Social Behavioral Theory
and Its Roots
Health Promotion: Individuals and Communities
Learning objectives for this lesson:
- Define theory in the social science sense, identify its parts, and apply Popper’s falsification test to tell a testable theory from an untestable account and from an empirical observation.
- Explain how hypotheses can be derived from any coherent account, including a myth, and why judging a theory depends on the ground rules of its historical, social, or cultural context.
- Describe the four assumptions that theory inherits from the Western scientific tradition (order and regularity, predictability, empirical data, and progress) and trace the history behind each.
- Distinguish empiricist, rationalist, phenomenological, and theological answers to how we know what we know, and identify which underlies scientific theory and what it may leave out.
- Describe the contributions of behaviourist, cognitive, humanistic, and social psychology to health behaviour theory, and identify which school’s assumption a program relies on.
- Describe the contributions of sociology and cultural anthropology to public health theory, and explain how their questions about a behaviour differ from those of psychology.
- Explain how ecology and human ecology produced the ecological model, and apply the principle of interdependent systems to a health promotion problem.
This course was developed by Dr. Kiffer G. Card, to accompany Edberg, M. Essentials of Health Behavior: Social and Behavioral Theory in Public Health. Jones & Bartlett Learning. This lesson follows Chapter 3 of the text.
Glossary: Key Terms, People & Concepts
📚 Reference page, available throughout the lesson
This glossary collects the key concepts, people, and ideas you will meet in this lesson. Use it as a reference while you work through the material, or as a review before assessments. Type in the search box to filter entries.
Thinking About Theory: What a Theory Is and How It Is Tested
⏱ Estimated reading time: 15 minutes
Overview
The word theory is used constantly in health promotion, often without a definition, and this section supplies one. It sets out what a theory is in the social science sense, how Karl Popper argued a theory should be tested, how a theory works as an account from which hypotheses can be drawn, and why every judgment about a theory depends on the ground rules of a context. These are the tools you will use to examine any named theory of health behaviour.
Learning Objectives
- 1.1 Define theory in the social science sense, identify its parts (constructs, definitions, and propositions), and distinguish a theory from the hypotheses and principles derived from it.
- 1.2 Explain Karl Popper’s claim that a theory is tested by attempts to falsify it, in situations relevant to its claims, and why collecting confirming cases is a weak test.
- 1.3 Classify a statement as a testable proposition, an untestable account, or an empirical observation.
- 2.1 Describe theory as an account, and derive testable hypotheses from a coherent account, including a myth.
- 2.2 Explain why judging a theory depends on contextual ground rules, using Wittgenstein’s language games and Foucault’s idea of discourse.
1.1 Theory in the Scientific Sense
The idea of theory is most closely associated with its use in the scientific method, and that association gives the term a specific meaning. A widely used definition oriented to social science, drawn from Kerlinger, runs as follows: a theory is a set of interrelated constructs (concepts), definitions, and propositions that presents a systematic view of phenomena by specifying relations among variables, with the purpose of explaining and predicting those phenomena. The definition is compact, so it helps to take it apart, because each part does a specific job. A construct is a concept the theory names and defines, such as perceived risk or reinforcement. By this we mean that a theory does not simply talk about people in general terms; it picks out particular ideas, gives them names, and says exactly what they refer to, so that everyone using the theory is talking about the same thing. A proposition then states how those constructs relate to one another. For example, a proposition might say that the more at risk a person believes they are, the more likely they are to act. Constructs on their own are only a vocabulary, and it is the propositions that turn that vocabulary into a claim about the world.
The definition adds two further requirements. First, the whole set is systematic, which means the constructs and propositions fit together into one picture rather than sitting side by side in a list. A list of factors that seem related to smoking is therefore not yet a theory, because it does not say how the factors connect. Second, the purpose of a theory is twofold: to explain what has happened and to predict what will. In other words, a theory should help us understand why a behaviour occurred and also tell us what to expect in a new situation, which is what makes it useful to someone planning a program.
A theory also gives rise to more specific statements, and two of them should be kept separate from the theory itself, because students often confuse them with it. A hypothesis is a specific, testable prediction derived from a theory. The purpose of a hypothesis is to bring a general theory down to one situation where it can be checked. For example, if the theory says carcinogens cause cells to mutate, a hypothesis might state that workers exposed to a particular chemical will show higher rates of a particular cancer than unexposed workers. A principle, in contrast, is a general rule for practice derived from a theory. Where a hypothesis is written for testing, a principle is written for doing. For example, if reinforcement theory holds, a principle for program design might be that a new behaviour should be rewarded promptly and often at first. The four cards below define these building blocks, which you will meet again in every theory in this course.
Hypothesis
A specific, testable prediction derived from a theory. If the theory says carcinogens cause cells to mutate, a hypothesis might state that workers exposed to a particular chemical will show higher rates of a particular cancer than unexposed workers. The hypothesis is what actually gets tested.
Construct
A concept that a theory names and defines. Gravity is a construct in the first example; carcinogen is a construct in the second. In the health behaviour theories to come, constructs such as perceived susceptibility and self-efficacy are the building blocks. A theory specifies how its constructs relate to one another.
Proposition
A statement of relation among constructs. "The greater a person’s perceived susceptibility, the more likely they are to act" is a proposition. Propositions are the connective tissue of a theory; together they give it the systematic character the definition requires.
Principle
A general rule for practice derived from a theory. If reinforcement theory holds, a principle for program design might be that a new behaviour should be rewarded promptly and often at first. Principles translate a theory into guidance, which is where most of health promotion practice lives.
Taken together, the cards show the direction of travel. Constructs and propositions make up the theory, while hypotheses and principles are derived from it, the first for testing and the second for practice. A definition says what a theory is; the next question is how anyone decides whether a theory deserves to be kept, and Popper’s answer is the one most scientists still use.
1.2 Popper’s Test: Falsification
The philosopher of science Karl Popper framed theory in the way most commonly used in scientific inquiry today. For Popper, a theory is a proposed explanatory solution to a problem. By this we mean that a theory starts from something we do not understand, such as why some people quit smoking and others do not, and offers an explanation for it. The important move is what Popper said should happen next. A theory’s validity is not established by proving it true, because that is easy: confirming cases can be found for almost any claim. For example, a program manager who believes that posters change behaviour can always find someone who saw a poster and then changed, but those cases say nothing about the many people who saw the poster and did not change. The real test, Popper argued, is trying to falsify the theory, that is, to find the observation that would show it wrong. A theory is therefore an explanatory proposition that can be tested, and tested by falsification.
What happens after the test depends on the result. If, over time and in situations relevant to what it claims, the theory is not falsified, it remains part of the ongoing body of scientific knowledge. If it is falsified, it is reworked or discarded. Either way, Popper argued, science advances, because both outcomes tell us something the untested account could not. This changes how you should read any claim that a theory has been "proven": the stronger claim is that it has survived serious attempts to show it false. Popper’s account also clears up a common confusion about the word theory itself.
Common confusion: "it’s only a theory"
In everyday speech, a theory is a guess. In science the relationship runs the other way. The theory is the general explanatory account, and the hypothesis is the specific, testable prediction derived from it. A theory that has survived repeated attempts at falsification carries more weight than a hunch, not less. When someone dismisses an explanation as "only a theory," they usually mean it is only a hypothesis, or only a belief.
Popper’s account yields three questions that can be put to any proposed theory: whether an observation could show it false, whether it has been tested in situations relevant to its claims, and what happened when it failed. Each question is worked through below with an example from health promotion.
Test 1: Can you say what would show it to be false?
This is Popper’s central demand. "Fear-based warnings reduce smoking" is falsifiable: a trial in which warnings produce no change would count against it. "Our program changed lives in ways that cannot be measured" is not, because no observation could ever count against it. The second statement may be sincere, but it is not a scientific theory.
Test 2: Has it been tested in situations relevant to what it claims?
Popper’s test carries a condition that is easy to miss: a theory earns its place only if it has been tested in situations relevant to its claims. A theory of adolescent smoking tested only among middle-aged adults in one country has not really been tested. The reason is that a theory can only fail where its claims apply. Middle-aged adults may differ from adolescents in the very things the theory is about, such as the pull of peers or the way risk is perceived, so a result among adults says little about whether the theory holds for the young people it was meant to explain. The same condition applies whenever a theory developed in one population is carried over to another.
Test 3: What happened when it failed?
A falsified theory can be reworked, which is how most theories in this course developed: constructs were added, relations redrawn, and the revised version tested again. Or it can be discarded. The point is that both outcomes move science forward, because both tell us something the untested account could not.
The second question is the one most often skipped in practice. A theory that has survived testing in one population has not yet been tested in another, so its claim to apply there stays open until someone tries to falsify it in that setting. The first question, whether anything could show a statement false, is also the quickest way to sort the statements you meet in health promotion, and that sorting is the skill the next subsection practises.
1.3 Theory, Hunch, or Observation?
Popper’s test sorts the statements we meet in health promotion into three kinds. The first is a testable proposition, which proposes a cause or a relation that some observation could show false. For example, "people who believe they are personally at risk are more likely to take preventive action" could be contradicted by a study in which those people acted no differently from anyone else. The second is an untestable account, which is framed so that no possible observation could count against it. An untestable account may be sincere, and even deeply meaningful to the people who hold it, but it is not a scientific theory in Popper’s sense, because nothing that happens could ever show it to be wrong. The third is an empirical observation, which is a datum. By this we mean that it reports what was found or counted, such as the number of vaccinations a clinic gave on one day, and it describes without explaining.
Two questions, asked in order, do the sorting. The first is whether any observation could show the statement false; if none could, the statement is an untestable account. The second is whether the statement explains or only describes; if it only reports what was found, it is an observation, and if it proposes why something happens, it is a testable proposition. The two questions matter because the categories are easy to blur. An observation can sound scientific because it contains a number, and an untestable account can sound like a claim about evidence, yet neither is a theory that could be tested.
Interactive 2.1 gives you twelve statements to sort into these three categories. Click a statement, then click the category it belongs to. You will get feedback on each choice and a first-attempt score at the end, so work through all twelve before reading on.
📊 Interactive 2.1: Theory or hunch?
Click a statement, then click the category it belongs to. You get immediate feedback, and your first-attempt score at the end.Testable proposition
An observation could show it false.
Untestable account
No observation could count against it.
Empirical observation
A datum: it describes, it does not explain.
Two things to notice. First, the untestable accounts are not necessarily false, and some are deeply meaningful to the people who hold them; they are simply not scientific theories in Popper’s sense, because nothing could count against them. Second, observations on their own are not theories either. A survey result describes; a theory says why. Public health needs both, and it needs to keep them apart.
The exercise shows that observations and theories need each other but must be kept apart: a survey result tells you what is happening, and only a theory says why. Worked Example 2.1 applies the same sorting to a well-known Canadian campaign. As you read it, watch for the difference between a message that is memorable and a claim that could be tested.
Worked Example 2.1: Classifying a Famous Campaign Claim
The case. In 1973 the Canadian physical activity organization ParticipACTION (Wikipedia) ran a television spot claiming that the average thirty-year-old Canadian was in roughly the same physical shape as the average sixty-year-old Swede. The line became one of the most remembered pieces of Canadian public health advertising. It was also a rhetorical comparison rather than the result of a study that measured the two groups. The task is to classify the claim and to say what a theory-based version of the campaign would have needed.
Step 1: Classify the claim. The Swede comparison describes the state of two groups. It proposes no cause and says nothing about why Canadians were inactive, so it presents itself as an empirical observation, one that was not even based on measurement. It is not an untestable account, because the fitness of two groups could in principle be measured, and it is not a testable proposition, because it explains nothing.
Step 2: State what a theory-based version would need. A theory-based campaign would name constructs and a proposition connecting them to behaviour. For example: adults who believe they are less fit than their peers, and who see activity as easy to fit into daily life, are more likely to become active. That is a claim about why people act, and it tells the campaign what it should try to change.
Step 3: Name the observation that could falsify it. From that proposition follows a hypothesis: adults who saw the campaign would report more physical activity than comparable adults who did not. A careful comparison in which exposed adults were no more active would count against it, and the fact that such an observation is possible is exactly what makes the proposition testable.
What this shows. Judged as a message, the spot worked: people talked about it for decades. Judged as a theory, it made no claim at all. Later tobacco control in Canada took a different route, stating explicitly which influences it was targeting (price, packaging, smoke-free spaces, social norms) and evaluating each, so that each claim could fail. The mistake to avoid is treating a striking statistic as if it were an explanation.
Sorting statements by Popper’s test raises a further question. One of the statements in Interactive 2.1 was a myth, and a myth is a coherent story too. The next subsection asks what a theory is at its most basic, and why a myth also counts as one in the broad sense.
2.1 Theory as an Account
Before going further, ask what theory is in a more basic sense. Boiled down, definitions of theory refer to a kind of story, or, to use a broader word, an account. A theory is an account that is said to explain something and to posit connections between phenomena. By this we mean that a theory tells us why something happens by linking it to something else. For example, one account says that apples and other objects fall from trees because a force called gravity acts on them, which links falling to gravity. Another says that substances called carcinogens cause cells to mutate and grow abnormally, out of control, which links a substance to a disease. From such accounts you can derive more specific applications. These are the building blocks defined in the cards in 1.1: hypotheses, which are testable predictions; constructs, which are the named concepts; and principles, which are general rules for practice.
Seen this way, theory is an ancient human activity. A key characteristic of modern humans since prehistoric times has been the creation of tales, myths, and stories that describe an entire cosmological system, explain the creation of society, or explain how men and women came to be what they are. These are theories in the broad sense, because they present a coherent account from which more specific judgments can be drawn. Consider the myth you met in Interactive 2.1, in which men were created from fire and women from water. Taken seriously, that account yields hypotheses: that men are emotional and prone to conflict while women are better at stopping conflicts (water on fire); that men destroy while women nourish; that men provide what is needed in adverse conditions while women provide the sustenance needed all the time.
Most of us would dismiss this as folktale. The harder question is: by what standards? We would probably say there is no proof, and that the account contradicts known facts about the origins of gender. But that answer assumes a set of rules about what counts as proof and what counts as a known fact. The ability to generate hypotheses does not separate a scientific theory from a myth, since any coherent account can do it; the rules used to judge the account are doing the work. Which rules, and who sets them, is the subject of the next subsection.
2.2 Ground Rules: Who Decides What Counts?
Evaluating a theory or a proposition necessarily rests on some set of standards for making the judgment. By this we mean that nobody can decide whether an account is right without, at least implicitly, using rules about what counts as a good reason, a fair test, or a known fact. Two philosophers offer ways of describing those rules. The first is Ludwig Wittgenstein, who described language games: statements with meaning, validity, and truth or falsity within a particular practice and its rules. The comparison with a game is deliberate. A move in chess makes sense only inside the rules of chess, and in the same way a statement makes sense, and can be judged true or false, only inside the practice that gives it its rules. Seen this way, a scientific theory is a move within the practice of science.
The second is Michel Foucault, who described theories as statements within the discourse of science. Foucault argued that discourse, the modes of expression of a period and how they are used, is the product of that period and its dominant institutions. In addition to shaping how people speak, each period’s discourse carries rules for what is true and false, normal and not normal. Where Wittgenstein draws attention to the rules of a practice, Foucault draws attention to where those rules come from: they are set by a particular time and by the institutions that hold influence in it. In the era of modern science, that discourse predisposes us to judge truth by rational or empirical criteria, so a claim supported by observation and reasoning sounds true to us almost automatically.
Theories, then, have meaning and validity within a specific historical, social, or cultural context, and to evaluate one you need to understand the contextual ground rules. This understanding is one of the most important tools you can have for assessing theories about human behaviour and deciding when and where they will be useful in practice. Ground rules are not only a matter for philosophers, however; they hide inside ordinary program rationales too. For example, a campaign built on the reasoning "young people vape because they think it is harmless, so telling them the harms will stop them" takes for granted that behaviour follows a rational weighing of health consequences. An account rooted in social psychology, which treats vaping as a way of managing belonging and identity among friends, does not share that rule and would not expect harm information alone to change behaviour.
A common misreading: context does not mean anything goes
Saying that a theory is valid within a context does not mean that every account is equally valid, or that a myth and a scientific theory are the same thing. It means that no judgment is made without rules, so before deciding which account is right you should name the rules being used to judge it. In modern science those rules are rational and empirical, and Popper’s falsification test is one of them.
Worked Example 2.2 shows ground rules at work in the history of public health itself. As you read it, notice that both accounts were coherent stories about the same deaths, and that what changed was the standard used to judge them.
Worked Example 2.2: Two Accounts of Cholera
The case. In mid-nineteenth-century London, the dominant scientific account held that cholera spread through miasma, foul air rising from filth. The physician John Snow proposed that it was carried in contaminated water. Within the discourse of the day the miasma account was meaningful and widely held; Snow’s was resisted for years. The task is to identify the ground rules that made miasma seem correct and what changed.
Step 1: Identify the two accounts. Both are theories in the broad sense of 2.1. Miasma connects foul air from filth to cholera deaths; Snow’s account connects contaminated water to the same deaths. Each is coherent, and each explains the same observations of where people fell ill.
Step 2: Name the ground rules that favoured miasma. In the discourse of the period, foul smells and filth were the accepted signs of disease, and miasma was the dominant scientific account. A statement that fit that discourse sounded true. Snow’s proposal of an unseen cause in drinking water did not fit, so it was resisted even though it was coherent.
Step 3: Identify what changed. Snow’s account generated a prediction that could fail: households drawing water from a contaminated supply would suffer more cases than neighbours drawing from a cleaner one. The prediction held, and the miasma account was falsified in that situation. The rule that settled the question was Popper’s: an account earns its place by surviving a test it could have failed, judged by observable comparison rather than by agreement with the established view.
What this shows. Judging an account is never free of rules. Miasma was not foolish within its own rules, and Snow did not win by being more confident; his account prevailed when the judgment turned on falsifiable, observable evidence. When you assess a theory, name the rules being used to judge it before deciding who is right.
If judging a theory depends on its context, the next step is to identify the context in which public health uses theory and the ground rules that context supplies, which is the question the next section takes up.
The key takeaways below gather what this section has established: the social science definition of theory, Popper’s test of falsification, the three kinds of statement it sorts, theory as an account, and the dependence of every judgment on contextual ground rules. The knowledge check that follows asks you to apply these ideas to short cases.
Key Takeaways
- 1.1 In social science, a theory is a systematic set of interrelated constructs, definitions, and propositions that specifies relations among variables in order to explain and predict. Constructs are the concepts a theory names, such as perceived risk, and propositions are the statements that say how those constructs relate. Hypotheses and principles are not the theory itself but things derived from it: a hypothesis is a testable prediction for one situation, and a principle is a rule for practice. When a question asks you to restate a program’s reasoning as a theory, name at least two constructs and then write the proposition that links them to behaviour; if you have only a list of factors with no stated relation, you do not yet have a theory.
- 1.2 Following Popper, a theory is a proposed explanatory solution to a problem, and it earns its place by surviving serious attempts to falsify it, not by piling up confirming cases, which are easy to find for almost any claim. The test must happen in situations relevant to what the theory claims, so a theory tested only among university students has not been tested in a remote community. A falsified theory is reworked or discarded, and both outcomes move science forward. In exam questions, be suspicious of any claim that a theory is "proven" by success stories, and when asked for a falsifying observation, describe a fair comparison in which the predicted difference fails to appear.
- 1.3 Statements come in three kinds. A testable proposition proposes a cause or relation that some observation could show wrong; an untestable account is framed so that nothing could count against it; and an empirical observation reports what was found without explaining it. Ask two questions in order: could any observation show this false, and does it explain or only describe? A common trap is a statement such as "the program worked in ways no evaluation can capture," which sounds like a claim about evidence but cannot fail, so it is an untestable account. Another trap is treating a survey figure, however striking, as if it were an explanation.
- 2.1 At its most basic, a theory is an account, a story that explains something and connects one phenomenon with another, and humans have built such accounts since prehistory in myths about the cosmos, society, and gender. Hypotheses, constructs, and principles can be derived from any coherent account, including a myth such as men being created from fire and women from water. The practical lesson is that producing hypotheses does not make an account scientific. If a question asks what separates a myth from a scientific theory, the answer is the standards used to judge it, not the presence or absence of derived claims.
- 2.2 Every judgment about a theory rests on ground rules supplied by a context. Wittgenstein’s language games describe practices whose rules give statements their meaning, and Foucault’s discourse describes how each period and its dominant institutions set the rules for what counts as true or normal; in modern science the rules are rational and empirical. This does not mean anything goes: it means you should name the rules being applied before you decide who is right. When you analyze a program or a disagreement, look for the assumption that one side takes for granted, such as the belief that behaviour follows a rational weighing of health consequences, and ask whether a different account would share it.
1. A program evaluator reports: "We found dozens of participants who quit smoking after our workshop, so the theory behind the workshop is confirmed." From Popper’s point of view, what is the problem with this reasoning?
2. Which of the following statements is best classified as an empirical observation rather than a theory or a hypothesis?
3. From the account "men were created from fire and women from water" one could derive hypotheses about conflict, destruction, and provision. What point does this example make?
4. A colleague argues that a theory of health behaviour developed and tested only among university students in the United States has been "thoroughly tested" and can be applied unchanged in a remote First Nations community. Which condition of Popper’s test does this overlook?
5. A program planner writes: "Because new behaviours are maintained by reinforcement, participants should receive praise promptly and often in their first weeks." In the vocabulary of this section, what is this statement?
6. A regional health authority proposes a campaign with this rationale: "Young people vape because they think it is harmless. If we tell them the harms, they will stop." Which restatement turns this rationale into a theory in the social science sense?
7. From that theory, a team derives a hypothesis: students exposed to a harms campaign will report higher perceived harm and less past-month vaping than comparable unexposed students. Which result would falsify the link between perceived harm and vaping?
8. The same rationale takes a ground rule for granted. Which assumption does it rely on that an account rooted in social psychology, treating vaping as a way of managing belonging among friends, would not share?
✦ Pass the knowledge check with 100% to continue
The Context of Theory in the Western Tradition
⏱ Estimated reading time: 18 minutes
Overview
The previous section showed that judging a theory depends on ground rules. This section asks where the ground rules for public health theory come from. The answer is the Western philosophical and scientific tradition, which builds four assumptions into what we mean by theory: order and regularity, predictability, empirical data, and progress. Knowing the history behind each assumption, and the different answers people have given to the question of how we know what we know, lets you see what a theory takes for granted and what it may leave out.
Learning Objectives
- 3.1 Explain what it means to situate the concept of theory within the Western philosophical and scientific tradition, and distinguish situating a tradition from privileging it.
- 3.2 Describe the four assumptions the tradition builds into theory: order and regularity, predictability, empirical data, and progress.
- 3.3 Trace the history of the assumption of order, from the Greek philosophers through the church-centred Middle Ages and the secular Enlightenment to nineteenth-century positivism.
- 3.4 Explain predictability as the child of order, and describe Comte’s three stages of human thought and his goal of predicting and shaping society.
- 3.5 Describe the assumption of progress and explain how it makes science a continuous accumulation of knowledge.
- 4.1 Distinguish empiricism, rationalism, phenomenology, and the theological or deist orientation as answers to how we know what we know, and identify the one within which scientific theory developed.
- 4.2 Explain why the empiricist standard of evidence may not always be enough, and apply that question to the evaluation of a health program.
3.1 Where the Ground Rules Come From
If judging a theory depends on ground rules, what are the rules for the theories public health uses? The answer is plain. The term theory takes its meaning from Western philosophy and science, the tradition that began with the Greek philosophers and was carried forward largely in Europe and North America. Saying this does not privilege that tradition; it situates it in a social and historical context. The difference between the two words matters. To privilege a tradition would be to claim that it is the best or only way of understanding the world. To situate it, by contrast, is simply to say where and when it came from, in the same way we would describe the origins of any other set of ideas. The purpose of situating theory is to make its assumptions visible, so that they can be examined rather than taken for granted. The tradition has been influenced and paralleled by currents from outside its mainstream, including the Islamic scholars Avicenna (ibn Sina) and Averroes (ibn Rushd) and the Chinese philosophers Confucius and Chuang Tzu, and other traditions such as Confucianism, Taoism, and Navajo cosmology hold elaborate ideas of their own about the natural order. Still, the concept of theory public health inherited is largely a Western product. Knowing where a concept comes from places it in context without ranking it above anyone else’s, and it lets you ask which of its assumptions travel well to other settings. Those assumptions can be boiled down to four elements, which the next subsection names.
3.2 Four Assumptions Built into Theory
Theory in the Western tradition rests on four assumptions. They are called assumptions because they are rarely stated or questioned; they are simply taken for granted whenever someone proposes or tests a theory. The first is order and regularity, the assumption that nature has an underlying order that can be progressively discovered and put to practical use. By this we mean that events are not random: they follow patterns, and those patterns can be found and used. The second, predictability, builds directly on the first. If we learn the rules of that order, we can forecast what will happen. For example, a weather forecast makes sense only if the weather follows rules that someone has learned.
The third assumption, empirical data, concerns how we come to know those rules at all: what we know comes to us through the senses, from a reality that is out there to be observed. This is why a theory is expected to point to evidence that can be seen, counted, or measured. The fourth, progress and perfectability, concerns knowledge over time: knowledge accumulates, and time moves toward fuller understanding. In addition to assuming that we can know the world, then, the tradition assumes that each generation can know it a little better than the last. The four cards below give a first pass at each assumption, with an example of where it shows up.
Order and
regularity
The assumption that nature has an underlying order that can be progressively discovered and put to practical use. Every culture has ideas about the natural order of things; in the West, the search for order took a turn that fed directly into science, from Democritus and Aristotle through Newton. Theory today is inseparable from the idea of order.
Predictability
The child of order: if nature is ordered and we learn the rules, we can predict what will happen. The weather forecast and the doctor’s prescription both rest on this expectation. Auguste Comte made prediction, and through it the shaping of society, the goal of the human sciences.
Empirical
data
The assumption that what we know comes to us through the senses, from an objective reality that is out there to be perceived. Science in this empiricist tradition relies on observable, tangible data as evidence, and a theory is expected to say something evidence-based about observable relationships between phenomena.
Progress and
perfectability
The assumption that knowledge accumulates and that time moves toward fuller understanding. Almost every major thinker since the Enlightenment has built progress into their theories, and doing science is by definition a continuous accumulation of knowledge in which theory is the tactic used to generate investigation.
The cards show that the assumptions are linked rather than separate: predictability depends on order, and progress depends on evidence that can be gathered and built upon. Each assumption also has a history, and the history of order comes first because the others grew out of it.
3.3 Order and Regularity: From the Greeks to Positivism
It would be silly to claim that the idea of order is unique to Western thought; Confucianism, Taoism, and Navajo cosmology all contain elaborate concepts of natural order. What happened in the West was a specific turn: the progressive discovery of an assumed order underlying nature, combined with the practical application of that knowledge to human ends, became the central project of philosophy and then of science. In other words, the West did not invent the idea that nature is orderly; what it did was make the search for that order, and the use of it, the main business of its scholars. The turn began with the Greek philosophers. Around the fourth century BCE, Democritus pictured a world made of atoms, small discrete bits of matter whose arrangement explained the things we see. Aristotle took a different route and built a scheme for classifying natural phenomena by matter and form, motion, space, and time. Unlike Plato, who was more interested in ideal forms, Aristotle wanted classifications that had practical use, and that pairing of order with usefulness is the part of the Greek legacy that science later inherited.
The search for order continued in the Middle Ages, but it took a new form. From the fall of Rome in the fifth century to the fifteenth century, the church held a monopoly on scholarship, which means that almost all formal learning took place within religious institutions and under their rules. As a result, understanding nature’s order meant understanding divine order: the regularities of the world were read as signs of God’s design. Thomas Aquinas shows how closely the two were joined, since one of his arguments ran from the order of nature to the existence of a God who created it. Order, in other words, was still assumed, but its explanation lay in the divine rather than in the world itself.
The Enlightenment broke that monopoly. Several forces worked together to do so: printing and literacy spread knowledge beyond the church, exploration revealed the diversity of human ways of life, astronomy moved the Earth from the centre of the universe, and natural philosophers such as Locke, Voltaire, and Rousseau argued for new ways of thinking. Together they shifted explanation from the divine to the secular, that is, to reason and worldly evidence. However, the focus on order survived the shift. The universe was now pictured as a mechanical clock whose gears turned in endless repetition, and Newton’s law of gravity became the model of a scientific law. In other words, the order people looked for was no longer God’s design but a set of natural laws, and the search for it continued.
As discovery grew, natural philosophy split into separate fields: first biology, physics, and astronomy, and later sociology, anthropology, and psychology. The newer fields wanted to be sciences in the same way as physics, which meant finding laws of human life as reliable as the law of gravity. In the nineteenth century, Auguste Comte and others pushed for exactly this, a science of humanity that would discover laws of human behaviour and use them to develop society. That program is called positivism, the tradition asserting that knowledge is based on natural phenomena and their properties and relations, as verified by the empirical sciences. By this we mean that, for a positivist, something counts as knowledge only when it has been observed and checked by scientific methods, and that this standard should apply to the study of people as much as to the study of planets.
Interactive 2.2 lets you follow this turn era by era. It places six eras on a timeline, from Classical Greece to the human sciences of the twentieth century, and tags each era with the assumptions it fed. Click each era, or press "Step through" to move through them in order, and watch how the tags accumulate.
📊 Interactive 2.2: The turn toward science.
Click an era on the timeline, or step through them in order. The tags show which of the four assumptions each era fed.Select an era
Start with Classical Greece, or press "Step through" to follow the sequence.
Two things about this history matter for practice. First, the shift from divine to secular explanation coincided with the beginnings of the Industrial Revolution and with a shift in power from church and monarchy to those who used science and technology to produce goods. By this we mean that the change in how people decided what was true did not happen in isolation; it happened at the same time as a change in who held influence. The church had been the authority on knowledge while it held power, and science became the authority as the people who used it to make goods gained power. Ways of knowing and arrangements of power therefore moved together, which is Foucault’s point from Section 1: the rules for what counts as true are shaped by the period and by its dominant institutions. Second, the idea of theory today is inseparable from the idea of order, even among those who argue that the human sciences should differ from the physical sciences. Even a critic who thinks people cannot be studied like planets still assumes that there is some pattern in human behaviour worth finding. Once order is assumed, prediction follows, and that is the next assumption.
3.4 Predictability: Comte’s Science of Society
Predictability is the child of order and regularity: if nature is ordered and we discover the rules, then in principle we can predict what will happen. The idea is so ingrained in common sense that few people notice it is an idea, yet every weather report and every prescription assumes that someone is using science to predict. A prescription, for example, makes sense only because the doctor expects the drug to act on the body in the same way it has acted on other bodies before. It was Auguste Comte who institutionalized prediction as a goal for the human sciences. By this we mean that Comte did not simply hope that the study of people might one day forecast behaviour; he made forecasting the stated purpose of that study, the standard by which it would be judged. To support this goal, he described the history of human thought as a series of three stages on the road to modern science. The first is a theological stage, which attributes events to the supernatural, such as the will of gods or spirits. The second is a metaphysical stage, which attributes events to fundamental energies or ideas, abstract forces that are reasoned about rather than observed. The third is a positive stage, which explains events by observation, hypothesis, and experimentation. Each stage, in Comte’s view, replaced the one before it, so the positive stage was the most advanced form of thought and the only one that could support reliable prediction. Table 2.1 names the three stages, states how each explains phenomena, and explains the same outbreak in the terms of each.
Table 2.1. Comte’s three stages of human thought, how each explains phenomena, and the same outbreak explained three ways.
| Comte’s stage | How phenomena are explained | The same outbreak, explained three ways |
|---|---|---|
| Theological | Events and phenomena are attributed to the supernatural. | The illness is a punishment or a visitation, and the response is prayer, sacrifice, or penance. |
| Metaphysical | Phenomena are attributed to fundamental energies or ideas. | The illness is an imbalance of humours or a corruption in the air, and the response is to restore balance or purify the air. |
| Positive | Phenomena are explained by observation, hypothesis, and experimentation. | The illness follows exposure to a contaminated water supply; the hypothesis is tested by comparing households, and the response is to change the supply. |
Reading across Table 2.1, notice that only the positive stage explains the outbreak with a claim that could be tested by comparing households. In Comte’s view, the orderly application of a positivist approach would eventually make it possible to predict, and therefore to shape, society. That ambition is the ancestor of every program that promises to change behaviour by applying a theory, and it is also what later critics distrusted, because a science that can shape society raises the question of who does the shaping. Prediction looks forward in time, and so does the fourth assumption, progress, which the next subsection takes up before we return to the third assumption, empirical data.
3.5 Progress and Perfectability
The assumption of progress holds that knowledge accumulates and that time moves toward fuller understanding. Progress in some form belongs to many traditions; for example, in Buddhist and Hindu thought the soul progresses through reincarnation toward enlightenment. In the West, the idea appears early in Plato’s cave, which pictured knowledge as an ascent from shadows to light. Much later, Francis Bacon, in the late sixteenth and early seventeenth centuries, proposed replacing a framework of unchallenged superstition and style over substance with one built on empiricism, progress, and the practical use of knowledge. By this we mean that Bacon objected to accepting ideas because they were traditional or elegantly argued, and wanted instead to accept them because they were supported by observation and proved useful. Bacon’s proposal tied progress directly to science. Because knowledge would be built on evidence rather than on authority, each new finding could be checked and added to what was already known, and because it would be put to use, its growth would also improve human life. Knowledge, in this picture, does not simply change over time; it gets better.
From the Enlightenment onward, almost every major thinker built progress into theory, even when they disagreed about everything else. In biology, Darwin described change through natural selection, and Spencer carried the idea into society as social Darwinism. In philosophy, Hegel described the progression of spirit. In the study of society, Marx, Weber, and Durkheim described the stages through which societies move, and in psychology Freud and Erikson described the stages of psychological development. What these very different theories share is the assumption that time does not stand still: things move forward through stages rather than staying as they are.
For science, the consequence is direct. Doing science, by definition, involves a continuous accumulation of knowledge, and theory is the tactic used to generate investigation. When a health unit says that each evaluation adds to what is known so that the next program can be better, it is speaking from this assumption. Progress, though, depends on agreeing about what counts as knowledge in the first place, and that is the question behind the third assumption, empirical data.
4.1 Empirical Data: How Do We Know What We Know?
The third assumption, empirical data, raises a question that sits underneath every theory: how do we know anything at all? Here we need the word epistemology, which means ideas about how we know what we know. Epistemology is not itself a theory about health or behaviour; it is the set of answers people give to the question of where knowledge comes from. Three classic answers can be put as questions. Do we know something because we can see and touch it, because the thought exists in our minds, or because a sacred text says so? The three questions correspond, in order, to empiricism, rationalism, and a theological or deist orientation.
Scientific theory developed within the first of these, the empiricism of John Locke and David Hume. Empiricism holds that there is an objective reality out there and that knowledge comes to us through the senses. The practical consequence is that science relies on observable, tangible data as evidence, which is why a theory is expected to point to something that can be seen or measured. For example, a claim that a vaccine prevents illness is accepted in this tradition because vaccinated and unvaccinated people can be observed and their rates of illness counted. Rationalism, from René Descartes, gives a different answer: it grounds reality in the mind and in reasoning, so that knowledge is reached by thinking rather than by observing. By this we mean that, for a rationalist, the most secure knowledge is what can be worked out by careful reasoning, in the way a mathematical proof is established without measuring anything in the world. The theological or deist orientation gives a third answer, in which something is known to be true because it has been revealed, through a sacred text or a religious authority, rather than because it has been observed or reasoned out. The three answers are not simply different opinions; each sets a different standard for what would count as a good reason to believe something.
A fourth position, phenomenology, from Wilhelm Dilthey and Edmund Husserl, is best understood as a challenge to empiricism. Phenomenology objects that individuals do the perceiving and that perception is shaped by biology, life experience, culture, and history, so it is never objective. By this we mean that two people looking at the same event bring different histories to it and may genuinely see different things, so there is no view from nowhere. Put briefly, reality is experienced reality. For example, an outside evaluator and a program participant may describe the same program very differently, and phenomenology treats both descriptions as real knowledge rather than dismissing one as bias. Open each of the four tabs below to compare the positions; each tab also says where that position shows up in health behaviour theory or in the practice of health promotion.
Empiricism: knowledge comes through the senses
The tradition of the British empiricists John Locke and David Hume. There is an objective reality out there to be perceived, and our ideas about existence stem from those perceptions. Science in this tradition relies on observable, tangible data as evidence, and a theory is expected to say something about the observable relationships between phenomena. This standard of evidence is built into most of the theories in this course.
Rationalism: reality is grounded in the mind
The tradition of René Descartes, in which reality is based in the mind rather than in an objective world out there, and knowledge is reached through reasoning. It survives in health behaviour theory in the assumption that people reason their way to decisions, which cognitive theories of health behaviour depend on.
Phenomenology: reality is experienced reality
The tradition of Wilhelm Dilthey and Edmund Husserl. Because individuals do the perceiving, and individual perception is shaped by biology, life experience, culture, and history, perception is never objective, and what we know of reality can never extend beyond our experience of it. This is the main challenge to the empiricist standard, and the reason qualitative and community-based methods have a place in health promotion research.
Theological or deist: knowledge is revealed
Something is known to be true because a sacred text or revelation says so. In the Middle Ages this orientation and the inquiry into natural order were the same project. Many people health promotion works with hold beliefs about health and healing within this orientation, and the point about ground rules from the previous section applies: such beliefs are meaningful within their context, whether or not they meet an empirical standard.
Across the tabs, the contrast that matters most is between empiricism, which treats the senses as reporting an objective reality, and phenomenology, which holds that every perception carries the perceiver’s culture and history. Rationalism survives in the assumption that people reason their way to decisions, and the theological orientation describes how many of the people health promotion serves hold their beliefs about health and healing.
Keep these terms apart
Epistemology is the study of how we know what we know. Empiricism is one answer to that question: knowledge comes through the senses. Positivism is not an epistemology in this list but a program built on empiricism, the effort, associated with Comte, to build a science of society from empirically verified knowledge. A question that describes someone insisting that only what an outside observer can measure counts as evidence is describing empiricism; a question about building laws of society to predict and shape it is describing positivism.
The empirical standard of evidence is built into most of the theories in this course. Whether it is always enough is the question the next subsection asks.
4.2 Is the Empirical Standard Always Enough?
The discussion of empirical data closes with a question that the lesson deliberately leaves open, and that you should carry into every evaluation you design.
An open question: is the standard of evidence always enough?
The standard of evidence is embedded in many of the theories we will study, and we must also ask if it is always enough. Phenomenology supplies one reason for doubt: if perception is always shaped by culture and history, then one observer’s "objective" data carry that observer’s ground rules with them. For example, an evaluator who decides in advance which outcomes to measure has already made a judgment about what matters, and the people a program serves might have chosen different outcomes. The data can be accurate and still leave out what those people would count as success. Keep the question open; it returns in the lessons on culture and on evaluation.
Asking the question does not mean abandoning evidence or Popper’s test. A sensible response keeps falsification while widening what counts as an observation. By this we mean that an evaluation can still demand that a program’s claims be able to fail, while accepting more kinds of information as evidence of whether they did. In practice this involves three steps. The first is to state the program’s theory explicitly, including constructs drawn from the community’s own account, so that the community’s understanding of the program is part of what is tested. The second is to derive predictions that could fail, which keeps the evaluation honest. The third is to gather both measured outcomes and systematic accounts of participants’ experience, and to treat disagreement between the two as information rather than as noise. For example, if the numbers show little change but participants describe a real difference in their lives, that gap is a finding worth explaining, not an error to be removed. Popper’s own condition supports this approach, because a theory validated elsewhere has not yet been tested in situations relevant to a new community. Worked Example 2.3 applies all four assumptions and the question of evidence to a real kind of decision. As you read it, watch for which assumptions the funder’s request draws on, and which the community’s account shares or challenges.
Worked Example 2.3: Whose Evidence Counts?
The case. A First Nations health organization in British Columbia runs a land-based wellness program for youth, built around time on the territory with Elders, language, and traditional foods. A funder asks for an evaluation showing measurable, generalizable outcomes, ideally with a comparison group. The organization describes what the program does in terms of relationship, identity, and balance, and it draws on Etuaptmumk, or Two-Eyed Seeing, a guiding principle brought forward by Mi’kmaw Elder Albert Marshall: seeing with the strengths of Indigenous knowledge from one eye and the strengths of Western knowledge from the other, and using both together. The evaluation team must decide what evidence to gather.
Step 1: Identify the assumptions behind the funder’s request. "Measurable" draws on empirical data, the empiricist view that what counts is what an outside observer can observe and measure. "Generalizable" draws on order and predictability, the expectation that a stable relation between program and outcome will hold in other settings. The wish to add the result to a body of evidence that guides future funding draws on progress.
Step 2: Identify what the community’s account challenges and what it shares. The account challenges the empiricist claim that only an outside observer’s measures count: relationship, identity, and balance are experienced by the young people and their communities, which is the phenomenological point that reality is experienced reality. It does not reject evidence, however. Two-Eyed Seeing explicitly keeps the strengths of Western knowledge, so the community shares the commitment to learning from what is observed.
Step 3: Design an evaluation with two eyes. The team states the program’s theory explicitly, using constructs from the community’s own account (relationship, identity, balance) alongside measurable outcomes. It derives predictions that could fail, gathers both measured outcomes and systematic accounts from youth and Elders, and treats any disagreement between the two as information. It also recognizes that a theory validated elsewhere has not been tested in situations relevant to this program, so the evaluation is itself the test.
What this shows. The four assumptions are not right or wrong in the abstract; they are ground rules, and naming them lets an evaluation team see which rules each party brings. The mistake to avoid is choosing between "real evidence" and "community knowledge" as if one had to be discarded; the stronger design keeps Popper’s test and widens what counts as an observation.
You should now be able to see how theory, in this context, incorporates order, predictability, empirical data, and progress, and where each assumption can be questioned. The next two sections turn from the ground rules to the specific disciplines that produced the theories public health uses.
The key takeaways below gather what this section has established: why theory is situated in the Western tradition, the four assumptions and their history, Comte’s positivism, and the four answers to how we know what we know. The knowledge check that follows asks you to apply them to short cases.
Key Takeaways
- 3.1 The term theory takes its meaning from the Western philosophical and scientific tradition, which ran from the Greek philosophers through Europe and North America and was influenced by thinkers outside its mainstream such as Avicenna, Averroes, Confucius, and Chuang Tzu. Situating theory there places it in context; it does not rank it above traditions such as Confucianism, Taoism, or Navajo cosmology, all of which hold elaborate ideas of natural order. If a question suggests that naming the tradition means claiming it is superior, the correct response is that situating a concept and privileging it are different acts. The practical value of situating is that it lets you ask which assumptions a theory carries into a new setting.
- 3.2 Four assumptions are built into theory in this tradition: order and regularity (nature has a discoverable, usable order), predictability (know the rules and you can forecast the outcome), empirical data (knowledge comes through the senses), and progress (knowledge accumulates over time). They are linked, since predictability depends on order and progress depends on evidence that can be built upon. When a question describes a planner’s reasoning, look for the key word: a forecast points to predictability, a demand for measured outcomes points to empirical data, and a claim that knowledge keeps improving points to progress.
- 3.3 The history of order runs from Democritus and Aristotle, who looked for a classifiable and useful order in nature, through the Middle Ages, when the church’s monopoly on scholarship made natural order the same as divine order (Aquinas), to the Enlightenment, which shifted explanation from the divine to the secular and pictured the universe as Newton’s clockwork. In the nineteenth century, Comte’s positivism sought laws of human behaviour on the same model. The shift in ways of knowing coincided with the Industrial Revolution and a shift of power toward those who used science to produce goods. A common trap is to think the Enlightenment discovered order; what it changed was the source of explanation, from God to reason and evidence, while keeping the assumption of order.
- 3.4 Predictability is the child of order: if the rules are known, outcomes can be forecast, an expectation we rely on in every weather report and prescription. Comte made prediction the goal of the human sciences and described three stages of thought: theological (supernatural causes), metaphysical (fundamental energies or ideas), and positive (observation, hypothesis, and experimentation). His hope that positive science would let us predict, and therefore shape, society is the ancestor of every theory-based program. To place an explanation in one of Comte’s stages, ask what it appeals to: a punishment or visitation is theological, an imbalance or corruption is metaphysical, and a tested comparison is positive.
- 3.5 Progress is the assumption that knowledge accumulates and that time moves toward fuller understanding, an idea that runs from Plato’s cave and Francis Bacon to nearly every major thinker since the Enlightenment, including Darwin, Spencer, Hegel, Marx, Weber, Durkheim, Freud, and Erikson. For science it means that doing research is a continuous accumulation of knowledge, with theory as the tactic used to generate investigation. If a question quotes someone saying that each study builds on the last so that later programs will be better, the assumption at work is progress, not predictability, which is about forecasting a specific outcome.
- 4.1 Epistemology asks how we know what we know. Empiricism (Locke, Hume) says knowledge comes through the senses from an objective reality, and scientific theory developed within it; rationalism (Descartes) grounds reality in the mind and in reasoning; phenomenology (Dilthey, Husserl) holds that perception is shaped by biology, experience, culture, and history, so reality is experienced reality; and the theological or deist orientation holds that knowledge is revealed in a sacred text. To classify a statement, find its source of knowledge: the senses, the mind, the person’s experience, or revelation. Do not confuse empiricism, an answer about how we know, with positivism, Comte’s program of building a science of society on empirical knowledge.
- 4.2 The empirical standard of evidence is built into most health behaviour theories, and the lesson asks whether it is always enough. Phenomenology gives one reason for doubt: an outside observer’s "objective" measures carry that observer’s ground rules, so they may miss what a program changes for the people in it. The answer is not to abandon evidence but to keep Popper’s test while widening what counts as an observation, for example by using constructs from a community’s own account and gathering both measured outcomes and participants’ experience. In a case question, identify which assumptions each party brings, then propose a design that both could accept.
1. A classmate says: "If the lesson says theory comes from the Western tradition, it must be claiming that Western knowledge is superior." Which response best reflects the lesson?
2. What characterized inquiry into the order of nature during the Middle Ages, and what changed during the Enlightenment?
3. A health unit forecasts that raising the price of sugary drinks will reduce consumption, because past increases in tobacco prices reduced smoking. Which assumption of the Western tradition is doing the most work in that forecast?
4. During an outbreak, a community explains the illness as an imbalance caused by a corruption in the air, and responds by trying to purify the air. In Comte’s scheme, which stage of thought does this explanation belong to?
5. A health unit director says: "Each evaluation we run adds to what we know, so the next generation of programs will be better than this one, and our theories tell us what to investigate next." Which assumption of the Western tradition is she expressing?
6. A researcher argues: "Because every observer perceives through the filter of their own culture, history, and experience, what we know of health can never extend beyond how it is experienced." Which epistemological tradition is this?
7. A provincial ministry announces that it will fund only programs whose theory has been "validated by randomized trials with measurable outcomes." A community organization serving newcomers argues that its program, built on how families themselves explain illness and healing, cannot be judged on those terms alone. Which pairing correctly names the epistemology behind each side?
8. Which standard of evidence for the newcomer program takes seriously the question of whether the empirical standard is always enough, without abandoning Popper’s falsification test?
✦ Pass the knowledge check with 100% to continue
Antecedents I: Psychology and Social Psychology
⏱ Estimated reading time: 18 minutes
Overview
With the ground rules established, this section turns to the disciplines that actually produced the theories public health uses, beginning with the two that contributed most: psychology and social psychology. Each school of thought makes its own assumption about where behaviour comes from, whether in the environment, in thought, in a drive toward growth, or in the pull of the group. Those assumptions travel into the named theories of health behaviour and into every program built on them, so learning to recognize them is a practical skill.
Learning Objectives
- 5.1 Describe behaviourist psychology, including classical conditioning (Pavlov), operant conditioning (Skinner), reinforcement, shaping, deconditioning, and behaviour modification.
- 5.2 Describe cognitive psychology, Piaget’s assimilation and accommodation, and the cognitive assumption shared by the Health Belief Model, the Theory of Planned Behavior, and Social-Cognitive Theory.
- 5.3 Explain the humanistic emphasis on agency and Maslow's hierarchy of needs, and explain how they inform the philosophy of health promotion.
- 5.4 Summarize what social psychology contributes: obedience to authority, groupthink and conformity, dissonance and self-perception, and Fishbein and Ajzen’s placement of intention between attitudes and behaviour.
- 5.5 Identify the school of psychology whose assumption about the source of behaviour a health promotion program relies on.
5.1 Behaviourist Psychology: The Black Box
We can call the more specific lines of thought that feed current behavioural theory in public health its antecedents. By this we mean the earlier bodies of work from which today’s health behaviour theories borrowed their main ideas, in the way a family tree shows where a person’s traits came from. The primary fields are psychology and social psychology. Psychology has many subfields, however, and only some have left a mark. Freudian psychology, for all its cultural influence, has contributed little to public health behavioural theory. In contrast, behaviourist, cognitive, and humanistic psychology have all contributed a great deal, and so has social psychology.
The three psychological schools are easiest to tell apart by asking where each one locates the source of behaviour. Behaviourism locates it outside the person, in the environment acting on reflexive responses. Cognitive psychology locates it inside the person, in internal processes such as perception, memory, and judgment. Humanistic psychology also looks inside the person, but to individual agency and a drive toward growth rather than to calculation. Keeping this one question in mind will help you recognize each school when you meet it inside a program. Behaviourism is the oldest, so it comes first.
Behaviourist psychology, dating from the late nineteenth century, holds that behaviour is learned, or conditioned, through stimulus and response. Thinking and emotion are given little importance because they are not considered essential to behaviour change; what matters is the effect of the environment on the brain’s reflexive responses. Internal mental processes are treated as a black box: a stimulus goes in, a behaviour comes out. By this we mean that a behaviourist does not deny that people think and feel; rather, the behaviourist sets those processes aside as unnecessary for explaining what people do, and looks only at what happens around a person and how the person responds. The first behaviourists were Russian, most famously Ivan Pavlov, who rang a bell while placing meat powder on a dog’s tongue, which made the dog salivate. After many repetitions the bell alone produced salivation, even when no food was present. This is classical conditioning: a stimulus repeatedly paired with one that already produces a response comes to produce the response on its own. The bell had no natural link to salivation, but because it kept arriving with the food, the dog came to respond to the bell as if it were the food. The same process explains why a cue that has often accompanied a behaviour, such as a morning coffee that has always come with a cigarette, can trigger the urge to repeat it. In the United States, Edward Thorndike and John Watson carried the school forward.
B.F. Skinner developed the modern approach, operant conditioning. It rests on the same assumption of a reflexive link between environment and behaviour as classical conditioning, but the machinery is richer, and each part of it gives a program designer something to work with. First, a behaviour is conditioned through positive and negative reinforcers, the consequences that follow it. Second, reinforcers can be delivered on different schedules, and the schedule affects how well a behaviour is maintained. Third, a behaviour can be learned through shaping. By this we mean that a person is not expected to reach the target behaviour all at once; instead, approximations that come closer and closer to the target are reinforced along the way. Fourth, behaviours can be deconditioned, so that a learned link between a cue and a behaviour is broken. Taken together, these techniques make up the approach called behaviour modification. The difference from Pavlov is worth noting: classical conditioning pairs two stimuli before a response, whereas operant conditioning works through what follows a behaviour. Behaviourist methods are used today in smoking cessation and other addiction treatment, and the basic assumptions about learning through reinforcement appear inside a number of health behaviour theories. Worked Example 2.4 applies this vocabulary to a cessation program; as you read it, match each program feature to a behaviourist process, and notice the one question the program never needs to ask.
Worked Example 2.4: Reading a Cessation Program in Behaviourist Terms
The case. A provincial quitline phones participants with congratulations after each verified smoke-free week. Its reward plan recognizes a first week without smoking, then two weeks, then a month. A counsellor also works with one participant who reaches for a cigarette every time the phone rings.
Step 1: Identify the behaviour and the population. The behaviour is smoking, and the target is sustained abstinence among adults enrolled in the quitline.
Step 2: Map each feature onto a behaviourist process. The weekly congratulatory call is a positive reinforcer delivered on a schedule. Rewarding one week, then two, then a month reinforces closer and closer approximations of the target of lasting abstinence, which is shaping. The ringing phone has become a stimulus that triggers smoking, a learned association of the kind Pavlov demonstrated, and the counsellor’s work to break that link is deconditioning. Together these make up behaviour modification.
Step 3: State what the analysis implies for the program. Every feature can be designed and evaluated by watching behaviour alone: how often reinforcement arrives, which cues trigger smoking, and whether abstinence lasts. The program never needs to ask what the participant thinks about smoking, which is both the strength of the approach (it is concrete and measurable) and its limit (it is silent about beliefs, meanings, and circumstances).
What this shows. Behaviourist assumptions are easy to spot once you know the vocabulary. The mistake to avoid is calling the phone-and-cigarette link a belief or an attitude; it is a conditioned association, and the remedy is deconditioning, not persuasion.
Behaviourism deliberately left the black box closed. The next school made the inside of the box its whole subject.
5.2 Cognitive Psychology: Inside the Box
Cognitive psychology treats the thinking process itself as the source of behaviour. Where behaviourism regarded internal processes as insignificant, here the inside of the black box is exactly what is of interest: perception, memory, decision making, interpretation, reasoning, and judgment. Jean Piaget, one of the most influential thinkers in this school, described two ways we process information. Assimilation fits new information into existing categories of knowledge. By this we mean that the person keeps their current way of understanding the world and finds a place for the new information within it, so the information is absorbed without changing anything. Accommodation, in contrast, changes or adapts existing beliefs to incorporate the new information. Here the new information does not fit, so the person revises the category itself. For example, a student who hears that vaping carries risks and files it under "everything is supposed to be dangerous now" is assimilating, because the message has been absorbed into an old belief and leaves that belief intact. A student who revises the belief that vaping is harmless is accommodating, because the message has changed how the student thinks about vaping. The distinction matters for health promotion, because a message that is merely assimilated may be heard and remembered without changing anything. Piaget is also known for his four stages of cognitive development: sensorimotor, preoperational, concrete operational, and formal operational.
For this course, cognitive psychology matters because it is an important part of the Health Belief Model, the Theory of Planned Behavior, and Social-Cognitive Theory, among others. All of them assume that internal processes, to one degree or another, determine behaviour. By this we mean that, in these theories, what a person does follows from what goes on in their head: calculations of risk and benefit, expectations about outcomes, and so on. This is the opposite of the behaviourist position, which set those same processes aside as a black box. The constructs of the Health Belief Model, for example, are cognitions. A program that tries to change what people believe, rather than letting a message slide into old categories, is aiming for accommodation. The third school objected to both behaviourism and Freud on different grounds, and the next subsection turns to it.
5.3 Humanistic Psychology: Agency and Growth
Humanistic psychology developed partly as a reaction to what some saw as the mechanistic and determinist character of behaviourism and Freudian psychology. To call a school mechanistic and determinist is to say that it treats people as if their behaviour were fully produced by forces acting on them, whether rewards in the environment or drives beneath awareness, with little room for choice. Humanistic psychology rejects that picture. It draws on a philosophical tradition that emphasizes individual agency, the capacity of people to make choices and determine their future. By this we mean that people are treated as the authors of their own lives rather than as the products of their conditioning. Its basic assumption follows from this: human beings ultimately desire to grow and attain their potential. Abraham Maslow’s hierarchy of needs adds a condition to that assumption. Before people can pursue higher-level growth, they must first satisfy a set of needs, starting with basic physiological needs such as food and shelter and moving through emotional and social needs such as safety and belonging. In other words, the drive toward growth is real, but it cannot take priority while more basic needs go unmet. A person worried about where they will sleep tonight is unlikely to be thinking about long-term goals for their health.
The ties between this school and any specific public health theory are not always direct. Its influence is on the philosophy of public health, visible in definitions of health promotion as improving quality of life for the public and promoting healthy lifestyles and choices. Health promotion, in part, therefore involves promoting the conditions, including housing, employment, and access to health care, that allow people to live healthier and higher-quality lives. In practice, Maslow’s hierarchy gives a planner a check to run before launching any program aimed at higher-level choices: are the people it serves fed, safe, and housed? If they are not, the program is unlikely to reach them until those needs are addressed. Worked Example 2.5 looks at a Canadian study whose whole design follows from this assumption. As you read it, ask what a designer from each of the other schools would have proposed instead.
Worked Example 2.5: At Home/Chez Soi and Housing First
The case. Between 2009 and 2013, the Mental Health Commission of Canada ran At Home/Chez Soi, a large randomized study of Housing First for people experiencing homelessness and serious mental illness, in Vancouver, Winnipeg, Toronto, Montréal, and Moncton. Housing First reverses the usual sequence: participants are offered permanent housing immediately, with supports, rather than being required to complete treatment or demonstrate sobriety first.
Step 1: Identify the behaviour and the population. The population is adults experiencing homelessness and serious mental illness. The outcomes of interest are stable housing and movement toward recovery.
Step 2: Map the design onto a school. The design is a wager about human motivation. It assumes that a person without shelter cannot be expected to work on anything higher up, which is Maslow’s hierarchy of needs, and that once basic needs are secure people will move toward recovery and the lives they want, which is the humanistic assumption of agency and a drive toward growth. The school is humanistic psychology.
Step 3: Compare the alternatives. A behaviourist designer might have kept the usual sequence and made housing a reward that follows sobriety or treatment, a reinforcer contingent on behaviour. A cognitive designer might have focused on changing beliefs about treatment through education or counselling. Each would miss the humanistic point that a person struggling for shelter is unlikely to engage with higher-level goals, whatever the reward or the information.
What this shows. Housing First is Maslow’s hierarchy turned into policy. The common mistake is to call it behaviourist because housing is "given"; in fact housing is not contingent on any behaviour, so no reinforcement is involved.
All three schools so far study the individual mind. Social psychology keeps the individual as its subject but places that individual among others.
5.4 Social Psychology: The Individual in the Group
Psychology as a whole is concerned with the mental processes and behaviour of individuals. Social psychology is concerned with how individuals, and their mental processes, interact with their social surroundings: groups, relationships, and other social units. By this we mean that social psychology still studies the individual person, but it asks how that person’s thoughts and actions change because other people are present, watching, or setting expectations. Its subject matter is broad. It includes group dynamics, authority and legitimacy, emotion and its expression, aggression, self and identity, motivation, gender, group prejudice (the process of othering), norms, and attitudes. Health behaviour is often complex and socially motivated, so this subject matter connects directly to several theories in public health.
Several lines of work stand out. The first concerns authority. Stanley Milgram showed how far ordinary people would go in administering what they believed were harmful shocks when an authority told them to, which demonstrated that authority is a powerful social force in its own right. By this we mean that the instruction itself, coming from someone in a position of authority, was enough to lead many people to act against their own judgment. The second concerns the group. Irving Janis studied groupthink in government decision making, the way a group converges on one course and suppresses dissent. In a group affected by groupthink, members who have doubts keep quiet because the pressure to agree outweighs the wish to raise them, so the group can reach a poor decision that few of its members would have made alone. Crandall found the same conformity process at work in a very different setting, where it shaped eating behaviour among the members of a sorority. In both cases, belonging to a group changed what members thought and did, which is why health behaviour cannot always be explained by looking at individuals one at a time.
The third line of work concerns attitudes and how they relate to behaviour, and here there were competing explanations. One early view held that when behaviour contradicts attitudes, the resulting dissonance is uncomfortable, and people adjust their attitudes to relieve it. Another view, self-perception, held instead that people infer their attitudes from watching their own behaviour. In other words, dissonance theory says the attitude bends to fit the behaviour because the mismatch is uncomfortable, while self-perception says the attitude is read off the behaviour in the first place. Martin Fishbein and Icek Ajzen then reorganized the question by placing intention between attitude and behaviour, with attitudes and perceived norms acting on intention. Rather than treating attitude as the direct cause of behaviour, their proposal describes a step in between, and that step is where many later health programs try to intervene.
The six cards below take these lines of work one at a time: Milgram’s studies of obedience, the work of Janis and Crandall on groupthink and conformity, dissonance, self-perception, Fishbein and Ajzen’s placement of intention, and norms and othering. Each card gives a fuller account and a health example.
Milgram:
obedience
Stanley Milgram tested whether ordinary people would administer what they believed were harmful electric shocks to another person when instructed to do so by someone presented as an authority. Many did. The widely publicized results raised hard questions about people’s willingness to set aside their own moral judgment to obey or conform. For public health, it is a reminder that authority is a social force in its own right, for good and ill.
Janis, Crandall:
groupthink
Irving Janis studied groupthink, the way government decision-making groups converge on a course of action and suppress dissent. Crandall examined the same phenomenon in a different setting: the spread of eating-disordered behaviour within a sorority, where group membership shaped what members did. Belonging to a group changes both behaviour and thought.
Dissonance
Attitudes are complex connections of belief, identity, and social relations, and social psychologists have long been interested in their consistency with behaviour. One early position held that when behaviour contradicts attitudes, the resulting dissonance is uncomfortable, and people tend to rationalize or adjust their attitudes to resolve it. A person who keeps smoking may come to believe the risks are exaggerated.
Self-perception
A second early view held that people infer their attitudes over time from observing how they behave in similar situations. Someone who has walked to work every day for a month may conclude that they are the kind of person who values activity. Programs that get people to act first, and let attitudes follow, draw on this idea.
Fishbein, Ajzen:
intentions
Martin Fishbein and Icek Ajzen proposed intention as an intermediate factor between attitudes and behaviour. Attitudes are one of several influences on intention; another is the perceived norms and opinions of significant others. Intention then predicts behaviour. This is the seed of the Theory of Reasoned Action and the Theory of Planned Behavior.
Norms and
othering
Two further topics on the social psychology list matter for health promotion. Norms, the shared expectations of a group, shape what members see as ordinary; a great deal of adolescent substance use tracks what young people believe their peers do. Othering, the process by which a group defines outsiders as different and lesser, underlies stigma toward people who use drugs, people living with HIV, and many other groups public health serves.
Two of the cards are easy to confuse, so the distinction is worth stating plainly.
Dissonance or self-perception?
Both link attitudes to behaviour, but they start from different places. In dissonance, the person already holds an attitude that their behaviour contradicts, and they adjust the attitude to relieve the discomfort: a smoker comes to believe the warnings are exaggerated. In self-perception, the person has no settled attitude and infers one from watching their own behaviour over time: someone who has walked to work for a month concludes they are the kind of person who values activity. Ask whether a conflicting attitude came first.
The obedience studies (Milgram, 1963) and the dissonance experiments (Festinger and Carlsmith, 1959) remain among the most cited in the discipline. The Fishbein and Ajzen proposal deserves a diagram, because it reorganized the attitude-behaviour question in a way that health promotion adopted wholesale. Rather than asking whether attitudes cause behaviour directly, it placed intention in between, with attitudes and perceived norms acting on intention. Figure 2.1 draws that arrangement.
Figure 2.1. Attitude toward the behaviour and perceived norms (significant others) act on intention, which predicts behaviour, after Fishbein and Ajzen.
Figure 2.1 is the seed of the Theory of Reasoned Action and its revision, the Theory of Planned Behavior. A program that turns a favourable attitude into a stated plan, or that corrects what people believe their peers do, is working on the boxes in this figure. With all four schools described, the last step is to recognize them inside real programs.
5.5 Which School Is Behind This Program?
Each school makes a different assumption about where behaviour comes from, and programs inherit those assumptions whether or not their designers say so. The quickest way to identify the school is to ask what the program is trying to change. A program that changes rewards, schedules, or cues is behaviourist. One that changes beliefs, risk calculations, or expectations is cognitive. One that secures basic needs or builds on what people want to become is humanistic. And one that works on norms, group membership, authority, or the step from attitude to intention is social psychological. Many programs draw on more than one school, so pick the one doing the most work. Before trying the matcher, open the three tabs below to review the behaviourist, cognitive, and humanistic schools side by side; each tab gives a fuller account of the school, names its key figures, and says where it appears in health promotion.
Behaviourist psychology: the black box
An early school dating from the late nineteenth century, in which behaviour is learned or conditioned through stimulus-response mechanisms. Thinking and emotion are given little importance because they are not considered essential to behaviour change; what matters is the effect of the environment on the brain’s reflexive responses. Internal mental processes are treated as a black box: a stimulus goes in, a behaviour comes out. The first behaviourists were Russian, most famously Ivan Pavlov (1849 to 1936). Pavlov rang a bell while placing meat powder on a dog’s tongue, which made the dog salivate. After many repetitions, the bell alone produced salivation: the conditioned stimulus had become associated with the meat powder. This is classical conditioning. In the United States, Edward Thorndike and John Watson were well-known early behaviourists.
B.F. Skinner (1904 to 1990) developed the modern approach, operant conditioning. It rests on the same assumptions about reflexive links between environment and behaviour, but it involves more steps. A behaviour is conditioned through positive and negative reinforcers; reinforcers can be delivered on different schedules, which have different effects on how well a behaviour is maintained; a behaviour can be learned through shaping, by reinforcing approximations that come closer and closer to the target; and behaviours can be deconditioned. The whole approach is called behaviour modification. Behaviourist methods are used today in smoking cessation and other addiction treatment, and the basic assumptions about learning through reinforcement appear in a number of health behaviour theories.
Cognitive psychology: inside the box
Cognitive psychology treats the thinking process itself as the source of behaviour. Where behaviourism regarded internal processes as insignificant, here the inside of the black box is exactly what is of interest: perception, memory, decision making, interpretation, reasoning, and judgment, among other faculties. Jean Piaget, one of the most influential thinkers in this school, described two ways we process information. Assimilation fits new information into existing categories of knowledge; accommodation changes or adapts existing beliefs to incorporate the new information. A student who hears that vaping carries risks and files it under "everything is supposed to be dangerous now" is assimilating; a student who revises the belief that vaping is harmless is accommodating. Piaget is also famous for his stages of cognitive development: sensorimotor, preoperational, concrete operational, and formal operational.
Cognitive psychology is an important part of the Health Belief Model, the Theory of Planned Behavior, and Social-Cognitive Theory, among others. All of them assume that internal processes, to one degree or another, determine behaviour: calculations of risk and benefit, expectations about outcomes, and so on. The constructs of the Health Belief Model, for example, are cognitions.
Humanistic psychology: agency and growth
Humanistic psychology developed partly as a reaction to what some saw as the mechanistic and determinist character of behaviourism and Freudian psychology. It draws on a philosophical tradition that emphasizes individual agency, the capacity of people to make choices and determine their future. Its basic assumption is that human beings ultimately desire to grow and attain their potential. Abraham Maslow’s hierarchy of needs adds a condition: before people can pursue that higher-level growth, they must first satisfy a set of needs, from basic physiological needs through emotional and social ones.
The ties between this school and any specific public health theory are not always direct. Its influence is on the philosophy of public health, visible in definitions of health promotion as improving quality of life for the public and promoting healthy lifestyles and choices. Health promotion, in part, therefore involves promoting the conditions, including housing, employment, and access to health care, that allow people to live healthier and higher-quality lives. That is Maslow’s hierarchy expressed as policy.
Table 2.2 adds social psychology and sets all four schools side by side: where behaviour comes from, the key figures, and where each school appears in health promotion.
Table 2.2. Four schools of psychology compared: where behaviour comes from, key figures, and where each appears in health promotion.
| School | Where behaviour comes from | Key figures | Where it appears in health promotion |
|---|---|---|---|
| Behaviourist | The environment acting on reflexive responses; conditioning and reinforcement | Pavlov, Thorndike, Watson, Skinner | Smoking cessation and addiction treatment; reinforcement assumptions inside several theories |
| Cognitive | Internal processes: perception, memory, judgment, calculations of risk and benefit | Piaget | Health Belief Model, Theory of Planned Behavior, Social-Cognitive Theory |
| Humanistic | Individual agency and a drive toward growth, once basic needs are met | Maslow | The philosophy of health promotion: quality of life, healthy choices, and the conditions that allow them |
| Social psychology | Interaction between the individual and groups, norms, authority, and relationships | Milgram, Janis, Crandall, Fishbein and Ajzen | Theories built on norms, social influence, and the attitude-intention-behaviour chain |
With the comparison in view, try Interactive 2.3. It describes eight programs and offers four options for each (behaviourist, cognitive, humanistic, and social psychology). Click the school whose core assumption each program relies on and read the feedback, especially for any you miss.
📊 Interactive 2.3: Match the program to its school.
Click one option per program.A quitline offers small gift cards for each verified week without smoking, with the value rising for each consecutive week.
A screening decision aid lays out the chances of benefit and of harm so that each person can weigh them before choosing.
A program provides permanent housing immediately, without requiring sobriety or treatment first, on the premise that people cannot work on recovery while unsheltered.
A campus campaign publicizes accurate figures on how many students actually drink heavily, to correct exaggerated beliefs about peers.
A children’s dental clinic follows every checkup with a short, enjoyable activity so that visits become associated with something pleasant.
A vaccination program asks people who say they support vaccination to write down when and where they will get their dose.
A youth program begins by asking each participant who they want to become, and organizes its supports around that goal.
A nutrition program discovers that participants fit every new food message into the belief that "healthy food is expensive," and redesigns its lessons to change that belief directly.
The same habit applies to a program you are asked to design, because choosing a design means choosing an assumption about where behaviour comes from. For example, suppose you are asked to reduce vaping among grade 9 students. A behaviourist design would reward vape-free weeks on a growing schedule and break the cues that trigger use, because it assumes the environment drives the behaviour. A cognitive design would aim to change the belief that vaping is harmless, because it assumes behaviour follows from what students think. A social psychological design would correct exaggerated beliefs about how many peers vape and turn favourable attitudes into stated intentions, because it assumes the group and the step from attitude to intention matter most. Whatever the design, however, the humanistic check comes first: students who are hungry, unsafe, or without stable housing are unlikely to engage with a program aimed at higher-level choices. For all their differences, the psychological schools share one feature: their unit of analysis is the individual, even when, as in social psychology, the individual is placed among others. The next section moves to the disciplines whose starting point is the group, the culture, and the system.
The key takeaways below gather what this section has established about the four schools and the assumption each passes on, and the knowledge check that follows asks you to identify those assumptions in short cases.
HEAL connection: the schools of psychology
The HEAL Framework for Wellbeing introduced in Lesson 1 names several processes that correspond to the schools in this section. Behaviourist psychology corresponds to conditioning, the process by which environments train behaviour through repeated reinforcement and hold habits in place. Cognitive and social psychology correspond to reasoned action, cognition, and learning, the processes by which beliefs and expectations guide action and are updated by experience.
In HEAL these processes sit downstream of social position and material circumstance. The sociological and anthropological starting points in Section 6 move in that upstream direction, toward structure, capital, and culture.
Key Takeaways
- 5.1 Behaviourism treats the mind as a black box and explains behaviour as learned through stimulus and response. Pavlov’s classical conditioning shows how a stimulus paired with one that already produces a response comes to produce it alone; Skinner’s operant conditioning adds positive and negative reinforcers, schedules of reinforcement, shaping by rewarding closer approximations, and deconditioning, together called behaviour modification. Thorndike and Watson carried the school forward in the United States, and its methods live on in smoking cessation and addiction treatment. In a case, rewards on a schedule point to reinforcement, rewards for steadily longer stretches point to shaping, and breaking a cue-behaviour link points to deconditioning; none of these requires asking what the person thinks.
- 5.2 Cognitive psychology opens the black box and treats thinking (perception, memory, decision making, reasoning, judgment) as the source of behaviour. Piaget described assimilation, fitting new information into existing categories, and accommodation, changing existing beliefs to take in new information, along with four stages of cognitive development. The Health Belief Model, the Theory of Planned Behavior, and Social-Cognitive Theory all carry the cognitive assumption that internal calculations of risk, benefit, and expected outcome shape behaviour. To tell assimilation from accommodation, ask whether the old belief survived: if the message was filed under an existing belief, that is assimilation; if the belief changed, that is accommodation.
- 5.3 Humanistic psychology arose partly in reaction to the mechanistic, determinist feel of behaviourism and Freud. It emphasizes agency and assumes that people want to grow toward their potential, while Maslow’s hierarchy of needs adds that basic physiological, emotional, and social needs must be met first. Its influence on public health is on the field’s philosophy rather than on one named theory: health promotion as improving quality of life and creating conditions such as housing, employment, and access to care. Housing First is the clearest example. When a case puts basic needs first, or asks whether people are fed, safe, and housed before a program starts, the school at work is humanistic.
- 5.4 Social psychology studies the individual among others: Milgram on obedience to authority, Janis on groupthink, Crandall on conformity in eating behaviour, and two early views of attitudes, dissonance (people adjust attitudes that conflict with their behaviour) and self-perception (people infer attitudes from their own behaviour). Fishbein and Ajzen placed intention between attitudes and behaviour, with attitudes and perceived norms acting on intention, the arrangement drawn in Figure 2.1 and the seed of the Theory of Reasoned Action and the Theory of Planned Behavior. Norms and othering also matter for health promotion, from peer beliefs about substance use to stigma. Keep dissonance and self-perception apart by asking whether a conflicting attitude came first.
- 5.5 Every program carries an assumption about where behaviour comes from, whether or not its designers wrote it down. Identify it by asking what the program changes: rewards and cues (behaviourist), beliefs and risk calculations (cognitive), basic needs and personal goals (humanistic), or norms, groups, authority, and intentions (social psychology). When a program draws on several schools, name the one doing the most work and say why. All four schools share one limit: their unit of analysis is the individual, which is exactly what the disciplines in the next section question.
1. A cessation counsellor notices that a client reaches for a cigarette every time she pours a morning coffee, and works with her to break the link between the two. Which idea from behaviourist psychology is the counsellor applying?
2. The Health Belief Model, the Theory of Planned Behavior, and Social-Cognitive Theory share an assumption inherited from cognitive psychology. What is it?
3. A person who continues to smoke gradually comes to believe that the health warnings are exaggerated. Which social psychological idea best describes this shift?
4. A provincial health promotion strategy states that its goal is to improve quality of life by ensuring access to housing, employment, and health care so that people can make healthy choices. Which school of psychology is the general influence behind this philosophy?
5. A workplace program posts each team’s weekly step counts on a shared board and asks every team to set a group goal, on the premise that people walk more when they see that walking is what their group does. Which school’s assumption is doing the most work?
6. A school district in Manitoba wants to reduce vaping among grade 9 students. Which of these program ideas is built on the social psychological assumption about where behaviour comes from?
7. Before launching any vaping program for these grade 9 students, what would Maslow’s hierarchy of needs lead the planner to check?
✦ Pass the knowledge check with 100% to continue
Antecedents II: Sociology, Cultural Anthropology, and Ecology
⏱ Estimated reading time: 18 minutes
Overview
The psychological schools of the last section share a starting point: the individual. This section turns to three disciplines that start elsewhere, with the group, the culture, and the system. Sociology and cultural anthropology contributed ideas such as social class, social capital, and cultural competency, and ecology contributed the principle of interdependent systems that became the ecological model, the framework that holds this whole course together.
Learning Objectives
- 6.1 Contrast sociology and cultural anthropology with psychology in their focus, their methods, and the question each asks about a behaviour.
- 6.2 Describe sociology’s four contributions to public health theory: social structure and class, the influence of the group, social capital, and social organization.
- 6.3 Describe cultural anthropology’s three contributions: behaviour understood in context, cultural competency, and the study of how cultural settings and conditions shape health problems.
- 7.1 Explain how ecology and human ecology produced the ecological model, and name the four domains of influence it places around health behaviour.
- 7.2 Apply the principle of interdependent systems to trace how a change in one domain moves through the others to a health behaviour.
- 7.3 Explain why a single disciplinary theory captures only part of a health behaviour, and how the ecological model allows a program to combine the questions of several disciplines.
6.1 Group, Culture, and System: A Different Starting Point
Sociology and anthropology both focus on the social, societal, or cultural aspects of behaviour, in contrast to the more individual focus of psychology. By this we mean that, where a psychologist starts with a person and asks what is going on inside them, a sociologist or anthropologist starts with the group or the culture the person belongs to. In addition, neither is a clinical discipline, so their research and theory rely on methods different from those of psychology.
Beyond these shared features, however, the two disciplines diverge. Sociology has generally focused on domestic social phenomena, while cultural anthropology has addressed both global and domestic themes, often comparatively. Their interests differ too. Sociologists are interested in social groups, hierarchies, structures, and the nature of social interaction; in other words, in how a society is arranged and how people within it relate to one another. Cultural anthropologists, in contrast, are interested in the role of culture in behaviour, in how life patterns are organized, in systems of knowledge and belief, and in language, symbols, and the other ways we represent life and its meaning; in other words, in what things mean to the people who live them. The contrast with psychology is the quickest way to tell the three disciplines apart.
Three disciplines, three questions
Faced with the same behaviour, each discipline asks a different question. A psychologist asks what a person believes. A sociologist asks what the person’s position lets them expect, and what networks and structures surround them. An anthropologist asks what the behaviour means where it happens. When a case describes a researcher’s question, match the question to the discipline.
The section closes with ecology, a field from biology whose central idea ties the others together. Sociology comes first, and its starting point is the group.
6.2 Sociology: Structure, Group, Capital, Organization
Four influences from sociology on public health stand out. The first is social structure and class. Karl Marx, Friedrich Engels, Max Weber, and many others wrote about how societies divide by class, and Pierre Bourdieu showed how class position becomes part of a person’s practical understanding of what to expect from daily life, including health. By this we mean that class does not only affect what people can afford; it also shapes what they assume is normal and possible for someone like them. For example, a person who has grown up in a family where no one has a regular doctor may not think of preventive care as something meant for them. The second influence is the influence of the group, which works through norms and conformity, and here Emile Durkheim had a tremendous early influence. Norms are the shared expectations that tell members of a group what is ordinary, and conformity is the tendency of members to act in line with those expectations. This overlaps with social psychology, but the two disciplines ask about it from different ends. Social psychology asks how a particular individual is affected by the group around them, whereas sociology asks about the group as a whole: how its norms arise, how they hold the group together, and how they differ from one group to another.
The third influence is social capital, an idea associated with Bourdieu, James Coleman, and Robert Putnam. Social capital means the social networks and resources a person has, and how these shape access to education, jobs, health care, and other social benefits. It is easy to confuse with class, so the contrast is worth stating. Class is about position in a social hierarchy and the expectations that come with it, whereas social capital is about the people a person can call on and the resources those connections open up. The fourth influence is social organization, the work of Durkheim, Weber, and others on how society is structured, how labour is divided, and what motivates social action. The four cards below give a fuller account of each influence with a Canadian or health example.
Social structure
and class
Karl Marx, Friedrich Engels, Max Weber, and many others wrote about how societies are divided by class, and about the paths that class opens or closes to individuals. More recently Pierre Bourdieu examined how class and social position become part of a person’s practical understanding of what to expect from day-to-day life, including health. Someone who has never known anyone with a family doctor does not expect one. This idea also feeds concepts of social ecologies and their role in health.
The influence
of the group
Group norms and conformity are the key issues. There is overlap here with social psychology, but these questions became very important to later developments in health behaviour theory. Emile Durkheim, among others, had a tremendous early influence on the discussion of social conformity, and his work on the division of labour shaped how sociologists think about the bonds that hold groups together.
Social capital
The social networks and resources a person has, and how these influence access to education, jobs, health care, and other social benefits. The idea is associated with Bourdieu, James Coleman, and Robert Putnam. A newcomer to Canada with relatives who know how the health system works has social capital that another newcomer, equally motivated, lacks.
Social
organization
Durkheim, Weber, and others contributed to theory and analysis of how society is structured, how labour is divided, and the nature of and motivation for social action. Theories of how a community or an organization changes draw on this line of work.
Notice how different the sociological questions are from the psychological ones. A cognitive psychologist asks what a person believes about the benefits of cancer screening. A sociologist asks whether the person’s class position leads them to expect screening at all, whether their network includes anyone who has been screened (social capital in the sense of Coleman, 1988), and how the health system is organized to deliver it. Expectation shaped by position points to class in Bourdieu’s sense; access shaped by networks points to social capital. Both kinds of question are legitimate, and the ecological model in 7.1 is the framework that lets a program ask both. Anthropology adds a third kind of question, about meaning, which the next subsection takes up.
6.3 Cultural Anthropology: Context, Competency, and Conditions
Anthropology has addressed public health since early in its history. The discipline as a whole has four subfields: sociocultural anthropology, archaeology, physical (biological) anthropology, and anthropological linguistics, of which cultural and physical anthropology have interacted most with public health. Franz Boas fought racist stereotypes and taught the public to understand cultural patterns on their own terms. By this we mean that a practice should be understood by the logic it has for the people who follow it, not ranked against the observer’s own culture and judged as backward or strange. Margaret Mead used research on childrearing, adolescence, and gender to shape debates about young people. Later traditions took the study of culture in several directions. One studied the connection between culture and personality, asking how growing up in a culture shapes the kind of person one becomes. Another studied cultural models, the shared understandings people draw on, often without noticing, to decide how to act in a given situation. A third, Marvin Harris’s materialist tradition, looked at the tie between behaviour and systems of production, asking how the way a society makes its living shapes what its members do. The habit of mind they share is the one public health borrowed: before you judge a behaviour, find out what it means to the people who do it.
From this work come three contributions to public health, and each one answers a slightly different question. The first is the whole-context approach reflected in the ecological model: human behaviour can never properly be understood outside the social, cultural, and situational context in which it occurs. By this we mean that a behaviour taken out of its setting can look irrational or careless, when in its setting it may make good sense. The second is cultural competency. Concepts of what is healthy, classifications of illness and its causes, which treatments and providers are appropriate, and how to interact with a sick person are all heavily shaped by culture. The purpose of cultural competency is therefore to make sure that programs and care understand the beliefs and practices people bring, rather than assuming everyone shares the provider’s view.
The third contribution is the study of how specific settings and conditions produce health problems. Where cultural competency focuses on beliefs, this contribution focuses on the circumstances people live in. For example, Merrill Singer and Paul Farmer linked poverty and oppression to the spread of HIV. Mark Nichter studied culture and adolescent smoking, and Arthur Kleinman showed that disease and illness are experienced and treated differently across cultures. A useful way to keep the three apart is to ask what a case emphasizes: the need to see behaviour in its setting points to the first, people’s own beliefs about illness and treatment point to the second, and conditions such as poverty producing disease point to the third. The parts that follow trace this line of work in more detail and describe each contribution more fully, including how Canada has extended cultural competency into cultural safety.
Boas and Mead: culture on its own terms
In the early twentieth century Franz Boas laid the groundwork in his fight to counter racist stereotypes and to help the public understand varieties of cultural patterns on their own terms. Margaret Mead, perhaps the most public of anthropologists, used her research on childrearing, adolescence, and gender to influence the American debate about how to understand and work with adolescents. Both established a habit of mind that public health still relies on: before judging a behaviour, learn what it means to the people who do it.
Culture and personality, cultural models, and materialism
A group of mid-twentieth-century anthropologists, including Ruth Benedict, Margaret Mead, Abram Kardiner, Cora DuBois, John and Beatrice Whiting, Irving Hallowell, and Anthony F.C. Wallace, studied the connections between culture and personality and its expression in behaviour. Cognitive and psychological anthropologists such as Ward Goodenough, Roy D’Andrade, Melford Spiro, Claudia Strauss, Dorothy Holland, and Naomi Quinn continued the line, looking at the cultural models people refer to in patterning their behaviour. A different direction, the materialist tradition exemplified by Marvin Harris, focused on the relationship between human behaviour and systems of production.
Contribution 1: behaviour cannot be understood outside its context
The first contribution is the whole-context approach to health behaviour reflected in what is known as the ecological model: the idea that human behaviour can never properly be understood outside the social, cultural, and situational context in which it occurs. For example, skipping a follow-up appointment may look careless to a clinician, yet it can make sense to a parent who would lose a day’s pay and has no one to watch the children. Seen in context, the behaviour has reasons that a program needs to know about. Anthropology supplied the insistence on context; ecology, below, supplied the language of systems.
Contribution 2: cultural competency
The second is the idea of cultural competency, or culturally appropriate programs and care. Concepts of what is healthy or not healthy, classifications of disease and illness and their causes, which treatments are appropriate and who counts as a health provider, and how to interact with someone who is ill are all heavily shaped by culture. Given the diversity of patient populations, understanding the health beliefs and practices a person brings, and how to interact with diverse populations, is a central part of developing health promotion and treatment programs. In Canada this idea has been extended, in the training of health professionals, into cultural safety, which asks providers to examine the power they hold as well as the beliefs their patients hold.
Contribution 3: cultural settings, conditions, and health problems
The third is the study of how specific cultural settings and practices relate to health problems. Merrill Singer and Paul Farmer have been deeply involved in research on the link between conditions of poverty and oppression and the spread of HIV/AIDS. Mark Nichter is known for his work on culture and adolescent smoking. Arthur Kleinman pioneered the study of the sociocultural nature of disease and illness and of how these are experienced and treated across cultures, including the observation that the patient’s explanation of an illness and the clinician’s explanation may be two different accounts of the same event.
Read together, the three contributions build on one another: insisting on context leads to taking people’s own beliefs seriously, and that in turn leads to asking how the conditions people live in shape their health. Worked Example 2.6 applies cultural competency and Kleinman’s idea of competing accounts to a clinic’s problem. As you read it, notice that the patients’ accounts are treated as explanations to work with rather than as errors to correct.
Worked Example 2.6: Two Accounts of Diabetes
The case. A community health centre notices that many patients with type 2 diabetes do not follow the dietary and medication plan they agreed to. Interviews, in the spirit of Kleinman, reveal that patients hold their own accounts of the illness: some describe it as "sweet blood" that runs in the family and cannot be changed, some as a consequence of grief, and some as the result of a change in food since moving from the countryside. The clinical account is insulin resistance managed by diet, activity, and medication.
Step 1: Identify the behaviour and the population. The behaviour is following a diabetes management plan, among adult patients of one community health centre.
Step 2: Map the case onto the anthropological contributions. Each patient account is a theory in the broad sense of Section 1, with its own implications for what a person should do: if diabetes runs in the family and cannot be changed, a diet plan looks pointless. Kleinman’s point applies directly, since the patient’s explanation and the clinician’s explanation are two accounts of the same illness. The contribution most directly at work is cultural competency, because the classification of the illness, its cause, and the treatment that makes sense are all shaped by culture and experience.
Step 3: State what this implies for the program. A culturally competent program starts by asking how each patient understands the cause of the illness and what treatment seems appropriate, then builds the plan from that account. It might show a patient who believes the illness is inherited which parts of its course can still be changed, include support for grief, or build meal plans around the foods a family ate before moving.
What this shows. None of the patients’ accounts is a refusal of care. The mistake to avoid is labelling the gap as non-compliance or ignorance and repeating the clinical account more loudly; a program that works with people’s own accounts has a better chance of changing what they do.
Anthropology supplied the insistence on context. Ecology, a field from biology, supplied the language of systems in which that context can be described, and it is the subject of the next subsection.
7.1 Ecology and the Ecological Model
Ecology is the study, within biology, of how living organisms function within systems. The food chain is the obvious example: many organisms depend on other organisms and on a specific physical environment for their existence, and when the system is disrupted, because one organism becomes extinct or a body of water dries up, the entire system and everything in it is affected. Human ecology applies the same focus to how humans function as part of a biophysical and social environment; human existence cannot be conceptualized separately from the environment in which we live. From both fields the general principle is the same: life, and the behaviour of living organisms, exists within interdependent systems. By this we mean that the parts of a system depend on one another, so nothing in it can change without affecting something else. The food chain shows this for animals and plants, and human ecology claims the same is true for people and their surroundings.
In public health, this principle shaped the way health behaviour is now conceptualized: as an outcome of a complex system of influences from several domains, including policy and regulation, sociocultural factors, the physical environment, and individual factors. This is the ecological model, the prevalent general framework in public health for understanding health behaviour. The purpose of the model is to stop us from treating a behaviour as if it came only from the person who performs it. For example, what a family eats depends on their knowledge and preferences, but also on what food is sold nearby, what it costs, what is normal in their community, and what policies fund or regulate it. The model changes how a program is read: a program that works only on individual beliefs is not wrong, but it is addressing one domain out of four. Green and Kreuter, Bronfenbrenner, and Lewin are among its sources. Figure 2.2 draws the ecological model in these terms, with health behaviour at the centre and the four domains around it.
Figure 2.2. The ecological model: health behaviour at the centre of four interdependent domains (policy and regulation, sociocultural factors, physical environment, and individual factors), with every domain connected to every other.
The point of Figure 2.2 is the grey lines. Each domain is connected to the others, so a change in one moves through the rest before it reaches the behaviour. A program that works on only one box, however well, leaves the others acting on the same behaviour. The next subsection puts that claim to work.
7.2 Tracing a Change Through the System
Applying the principle of interdependent systems means following a change from where it starts, through each domain it touches, to the behaviour. Interactive 2.4 lets you do this on a small community food system. Its five events run from the closure of the only grocery store to the opening of a community garden. Click each event in turn: the parts of the system it touches light up, the panel narrates the cascade to what people eat, and the count tells you how many domains the event passed through.
📊 Interactive 2.4: Disrupt the system.
Pick an event. The nodes it touches light up, and the panel narrates the cascade. Count how many domains each event reaches before it arrives at the behaviour.Across the five events, notice that the behaviour changed without any change in what people knew or wanted, and that a policy decision such as cutting a bus route can matter more to diet than a nutrition class. Worked Example 2.7 traces the same kind of cascade in a real Canadian public health emergency. As you read it, watch for which contribution from 6.3 frames the problem, and what the ecological model adds.
Worked Example 2.7: Vancouver’s Downtown Eastside, 1997
The case. In 1997 the Vancouver/Richmond Health Board declared a public health emergency in response to the spread of HIV among people who inject drugs in the Downtown Eastside. An individual-level account explained the epidemic through needle sharing, a behaviour, and pointed to education about sterile equipment. A second account, in the spirit of Singer and Farmer, looked at the conditions in which the behaviour occurred: concentrated poverty, unstable housing, the criminalization of drug use, the loss of income-support and mental health services, and a neighbourhood where people who used drugs had been pushed together and out of sight.
Step 1: Identify the behaviour and the population. The behaviour is sharing injection equipment, and the population is people who inject drugs in one Vancouver neighbourhood.
Step 2: Name the discipline behind each account. The first account treats the behaviour as an individual choice to be corrected with information, a cognitive assumption. The second frames the epidemic as a product of conditions rather than choices, which is cultural anthropology’s third contribution: the study of how settings and conditions of poverty and oppression produce health problems.
Step 3: Map the case onto the ecological model. Policy and regulation: the criminalization of drug use and the loss of services. Physical environment: unstable housing and a neighbourhood where people were concentrated out of sight. Sociocultural factors: concentrated poverty and stigma. Individual factors: knowledge and needle-sharing practices. The domains act on one another; without stable housing or safe places to inject, people share equipment even when they know the risk, so education alone runs into every unchanged domain.
Step 4: State what the analysis implies for the response. The response that eventually took shape combined both accounts: expanded needle distribution and, in 2003, North America’s first sanctioned supervised injection site, Insite (Wikipedia), alongside housing and treatment initiatives. It reached the individual, physical-environment, and policy domains at once.
What this shows. Neither account on its own says how the pieces fit. The ecological model adds the system: it shows how conditions in several domains act together on one behaviour, so a response can target more than one. The mistake to avoid is treating the two accounts as rivals when they describe different parts of the same system.
The case shows that each discipline saw a real part of the problem. The last subsection draws that lesson out for the course as a whole.
7.3 Pieces of the Puzzle
The idea of ecology should help you tie together every kind of theory in this course. Each theory is useful for describing or understanding one piece of the puzzle. For example, a cognitive theory explains beliefs, a sociological theory explains structure and networks, and an anthropological approach explains meaning. No single piece is wrong, but no single piece is the whole picture either. What matters most is the way the pieces work together, and the ecological model is the framework that shows how they connect. That is why this course teaches individual theories and social, cultural, and environmental theories side by side. Each discipline in this lesson begins from a different starting point, and each would ask a different question about the same behaviour. Table 2.3 compares psychology and social psychology from Section 3 with sociology, cultural anthropology, and ecology from this section, giving for each its starting point, a typical question about smoking, and its contribution to public health theory.
Table 2.3. Four disciplines compared: starting point, typical question about smoking, and contribution to public health theory.
| Discipline | Starting point | Typical question about smoking | Contribution to public health theory |
|---|---|---|---|
| Psychology and social psychology | The individual, alone or among others | What does this person believe about the risks, and what do they think their friends do? | Cognitive constructs, reinforcement, norms, intention |
| Sociology | Groups, hierarchies, structures, interaction | How does class position shape who takes up smoking, and what networks and resources help people quit? | Social structure and class, group influence, social capital, social organization |
| Cultural anthropology | Culture, meaning, systems of knowledge and belief | What does smoking mean in this setting, and how do local ideas of health frame it (Nichter)? | Behaviour in context, cultural competency, cultural settings and health problems |
| Ecology and human ecology | Interdependent systems | How do pricing, packaging laws, retail environments, norms, and individual factors act together on smoking? | The ecological model |
Reading down the last column of Table 2.3, a program built on only one row reaches only one piece of the system. When you critique a proposal, name the row it comes from, then name a domain it leaves untouched and an addition that would reach it. With the roots in view, the final section brings the lesson together and asks you to use all of it at once: to recognize a theory, to judge it by the ground rules of its tradition, and to identify which discipline’s assumptions a program is carrying.
The key takeaways below gather what this section has established about sociology, cultural anthropology, and the ecological model, and the knowledge check that follows asks you to apply them to short cases.
Key Takeaways
- 6.1 Sociology and cultural anthropology begin with the group and the culture rather than the individual, and neither is a clinical discipline, so their methods differ from psychology’s. Sociology has mostly studied domestic social phenomena such as groups, hierarchies, structures, and interaction; anthropology has worked globally and at home, often comparatively, on culture, meaning, and systems of knowledge and belief. A simple test sorts them: a psychologist asks what a person believes, a sociologist asks what their position lets them expect, and an anthropologist asks what the behaviour means where it happens. When a case describes a researcher’s question, match the question rather than the topic.
- 6.2 Sociology contributed four ideas to public health theory: social structure and class (Marx, Engels, Weber, and Bourdieu, who showed how class position shapes what a person expects from daily life), the influence of the group through norms and conformity (Durkheim), social capital, the networks and resources that shape access to services (Bourdieu, Coleman, Putnam), and social organization, how society is structured and labour divided (Durkheim, Weber). The most common confusion is between class and social capital. If the case is about what people expect for "people like them," think class; if it is about whom they know and who can help them get access, think social capital.
- 6.3 Cultural anthropology, from Boas and Mead through the culture-and-personality, cognitive, and materialist traditions, contributed three ideas: behaviour cannot be understood outside its context; cultural competency, because ideas of health, illness, causes, treatments, and healers are shaped by culture; and the study of how settings and conditions produce health problems (Singer and Farmer on poverty and HIV, Nichter on adolescent smoking, Kleinman on illness across cultures). Kleinman’s insight that a patient’s explanation and a clinician’s explanation are two accounts of the same illness is especially useful. When a case shows a program asking people how they understand their illness before proposing a plan, the contribution at work is cultural competency.
- 7.1 Ecology studies how organisms function within systems, as in the food chain, where a disruption anywhere affects the whole, and human ecology applies the same focus to people within their biophysical and social environment. The shared principle is that life and behaviour exist within interdependent systems. In public health this became the ecological model, the prevalent framework, which treats health behaviour as the outcome of influences from four domains: policy and regulation, sociocultural factors, the physical environment, and individual factors. Learn the four domains by name, because questions often ask which domain a program reaches or leaves out.
- 7.2 Applying the principle of interdependent systems means tracing a change from its origin, through each domain it touches, to the behaviour, as Interactive 2.4 does for a food system and Worked Example 2.7 does for HIV in the Downtown Eastside. Behaviour can change without any change in what people know or want, because a store closing or a bus route being cut moves through budgets and norms to the plate. When asked to apply the principle, name at least three domains acting on the behaviour, explain how a change in one would move through the others, and propose an addition that reaches a domain the existing program does not.
- 7.3 Each theory in the course describes one piece of the puzzle: cognitive theories explain beliefs, sociological theories explain structure and networks, and anthropological approaches explain meaning. The way the pieces work together is the key, and the ecological model is the frame that lets a program ask the psychological, sociological, and anthropological questions at once. The most useful critique of a single-domain program, such as a classroom lesson on smoking risks, is not that it is wrong but that its effect depends on parts of the system it leaves untouched. Avoid the opposite trap of dismissing the individual domain altogether; it is one piece, not no piece.
1. A researcher studying smoking among young people in a northern community asks what smoking means to them in that setting and how it fits local ideas of health. Which discipline’s question is this?
2. A study finds that people in a low-income neighbourhood rarely seek cancer screening, and interviews suggest they simply do not expect preventive care to be something people like them receive. Which sociological contribution best captures this finding?
3. A community health centre trains its staff to ask each patient how they understand the cause of their illness, what treatment they consider appropriate, and who they consider a healer, before proposing a plan. Which contribution of cultural anthropology is this most directly applying?
4. Which statement best expresses the general principle drawn from ecology and human ecology?
5. Which list correctly names the four domains of influence that the ecological model places around health behaviour?
6. A provincial ministry proposes to reduce youth smoking with a classroom lesson on health risks. Applying the principle that each theory describes one piece of the puzzle and that the way the pieces work together is the key, what is the strongest critique?
7. A health unit in northern Ontario reports that fruit and vegetable intake in a small fly-in community is far below provincial averages and proposes a cooking-skills course. Which concern reflects a sociological contribution that the proposal ignores?
8. For the same fly-in community, which addition to the cooking course would reach a domain of the ecological model that the course does not?
✦ Pass the knowledge check with 100% to continue
Final Review & Assessment
⏱ Estimated time: 25 minutes
Bringing It All Together
This lesson defined the word theory. In the social science sense, a theory is a systematic set of interrelated constructs, definitions, and propositions that specifies relations among variables in order to explain and predict. Following Karl Popper, a theory is a proposed explanatory solution to a problem, and its test is falsification rather than confirmation, carried out in situations relevant to what it claims. At the same time, a theory is an account, a story that explains, and stories of that kind are as old as humanity. What separates a scientific theory from a myth is the set of ground rules used to judge it, which is why the lesson brought in Wittgenstein’s language games and Foucault’s discourse: a theory has meaning and validity within a context, and understanding that context is one of the most useful tools you can carry into practice.
The context for public health theory is the Western philosophical and scientific tradition, and the lesson traced the four assumptions that tradition built into theory. Order and regularity came from the Greek search for a discoverable, usable order in nature, survived the church-centred Middle Ages, and emerged from the Enlightenment as the clockwork universe. Predictability is order’s child, institutionalized by Comte’s positivism as the goal of a science of society. Empirical data reflects the empiricist epistemology of Locke and Hume, against which rationalism, phenomenology, and the theological or deist orientation stand as alternatives, and the lesson asked whether the empirical standard of evidence is always enough. Progress, from Plato’s cave to Bacon to Darwin, Marx, and Freud, makes science a continuous accumulation of knowledge in which theory is the tactic that generates investigation.
The last two sections named the disciplines from which health behaviour theory descends. Behaviourism (Pavlov, Skinner) gave reinforcement and behaviour modification; cognitive psychology (Piaget) gave the assumption that internal calculations of risk and benefit shape behaviour, which underlies the Health Belief Model, the Theory of Planned Behavior, and Social-Cognitive Theory; humanistic psychology (Maslow) gave agency, growth, and the philosophy of health promotion; and social psychology gave social influence, conformity, and the chain from attitudes and norms through intention to behaviour (Fishbein and Ajzen). Sociology contributed social structure and class, group influence, social capital, and social organization; cultural anthropology contributed behaviour in context, cultural competency, and the study of how settings and conditions produce health problems; and ecology contributed the principle of interdependent systems that became the ecological model. Each theory describes one piece of the puzzle. The way the pieces work together is the key.
Key Takeaways from this lesson
- You can now define a theory as a systematic set of constructs, definitions, and propositions that explains and predicts, and separate it from the hypotheses and principles derived from it. You can also apply Popper’s test, which asks whether a theory survives attempts to falsify it in situations relevant to its claims, to sort a statement into a testable proposition, an untestable account, or an empirical observation. The most useful reminder: confirming cases prove little, so always ask what observation could show a claim wrong.
- You can now explain that, at its most basic, a theory is an account, and that hypotheses can be drawn from any coherent account, even a myth. You can also explain why judging any account depends on ground rules supplied by a context, using Wittgenstein’s language games and Foucault’s discourse. When you assess a theory or a program rationale, name the rules being used to judge it, and the assumption it takes for granted, before deciding who is right.
- You can now describe the four assumptions the Western tradition builds into theory (order and regularity, predictability, empirical data, and progress) and trace their history from the Greek philosophers through the church-centred Middle Ages and the secular Enlightenment to Comte’s positivism and his three stages of thought. Remember that situating theory in this tradition does not rank it above others, and that a planner’s forecast, demand for measured outcomes, or confidence that knowledge keeps improving each points to a different assumption.
- You can now distinguish empiricism (knowledge through the senses), rationalism (knowledge grounded in the mind), phenomenology (reality as experienced reality), and the theological or deist orientation (knowledge as revelation), and say that scientific theory grew up within empiricism. You can also ask whether the empirical standard is always enough. The practical answer is to keep Popper’s test while widening what counts as an observation, not to abandon evidence.
- You can now describe what behaviourist (conditioning and reinforcement), cognitive (thought, risk calculation, assimilation and accommodation), humanistic (agency, growth, and Maslow’s hierarchy), and social psychology (obedience, conformity, dissonance, and intention) contributed to health behaviour theory. You can identify which school a program relies on by asking what the program changes: rewards and cues, beliefs, basic needs, or norms and intentions. These assumptions reappear inside the named theories of health behaviour.
- You can now describe sociology’s contributions (social structure and class, group influence, social capital, and social organization) and cultural anthropology’s (behaviour in context, cultural competency, and the study of how settings and conditions produce health problems). You can tell the disciplines apart by their questions: a psychologist asks what a person believes, a sociologist what their position lets them expect, and an anthropologist what the behaviour means where it happens.
- You can now explain how ecology and human ecology gave public health the ecological model, with health behaviour shaped by policy and regulation, sociocultural factors, the physical environment, and individual factors, and you can trace how a change in one domain moves through the others. Each theory describes one piece of the puzzle, and the way the pieces work together is the key. When you critique a program, name the domain it reaches, the domains it leaves untouched, and an addition that would reach one of them.
Final Knowledge Assessment
This assessment covers all seven lesson objectives with 19 questions. You must score 100% to complete the lesson. Review the feedback for any incorrect answers and try again.
1. Which of the following best states Popper’s view of how a theory earns its place in scientific knowledge?
2. A colleague says: "Our program worked, and any evaluation that fails to show it simply measured the wrong things." What kind of statement is this?
3. In the social science definition of theory drawn from Kerlinger, what is the role of propositions in a theory?
4. Why are Wittgenstein’s language games and Foucault’s idea of discourse relevant to evaluating a theory?
5. Which of the following is the best description of positivism?
6. The Enlightenment shift from divine to secular explanation coincided with a particular economic and political change. What was it?
7. A health researcher insists that only outcomes an outside observer can measure count as evidence, because the senses report an objective reality that is out there. Which epistemological tradition is she working within?
8. Which assumption of the Western tradition is expressed in the claim that doing science involves a continuous accumulation of knowledge, with theory as the tactic used to generate investigation?
9. A smoking cessation program gives participants a small reward for each verified smoke-free week and increases the reward for consecutive weeks. Which antecedent and process does this design draw on?
10. Piaget distinguished assimilation from accommodation. Which example illustrates accommodation?
11. Which of the following is the contribution of Fishbein and Ajzen to the study of attitudes and behaviour?
12. Humanistic psychology developed in part as a reaction to something. To what?
13. A newcomer family knows no one who has used the Canadian health system and has no one to ask how to find a family physician, while a second family with relatives already settled here is registered within a month. Which sociological concept explains the difference?
14. Researchers working in the tradition of Singer and Farmer study an outbreak of HIV among people who inject drugs. Which question are they most likely to ask?
15. A health unit designs a program to increase physical activity that combines a bylaw funding winter-maintained trails, a workplace challenge with team norms, and an app that sets personal goals. Which idea from the lesson best justifies combining these elements?
16. A regional health authority in Alberta reviews a proposal resting on this reasoning: "Young adults drink heavily because they underestimate the risks. A social media campaign about the risks will change their minds, and once their minds change, their drinking will change." Which observation would falsify the link between changed minds and changed drinking?
17. The same proposal carries the assumption of one school of psychology and ignores another’s contribution. Which answer names both correctly?
18. What would a phenomenological objection to the same proposal sound like?
19. Using the ecological model, which addition would reach a domain that the social media campaign does not?
✦ Pass every section knowledge check with 100% before submitting