The Links Between
Health and Behavior
Health Promotion: Individuals and Communities
Learning objectives for this lesson:
- Explain why a single health behaviour can rest on several motives, some of them unrelated to health, and how the setting changes which motive dominates.
- State the goal of the field concerned with health behaviour and the two questions that organize it.
- Define the ecological model and explain why it displaced approaches that focused on individual knowledge, attitudes, and motivation.
- Classify the influences on a health behaviour by type of factor and by level of influence within a social ecology.
- Analyze obesity, youth violence, and HIV/AIDS as behavioural problems with influences at several levels, and explain why lasting change requires interventions at more than one level.
- Compare explanations for youth violence by the level of influence at which each locates the cause.
- Apply a three-step planning sequence of identifying, choosing, and designing to a health problem, and explain how it guards against standardized programs that ignore local context.
This course was developed by Dr. Kiffer G. Card, to accompany Edberg, M. Essentials of Health Behavior: Social and Behavioral Theory in Public Health. Jones & Bartlett Learning. This lesson follows Chapters 1 and 2 of the text.
Glossary: Key Terms, People & Concepts
📚 Reference page, available throughout the lesson
This glossary collects the key concepts, people, and ideas you will meet in this lesson. Use it as a reference while you work through the material, or as a review before assessments. Type in the search box to filter entries.
Everyday Behaviour and the Questions Public Health Asks
⏱ Estimated reading time: 15 minutes
Overview
Any serious discussion of health behaviour involves wrestling with abstractions: motives, causal and contributing factors, contexts, cues. This lesson avoids starting there. It starts with a friend brushing his teeth, and it uses that scene to show that even the most ordinary health behaviour can have several explanations at once. This section works through the scenario, the questions it raises for public health, and the first evidence that where a person lives, what they can afford, and what the law allows often matter more than what they want.
Learning Objectives
- 1.1 Identify several motives, some of them unrelated to health, that can lie behind an everyday health behaviour, and explain how the setting changes which motive dominates.
- 1.2 Distinguish four ways in which a behaviour labelled a health behaviour can relate to health, including cases in which health is defined differently from Western medical standards.
- 2.1 State the goal of the field of health behaviour and the two questions that organize it, and give examples of behaviours that harm health as well as behaviours that protect it.
- 3.1 Give examples in which socioeconomic circumstances, environmental conditions, or public policies shape health behaviour more than personal motivation.
1.1 One Habit, Many Motives
Suppose a friend, Sam, is brushing his teeth very vigorously. You ask why. He is puzzled by the question: he does not want cavities, and he does not want his teeth to fall out. End of story. Sam brushes to maintain healthy teeth, and that makes perfect sense.
Toothbrushing is a good example precisely because it is habit, far below the radar of our thinking selves. Habits are where we are most likely to accept the first explanation offered, which makes them a good test of whether the obvious explanation is the whole story. Interactive 1.1 reveals the rest of the scene one clue at a time. Click the button to reveal each clue in turn and watch the list of possible motives on the right grow; by the last of its six clues, a single habit has six candidate motives.
📊 Interactive 1.1: The plot thickens.
Reveal each clue in turn. The list on the right keeps track of every motive the evidence supports so far.Asked why he is brushing so hard, Sam says he does not want cavities or to lose his teeth.
On the sink lies a men’s magazine. The cover model, leather jacket open, hair artfully careless, has a set of perfect, strong, gleaming white teeth.
Sam digs through his rumpled wardrobe for exactly the right look. Eventually he admits it: a party, at her parents’ house, and she did not invite only him. He wants to stand out.
Ask Sam the same question tomorrow morning, barely awake and on his way to work, and the honest answer might be plain habit, or so that his breath will not smell.
Suppose Sam was the first person from his small rural town to go to college, from a family with little income and no health insurance. A doctor’s visit would be a crisis. A dentist would be out of reach entirely.
Suppose Sam’s mother, who lost most of her own teeth young because nobody in her family knew much about brushing, drilled into him that he was not clean or presentable without brushing after every meal. Sam never knew why. He only knew it mattered to her.
Possible motives so far
- Nothing revealed yet.
Six candidate motives for one habit. Which one dominates depends on the day, the setting, and the history behind the person. Sam himself may not know the reasons behind his mother’s rule. A program that assumes a single motive, such as fear of cavities, will speak past him on the night of the party, and a program that assumes appearance will speak past him on a sleepy Tuesday morning.
Read in order, the clues add a cultural image (the magazine cover's picture of the ideal male, gleaming teeth included), attraction (a party and a special person to stand out for, with a little biology mixed in), habit or fresh breath on a sleepy morning, economic precarity (a family that could never pay a dentist's bill), and family socialization (a mother who lost her own teeth young and drilled brushing into her son). Only the first motive, preventing cavities and tooth loss, is about health in the medical sense.
A harder question follows: which motive was dominant in the scene just described? Probably the cultural image or the attraction, this time anyway. Ask Sam tomorrow, when he is barely awake and on his way to work, and health, or habit, or fresh breath may be the truthful answer. The point is that motives are layered and situational. A person does not carry one reason for a behaviour; they carry a repertoire, and the setting selects from it. When you analyse a case, list every plausible motive first, and only then ask which one the setting makes dominant. The callout below draws out what this layering of motives means for the design of public health programs.
Why this matters for program design
Public health messages tend to assume a motive. By this we mean that every message is built around a guess about why people act, even when the guess is never stated. A cavity-prevention poster assumes health. A whitening advertisement assumes appearance. A school program that has children brush after lunch assumes habit and socialization. None is wrong, but each reaches only the people, and the moments, for which that motive is active. For example, the cavity poster would speak to Sam on a morning when he is worried about his teeth, but it would have little to say to him on the night of the party, when appearance and attraction are doing the work. Because a program can only engage the motives it was designed around, the choice of motive is one of the most important decisions a planner makes. The rest of this course is largely about making that decision on the basis of evidence and theory rather than guessing.
Sam's motives also differ in how closely they are tied to health at all, and the next subsection sorts out the possibilities.
1.2 Four Ways a Health Behaviour Can Relate to Health
The Sam scenario shows that behaviour categorized as health behaviour is not necessarily motivated or influenced by concerns about health. By this we mean that the label "health behaviour" describes what a behaviour does to health, not why the person does it. Toothbrushing protects teeth whatever Sam's reasons are, but his reasons may have little to do with his teeth. The purpose of separating the effect of a behaviour from its motive is to stop us from assuming that every program about a health behaviour should talk about health. There are four possibilities, and it helps to treat them as a short checklist.
First, the behaviour may be motivated by health concerns. For example, a person who quits smoking after a cardiac scare is acting directly on a worry about their health, so the obvious explanation is also the right one. Second, the behaviour may rest on health concerns mixed together with other concerns. Sam's brushing on the night of the party is a case of this kind, because he brushes for his teeth, for the mirror, and for someone special all at once; health is present, but it is only one strand among several. Third, the behaviour may rest on concerns that have nothing to do with health. For example, a teenager who takes up vaping to fit in with a friend group is managing belonging rather than lungs, so health does not enter the decision at all, even though the behaviour clearly affects health. Fourth, the behaviour may reflect an idea of health that differs from the standards of Western medicine. In this case the person is thinking about health, but health means something different to them than it does to a clinician. Each possibility has its own card below.
Motivated
by health
Sometimes the obvious explanation is the right one. Sam does want to keep his teeth. A person who quits smoking after a cardiac scare is acting on health concern, and a program that supplies risk information and support fits that person well.
Health mixed with
other concerns
Health concern is present but blended with others: appearance, thrift, family expectation, the wish to be a good parent. Sam on the night of the party is brushing for his teeth and for the mirror and for someone special, all at once. Programs that speak to only one strand miss the others.
Nothing to do
with health
Some behaviour that affects health is not about health at all. A teenager who takes up vaping to fit in with a friend group is managing belonging, not lungs. Sam brushing to look like the magazine cover is managing an image. Health messages aimed at such behaviour compete with the real motive rather than engaging it.
A different
idea of health
The behaviour is about health, but health defined differently from the standards of Western medicine. In many cultures, particularly those with a history of food shortage, a large person is seen as healthy and "doing well," and thinness is a reminder of starvation. A weight-loss program built on Western norms may be read, quite reasonably, as a program for becoming sickly.
The fourth possibility deserves emphasis because it will return when this lesson turns to obesity, and because it is the one students most often confuse with the third. The case in point is body size. For many peoples who have experienced food shortage through their history, a large man, one we might call overweight, is viewed as healthy and doing well, while thinness is a symbol of starvation. By this we mean that the person is not ignoring health, as the vaping teenager is; they are pursuing health as their community defines it. The difference matters for programs. A weight-loss program that ignores this definition will be ineffective, and worse, it will be asking people to pursue what they understand as illness.
When you classify a case, ask two questions in turn. The first is whether health is part of the motive at all; if it is not, the case belongs to the third possibility. The second, if health is part of the motive, is whether it is health as Western medicine defines it; if it is not, the case belongs to the fourth possibility. Working through the questions in this order protects against two opposite errors. A behaviour that worries a clinician can still be health-motivated under a different definition, and a behaviour that protects health can have nothing to do with health in the person's own mind. Seeing how far motives can stray from health raises the question of what the field that studies health behaviour is trying to do, which the next subsection answers.
2.1 The Goal of the Field and Its Two Questions
The moral of the story is that an entire field of study and practice exists around the complex nature of health behaviour. Its goal is implementing programs and interventions that promote change in behaviour in order to improve the health of the public or a segment of it. By this we mean that the field is applied: it studies why people behave as they do so that it can design something that changes behaviour, and it judges its work by whether the health of a population, or of a group within it, improves. Understanding behaviour is therefore a means to an end rather than the end itself. You already know these programs: campaigns to stop smoking, warnings on cigarette packaging and lawsuits against tobacco companies, school programs and television advertisements about drugs, alcohol, and drinking and driving, billboard and transit advertising about HIV risk and the benefits of testing, and public campaigns about cardiovascular health and diet. Canada has run versions of every one. Table 1.1 pairs four of these types of program with a Canadian version of each and the behaviour each targets.
Table 1.1. Four types of behaviour change program, a Canadian version of each, and the behaviour each targets.
| Program type | A Canadian version | Behaviour targeted |
|---|---|---|
| Warnings on cigarette packaging and campaigns to stop smoking | Canada was the first country to require graphic picture warnings on cigarette packages, beginning in 2000 and 2001, later added plain packaging, and in 2023 became the first to require warnings printed on individual cigarettes | Tobacco use and cessation |
| Warnings to young people about drinking and driving | British Columbia's CounterAttack roadside checks, run by police since 1977 and paired with public awareness campaigns from the province's public auto insurer | Impaired driving |
| Public campaigns about HIV risk and the benefits of testing | GetCheckedOnline, an internet-based HIV and sexually transmitted infection testing service launched by the BC Centre for Disease Control in 2014 | HIV testing |
| Public campaigns about cardiovascular health and diet | Canada's Food Guide (revised in 2019) and Heart and Stroke Foundation campaigns on diet, activity, and blood pressure | Diet and physical activity |
Most of these programs rest on a body of knowledge about what motivates and influences human behaviour, and that body of knowledge is organized by two questions. The first is the public health question: why do people behave in healthy (or unhealthy) ways? The second is a much older and broader question: why do people do what they do? The two are not separate topics. The public health question is a focused version of the general one, in the same way that toothbrushing is one behaviour among all the things Sam does in a day. The purpose of keeping the general question in view is to avoid treating health behaviour as if it followed rules of its own. For example, Sam's brushing turned out to be driven by image, attraction, habit, money, and family, which are the same forces that drive behaviour of every kind. To understand the subset of behaviour we label health behaviour, then, we have to think about it in the context of what generally motivates or influences behaviour of any kind, which is why this course draws on psychology, sociology, and anthropology as well as on public health. The callout below clears up a common confusion about what the category of health behaviour includes.
Common confusion: health behaviour is a category
Health behaviour is a category, not a compliment. By this we mean that calling something a health behaviour says only that it affects health, not that it is good for health. The category therefore includes smoking and needle sharing as well as brushing and vaccination. The field studies behaviour that affects health, in either direction, and the same question, why do people do this, applies to both. For example, asking why a teenager starts vaping is the same kind of question as asking why Sam brushes his teeth, and both answers may turn out to involve image, belonging, and habit as much as health.
The goal and the two questions frame everything that follows. The next subsection shows that the answer to "why do people do this?" often lies outside the person altogether.
3.1 When Motivation Is Beside the Point
The final move in this section is to shift the ground entirely. Often, what people do or do not do about their health has more to do with socioeconomic circumstances, environmental conditions, or public policies and regulations than with motivation at all. By this we mean that a person can want to act and still be unable to, or can act in a risky way because the setting leaves few alternatives. The first two subsections asked what is going on inside the person; this one asks what is going on around them. The distinction matters because the two kinds of explanation call for different responses: a shortage of motivation suggests persuasion, while a shortage of access, income, or safe conditions calls for a change in the circumstances themselves. Three cases make the point, and each has a Canadian counterpart.
The first is a woman who does not get routinely screened for breast cancer simply because she lives in a rural area and the providers who do screening are not easily accessible. This does not have as much to do with her motivation as with her social and geographic situation. In British Columbia, the provincial cancer agency operates a mobile mammography service that travels to rural and remote communities, a response that treats access, rather than attitude, as the problem. Worked Example 1.1 tests a different response against this case; as you read it, watch for which part of the problem each response actually reaches.
Worked Example 1.1: A Poster Campaign for Rural Screening
Screening rates are low in a rural region where no provider who performs mammography is within easy reach. A local health unit proposes a poster campaign about the importance of early detection. Which part of the problem would the campaign address, and which part would it leave untouched?
Step 1, identify the behaviour and the population. The behaviour is routine breast cancer screening; the population is women living in the rural region.
Step 2, locate what shapes the behaviour. The case says the main obstacle is distance to a provider: a matter of geography and access to services, part of the woman's social and geographic situation. Knowledge and motivation may play some part, but the case states that they are not the main issue.
Step 3, test the proposed response. A poster about early detection works on knowledge and attitudes, inside the individual. It addresses the part of the problem that is about awareness and leaves the distance to a provider exactly where it was. A woman fully persuaded by the poster still has no screening provider within reach.
Step 4, state the implication for the program. The response has to change access, as British Columbia's mobile service does by bringing screening to the community. A poster could still play a supporting part, for example by announcing when the mobile unit will arrive, but it cannot replace the service.
The example shows the most common mistake in reading a health behaviour: treating a low rate as a shortage of motivation. Ask first whether people could act even if they wanted to.
The rural case turns on access. The second case adds livelihood and culture. People living downstream from a factory that pollutes the waterway may suffer health consequences from eating contaminated fish or drinking contaminated water. They may not be fully aware of the risk. They may also depend on fishing for their livelihood, and may have done so for generations, long enough to build a local culture around the fishing life. Canada's clearest example is Grassy Narrows (Asubpeeschoseewagong) First Nation in northwestern Ontario, where mercury discharged from a pulp and paper operation at Dryden into the English-Wabigoon River system in the 1960s and early 1970s contaminated fish that were at once food, livelihood, and a centre of community life. If you were trying to reduce the health risk for these people, what would you address first? Worked Example 1.2 works through that question by listing every influence before choosing among them.
Worked Example 1.2: Downstream from the Factory
A health agency considers telling the community at Grassy Narrows to stop eating fish from the river. Is "stop eating the fish" a behaviour-change message or a demand to give up a livelihood and a culture, and who bears the cost of each possible response?
Step 1, identify the behaviour and the risk. The behaviour is eating fish from the contaminated river system; the health risk is mercury poisoning.
Step 2, list the influences on the behaviour. Residents may not be fully aware of the risk (individual knowledge). They depend on fishing for food and income (socioeconomic circumstances). Fishing is a culture built over generations (cultural). Mercury is in the water and the fish (environmental). The discharge, and whether it is stopped and cleaned up, is a matter of regulation (political).
Step 3, test the proposed message. "Stop eating the fish" treats the problem as one of individual knowledge and choice. In practice it asks residents to give up a food source, an income, and a centre of community life, so the cost of the response falls on the people who were harmed rather than on the source of the harm.
Step 4, decide where to begin. Read ecologically, the case points first to the contamination itself and its regulation, and to replacing the food and livelihood the fish provided. Information about the risk has a place, but it cannot carry the response alone.
The example shows that several influences at different levels operate together, so deciding where to begin is the real question. A response aimed only at individual behaviour can quietly shift the cost of a problem onto the people it harms.
The third case is broader still, because it concerns a whole society changing rather than a single community. In parts of the rapidly developing world, rural agrarian economies have shifted quickly to urban and industrial ones. In the villages people left behind, there was little pressure on the local environment and food was relatively easy to obtain. In the crowded cities they move to, however, food is scarcer, water and sanitary systems are overwhelmed, housing is hard to find, and tuberculosis spreads more easily. The change in setting also changes the choices open to people. For example, women arriving from rural areas may be forced into the sex trade to survive, placing themselves and their partners at risk of HIV and other sexually transmitted infections, while limited knowledge of risk and restrictive attitudes about gender roles close off other work. Ask where you would begin, and notice how few of the key influences belong to any one person: food scarcity, overwhelmed water and sanitation, scarce housing, the spread of tuberculosis, a labour market that pushes women into the sex trade, and gender norms. Limited knowledge of risk is the only item on that list that sits inside an individual, and even it is shaped by the setting.
Taken together, the three cases illustrate the complexity of factors that influence behaviour. In the rural case the obstacle is access, in the downstream case it is livelihood, culture, and contamination together, and in the city case it is the whole economic and social setting. In none of them would more motivation solve the problem on its own. The practical lesson for analysing a case follows directly. When a case question asks where to begin, a strong answer names the influences at each level before choosing among them, and it does not assume that a low rate of a health behaviour means low motivation. That complexity is what the ecological model was built to organize, and the next section gives it a name and a structure.
This section has shown that a single health behaviour can rest on several motives at once, that behaviour labelled health behaviour is not always motivated by health, and that socioeconomic circumstances, environmental conditions, and public policies often matter more than motivation. The key takeaways and knowledge check that follow review this material.
Key Takeaways
- 1.1 The lesson opens with a habit, toothbrushing, because habits are where we most easily accept the first explanation offered. Sam's single behaviour turns out to have at least six candidate motives: health, a cultural image, attraction, habit or fresh breath, economic precarity, and family socialization. Which motive dominates changes with the day and the setting, so the honest answer on the night of the party is not the honest answer on a sleepy morning. In a case question, list the plausible motives before naming the dominant one, and be wary of any program that assumes a single motive, because it reaches only the people and moments for which that motive is active.
- 1.2 Behaviour labelled health behaviour may be motivated by health, by health mixed with other concerns, by concerns that have nothing to do with health, or by an idea of health that differs from Western medical standards. The fourth is the easiest to misread: where a large body signals doing well and thinness recalls starvation, the behaviour is health-motivated, just under a different definition of health. A common trap is to call such behaviour "not about health"; ask instead whose definition of health is in play. A program that ignores a different definition may be read as asking people to pursue illness.
- 2.1 The field concerned with health behaviour exists to implement programs and interventions that promote behaviour change in order to improve the health of the public or a segment of it. Its question, why do people behave in healthy or unhealthy ways, is a focused version of the much older question, why do people do what they do, so understanding health behaviour means drawing on what is known about behaviour of any kind. Health behaviour is a category rather than a compliment: smoking and needle sharing belong to it as much as brushing and vaccination. When asked for the goal of the field, make sure your answer names programs, behaviour change, and the health of the public or a segment of it.
- 3.1 Often what people do about their health reflects socioeconomic circumstances, environmental conditions, or public policy more than motivation. The rural woman without a screening provider, the community downstream from a polluting factory, and the village that became a city each show influences that no single person controls. When a case describes a low rate of a health behaviour, check first whether people could act even if they wanted to: an information campaign reaches knowledge and attitudes but leaves access, livelihood, and environment untouched. These observations are what the ecological model, introduced in the next section, organizes.
1. A dental health campaign in a university residence assumes that students brush their teeth to prevent cavities, and every poster shows tooth decay. Based on the Sam scenario, what is the main limitation of this design?
2. A woman in a rural area does not get routinely screened for breast cancer because no provider who performs screening is easily accessible. This example makes which point?
3. In cultures with a long history of food shortage, a large person is often viewed as healthy and doing well. Eating to maintain a large body in such a setting illustrates health behaviour that is:
4. Which statement best captures the relationship between the public health question and the general question about behaviour?
5. A grade 10 student takes up vaping because everyone in her friend group vapes and she wants to belong. Which of the four ways a health behaviour can relate to health best fits her vaping?
6. A student has cycled to campus with a helmet for years: partly for safety, partly to avoid the fine under British Columbia's helmet law, and partly out of habit. When the separated bike lane on her route is removed, she stops cycling altogether. What does this best illustrate?
7. A classmate argues that needle sharing should not be called a health behaviour because it damages health. What is wrong with this argument?
8. A health unit responds to low breast cancer screening rates in a remote region, where no screening provider is within easy reach, with posters about the importance of early detection. Which statement best evaluates the plan?
✦ Pass the knowledge check with 100% to continue
The Social-Ecological Web and the Ecological Model
⏱ Estimated reading time: 15 minutes
Overview
The cases that closed the last section, the rural woman and the mammogram, the fishing community downstream from a factory, the village that became a city, illustrate the complexity of factors that influence behaviour. This section gives that complexity a name and a structure. The name is the ecological model. The structure is a set of factor groups and levels at which influences operate, drawn as nested rings. Along the way the section connects the model to the international and Canadian documents that state the same idea, and it closes with what respecting this complexity means for anyone who designs programs.
Learning Objectives
- 3.2 Describe the shift in health promotion during the late 1970s and early 1980s from a focus on individual knowledge, attitudes, and motivation to the ecological model, and the reasons for it.
- 3.3 Define the ecological model, state its central assumption, and explain what "environment" means in it.
- 3.4 Explain how the ecological model connects to the World Health Organization's social determinants approach, the Lalonde Report, and the Ottawa Charter for Health Promotion.
- 4.1 Name the five groups of factors that contribute to behaviour, and explain why the biological term ecology fits behaviour in context.
- 4.2 Classify the influences on a specific health behaviour into the five groups of factors and the nested levels of influence of the ecological model.
- 7.1 Explain how attention to the complexity of a behaviour and its context guards against standardized programs that do not fit the people they serve.
3.2 From Individual Motives to the Ecological Model
Until the late 1970s and early 1980s, health promotion professionals and programs focused primarily on the knowledge, attitudes, and motivations of individuals, without much attention to the social, cultural, and economic circumstances that are also major determinants of behaviour. The reasoning behind this focus was simple: if people knew the risks and wanted to avoid them, they would change. By this we mean that the older programs treated the person as the whole of the problem, so the solution was to inform and persuade that person. The cases in Section 1 show the weakness of this reasoning, because the rural woman, the downstream community, and the women arriving in the city all faced obstacles that information could not remove.
The turn away from this individual focus is usually credited to the planning work of Green and Kreuter. The more recent focus on the multiplicity of influences on behaviour, that is, on the many influences that act on a behaviour at once, is what is called the ecological model. It is important to be clear about what kind of thing the ecological model is. It is an approach to understanding behaviour, a way of framing the problem, rather than a single named theory with a fixed set of constructs. In other words, it tells you where to look for causes, while specific behavioural theories tell you how particular causes work.
A quick way to place any program on either side of this turn is to ask what it assumes will change behaviour. A program that assumes information and motivation are enough belongs to the older, individual focus; a program that also asks what in people's surroundings makes the behaviour easy or hard belongs to the ecological approach. The model's own definition makes that second question explicit, as the next subsection shows.
3.3 Defining the Ecological Model
The definition is worth reading slowly, and it is worth memorizing in the form given below.
Definition: the ecological model
Under the ecological model, it is assumed that no single factor influences people's behaviour; instead, the complex interaction between individuals and an environment is a process that, taken together, influences behaviour. In short, behaviour does not exist in a vacuum.
Two words carry the weight of this definition. The first is interaction. By this we mean that people and environments act on each other: the environment shapes what people do, and what people do changes the environment in turn. This two-way traffic is what Figure 1.1, later in this section, draws as influences flowing inward through the layers around a person and behaviour flowing back out to reshape them. Because the two shape each other, studying the person and then the environment, one after the other, misses the process that links them. The second word is environment, which here means that which exists outside the individual, so it includes the social environment as well as the physical one. Family, peers, institutions, laws, and prices are environment in this sense, along with air and water. Reading "environment" as the physical world alone is the most common error with this definition, and it would leave out most of the influences this section goes on to sort. A second confusion comes from a similar-sounding term in epidemiology, and the callout below separates the two.
Common confusion: not the ecological fallacy
Students arriving from epidemiology sometimes hear "ecological" and think of the ecological fallacy, the error of inferring individual associations from group-level data. For example, finding that neighbourhoods with more fast-food outlets have higher obesity rates does not show that the particular people who eat fast food are the ones who are obese; assuming that it does is the fallacy. The ecological model is a different idea from a different tradition. It is a claim about where the causes of behaviour lie, and it says they lie at many levels at once, from the individual out to policy. In other words, the model is a way of looking for causes, not a method of analysing data. It has nothing to say about the statistical problem of group versus individual inference, and it shares only the word "ecological", borrowed from biology, with the fallacy. It is no more a fallacy than an ecosystem is.
The ecological model did not develop in isolation. The same insight appears in international and Canadian statements about health, which the next subsection compares.
3.4 The Social Determinants Approach and Canadian Milestones
The ecological model is closely related to a perspective advocated by the World Health Organization known as the social determinants approach, set out in the Rio Political Declaration on Social Determinants of Health of 2011. The declaration states that health inequities arise from the societal conditions in which people are born, grow, live, work, and age. By this we mean that differences in health between groups are produced mainly by the conditions of people's lives, such as their early years, schooling, work, and housing, rather than by differences in individual choices. The two ideas fit together because they look in the same place: the ecological model explains an individual's behaviour by the layers of influence around that person, and the social determinants approach explains a population's health by the societal conditions around that population.
Canada arrived at similar conclusions on its own timeline, and two of the documents that shaped health promotion internationally were written here. The first is the Lalonde Report of 1974, which held that health is determined by four things: human biology, environment, lifestyle, and the organization of health care. Its importance lies in what it placed beside health care. By naming environment and lifestyle alongside biology and health care, it said that keeping people healthy is not only a matter of treating them when they are sick. The second is the Ottawa Charter of 1986, which defined health promotion as the process of enabling people to increase control over, and to improve, their health. In addition to this definition, the Charter built healthy public policy and supportive environments into the work of health promotion, so that changing the conditions around people became part of the job rather than an afterthought.
Interactive 1.2 holds one tab for each of the three documents. Open each tab and note, for each document, which influences on health it names beyond the individual and how it relates to the ecological model.
Interactive 1.2. Three documents that state the ecological insight: the Lalonde Report (1974), the Ottawa Charter (1986), and the Rio Political Declaration (2011).
A New Perspective on the Health of Canadians
Marc Lalonde, then federal Minister of National Health and Welfare, released this report in 1974 (Lalonde, 1974). Its "health field concept" held that health is determined by four things: human biology, environment, lifestyle, and the organization of health care. It is often described as the first government document in a Western country to say plainly that health care is not the main determinant of health. It also shows the tension described earlier in this section, between explaining behaviour by individual motives and explaining it by circumstances. By giving lifestyle its own box, the report invited programs that targeted individual choices, as if diet, smoking, and exercise were simply decisions people made on their own. Later critics argued that it underplayed the social conditions that shape those choices, such as income, housing, and the food available nearby. The ecological model can be read as the correction, because it treats lifestyle not as a separate box but as something produced by the layers of influence around a person.
The Ottawa Charter for Health Promotion
The first International Conference on Health Promotion met in Ottawa in November 1986 and produced the charter that still defines the field (WHO, 1986). It defines health promotion as the process of enabling people to increase control over, and to improve, their health. It lists prerequisites for health that reach far beyond the clinic: peace, shelter, education, food, income, a stable ecosystem, sustainable resources, social justice, and equity. Its five action areas, building healthy public policy, creating supportive environments, strengthening community action, developing personal skills, and reorienting health services, map almost exactly onto the levels of the ecological model. Only one of the five is about the individual.
The Rio Political Declaration on Social Determinants of Health
Adopted at the World Conference on Social Determinants of Health in Rio de Janeiro in October 2011 (WHO, 2011), the declaration states that health inequities arise from the societal conditions in which people are born, grow, live, work, and age. It names early years' experiences, education, economic status, employment and decent work, housing and environment, and effective systems of preventing and treating ill health, and it calls action on these determinants, for vulnerable groups and for entire populations, essential to inclusive, equitable, economically productive, and healthy societies. This is the same insight as the ecological model, stated at the level of populations and policy.
Read together, the tabs show the same claim stated three times. The Lalonde Report put lifestyle and environment on the map, although by giving lifestyle its own box it also invited programs aimed only at individual choices. The Ottawa Charter's five action areas, building healthy public policy, creating supportive environments, strengthening community action, developing personal skills, and reorienting health services, spread action across the levels of the model, and only one of the five, developing personal skills, is about the individual. The Rio Declaration states the insight at the level of populations and policy.
Indigenous-led frameworks in Canada arrive at the same structure from a different starting point. The First Nations Health Authority in British Columbia, the first province-wide First Nations health authority in the country, describes health and wellness with a schematic that places the person at the centre, surrounded by family, community, nations, and land, and finally by social, environmental, cultural, and economic determinants. The vocabulary differs, but the claim that a person's health is produced by the layers around them is the same. Those layers, and the factors that make them up, are the subject of the next subsection.
4.1 Five Groups of Factors
The ecological model says that influences on behaviour come from many places, but a planner needs a way to list them that is systematic rather than haphazard. The purpose of grouping the influences is to make sure that an analysis checks every kind of influence before deciding which ones matter most in a given case. A sampling of potential contributors to the behaviour of individuals can be sorted into five groups, which run roughly from the person outward.
Individual factors include awareness and knowledge, biophysical characteristics such as genetics, personal attitudes and motivations, developmental stage, and habits socialized by parents and family; these are the characteristics a person carries with them from setting to setting. Social, cultural, and group factors include peer group lifestyle patterns, cultural attitudes and beliefs, and the level of social support; these belong to the groups a person is part of rather than to the person alone. Socioeconomic and structural factors include poverty, education, access to health care, prevention services, and information, social stressors such as civil strife, neighbourhood violence, and discrimination, and access to clean water; these are the conditions and resources that shape what is possible for a person, whatever they know or want. Political factors include policies and funding for health promotion programs, health insurance, and regulations that affect health risk; these are decisions made by governments and institutions. Environmental factors include the presence of an environmental risk such as air or water pollution, disasters, and conditions for the spread of infectious disease; these are features of the physical world in which everything else takes place.
For example, Sam's case from Section 1 touches several groups at once. His mother's rule, now his own habit, is an individual factor; the magazine's picture of the ideal male is a cultural one; and a family that could never pay a dentist's bill reflects poverty and access to care, which are socioeconomic and structural.
The five groups are described below. Each description gives a list of examples and a Canadian illustration of how factors in that group act on a real behaviour.
Individual factors
Examples: awareness and knowledge (about health risks and ways to prevent problems); biophysical characteristics such as genetics and systemic vulnerabilities; personal attitudes and motivations; developmental stage (adolescent, adult); and behaviour or habit socialization from parents and family.
Illustration: a 16-year-old in Kelowna knows that vaping harms the lungs (knowledge), is at a stage where peer approval outweighs distant risk (developmental stage), and grew up in a household where nobody smoked (socialization). Three individual factors, pulling in different directions.
Social, cultural, and group factors
Examples: social and peer group lifestyle patterns; cultural attitudes and beliefs and their implications for health; and level of social support.
Illustration: the same teenager's friend group all vape (peer lifestyle), and in her extended family a large body is read as a sign of doing well (cultural belief). Neither belongs to her alone; both shape what she does.
Socioeconomic and structural factors
Examples: poverty; education; access to health care and prevention services and information; social stressors such as civil strife, neighbourhood violence, and racial and other discrimination; and access to clean water.
Illustration: many First Nations communities in Canada have lived under long-term drinking water advisories, some for well over a decade. Access to clean water sits in the structural group because it is a matter of infrastructure and investment rather than of any resident's choices.
Political factors
Examples: policies and funding for health promotion programs; health insurance (policies, cost, availability); and regulations that affect health risk, such as prohibiting the sale of cigarettes to minors.
Illustration: provincial rules on flavoured vaping products, the federal decision to fund or not fund a school food program, and the fact that routine dental care sits outside medicare for most Canadians are all political factors. None of them appears in a survey of attitudes, and all of them move behaviour.
Environmental factors
Examples: the presence of an environmental risk such as air or water pollution; disasters; and conditions for the spread of an infectious disease.
Illustration: wildfire smoke that blankets the BC Interior for weeks each summer keeps people indoors, cancels outdoor activity, and changes what "getting some exercise" can mean. In the same way, mercury in a river changes what a fish means: a food that once stood for nourishment and community becomes a hazard. The environment sets the terms within which every other level operates, because no amount of knowledge or motivation can make smoky air safe to exercise in or contaminated fish safe to eat.
Two points from these descriptions are worth carrying forward. First, one distinction is easy to blur. Access to clean water is listed under socioeconomic and structural factors, because whether a community has safe water is a matter of infrastructure and investment. The presence of water pollution, however, is listed under environmental factors, because it is a hazard in the physical world. The same glass of water can therefore raise two different kinds of influence, and an answer should say which one the case describes.
Second, and more important, this list does not operate in the world as a collection of separate items. The factors tend to operate together, and that is why the model borrows the term ecology from biology. In biology, ecology refers to three things: a system of interactions between organisms and an environment; the complex relationships among organisms within the system (niches, for example); and the dependent relationships among the parts, such that if one part is disturbed, the others are affected. Each of these carries over to behaviour. People interact with their surroundings, they occupy different positions within families, communities, and societies, and a change at one point spreads to the others. For example, in the Grassy Narrows case, contamination of the river (environmental) disturbed a food source, a livelihood (socioeconomic), and a way of life (cultural) all at once. The human version of that ecology is usually drawn as levels, which the next subsection sets out.
4.2 Levels of Influence
The five groups of factors answer the question "what kinds of influence are there?" The levels of influence answer a related but different question: "how close to the person does each influence operate?" The levels are usually drawn as nested rings. The individual sits at the centre. Around the individual is the family and social group, then the community or population group, then the cultural and societal level, and finally the political, economic, and structural level. By this we mean that each ring contains the ones inside it, so a provincial law reaches a person through their community and family as well as directly. Arrows run in both directions: influences flow inward through the layers, and behaviour flows back out and reshapes them. Figure 1.1 draws these levels as nested rings around the individual.
Figure 1.1. Levels of influence within a social ecology of behaviour, drawn as nested rings around the individual. Influences move inward through the layers; behaviour moves outward and reshapes them.
Notice that the rings and the five-group list do not match one for one, and students are often unsure which to use. The list separates political, structural, and environmental factors into three groups, whereas Figure 1.1 folds them into a single outer ring. In addition, the figure adds explicit community and cultural layers that the list combines with social and group factors. The reason for the difference is that both are sorting tools rather than fixed taxonomies: they exist to make sure nothing is missed, not to assign every influence a single correct box. As a result, an influence can plausibly sit in more than one place. For example, a parent's rule that has become a child's own habit can be read as individual or as social, and a missing dentist combined with no public dental coverage can be read as structural or as political. What matters is the habit of asking, for any behaviour, what is acting on it at each level. Interactive 1.3 gives you practice with eleven influences drawn from this lesson. Click an influence, then click the group of factors where it belongs, and read the feedback, which explains the reasoning and the cases where two groups are defensible.
📊 Interactive 1.3: Sort the influences.
Click an influence, then click the group of factors where it belongs. Some influences fit more than one group; the feedback explains the reasoning.Individual
Social, cultural, and group
Socioeconomic and structural
Political
Environmental
When you sort an influence in an answer, name the group and give the reason from the list: "neighbourhood violence is socioeconomic and structural because it is a social stressor", not simply "it is outside the person". Where two groups are defensible, as with a parent's rule that has become the child's own habit, say which you chose and why. Sorting is not the end of the analysis, though, and the last subsection explains why the complexity it reveals is something to respect rather than to simplify away.
4.3 The HEAL Framework for Wellbeing
The levels of influence describe how close to the person each influence operates. This course also uses a second map, which the studio sessions return to in every lesson: the Healthy Ecologies and Lifestyles (HEAL) Framework for Wellbeing, a social-ecological model developed by Kiffer Card to organize his research on social connection, climate and mental health, and syndemics. The framework describes how natural and social environments, above and beyond individual behaviour, shape health inequities. Its central claim is that health is patterned by social position, power, and material conditions, and not mainly by personal choice. Individual behaviour remains in the model, but it is treated as shaped by constraints set further upstream.
The framework has two kinds of domain. Five domains are where inequity is structured: the sociopolitical context (the arrangement of political institutions, ideologies, and governance that sets the terms for everything downstream), social position (a person's location in hierarchies of class, race, gender, sexuality, ability, and citizenship, which is produced by context and is not a personal trait), material circumstance (income, housing, neighbourhood, food security, and working conditions), health and social systems (the institutions that deliver or withhold care, income support, housing, and education), and biological response and function (how environments get under the skin through stress, immune function, and cumulative wear). Three domains are where inequity appears: psychosocial state or disposition (beliefs, emotions, identities, and expectations), behaviour, and health and harms. Figure 1.2 sets out a simplified version.
Figure 1.2. A simplified version of the HEAL Framework for Wellbeing (Card). Grey domains are where inequity is structured; teal domains are where it appears as disposition, behaviour, and health. The grouping of processes is a simplification for this course; the interactive original, with a description of every domain and process, is at kiffercard.com/research-framework.html.
Processes connect the domains, and they carry inequity from the structure of society into the body and back again. Four processes are structural: the -isms (systems of oppression such as racism, classism, cis-heterosexism, and ableism, which sort people into social positions), politics (the contest over what is funded and for whom), power and capital (the conversion of social position into material advantage or disadvantage), and policy (the lever that connects systems to the conditions of daily life, and the point where intervention is most actionable). Several processes act on the body and the mind, among them alteration (the direct biological imprint of environments), sensitivity (accumulated disadvantage making the same exposure more harmful, a process sometimes called weathering), conditioning, compulsion, acculturation (absorbing the norms and ideologies of one's context), learning, and reasoned action. Reasoned action is the narrow band in which deliberate, intentional choice operates; individualized models of health treat it as the whole story, whereas a social-ecological model treats it as one input among many. Other processes run back up the model: selection (health and disposition sorting people into social positions), compounding consequences (ill health lowering social position, which worsens exposure and access), services and supports (the pathways through which systems reach, or fail to reach, people's behaviour and health), and social construction (collective behaviour reshaping the sociopolitical context over time, which is where change becomes possible). Time, or the life course, is the framework's axis rather than a process of its own: advantage and disadvantage build up over lives and across generations.
The framework is used in this course for three reasons. First, it places the theories of later lessons on one map: most individual theories describe the narrow band between psychosocial state and behaviour, while political economy, cultural theory, and multilevel theory work further upstream. Second, its research program on social connection treats social environments, rather than personal sociability, as the modifiable determinant of loneliness, which is the position the course's running examples take. Third, it states its commitments openly: health inequities are produced by how societies are organized, equity-oriented public health works on upstream constraints, and the framework is accountable to lived experience and community knowledge. It credits its core commitments (interconnectedness, the inseparability of environment and wellbeing, and health residing in relationships among people, land, and community) to Indigenous knowledge systems and to Two-Eyed Seeing (Etuaptmumk), from Mi'kmaw Elders Albert and Murdena Marshall.
7.1 Respecting Complexity
Answering "Why do people do what they do?" or its public health version is, admittedly, no easy matter, and the five groups and nested levels show how many places an answer can come from. It might seem that this complexity is simply an obstacle. However, knowing that the task is complex is good. Gaining a certain respect for the complexity of the task is healthy, because it changes how a planner behaves. If you think the problem is simple, you are more likely to implement a standardized or cookie-cutter program, by which we mean a ready-made program applied to a new place without much thought about whether it fits the situation. If you respect the complexity, you are more likely to ask first what is acting on the behaviour in this particular setting, and only then decide what to do. One goal of this course is that you emerge with more wisdom than the cookie-cutter approach. Worked Example 1.3 applies the levels of influence to a program at risk of exactly this mistake; as you read it, notice which levels the program reaches and which it never mentions.
Worked Example 1.3: A Cookie-Cutter Program Travels North
A school district in the Lower Mainland has run a well-received healthy-eating curriculum for several years. Lessons teach students to read nutrition labels, plan balanced meals from Canada's Food Guide, and choose fresh produce over packaged snacks. A health authority proposes exporting the curriculum unchanged to a fly-in community in the territories, where perishable food arrives by air, fresh produce is sometimes unavailable and often costs several times the southern price, and traditional foods from hunting and fishing remain central to diet and identity. The federal Nutrition North Canada subsidy exists precisely because of these price gaps. Which levels does the curriculum address, which does it leave untouched, and what would a program built for this community need to include?
Step 1, identify the behaviour and the population. The behaviour is healthy eating; the population is students in a fly-in community in the territories.
Step 2, map the curriculum onto the levels. Label reading, meal planning, and choosing produce are knowledge and skills. The curriculum works almost entirely at the individual level.
Step 3, map the community's influences onto the levels the curriculum leaves untouched. At the socioeconomic and structural level, perishable food arrives by air and fresh produce is scarce and costly. At the political level, the question is whether the Nutrition North Canada subsidy actually reaches shelf prices and whether program funding lasts. At the social and cultural level, traditional foods from hunting and fishing, food-sharing norms, and local meanings of body size shape what counts as a good diet.
Step 4, state the implication for the program. Because behaviour and environment interact, lessons that run into unchanged prices and empty shelves are likely to fade. A program built for the community, rather than imported into it, would pair classroom lessons with structural and cultural components designed with the community: a traditional foods program, a community greenhouse or garden, or negotiated pricing at the store, so that what students learn can be cooked from food they can actually get.
The curriculum is not wrong; it is incomplete for this setting. The cookie-cutter mistake is assuming that what worked in one place will work in another without asking which levels differ.
None of this is a reason to throw up your hands. Respecting complexity does not mean deciding that nothing can be done; it means doing the work of assessment before acting. A long tradition of researchers and practitioners has built up a considerable store of scientific knowledge, interpretive understanding, and practical application with respect to changing behaviour. There are many schools of thought and many disagreements about what should be the focus of attention, but those disagreements are a resource, because they give a planner several ways of looking at the same problem. The remainder of this course does three things with that tradition: it reviews theoretical approaches and their assumptions so that you can judge which make sense in a given situation; it presents a general planning approach for assessing a problem, deciding what kind of program might change it, and determining whether you succeeded; and it tours the settings and health problems, including smoking, cancer, cardiovascular disease, HIV/AIDS, maternal and child health, youth violence, and obesity, where the theory gets applied. Treat the course as a resource for an ongoing search for answers rather than a compendium of the answers themselves.
This section has named the ecological model and its central assumption, related it to the social determinants approach and to Canadian milestones in health promotion, sorted the influences on behaviour into five groups of factors and nested levels of influence, and explained why respecting that complexity protects against cookie-cutter programs. The key takeaways and knowledge check that follow review this material, and the next section applies the model to two health problems, obesity and youth violence.
Key Takeaways
- 3.2 Until the late 1970s and early 1980s, health promotion concentrated on the knowledge, attitudes, and motivations of individuals, on the assumption that people who knew the risks would change. The turn that followed shifted attention to the multiplicity of influences on behaviour, and that focus is what is called the ecological model. Green and Kreuter's planning work contributed to the turn, and the health promotion literature usually traces the ecological model itself to McLeroy and colleagues (1988) and Stokols (1992, 1996). Remember that the model is an approach to framing a problem, not a single named theory. To place a program on either side of the turn, ask whether it assumes that information and motivation are enough.
- 3.3 The ecological model assumes that no single factor influences behaviour; instead, the complex interaction between individuals and an environment, taken together, does. Two words carry the definition: interaction, meaning people and environments act on each other, and environment, meaning everything outside the individual, social as well as physical. Family, peers, institutions, laws, and prices all count as environment. A common trap is to read "environment" as the physical world only; another is to confuse the ecological model with the ecological fallacy, which is an unrelated statistical error.
- 3.4 The World Health Organization's social determinants approach, set out in the Rio Political Declaration of 2011, says that health inequities arise from the conditions in which people are born, grow, live, work, and age: the same insight as the ecological model, stated at the level of populations and policy. In Canada, the Lalonde Report (1974) placed environment and lifestyle beside biology and health care, and the Ottawa Charter (1986) defined health promotion as enabling people to increase control over and improve their health, with five action areas of which only developing personal skills is about the individual. If asked which document says what, anchor each to its key phrase: health field concept, enabling control, societal conditions.
- 4.1 Influences on behaviour can be sampled in five groups: individual; social, cultural, and group; socioeconomic and structural; political; and environmental. The groups are a sorting tool, and in the world they operate together, which is why the biological term ecology fits: in biology it means a system of interactions between organisms and an environment in which disturbing one part affects the others. Watch the boundary between structural and environmental factors: access to clean water is structural, while pollution of the water is environmental.
- 4.2 The same influences can be drawn as nested levels: individual, family and social group, community and population group, cultural and societal, and political, economic, and structural, with influences flowing inward and behaviour flowing back out. The rings and the five groups do not match one for one, and some influences sit defensibly in two places. When you classify an influence, name the group and give the reason from the list, and if two groups fit, say which you chose and why.
- 7.1 Respecting the complexity of behaviour is healthy for a practitioner, because anyone who thinks the problem is simple is more likely to implement a standardized, cookie-cutter program without asking whether it fits. The healthy-eating curriculum exported to a fly-in community shows the error: it reaches individual knowledge and ignores the prices, supply, subsidies, and food traditions that decide what people eat. Respect for complexity is not despair, because a long tradition of research and practice offers usable knowledge. When a case describes a program moved from one place to another, ask which levels differ between the two settings.
1. Which statement best captures the central assumption of the ecological model?
2. A First Nations community has lived under a drinking water advisory for more than a decade because its treatment plant was never upgraded. In the five-group sampling of factors, this lack of access to clean water belongs under which group?
3. For the purposes of the ecological model, "environment" is defined as:
4. Why is gaining respect for the complexity of behaviour described as "healthy" for someone who will design programs?
5. The Ottawa Charter for Health Promotion (1986) lists five action areas. Which one is the only area aimed primarily at the individual level of the ecological model?
6. A public health unit plans a six-week "healthy choices" workshop on diet and activity for a remote, fly-in community where type 2 diabetes is rising. Which influence on eating sits at the socioeconomic and structural level and would be left untouched by the workshop?
7. A program designed in 1975 assumes that if people know the risks of smoking and want to avoid them, they will quit, so it relies entirely on information leaflets. How is this program best described?
8. A health authority wants to export a successful Lower Mainland healthy-eating curriculum unchanged to a fly-in community in the territories. Which change would do most to make the program fit the new setting?
✦ Pass the knowledge check with 100% to continue
Health Issues and Behaviour I: Obesity and Youth Violence
⏱ Estimated reading time: 18 minutes
Overview
The second half of this lesson exists to show why an understanding of behaviour matters for public health problems. For each of three health issues it asks which behaviours are involved, what consequences follow, and what shapes those behaviours, with one framing sentence that is easy to skip: behaviour is just one factor that determines a health problem, and behaviour is itself influenced by many factors. This section takes up the first two issues. Obesity shows why education alone produced only short-term change and what an ecological intervention adds; youth violence shows one behaviour explained at many different levels.
Learning Objectives
- 5.1 Describe the scale and consequences of obesity and the behavioural and environmental causes commonly given for it, and explain why the problem is considered preventable.
- 5.2 Explain why education-only approaches to obesity produced short-term success but weak long-term change, and what an ecological intervention adds.
- 5.3 Identify individual, social, cultural, and physical-environment influences on food choice and physical activity, including the built environment.
- 5.4 Describe youth violence as a behaviour, its consequences, and the period of life in which it peaks.
- 6.1 Describe the six explanations for youth violence and identify the level at which each locates the cause.
- 6.2 Explain how explanations of youth violence at different levels complement one another, and identify the explanation on which a given program draws.
5.1 Obesity: A Recent Trend, and Therefore a Preventable One
Obesity is the first of the two problems. Start with scale: more than two thirds of American adults were overweight or obese in 2007 to 2008 (Flegal and colleagues, 2010), obesity among children aged 6 to 11 was nearly five times its early-1970s level (Ogden and Carroll, 2010), and about 1.5 billion adults worldwide were overweight by World Health Organization estimates, with rapid increases in China, Brazil, Colombia, and urban sub-Saharan Africa. Statistics Canada surveys have for years found more than one Canadian adult in four with a body mass index in the obese range. The scale matters because obesity is not a health problem in itself so much as a condition that raises the risk of others. The consequences named are type 2 diabetes, heart disease, and certain cancers, and in addition to this illness, the rising costs of treating it place a burden on healthcare systems. In other words, a trend in body weight becomes a public health problem because of the disease and expense that follow from it.
Where does behaviour come in? The answer turns on timing. Because these trends are recent, most researchers agree that interactions between behaviour and environment, rather than biology, are the primary cause. The reasoning is that genetics have not changed in a generation, whereas the way people live and the surroundings they live in have. A cause that changed recently is a cause that can, in principle, be changed again, and that is what makes the problem preventable. The usual list of causes deliberately mixes behaviours with the environments that produce them: marketing of unhealthy food, overeating, lack of exercise, reliance on vehicles, a sedentary life built around screens and labour-saving devices, changes in food quality, larger portions, eating out, the convenience food industry, and more advertising. Notice how few of these items a single person controls. Then ask yourself directly: how often do you eat out, and how often do you exercise?
If the causes are mostly behaviour interacting with environment, the obvious first response is to tell people what to change. The next subsection explains why that response, on its own, fell short.
5.2 Why Knowledge Alone Fell Short
For a while, public health efforts concentrated on awareness. In practice this meant guidelines for diet and exercise, warnings about excess weight, and programs to build personal knowledge and skills. These efforts produced moderate short-term successes, but they did not prove effective in the long term. Critics explained the pattern as an overreliance on what individuals can and cannot do, at the expense of the sociocultural and physical environments that shape their decisions. By this we mean that the programs asked people to change while leaving unchanged the surroundings that had produced the behaviour in the first place, so that once the program ended, those surroundings pulled behaviour back. Many of those efforts drew on individual behaviour change theories, which explain behaviour through a person's own beliefs, knowledge and skills.
Here a point is easy to miss. It might seem that the fix is simply to add an environmental program to the educational one. However, the shortfall cannot necessarily be fixed by adding an individual-level intervention to an environmental one, because behaviour and the environment interact: they act upon one another. This is where ecological models come in. They integrate interpersonal, organizational, community, and policy influences, and an ecological intervention includes components at several levels designed so that an environmental change supports a behaviour change. The key word is "designed". The components are planned together so that each makes the others work, rather than being run side by side. The classic example is small and concrete: removing vending machines, or changing what they sell, cuts down on high-fat snacking. Here the environmental change makes the advised behaviour the easy one, so a lesson about snacking and a change to the machines reinforce each other. The callout below names the trap this point sets for exam answers.
A common trap: adding is not integrating
It is tempting to answer that the fix for education-only programs is "education plus an environmental program". That is not what the model asks. Because behaviour and environment act on each other, the components have to be designed so that each supports the other, as when the vending machines stop selling the very snacks the nutrition lesson told students to avoid. Two programs that merely run side by side are not yet an ecological intervention.
Table 1.2 sets out influences on obesity-related behaviour at the individual, social, cultural, and physical environment levels, with a Canadian program example at each level. Read across each row to see which kind of program reaches which kind of influence.
Table 1.2. Influences on obesity-related behaviour at four levels, with a Canadian program example at each level.
| Level | Influences on obesity-related behaviour | A Canadian program example |
|---|---|---|
| Individual | Genetics, taste and food preferences, attitudes, beliefs, knowledge, hunger | Dietitian counselling in primary care; Canada's Food Guide as a personal tool |
| Social | Interpersonal processes, relationships, social status | Community kitchens and family cooking programs run by health units |
| Cultural | Shared beliefs and values about food, the body, and eating practices | The 2007 Food Guide adaptation for First Nations, Inuit, and Métis, built around traditional foods |
| Physical environment | Availability and cost of food and exercise options; physical layout of the environment | British Columbia's mandatory school food and beverage guidelines (since 2008); municipal active-transportation plans |
Only the first row of Table 1.2 is reached by education alone. The next subsection looks more closely at what sits in the other rows for the two behaviours at the heart of obesity, eating and physical activity.
5.3 What Shapes Eating and Physical Activity
Taste, cost, convenience, and preference are the obvious influences on diet, but by themselves they do not explain much, because they describe choices without asking what shapes the options. The other influences can be read level by level. At the level of the physical environment, food choice is limited by availability, because low-income areas often lack the stores most likely to stock fresh produce; a person cannot choose produce that is not sold nearby. At the cultural level, food choice is shaped by ideas of what counts as a proper meal, usually a protein paired with a starch, and by the meanings of food sharing, which expresses hospitality, solidarity, and obligation. For example, because sharing food expresses obligation as well as hospitality, what a person eats at a shared meal is not simply their own decision about nutrition. Culture also shapes how body size is read, since in many societies being large has been a sign of health, which connects back to the fourth way a behaviour can relate to health in Section 1. At the individual level, whether someone chooses low-fat foods depends on their beliefs about the benefit and their confidence, usually called self-efficacy, that they can manage the choice.
Physical activity follows the same pattern. Cost, time, safety, and access are the major factors in whether a person is active. In addition to these, the built environment, the human-made surroundings that provide the setting for daily activity, has been shown to change how much people move. By this we mean that the design of streets, buildings, and worksites can make activity the easy choice or the hard one, quite apart from what a person intends.
Interactive 1.4 has two tabs, one for each behaviour. Open both tabs: the first describes the influences on food choice in more detail, and the second the factors that govern regular activity, with the studies that link the built environment to how much people move.
Interactive 1.4. Influences on food choice and on physical activity, including the built environment.
Food, eating, and obesity
Taste, cost, convenience, and preference are the obvious influences on diet, but by themselves they do not explain much. Availability: low-income areas often lack the stores most likely to stock fresh produce, so choice is limited by where one lives. Norms and identity: ideas about what counts as a meal vary by ethnicity, region, gender, age, and class; across cultures the ideal meal pairs a protein with a starch. Meanings: food sharing expresses hospitality, solidarity, and obligation, and local models often judge a food healthful because it is common and filling rather than by its composition.
Three further points matter for program planning. First, calling obesity a disease is new, and being large has carried positive value in many societies, so a program that treats body size as a medical problem may be working against a long-standing local meaning. Second, whether someone chooses low-fat foods depends on beliefs about the benefit and on their confidence, usually called self-efficacy, that they can manage the choice. By this we mean that a person who believes low-fat eating helps, but doubts they can keep it up, may not try at all. Third, risks are hard to take seriously when they are not connected to lived experience, while the immediate benefits of a risky behaviour feel like wellbeing. For example, a teenager who smokes may feel more grown-up and accepted today, while lung disease remains an abstraction decades away; a person who shares needles may experience the sharing as a matter of relief and belonging rather than risk. Because the benefit is felt now and the harm is only imagined, the risky behaviour can seem like the sensible choice.
Physical exercise and obesity
Cost, time, safety, and access are the major factors in whether a person takes up regular activity, and whether exercise becomes routine depends on their job, free time, facilities, and the physical character of the neighbourhood, worksite, or school. This last factor is the built environment: the man-made surroundings that provide the setting for human activity, from civic surroundings to personal places.
When changes to the built environment remove barriers, people walk or bike to destinations, exercise at lunch, or take the stairs on their own. By this we mean that the change does not persuade anyone; it simply makes the active choice easier than it was. Studies have found that signs prompting stair use increased it among shoppers, that showers and changing rooms at work increased active commuting, and that new trails increased walking in rural communities. In the second case, for example, a worker who would like to cycle in but cannot arrive at a meeting sweaty now has a practical way to do it. Each is an environmental change that supports a behaviour, the definition of an ecological intervention.
The physical activity tab ends with three findings worth remembering: signs prompting stair use increased it among shoppers, showers and changing rooms at work increased active commuting, and new trails increased walking in rural communities. Each is an environmental change that supports a behaviour, which is the definition of an ecological intervention. Two Canadian programs show how these influences look from the program side. Worked Example 1.4 measures both against the argument of 5.2; as you read it, watch for messages that quietly assume an environment many Canadians do not have.
Worked Example 1.4: Canada's Food Guide and ParticipACTION
Health Canada's 2019 revision of Canada's Food Guide replaced four food groups and serving counts with a single plate: half vegetables and fruit, a quarter whole grains, a quarter protein foods, water as the drink of choice. Industry-commissioned reports were excluded from the evidence review, and the guide reaches past nutrients: cook more often, eat with others, limit highly processed foods, be aware of food marketing. ParticipACTION was founded in 1971 to promote physical activity, and its 1973 television spot claiming that the average 30-year-old Canadian was as fit as a 60-year-old Swede became one of the best-known pieces of Canadian health communication. Wound down in 2001 and relaunched in 2007, it now co-produces the Canadian 24-Hour Movement Guidelines. Using the account of why education fell short, how far can each program go on its own, and what would it need to be paired with?
Step 1, identify the level each program works at. The guide is still, in the end, a document that individuals read. For most of its history, ParticipACTION's main tool was the mass media message. Both work at the individual level, on knowledge and motivation.
Step 2, find the messages that depend on an environment. "Half vegetables and fruit" depends on stores that stock affordable produce, which low-income areas often lack. "Cook more often" depends on time, a kitchen, and the cost of ingredients. "Water as the drink of choice" depends on safe tap water, which communities under long-term drinking water advisories do not have. "Move more" depends on cost, time, safety, access, and a built environment that makes activity practical.
Step 3, decide what each program needs to be paired with. Some of the guide's environmental partners already exist: British Columbia has required schools to meet nutrition guidelines for the food they sell since 2008, and the 2024 federal budget committed funding to a national school food program, both of which change what children can actually eat. ParticipACTION's messages would need trails, bike lanes, worksite showers, stair prompts, and affordable programs alongside them.
Education is not wasted: it produced moderate short-term success. The example shows the lesson of the obesity case, which is that a message lasts when the environment makes the advised behaviour possible.
Step 3 of the worked example asks what a campaign would need to be paired with, and Interactive 1.5 turns that question into an exercise. It asks you to design an obesity program for a mid-sized city from components at the individual, social and cultural, physical and organizational environment, and policy levels. Choose the components you would fund, then press the assess button to see how many sit at each level and whether the package pairs changes in people with changes in their environment.
📊 Interactive 1.5: Build an intervention package.
A regional health authority has asked you to design an obesity program for a mid-sized city. Choose the components you would fund, then assess the package.Individual
Social and cultural
Physical and organizational environment
Policy
A package that scores as ecological is one in which, for example, the nutrition classes are matched by school food standards and the walking groups by lit trails, so that each change in people has a change in the environment to support it. The obesity case has shown that education aimed at individuals produced moderate short-term success and weak long-term change, and that an ecological intervention combines components at several levels so that a change in the environment supports a change in behaviour. The section turns next to its second problem, youth violence.
5.4 Youth Violence as a Behaviour
The second issue differs from the first in an important way. Obesity is a condition that behaviour contributes to, whereas youth violence is itself a behaviour. By this we mean that the thing public health wants to prevent is an act that people do, and the public health concern is the injury and trauma that the act causes. The World Health Organization views violence as one of the leading public health issues of our time, and as of 2026 it estimates that young people aged 15 to 29 account for about 40 percent of homicides worldwide, some 193,000 deaths a year (World Health Organization, 2026). In the United States, homicide was the second leading cause of death for ages 10 to 24 in 2007, most of those victims were killed with a firearm, and the burden fell far more heavily on African American and Latino youth (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 2010). Canada's homicide rate is a fraction of the American rate, but here too, youth and young adults have the highest rates of both committing and experiencing violent crime.
Serious violence generally begins between ages 12 and 20, so the peak period coincides with adolescence, the years in which young people are forming identities, seeking status among peers, and taking more risks of every kind. The burden is also concentrated in high-poverty communities and among racialized youth. Together, these two patterns suggest that the causes cannot lie only in individual young people, because both the timing and the location of violence follow features of the life course and of the surrounding community. Those facts raise the question the next subsection takes up: why so much violence among young people?
6.1 Six Explanations for Youth Violence
Beyond biological and developmental accounts of aggression, there is a set of social and psychological explanations for youth violence. What they share is a concern with the interaction between youth and their family, community, and school environments, and many of them treat violence as one of a set of adolescent risk behaviours rather than as a problem on its own. Six are commonly distinguished. The most useful way to tell them apart is to ask, for each one, where it locates the cause: in the young person's mind, in their history, in their pattern of behaviour, in their surroundings, or in some combination. Each explanation answers that question differently, and each answer points to a different kind of program:
- Risk and protective factor explanations list influences across family, peers, school, and community that raise risk (family violence, poverty, easy access to weapons, norms that support violence) or offset it (a caring adult, connection to school). The cause lies in the balance of factors across several levels at once, a "web of influence". By this we mean that no single factor decides the outcome; a young person exposed to family violence and neighbourhood weapons may still avoid violence if a caring adult and a strong connection to school weigh on the other side.
- Problem behaviour syndrome treats violence as part of a coherent pattern of adolescent risk taking, alongside substance use and early sexual activity, with overlapping risk factors. The cause lies in the young person's overall pattern of behaviour and their weak commitment to conventional society. In other words, violence is read as one expression of a broader stance toward the conventional world, so the same young person is likely to show several of the behaviours at once.
- Developmental pathways treat violence as the outcome of a trajectory that begins early in life. The cause lies in time: early experience sets a young person on a course, and what happens later can make that course steeper, as when further risks pile up, or bend it toward a better outcome, as when supports arrive. This is why programs in this tradition intervene in childhood rather than waiting for adolescence.
- Self-concept and possible selves ask what futures an adolescent can imagine for themselves. When no satisfactory conventional possible self is available, violence and delinquency become alternative routes to self-definition and prestige. The cause lies in identity, shaped by context. For example, a young person who cannot picture becoming a student, a worker, or a respected family member may instead build an identity around toughness, because that is the self the setting makes available.
- Socioecological models locate the cause in community and structural conditions: poverty, isolation, a street economy that becomes the main field for status, and the codes of the street that govern conflict. By this we mean that where legitimate work and status are scarce, the informal and often illegal economy becomes the place to earn respect, and the unwritten rules of that economy, such as never backing down from a challenge, make violence an expected response rather than an individual failing.
- Social-cognitive models, such as social information processing, locate the cause in how a young person encodes and interprets a social cue, such as an insult or a grimace, and selects a response. The cause lies in individual cognition and the repertoire of responses available.
The six explanations are described below, each with the researchers and the evidence behind it. For each explanation, note what kind of program it would point to.
1. Risk and protective factor explanations
Risk factors include family conflict and violence, absence of positive role models, being a victim of or witnessing violence, poverty, a crime-ridden community where weapons are easily available, and norms that support violence (Hawkins, Catalano, and Miller, 1992). Protective factors such as a caring adult or connection to school can offset them. Two approaches build on this idea of protection. Resilience approaches ask why some young people exposed to many risks do well anyway, and positive youth development aims to promote thriving rather than only to prevent problems, for example by building skills, relationships, and opportunities to contribute. The interaction between a person and factors across domains such as family, peers, school, and community is a "web of influence," drawing on Bronfenbrenner's ecological perspective. The word "web" signals that the factors are connected, so a change in one domain, such as a new mentor at school, can shift the balance in the others.
2. Problem behaviour syndrome
Substance use, delinquency and violence, early sexual activity, and other behaviours form a coherent pattern of risk taking with overlapping risk factors and trajectories. A widely used chart from Hawkins, Catalano, and colleagues lists 19 risk factors for adolescent problem behaviour: 16 predict both delinquency and substance use, and 11 predict delinquency, substance use, and violence alike (Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention, 1998). The pattern may reflect an antagonistic relationship with the conventional world. By this we mean that the behaviours cluster because they share a common source: adolescents whose aspirations are frustrated by poverty, school failure, or social disorganization may come to see school, work, and the law as closed to them. Because they expect little from conventional society, they hold a low commitment to its rules and bond instead to peers with the same behaviours, who in turn reward them. This explains why a young person involved in violence is often involved in substance use and early sexual activity as well.
3. Developmental pathways
Several theories treat crime and violence as the outcome of a developmental pathway, or trajectory, that begins at an early age and is shaped by multiple risk factors along the way. The emphasis is on time: early experience sets a course that later risks can steepen or later supports can bend, so programs in this tradition intervene early rather than at the age when violence peaks.
4. Self-concept and possible selves
Self-concept is the mental image one has of oneself. This approach focuses on the possible selves an adolescent can envision as relevant to their life (Oyserman and Markus, 1990). A satisfactory possible self in family, friends, or school motivates the transition to adulthood; if none is available, delinquency and violence become alternative routes to self-definition and prestige, especially where peers value them. Oyserman and Packer add that identity formation is tied to context. By this we mean that young people build their sense of who they could become from the paths they can actually see around them. Where academic success seems unrelated to any available life path, its behaviours, such as studying and attending class, will not be valued, and others, such as toughness or standing in a peer group, will be.
5. Socioecological models
Youth risk behaviours are viewed as health disparities, with involvement and its causes differing by socioeconomic status. By this we mean that these models do not ask why one young person turns to violence, but why violence is concentrated in some communities and not others. Their answer is that the conditions young people face differ by class and race. For example, lower-SES and minority youth are more likely to be involved in drug dealing, which carries a much higher risk of violence. William Julius Wilson described isolated, uniformly poor inner-city communities where the street economy became the main field for status. Elijah Anderson described how these conditions shape norms about violence and the codes of the street that govern it. Homicide data support the argument: the rise in juvenile homicide from the mid-1980s to the mid-1990s tracked the crack cocaine epidemic and the guns that came with it and stayed. Spergel's gang intervention model treats gangs as a product of missing opportunity, social disorganization, poverty, institutional racism, and weak social controls.
6. Social-cognitive models
In the social information processing model (Crick and Dodge, 1994), aggression happens when a youth evaluates a social cue such as a grimace or an insult, interprets it according to context, and chooses a potentially violent response. Aggression results from difficulty coding and interpreting cues, or from a limited repertoire of nonaggressive responses. For example, a youth who reads an accidental bump in a hallway as a deliberate challenge, and who knows no way to respond other than to fight back, is likely to turn the moment into violence. Both difficulties depend on beliefs about the legitimacy of aggression, that is, whether hitting back is seen as acceptable or even necessary, and those beliefs are linked to perceived neighbourhood danger. A young person who believes the streets are dangerous has good reason to read cues as threats. The approach therefore intersects with the others: the prevalence and utility of violence in a community feed both beliefs and involvement.
The descriptions add evidence worth knowing, and each piece of evidence supports a particular explanation. The chart from Hawkins, Catalano, and colleagues shows that of 19 risk factors for adolescent problem behaviour, 11 are common to delinquency, substance use, and violence. Because the three behaviours share so many risk factors, it makes sense to treat them as one syndrome rather than as separate problems, so this finding is the evidence for problem behaviour syndrome. The rise in juvenile homicide from the mid-1980s to the mid-1990s tracked the crack cocaine epidemic and the guns that came with it. Because the cause here is a change in neighbourhood conditions rather than in individual young people, this finding supports the socioecological account.
Some pairs of explanations are easy to confuse, and it helps to name the difference directly. Risk and protective factor explanations and socioecological models both look beyond the individual; however, the first weighs a balance of influences across family, peers, school, and community, while the second points specifically to community and structural conditions such as poverty, isolation, and the street economy. Similarly, developmental pathways and problem behaviour syndrome both look at more than one moment in a young person's life; however, the first follows a trajectory through time, while the second looks at a cluster of risk behaviours occurring together. When a question describes a mechanism, identify the explanation from where it locates the cause: in a cue and a response, in a trajectory, in an imagined future, in a pattern of risk taking, in the balance of risk and protective factors, or in neighbourhood conditions. The next subsection asks how the six fit together.
6.2 Reading the Explanations Together
Read the six as a set. Each locates the cause at a different level of the web and implies a different program, so it might seem that a planner has to pick the correct one. However, the explanations intersect rather than compete. By this we mean that the causes they describe feed into one another, so each explanation captures part of a single process rather than a rival account of it. For example, the prevalence and utility of violence in a community, a socioecological condition, feed young people's beliefs about the legitimacy of aggression, and those beliefs drive the interpretations of cues that social-cognitive programs try to change. In the same way, a young person who cannot picture a satisfactory future in school or work, a self-concept problem, is also responding to the opportunities the neighbourhood offers, which is a socioecological condition. Because the causes are linked, a program built on only one explanation leaves the others free to undo its work. A serious program therefore draws on several explanations. Worked Example 1.5 applies this reasoning to a school program from Ontario; as you read it, identify the explanation from what the program actually changes.
Worked Example 1.5: The Fourth R and a High-Poverty Neighbourhood
The Fourth R is a grade 9 health curriculum developed in London, Ontario, by David Wolfe and colleagues on the premise that relationship skills, the "fourth R" alongside reading, writing, and arithmetic, can be taught through role play and rehearsal of how to respond to conflict and provocation without aggression. A cluster randomized trial in Ontario schools reported less physical dating violence among students who received it (Wolfe and colleagues, 2009). Which explanation does it draw on most directly, which level does it leave to other programs, and what one component would you add for a high-poverty neighbourhood?
Step 1, identify the behaviour and the population. The behaviour is aggression, including physical dating violence; the population is grade 9 students.
Step 2, match the program to an explanation. Rehearsing how to respond to provocation without aggression assumes that violence arises from how a young person reads a provocation and from a limited repertoire of nonaggressive responses. That is the social-cognitive, or social information processing, explanation, and its level is the individual, delivered in the school setting.
Step 3, find the levels the program leaves untouched. The curriculum does not change the opportunities and norms that make aggression useful: the street economy and codes of the street of the socioecological account, or the futures a young person can imagine, which is the concern of the self-concept account.
Step 4, add a component for a high-poverty neighbourhood. A youth employment and mentorship program run with local businesses would change the opportunity structure and make a conventional possible self feel real, and a mentor is the caring adult that risk and protective factor research treats as protective. Because the explanations intersect, the two pieces should be designed to support each other: mentors can reinforce the skills the curriculum teaches, and the school program can point toward jobs that actually exist.
The example shows how to identify an explanation from what a program changes rather than from its name or setting, and why skills training and jobs are stronger together than either is alone.
This section has applied the ecological model to obesity and youth violence. In both, behaviour is one factor in the health problem and is itself shaped by influences at several levels, and a serious program draws on more than one of them. The key takeaways and knowledge check that follow review this material, and the next section turns to the third health issue, HIV/AIDS.
Key Takeaways
- 5.1 Obesity has risen fast: more than two thirds of American adults were overweight or obese by 2007 to 2008, and about 1.5 billion adults worldwide were overweight, with consequences that include type 2 diabetes, heart disease, and certain cancers. Because the rise is recent, behaviour interacting with environment, rather than biology, is seen as the primary cause, and that is exactly why the problem is considered preventable. The usual list of causes mixes behaviours (overeating, lack of exercise) with environments (food marketing, portion sizes, vehicle reliance). If asked why obesity is preventable, the key reasoning is "recent trend, so not biology, so behaviour and environment".
- 5.2 Education-only approaches, built on guidelines and warnings, produced moderate short-term success and weak long-term change, because they relied too heavily on what individuals can do and ignored the environments that shape their decisions. The fix is not simply to add an environmental program alongside, because behaviour and environment interact. An ecological intervention designs components at several levels so that an environmental change supports a behaviour change, as when changing what vending machines sell reduces high-fat snacking. In an answer, show how the pieces support each other rather than listing them side by side.
- 5.3 Food choice is shaped by availability where people live, cultural definitions of a proper meal, the social meanings of sharing, positive meanings of a large body, beliefs about benefit, and self-efficacy. Physical activity is shaped by cost, time, safety, access, and the built environment, the human-made surroundings of daily life. Stair prompts, worksite showers, and rural trails each raised activity without an education campaign. When a case describes an environmental change followed by more activity, recognize it as an ecological intervention working through the built environment; and when a program is a message, like the Food Guide or ParticipACTION's campaigns, ask which environment its advice assumes.
- 5.4 Youth violence is a behaviour rather than a condition, and the public health concern is the injury and trauma it produces. The World Health Organization treats violence as one of the leading public health issues of our time, serious violence generally begins between ages 12 and 20, and the burden is concentrated in high-poverty communities and among racialized youth. Keep the distinction clear in answers: the behaviour is violence, the health consequence is injury and death.
- 6.1 Six explanations are commonly distinguished: risk and protective factors (a balance of influences across levels), problem behaviour syndrome (a coherent pattern of risk taking), developmental pathways (a trajectory from early life), self-concept and possible selves (the futures a young person can imagine), socioecological models (poverty, isolation, the street economy), and social-cognitive models (how a cue is interpreted and a response chosen). To identify an explanation in a case, look for where it places the cause: a cue and response points to social-cognitive, shared risk factors across behaviours to problem behaviour syndrome, neighbourhood economics to socioecological. Do not confuse risk and protective factors, which weigh many influences, with problem behaviour syndrome, which groups many behaviours.
- 6.2 The six explanations intersect rather than compete: community conditions shape beliefs about aggression, and the futures a young person can imagine depend on the opportunities around them. A serious program therefore draws on several explanations and designs its pieces to support each other. The Fourth R, which rehearses nonaggressive responses to provocation, draws on the social-cognitive explanation and leaves the street economy and possible selves to other programs, such as employment and mentorship. Identify the explanation a program draws on from what it changes, not from its name.
1. Why is the rise in obesity considered preventable?
2. A large employer adds showers and changing rooms, and active commuting increases without any accompanying education campaign. This result best illustrates:
3. Which explanation for youth violence locates the cause in how a young person encodes and interprets a social cue, such as an insult or a facial grimace, and then selects a response?
4. A chart from Hawkins, Catalano, and colleagues shows that, of 19 risk factors for adolescent problem behaviour, 11 are common to delinquency, substance use, and violence. This finding most directly supports which explanation?
5. A colleague proposes fixing an education-only obesity program by running a separate environmental program alongside it. Why does the ecological model say this may not be enough?
6. Which statement about youth violence is consistent with this lesson?
7. A city proposes a youth employment and mentorship program, run with local businesses, for a high-poverty neighbourhood where the street economy has become the main source of status for young people. Which explanation for youth violence does this program draw on most directly?
8. A health department will combine a school program that teaches students to respond to provocation without aggression with a youth employment program in the same neighbourhood. What does the idea that the explanations intersect imply for how the two should be combined?
✦ Pass the knowledge check with 100% to continue
Health Issues and Behaviour II: HIV/AIDS and the Path to Intervention
⏱ Estimated reading time: 18 minutes
Overview
The third health issue is the one where the link between behaviour and disease is most direct. Human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) passes from person to person through a small number of acts, every one of which is a behaviour or its direct result. That makes HIV/AIDS the clearest demonstration of this lesson's argument, and the clearest warning against reading behaviour apart from the moral, cultural, and economic systems around it. The section works through the global toll, the regional patterns, and Canada's shift to combination prevention, then closes with the three-step path from behaviours to interventions that the rest of the course follows.
Learning Objectives
- 5.5 Summarize the global toll of HIV/AIDS, explain why prevention carries so much of the burden, and explain why each route of transmission is a behaviour or its direct result.
- 5.6 Compare how HIV epidemic patterns differ across regions and change over time, and classify the findings of a qualitative study of HIV risk in Roma communities by level of influence.
- 5.7 Describe the shift in Canadian HIV prevention toward combination prevention, and explain why each of its tools still depends on behaviour.
- 7.2 Apply the three planning steps of identifying, choosing, and designing, in order, to a health problem, using assessment questions about the behaviours and influences involved.
5.5 The Toll of HIV/AIDS and Why Prevention Carries the Burden
Data from the end of 2011 put approximately 34 million people living with HIV/AIDS, nearly 30 million deaths since the 1980s, and roughly 2.5 million new infections a year, a sign the pandemic was still expanding. The toll reaches past illness: lower life expectancy, lost household income as fewer members work and medical costs rise, depleted schools, lower economic production, rising poverty, and a generation of orphaned children. More recent UNAIDS estimates put the number living with HIV near 40 million, with new infections and deaths well below the 2011 levels, largely because of treatment.
HIV has been a crisis filled with ambiguity and controversy for two reasons that belong together: its epidemiology, the way it spreads, is clearly tied to behaviour, and although anti-retroviral drugs, given in combinations known as highly active anti-retroviral therapy (HAART), can treat the condition, there is still no cure. By this we mean that treatment can keep people alive and well but cannot remove the virus, so the most reliable way to reduce the toll is to stop new infections from happening. That places a huge burden on prevention, and because the virus spreads through what people do, prevention is largely about behaviour. There are three major routes of transmission: sexual transmission, whether heterosexual or same-sex; sharing intravenous drug equipment; and mother-to-child, or perinatal, transmission. Contaminated blood products are a distant fourth. Every one of these routes is a behaviour or the direct result of one. Sex and sharing injection equipment are behaviours in their own right. Perinatal transmission is the direct result of a woman's own infection, and whether it occurs depends on her access to testing and treatment in pregnancy. The blood route depends on how blood is donated and screened. Table 1.3 lists the routes, the behaviours involved in each, and what those behaviours are intertwined with.
Table 1.3. Routes of HIV transmission, the behaviours involved in each, and the systems with which those behaviours are intertwined.
| Route of transmission | The behaviours involved | What the behaviours are intertwined with |
|---|---|---|
| Sexual transmission (heterosexual or same-sex) | Unprotected sex; number and type of partners; forced or survival sex | Moral and religious systems, gender definitions and power, poverty and wealth |
| Sharing intravenous drug equipment | Injecting; sharing needles or rinse water; injecting alone or with others | Addiction, criminalization, the injecting setting, access to sterile equipment and treatment |
| Mother-to-child (perinatal) transmission | The direct result of a woman's own infection; access to testing and treatment in pregnancy | Women's status; conflict-related rape and abuse; health system reach |
| Contaminated blood products (a distant fourth) | Transfusion; unsafe paid blood donation, as in China in the 1990s | Regulation and screening of the blood supply |
Saying that transmission is behavioural does not mean that it is simply a matter of individual choice. Understandings of sexual behaviour sit at the centre of the moral and religious systems of virtually every society, and sexual behaviour is tied to gender relations and, inescapably, to poverty and wealth. By this we mean that whether a person has unprotected sex, or survival sex, depends on what their society permits, on how much power they hold in a relationship, and on whether they can afford to refuse. To understand transmission in a particular place you have to look at all of these. Even then the picture is incomplete, because it still leaves out the risks people take without knowing it, such as sex with a partner whose infection, or whose other partners, they know nothing about. Because the systems around each route differ from place to place, so does the epidemic, as the next subsection shows.
5.6 Different Places, Different Epidemics
Patterns of spread vary by country, gender, and subgroup, and change as an epidemic evolves. By this we mean that there is no single HIV epidemic but many, each with its own main route and its own most affected groups, and that the pattern in one place can shift over time. The purpose of comparing regions is to see that the route which dominates in a place depends on the systems around behaviour there: migration, gender roles, conflict, the sex trade, and economic change. In the United States the epidemic was first identified among men who have sex with men (MSM), and most new infections still occur among MSM, with women of colour affected at a disproportionate rate. In sub-Saharan Africa, where the pandemic is most severe, unprotected heterosexual transmission is the primary path, shaped by migrant work, gender roles in which men have multiple partners, conflict, and poor access to prevention and treatment. In Southeast Asia the sex trade and injection drug use drove early epidemics, and Thailand's intense, government-led condom program slowed one of them. In Eastern Europe and Central Asia a more recent epidemic grew from injection drug use after the economic upheavals of the early 1990s. In India unprotected sex accounts for most infections and is intertwined with the low status of women, the sex trade, and migration. China's epidemic began among injection drug users and people who donated or received blood, and heterosexual transmission later overtook both, which makes it the clearest example of an epidemic changing shape over time.
Interactive 1.6 has one tab for each of these six regions and countries. Open each tab and note, for each pattern, the context behind it: who is most affected, through which route, and why.
Interactive 1.6. HIV epidemic patterns in six regions and countries, and the contexts behind them.
United States
First identified among men who have sex with men (MSM), the epidemic soon reached injection drug users and their partners, sex workers, homeless youth, and incarcerated people. Therapy in the mid-1990s cut mortality, but most new infections still occur among MSM, with the sharpest increases among young African American MSM, and women of colour are affected at a disproportionate rate. By the time of writing, nearly 619,400 Americans had died.
Sub-Saharan Africa
Where the pandemic is most severe, unprotected heterosexual transmission remains the primary path. The contexts are migrant work, gender roles in which men have multiple partners, and lack of access to prevention and treatment. Prolonged conflict has involved rape and abuse of women, and infection of women raises the likelihood of perinatal transmission.
Southeast Asia
Thailand was an early epicentre through the sex trade and injection drug use, and an intense, government-led condom program slowed the spread. The epidemic then grew rapidly in Vietnam (injection and the sex trade), Cambodia (the sex trade, tied to post-war development and migrant labour), and Myanmar. Rates remain high among MSM and higher still among injection drug users.
Eastern Europe and Central Asia
A more recent epidemic driven by injection drug use, its spread to sexual partners, and its intersection with sex work; the number living with HIV almost tripled after 2000. The early phase is linked to the economic upheavals of the early 1990s, after the collapse of the Soviet Union, when a surge in trade, legal and illegal, and a scramble for ways to make money opened new drug routes and pushed some people into drug use and sex work. In other words, the epidemic followed an economic change rather than a change in what individuals knew about HIV.
India
An estimated 2.4 million people were living with the virus in 2009. Sexual transmission accounted for 87.4 percent of reported HIV cases and is intertwined with the low status of women, the sex trade, migration, MSM, and to a lesser degree injection drug use. Migrant workers away from family may buy sex and later carry infection home to their wives. Some MSM also have female partners and form a bridge population between networks, meaning a group whose sexual contacts link one network, where the virus is common, to another, where it is not. Unequal relationships leave women vulnerable, because a wife may have little power to ask about her husband's other partners or to insist on condoms. Finally, stigma concentrates risk, because groups that are shamed or criminalized are pushed away from testing and prevention services.
China
Limited until the mid-1990s, the epidemic then grew dramatically, first among injection drug users and people who donated or received blood. By 2011 about 780,000 people were living with HIV, 28.6 percent of them women, and heterosexual transmission (46.5 percent) had overtaken injection drug use (28.4 percent), sex between men (17.4 percent), and blood donation or transfusion (6.6 percent). It is the clearest example of an epidemic changing shape over time.
Across the six tabs the contexts recur: migrant work, gender roles and women's status, conflict, economic upheaval, the sex trade, and stigma. None of them is a matter of individual knowledge alone, which is why the same prevention message cannot be expected to work in every place. The six sketches describe whole countries and regions. A study of one population shows the same forces at closer range, and Worked Example 1.6 sorts its findings into levels; as you read it, notice how much of the risk sits outside any individual's knowledge.
Worked Example 1.6: Sorting the Roma Study by Level
A study by Kelly and colleagues (2004) reports in-depth interviews with 42 men and women aged 18 to 52 in Roma settlements in Bulgaria and Hungary. The Roma, the largest ethnic minority in Central and Eastern Europe, live in often closed communities marked by poverty, limited education, and discrimination. Men had far more latitude in sexual behaviour before and during marriage, with unprotected sex with primary and outside partners and much more relationship power; women were expected to remain virgins before marriage and exclusive after it. Condoms were seen mainly as contraception. AIDS was known but not felt as a personal threat, misconceptions were widespread, and women in particular knew little about protection. The study called for programs culturally specific to Roma populations. Which findings are individual, which social and cultural, and which structural, and where would a program have to start for individual-level messages to land?
Step 1, identify the behaviour and the population. The behaviour is unprotected sex; the population is Roma men and women in settlements in Bulgaria and Hungary.
Step 2, sort the individual findings. AIDS was known but not felt as a personal threat, misconceptions about transmission were widespread, and women knew little about protection. These are knowledge and perceived threat, inside the individual.
Step 3, sort the social and cultural findings. Gender roles gave men latitude and relationship power and expected virginity and then exclusivity of women, and condoms were not normative and were read as contraception. These are shared norms, which belong to social, cultural, and group factors.
Step 4, sort the structural findings. Poverty, limited education, discrimination, and closed communities are socioeconomic and structural conditions.
Step 5, state the implication for the program. A message that raises perceived threat will not change behaviour while gender norms leave women little power to ask for protection and condoms mean contraception rather than disease prevention. A program would have to start by engaging those norms within the community, through channels a closed and discriminated-against population trusts, which is why the study called for culturally specific programs.
The gender findings sit at the social and cultural level. The common mistake is to read the knowledge gaps as the whole problem.
Patterns differ between places and change within them, and the Roma study shows that even within one population the influences sit at several levels. The next subsection brings the story to Canada, where the tools of prevention have changed as much as the epidemic.
5.7 Canada and the Shift to Combination Prevention
The Public Health Agency of Canada estimated that roughly 65,000 people were living with HIV in Canada at the end of 2022, most but not all diagnosed. Gay, bisexual, and other men who have sex with men account for the largest share of new diagnoses; people who inject drugs are the second group; and Indigenous people and African, Caribbean, and Black communities appear among new diagnoses well out of proportion to their population share. Saskatchewan has reported a diagnosis rate well above the national rate for more than a decade, much of it linked to injection drug use. Behind each pattern lie stigma, poverty, colonial history, and uneven access to testing and care. By this we mean that the groups most affected are not more affected because of who they are, but because of the conditions they live in. For example, the legacy of colonial policy, including residential schools, has left many Indigenous communities with good reason to distrust health services, and that distrust, together with distance and poverty, makes testing and treatment harder to reach. This is the ecological model at work in Canada: the behaviours that spread HIV are concentrated where the surrounding conditions make prevention hardest.
What has changed most since the 1980s is the toolkit. In the 1980s the tools were education, condoms, and testing, all of which ask the individual to change what they do. Vancouver opened one of North America's first needle exchanges in the late 1980s, an example of harm reduction, which changes the environment of a behaviour rather than trying to end it. By this we mean that harm reduction accepts that some people will continue a risky behaviour, such as injecting drugs, and works to make each instance of it safer, for example by making sterile equipment available. This is a different goal from the earlier tools, which aimed to stop or prevent the behaviour itself.
Biomedical tools and further harm reduction followed. In 1996 the International AIDS Conference in Vancouver announced the success of combination therapy. Insite, North America's first legal supervised injection site, opened in Vancouver's Downtown Eastside in 2003, extending harm reduction. From 2006, Julio Montaner and colleagues at the BC Centre for Excellence in HIV/AIDS argued that expanding treatment would cut transmission, because a person with a suppressed viral load rarely transmits, and British Columbia built its STOP HIV/AIDS program on that idea of treatment as prevention. In other words, treating people who already have HIV became a way of protecting people who do not. Pre-exposure prophylaxis (PrEP) was approved in 2016 and became free in British Columbia in 2018. The result is combination prevention: behavioural, harm reduction, biomedical, and structural tools used together. The purpose of combining them is that each tool reaches a different part of the problem, so that together they work at several levels at once, which is the ecological model's argument applied to HIV.
Interactive 1.7 traces this shift as a timeline of seven events from 1983 to 2018, each tagged as behavioural, harm reduction, biomedical, or structural prevention. Click each year and read the last line of each entry, which names the behaviour the tool still depends on.
📊 Interactive 1.7: Canada's HIV prevention timeline.
Each event is tagged as behavioural, harm reduction, biomedical, or structural prevention.1983: Community organizations and the first messages
AIDS Vancouver, the country's first AIDS service organization, was founded within two years of the first reported cases. With no treatment, prevention meant education, condom promotion, and support for the dying, built by the communities most affected.
Still depends on: hearing the message, believing it applies to you, and using condoms.
Late 1980s: Needle exchange in Vancouver
Vancouver opened one of North America's first needle exchanges, accepting that some people would continue to inject and aiming to make each injection safer. Harm reduction changes the environment of a behaviour rather than trying to end it.
Still depends on: reaching the exchange and choosing sterile equipment every time.
1996: Combination therapy announced in Vancouver
The XI International AIDS Conference in Vancouver announced the success of triple combination therapy, the HAART described above. Deaths fell sharply and HIV became a manageable chronic infection for those with access to treatment.
Still depends on: getting tested, starting treatment, and taking pills daily for life.
2003: Insite opens
After the regional health board declared a public health emergency in 1997 over HIV among people who inject drugs in the Downtown Eastside, Insite, North America's first legal supervised injection site, opened under a federal exemption: sterile equipment, nursing supervision, overdose response, and links to treatment.
Still depends on: choosing to inject at the site, and trusting the staff.
2006 to 2013: Treatment as prevention
Julio Montaner and colleagues at the BC Centre for Excellence in HIV/AIDS argued in The Lancet (2006) that expanding treatment would curb the epidemic, because a person with a suppressed viral load rarely transmits. British Columbia built its STOP HIV/AIDS program on the idea, piloting it in 2010 and extending it provincewide in 2013.
Still depends on: testing, linkage to care, and adherence.
2011: The Supreme Court and the HPTN 052 trial
The Supreme Court of Canada ruled unanimously that Insite could stay open, finding that closing it would threaten its clients' lives. The same year the HPTN 052 trial (Cohen and colleagues, 2011) showed that early treatment cut sexual transmission to partners by 96 percent.
Still depends on: the same testing and adherence behaviours.
2016 to 2018: PrEP and U=U
Health Canada approved a daily pill for pre-exposure prophylaxis (PrEP) for HIV-negative people at risk, and the Undetectable = Untransmittable (U=U) consensus statement summarized the evidence that a person with an undetectable viral load does not transmit HIV sexually, a message aimed at stigma as much as infection. From January 2018 British Columbia provided PrEP at no cost, turning a biomedical tool into one people could actually use.
Still depends on: uptake, persistence on PrEP, regular testing, and disclosure.
Click a year on the timeline to read what happened and which behaviour it still depends on.
Read together, the last lines of the timeline make one point: every tool on it, the biomedical ones included, still depends on something a person does, from getting tested to taking a pill every day. Worked Example 1.7 uses that point to test a colleague's claim that is often heard; as you read it, watch where the barriers to each behaviour sit.
Worked Example 1.7: Does Biomedical Prevention Make Behavioural Theory Obsolete?
By the late 2010s, British Columbia's approach rested on treatment as prevention, free PrEP, supervised consumption, and routine testing, and new diagnoses had fallen substantially from their 1990s peak. A colleague argues that this proves behaviour change programs were the wrong strategy all along: give people pills and sterile equipment and the epidemic takes care of itself. Is the colleague right?
Step 1, list the behaviour each tool depends on. Education and condoms depend on hearing the message, believing it applies to you, and using condoms. Needle exchange depends on reaching the exchange and choosing sterile equipment every time. Combination therapy and treatment as prevention depend on getting tested, being linked to care, starting treatment, and taking pills daily for life. Insite depends on choosing to inject at the site and trusting the staff. PrEP depends on uptake, persistence, regular testing, and disclosure.
Step 2, locate the barriers to those behaviours. Stigma and fear of disclosure are social barriers. Distance, cost, housing, and opening hours are structural. Whether PrEP is free and whether a supervised site may stay open are political, as the 2011 Supreme Court ruling on Insite showed.
Step 3, evaluate the claim. The fall in diagnoses shows that the tools work when people use them. It does not show that behaviour stopped mattering. Each new tool moved the behavioural question rather than removing it, from "use a condom every time" to "get tested, start treatment, and keep taking it".
Step 4, state the implication. Theory is still needed to understand and support uptake and adherence, and the barriers sit at social, structural, and political levels as well as the individual one. Combination prevention is the ecological model applied to HIV.
The error in the colleague's argument is treating "biomedical" as if it meant "behaviour-free".
The HIV case has shown that every route of transmission is a behaviour or its direct result, that epidemics differ by place and subgroup and change over time, and that even biomedical tools depend on behaviours whose barriers sit at social and structural levels. With obesity, youth violence, and HIV/AIDS all examined, the three health issues can now be considered together.
7.2 Identify, Choose, Design
7.2.1 The Three Steps and Their Order
This lesson closes with its central practical claim. All three health issues show the complex link among behaviour, social and environmental factors, and a health problem. The theories in the rest of the course are tools for working through that web, and figuring out what to do is made a little easier by a three-step process. The first step is to identify what you think is going on, in terms of behaviour and ecological influences. By this we mean naming the behaviours involved and the influences on them at each level, as the HIV assessment questions below do. The second step is to choose the theories or frameworks that best address what you think is going on. Here the theory is selected because it fits the problem the first step found, not because it is familiar. The third step is to use those theories to design programs, so that each component of the program can be traced back to a theory and, through it, to something the assessment found. Figure 1.2 sets out the three steps in the order in which they are taken.
Figure 1.2. The three-step process that leads from behaviours to interventions: identify what is going on in terms of behaviour and ecological influences, choose the theories or frameworks that best address it, and design programs using the theories to guide the components.
The order matters, and it is the part of the process that students most often get wrong. Assessment comes first, and it is ecological, which means it looks at every level rather than only at the individual. Theory is chosen to fit what the assessment found, which is why the course spends several lessons on theories before turning to planning. The program follows from both. If the order is reversed, the steps lose their purpose. For example, a planner who starts from a favourite theory will tend to see only the influences that theory names, and a planner who starts from a ready-made program will fit the community to the program rather than the program to the community. Either way, the first step is skipped, and the result is the cookie-cutter error described in 7.1. Following the steps in order is therefore what protects a program from that error. The first step can be practised now, and the next subsection shows what it looks like for HIV.
7.2.2 Step One in Practice: The Questions Before the Program
Each route of HIV transmission involves many behaviours that vary across cultures and circumstances, so before designing anything a practitioner needs answers to questions about the behaviours involved. Two sets of assessment questions follow, one about sexual transmission and one about injection drug use. As you read them, count how many of the questions are about knowledge and how many are about setting, power, and options.
Questions about sexual transmission
- What is the range of sexual practices, and in what contexts do they occur?
- What types of partners are there, and do risk situations differ by type of partner?
- Are there situations where sex is forced, or necessary for survival?
- What gender rules are involved? Can one partner easily raise HIV risk and prevention with the other?
Questions about injection drug use
- Who are the users: young, old, male, female, poor, middle class?
- Do people inject in public or in private, with others or alone?
- Is sharing common or necessary? Do people share needles, or the water used for rinsing?
- Do users know the risks? Can they take precautions, or does addiction override such attempts?
- What treatment and prevention options exist: needle exchange, drug treatment?
Notice how few of these questions are about knowledge, and how many are about setting, power, necessity, and options. For example, only one question in the injection drug use set asks whether users know the risks, and even that question goes on to ask whether addiction overrides their attempts to take precautions. The rest ask who is injecting, where, with whom, whether sharing is necessary, and what services exist. That is the ecological model as a set of assessment questions: it turns the levels of influence into things a planner can find out before choosing a theory or designing a program. Worked Example 1.8 puts the three steps and these questions to work on a Canadian case; as you read it, check that each step uses what the previous step found.
Worked Example 1.8: Applying the Three Steps to HIV Among People Who Inject Drugs
A health authority in a Prairie province is seeing rising HIV diagnoses among people who inject drugs, many of them in small communities far from a city. The first proposal on the table is a testing campaign built around radio advertisements. How would the three-step logic handle this proposal?
Step 1, identify what is going on. Use the assessment questions about injection drug use: who is injecting (age, gender, income); whether people inject alone or with others, in public or in private; whether sharing needles or rinse water is common, or simply necessary because sterile equipment is not available; whether people know the risks and can act on that knowledge given addiction; and what treatment and prevention options are actually within reach, such as needle distribution, drug treatment, supervised consumption, and testing. Add the structural context the ecological model insists on: distance, poverty, stigma, and, in many Prairie communities, the legacy of colonial policy that shapes trust in health services.
Step 2, choose theories or frameworks that fit. Even before choosing among specific theories, the ecological model shows that radio advertisements address knowledge alone and leave every other level untouched, so whatever is chosen must reach beyond the individual.
Step 3, design the program. Pair tools across levels, and for each name the behaviour it depends on and where the main barrier sits. Harm reduction: equipment distribution through local outreach, which depends on people reaching it and using sterile equipment every time, with barriers at the structural level (distance, hours) and the social level (stigma at the pharmacy). Biomedical: testing brought to the community, immediate linkage to anti-retroviral treatment, and access to PrEP, which depend on getting tested, starting treatment, and persisting, with barriers at the social level (stigma, disclosure) and the structural level (transport, housing). Behavioural: peer-led education by people with lived experience, which depends on trust and on believing the risk applies to oneself, with barriers at the social and cultural levels.
The radio campaign is not wrong so much as alone, and starting with it skips the first step. The example shows combination prevention as the three-step logic and the ecological model applied together.
This section has followed HIV/AIDS from its global toll to Canada's shift to combination prevention, and it has set out the three steps that carry an ecological assessment into the choice of theory and the design of a program. The key takeaways and knowledge check that follow review this material.
Key Takeaways
- 5.5 HIV/AIDS shapes whole societies: around 34 million people were living with HIV at the end of 2011, with effects on life expectancy, household income, schools, production, poverty, and orphaned children. Because anti-retroviral therapy (HAART) treats but does not cure, prevention carries the burden, and prevention is largely about behaviour. The three major routes, sexual transmission, sharing injection equipment, and mother-to-child transmission, with contaminated blood products a distant fourth, are all behaviours or their direct results, intertwined with moral, gender, and economic systems. If asked why behaviour matters so much for HIV, give both halves of the reason: transmission is tied to behaviour, and there is no cure.
- 5.6 HIV epidemics differ by place and subgroup and change over time: men who have sex with men in the United States, heterosexual transmission shaped by migrant work, gender roles, and conflict in sub-Saharan Africa, injection drug use in Eastern Europe, and in China a shift from injection drug use and blood donation to heterosexual transmission. The Roma study shows the same forces in one population: knowledge gaps at the individual level, gender roles and condom norms at the social and cultural level, and poverty and discrimination at the structural level. When you classify such findings, put shared norms under social and cultural factors, and do not treat the knowledge gaps as the whole problem.
- 5.7 Canadian prevention has broadened from education, condoms, and testing to combination prevention: needle exchange, Insite, treatment as prevention through British Columbia's STOP HIV/AIDS program, PrEP, and U=U. Harm reduction changes the environment of a behaviour rather than trying to end it. Every one of these tools still depends on behaviours, such as testing, adherence, and reaching a service, whose barriers sit at social, structural, and political levels. A common trap is to treat biomedical prevention as behaviour-free; the strong answer names the behaviour each tool depends on.
- 7.2 The path from behaviours to interventions has three steps in a fixed order: identify what is going on in terms of behaviour and ecological influences, choose the theories or frameworks that best address it, and use them to design programs. Step one is answered with assessment questions about setting, power, necessity, and options, not only about knowledge. Starting from a favourite theory or a ready-made campaign, such as a radio advertisement, skips the first step. In a case answer, show each step using what the previous step found.
1. Why does HIV/AIDS place a huge burden on prevention?
2. Which of the following is NOT one of the three major routes of HIV transmission?
3. In the Roma study, condom use was not normative and was perceived mainly as contraception, and men held far more relationship power than women. At which level of the ecological model do these findings mainly sit?
4. Treatment as prevention, the strategy behind British Columbia's STOP HIV/AIDS program, depends most directly on which behaviours?
5. What is the order of the three-step process for moving from behaviours to interventions?
6. A health authority in a Prairie province faces rising HIV diagnoses among people who inject drugs in small communities. Its first proposal is a radio advertising campaign about testing. According to the three-step logic, what should come first?
7. A needle distribution program serves people who inject drugs in a small community, but its only office is in a city two hours away and open on weekdays. Which statement best describes the behaviour the tool depends on and where the main barrier sits?
8. In China, HIV spread first among injection drug users and people who donated or received blood, and by 2011 heterosexual transmission had become the largest route. What does this pattern best illustrate?
✦ Pass the knowledge check with 100% to continue
Final Review & Assessment
⏱ Estimated time: 25 minutes
Bringing It All Together
This lesson began with a friend brushing his teeth and ended with a provincial HIV program, and the same idea ran through both. Sam's toothbrushing had at least six candidate motives, from cavities to a magazine cover to a mother who had lost her own teeth, and the dominant motive shifted with the day and the setting. Two lessons follow from that scene. First, the public health question, why do people behave in healthy or unhealthy ways, is a focused version of the general question of why people do what they do, so understanding health behaviour means drawing on everything we know about behaviour. Second, behaviour labelled as health behaviour may be motivated by health, by health mixed with other concerns, by something unrelated to health, or by an idea of health that differs from Western medicine's. And often motivation is beside the point, because circumstance, environment, and policy set the terms before any motive has a say.
The ecological model gives that observation a structure. Since the late 1970s and early 1980s, health promotion has moved from a focus on individual knowledge, attitudes, and motivation toward the assumption that no single factor influences behaviour and that people and their environments, social as well as physical, act on each other. Influences can be sorted into five groups of factors, individual, social and cultural, socioeconomic and structural, political, and environmental, and drawn as nested levels of influence. The World Health Organization's social determinants approach and the Rio Declaration state the same claim at the level of populations; the Lalonde Report and the Ottawa Charter mark the same turn in Canada. Respecting this complexity is what keeps a practitioner from importing a cookie-cutter program into a place it does not fit.
The second half of the lesson put the model to work. Obesity showed that education alone produced short-term change and that lasting change requires environments that support behaviour, from vending machines to trails to food policy. Youth violence showed that one behaviour can be explained in six different ways, each locating the cause at its own level, from a young person's reading of a facial cue to the economics of an isolated neighbourhood, and that the explanations intersect. HIV/AIDS showed transmission routes that are all behaviours, patterns that differ by place and change over time, and, in Canada, a prevention toolkit that has broadened from behaviour change alone to combination prevention while still depending on what people do. The lesson closed with a three-step path that the rest of the course follows: identify what is going on, choose the theories that fit, and design the program.
Key Takeaways from this lesson
- You can now explain why one health behaviour can carry many motives, not all of them about health, and why the dominant motive changes with the person, the day, and the setting. The practical reminder: a program that assumes a single motive reaches only the people and moments for which that motive is active, so list the possible motives before you design anything.
- You can state the goal of the field: to implement programs and interventions that promote behaviour change to improve the health of the public or a segment of it. Its guiding question, why do people behave in healthy or unhealthy ways, is a focused version of why people do what they do, and health behaviour includes behaviour that harms health as well as behaviour that protects it.
- You can define the ecological model: no single factor determines behaviour, because individuals and their environments, social as well as physical, interact. Remember that the model replaced an earlier focus on individual knowledge, attitudes, and motivation, and that the social determinants approach, the Lalonde Report, and the Ottawa Charter state the same insight. When a low rate of a behaviour appears in a case, ask whether people could act even if they wanted to.
- You can classify influences on a behaviour into the five groups of factors, individual, social and cultural, socioeconomic and structural, political, and environmental, and into the nested levels from the individual to the political and structural. When you sort an influence, give the reason from the list, and remember that the groups operate together rather than as separate items.
- You can describe how obesity, youth violence, and HIV/AIDS each involve behaviours shaped at every level of the web. Obesity shows that education alone gives short-term change and that an ecological intervention designs its components so that environmental change supports behaviour change; HIV shows that even biomedical tools depend on behaviours whose barriers sit at social and structural levels.
- You can compare the six explanations for youth violence, risk and protective factors, problem behaviour syndrome, developmental pathways, self-concept and possible selves, socioecological models, and social-cognitive models, by where each locates the cause. Identify the explanation a program draws on from what the program changes, and remember that the explanations intersect, so strong programs draw on several.
- You can apply the three-step path in its fixed order: identify what is going on in terms of behaviour and ecological influences, choose the theories or frameworks that fit, and design the program. Starting from a favourite theory or a ready-made program skips the first step and produces the cookie-cutter error that respect for complexity is meant to prevent.
Final Knowledge Assessment
This assessment covers all material from this lesson. You must score 100% to complete the lesson. Review the feedback for any incorrect answers and try again.
1. In the Sam scenario, which motive was probably dominant on the night of the party at his friend's parents' house?
2. The goal of the field of study and practice concerned with health behaviour is to:
3. A community downstream from a polluting factory eats contaminated fish. Its members may not know the risk, but fishing is their livelihood and has been for generations. Which statement best reflects the point of this example?
4. Canada was the first country to require graphic picture warnings on cigarette packages. Within the ecological framework, this measure is best described as:
5. Before the late 1970s and early 1980s, health promotion professionals and programs focused primarily on:
6. Which of the following best illustrates the ecological model's claim that behaviour does not exist in a vacuum?
7. The Rio Political Declaration on Social Determinants of Health (2011) states that health inequities arise from:
8. The ecological model borrows the term "ecology" from biology because, in biology, it refers to:
9. A school district changes what its vending machines sell, and purchases of high-fat snacks fall without any classroom lesson on nutrition. This example illustrates:
10. Being large has carried positive value in a number of societies, where a good appetite and a large body signal health. For program design, this implies that:
11. Which explanation for youth violence treats delinquency and violence as alternative routes to positive self-definition and prestige when a satisfactory conventional future seems out of reach?
12. The steep rise in juvenile homicide in the United States from the mid-1980s to the mid-1990s tracked the crack cocaine epidemic, which drew urban youth into dealing, and the guns that came with it. This evidence most directly supports which explanation for youth violence?
13. Which pattern of HIV transmission characterizes sub-Saharan Africa?
14. Insite, the supervised injection site in Vancouver, and needle distribution programs are best described in this lesson as:
15. A health unit begins designing an HIV prevention program by selecting its staff's favourite theory and then looking for a behaviour to apply it to. According to the three-step logic, what is wrong with this approach?
16. A regional health authority is concerned about rising vaping among students in grades 8 to 10. Many students say they vape to fit in with friends, to handle stress or boredom, or because they like the flavours and devices. Why might a campaign built on images of lung damage miss many of them?
17. For the same briefing, the authority lists influences on student vaping. One of them is a provincial regulation that bans the sale of flavoured vaping products. To which group of factors does this influence belong?
18. The three schools in the briefing are in a wealthy suburb, a rural resource town, and a low-income urban neighbourhood. A colleague suggests running one identical anti-vaping program in all three. What is the strongest objection?
✦ Pass every section knowledge check with 100% before submitting