Finckenor and Byrd-Bredbenner, 2000). And the home radon study confirmed that barriers change by stage: risk information moved undecided homeowners to decide to test, and a low-effort how-to-test intervention moved those who had decided to order a kit (Weinstein and colleagues, 1998). The radon result is the clearest illustration of the matching requirement. The same piece of information was useful at one stage and of little use at the next, so a program that sent risk information to everyone would have helped the undecided while leaving those who had already decided exactly where they were.
Priya, one last time. A stage model asks where she is rather than whether she will act, and the answer changes what would help her. She began the autumn in precontemplation, with no intention of getting a flu shot. The sign and her mother's remark moved her to contemplation, and at the door she is weighing a week of feeling unwell against her grandmother's heart. Because she is weighing rather than planning, more information about where to get the shot would come too early. What she needs first is for the decisional balance to tip, for example through a clearer sense that the shot protects her grandmother. Once it tips, she needs an easy action, and here the setting already helps her: there is no appointment to book, and the pharmacy is on her way.
Worked Example 3.6 applies the first two requirements, assessing stage and choosing a process of change, to four callers to British Columbia's QuitNow service. Watch the fourth caller, whose story does not fit a straight line.
Worked Example 3.6: A Quitline That Meets Callers Where They Are
The case. British Columbia's QuitNow service offers free coaching by phone, text, and online, and the province's Smoking Cessation Program covers nicotine replacement products through pharmacies. A coach takes four calls. The first caller's partner made her phone; she says she is fine as she is. The second has been putting it off for two years and wants to know what withdrawal feels like. The third quit three days ago and is calling from the parking lot outside a bar. The fourth quit last spring, relapsed at a funeral, has been smoking for a month, and wants to try again.
Step 1, assess each caller's TTM stage. The first caller has no intention to act: precontemplation. The second is thinking about changing and weighing it without a plan: contemplation. The third has recently stopped: action. The fourth has relapsed and wants to quit again, so this caller has re-entered the process at contemplation, or at preparation if they already have a quit plan, rather than back at precontemplation.
Step 2, match a process of change to each stage. For the first caller, consciousness raising and environmental reevaluation, connecting smoking to the partner who made her call. For the second, work on the decisional balance, including honest information about withdrawal, the cost this caller is worried about. For the third, counter-conditioning and support: a substitute for the cigarette at the moment of craving, and help avoiding the bar for now. For the fourth, action planning that draws on what worked last spring, with relapse prevention for the next funeral or crisis.
Step 3, what the fourth caller reveals. The caller moved forward, fell back, and is moving forward again, from a point further along than where they began: they already know they can quit. Stages do not always run in a straight line, which is the first critique of stage models in 6.3.
The common mistake is to place a relapsed caller back at the start. Someone who wants to try again is not in precontemplation, and treating them as if they were would waste the coach's call on information he already has.
The example showed that a coach who assesses stage first can offer four callers four different things in one afternoon. It also showed the two places where stage models strain: a person who cycles back, and a boundary, contemplation or preparation, that is hard to call. Those are the two critiques.
6.3 Critiques of Stage Models
Stage models face two critiques. The first concerns whether people pass through the stages in order, and the second how a person's stage is measured. Figure 3.3 draws the six stages of the Transtheoretical Model as a cycle with paths for relapse, following the story of Fred in the first critique. Study the figure, then read the two critiques below it.
Figure 3.3. The six stages of the Transtheoretical Model drawn as a cycle, from precontemplation through contemplation, preparation, action, and maintenance to termination, with dashed arrows for relapse that send a person from action or maintenance back to contemplation, further along than the start.
Critique 1: People do not go through a fixed set of stages in a straight line
Both models propose an ordered sequence, but people often go in circles, moving forward, doubling back, and re-entering. Consider Fred, who starts smoking after a breakup, decides a year later to quit (preparation), attends a program and stops (action), keeps it up for a few weeks (maintenance), and then sees his former partner at the movies with somebody else. Flustered, he buys a pack. Back a few stages. Within two weeks he has cut back and returned to a quit stage. The process is cyclical rather than a straight line, which means a model that predicts orderly forward movement will misdescribe many real people. However, the cycle is not simply a return to the beginning. When Fred re-enters the path he is not where he started, because he has already quit once and knows he can, as Figure 3.3 shows. A relapse in this view is part of the process of change rather than proof that it failed.
Critique 2: How do you measure what stage people are in?
To assess stage you have to develop an arbitrary set of criteria. By this we mean that the stages are not visible facts about a person; a researcher or program has to decide what answer, or what behaviour, counts as being in each one. For some stages that is easy: to separate unaware from unengaged, ask whether people have heard of the problem and whether it matters to them. For other boundaries, contemplation versus preparation, maintenance versus termination, or deciding about acting versus deciding to act, it gets trickier. For example, does a smoker who says she will probably quit next month, but has no quit date, count as contemplating or preparing? The criteria matter because the stage a person is assigned to decides the intervention they receive, so it is easy to slip into hair-splitting about what stage someone is in, and thus what help they get, on the strength of a cut-off that someone had to choose.
Both critiques have practical consequences. Because people cycle, a program should expect relapse and plan for re-entry rather than treat it as failure. For example, the QuitNow coach in Worked Example 3.6 did not send the fourth caller back to the beginning, but built on what had worked the previous spring. Because stage boundaries are arbitrary, a program should state its criteria openly (for example, a single clear registration question) so that everyone assigns stages in the same way. It should also accept that the cut-off is a judgment, and that this judgment decides which intervention a person receives, so a person near a boundary may reasonably be offered elements of both.
6.4 Choosing Among the Five Approaches
With all five approaches described, the lesson's last skill is choosing among them. No approach is right for every problem; instead, the problem chooses the theory. By this we mean that you begin with what is known about the behaviour and the people, and then ask which approach describes that pattern best. The Health Belief Model fits problems where beliefs about risk and about a preventive action are at issue: whether people feel susceptible, think the problem serious, and see the action as worth its costs. The Theory of Planned Behavior, in contrast, fits problems where social approval and control over the behaviour are at issue, or where people intend to act and do not. A stage model fits a different kind of problem, one where a population is spread across levels of readiness and therefore needs more than one intervention. Among the stage models, the PAPM in particular fits precautions where the difference between unaware and unengaged matters. Whatever the choice, the EZ program structure illusion still applies, so research the people before you specify a single construct or stage. Finally, more than one approach can often be defended for the same problem, provided the choice is justified by what the research found.
Worked Example 3.7 applies this rule to a single survey and shows that more than one choice can be defended. Watch how each finding in the survey points to a construct or a stage, and how the choice is justified against an alternative.
Worked Example 3.7: Choosing a Framework for Campus Flu Vaccination
The case. A regional health authority in British Columbia asks for a plan to raise seasonal influenza vaccination among students at a large university, where uptake is low. A quick survey finds that most students see influenza as a mild illness for people their age; many believe their friends regard the shot as unnecessary or as something that makes you sick; about a fifth say they meant to get it last year and never did; and a small group did not know the vaccine was free at campus pharmacies.
Step 1, read each finding against the constructs and stages. Seeing influenza as mild is low perceived susceptibility and severity (Health Belief Model), or being unengaged (PAPM stage 2). Friends regarding the shot as unnecessary is a subjective norm (Theory of Planned Behavior). Meaning to get it and never doing so is an intention that did not become action, the gap the theory's time critique describes, or PAPM stage 5, deciding to act. Not knowing the vaccine is free is being unaware (PAPM stage 1) or a perceived barrier.
Step 2, choose a primary framework and justify it. One defensible choice is the Theory of Planned Behavior, because the survey points to the subjective norm and to a gap between intention and action; the Health Belief Model's low susceptibility and severity can be folded in as the outcome beliefs behind attitude. Another defensible choice is the PAPM, because the survey describes a population spread across stages: unaware, unengaged, and decided but not acted, each needing a different intervention.
Step 3, specify components. For susceptibility, severity, or engagement: messages connecting influenza to grandparents, roommates, and midterms lost to a week in bed. For the norm: visible evidence of how many students have been vaccinated, and peer messengers. For control and for those who decided but did not act: clinics in residences and lecture halls with no appointment, text reminders, and a same-week window. For the unaware: plain information that the vaccine is free on campus.
Step 4, research and a critique to guard against. Before building anything, interviews or focus groups should ask which friends' opinions matter, what students believe the shot does, and what stopped last year's intenders; posters built from constructs without that information would repeat the blues musicians' campaign. If the plan uses the Theory of Planned Behavior, the time critique is the risk: an intention measured in September for a shot offered in October may fade, so the plan makes the action available the moment the message lands. If it uses the PAPM, the measurement critique is the risk, so the plan uses one clear question to assign stage.
What the example shows is that a good answer does not pick a favourite theory. It matches the findings to constructs or stages, chooses a framework that fits the pattern, and names the research and the critique that come with it. Building one poster campaign from all six Health Belief Model constructs, because vaccination is preventive, would be applying a theory by category rather than by fit.
The example brings the lesson together: five approaches, one shape, a warning that applies to all of them, and critiques that mark where each will strain. This section has set the stage models beside the point-in-time theories, described the Transtheoretical Model with its six stages and processes of change and the Precaution Adoption Process Model with its seven ordered stages, set out the three requirements for using either model, stated two critiques, and shown how to choose among the five approaches. The key takeaways and knowledge check that follow review this material, and the lesson's closing review then brings the four sections together.
HEAL connection: the narrow band of reasoned action
On the HEAL Framework for Wellbeing introduced in Lesson 1, all five approaches in this lesson describe a psychosocial state (beliefs, attitudes, intentions, and readiness) becoming behaviour through deliberate choice, with experience feeding back through learning. HEAL calls deliberate choice reasoned action and describes it as a narrow band. Individualized models treat that band as the whole story, whereas a social-ecological model treats it as one input among many, beside conditioning, compulsion, and constraints set upstream by social position and material circumstance.
The critique of individual theories in this lesson is therefore a claim about where on the map they operate. The theories remain useful for designing the parts of a program that work on beliefs and intentions, provided that the program also asks what lies upstream of the choice.
Key Takeaways
- 4.2 The Health Belief Model and the Theory of Planned Behavior are point-in-time theories: they treat the beliefs, attitudes, and decision about a behaviour as a single process. Prochaska and DiClemente's research on smokers who were quitting showed that change takes place in stages over time, through many little decisions, much as Jane bought a car over a week. The stage models are called models because they describe a process and draw on many theories to explain movement through it. If a case describes someone moving through several decisions over weeks or months, that is the cue to think in stages.
- 4.3 The Transtheoretical Model's six stages are precontemplation (no intention to act), contemplation (weighing pros and cons, the decisional balance), preparation (intending to act soon, with a plan), action (a recent change that reduces risk), maintenance (keeping the change, with effort), and termination (no temptation left, which is not typical). It is transtheoretical because a different theory applies at each stage. Processes of change such as environmental reevaluation and counter-conditioning move people between stages, and self-efficacy is developed in maintenance and possessed in termination. To place a person, look for the one detail that marks the stage: a plan means preparation, a recent change means action, ongoing effort means maintenance.
- 4.4 The Precaution Adoption Process Model, built by Weinstein and Sandman around home radon testing, has seven ordered stages: unaware, unengaged, deciding about acting, deciding not to act, deciding to act, acting, and maintenance. Compared with the TTM it splits precontemplation into unaware and unengaged, adds deciding not to act, separates deciding to act from acting, and does not separate maintenance from termination. It also states explicitly that the stages occur in order. On an exam, someone who has heard of a hazard but never applied it to themselves is unengaged, not unaware.
- 5.4 Using a stage model requires three things: assess the stage of the target group with a measure that fits the behaviour, match the intervention to the processes that move people from that stage, and set criteria for judging whether they moved. Expect a group to be split across stages and to need more than one intervention, as the blues musicians, the radon homeowners, and the QuitNow callers were. The home radon study confirmed that risk information moves the undecided while a low-effort how-to moves those who have decided. When a question asks how to evaluate such a program, measure movement to the next stage, not only the final behaviour.
- 6.3 Two critiques: people cycle rather than march through stages, as Fred's relapse at the movies shows, re-entering the path further along than where they began; and stage must be measured with arbitrary criteria, so at close boundaries such as contemplation versus preparation, or maintenance versus termination, hair-splitting decides which intervention a person receives. A relapsed person who wants to try again illustrates the first critique, and a dispute about where to draw a survey cut-off illustrates the second.
- 6.4 Choose among the five approaches by the problem: the Health Belief Model where beliefs about risk and a preventive action are at issue, the Theory of Planned Behavior where social approval, control, or a gap between intention and action is at issue, and a stage model where a population is spread across levels of readiness and needs more than one intervention. More than one choice can be defensible, as the campus flu example showed; what makes an answer strong is matching each finding to a construct or stage, justifying the choice against an alternative, and naming the research and the critique that come with it.
1. What is it about the Transtheoretical Model that is transtheoretical?
2. A caller to a quitline says: "I have set a quit date for the first of the month and picked up patches yesterday." In the Transtheoretical Model, which stage is this caller in?
3. Which distinction does the Precaution Adoption Process Model make that the Transtheoretical Model does not?
4. In the home radon testing study described in this lesson, which pattern of results supported the Precaution Adoption Process Model?
5. Fred quits smoking, holds on for a few weeks, buys a pack after seeing his former partner at the movies, and two weeks later is back in a quit stage. What does this story show about stage models?
6. A survey of homeowners in a high-radon region finds a group who have heard about radon in the news but have never thought of it as something to do with their own house. Which Precaution Adoption Process Model stage are they in, and what intervention fits?
7. A radon program sends local risk information to homeowners who were unengaged. Six months later, few of them have tested yet. Following the third requirement for using a stage model, how should the program judge whether this part worked?
8. A colleague describes the Health Belief Model and the Theory of Planned Behavior as point-in-time theories. What does the label mean?
✦ Pass the knowledge check with 100% to continue
Final Review & Assessment
⏱ Estimated time: 25 minutes
Bringing It All Together
This lesson covered the theories that treat the individual as the primary source of behaviour, and it opened by complicating that idea. Sam decided to brush his teeth, but the information, the situation, and the upbringing behind the decision were social; the everyday self comes apart into genes, examples, stories, and people we chose to emulate; and Dumont's distinction reminds us that the theories were written in a society that takes the autonomous individual for granted. The five approaches that followed share a shape. Each describes what happens inside a person before a health action, treats that process as largely rational, and treats the person as the unit of analysis and intervention. The cues, references, and information that feed the process come from social, physical, and cultural environments, and the theories mostly take them as given.
The Health Belief Model began with Hochbaum's question about a free tuberculosis screening program that few people used. Its six constructs, perceived susceptibility, severity, benefits, and barriers, cues to action, and self-efficacy, read as one statement about a person, and the model is a value expectancy model: people act when they value the outcome and expect the behaviour to produce it. The Theory of Reasoned Action and Planned Behavior began with a different question, whether attitudes predict behaviour, and answered it by separating attitudes from intentions: attitude toward a specific behaviour and subjective norms produce an intention, and the revision added perceived behavioural control for behaviours a person cannot fully control. The Transtheoretical Model and the Precaution Adoption Process Model replaced the single decision with a sequence of stages, from precontemplation or unawareness through action and maintenance, and argued that the theory and the intervention that apply depend on where a person is.
Two threads ran through all of it. The first is the EZ program structure illusion. The blues musicians' campaign hit every construct of the Health Belief Model and moved no one, because nobody had asked what severity and barriers meant to musicians without insurance whose livelihood depended on gigs; the same warning applied to the Theory of Planned Behavior, where the reference group must be discovered before norms can be addressed, and to the stage models, where stage must be assessed before a process of change can be chosen. The second thread is the critiques, which land on the same three assumptions each time: context can block a rational calculation, constructs are unclear and few studies test a whole theory, emotion and habit fit awkwardly, time between intention and action is ignored, and stages are neither linear nor easy to measure. None of this makes the theories useless. It makes them tools, guidelines, and frameworks that require research and judgment, chosen to fit the problem rather than by habit, which is the stance this course asks you to take toward every theory.
Key Takeaways from this lesson
- You can now explain why these are called individual theories: they look at the thought process inside a person before a health action, while that process is fed by social, physical, and cultural environments. Sam's story, the parts of the self, and Dumont's distinction all show that the line between person and context is blurred. The practical reminder is to ask, in any case, where a belief came from and who actually makes the decision.
- You can trace the Health Belief Model from Hochbaum's empty tuberculosis clinics to its six constructs and explain its value expectancy logic. Read the constructs as one statement about a person: at risk, serious, worth it, little in the way, a push, and the belief that she can. Keep severity (about the problem) and barriers (about the action) apart.
- You can distinguish attitude toward a behaviour, subjective norm, behavioural intention, and perceived behavioural control, each with its parts, and explain why intention without control led to the Theory of Planned Behavior. The key reminder is that the theory predicts from the attitude toward the specific behaviour, not from a general attitude.
- You can name the six stages of the Transtheoretical Model and the seven of the Precaution Adoption Process Model and say how stage models differ from point-in-time theories. To place a person, look for the one detail that marks the stage, and remember that the PAPM splits unaware from unengaged and adds deciding not to act.
- You can apply each approach to a health promotion case by mapping its details onto constructs or stages and naming the program component that fits. Whatever the theory, research the people before you specify a single construct: skipping that step is the EZ program structure illusion that sank the blues musicians' first campaign.
- You can evaluate the critiques of each approach and choose among them for a given problem: the Health Belief Model for beliefs about risk and a preventive action, the Theory of Planned Behavior for social approval, control, or an intention gap, and a stage model for a population spread across readiness. A strong answer justifies the choice against an alternative and names the critique most likely to undermine it.
Final Knowledge Assessment
This assessment covers all material from this lesson. You must score 100% to complete the lesson. Review the feedback for any incorrect answers and try again.
1. The decisions people make to take or not take a health action are based on cues, references, and information from their social, physical, and cultural environments. Why does this lesson make that point at the start of its treatment of individual theories?
2. Why are the Transtheoretical Model and the Precaution Adoption Process Model called models rather than theories?
3. A health promoter assumes that persuading each patient individually is the right approach in every community she serves. Which idea from the lesson most directly challenges that assumption?
4. Which sequence correctly describes how the Health Belief Model reached its current six constructs?
5. The Health Belief Model is called a value expectancy model. Which statement expresses that assumption?
6. In the revised blues musicians campaign, the perceived severity theme shifted from cancer statistics to the tagline "Got throat cancer? Can't get gigs." What made the revision possible?
7. In the Baltimore mammography intervention described in this lesson, which factors were significant predictors of screening?
8. Which statement correctly describes the relationship between the Theory of Reasoned Action and the Theory of Planned Behavior?
9. Jane believes it would be easy to get a ride to the screening facility, and a ride is the only way she could get there. In Theory of Planned Behavior terms, how would you describe these two facts?
10. A program to reduce smoking among blues musicians runs group sessions near the clubs so that fellow musicians come to view quit programs favourably. In the Theory of Planned Behavior, which construct is the program trying to change, and why that group?
11. The difference between perceived behavioural control and self-efficacy is hard to define. Which critique does this observation belong to?
12. A man has quit smoking for eight months and still avoids the bar because he wants a cigarette when he drinks. In the Transtheoretical Model, which stage is he in, and what is true of that stage?
13. Which stage exists in the Precaution Adoption Process Model but has no counterpart in the Transtheoretical Model?
14. Using a stage model in a program has three requirements. Which set is correct?
15. A campus survey finds that most students see influenza as mild, many believe their friends think the shot is unnecessary, a fifth intended to get vaccinated last year and did not, and a few did not know the vaccine was free. Which of the following is the best-reasoned use of this lesson?
16. In the same campus survey, about a fifth of students said they meant to get the flu shot last year and never did. Read through the Precaution Adoption Process Model, which stage are they in, and what kind of intervention fits?
17. A plan built on the Theory of Planned Behavior measures students' intention to get a flu shot in September, and the shot will be offered in October. Which critique of the theory most threatens the plan, and what is the best guard against it?
18. Two quitline coaches disagree about a caller who says she will probably quit "sometime soon" and has looked up nicotine patches but has not bought any. One says contemplation, the other preparation, and the program sends a different intervention to each stage. Which critique of stage models does this disagreement illustrate?
✦ Pass every section knowledge check with 100% before submitting