Summary
The episode works through five questions that students find difficult in the lesson on health behaviours, mental health and social influence. The hosts use the published counts from Doll and Hill's 1950 study to show that percentages of smokers that look nearly identical correspond to odds about fourteen times higher among the lung cancer patients, and they discuss Ronald Fisher's constitutional hypothesis and Cornfield's reply. They then work a harder example with a hypothetical province in which the reach of a quit line limits its population effect, compare it with a tax, and show how the two combine. The hosts classify invented observations as influence, homophily or shared environment, review the critiques of the Christakis and Fowler network studies, and read the before-and-after evidence on Insite in Vancouver. The episode closes with a debate over whether the comparison between social isolation and smoking fifteen cigarettes a day is a fair one.