HSCI 341 · Lesson 4

Measures of
Disease Frequency

Fundamental Epidemiological Concepts and Approaches

Learning objectives for this lesson:

  1. Distinguish counts, proportions, odds, and rates by their numerators, denominators, ranges, and units, and explain why a count alone is of limited use.
  2. Choose between an incidence risk, an incidence rate, and a prevalence for a described situation, using the study period, the risk period, and whether the population is closed or open.
  3. Calculate and interpret an incidence risk (subtracting half the withdrawals from the population at risk) and an incidence rate from person-time, stating the period or the units with each, and convert an incidence rate into a risk.
  4. Explain what prevalence measures and how it differs from incidence, calculate a point prevalence, and explain why prevalence depends on both incidence and duration and is therefore a poor measure for identifying causes.
  5. Calculate and interpret attack rates, secondary attack rates, case fatality rates, mortality rates, and proportional mortality.
  6. Calculate years of life lost (YLLs), years lived with disability (YLDs), and disability-adjusted life years (DALYs), and explain what DALYs add to mortality and morbidity measures.
  7. Explain why crude rates can mislead, distinguish direct from indirect standardisation, calculate and interpret a standardised morbidity ratio and a directly standardised rate, and calculate an approximate 95% confidence interval for a proportion or a rate.

This course was developed by Dr. Kiffer G. Card based on Dohoo, I. R., Martin, S. W., & Stryhn, H. (2012). Methods in Epidemiologic Research. VER Inc.

Reference

Glossary: Key Terms, People & Concepts

📚 Reference page, available throughout the lesson

This glossary collects the key concepts, people, and ideas you will meet in this lesson. Use it as a reference while you work through the material, or as a review before assessments. Type in the search box to filter entries.

Foundational Concepts
Count A simple frequency: the number of cases or events. Counts alone are uninterpretable without a denominator.
Proportion A fraction whose numerator is included in the denominator (e.g., the proportion of a population with disease). Bounded between 0 and 1.
Ratio A division of two quantities where the numerator is not necessarily contained in the denominator (e.g., sex ratio).
Odds The ratio of the probability of an event to the probability of its complement: p / (1 − p). Used in case-control studies and logistic regression.
Rate A measure of how quickly events occur, with time in the denominator (e.g., cases per 1,000 person-years). Has units of inverse time.
Person-Time The sum of time each person was at risk for the outcome, for example person-years. The denominator for incidence rates.
Measures of Disease Frequency
Prevalence The proportion of a population with the disease at a specified time. Reflects both incidence and duration; a snapshot rather than a flow measure.
Point Prevalence Prevalence measured at a single point in time (a snapshot). The standard prevalence measure in cross-sectional surveys.
Period Prevalence The proportion of a population with the disease at any time during a specified period (e.g., 12-month prevalence).
Incidence The occurrence of new cases of disease in a population over a defined time. The flow measure that, together with duration, drives prevalence.
Incidence Proportion (Cumulative Incidence, Risk) The proportion of an initially disease-free population that develops the outcome over a defined follow-up period. Bounded between 0 and 1; requires the time period to be specified.
Incidence Rate (Incidence Density) New cases divided by total person-time at risk. Has units of inverse time and is appropriate when follow-up time varies across individuals.
Attack Rate Cumulative incidence in an outbreak setting over a short, defined period; commonly used for foodborne or infectious-disease outbreaks.
Secondary Attack Rate The proportion of contacts of a primary case who develop disease; a measure of transmissibility within close-contact settings (e.g., households).
Case-Fatality Rate (CFR) The proportion of diagnosed cases that die from the disease within a specified time. Despite the name, it is a proportion, not a rate.
Mortality Rate Deaths per unit person-time in a specified population (e.g., per 100,000 person-years). May be all-cause or cause-specific.
Proportional Mortality The proportion of deaths in a population that are attributable to a specific cause. Useful for ranking causes but does not measure risk.
Burden & Adjustment
Years of Life Lost (YLL) The years of life lost due to premature mortality, calculated against a standard life expectancy.
Years Lived with Disability (YLD) Prevalence-weighted years lived in less-than-full health, where disability weights reflect severity.
Disability-Adjusted Life Year (DALY) A summary burden measure equal to YLL + YLD; one DALY represents one year of healthy life lost.
Standardisation (Direct & Indirect) Methods to remove the effect of confounding by age (or other variables) when comparing rates across populations. Direct standardisation applies a standard population’s structure to observed rates; indirect applies a standard set of rates to the observed structure (yielding the SMR).
Confidence Interval A range of values constructed so that, on repeated sampling, a specified proportion (often 95%) of such intervals would contain the true population parameter.
No matching entries. Try a different search term.
Section 1

Introduction & Foundational Concepts

⏱ Estimated reading time: 12 minutes

Lesson 4 · HSCI 341

The Numbers Epidemiology Runs On

Every rate, risk, and ratio you compute later depends on a denominator decision made here.

Section 1 of 4

Introduction & Foundational Concepts

Counts, proportions, odds, and rates: their definitions, denominators, and the time concepts that govern which to use.

Why it matters

Description before explanation

Measuring how often a disease occurs, and in which groups, is the prerequisite for finding its causes.

Morbidity and mortality are the two main event categories, but the measurement logic applies to any outcome: vaccination, hospitalisation, birth, or death. Stratifying by host attributes reveals patterns that aggregate figures conceal.

Time concepts

Study period vs. risk period

Study period

The calendar interval during which subjects are observed. Can be a point in time or an interval defined by a specific event.

Risk period

The window within which an individual can develop the disease. Short for post-partum eclampsia; lifelong for migraine. Governs which measure fits.

Short risk period relative to study duration → use risk (proportion). Long or open-ended risk period → use rate (person-time denominator).

Four forms

Count, proportion, odds, rate

Count

Raw number of cases. No denominator, so it cannot be interpreted without knowing the population size.

Proportion

Cases ÷ total containing those cases. Dimensionless, range 0–1. Prevalence and incidence risk are both proportions.

Odds

Cases ÷ non-cases. Numerator is not a subset of denominator. Range 0 to ∞. Used in case-control studies.

Rate

Cases ÷ person-time at risk. Units of 1/time. Range 0 to ∞. The only form that places time explicitly in the denominator.

Common confusion

Proportion, odds, and the misuse of "rate"

Proportion (e.g., stillbirth proportion)
\[ \color{#0B7B6B}{p} = \frac{\color{#C2410C}{3}}{\color{#6D28D9}{123}} = 0.024 \]
p proportion3 cases (stillbirths)123 total births, the whole group
Odds (e.g., stillbirth odds)
\[ \color{#0B7B6B}{\text{Odds}} = \frac{\color{#C2410C}{3}}{\color{#6D28D9}{120}} = 0.025 \]
Odds odds3 cases (stillbirths)120 non-cases (live births)

Close when events are rare; diverge as frequency rises. The word “rate” is often used loosely to mean any frequency measure. Strictly, it requires person-time in the denominator.

Carry forward

What to take into the next section

  • Counts need a denominator to mean anything.
  • Proportions and rates are the two main forms; each suits a different population structure and risk period.
  • Odds appear in case-control designs and logistic regression; proportion and odds diverge as frequency rises.
  • Every measure of association in later lessons is a ratio or difference of two frequency measures.

Overview

This section introduces the vocabulary on which the rest of the lesson is built. Measures of disease frequency turn the data produced by surveillance, sampling and questionnaires into the standard quantitative outputs of epidemiology, and the definitions of Rothman (2012) and Porta (2014) are the references used throughout. The section begins with why frequency has to be measured before disease can be explained, and why a count on its own says little. It then sets out the four mathematical forms that every measure takes, counts, proportions, odds and rates, and applies them to a single outbreak, before showing how the study period and the risk period guide the choice between a risk and a rate. Later sections build on this vocabulary, covering the two faces of incidence, then prevalence, mortality and burden-of-disease measures such as DALYs, and finally the standardisation techniques and confidence intervals that make fair comparisons between populations possible. Every measure of association, such as a risk ratio or a rate difference, is built from two of these frequency measures.

Learning Objectives

  • 1.1 Explain why measuring disease frequency comes before explaining disease, and why a count alone is of limited use.
  • 1.2 Distinguish counts, proportions, odds, and rates by their numerators, denominators, ranges, and units.
  • 2.1 Use the study period and the risk period to decide whether a risk or a rate fits a described situation.

1.1 Why Measure Disease Frequency?

Measurement of disease (or event) frequency is the foundation of many epidemiological activities, including routine surveillance, observational research and outbreak investigations (Porta, 2014). Before an epidemiologist can explain why a disease occurs, they first need to describe how often it occurs, and in observational studies, measuring the frequency of a disease and linking it to an exposure are the first steps toward inferring causation (Rothman, 2012). Morbidity and mortality are the two main categories of events for which frequency measures are calculated, but the same approaches apply to other events of interest, such as vaccination, hospital admission or giving birth.

The simplest measure is a count of cases. Because a count does not take the size of the population into account, it has very limited use on its own: the same number of cases means something very different in a village than in a city. A count becomes informative only when it is set against the population it came from, which is what the proportions and rates in 1.2 do.

Frequency measures are also rarely reported for a whole population alone, for a reason worth remembering.

Stratification Matters

Because both morbidity and mortality are strongly associated with individual attributes, and because different diseases have different impacts, we often calculate frequency measures for specific host attributes (e.g., age, sex, race) and for specific diseases. This stratification allows us to detect patterns that would be hidden in overall population-level data.

Stratification returns in Section 4, where differences in the make-up of two populations are shown to distort a comparison of their overall rates. Turning a count into a useful measure starts with choosing a denominator, and the choice of denominator defines the forms of measure described next.

1.2 Counts, Proportions, Odds and Rates

Every measure of disease frequency in this lesson takes one of four mathematical forms. The simplest, a count, has no denominator at all; it is just the number of cases. The other three are ratios, and they all share the same numerator, the cases. What distinguishes them is the denominator, that is, what the cases are divided by. In a proportion, the numerator is part of the denominator. By this we mean that every person counted on top of the fraction is also counted underneath it, as when 30 ill residents are divided by all 100 residents, including those 30. In the odds, by contrast, the denominator is the non-cases, so the people on top are not counted underneath. In a rate, the denominator is not a number of people at all but the person-time at risk, the total amount of time that people spent being observed while they could still become a case. Because these three denominators answer different questions, the same cases can produce three different numbers, and learning to recognise the denominator is the first skill this lesson builds.

1.2.1 Numerators, Denominators, Ranges and Units

The four cards below give a fuller definition of each form with a short numerical example, including the nursing-home outbreak that Worked Example 4.1 returns to. Click each card to see how its denominator is built, and notice on the Odds card how the same stillbirth data give slightly different values as odds and as a proportion.

CountClick to learn more
ProportionClick to learn more
OddsClick to learn more
RateClick to learn more

Table 4.1 then sets the four forms side by side, so that their numerators, denominators, ranges and units can be compared directly. A useful check follows from the ranges: a proportion can never be larger than 1, whereas odds and rates can, and only a rate carries units.

Table 4.1. The numerator, denominator, range and units of counts, proportions, odds and rates.

MeasureNumeratorDenominatorRangeUnits
CountCasesNone0 to ∞None
ProportionSubset of denominatorTotal population0 to 1Dimensionless
OddsCasesNon-cases0 to ∞Dimensionless
RateCasesPerson-time at risk0 to ∞Per person-time

1.2.2 One Set of Observations, Three Measures

Because the three ratios share a numerator, proportions, odds and rates can all be calculated from the same set of observations, and they give different numbers for the same events only because their denominators differ. Equation 4.1 divides the cases by the total population that contains them, Equation 4.2 divides them by the non-cases, and Equation 4.3 divides them by the person-time at risk.

Proportion
\[ {\color{#0B7B6B}{p}} = \dfrac{{\color{#C2410C}{\text{cases}}}}{{\color{#6D28D9}{\text{total population}}}} \]Eq 4.1
a proportion equals the number of cases divided by the total population that contains those cases.
Odds
\[ {\color{#0B7B6B}{\text{odds}}} = \dfrac{{\color{#C2410C}{\text{cases}}}}{{\color{#1D4ED8}{\text{non-cases}}}} \]Eq 4.2
the odds equal the number of cases divided by the number of people who did not become cases.
Rate
\[ {\color{#0B7B6B}{\text{rate}}} = \dfrac{{\color{#C2410C}{\text{cases}}}}{{\color{#BE185D}{\text{person-time at risk}}}} \]Eq 4.3
a rate equals the number of cases divided by the total person-time during which people were at risk.

Worked Example 4.1 applies Equations 4.1 to 4.3 to the nursing-home outbreak from the Rate card. As you work through it, watch how the numerator stays fixed while the denominator changes, and which of the three results carries units.

Worked Example 4.1: One Outbreak, Three Measures

The Rate card in 1.2.1 describes 30 cases of diarrhea among the 100 residents of a nursing home over 3 months. The same data yield all three measures.

  • Proportion: p = 30 / 100 = 0.30, so 30% of the residents became ill during the 3 months.
  • Odds: odds = 30 / (100 − 30) = 30 / 70 = 0.43, so there were 0.43 cases for every resident who stayed well.
  • Rate: if each resident is counted as at risk for the full 3 months, as on the Rate card, the person-time is 100 × 3 = 300 person-months and the rate is 30 / 300 = 0.10 cases per person-month.

The proportion and the odds differ noticeably here because the outcome is common; with 3 cases instead of 30 they would be 0.030 and 0.031. Removing residents from the denominator once they fall ill would reduce the person-time and raise the rate, which is the refinement introduced in the next section. Only the rate carries units.

The worked example shows that the denominator, not the label, determines which measure has been calculated, so the first step with any reported figure is to write down what was divided by what. Labels are an unreliable guide, as the following caution explains.

Common Terminology Confusion

The term “rate” is often used loosely to refer to all types of measures of disease frequency. Similarly, people commonly say someone has a high “chance” or “risk” of disease when the underlying measure might actually be a rate. Being precise about these terms helps avoid misinterpretation of research findings.

The rate in Worked Example 4.1 counted every resident as at risk for the full 3 months. Whether a risk or a rate is the better summary of such data depends on how long people can develop the disease, which is the subject of 2.1.

2.1 Study Period and Risk Period

The choice among the measures in 1.2, and in particular between a risk and a rate, depends on two time-related concepts: the study period, during which people are observed, and the risk period, during which a person could develop the disease. Open each tab to read the definition of each period with its examples, and compare the very short risk period of post-partum eclampsia with the lifelong risk period of migraine.

Study Period

The study period is the time interval during which study subjects are observed for the outcome of interest. It is usually measured in calendar time, but sometimes represents a point in time. The study period could also be defined by a specific event, for example “at birth” or “congenital defects during 2008–2010.”

Risk Period

The risk period is the time during which an individual could develop the disease. For some conditions, the risk period is very short (e.g., post-partum eclampsia, usually less than 2 days), while for others it is essentially lifelong (e.g., migraine headaches).

The length of the risk period relative to the study period guides the choice between risk-based and rate-based measures. Diseases with a short risk period relative to the study period are good candidates for risk measures, because nearly all cases will appear while people are being observed, so the proportion who become ill summarises their experience well. Diseases with long risk periods are better suited to rate-based measures, which divide the cases by the person-time actually observed, and a rate is also the better choice when people are followed for different lengths of time. To decide in a given situation, ask how long a person could develop the outcome and whether everyone is observed for the whole of that time, and justify the choice in a sentence that names the risk period.

This section has defined counts, proportions, odds and rates, shown how the same observations yield each measure, and described the time periods that guide the choice among them. The key takeaways below summarise these points.

Key Takeaways

  • 1.1 Before we can explain why a disease occurs, we first need to describe how often it occurs, which is why measures of disease frequency sit underneath surveillance, observational research and outbreak investigations alike. Measuring how often a disease occurs and then linking it to an exposure is the first step toward inferring a cause. A count on its own, such as 50 cases of flu, tells you very little, because you cannot judge whether 50 is a lot until you know how many people the cases came from. When a question or a news report compares raw counts from places of different sizes, turn each count into a proportion or a rate before you draw any conclusion. Because frequency often varies with age, sex and other host attributes, you will also often see these measures calculated separately for each group (subsection 1.1).
  • 1.2 Counts, proportions, odds and rates are the four mathematical forms that the measures in this lesson take, and the easiest way to tell them apart is to look at the denominator. In a proportion the numerator is part of the denominator (cases divided by the whole group, ranging from 0 to 1 with no units); in the odds the denominator is the non-cases (ranging from 0 upwards with no units); and in a rate the denominator is person-time at risk, so only a rate carries units, such as cases per person-month. When you work through an example, write down what is being divided by what before you name the measure: in Worked Example 4.1, 30 cases among 100 nursing-home residents over 3 months give a proportion of 30 / 100 = 0.30, odds of 30 / 70 = 0.43 and a rate of 30 / 300 = 0.10 cases per person-month. Be careful with labels, because the word "rate" is often used loosely for proportions and odds; the denominator, not the name a source uses, tells you which measure you have. A quick check is that a proportion can never be larger than 1, whereas odds and rates can.
  • 2.1 Two time periods guide the choice between a risk and a rate. The study period is the stretch of time during which people are observed, and the risk period is the time during which a person could actually develop the disease. When the risk period is short relative to the study period (post-partum eclampsia, for example, usually occurs within 2 days), nearly all cases will appear while people are being observed, so a risk (the proportion who become ill) works well. When the risk period is long or lifelong (as with migraine headaches), or when people are followed for different lengths of time, a rate with a person-time denominator fits better. In a question, look for how long people could develop the outcome and whether everyone was followed for the same time, and justify your choice in a sentence that names the risk period.
Knowledge Check: this section

1. Over a 6-month winter, 25 of the 125 residents of a group home developed an influenza-like illness. A colleague reports the “rate” of illness as 25 / 100 = 0.25. Which statement is correct?

A proportion divides the cases by a total that contains them, 25 / 125 = 0.20. The denominator of 100 leaves out the 25 cases, so 0.25 cannot be the proportion.
Stating the 6-month period does not make a value a rate. A true rate divides the cases by the person-time at risk, such as person-months, and carries units; 25 / 100 divides by people who stayed well.
25 / 100 divides the cases by the non-cases, which is the odds. The proportion uses the whole group, 25 / 125 = 0.20, and a true rate would need person-time at risk in its denominator.
The labels are swapped. 0.25 divides by the 100 non-cases, so it is the odds, while 25 / 125 = 0.20 divides by a total that includes the cases, so it is the proportion.
Correct answer: the colleague has calculated the odds. The information needed is the number of cases (25), the number who stayed well (125 − 25 = 100) and the total (125). A proportion divides the cases by a total that contains them (25 / 125 = 0.20); the odds divide the cases by the non-cases (25 / 100 = 0.25); a true rate would divide the 25 cases by the person-time at risk, such as person-months, and would carry units. Calling 0.25 the proportion is the tempting slip, but its denominator of 100 leaves out the 25 cases, so the numerator is not part of the denominator. (Section 1, 1.2 Counts, Proportions, Odds and Rates, Table 4.1 and Worked Example 4.1; Objective 1.2)

2. Two studies are planned in the same health region. Study A follows 600 patients for the 30 days after hip-replacement surgery to count surgical-site infections, which almost always appear within that window. Study B follows a cohort of adults for 10 years to count first diagnoses of type 2 diabetes; people can develop diabetes at any age, and many participants move away or join partway through. Which pairing of measures fits best?

A risk suits Study A, where everyone is followed for the same 30 days, but not Study B. There the risk period is longer than the observation and people are followed for different lengths of time, so a head count misrepresents time at risk.
Study A’s risk period fits inside the study period with equal follow-up, so new infections ÷ patients at risk gives a 30-day risk. Study B has a lifelong risk period and unequal follow-up, so cases are divided by person-time at risk.
The pairing is reversed. Study A has a short risk period, a closed group and equal follow-up, which suits a risk, while Study B’s unequal follow-up and open membership call for a rate with person-time.
A count of cases has no denominator, so it cannot show how often infection or diabetes occurs among those at risk. Starting with a defined group is a reason to calculate a risk or rate, not to stop at a count.
Correct answer: a risk for Study A and a rate for Study B. The information needed is the length of the risk period compared with the study period, and whether everyone is followed for the same time. In Study A the risk period (about 30 days) fits inside the study period and every patient is followed for the same 30 days, so new infections ÷ patients at risk at the start gives a 30-day risk. In Study B the risk period is lifelong, longer than the 10 years of observation, and people are observed for different lengths of time, so the cases are divided by the person-time at risk. Using a risk for both is tempting, but in Study B a head count treats someone followed for one year the same as someone followed for ten. (Section 1, 2.1 Study Period and Risk Period and its tabs; Objective 2.1)

3. In one year, Town A (population 4,000) recorded 40 cases of pertussis and City B (population 80,000) recorded 200. A local news report says pertussis is “five times worse” in City B. Which response is correct?

Five times as many cases reflects the much larger population of City B as much as the frequency of disease. A count has no denominator, so it cannot show which place has the higher frequency.
Dividing by one year does not create a rate in the epidemiological sense: “cases per year” has no population in its denominator, so it is still a count and still reflects population size.
Proportions can be compared between populations of different sizes; dividing by each population is exactly what makes them comparable. The odds would not correct the report’s real error, which was comparing raw counts.
Dividing each count by its population gives 40 / 4,000 = 0.010 in Town A and 200 / 80,000 = 0.0025 in City B. The ratio 0.010 / 0.0025 = 4, so pertussis was four times as frequent in the smaller town.
Correct answer: the report reverses the picture. The information needed is each count and the size of the population it came from. Dividing each count by its population gives 40 / 4,000 = 0.010 (1 in 100) in Town A and 200 / 80,000 = 0.0025 (1 in 400) in City B, and 0.010 / 0.0025 = 4, so pertussis was four times as frequent in the smaller town. The report compared raw counts, but a count has no denominator, so it reflects the size of the population as much as the frequency of disease; “cases per year” is still a count, because no population is divided into it. (Section 1, 1.1 Why Measure Disease Frequency? and the Count card in 1.2.1; Objective 1.1)

✦ Pass the knowledge check with 100% to continue

Section 2

Incidence: Risk & Rate

⏱ Estimated reading time: 15 minutes

Section 2 of 4

Incidence: Risk & Rate

Two faces of the same concept, each requiring a different denominator and suited to a different population structure.

What incidence measures

New cases only

Incidence counts events that begin within the observation window. Individuals already diseased at the start are not included in the numerator.

Incidence Risk (R)

A probability. Dimensionless, range 0–1. Requires a defined time period and a closed population.

Incidence Rate (I)

Cases per person-time. Units of 1/time. No upper bound. Works for open populations where individuals enter and leave.

Calculating risk

Incidence risk in a closed population

Incidence Risk (Eq 4.1)
\[ \color{#0B7B6B}{R} = \frac{\color{#C2410C}{\text{newly affected individuals}}}{\color{#6D28D9}{\text{population at risk}}} \]
R incidence risk (a probability)new cases people who develop disease in the periodat risk disease-free people at the start

Withdrawals: subtract half the number of withdrawals from the denominator, assuming they leave at the midpoint of the study period on average.

Always specify the time period. "Risk of 0.14" means nothing without "over 12 months" or equivalent.

Calculating rate

Incidence rate and person-time

Incidence Rate (Eq 4.2)
\[ \color{#0B7B6B}{I} = \frac{\color{#C2410C}{\text{new cases}}}{\color{#6D28D9}{\text{person-time at risk}}} \]
I incidence rate (per person-time)new cases events in the periodperson-time time each person was at risk

Approximate formula (Eq 4.3) when exact times are unavailable:

Approximate I
\[ \color{#0B7B6B}{I} \approx \frac{\color{#C2410C}{A}}{\color{#6D28D9}{(N_0 - \tfrac{1}{2}\text{sick} - \tfrac{1}{2}\text{withdrawn} + \tfrac{1}{2}\text{added})} \times \color{#1D4ED8}{\Delta t}} \]
I incidence rateA new casesN₀ ... approximate persons at risk (mid-period adjustment)Δt length of the period

Events are assumed to occur at the midpoint of the follow-up window on average.

Connecting the two

The risk-rate relationship

Exact relationship
\[ \color{#0B7B6B}{R} = 1 - e^{-\color{#C2410C}{I} \cdot \color{#6D28D9}{\Delta t}} \]
R incidence riskI incidence rateΔt length of the interval
Linear approximation (when \(I \cdot \Delta t < 0.1\))
\[ \color{#0B7B6B}{R} \approx \color{#C2410C}{I} \times \color{#6D28D9}{\Delta t} \]
R incidence riskI incidence rateΔt length of the interval

The exponential form accounts for the shrinking at-risk pool as people develop disease. For small products the two expressions give nearly identical answers.

Carry forward

What to take into the next section

  • Closed population + defined follow-up → incidence risk (proportion).
  • Open population or unequal follow-up → incidence rate (person-time).
  • Risk from rate: \(R = 1 - e^{-I \Delta t}\). Linear approximation holds when \(I \Delta t < 0.1\).
  • The exact formula and the linear form are numerically close for small rates; they diverge for long follow-up or high rates.

Overview

Section 1 set up the basic vocabulary of counts, proportions, odds and rates. This section takes the most consequential of these measures, incidence, and works through its two faces: risk, which is a probability, and rate, which counts events per unit of person-time. The distinction is central, because risk-based and rate-based designs lead to different measures of association: risk ratios and risk differences on one side, rate ratios and rate differences on the other. The section shows how the kind of population being followed decides between a risk and a rate, describes the four ways in which incidence can be expressed, calculates an incidence risk and an incidence rate from exact and approximate person-time, and ends by converting a rate into a risk.

Learning Objectives

  • 2.2 Distinguish incidence risk from incidence rate, and closed from open populations, and choose the measure that fits a described study.
  • 3.1 Define incidence as the occurrence of new cases and describe the four ways to express it.
  • 3.2 Calculate an incidence risk, subtracting half the withdrawals from the population at risk, and an incidence rate from exact or approximate person-time, reporting the period or the units with each.
  • 3.3 Convert an incidence rate into a risk, and explain when the shortcut R ≈ I × Δt is adequate.

2.2 Incidence Risk and Incidence Rate in Closed and Open Populations

Incidence relates to the number of new events (for example, new cases of a disease) in a defined population within a specific period. By this we mean the transitions from being well to becoming ill that happen while people are being watched, not the illness that was already present when observation began. Because it follows people through that transition, incidence is the measure used to identify factors associated with becoming ill: if smokers make the transition more often than non-smokers, that difference is a clue about cause. It also follows that anyone who already has the disease when observation begins cannot become a new case, so they are left out of the population at risk. For example, if 20 of 1,000 adults already have diabetes when a study starts, only the remaining 980 can contribute new cases and only they belong in the denominator. Measuring incidence in this way requires a clear case definition, so that everyone agrees on what counts as becoming ill, along with a surveillance programme capable of identifying all cases as they arise.

Incidence has two main faces. An incidence risk is the proportion of disease-free people who develop the disease during a stated period, so it ranges from 0 to 1. An incidence rate is the number of new cases per unit of person-time at risk, so it carries units of 1/time. Both need an estimate of the population at risk, and which of them can be calculated depends on whether the population being followed is closed or open. Open each tab below to compare the two kinds of population, their examples, and what each means for the population at risk.

Closed Population

A closed population has no additions and few to no losses during the study period. Examples include residents of a nursing home followed for a year, or women followed for one week post-partum.

Only disease-free individuals at the start are considered at risk. Even in a closed population, however, some people may be lost to follow-up, for example because they move away or stop attending. These people are called withdrawals, and they create a problem for the denominator: they were observed for part of the period but not all of it, so counting them as fully at risk would overstate the population at risk, while dropping them entirely would ignore the time they were watched. The simplest correction is to subtract half the number of withdrawals from the population at risk. The reasoning is that, if people leave at scattered times, they leave on average halfway through the study, so each withdrawal is treated as having been at risk for half of the period.

Open Population

An open population has individuals entering and leaving throughout the study period. For example, women served by a cancer centre who had mastectomies form an open population as new patients continually arrive.

An open population is considered stable (stationary) if the rate of additions and withdrawals, and the distribution of host attributes, remain relatively constant over time. By this we mean that, although the individual members keep changing, the population as a whole looks much the same from one month to the next: roughly as many people arrive as leave, and its age and sex make-up stays similar. This matters because several shortcuts later in the lesson, such as the link between prevalence, incidence and duration, assume a population of this kind.

Risk cannot be computed directly from an open population, because there is no fixed group whose members are all followed from the start to the end of the period. A risk asks what proportion of a defined group became ill, and in an open population the group itself keeps changing. Instead, risk can be estimated from the incidence rate (I) using the relationship between risk and rate described in 3.3.

The choice between a rate and a risk therefore follows from the design. In a closed population the fixed group can be followed from start to finish and its incidence reported as a risk over a stated period. When people join and leave at different times, as in an open cohort, the number of people says little about how long each one was observed, so the cases are divided by the person-time actually accumulated at risk rather than by a head count, and the result is a rate. A study description that says participants joined, left, moved away or were followed for different lengths of time therefore calls for a rate. Risk and rate are not the only ways to express incidence, however, as the next subsection shows.

3.1 Four Ways to Express Incidence

Incidence can be expressed as incident times, as an incidence count, as an incidence risk (R) or as an incidence rate (I). Expand each panel below to see how each form is defined and what it is used for, and pay particular attention to the last panel, which explains why a rate, unlike a risk, can be larger than 1.

Incident Times▼

Incident times are the specific times at which cases occur, measured as elapsed time since a reference event (e.g., days after exposure to a toxin, or days after parturition). Incident times form the basis of survival analysis and are discussed at length in more advanced topics.

Incidence Count▼

The incidence count is the simple count of new cases observed. It is often used when a disease did not previously exist or was very rare in a population. Incidence counts are sometimes expressed as absolute rates, relating the number of cases to the time period of observation (e.g., “3 cases per year”). They have limited value unless combined with population-at-risk data.

Incidence Risk (R)▼

Incidence risk (R) is the probability that an individual will contract or develop a disease in a defined time period. It is a proportion (dimensionless, ranges from 0 to 1) and the time period must be specified. Only the first occurrence in the period of interest counts. Sometimes called cumulative incidence.

R is used in studies focused on individual-level predictions (e.g., the probability of breast cancer recurrence within the next year is 14%).

Incidence Rate (I)▼

Incidence rate (I) is the number of new cases per unit of person-time during a given time period. By this we mean that the cases are divided by the total time that people spent at risk, so the rate describes how fast new cases arise rather than what fraction of a group fell ill. Because time sits in the denominator, the rate has units of 1/time (for example, cases per person-year), and it is positive without an upper bound. It is also called incidence density, a name that reflects the idea of how densely cases are packed into the time at risk.

I is used to determine what factors are related to diseases and the effects of those diseases. It is the preferred measure for open populations where individuals enter and leave over time.

A rate has no upper limit of 1. A rate of 1.5 cases per person-year does not mean that 150% of people fall ill; it means 15 cases arose per 10 person-years of observation. Because the denominator is accumulated time rather than a head count, a rate can climb above 1, whereas a risk (which is a proportion) never can.

Incident times and incidence counts describe when and how many cases occurred, but only the risk and the rate relate the cases to the population that produced them, which is why the rest of this section concentrates on those two. Before either is calculated, one more decision has to be made about what counts as a new case.

First Cases vs. All Cases

Although incidence deals with “new cases,” this does not necessarily mean only the first-ever case within an individual. For some conditions (e.g., migraine headaches, recurrent infections), multiple episodes can occur. Researchers must decide whether to count only first cases or all new episodes, and clearly state this in their methodology.

With the population, the measure and the case definition settled, the next step is the calculation itself.

3.2 Calculating Incidence Risk and Incidence Rate

Both calculations divide the new cases by a denominator that describes the population at risk. For a risk the denominator is a number of people, and for a rate it is the person-time that those people spent at risk, which can be added up exactly or approximated.

3.2.1 Incidence Risk in a Closed Population

Incidence risk is a proportion, and its calculation requires a count of new cases in a defined period and an estimate of the population at risk. Equation 4.4 sets out the formula.

Incidence risk
\[ {\color{#0B7B6B}{R}} = \dfrac{\color{#C2410C}{\text{new cases in the period}}}{\color{#6D28D9}{\text{population at risk}}} \]Eq 4.4
risk equals the number of newly affected individuals in a defined time period divided by the population at risk.

The population at risk is the number of individuals who are free of the disease when follow-up begins, less half of any withdrawals, as described on the Closed Population tab in 2.2. Worked Example 4.2 applies Equation 4.4 to a closed cohort of long-term care residents; watch where the withdrawals enter the denominator.

Worked Example 4.2: Incidence Risk in a Closed Cohort

A long-term care network admits 500 residents who are free of pressure ulcers and follows each of them for 90 days. During follow-up, 35 residents develop a pressure ulcer and 20 are transferred to other facilities before the 90 days are complete (withdrawals).

  • Population at risk = 500 − ½ × 20 = 490, subtracting half of the withdrawals on the assumption that they left, on average, halfway through follow-up.
  • R = 35 / 490 = 0.071, or 7.1% over 90 days.

Ignoring the withdrawals would give 35 / 500 = 0.070, a slight underestimate, because the residents who left early were not observed for the whole risk period. The result is a 90-day risk, and the period is reported with it.

The worked example shows that the withdrawal correction changes the risk only slightly, but that the period must always be reported with the result. Calculator 4.1 carries out the same calculation for other numbers of cases, starting population and withdrawals.

Risk can be computed directly only for a closed population like this one. Open populations need a denominator that reflects how long each person was observed, which is the incidence rate.

3.2.2 Incidence Rate from Exact Person-Time

The incidence rate has the person-time at risk as its denominator, so its calculation depends on how long each individual remains at risk. Equation 4.5 sets out the formula.

Incidence rate
\[ {\color{#0B7B6B}{I}} = \dfrac{\color{#C2410C}{\text{new cases in the period}}}{\color{#6D28D9}{\text{person-time at risk}}} \]Eq 4.5
the incidence rate equals the number of new cases in a defined time period divided by the number of person-time units at risk during that period.

A person-time unit is one person observed for a defined period (for example, one person-month or one person-year). By this we mean that time and people are combined into a single quantity: one person followed for two years and two people followed for one year each both contribute 2 person-years. This is what allows people who were watched for different lengths of time to be added together in one denominator. Each person contributes time from the start of observation until they develop the disease, leave the study or reach the end of the period, whichever comes first. The reason for stopping the clock at diagnosis is that, after an individual contracts the disease of interest, they can no longer become a new case, so they are no longer at risk and no longer contribute person-time to the denominator (for first-case analyses). Worked Example 4.3 applies Equation 4.5 by adding up the exact person-time contributed by four individuals; watch how much time each person contributes before they fall ill or leave.

Worked Example 4.3: Exact Incidence Rate

Assume 4 previously healthy people were observed for exactly 1 month (30 days):

  • Person 1: not sick at all → 1.00 person-months at risk
  • Person 2: sick on day 10 → 0.33 person-months at risk
  • Person 3: sick on day 20 → 0.67 person-months at risk
  • Person 4: moved away on day 15 (lost to follow-up) → 0.50 person-months at risk

Total person-months at risk = 2.50

Total new cases = 2

I = 2 / 2.50 = 0.80 cases per person-month

The worked example shows that the two people who fell ill count in full in the numerator but contribute only the time before they fell ill to the denominator, and that the person who moved away contributes the half month during which they were observed. Calculator 4.2 repeats the calculation with other values.

3.2.3 Incidence Rate from Approximate Person-Time

When exact person-time data are unavailable, the denominator can be approximated with Equation 4.6. The starting population is reduced by half of those who fell ill and half of those who withdrew, increased by half of those who were added, and multiplied by the length of the period.

Incidence rate (approximate)
\[ {\color{#0B7B6B}{I}} = \dfrac{\color{#C2410C}{\text{cases}}}{{\color{#6D28D9}{(\text{start} - \tfrac12\text{sick} - \tfrac12\text{withdrawn} + \tfrac12\text{added})}}\times {\color{#1D4ED8}{\text{time}}}} \]Eq 4.6
the incidence rate equals cases divided by an approximate person-time denominator (the starting population, minus half of those who got sick or withdrew, plus half of those added) multiplied by the length of the period.

This assumes that, on average, events (illness, withdrawal, addition) occur at the midpoint of the study period. By this we mean that, when we do not know exactly when someone fell ill, left or joined, we treat them as having done so halfway through, so each of them contributes half of the period to the person-time. A person who falls ill or leaves therefore counts as half a person at risk, which is why half of them are subtracted. A person who joins also counts as half a person, but because they were not in the starting population they have to be added. If events are spread fairly evenly across the period, the early and late events balance out and the approximation is close to the exact person-time. Worked Example 4.4 applies Equation 4.6 to an occupational cohort for which exact dates are unavailable; check the sign of each half-adjustment as you follow it.

Worked Example 4.4: Approximate Incidence Rate

An occupational cohort begins a one-year period with 1,200 workers who are free of work-related back injury. During the year, 90 workers are injured, 100 leave the company, and 60 new workers join. Exact dates are unavailable, so each event is placed at the midpoint of the year.

  • Approximate number at risk = 1,200 − ½(90) − ½(100) + ½(60) = 1,200 − 45 − 50 + 30 = 1,135.
  • Person-time = 1,135 × 1 year = 1,135 person-years.
  • I = 90 / 1,135 = 0.079 cases per person-year, or about 79 per 1,000 person-years.

The injured workers appear twice in the calculation: in full in the numerator, and as half a person each in the denominator, because they stop contributing time at risk once they are injured.

The worked example shows how a rate can be estimated from start and end counts alone, and how it is rescaled to a convenient multiplier. Calculator 4.3 carries out the approximate calculation for other values.

Whether the person-time is exact or approximate, a rate can be interpreted only when it is reported with its units, and the conventions for doing so are worth committing to memory.

Reporting a Rate in Convenient Units

A rate is often a small decimal, so it is usually multiplied by a round number of person-time units before it is reported. A rate of 0.079 cases per person-year is 0.079 × 1,000 = 79 cases per 1,000 person-years, and a rate of 18 cases in 90,000 child-years is 18 / 90,000 × 100,000 = 20 cases per 100,000 child-years. The person-time must be in one unit before the division: if some follow-up is recorded in person-months, divide it by 12 to convert it to person-years (for example, 54,000 person-months = 4,500 person-years). Whatever multiplier is chosen, the units are written out in full with the number.

The exact and the approximate methods both express new cases per unit of person-time. Because a risk cannot be computed directly from an open population, the last step is to convert a rate of this kind into a risk.

3.3 Converting a Rate to a Risk

Risk and rate are mathematically related, because both are built from the same new cases arising in the same people. The rate tells us how many cases arise per unit of time at risk, so multiplying it by the length of the interval gives an estimate of how many cases each person would accumulate over that interval. For example, a rate of 0.01 cases per person-year sustained over 5 years suggests that about 0.05, or 5%, of the group will become ill. Thus, for a closed population followed over an interval Δt, the risk is approximately the incidence rate multiplied by the length of the interval, provided that this product is small (Equation 4.7).

Risk from rate (small-risk approximation)
\[ {\color{#0B7B6B}{R}} \approx {\color{#C2410C}{I}} \times {\color{#6D28D9}{\Delta t}} \quad ({\color{#C2410C}{I}}\,{\color{#6D28D9}{\Delta t}}\text{ small}) \]Eq 4.7
when the product is small, risk is approximately the incidence rate times the length of the time interval.

More precisely, assuming a constant rate, the relationship is exponential (Equation 4.8).

Risk from rate (exact, constant rate)
\[ {\color{#0B7B6B}{R}} = 1 - e^{-{\color{#C2410C}{I}}\,{\color{#6D28D9}{\Delta t}}} \]Eq 4.8
risk equals one minus the exponential of minus the incidence rate times the length of the time interval.

The exponential formula in Equation 4.8 accounts for the fact that as people become diseased, they leave the at-risk pool. By this we mean that a constant rate acts on a shrinking group: in the early years many people are still well and can fall ill, but as cases accumulate there are fewer well people left for the same rate to act on. The number of new cases each year therefore falls slowly over time, so the risk grows more slowly than the rate multiplied by the time, and it can approach 1 but never exceed it. The linear shortcut ignores this shrinking, which is harmless when only a small fraction of the group falls ill but misleading when a large fraction does. When the product I×Δt is small (less than 0.1), the simpler linear approximation in Equation 4.7 works well; when the product is larger, the approximation overstates the risk. The exponential relationship assumes that the rate stays constant over the period. Survival methods such as the Kaplan–Meier estimator apply the same idea of turning the experience of people at risk into a risk, but they do so over many short intervals and do not need the rate to be constant (Kaplan & Meier, 1958; see also Wikipedia). Worked Example 4.5 applies both equations to an incidence rate of type 2 diabetes over a short and a long period; watch the size of I × Δt in each case.

Worked Example 4.5: Converting a Rate to a Risk

Suppose the incidence rate of type 2 diabetes in a cohort of adults is 0.012 cases per person-year, and the question is what proportion of a disease-free group would develop diabetes over a given period.

  • Over 5 years, I × Δt = 0.012 × 5 = 0.060. The approximation gives R ≈ 0.060, and the exact formula gives R = 1 − e−0.060 = 0.058. The two agree closely because the product is small.
  • Over 40 years, I × Δt = 0.012 × 40 = 0.48. The approximation gives R ≈ 0.48, whereas the exact formula gives R = 1 − e−0.48 = 0.38. The approximation now overstates the risk by ten percentage points, because many people have already developed diabetes and left the at-risk pool.

The worked example shows that the shortcut is adequate over 5 years but overstates the risk by ten percentage points over 40 years. Before converting, put the rate and Δt in the same time unit and work out I × Δt; if the product is 0.1 or more, use the exact formula. Calculator 4.4 carries out both conversions for other values.

This section has shown how the type of population decides between a risk and a rate, described the forms in which incidence is expressed, set out how a risk and a rate are calculated, and described the relationship between them. The key takeaways below summarise these points.

Key Takeaways

  • 2.2 Incidence risk and incidence rate are the two faces of incidence, and the kind of population usually tells you which one to use. A closed population has no additions and few or no losses during the study (residents of a nursing home followed for a year, for example), so you can follow the fixed group and report a risk: a proportion between 0 and 1 over a stated period. An open population has people entering and leaving throughout (such as patients who keep arriving at a cancer centre), so a head count says little about how long each person was observed, and you divide the new cases by the person-time actually accumulated at risk to get a rate. In exam questions, words such as "joined", "left", "moved away" or "followed for different lengths of time" signal an open population and a rate. Risk cannot be calculated directly from an open population; if you need one, estimate it from the rate using the risk-rate relationship in takeaway 3.3.
  • 3.1 Incidence is about new cases: people who were free of the disease at the start and develop it during the period you are observing. Because it follows people from being well to becoming ill, incidence is the family of measures used to identify factors associated with becoming ill, and anyone who already has the disease at the start is left out of the population at risk. Incidence can be expressed in four ways: incident times (when each case occurred, the basis of survival analysis), an incidence count, an incidence risk (R, a proportion) and an incidence rate (I, new cases per unit of person-time). When a question describes a group that already contains some cases at the start, remove them from the population at risk and count only the cases that arise afterwards. Also check whether a study counts only first cases or every new episode (subsection 3.1), because recurrent conditions such as migraine can be counted either way.
  • 3.2 An incidence risk is the number of new cases divided by the population at risk at the start, meaning the people who were free of the disease when follow-up began. If some people leave before the end (withdrawals), subtract half of them from the population at risk, on the assumption that they left halfway through on average: in Worked Example 4.2, 35 / (500 − ½ × 20) = 35 / 490 = 0.071, or 7.1% over 90 days. An incidence rate is new cases divided by person-time at risk, either added up person by person (Worked Example 4.3) or, when exact dates are missing, approximated as (start − ½ sick − ½ withdrawn + ½ added) × the length of the period (Worked Example 4.4). Common traps are forgetting the withdrawal correction and dividing a rate by a head count, so write the denominator out in full before you divide. Finish every answer with its period or its units. A risk needs its time period ("7.1% over 90 days"), and a rate needs person-time units, so convert all follow-up to one unit first (person-months ÷ 12 = person-years) and then rescale it to a convenient multiplier, as when 0.079 cases per person-year becomes 79 per 1,000 person-years.
  • 3.3 Because risk and rate are linked, you can turn an incidence rate into the risk of becoming ill over a stated period with R = 1 − e−IΔt. The exact formula allows for the people who become ill leaving the at-risk pool, which is why the risk grows more slowly than the rate multiplied by the time. When I × Δt is small (below about 0.1), the shortcut R ≈ I × Δt is close enough: in Worked Example 4.5, 0.012 × 5 = 0.060, against an exact risk of 0.058. Over 40 years, however, the shortcut gives 0.48 while the exact risk is 0.38, an overstatement of ten percentage points. Before you convert, make sure the rate and Δt use the same time unit, work out I × Δt first, and use the exact formula whenever that product is 0.1 or more.
Knowledge Check: this section

1. A factory screens 500 newly hired workers for noise-induced hearing loss and finds 20 who already have it. The other 480 are retested 2 years later, and 12 of them have developed hearing loss. What is the incidence risk, and how should it be read?

32 / 500 adds the 20 workers who already had hearing loss at hire to the new cases, which mixes prevalence with incidence. Incidence counts only new cases among those who could become cases.
The 20 workers with hearing loss at hire could not become new cases, so they do not belong in the denominator. The population at risk is 500 − 20 = 480.
The numbers are right, but a risk is a probability with no units, read together with its period. Cases per person-year are the units of a rate, which would need person-time in the denominator.
Only the 480 workers free of hearing loss at hire were at risk, and 12 became new cases, so R = 12 / 480 = 0.025: a 2.5% probability of developing hearing loss within 2 years, with no units.
Correct answer: 12 / 480 = 0.025, a 2.5% probability over 2 years. The information needed is who was free of the condition at the start (500 − 20 = 480) and how many of them developed it (12). Incidence counts only new cases, so the 20 workers who already had hearing loss at hire go in neither the numerator nor the denominator, because they could not become new cases. The risk is 12 / 480 = 0.025, a probability with no units, read together with its period of 2 years. The tempting 32 / 500 adds the existing cases to the new ones, which mixes prevalence with incidence. (Section 2, 3.1 Four Ways to Express Incidence, panel Incidence Risk (R), and 3.2.1 Incidence Risk in a Closed Population, Eq 4.4; Objectives 3.1 and 3.2)

2. A cohort of 320 newly hired paramedics, none with a back injury, is followed for 12 months. During the year, 30 are injured and 40 leave the service before the year ends. Assuming that those who left did so, on average, halfway through the year, what is the 12-month incidence risk of back injury?

Dividing by 320 treats the 40 paramedics who left as if they had been observed for the whole year, which overstates the population at risk.
Those who left were observed for about half the year, so the population at risk is 320 − ½ × 40 = 300, and R = 30 / 300 = 0.10, a 10% risk over 12 months.
285 also subtracts half the cases, a step that belongs to the approximate person-time formula for a rate. For a risk in a closed population, only the withdrawals are halved.
Dividing by 280 subtracts all 40 leavers, treating them as never observed, although they were followed for about half the year on average.
Correct answer: 0.10. The information needed is the number at risk at the start (320), the new cases (30) and the withdrawals (40). Step 1: population at risk = 320 − ½ × 40 = 300, because a paramedic who left halfway through was observed for about half the year. Step 2: R = 30 / 300 = 0.10, reported as a 10% risk over 12 months. Dividing by 320 ignores that the 40 leavers were not observed for the whole year, dividing by 280 treats them as never observed at all, and 285 also subtracts half the cases, a step that belongs to the approximate person-time formula for a rate, not to a risk. (Section 2, Closed Population tab in 2.2, 3.2.1 Incidence Risk in a Closed Population, Worked Example 4.2 and Calculator 4.1; Objective 3.2)

3. Over three years, a transit company’s bus drivers, who joined and left at different times, contributed a total of 14,400 person-months free of high blood pressure, and 36 drivers were newly diagnosed with it. What is the incidence rate per 1,000 person-years?

14,400 ÷ 12 = 1,200 person-years, and 36 / 1,200 = 0.030 per person-year, or 30 per 1,000 person-years. Converting the person-time to the unit asked for is the key step.
36 / 14,400 × 1,000 = 2.5 skips the conversion from months to years, so it is really 2.5 per 1,000 person-months, not per 1,000 person-years.
0.03 is the rate per single person-year. Reporting it per 1,000 person-years requires multiplying by 1,000, giving 30.
A rate always carries units, because its denominator is person-time. 0.03 is cases per person-year, not a proportion, and the question asks for it per 1,000 person-years.
Correct answer: 30 per 1,000 person-years. The information needed is the number of new cases (36) and the person-time at risk (14,400 person-months). Step 1: put the person-time in the unit asked for: 14,400 ÷ 12 = 1,200 person-years. Step 2: I = 36 / 1,200 = 0.030 cases per person-year. Step 3: multiply by 1,000 to report 30 cases per 1,000 person-years. The tempting 2.5 skips the conversion, so it is really a rate per 1,000 person-months; and a rate always carries units, because its denominator is time. (Section 2, 3.2.2 Incidence Rate from Exact Person-Time, Eq 4.5, and the box Reporting a Rate in Convenient Units in 3.2.3; Objective 3.2)

4. A city health unit wants to describe how often nurses have their first needle-stick injury over a five-year period. Nurses are hired and leave throughout, so some are observed for a few months and others for all five years. A colleague proposes dividing the injuries by the number of nurses on the payroll at the start. Which approach is best?

A long follow-up is a reason against a head-count risk here, not for it. With nurses hired and leaving throughout, the starting payroll leaves out later hires and treats a few months of observation the same as five years.
The half-withdrawal correction is a small adjustment for a few losses from a closed population. It cannot rescue a risk when people keep entering and leaving an open population.
Nurses join and leave throughout, so the population is open and follow-up is unequal. Dividing injuries by the nurse-years actually spent at risk allows for each nurse’s time under observation.
A count of injuries needs no denominator, but that is its weakness: without the population or person-time at risk, it cannot show how often injuries occur among the nurses.
Correct answer: an incidence rate. The information needed is how the group behaves over time: nurses join and leave throughout, so the population is open and follow-up is unequal. A head count at the start leaves out the nurses hired later and treats someone observed for three months the same as someone observed for five years, so the injuries are divided by the person-time at risk (nurse-years) instead. The half-withdrawal correction is tempting, but it is a small adjustment for a few losses from a closed population and cannot rescue a risk when people keep entering; an incidence count on its own has no denominator, so it cannot show how often injuries occur among the nurses at risk. (Section 2, 2.2 Incidence Risk and Incidence Rate in Closed and Open Populations, and the box Reporting a Rate in Convenient Units in 3.2.3; Objective 2.2)

5. In a cohort of adults, the incidence rate of a chronic condition is roughly constant at 0.02 cases per person-year. A planner wants the risk for a disease-free person over 3 years and over 25 years, and proposes using R ≈ I × Δt for both. Which statement is correct?

A constant rate does not make the shortcut safe. R ≈ I × Δt is adequate only when I × Δt is below about 0.1; over 25 years it is 0.50, far above that limit.
Over 3 years I × Δt = 0.06, below about 0.1, so the shortcut agrees with the exact 0.058. Over 25 years I × Δt = 0.50 is too large, and the exact risk is 1 − e−0.50 = 0.39.
The direction is reversed. The exact risk, 0.39, is lower than the shortcut’s 0.50, because people who have already become ill leave the at-risk pool and cannot become cases again.
Converting a rate to a risk is exactly how a risk is estimated when it cannot be calculated directly. A closed population is needed only for calculating a risk directly from counts.
Correct answer: the shortcut works for 3 years but not for 25. The information needed is the rate (0.02 per person-year), each period, and the rule that R ≈ I × Δt is adequate only when I × Δt is below about 0.1. Over 3 years, I × Δt = 0.02 × 3 = 0.06, so R ≈ 0.06, and the exact R = 1 − e−0.06 = 0.058 agrees. Over 25 years, I × Δt = 0.50, well above 0.1, so the exact R = 1 − e−0.50 = 0.39 is needed; the shortcut overstates the risk, because people who have already become ill leave the at-risk pool, so the option claiming the exact value is higher has the direction reversed. Converting a rate in this way is exactly how a risk is estimated when it cannot be calculated directly. (Section 2, 3.3 Converting a Rate to a Risk, Eq 4.7 and Eq 4.8, Worked Example 4.5 and Calculator 4.4; Objective 3.3)

6. A diabetes prevention programme follows 960 adults who are free of type 2 diabetes for two years. Over the two years, 72 new cases are diagnosed, 100 participants move away, and 60 new participants, all free of diabetes, join. Exact dates were not recorded, so each event is placed at the midpoint of the two years. Using the approximate person-time formula, what is the incidence rate?

72 / (960 × 2) ignores the half-adjustments for cases, departures and arrivals, treating the starting group as if it stayed unchanged for the full two years.
The adjusted number at risk, 904, is right, but it must be multiplied by the two years to give person-time. 72 / 904 gives a value twice as large as the true rate.
Approximate number at risk = 960 − ½(72) − ½(100) + ½(60) = 904, so person-time = 904 × 2 = 1,808 person-years, and I = 72 / 1,808 = 39.8 per 1,000 person-years.
72 / 960 is a risk, which cannot be calculated directly for a group that people join and leave, and the question asks for the incidence rate, which needs person-time in the denominator.
Correct answer: 39.8 per 1,000 person-years. The information needed is the number at risk at the start (960), the new cases (72), the departures (100), the arrivals (60) and the length of the period (2 years). Step 1: approximate number at risk = 960 − ½(72) − ½(100) + ½(60) = 960 − 36 − 50 + 30 = 904. Step 2: person-time = 904 × 2 years = 1,808 person-years. Step 3: I = 72 / 1,808 = 0.0398 cases per person-year, or 39.8 per 1,000 person-years. Ignoring the half-adjustments gives 37.5, and forgetting to multiply by the two years gives 79.6; 72 / 960 is a risk, which cannot be calculated directly for a group that people join and leave. (Section 2, 3.2.3 Incidence Rate from Approximate Person-Time, Eq 4.6 and Worked Example 4.4; Objectives 2.2 and 3.2)

✦ Pass the knowledge check with 100% to continue

Section 3

Prevalence, Mortality & Other Frequency Measures

⏱ Estimated reading time: 18 minutes

Section 3 of 4

Prevalence, Mortality & Other Frequency Measures

Existing cases, death outcomes, and the burden-of-disease framework that combines fatal and non-fatal health loss.

Existing cases

Prevalence: the water level

Point prevalence (Eq 4.4)
\[ \color{#0B7B6B}{P} = \frac{\color{#C2410C}{\text{cases at a point in time}}}{\color{#6D28D9}{\text{population at the same time}}} \]
P point prevalencecases existing cases at that momentpopulation everyone present at that moment

Prevalence reflects both incidence and disease duration. A high prevalence can mean high incidence, long duration, or both. This is why prevalence is a poor measure of risk-factor exposure.

Steady-state relationship (Eq 4.5)
\[ \color{#0B7B6B}{P} = \frac{\color{#C2410C}{I} \times \color{#6D28D9}{D}}{\color{#C2410C}{I} \times \color{#6D28D9}{D} + 1} \]
P prevalenceI incidence rateD average duration of disease
Death as an outcome

Mortality statistics and outbreak measures

Mortality rate

Deaths per person-time. Structurally identical to incidence rate, with death as the event.

Case fatality rate (CFR)

Deaths ÷ cases. A proportion (0 to 1), despite the word “rate.” Measures lethality among those already infected.

Attack rate

Cases ÷ exposed population, over a defined outbreak period. Cumulative incidence in a short-window exposure scenario.

Secondary attack rate

Secondary cases ÷ contacts of primary cases. Measures person-to-person transmissibility within a household or close-contact setting.

A common currency

The Disability-Adjusted Life Year (DALY)

DALY (Eq 4.8)
\[ \color{#0B7B6B}{\text{DALY}} = \color{#C2410C}{\text{YLL}} + \color{#6D28D9}{\text{YLD}} \]
DALY disability-adjusted life yearYLL years of life lost to early deathYLD years lived with disability

One DALY = one year of healthy life lost. The framework was developed by Murray and Lopez (1997) and is now updated regularly by the Global Burden of Disease Study at IHME.

It puts a condition that primarily kills (heart disease) on the same scale as one that primarily disables (depression), which no single mortality or morbidity measure can do.

The two components

YLL and YLD

Years of Life Lost (Eq 4.6)
\[ \color{#0B7B6B}{\text{YLL}} = \sum \color{#C2410C}{N_x} \times \color{#6D28D9}{L_x} \]
YLL years of life lostNₓ deaths at age xLₓ life expectancy remaining at age x

Where \(N_x\) = deaths at age \(x\) and \(L_x\) = standard life expectancy remaining at age \(x\). Under the GBD 2010 standard, a death at ages 30 to 34 contributes about 54 YLLs; at 80 to 84 it contributes about 9.

Years Lived with Disability (Eq 4.7)
\[ \color{#0B7B6B}{\text{YLD}} = \color{#C2410C}{I} \times \color{#6D28D9}{D} \times \color{#1D4ED8}{\text{DW}} \quad\text{or}\quad \color{#BE185D}{P} \times \color{#1D4ED8}{\text{DW}} \]
YLD years lived with disabilityI incidenceD durationDW disability weightP prevalence

Disability weight (DW): 0 = perfect health, 1 = state equivalent to death. Incidence form uses new cases × duration; prevalence form uses current cases. Weights come from large population surveys of paired health-state comparisons.

Carry forward

What to take into the next section

  • Prevalence reflects incidence and duration together; use \(P = ID/(ID+1)\) to distinguish the contributions.
  • CFR, attack rate, secondary attack rate are proportions used in specific outbreak and clinical contexts.
  • DALYs = YLL + YLD: the only single measure that captures both premature death and non-fatal disability on the same scale.
  • Disability weights and life expectancy assumptions are explicit value choices; check which GBD revision your source uses.

Overview

Section 2 covered incidence, the measures of how quickly new cases arise. This section turns to the complementary measures that describe disease as it currently exists in a population and the harm it causes: prevalence (current cases), mortality (deaths), and burden-of-disease summaries such as DALYs that combine premature mortality with disability. Each tells you something different about a population's health. The section defines point and period prevalence and shows how prevalence depends on both incidence and the duration of disease. It then treats mortality rates as incidence rates with death as the outcome, introduces the attack rate, secondary attack rate, case fatality rate and proportional mortality, which are proportions despite their names, and ends with years of life lost, years lived with disability and DALYs, which place fatal and non-fatal health loss on one scale.

Learning Objectives

  • 4.1 Define point and period prevalence, explain how prevalence differs from incidence, and calculate a point prevalence.
  • 4.2 Explain how prevalence depends on incidence and disease duration, using the sink analogy and P = ID / (ID + 1), and why prevalence is a poor measure for identifying causes.
  • 5.1 Explain overall and cause-specific mortality rates as incidence rates with death as the outcome.
  • 5.2 Calculate and interpret attack rates, secondary attack rates, case fatality rates, and proportional mortality, and explain why each is a proportion despite its name.
  • 6.1 Calculate Years of Life Lost (YLLs), Years Lived with Disability (YLDs), and Disability-Adjusted Life Years (DALYs), and explain why they add value beyond mortality and morbidity measures alone.

4.1 Point and Period Prevalence

Unlike incidence, which counts new cases, prevalence measures the number of existing cases of disease at a specific point in time (or over a period), however long ago each case began. The prevalence count is the number of individuals in a population who have an attribute or disease at a particular time. Equation 4.9 gives point prevalence as the number of existing cases divided by the population at the same point in time, so its denominator is everyone in the population at that moment, not only the people who were free of disease at some earlier start.

Point prevalence
\[ {\color{#0B7B6B}{P}} = \dfrac{\color{#C2410C}{\text{existing cases at a point in time}}}{\color{#6D28D9}{\text{population at the same point}}} \]Eq 4.9
prevalence equals the number of cases of disease at a point in time divided by the number of individuals in the population at the same point in time.

For example, if 75 athletes are tested for performance-enhancing drug use and 3 test positive, then P = 3/75 = 0.04 (4%). Operational decisions about case definitions and time windows matter more than this simple formula suggests (Spronk et al., 2019). Calculator 4.5 carries out the same calculation for other counts.

Period prevalence uses the same logic over an interval: it counts everyone who had the disease at any time during a stated period (for example, a calendar year) and divides by the population during that period. Like point prevalence, it is a proportion with no time units, so the moment or the period it describes is reported with it. Because it counts everyone who currently has the disease, prevalence is the measure used to plan health services, such as the staff, beds or treatments needed at a given time, whereas incidence is used to study causes and prevention.

Because prevalence counts existing cases and incidence counts new ones, the two can differ sharply even when they are measured in the same group. Suppose 400 children at a summer camp are well on day 0, and 60 develop a short diarrheal illness, lasting two to three days, over the next 14 days. The 14-day incidence risk is 60 / 400 = 0.15 (15%), because it counts every new case over the whole period. If a nurse counts the children who are ill at 9 a.m. on day 7 and finds 20 among the 400 present, the point prevalence is 20 / 400 = 0.05 (5%). The prevalence is lower because it misses the children who have already recovered and those who have not yet fallen ill. An incidence rate would divide the 60 new cases by the person-time at risk, giving the speed at which cases arise (cases per person-day), whereas the prevalence counts existing cases at one moment and has no time units.

The summer camp shows that a short illness keeps prevalence low even when new cases arise quickly. The next subsection makes this dependence on duration precise.

4.2 How Prevalence Depends on Incidence and Duration

Prevalence depends on two things: how quickly new cases arise and how long people stay ill. The reason is that the pool of existing cases is filled by new cases and emptied by recovery or death. If new cases arrive quickly, the pool grows; if each case lasts a long time, people stay in the pool longer, and it grows as well. For example, two diseases with the same incidence will have very different prevalences if one lasts a week and the other a lifetime. When the incidence rate (I) and the duration stay constant in a stable population, the inflow and outflow eventually balance, and the pool settles at a steady level. At that steady state, prevalence (P), incidence, and mean disease duration (D) are related by Equation 4.10, in which I and D must be expressed in the same time unit.

Prevalence from incidence and duration
\[ {\color{#0B7B6B}{P}} = \dfrac{{\color{#C2410C}{I}} \times {\color{#6D28D9}{D}}}{{\color{#C2410C}{I}} \times {\color{#6D28D9}{D}} + 1} \]Eq 4.10
at steady state, prevalence is a function of incidence and average duration: their product divided by that product plus one.

Worked Example 4.6 applies Equation 4.10 to influenza in an urban population; watch how the duration is converted to match the units of the rate.

Worked Example 4.6: Prevalence of Influenza from Incidence and Duration

If the incidence rate of influenza in an urban population is 0.3/person-year (30 cases per 100 people per year) and the mean duration of infection is 3 weeks (0.058 years), then:

P = (0.3 × 0.058) / (0.3 × 0.058 + 1) = 0.0174 / 1.0174 = 0.017 (1.7%)

So on any given day, we would expect about 1.7% of the population to have the flu.

Watch the units. The 3-week duration is converted to years (0.058) so that it lines up with the per-year incidence rate. I and D must be expressed in the same time unit, which is what makes their product I × D a pure number with no units. Feeding in 3 (weeks) next to 0.3 (per year) would inflate the answer by a factor of 52.

The worked example shows that a common, short illness produces a low prevalence, and that a units mismatch would inflate the answer many times over. Calculator 4.6 performs the calculation for other values of incidence and duration.

Interactive 4.1 represents the same relationship as water in a sink, with the incidence rate as the inflow from the tap, recovery and death as the two drains, and the prevalence as the water level. Try the disease presets first, then move one slider at a time and watch how the level settles as you open the tap or widen either drain.

🚰 Interactive 4.1: The Sink Analogy for Incidence, Duration & Prevalence

This simulator treats disease in a population like water in a sink: the tap is the incidence rate (new cases flowing in), the two drains are recovery and death from the disease (ways out of the pool of cases), and the water level is the prevalence. It is meant to show you that prevalence depends on how long cases last as well as on how often new cases arise, which is the relationship P = I × D ÷ (I × D + 1) above. As you open the tap by raising the incidence rate, notice that the level rises; as you widen either drain by raising the recovery or mortality rate, the mean duration shortens and the level falls. Try the disease presets first, then move one slider at a time and watch the level settle at its new equilibrium.
Incidence (tap) new cases flowing in 0% 10% 20% 30% Recovery Mortality (get well drain) (death drain) P = 0%
How many new cases occur per 1,000 susceptible people each year.
Higher = faster recovery (left drain opens wider).
Higher = faster death from disease (right drain opens wider).
Prevalence
–
Mean Duration
–
Steady state: P = I × D / (I × D + 1)   where   D = 1 / (r + m)
Presets:
Pick a preset or move the sliders to see how the inflow and drains determine the water level.

The sink shows that two diseases can have very different prevalences for entirely different reasons. Diabetes has a low incidence but a very long duration: the sink fills slowly but barely drains, so prevalence is high. Pancreatic cancer has a low incidence and a very short duration because of its high mortality: the drain is wide open, so prevalence stays near zero even though the disease is deadly. It follows that anything that changes how long people stay ill, such as a treatment that prolongs survival, changes prevalence without causing or preventing a single new case.

Prevalence Is a Poor Guide to Causes

Prevalence (P) is less useful than incidence rate (I) for research into risk factors, because factors that affect either the occurrence of disease or its duration will both influence prevalence. A disease may have high prevalence simply because people survive with it for a long time, not because new cases are frequent. For example, if patients in one region receive better treatment that keeps them alive longer, more of them will be counted as existing cases at any moment, and a prevalence study comparing regions could wrongly suggest that something about that region makes people more likely to develop the disease. In this sense prevalence alone confounds occurrence and survival, mixing the two together so that they cannot be told apart, which is why it is a poor measure of disease risk.

Prevalence studies still have a part to play in measuring incidence. Serial prevalence studies, by which we mean repeated surveys of the same people at regular intervals, can be used to estimate incidence rates for diseases that are not easily detected at onset. Many infections, for example, cause no symptoms when they begin, so nobody notices the moment a person becomes a case. By testing blood samples at regular intervals, researchers can see which people were negative at one test and positive at the next, and so determine the window in which each of them became infected. Counting these conversions and dividing by the person-time between tests gives an estimate of the incidence rate.

Prevalence, incidence and duration together describe how disease occurs and persists in a population. The same measures apply when the outcome is death.

5.1 Mortality Rates

Mortality statistics are calculated in exactly the same way as P, R, and I, except that the outcome of interest is death. The term mortality rate, strictly speaking, refers to the incidence rate of mortality, but it is often used to describe the risk of mortality (Porta, 2014; Rothman, 2012), so the denominator has to be checked before the measure is named. As incidence rates, mortality rates carry person-time units, and their denominator is the person-time of the whole population at risk. Open each tab below to see how the overall and the cause-specific mortality rates are defined, and why attributing a death to one cause is harder than it looks.

Overall Mortality Rate

The overall mortality rate describes the number of individuals that die from all causes in a defined time period. It is analogous to incidence rate (I) except that the outcome is death rather than disease onset.

Cause-Specific Mortality Rate

The cause-specific mortality rate describes the number of individuals that die from (or with) a specific disease during a defined period. It is calculated the same way as I but focuses on deaths attributed to one disease.

Challenges of Cause Attribution

It is often difficult to determine the specific cause of death. For example, if a recumbent patient regurgitates, contracts aspiration pneumonia, and then dies, did they die: from the initial condition causing recumbency? Due to pneumonia? With pneumonia? The “cause” is usually deemed to be the proximate cause, the factor considered the final trigger, but this determination can be challenging.

The cause recorded is usually the proximate one, so a cause-specific rate inherits any error in that judgement. Mortality rates divide deaths by the person-time of the whole population, but several other widely used measures divide cases or deaths by much narrower groups.

5.2 Attack Rates, Case Fatality and Proportional Mortality

Several additional frequency measures appear frequently in the epidemiological literature. Most of them are technically measures of risk (proportions), a number of people divided by a number of people with no person-time in the denominator, even though they are often called “rates.” The word “rate” in these names is a long-standing habit of usage rather than a description of the calculation. For example, an attack rate of 30% means that 30 of every 100 exposed people became ill; it says nothing about how many cases arose per person-day, so it is read as a proportion and carries no time units. What separates these measures from one another is the denominator: everyone exposed for an attack rate, the contacts without the primary cases for a secondary attack rate, the people with the disease for a case fatality rate, and all deaths for proportional mortality.

5.2.1 What Each Measure Describes

The four cards below define the attack rate, the secondary attack rate, the case fatality rate and proportional morbidity or mortality. Click each card to see what the measure describes, how it is calculated and when it is appropriate, and compare the case fatality rate with the mortality rate in 5.1.

Attack
Rate
Click to learn more
Secondary
Attack Rate
Click to learn more
Case Fatality
Rate
Click to learn more
Proportional
Morbidity/Mortality
Click to learn more

Each of these definitions becomes a simple equation, and the calculations below make the different denominators concrete.

5.2.2 Calculating Each Measure

Each tab below gives the equation for one measure, a worked example from a realistic outbreak or death register, and a calculator. Open the tabs in turn and, before reading each worked example, name the group that belongs in the denominator.

Equation 4.14 gives the attack rate, the people who became ill divided by everyone exposed during the outbreak.

Attack rate
\[ {\color{#0B7B6B}{\text{AR}}} = \dfrac{{\color{#C2410C}{\text{people who became ill}}}}{{\color{#6D28D9}{\text{people exposed during the outbreak}}}} \]Eq 4.14
the attack rate equals the number of people who became ill divided by the number of people exposed during the outbreak period.

Worked Example 4.10 applies Equation 4.14 to an outbreak of gastroenteritis at a wedding reception; watch how comparing eaters with non-eaters of one food points to the source.

Worked Example 4.10: Attack Rate

Of the 180 guests at a wedding reception who ate the chicken salad, 54 developed gastroenteritis within 72 hours. The attack rate is 54 / 180 = 0.30, so 30% of those exposed became ill during the outbreak window. Among the 120 guests who did not eat the salad, 6 became ill, an attack rate of 6 / 120 = 0.05. The contrast between the two attack rates points to the salad as the likely source. Dividing one attack rate by the other gives the risk ratio used in outbreak investigations: 0.30 / 0.05 = 6.0, so guests who ate the salad were six times as likely to become ill as guests who did not. Each attack rate is calculated for one food at a time, with the people who ate it in the denominator.

The worked example shows that attack rates are most useful in pairs, one food at a time. Calculator 4.10 calculates the attack rate for other values.

Equation 4.15 gives the secondary attack rate, which removes the primary cases from both the numerator and the denominator.

Secondary attack rate
\[ {\color{#0B7B6B}{\text{SAR}}} = \dfrac{{\color{#C2410C}{\text{all cases}}} - {\color{#1D4ED8}{\text{primary cases}}}}{{\color{#6D28D9}{\text{people in the groups}}} - {\color{#1D4ED8}{\text{primary cases}}}} \]Eq 4.15
the secondary attack rate equals the secondary cases (all cases minus the primary cases) divided by the contacts at risk (the people in the households or other groups minus the primary cases).

Worked Example 4.11 applies Equation 4.15 to influenza in 40 households; watch where the 40 primary cases are subtracted.

Worked Example 4.11: Secondary Attack Rate

An influenza surveillance team follows 40 households containing 160 people in total. Each household has one primary case, and over the following week 18 other household members become ill, so there are 58 cases in all.

SAR = (58 − 40) / (160 − 40) = 18 / 120 = 0.15, so 15% of household contacts became secondary cases.

In plain words, the secondary attack rate measures how easily an infection spreads from a first (primary) case to the people around it. The primary cases are removed from both the numerator and the denominator because they were infected elsewhere and cannot become secondary cases.

The worked example shows how to isolate person-to-person spread from the infections that began it. Calculator 4.11 calculates the secondary attack rate for other values.

Equation 4.16 gives the case fatality rate, the deaths among people with the disease divided by the people with the disease.

Case fatality rate
\[ {\color{#0B7B6B}{\text{CFR}}} = \dfrac{{\color{#C2410C}{\text{deaths from the disease}}}}{{\color{#6D28D9}{\text{people with the disease}}}} \]Eq 4.16
the case fatality rate equals the number of people with the disease who die from it within a stated period divided by the number of people with the disease.

Worked Example 4.12 applies Equation 4.16 to an outbreak of Legionnaires’ disease; note the time window that is reported with the result.

Worked Example 4.12: Case Fatality Rate

During an outbreak of Legionnaires’ disease, 250 people are confirmed as cases, and 25 of them die within 30 days of diagnosis. CFR = 25 / 250 = 0.10, so 10% of cases died within 30 days. The value describes the severity of the illness among those who had it, and the 30-day window is reported with it.

The worked example shows that the case fatality rate describes severity among the cases, not the risk of death in the population. Calculator 4.12 calculates the case fatality rate for other values.

Equation 4.17 gives proportional mortality, the deaths from one cause divided by the deaths from all causes.

Proportional mortality
\[ {\color{#0B7B6B}{\text{PMR}}} = \dfrac{{\color{#C2410C}{\text{deaths from a specific cause}}}}{{\color{#6D28D9}{\text{deaths from all causes}}}} \]Eq 4.17
the proportional mortality equals the number of deaths from a specific cause divided by the number of deaths from all causes; proportional morbidity uses cases in place of deaths.

Worked Example 4.13 applies Equation 4.17 to the deaths recorded in one health region; notice that the population at risk never enters the calculation.

Worked Example 4.13: Proportional Mortality

A health region records 12,000 deaths in one year, of which 3,000 are attributed to cancer. The proportional mortality for cancer is 3,000 / 12,000 = 0.25, so cancer accounts for 25% of deaths. Because the population at risk does not enter the calculation, the figure describes the share of deaths and gives no information about the risk of dying from cancer.

The worked example shows that proportional mortality describes the share of deaths and says nothing about anyone's risk of dying. That is also why and when it is used: analysts turn to proportional mortality when the population at risk is unknown or unavailable, for example when a death register records the cause of each death but there is no count of the population or its person-time. When the person-time at risk is known, the cause-specific mortality rate in 5.1 is the better measure, because proportional mortality can change simply because deaths from other causes rise or fall. Calculator 4.13 calculates proportional mortality for other values.

Across the four tabs, the measures differ only in their denominators, and choosing the wrong group, such as dividing an attack rate by the people who became ill rather than by everyone exposed, is the most common error. All of these measures, like mortality rates, count deaths or cases without regard to the age at which death occurs or the illness that does not kill, and burden-of-disease measures address both limits.

6.1 Burden of Disease: YLLs, YLDs and DALYs

Mortality, incidence, and prevalence each tell us something different, but taken individually they give an incomplete picture of a disease's impact. A condition can be deadly but rare (pancreatic cancer), or non-fatal yet extremely common and disabling (low-back pain, depression, untreated vision loss). To compare these on a single scale, the World Health Organization (WHO) and the Global Burden of Disease (GBD) Study, originated by Murray & Lopez (1997) and now updated regularly by IHME (GBD 2019 Diseases and Injuries Collaborators, 2020), express disease impact in healthy years of life lost, a common “currency” that combines premature death and time spent in less-than-perfect health (Robine, Jagger, Mathers, Crimmins, & Suzman, 2003). The burden is built from years of life lost and years lived with disability, which add up to the DALY.

6.1.1 Years of Life Lost (YLL)

YLL quantifies the burden from premature mortality. Each death is weighted by the number of additional years that person would have been expected to live had they survived. A death at age 30 contributes far more YLLs than a death at age 90, even though both count equally toward a crude mortality count. Equation 4.11 expresses YLL as a sum across ages of the number of deaths multiplied by the remaining life expectancy.

Years of Life Lost
\[ {\color{#0B7B6B}{\text{YLL}}} = \sum {\color{#C2410C}{N_x}} \times {\color{#6D28D9}{L_x}} \]Eq 4.11
years of life lost sum, across ages, the number of deaths at age x times the standard life expectancy remaining at age x.

Here Nx is the number of deaths at age x, and Lx is the standard life expectancy remaining at age x, taken from a reference life table. A single reference table is used for every population, rather than each country's own life expectancy, so that a death at a given age counts as the same loss wherever it occurs; otherwise, a death in a country with low life expectancy would count as fewer years lost simply because people there tend to die younger. The reference life table of the GBD 2010 study set life expectancy at birth at about 86 years (World Health Organization, 2024); WHO and later rounds of the GBD study use their own reference life tables, so check which standard a published YLL figure uses. Worked Example 4.7 applies Equation 4.11 to road traffic deaths in one district; compare how much each age group contributes.

Worked Example 4.7: Summing YLL Across Ages

Suppose a district records 20 deaths from road traffic injuries in one year: 3 at age 20, 5 at age 40, and 12 at age 65. Suppose also that the reference life table gives a remaining life expectancy of 65 years at age 20, 45 years at age 40, and 20 years at age 65 (values rounded for illustration).

  • Age 20: 3 × 65 = 195 years.
  • Age 40: 5 × 45 = 225 years.
  • Age 65: 12 × 20 = 240 years.
  • YLL = 195 + 225 + 240 = 660 years of life lost.

The 3 deaths at age 20 contribute nearly as many years as the 12 deaths at age 65. This weighting for premature death is the information that a simple count of 20 deaths leaves out.

The worked example shows that a few early deaths can outweigh many later ones. Calculator 4.7 carries out the calculation for other numbers of deaths and life expectancies.

6.1.2 Years Lived with Disability (YLD)

YLD quantifies the burden from non-fatal health loss. Each year spent with a condition is multiplied by a disability weight (DW) between 0 (perfect health) and 1 (a health state as bad as death). By this we mean that a year lived with an illness is counted as only part of a healthy year lost, and the weight says how large that part is. For example, a year lived with a condition whose weight is 0.30 counts as 0.30 of a healthy year lost, so ten such years add up to three years of healthy life lost. The weight is needed because a year with mild hearing loss and a year with severe depression should not count the same, and without it every year of illness would be treated as equal to a year of death. Disability weights are derived from large population surveys that ask respondents to compare paired health states (Salomon et al., 2012). Equation 4.12 gives the incidence-based formula for YLD.

Years Lived with Disability
\[ {\color{#0B7B6B}{\text{YLD}}} = {\color{#C2410C}{I}} \times {\color{#6D28D9}{D}} \times {\color{#1D4ED8}{\text{DW}}} \]Eq 4.12
years lived with disability (incidence approach) equal incidence times average duration times the disability weight.

Here I is the number of incident cases, D is the average duration of the condition until remission or death, and DW is the disability weight. The incidence approach looks forward: it takes the people who develop the condition in a given year and counts all the years of disability they will live with it, even years that fall in the future. A prevalence-based version (used by GBD since 2010) instead looks at a single year: it multiplies the number of prevalent cases by DW directly, YLD = P × DW, so that each person living with the condition contributes one year of weighted disability for the year being measured. Worked Example 4.8 compares the incidence and prevalence approaches for a single condition; watch why they agree.

Worked Example 4.8: Incidence and Prevalence Approaches to YLD

Suppose 500 people develop a condition each year, each lives with it for 4 years on average, and its disability weight is 0.30. The incidence approach gives YLD = 500 × 4 × 0.30 = 600 years. If the population is in a steady state, about 500 × 4 = 2,000 people are living with the condition at any time, and the prevalence approach gives YLD = 2,000 × 0.30 = 600 years.

The two approaches agree here because incidence and duration have been stable long enough for prevalence to reflect them. They diverge when incidence is rising or falling.

The worked example shows that the two approaches agree only when incidence and duration are stable. Calculator 4.8 computes YLD for other values; whichever approach is used, every YLD term includes a disability weight between 0 and 1, and leaving it out is a common slip.

6.1.3 Disability-Adjusted Life Years (DALYs)

The DALY is the simple sum of years lost to early death and years lost to disability (Equation 4.13).

Disability-Adjusted Life Year
\[ {\color{#0B7B6B}{\text{DALY}}} = {\color{#C2410C}{\text{YLL}}} + {\color{#6D28D9}{\text{YLD}}} \]Eq 4.13
a DALY is the sum of years of life lost to early death and years lived with disability.

One DALY equals one healthy year of life lost. The total DALYs from a condition therefore measure the gap between current population health and an ideal in which everyone lives the standard life expectancy in full health (Murray et al., 2012). Worked Example 4.9 applies Equations 4.11 to 4.13 to breast cancer in a population of 100,000 women, using the same YLD inputs as Worked Example 4.8; compare the size of the two components.

Worked Example 4.9: Calculating DALYs for Breast Cancer

In a population of 100,000 women, suppose breast cancer causes 20 deaths in one year, with an average age at death of 60 (standard life expectancy at age 60 = 25 years). Suppose also that 500 women are newly diagnosed and live with breast cancer for an average of 4 years before remission or death, with a disability weight of 0.30.

YLL = 20 × 25 = 500 years

YLD = 500 × 4 × 0.30 = 600 years

DALYs = 500 + 600 = 1,100 healthy years lost in this population in one year.

Mortality alone would have shown only the 20 deaths. The DALY makes it visible that more than half of breast-cancer burden in this population is non-fatal, a fact that should shape investment in screening, treatment, and survivorship support alongside end-of-life care (Murray & Lopez, 1997).

The worked example shows that the non-fatal component can be the larger part of a disease's burden. Calculator 4.9 adds the two components for other values.

6.1.4 What DALYs Add and Where They Fall Short

Worked Example 4.9 illustrates the main reason for using DALYs beyond mortality, incidence and prevalence: they are a common currency. DALYs let you compare diseases that primarily kill with those that primarily disable on the same scale, for example ischaemic heart disease against major depression, which no single mortality or morbidity measure can do. Within that currency, premature death is weighted, because a young death contributes more YLLs than an old death, capturing the intuition that lost years matter in a way that crude mortality rates ignore. Non-fatal burden also becomes visible: conditions such as low-back pain, anxiety, hearing loss and migraine are major drivers of population health loss but are nearly invisible in mortality statistics. These properties make DALYs a tool for priority-setting and equity, since ministries of health, the WHO and global funders use them to compare cost-effectiveness across very different interventions (for example, dollars per DALY averted). Because they combine fatal and non-fatal loss, DALYs also track change over time, capturing epidemiological transitions, the shift from infectious, fatal diseases toward chronic, disabling ones, better than any single measure.

These advantages come with limits that apply whenever you read a DALY figure.

Caveats

DALYs are widely used but not value-neutral. Disability weights reflect aggregate survey responses and may not match an individual patient's lived experience; weights have also shifted across GBD revisions (Salomon et al., 2012; Vos et al., 2016). Choices about the standard life expectancy, age-weighting, and time-discounting can substantially change disease rankings (Murray & Lopez, 1997). As with any composite indicator, always check which version of the methodology produced the number you are reading, and whether comparing across years uses the same conventions.

Burden-of-disease measures complete the set of frequency measures in this section. Like the others, they are published routinely by surveillance agencies, and the additional context below describes where Canadian figures come from.

Additional Context

This part, on where Canadian frequency figures come from, is background for reading published figures rather than an exam objective. The incidence, prevalence, mortality, and case-fatality numbers in your textbooks and in the news are produced by named surveillance systems. The most important to know are the following.

  • Canadian Chronic Disease Surveillance System (CCDSS): PHAC. Linked provincial/territorial physician-billing and hospital data harmonised across jurisdictions. Produces national prevalence and incidence estimates for diabetes, hypertension, mental illness, COPD, asthma, IHD, cancer, and more.
  • Canadian Notifiable Disease Surveillance System (CNDSS): PHAC. Aggregated reports from provinces/territories on legally reportable communicable diseases (e.g., measles, pertussis, syphilis, HIV).
  • FluWatch and RVDSS (Respiratory Virus Detection Surveillance System): PHAC, sentinel and laboratory surveillance for influenza and respiratory viruses.
  • Canadian Cancer Registry: Statistics Canada / provincial cancer registries. Population-based incidence and survival data; the source for "Canadian Cancer Statistics" annual reports.
  • Canadian Vital Statistics, Births and Deaths Database: Statistics Canada. Source for crude and age-standardised mortality, life expectancy, infant mortality, and cause-specific death rates.
  • BC Centre for Disease Control (BCCDC) surveillance dashboards: provincial reportable-disease, STBBI, and overdose surveillance, including the overdose response indicators and weekly respiratory-virus reports.
  • BC Coroners Service: primary source for unregulated drug deaths and suicide statistics in British Columbia.
  • Canadian Institute for Health Information (CIHI): Discharge Abstract Database (DAD) and National Ambulatory Care Reporting System (NACRS); source for hospital-based incidence, length-of-stay, and case-fatality estimates.

Each system has its own case definition, denominator, and reporting lag. When you cite a Canadian rate, always state which surveillance system produced it, and check whether the case definition matches your research question. Worked Example 4.14 shows what is needed to interpret one such figure, the CCDSS prevalence of diagnosed diabetes; look for the three concepts from this lesson that it relies on.

Worked Example 4.14: Reading a CCDSS Diabetes Rate

The CCDSS reports that the age-standardised prevalence of diagnosed diabetes among Canadians aged 1+ was about 8.1% (2017–18 fiscal year; Public Health Agency of Canada, 2021). To interpret this number you need to know:

  • Numerator (case definition): a CCDSS case is a person with one hospital discharge OR two physician claims for diabetes within a two-year window, a validated administrative algorithm with sensitivity ~86% and specificity ~97% (Hux et al., 2002).
  • Denominator: all individuals registered with provincial health insurance during the fiscal year (a near-complete population frame, not a sample).
  • Standardisation: rates are direct-standardised to the 2011 Canadian population, so comparisons across years and provinces aren't distorted by ageing.

Notice how all three concepts from this lesson (case definition, denominator at risk, and standardisation) are required just to read a single published number correctly.

This section has covered prevalence, mortality, the specialised proportions used to describe outbreaks and deaths, and burden-of-disease measures. The key takeaways below summarise these points, and the next section turns to the standardisation on which comparisons such as the CCDSS rate depend.

Key Takeaways

  • 4.1 Prevalence describes how much disease exists in a population at a given time, counting every existing case however long ago it began, whereas incidence counts only new cases. Point prevalence is the number of existing cases at one moment divided by the population at that same moment (3 positive tests among 75 athletes gives 3 / 75 = 0.04, or 4%), and period prevalence counts everyone who had the disease at any time during a stated period. Prevalence is a proportion with no time units, so always report the moment or the period it describes. When a question gives you both a cumulative risk and a one-day count in the same group, expect them to differ: in the summer-camp example in subsection 4.1, the 14-day risk is 60 / 400 = 15% but the point prevalence on day 7 is 20 / 400 = 5%, because with a short illness many children have already recovered, or have not yet fallen ill, on the day of the count. Check your denominator too, because for point prevalence it is everyone in the population at that moment, not only the people who were free of disease at the start.
  • 4.2 Prevalence depends on two things: how quickly new cases arise and how long people stay ill. In the sink analogy, the tap is the incidence rate, the two drains are recovery and death, and the water level is the prevalence, so a disease with a low incidence but a long duration, such as diabetes, can still have a high prevalence, while a rapidly fatal disease, such as pancreatic cancer, keeps the level near zero. At steady state the relationship is P = I×D / (I×D + 1), and I and D must be in the same time unit: in Worked Example 4.6, 3 weeks becomes 0.058 years to match 0.3 cases per person-year, giving a prevalence of about 1.7%. Anything that changes how long people stay ill, such as a treatment that prolongs survival or a cure that shortens the illness, changes prevalence without causing or preventing a single new case, which makes prevalence a poor measure for identifying causes. When a question asks why, name both parts (occurrence and duration) and say that the incidence rate is the better measure for research into risk factors.
  • 5.1 Mortality statistics are not a new set of formulas: they are the measures you have already met, with death as the outcome instead of disease onset. The overall mortality rate is deaths from all causes divided by the person-time at risk, and the cause-specific mortality rate is deaths from one disease divided by the person-time at risk, so each is an incidence rate and carries person-time units. The term "mortality rate" is often used loosely for the risk of dying, so check the denominator before you name the measure. Keep the mortality rate separate from the case fatality rate and proportional mortality: the mortality rate divides by the person-time of the whole population at risk, the case fatality rate by the people who have the disease, and proportional mortality by the deaths alone. Remember too that the cause of a death can be hard to assign, and the cause recorded is usually the proximate one, the final trigger.
  • 5.2 The attack rate, secondary attack rate, case fatality rate and proportional mortality are often called rates, but each is a proportion: a number of people divided by a number of people, with no person-time. The attack rate is the people who became ill divided by everyone exposed during the outbreak (54 / 180 = 0.30 for the chicken salad in Worked Example 4.10), and comparing the attack rates of eaters and non-eaters, one food at a time, points to the likely source. The secondary attack rate measures how easily an infection spreads from a primary case to the people around it, so remove the primary cases from both the numerator and the denominator: (58 − 40) / (160 − 40) = 0.15 in Worked Example 4.11. The case fatality rate divides deaths by the people with the disease and describes severity (25 / 250 = 10% within 30 days), whereas proportional mortality divides deaths from one cause by all deaths and tells you only the share of deaths, not anyone's risk of dying. The trap in every case is the denominator, so before you divide, name the group the measure is about (the exposed, the contacts, the cases or all deaths); a frequent error is dividing an attack rate by the people who became ill instead of by everyone exposed. Report the period with your answer.
  • 6.1 Burden-of-disease measures express early death and time lived in poor health in one currency: healthy years of life lost. YLLs capture premature death by multiplying the deaths at each age by the standard remaining life expectancy at that age and adding the results (YLL = Σ Nx × Lx), so a death at 20 counts for far more than a death at 65. YLDs capture non-fatal health loss as incident cases × average duration × disability weight (YLD = I × D × DW, or prevalent cases × DW), and DALYs are simply YLL + YLD. In Worked Example 4.9, 20 deaths × 25 years = 500 YLLs and 500 cases × 4 years × 0.30 = 600 YLDs give 1,100 DALYs, which shows that more than half of the breast-cancer burden is non-fatal, something the 20 deaths alone would hide. A common slip is to leave out the disability weight, so check that every YLD term includes a weight between 0 and 1, and when you are asked what DALYs add, say that they put conditions that mainly kill and conditions that mainly disable on a single scale.
Knowledge Check: this section

1. A new treatment keeps people with a chronic lung disease alive for much longer but does not cure them. Over the next decade the number of new cases each year stays the same, yet the prevalence of the disease doubles. A colleague concludes that something in the environment must now be causing more of the disease. What is the best response?

Prevalence counts every existing case, so it depends on duration as well as on new cases. Here incidence stayed the same; the rise came from longer survival, not from more new cases.
Whether prevalence is measured at a point or over a period does not change the logic. Either way, prevalence reflects both incidence and duration, and longer survival alone can raise it.
Prevalence reflects both incidence and duration. With the tap (new cases) unchanged and the death drain narrowed by longer survival, the water level rises without any new cause of disease.
Prevalence is not limited to closed populations; it is the proportion of a population with the disease at a point or during a period. The colleague is wrong, but for the reason of duration.
Correct answer: prevalence rose because the duration of illness rose, not because new cases rose. The information needed is that incidence (new cases per year) stayed the same while survival lengthened. Prevalence counts every existing case, so it depends on how fast cases arise and on how long they last (P = I×D / (I×D+1) at steady state); in the sink, the tap ran as before while one drain narrowed, so the water level rose. A factor that changes duration therefore changes prevalence without causing any new cases, which is why prevalence is a poor measure for identifying causes and incidence is used instead. The colleague’s reasoning treats prevalence as if it counted only new cases. (Section 3, 4.2 How Prevalence Depends on Incidence and Duration, Interactive 4.1 and the box Prevalence Is a Poor Guide to Causes; Objective 4.2)

2. In one year, a health region whose 200,000 residents contribute about 200,000 person-years records 400 hospital admissions for confirmed influenza, and 20 of these patients die of it within 30 days. The region records 1,600 deaths from all causes that year. Which pair of values is correct?

The case fatality rate divides the 20 deaths by the 400 cases, 0.05, which measures severity. The cause-specific mortality rate divides the same 20 deaths by the population’s 200,000 person-years, giving 10 per 100,000 person-years.
The right numbers are in the wrong places. The case fatality rate divides deaths by cases (20 / 400), while the mortality rate divides deaths by the person-time of the whole population (20 / 200,000).
20 / 1,600 is proportional mortality, influenza’s share of all deaths, not the case fatality rate. And 400 / 200,000 is the rate of admissions, not of deaths.
400 / 200,000 is the rate of admissions, not a case fatality rate, which divides deaths by cases. And 20 / 1,600 is proportional mortality, not a mortality rate with person-time in its denominator.
Correct answer: a case fatality rate of 5% and a mortality rate of 10 per 100,000 person-years. The information needed is which group each measure divides by. The case fatality rate divides the deaths (20) by the people who had the disease (400), so 20 / 400 = 0.05: 5% of admitted cases died within 30 days, a measure of severity. The cause-specific mortality rate divides the same 20 deaths by the person-time of the whole population, 20 / 200,000 = 0.0001 per person-year, or 10 deaths per 100,000 person-years, which is an incidence rate with death as the outcome. The swapped option uses the right numbers in the wrong places, 400 / 200,000 is the rate of admissions rather than deaths, and 20 / 1,600 is the proportional mortality (influenza’s share of all deaths). (Section 3, 5.1 Mortality Rates and its tabs, and the Case fatality rate tab in 5.2.2, Eq 4.16 and Worked Example 4.12; Objectives 5.1 and 5.2)

3. In a stable population, the incidence rate of a skin infection is 0.4 cases per person-year, and an episode lasts 2 weeks on average. Using P = I×D / (I×D+1), about what proportion of the population has the infection on any given day?

44% comes from entering 2 weeks next to a rate per year, 0.8 / 1.8. I and D must share a time unit, so the duration is 2 ÷ 52 years and I × D is about 0.015.
With D = 2 ÷ 52 = 0.038 years, I × D = 0.4 × 0.038 = 0.015, and P = 0.015 / (0.015 + 1) is about 0.015, or 1.5%. The key step is putting I and D in the same unit.
17% comes from using 0.5 months for the duration while the rate is per year. I and D must be in the same time unit, so the duration should be 2 ÷ 52 years.
0.4 is the incidence rate, cases per person-year, not the proportion ill on a given day. Prevalence depends on both the rate and the 2-week duration, which keeps it far lower.
Correct answer: about 1.5%. The information needed is the incidence rate (0.4 per person-year), the mean duration (2 weeks) and the rule that I and D must be in the same time unit. Step 1: D = 2 ÷ 52 = 0.038 years. Step 2: I × D = 0.4 × 0.038 = 0.015, a pure number. Step 3: P = 0.015 / (0.015 + 1) = 0.015, so about 1.5% of the population is infected on any given day. The tempting 44% comes from entering 2 (weeks) next to a rate per year (0.8 / 1.8), which inflates I × D by a factor of 52; 17% comes from using 0.5 months, and 40% wrongly treats the incidence rate as the prevalence. (Section 3, 4.2 How Prevalence Depends on Incidence and Duration, Eq 4.10, Worked Example 4.6 and its Watch the units note, Calculator 4.6; Objective 4.2)

4. A condition causes 10 deaths at an average age where standard life expectancy is 30 remaining years, and 200 people newly develop the condition and live with it for 5 years on average, with a disability weight of 0.20. What is the total DALY burden?

200 is the YLD only (200 × 5 × 0.20). The DALY also includes the years of life lost to the 10 deaths, 10 × 30 = 300.
300 is the YLL only (10 × 30). The 200 people living with the condition also lose healthy years, so the YLD must be added.
YLL = 10 × 30 = 300 and YLD = 200 × 5 × 0.20 = 200, so DALYs = 300 + 200 = 500 healthy years lost. The DALY adds fatal and non-fatal loss on one scale.
1,000 leaves out the disability weight (200 × 5), which would count every year lived with the condition as if it were as bad as death. Weighting by 0.20 gives 200 YLD.
Correct answer: 500 DALYs. The information needed is the deaths (10) and the remaining life expectancy at the age of death (30 years) for the YLL, and the new cases (200), the average duration (5 years) and the disability weight (0.20) for the YLD. Step 1: YLL = 10 × 30 = 300 years. Step 2: YLD = 200 × 5 × 0.20 = 200 years. Step 3: DALYs = YLL + YLD = 300 + 200 = 500 healthy years lost. The tempting 1,300 leaves out the disability weight (200 × 5 = 1,000), which would treat every year lived with the condition as a year as bad as death, and the 200 and 300 options each keep only one of the two components. (Section 3, 6.1 Burden of Disease: YLLs, YLDs and DALYs, Eq 4.11 to Eq 4.13, Worked Examples 4.7 to 4.9; Objective 6.1)
A disability-adjusted life year is the sum of years of life lost and years lived with disabilityYLL = 300YLD = 200DALYs = 500 healthy years lostyears of life lost (early death)years lived with disability
Composition of disease burden for the worked example. A DALY is the sum of years of life lost to premature death (YLL) and years lived with disability (YLD), placing fatal and non-fatal loss on one scale.

5. A ministry compares two conditions in its province. Condition X causes 50 deaths a year, mostly after age 80, and little illness before death. Condition Y causes almost no deaths, but about 20,000 people are living with the moderate disability it causes at any time. A planner proposes ranking the two conditions by their annual death counts. What would DALYs add to this comparison?

Deaths are easy to count, but a death count shows nothing about the large non-fatal burden of Condition Y. DALYs add years lived with disability to years of life lost, so both can be compared.
A death does not automatically outweigh disability. Each death is weighted by the years of life it cuts off, so deaths after age 80 add few YLLs, while 20,000 people living with disability can add many YLDs.
This reverses the logic of YLL. Each death is multiplied by the remaining life expectancy at that age, so a death at 80 counts for far fewer years than a death at 20.
DALYs = YLL + YLD put fatal and non-fatal loss on one scale of healthy years lost, so Condition Y’s disability burden, invisible in a death count, can be weighed against Condition X’s late deaths. Disability weights remain a value choice.
Correct answer: DALYs put both conditions on one scale of healthy years lost. The information needed is that Condition X mainly kills, late in life, while Condition Y mainly disables. A death count makes X look like the bigger problem and Y like almost none, but DALYs add the years lived with disability to the years of life lost: with an illustrative disability weight of 0.1, Y gives about 20,000 × 0.1 = 2,000 YLDs a year, whereas 50 deaths at about age 80, with roughly 9 years of life expectancy remaining, give about 50 × 9 = 450 YLLs for X. The claim that a death always outweighs disability is wrong, because each death is weighted by the years it cuts off, so deaths in old age contribute few YLLs. DALYs still rest on value choices, such as the disability weights and the standard life expectancy. (Section 3, 6.1.3 Disability-Adjusted Life Years (DALYs), Worked Example 4.9, and 6.1.4 What DALYs Add and Where They Fall Short, with its Caveats box; Objective 6.1)

6. A residential school has 250 students, all well on 1 March and all present for the next three weeks. During those 21 days, 50 students develop a stomach illness that lasts 1 to 2 days. On the morning of 11 March, a nurse finds 10 of the 250 students ill. Which statement is correct?

The risk divides the 50 new cases by the 250 students at risk (0.20 over 21 days), and the point prevalence divides the 10 ill on 11 March by the 250 present then (0.04). A 1 to 2 day illness keeps prevalence low.
The values are swapped. 50 / 250 counts all new cases over the 21 days, which is the risk, while 10 / 250 counts the cases at one moment, which is the point prevalence.
The denominator of a prevalence is everyone present at that moment, not only the cases. 10 / 50 divides by the students who fell ill at some point, so it is not a prevalence.
Risk and prevalence describe different things: new cases over a period versus existing cases at a moment. Because prevalence also depends on duration, a short illness gives a prevalence well below the risk.
Correct answer: a risk of 0.20 and a point prevalence of 0.04, with the prevalence lower because the illness is short. The information needed is the students at risk at the start (250), the new cases over the 21 days (50), and the students ill at one moment together with everyone present then (10 of 250). The incidence risk divides all new cases over the period by the students at risk: 50 / 250 = 0.20 over 21 days. The point prevalence divides the existing cases at one moment by everyone present at that moment: 10 / 250 = 0.04 on the morning of 11 March. Because prevalence depends on both incidence and duration, an illness lasting 1 to 2 days keeps it low even when many students fall ill over three weeks. Dividing by the 50 cases is the tempting error, but the denominator of a prevalence is the whole population at that moment, not the cases. (Section 3, 4.1 Point and Period Prevalence, Eq 4.9 and the summer-camp comparison of risk and prevalence; Objective 4.1)

7. After a community barbecue, investigators collect food histories from all 200 guests and summarise them in the table below. Which food is the most likely vehicle, and what is its risk ratio?

FoodAte the food: ill / totalDid not eat the food: ill / total
Potato salad32 / 1008 / 100
Grilled corn30 / 12010 / 80
Lemonade34 / 1706 / 30
Lemonade has the most ill drinkers because most guests drank it. Its attack rate is the same among drinkers and non-drinkers (34 / 170 = 6 / 30 = 0.20), a risk ratio of 1.0.
The corn attack rates and its risk ratio of 2.0 are right, but potato salad has a stronger association, with a risk ratio of 4.0, so corn is not the most likely vehicle.
Potato salad is the right food, but 0.08 / 0.32 puts the non-eaters on top and reverses the reference group. The risk ratio divides the attack rate among those who ate it by the rate among those who did not.
Attack rates of 32 / 100 = 0.32 among eaters and 8 / 100 = 0.08 among non-eaters give a risk ratio of 4.0, the strongest association of any food in the table.
Correct answer: potato salad, with a risk ratio of 4.0. The information needed is, for each food, the number ill and the total among those who ate it and among those who did not. Step 1: attack rate = ill ÷ all in that group, one food at a time: potato salad 32 / 100 = 0.32 against 8 / 100 = 0.08; corn 30 / 120 = 0.25 against 10 / 80 = 0.125; lemonade 34 / 170 = 0.20 against 6 / 30 = 0.20. Step 2: risk ratio = attack rate among those who ate the food ÷ attack rate among those who did not: 4.0 for potato salad, 2.0 for corn and 1.0 for lemonade, so the potato salad has by far the strongest association. Lemonade is tempting because it has the most ill drinkers, but that count reflects how many guests drank it, and its attack rate is the same whether or not guests drank it; putting the non-eaters on top reverses the reference group and gives 0.25. (Section 3, card Attack Rate in 5.2.1 and the Attack rate tab in 5.2.2, Eq 4.14, Worked Example 4.10 and Calculator 4.10; Objective 5.2)

8. During an outbreak of hand, foot and mouth disease, 15 households each have one primary case, a child infected at a day-care centre. The 15 households contain 75 people in total, including the primary cases. Over the next two weeks, 21 further household members become ill. What is the secondary attack rate, and what does it measure?

36 / 75 counts the primary cases in both numerator and denominator. The primary cases were infected at day care and cannot become secondary cases, so they are removed from both.
Contacts at risk = 75 − 15 = 60, because the primary cases were infected elsewhere. SAR = 21 / 60 = 0.35: 35% of household contacts caught the infection, a measure of person-to-person spread.
21 / 75 keeps the 15 primary cases in the denominator, although they could not become secondary cases, so it understates the spread within households.
21 / 15 divides by the primary cases, which is not the people at risk, and a secondary attack rate measures how easily infection spreads, not how severe the illness is.
Correct answer: 21 / 60 = 0.35. The information needed is the number of secondary cases (21), the number of people in the households (75) and the number of primary cases (15). Step 1: contacts at risk = 75 − 15 = 60, because the primary cases were infected elsewhere and cannot become secondary cases. Step 2: SAR = 21 / 60 = 0.35, which is the same as (all cases − primary cases) ÷ (people in the households − primary cases) = (36 − 15) / (75 − 15). In plain words, 35% of the household contacts of a first case became ill, which measures how easily the infection spreads from person to person. The tempting 21 / 75 keeps the primary cases in the denominator and so understates the spread. (Section 3, card Secondary Attack Rate in 5.2.1 and the Secondary attack rate tab in 5.2.2, Eq 4.15 and Worked Example 4.11; Objective 5.2)

9. A town of 20,000 residents has a summer outbreak of hepatitis A in which 66 people become ill, and 1 of them dies within 60 days of diagnosis. A local news report states that “hepatitis A killed 1.5% of the town this summer.” Which response is correct?

1 / 66 divides the death by the people who had hepatitis A, which is the case fatality rate, a measure of severity. A mortality rate divides deaths by the whole population at risk.
Changing the units does not fix the error. The denominator, 66 cases, is the problem: a mortality rate needs the person-time of the whole population, not the cases.
1 / 66 = 1.5% is the case fatality rate, describing severity among the 66 cases. The risk of dying for residents uses the whole population, roughly 1 death among 20,000, or about 5 per 100,000 over the summer.
Proportional mortality divides by all deaths in the town, so it gives only hepatitis A’s share of deaths and says nothing about a resident’s risk of dying. The report’s error is calling a case fatality rate a mortality rate.
Correct answer: the 1.5% is a case fatality rate, not a mortality rate. The information needed is what each measure divides by. The case fatality rate divides the deaths by the people who have the disease (1 / 66 = 0.015), so it describes severity among the cases. The cause-specific mortality rate divides the deaths from the disease by the person-time of the whole population at risk; loosely, 1 death among 20,000 residents is about 5 per 100,000 over the summer, far below 1.5%. Calling the case fatality rate a mortality rate is the error in the report, and changing its units does not fix the denominator; proportional mortality gives only the share of all deaths that hepatitis A caused and says nothing about any resident’s risk of dying. (Section 3, 5.1 Mortality Rates and the Case fatality rate tab in 5.2.2, Eq 4.16; Objectives 5.1 and 5.2)

✦ Pass the knowledge check with 100% to continue

Section 4

Standardisation & Confidence Intervals

⏱ Estimated reading time: 15 minutes

Section 4 of 4

Standardisation & Confidence Intervals

Removing age-structure confounding before comparing populations, and quantifying the precision of any estimate.

The problem

Why crude rates mislead

Population A Young structure Crude rate: low Age-specific rates identical to B Population B Old structure Crude rate: high Age-specific rates identical to A After standardisation A = B age confounding removed
Method 1

Indirect standardisation and the SMR

Standardised Morbidity Ratio
\[ \color{#0B7B6B}{\text{SMR}} = \frac{\color{#C2410C}{A}}{\color{#6D28D9}{E}} = \frac{\color{#C2410C}{\text{observed cases}}}{\color{#6D28D9}{\text{expected cases}}} \]
SMR standardised morbidity ratioA observed cases in the study populationE cases expected from standard rates

Expected cases = study population age-specific person-time × standard population age-specific rates.

SMR > 1: more disease than expected. SMR < 1: less disease than expected. The indirectly standardised rate = standard rate × SMR.

Best choice when: study population's own stratum-specific rates are based on small samples.

Method 2

Direct standardisation

Directly standardised rate (Eq 4.9)
\[ \color{#0B7B6B}{I_{\text{dir}}} = \sum_j \color{#C2410C}{T^s_j} \times \color{#6D28D9}{I_j} \]
I_dir directly standardised rateTˢⱼ standard-population weight in stratum jIⱼ study rate in stratum j

Where \(T^s_j\) = proportion of the standard population in stratum \(j\) and \(I_j\) = observed rate in the study population for that stratum.

Best choice when: study stratum-specific rates are reliable (large enough samples). The standard: WHO World Standard population (Ahmad et al., 2001) for global comparisons; national census population for within-country work.

Precision

Standard errors and confidence intervals

SE for a proportion (Eq 4.10)
\[ \color{#0B7B6B}{\text{SE}(p)} = \sqrt{\frac{\color{#C2410C}{p}(1-\color{#C2410C}{p})}{\color{#6D28D9}{N}}} \]
SE(p) standard error of the proportionp estimated proportionN sample size
SE for an incidence rate (Eq 4.11)
\[ \color{#0B7B6B}{\text{SE}(I)} = \frac{\sqrt{\color{#C2410C}{A}}}{\color{#6D28D9}{t}} \]
SE(I) standard error of the rateA number of eventst person-time at risk
95% Confidence Interval (Eq 4.12)
\[ \color{#0B7B6B}{\hat{\theta}} \pm \color{#C2410C}{1.96} \times \color{#6D28D9}{\text{SE}(\hat{\theta})} \]
θ̂ point estimate1.96 z-value for 95% confidenceSE standard error of the estimate

Use exact binomial (for proportions) or Poisson (for rates) intervals when samples are small or frequencies are extreme.

Carry forward

What to take into the final review

  • Indirect standardisation uses standard rates → study structure → SMR.
  • Direct standardisation uses study rates → standard structure → comparable rate.
  • To halve CI width, quadruple sample size (SE ∝ \(1/\sqrt{N}\)).
  • Use exact intervals (binomial, Poisson) for small samples or extreme frequencies.

Overview

Sections 1 to 3 showed how to compute measures of disease frequency from raw data. This section addresses the problem that arises as soon as those measures are compared: a crude rate from one population almost never compares fairly with a crude rate from another, because populations differ in age structure and other characteristics that affect disease occurrence. Standardisation is the technique for making the comparison fair, in an indirect form that produces the standardised morbidity ratio and a direct form that re-weights each population to a common structure. Standard errors and confidence intervals then quantify how precise any estimated proportion or rate is.

Learning Objectives

  • 7.1 Explain why crude rates can mislead when populations differ in age structure, and why standardisation is then necessary.
  • 7.2 Distinguish indirect from direct standardisation, and calculate and interpret a standardised morbidity ratio and a directly standardised rate.
  • 7.3 Calculate standard errors and approximate 95% confidence intervals for a proportion and a rate, and explain when an exact interval is preferable.

7.1 Why Crude Rates Can Mislead

When comparing disease frequency between populations, differences in host characteristics (for example, age, sex or geographic location) can confound the comparison. A population with more elderly individuals will, for example, naturally have higher rates of many diseases, simply because those diseases are more common at older ages. Standardisation adjusts for these confounders, allowing for fairer comparisons (Ahmad et al., 2001).

The reason lies in how a crude rate, the overall rate for a whole population, is built, and it is the key idea of this section.

Key Concept: Confounding by Host Factors

A population can be divided into strata based on one or more host characteristics, for example into age groups. The overall frequency of disease depends on both the size of each stratum (Hj) and the stratum-specific rates or risks (Ij or Rj). By this we mean that the crude rate is a weighted average of the stratum-specific rates, in which each stratum counts in proportion to its share of the population. A stratum with a high rate, such as the oldest age group, therefore pulls the crude rate up more strongly when it makes up a larger share of the population. As a result, if two populations have different age distributions, their crude rates may differ even if their age-specific rates are identical, because the same rates are being averaged with different weights. Standardisation removes this confounding effect by giving both populations the same set of weights.

A population whose age-specific rates are all lower can even have the higher crude rate if more of its people fall in the oldest stratum, and Worked Example 4.16 in 7.2 shows exactly this pattern. Standardisation can be carried out indirectly or directly, and the next subsection describes each method in turn.

7.2 Indirect and Direct Standardisation

The two methods swap the roles of the two populations involved. Indirect standardisation applies the rates of a standard population to the structure of the study population, whereas direct standardisation applies the study population's own rates to the structure of a standard population.

7.2.1 Indirect Standardisation

Indirect standardisation uses standard (reference) population rates applied to the study population’s structure to calculate the expected number of cases. By this we mean the number of cases the study population would have had if its people, with their own ages, had experienced the same age-specific rates as the reference population. This expectation already takes the study population's age structure into account, so an older population will have more expected cases than a younger one. The method then compares the cases actually observed with that expectation in the standardised morbidity (or mortality) ratio, SMR = observed ÷ expected. If the two numbers are equal, the population is doing exactly as well as its age structure predicts; if more cases are observed than expected, the excess cannot be explained by age, and some other factor, or chance, must account for it. The procedure has three steps. Expand each step below in order to see what it involves, then compare it with the matching equation that follows.

Step 1: Obtain Standard Rates▼

Obtain a set of stratum-specific rates (Isj) from a reference or standard population. For example, national age-specific disease rates.

Step 2: Calculate Expected Cases▼

Apply those standard rates to the study population’s time-at-risk in each stratum. The expected adjusted rate (Ie) equals the sum of Hj × Isj, where Hj is the proportion of the study population in stratum j. By this we mean that each standard rate is weighted by how much of the study population falls in that stratum, so a population with many older people gives more weight to the higher rates of the older strata. The result is the overall rate the study population would be expected to have if it experienced the standard rates. The expected number of cases is then E = T × Ie, where T is the total time at risk, which simply converts that expected rate into a number of cases.

Step 3: Compute the SMR▼

The Standardised Morbidity (or Mortality) Ratio (SMR) is the ratio of observed cases (A) to expected cases (E): SMR = A / E.

An SMR > 1 means more cases were observed than expected; SMR < 1 means fewer. The indirect standardised rate is: Iind = Is × SMR, where Is is the overall rate in the standard population.

Equation 4.18 gives the expected cases from step 2, Equation 4.19 the SMR from step 3, and Equation 4.20 the indirectly standardised rate.

Expected cases
\[ {\color{#6D28D9}{E}} = {\color{#1D4ED8}{T}} \times \sum_j {\color{#1D4ED8}{H_j}} \times {\color{#BE185D}{Is_j}} \]Eq 4.18
the expected number of cases equals the total person-time in the study population times the sum, across strata, of the share of that person-time in stratum j times the standard population’s rate in stratum j.
Standardised morbidity (or mortality) ratio
\[ {\color{#0B7B6B}{\text{SMR}}} = \dfrac{{\color{#C2410C}{A}}}{{\color{#6D28D9}{E}}} \]Eq 4.19
the SMR equals the number of cases observed divided by the number of cases expected from the standard rates.
Indirectly standardised rate
\[ {\color{#0B7B6B}{I_{\text{ind}}}} = {\color{#047857}{Is}} \times {\color{#0B7B6B}{\text{SMR}}} \]Eq 4.20
the indirectly standardised rate equals the overall rate in the standard population multiplied by the SMR.

Worked Example 4.15 applies the three steps to a mining town, with the expected cases in each age stratum set out in Table 4.2; watch how the town's own person-time is combined with the provincial rates.

Worked Example 4.15: Indirect Standardisation

A mining town contributes 8,000 person-years of observation across three age strata, and 60 new cases of a respiratory disease are observed (A = 60). Provincial age-specific rates serve as the standard, and the overall provincial rate is 7.25 per 1,000 person-years (Is).

Table 4.2. Person-years, standard rates and expected cases of respiratory disease in each age stratum of the mining town.

Age stratumTown person-years (Tj)Share (Hj)Standard rate per 1,000 (Isj)Expected cases (Tj × Isj)
Under 404,0000.50028
40 to 593,0000.375824
60 and over1,0000.1252525
Total8,0001.00057
  • Expected rate: Ie = (0.500 × 2) + (0.375 × 8) + (0.125 × 25) = 7.125 per 1,000 person-years, so E = 8,000 × 7.125 / 1,000 = 57 expected cases.
  • SMR = 60 / 57 = 1.053, so the town recorded about 5% more cases than the provincial rates predict for a population with its age structure.
  • Indirectly standardised rate: Iind = 7.25 × 1.053 = 7.63 per 1,000 person-years.

The crude rate in the town is 60 / 8,000 = 7.50 per 1,000 person-years. It is slightly lower than the standardised rate because the town has a smaller share of older residents than the standard population.

The worked example shows that the town recorded slightly more cases than its age structure predicts, and that its crude rate understates its standardised rate. Calculator 4.14 carries out the three steps for other values.

An SMR describes one population at a time, and this matters when several populations are standardised against the same reference. Suppose three geographic regions with different age distributions report data on GI disease. Region 1 has a crude risk of 0.136, Region 2 has 0.125, and Region 3 has 0.088. After indirect standardisation, the SMRs are 1.12, 1.03, and 0.74 respectively. An SMR of 1.12 means Region 1 recorded about 12% more cases than the reference age-specific rates predict for a group of its age structure, while an SMR of 0.74 means Region 3 recorded about 26% fewer. Region 1’s observed risk was therefore higher than expected and Region 3’s lower, and it is worth asking what this suggests about the role of age distribution compared with true disease risk in these regions. What the SMRs cannot do is order the regions against one another.

Do Not Rank SMRs Against One Another

Each SMR uses its own region’s age structure as the weights, so SMRs from different regions are not standardised to a common population and should not be ranked against one another. Each one says only whether that region recorded more or fewer cases than the reference rates predict for its own age structure. Direct standardisation to a common standard population is the usual way to compare the regions with one another.

Indirect standardisation compares observed with expected cases using the study population's own structure. Direct standardisation reverses the roles of the study and standard populations.

7.2.2 Direct Standardisation

Direct standardisation uses the study population’s stratum-specific rates applied to a standard population distribution (Equation 4.21).

Directly standardised rate
\[ {\color{#0B7B6B}{I_{\text{dir}}}} = \sum {\color{#C2410C}{Ts_j}} \times {\color{#6D28D9}{I_j}} \]Eq 4.21
the directly standardised rate sums, across strata, the standard-population weight for stratum j times the study rate in stratum j.

Here Tsj is the proportion of person-time in the standard population assigned to stratum j, and Ij is the observed rate in the study population for that stratum.

In plain terms, the directly standardised rate is a weighted average of the study population's own stratum-specific rates, but using the standard population's proportions as the weights. It answers a single question: what would this population's overall rate be if it had the age structure of the standard population? Because every population is re-weighted to the same structure, their standardised rates can be laid side by side and compared directly. Worked Example 4.16 applies Equation 4.21 to two regions with different age structures, the situation described in 7.1; compare the crude and the standardised rates of the two regions.

Worked Example 4.16: Direct Standardisation

Two regions report the rates of a chronic disease shown in Table 4.3. Region A contributes 30,000, 15,000, and 5,000 person-years to the three age strata, and Region B, which is older, contributes 10,000 person-years to each. The standard population places 55% of its person-time under age 40, 30% at ages 40 to 64, and 15% at age 65 and over.

Table 4.3. Standard population weights and age-specific rates of a chronic disease in Region A and Region B.

Age stratumStandard weight (Tsj)Region A rate per 1,000 (Ij)Region B rate per 1,000 (Ij)
Under 400.551.00.9
40 to 640.304.03.8
65 and over0.1512.011.0
  • Region A: Idir = (0.55 × 1.0) + (0.30 × 4.0) + (0.15 × 12.0) = 0.55 + 1.20 + 1.80 = 3.55 per 1,000 person-years.
  • Region B: Idir = (0.55 × 0.9) + (0.30 × 3.8) + (0.15 × 11.0) = 0.495 + 1.14 + 1.65 = 3.29 per 1,000 person-years.

Region B has the higher crude rate (157 cases in 30,000 person-years, or 5.2 per 1,000, against 150 cases in 50,000 person-years, or 3.0 per 1,000, in Region A) because a third of its person-time falls in the oldest stratum. Its rate is lower than Region A’s in every age stratum, however, and once both regions are given the same age structure its standardised rate is the lower of the two.

The worked example shows that standardisation can reverse a crude comparison when the populations differ in age structure. Calculator 4.15 carries out the calculation for other values.

7.2.3 Choosing Between Indirect and Direct Standardisation

Indirect standardisation is useful when stratum-specific rates for the study population are unavailable or based on small samples, and it produces the SMR. The reason is that it borrows its rates from the large standard population and needs only the study population's person-time in each stratum and its total number of cases. For example, a small town may record only two or three cases among its oldest residents, too few to give a trustworthy age-specific rate, yet it can still be compared with provincial rates. Direct standardisation, by contrast, applies the study’s own stratum-specific rates to a standard distribution, which is why it is the method for comparing several populations with one another: every population is placed on the same structure. A drawback is that all stratum-specific rates receive equal weight regardless of precision. By this we mean that the weight each rate receives is set by the standard population, not by how many cases lie behind it, so a rate based on a handful of cases in a small stratum can still move the standardised rate considerably. Both methods are commonly used in practice. Age standardisation of cancer statistics is one well-known application (e.g., rates published by cancer registries); the WHO World Standard population (Ahmad et al., 2001) is the most widely used reference structure for direct standardisation in global health comparisons. See also Standardized mortality ratio (Wikipedia).

Standardisation makes rates comparable across populations, and any estimated proportion or rate, standardised or not, also needs a measure of its precision.

7.3 Standard Errors and Confidence Intervals

When estimating any proportion or rate, we need a measure of precision. Most estimates come from a sample or a limited period of observation, so a different sample of the same population would have given a slightly different answer purely by chance. The standard error (SE) quantifies this uncertainty around our estimate. By this we mean that it describes how much the estimate would typically vary from one sample to another: a small standard error means repeated samples would give similar answers, and a large one means they could differ considerably. For example, a prevalence based on 40 people will usually have a much larger standard error than one based on 4,000. A confidence interval built from the standard error then turns this idea into a range of values compatible with the data, which is easier to report and interpret than the standard error itself.

7.3.1 Standard Error of a Proportion

The standard error of a proportion depends on the proportion itself and on the sample size, as Equation 4.22 shows.

Standard error of a proportion
\[ {\color{#0B7B6B}{\text{SE}(p)}} = \sqrt{\dfrac{{\color{#C2410C}{p}}(1 - {\color{#C2410C}{p}})}{\color{#6D28D9}{N}}} \]Eq 4.22
the standard error of a proportion is the square root of the proportion times one minus the proportion, divided by the sample size.

Here p is the estimated proportion and N is the sample size, and p enters as a decimal rather than a percentage. Worked Example 4.17 applies Equation 4.22 to a survey estimate of high blood pressure; follow each step inside the square root.

Worked Example 4.17: Standard Error of a Proportion

In a survey of 400 adults, 88 report that a health professional has told them they have high blood pressure, so p = 88 / 400 = 0.22.

SE(p) = √[0.22 × (1 − 0.22) / 400] = √(0.1716 / 400) = √0.000429 = 0.0207.

The worked example gives a standard error of about two percentage points for a sample of 400. Calculator 4.16 performs the calculation for other values.

7.3.2 Standard Error of an Incidence Rate

For an incidence rate, the standard error depends on the number of cases and the person-time at risk, as Equation 4.23 shows.

Standard error of a rate
\[ {\color{#0B7B6B}{\text{SE}(I)}} = \dfrac{\sqrt{\color{#C2410C}{A}}}{\color{#6D28D9}{t}} \]Eq 4.23
the standard error of a rate is the square root of the number of events divided by the person-time at risk.

Here A is the number of cases and t is the total person-time at risk, so the standard error carries the same units as the rate. Worked Example 4.18 applies Equation 4.23 to a cohort with 2,500 person-years of follow-up; note that the square root is taken of the number of cases only.

Worked Example 4.18: Standard Error of a Rate

A cohort accumulates 2,500 person-years of follow-up, during which 40 new cases occur, so I = 40 / 2,500 = 0.016 cases per person-year (16 per 1,000 person-years).

SE(I) = √40 / 2,500 = 6.32 / 2,500 = 0.00253 cases per person-year.

The worked example shows that the precision of a rate depends on the number of cases observed. Calculator 4.17 performs the calculation for other values.

7.3.3 Confidence Intervals

An approximate confidence interval extends a multiple of the standard error on either side of the estimate, as in Equation 4.24.

Confidence interval for an estimate
\[ {\color{#0B7B6B}{\theta}} - {\color{#C2410C}{Z_\alpha}}\,{\color{#6D28D9}{\text{SE}}} \quad\text{to}\quad {\color{#0B7B6B}{\theta}} + {\color{#C2410C}{Z_\alpha}}\,{\color{#6D28D9}{\text{SE}}} \]Eq 4.24
a confidence interval runs from the point estimate minus to plus a z-multiplier for the confidence level times the standard error.

Here θ is the estimate and Zα is the appropriate percentile of the standard normal distribution (e.g., 1.96 for a 95% CI) (Rothman, 2012). The multiplier sets the level of confidence: a larger multiplier, such as 2.58 for a 99% interval, produces a wider interval in exchange for greater confidence. Because the sample size sits under a square root in both standard errors, quadrupling the sample size halves the width of the interval. This means that precision improves more slowly than sample size grows; for example, going from 400 to 1,600 participants halves the interval, but halving it again would require 6,400. Worked Example 4.19 applies Equation 4.24 to the estimates from Worked Examples 4.17 and 4.18; check that both limits of the rate's interval keep the rate's units.

Worked Example 4.19: 95% Confidence Intervals

Using the two earlier estimates (Worked Example 4.17 and Worked Example 4.18) and Zα = 1.96:

  • Proportion: 0.22 ± 1.96 × 0.0207 = 0.22 ± 0.041, giving a 95% CI from 0.179 to 0.261 (17.9% to 26.1%).
  • Rate: 0.016 ± 1.96 × 0.00253 = 0.016 ± 0.0050, giving a 95% CI from 0.0110 to 0.0210 cases per person-year (11.0 to 21.0 per 1,000 person-years).

The worked example shows how one standard error turns each point estimate into a range. Calculator 4.18 performs the calculation for other values.

These intervals rest on a normal approximation, which does not always hold.

When Approximate Intervals Mislead

In small samples, or when the frequency of disease is very low or very high, approximate CIs can produce misleading results (e.g., negative lower limits). The reason is that the approximate interval is always symmetrical, extending the same distance above and below the estimate, whereas a proportion cannot fall below 0 or rise above 1 and a rate cannot be negative. For example, if 1 person in a sample of 50 has a disease, p = 0.02 and its standard error is about 0.020, so subtracting 1.96 standard errors gives a lower limit below zero, which is impossible. In such cases, exact CIs based on the binomial distribution (for proportions) or the Poisson distribution (for rates) are more appropriate.

This section has shown why crude rates can mislead, how indirect and direct standardisation make rates comparable across populations, and how standard errors and confidence intervals express the precision of an estimate. The key takeaways below summarise these points.

Key Takeaways

  • 7.1 A crude rate, the overall rate for a whole population, depends on two things: the rate within each stratum (each age group, for example) and how much of the population falls into each stratum. Because many diseases become more common with age, an older population can have a higher crude rate even when its age-specific rates are the same as, or lower than, those of a younger population. In Worked Example 4.16, Region B has the higher crude rate (5.2 against 3.0 per 1,000 person-years) only because a third of its person-time falls in the oldest age group; its rate is lower than Region A's in every age stratum. This is confounding by host characteristics, and standardisation adjusts for it so that rates can be compared fairly. Whenever a question compares crude rates from populations with different age structures, look at the stratum-specific rates first and treat the crude comparison with caution until the rates have been standardised.
  • 7.2 Indirect and direct standardisation both deal with differences in population structure, but they swap which population supplies the rates. Indirect standardisation applies a standard population's stratum-specific rates to the study population's own person-time to obtain the expected number of cases (E), then compares the observed number (A) with it as the SMR = A / E; in Worked Example 4.15, 60 / 57 = 1.05, so the mining town recorded about 5% more cases than the provincial rates predict for a population with its age structure. Direct standardisation works the other way round: it applies the study population's own stratum-specific rates to a standard population's weights, giving a weighted average that answers the question "what would this population's rate be if it had the standard age structure?" Choose indirect standardisation when the study population is small or its stratum-specific rates are unavailable or unstable, and direct standardisation when you want to compare several populations with one another. Read an SMR above 1 as more cases than expected and below 1 as fewer, and do not rank SMRs from different populations against each other, because each one is weighted by its own population's structure.
  • 7.3 Every estimated proportion or rate needs a measure of its precision, and the standard error provides it: SE(p) = √[p(1 − p)/N] for a proportion, and SE(I) = √A/t for a rate, where A is the number of cases and t the person-time at risk. An approximate 95% confidence interval is the estimate ± 1.96 × SE; for 88 of 400 adults with high blood pressure, 0.22 ± 1.96 × 0.0207 gives an interval from 0.179 to 0.261. Work with decimals rather than percentages inside the square root, and give both limits of a rate's interval in the rate's units. Because the sample size sits under a square root, quadrupling it halves the width of the interval. When the sample is small or the frequency is very low or very high, the approximate interval can mislead (for example, by giving a negative lower limit), so an exact binomial interval (for a proportion) or Poisson interval (for a rate) is preferable.
Knowledge Check: this section

1. A small farming town recorded 30 new cases of skin cancer over five years. Applying provincial age-specific rates to the town’s person-time in each age group gives 20 expected cases. Which interpretation is correct?

This puts expected over observed and reverses the ratio. SMR = observed ÷ expected = 30 / 20 = 1.5, so the town recorded more cases than expected, not fewer.
SMR = 1.5 is right, but each SMR is weighted by its own town’s age structure, so SMRs from different towns are not standardised to a common population and should not be ranked against one another.
The SMR is a ratio, not a difference, and a ratio of counts has no units. 30 − 20 = 10 extra cases is an excess count, not an SMR or a rate per 1,000 person-years.
SMR = A / E = 30 / 20 = 1.5: the town recorded about 50% more cases than the provincial age-specific rates predict for a population with its own age structure.
Correct answer: SMR = 1.5, about 50% more cases than expected. The information needed is the observed cases (A = 30) and the expected cases (E = 20), which come from applying the standard (provincial) rates to the town’s own person-time in each age group. SMR = A / E = 30 / 20 = 1.5; a value above 1 means more cases than expected, here about 50% more. Ranking towns is the tempting misreading: each SMR is weighted by its own town’s age structure, so SMRs from different towns are not standardised to a common population and should not be ranked against one another. Putting expected over observed reverses the ratio, and a ratio of counts has no units. (Section 4, 7.2.1 Indirect Standardisation, steps 1 to 3, Eq 4.19, Worked Example 4.15 and the comparison of GI disease across three regions; Objective 7.2)

2. An analyst wants to report cancer incidence for (i) a remote community of 900 people, where most age groups recorded 0 to 2 cases, and (ii) the province’s five largest cities, each with hundreds of cases in every age group, and to compare the five cities with one another. Which plan is best?

With 0 to 2 cases per age group, the community’s own rates are unstable, so indirect standardisation applies stable standard rates to its person-time to give an SMR. The cities have reliable rates, so direct standardisation to one standard lets them be compared.
Direct standardisation would rely on the community’s own age-specific rates, and with 0 to 2 cases per age group those rates are too unstable to standardise reliably.
Standardisation addresses differences in age structure, not in population size. Crude rates can mislead when age structures differ, whatever the size of each population.
SMRs should not be ranked against one another, because each uses its own population’s structure as the weights. Cities with stable rates suit direct standardisation, whose rates can be compared directly.
Correct answer: indirect standardisation for the community and direct standardisation for the cities. The information needed is how many cases support each population’s age-specific rates and whether populations are to be compared with one another. With 0 to 2 cases per age group, the community’s own rates are unstable, so indirect standardisation borrows stable standard rates, applies them to the community’s person-time and gives an SMR. The cities have reliable age-specific rates, so direct standardisation applies each city’s own rates to the same standard population, and the resulting rates can be compared directly. Ranking SMRs is tempting, but each SMR uses its own population’s structure as the weights, and standardisation is about differences in age structure, not in population size. (Section 4, 7.2.1 Indirect Standardisation and its box Do Not Rank SMRs Against One Another, and 7.2.3 Choosing Between Indirect and Direct Standardisation; Objective 7.2)

3. In a survey of 900 adults, 180 report that they have been diagnosed with asthma. What is the approximate 95% confidence interval for the proportion with asthma?

0.20 ± 0.0133 leaves out the 1.96 multiplier, so it gives an interval narrower than 95%. With SE = 0.0133, the 95% interval is 0.20 ± 1.96 × 0.0133.
This interval leaves out the square root: 1.96 × 0.20 × 0.80 / 900 gives a margin of about 0.0003, far too small. SE(p) = √[p(1 − p) / N] = 0.0133.
p = 180 / 900 = 0.20, SE(p) = √[0.20 × 0.80 / 900] = 0.0133, and 0.20 ± 1.96 × 0.0133 = 0.20 ± 0.026, giving 0.174 to 0.226.
This uses the 180 cases as N, which inflates the standard error and widens the interval. N is the sample size, 900 adults, not the number with asthma.
Correct answer: 0.174 to 0.226. The information needed is the number with asthma (180), the sample size (N = 900) and the multiplier for 95% confidence (1.96). Step 1: p = 180 / 900 = 0.20. Step 2: SE(p) = √[0.20 × 0.80 / 900] = √0.000178 = 0.0133. Step 3: 0.20 ± 1.96 × 0.0133 = 0.20 ± 0.026, so the interval runs from 0.174 to 0.226 (17.4% to 22.6%). Using the 180 cases as the sample size gives the too-wide 0.142 to 0.258, leaving out the square root gives the far-too-narrow 0.1997 to 0.2003, and leaving out the 1.96 gives 0.187 to 0.213. (Section 4, 7.3.1 Standard Error of a Proportion and 7.3.3 Confidence Intervals, Eq 4.22 and Eq 4.24, Worked Examples 4.17 and 4.19, Calculator 4.18; Objective 7.3)

4. Two districts report deaths from heart disease, summarised in the table below. A colleague notes that District B’s crude death rate is about twice District A’s and concludes that heart disease is more deadly in District B. Which response is correct?

Age groupStandard weight (Tsj)District A rate per 1,000 person-yearsDistrict A share of person-timeDistrict B rate per 1,000 person-yearsDistrict B share of person-time
Under 650.8020.9010.50
65 and over0.20200.10150.50
The crude rates are right, but they are weighted by each district’s own age structure. District B’s rates are lower in both age groups, so its higher crude rate reflects its older population.
District B’s rates are lower in both age groups, and its crude rate is higher only because half its person-time is in the older group. Applying both districts’ rates to the same weights gives 5.6 for A and 3.8 for B.
An older population explains District B’s higher crude rate, but it does not make heart disease more deadly there. At every age District B’s rate is lower.
A difference in age structure is the reason to standardise, not a reason to abandon the comparison. Direct standardisation applies both districts’ rates to the same weights so they can be compared.
Correct answer: the colleague is wrong. The information needed is each district’s age-specific rates, its share of person-time in each age group, and the standard weights. Step 1: a crude rate weights the age-specific rates by the district’s own structure: A = 0.90 × 2 + 0.10 × 20 = 3.8 and B = 0.50 × 1 + 0.50 × 15 = 8.0 per 1,000 person-years. Step 2: B’s rates are lower in both age groups, so its higher crude rate comes from its older population, not from a higher risk at any age. Step 3: direct standardisation applies each district’s rates to the same weights: A = 0.80 × 2 + 0.20 × 20 = 5.6 and B = 0.80 × 1 + 0.20 × 15 = 3.8 per 1,000 person-years. An older population explains B’s higher crude rate but does not make the disease more deadly there, and a difference in age structure is the reason to standardise, not a reason to abandon the comparison. (Section 4, 7.1 Why Crude Rates Can Mislead and its box Key Concept: Confounding by Host Factors, 7.2.2 Direct Standardisation, Eq 4.21 and Worked Example 4.16; Objectives 7.1 and 7.2)

5. Over five years, the residents of a district contribute 20,000 person-years at risk, and 50 new cases of a chronic respiratory disease are diagnosed, a rate of 2.5 per 1,000 person-years. What is the approximate 95% confidence interval for this rate?

2.5 ± 1 × SE leaves out the 1.96 multiplier, so the interval is too narrow for 95% confidence. The 95% interval is 2.5 ± 1.96 × 0.35 per 1,000 person-years.
This takes the square root of the rate instead of the number of cases, which gives an impossible negative lower limit. SE(I) = √A / t, using the 50 cases.
I = 50 / 20,000 = 0.0025 per person-year, SE(I) = √50 / 20,000 = 0.00035, and 0.0025 ± 1.96 × 0.00035 gives 0.0018 to 0.0032 per person-year, or 1.8 to 3.2 per 1,000 person-years.
The limits are numerically right per person-year, but a rate keeps its person-time units. Calling it a proportion with no units confuses an incidence rate with a risk.
Correct answer: 1.8 to 3.2 per 1,000 person-years. The information needed is the number of cases (A = 50), the person-time (t = 20,000 person-years) and the multiplier for 95% confidence (1.96). Step 1: I = 50 / 20,000 = 0.0025 cases per person-year. Step 2: SE(I) = √A / t = 7.07 / 20,000 = 0.00035. Step 3: 0.0025 ± 1.96 × 0.00035 = 0.0025 ± 0.0007, or 0.0018 to 0.0032 cases per person-year, which is 1.8 to 3.2 per 1,000 person-years. Leaving out the 1.96 gives the too-narrow 2.15 to 2.85, taking the square root of the rate instead of the number of cases gives an impossible negative limit, and a rate keeps its person-time units, so it is not a proportion. (Section 4, 7.3.2 Standard Error of an Incidence Rate and 7.3.3 Confidence Intervals, Eq 4.23 and Eq 4.24, Worked Examples 4.18 and 4.19; Objective 7.3)

6. The same district contributes 10,000 person-years under age 40, 6,000 at ages 40 to 64 and 4,000 at age 65 and over, and records 50 cases. The provincial rates in these age groups are 0.5, 2.5 and 5.0 per 1,000 person-years, and the overall provincial rate is 2.7. A colleague notes that the district’s crude rate (2.5 per 1,000 person-years) is below the provincial rate and concludes that the district has no excess of the disease. Which response is correct?

Expected cases = 10,000 × 0.5 + 6,000 × 2.5 + 4,000 × 5.0, each per 1,000, giving 5 + 15 + 20 = 40, so SMR = 50 / 40 = 1.25. The district’s young age structure pulls its crude rate below the provincial rate.
A crude rate below the provincial rate does not mean fewer cases than expected when age structures differ. Half the district’s person-time is under age 40, where the disease is rare, so its expected count is only 40.
This puts expected over observed and inverts the SMR. SMR = observed ÷ expected = 50 / 40 = 1.25, an excess of about 25%, not a deficit.
Different age structures are the reason to standardise, not a reason to give up. Indirect standardisation applies the provincial rates to the district’s person-time, allowing the comparison.
Correct answer: disagree, because the SMR is 1.25. The information needed is the district’s person-time in each age group, the provincial rate in each group and the observed cases. Step 1: expected cases = 10,000 × 0.5 / 1,000 + 6,000 × 2.5 / 1,000 + 4,000 × 5.0 / 1,000 = 5 + 15 + 20 = 40. Step 2: SMR = observed ÷ expected = 50 / 40 = 1.25. Half of the district’s person-time falls under age 40, where the disease is least common, so at the provincial rates its crude rate would be only 40 / 20,000 = 2.0 per 1,000 person-years; the observed 2.5 is therefore an excess once age is taken into account. Putting expected over observed inverts the SMR, and a difference in age structure is the reason to standardise rather than a reason to abandon the comparison. (Section 4, 7.1 Why Crude Rates Can Mislead and 7.2.1 Indirect Standardisation, Eq 4.18 and Eq 4.19; Objectives 7.1 and 7.2)

✦ Pass the knowledge check with 100% to continue

Section 5

Final Review & Assessment

⏱ Estimated time: 20 minutes

Bringing It All Together

This lesson assembled the basic numerical vocabulary of epidemiology (Porta, 2014; Rothman, 2012). You moved from the four mathematical forms (counts, proportions, odds, and rates) through incidence (risk and rate), into prevalence and mortality, then into burden-of-disease metrics (GBD 2019 Diseases and Injuries Collaborators, 2020), and finally into standardisation (Ahmad et al., 2001) and the precision around the resulting estimates. Every comparison between groups, places or time periods depends on picking the right denominator for the question being asked.

The takeaways below pull these threads together. The decisions in this lesson are usually the difference between a defensible comparison and a misleading one: prevalence and incidence answer different questions; risks and rates require different denominators; and crude rates can hide more than they reveal whenever populations differ in age structure or other strong confounders.

Key Takeaways from this lesson

  1. You can tell counts, proportions, odds and rates apart by asking what is divided by what: a proportion's numerator is part of its denominator, the odds divide cases by non-cases, and only a rate has person-time in its denominator and carries units. You also know that a count means little until it is set against the population it came from. On the exam, identify the denominator before you trust the name given to a measure, because "rate" is often used loosely.
  2. You can choose the measure that fits a situation: a risk for a closed population followed over a defined period when the risk period is short, a rate with a person-time denominator for an open population, a long risk period or unequal follow-up, and a prevalence when the question is how many people have the disease at a point or during a period. Read each scenario for clues about who joins or leaves and how long each person is followed, and justify your choice in a sentence.
  3. You can calculate an incidence risk (new cases divided by the population at risk at the start, less half the withdrawals) and an incidence rate (new cases divided by exact or approximate person-time), and convert a rate into a risk with R = 1 − e−IΔt, or R ≈ IΔt when IΔt is below about 0.1. Always finish with the period for a risk or the person-time units for a rate, after putting all follow-up into one time unit.
  4. You can calculate a point prevalence and explain that prevalence counts existing cases whereas incidence counts new ones, and that prevalence rises with both incidence and duration, like the water level in the sink. This is why a risk and a point prevalence measured in the same group can differ, and why prevalence is a poor measure for identifying causes; when you are asked why, name both occurrence and duration.
  5. You can calculate and interpret attack rates, secondary attack rates, case fatality rates, mortality rates and proportional mortality, and you know that all of them except the mortality rate are proportions despite their names. Before dividing, decide who belongs in the denominator: everyone exposed for an attack rate, the contacts without the primary cases for a secondary attack rate, the people with the disease for a case fatality rate, the person-time at risk for a mortality rate, and all deaths for proportional mortality.
  6. You can calculate YLLs, YLDs and DALYs and explain how DALYs place fatal and non-fatal health loss on one scale of healthy years lost, so that conditions that mainly kill can be compared with conditions that mainly disable. When you calculate, weight each death by the remaining life expectancy at its age and multiply every YLD by its disability weight.
  7. You can explain why crude rates mislead when populations differ in age structure, calculate and interpret an SMR (observed ÷ expected) and a directly standardised rate, and attach an approximate 95% confidence interval (estimate ± 1.96 × SE) to a proportion or a rate. Remember that each SMR compares one population only with the standard rates, so use directly standardised rates to compare populations with one another, and report every estimate with its interval, since a point estimate without its precision is only half an answer.

Final Knowledge Assessment

This assessment covers all material from this lesson. You must score 100% to complete the lesson. Review the feedback for any incorrect answers and try again.

Final Assessment: Measures of Disease Frequency (16 Questions)

1. A clinic follows 200 adults for 6 months after a hip fracture, and 40 of them develop pneumonia. Which set of values is correctly labelled?

The denominators are swapped. 40 / 160 divides by the non-cases, so it is the odds, and 40 / 200 is the proportion. A proportion with a stated period is still not a rate, which needs person-time.
The proportion is right, but 160 / 40 inverts the odds, which divide cases by non-cases (40 / 160 = 0.25). A rate is not the same number as the proportion, because it divides by person-time.
The proportion divides cases by a total that contains them (40 / 200 = 0.20), the odds divide cases by non-cases (40 / 160 = 0.25), and a rate divides cases by person-time at risk and carries units.
The odds are right, but stating a period does not turn a proportion into a rate. A rate divides the 40 cases by the person-months at risk and carries units of 1/time.
Correct answer: proportion 0.20, odds 0.25, and a rate needs person-time. The information needed is the cases (40), the non-cases (200 − 40 = 160) and the total (200). A proportion divides the cases by a total that contains them (40 / 200 = 0.20, the 6-month risk); the odds divide the cases by the non-cases (40 / 160 = 0.25); a rate divides the cases by the person-time at risk and so carries units, such as cases per person-month. Swapping the two denominators, or inverting the odds, is the common slip: only in a proportion is the numerator part of the denominator, and a proportion with its period stated is still not a rate. (Section 1, 1.2 Counts, Proportions, Odds and Rates, Table 4.1, Eq 4.1 to Eq 4.3 and Worked Example 4.1; Objective 1.2)

2. A health authority must decide how many wound-care nurses to send to its long-term care homes next month, so it needs to know how many residents have an open pressure ulcer that needs dressing. Which measure fits this purpose best?

An incidence rate counts only new ulcers, which suits questions about causes and prevention. It leaves out residents with long-standing ulcers that still need dressing, so it does not describe current workload.
Staffing depends on how many residents need care at one time. Point prevalence counts every existing ulcer on the survey day, however long ago it began, divided by all residents present.
A 90-day incidence risk among new admissions counts only new ulcers in one subgroup, so it leaves out existing ulcers among long-stay residents who also need dressing.
The case fatality rate describes how severe pressure ulcers are among those who have them, not how many residents currently need wound care.
Correct answer: the point prevalence. The information needed is the purpose: staffing depends on how many residents need care at one time, including those whose ulcers began long ago. Point prevalence counts every existing case at a moment and divides by everyone present at that moment, so it describes the current workload. The incidence measures are tempting, but they count only new ulcers, which suits questions about causes and prevention and leaves out residents with long-standing ulcers that still need dressing; the case fatality rate describes severity, not workload. (Section 3, 4.1 Point and Period Prevalence and Eq 4.9; Objectives 2.2 and 4.1)

3. A travel-health report states: “Among travellers who were free of the infection when they arrived, the 2-week incidence risk was 0.06.” Which plain-words reading is correct?

Including travellers who arrived with the infection describes a period prevalence. Incidence risk counts only new infections among those who arrived free of it.
A risk is a probability with no units, read with its period. Cases per traveller-week are the units of a rate, which divides by person-time rather than by people at risk.
Dividing by travellers who stayed well describes odds, whose denominator is the non-cases. A risk divides new cases by everyone at risk at the start.
Incidence risk divides new cases during a period by those free of the disease at the start, giving a probability with no units: about a 6% chance of infection within the 2 weeks.
Correct answer: a traveller who arrived free of the infection had about a 6% chance of becoming infected within 2 weeks. The information needed is the definition of incidence risk: new cases during a stated period divided by the people at risk (free of the disease) at the start. It is a probability with no units, read with its period, and it counts only new infections among people who could get them. The first option describes a period prevalence, because it includes people who arrived already infected; the second gives the risk the units of a rate; and the third describes odds, whose denominator is the people who stayed well. (Section 2, 3.1 Four Ways to Express Incidence, panel Incidence Risk (R), and 3.2.1 Incidence Risk in a Closed Population, Eq 4.4; Objectives 3.1 and 3.2)

4. A fitness centre follows its members for one year for a first sports injury. At the start, 540 members are injury-free. During the year, 60 are injured, 40 cancel their membership and 20 new members join; exact dates are not recorded. Using the approximate formula, which places every event at the midpoint of the year, what is the incidence rate?

Approximate number at risk = 540 − ½(60) − ½(40) + ½(20) = 500, giving 500 person-years over one year, and I = 60 / 500 = 0.12 per person-year, or 120 per 1,000 person-years.
Dividing by 540 ignores the events: injured members stop being at risk, cancelled members leave and new members add time, and each event is placed at mid-year in the approximate formula.
540 − 60 − 40 + 20 = 460 uses whole numbers instead of halves, treating everyone who was injured, left or joined as contributing no time at all, although each was present for about half the year.
The denominator of 500 is right, but it is 500 person-years, so the result is a rate, 0.12 per person-year. A rate carries units and is not the proportion of members injured.
Correct answer: 120 per 1,000 person-years. The information needed is the starting number (540), the cases (60), the withdrawals (40), the additions (20) and the length of the period (1 year). Step 1: approximate number at risk = 540 − ½(60) − ½(40) + ½(20) = 540 − 30 − 20 + 10 = 500. Step 2: person-time = 500 × 1 year = 500 person-years. Step 3: I = 60 / 500 = 0.12 cases per person-year, or 120 per 1,000 person-years. Using whole numbers instead of halves (540 − 60 − 40 + 20 = 460) treats everyone who was injured, left or joined as contributing no time at all, ignoring the events gives 540, and a rate carries units, so it is not a percentage. (Section 2, 3.2.3 Incidence Rate from Approximate Person-Time, Eq 4.6, Worked Example 4.4 and Calculator 4.3; Objective 3.2)

5. A school district follows 1,050 children who have never had chickenpox and are not vaccinated against it, for one school year. During the year, 90 develop chickenpox, and 100 move out of the district partway through (assume, on average, at mid-year). What is the one-year incidence risk?

Dividing by 1,050 treats the 100 children who moved as if they had been followed for the whole year, although they were observed for only about half of it.
Dividing by 950 subtracts all 100 movers, treating them as never observed, although on average they were followed until mid-year.
Children who moved were observed for about half the year, so the population at risk is 1,050 − ½ × 100 = 1,000, and R = 90 / 1,000 = 0.090, a 9% risk over the school year.
A risk has no units. Writing it per 1,000 person-years confuses it with a rate, which would need person-time in the denominator rather than the number of children at risk.
Correct answer: 90 / 1,000 = 0.090. The information needed is the children at risk at the start (1,050), the new cases (90) and the withdrawals (100). Step 1: population at risk = 1,050 − ½ × 100 = 1,000, because a child who moved at mid-year was observed for about half the period. Step 2: R = 90 / 1,000 = 0.090, a 9% risk over the school year. Dividing by 1,050 ignores that the movers were not followed for the whole year, and dividing by 950 treats them as never observed at all. A risk has no units, so writing it per 1,000 person-years confuses it with a rate, which would need person-time in the denominator. (Section 2, Closed Population tab in 2.2, 3.2.1 Incidence Risk in a Closed Population and Worked Example 4.2; Objective 3.2)

6. The incidence rate of a cancer among long-term smokers is roughly constant at 4 per 1,000 person-years (0.004 per person-year). What is the risk that a cancer-free smoker develops this cancer within 10 years?

A rate is not a risk. 0.004 is cases per person-year and must be combined with the time at risk, here 10 years, to estimate a probability.
I × Δt = 0.004 × 10 = 0.04, below about 0.1, so the shortcut R ≈ I × Δt is adequate, and the exact 1 − e−0.04 = 0.039 confirms a risk of about 4% over 10 years.
The rate is 4 per 1,000 person-years, not per 100, so 4 × 10 gives 40 per 1,000, or 0.04. Reading it as per 100 overstates the risk tenfold.
Converting a rate to a risk is exactly how a risk is estimated when it cannot be observed directly in a closed population followed for the full period.
Correct answer: about 0.04. The information needed is the rate (0.004 per person-year), the period (10 years) and the rule for the shortcut. Step 1: I × Δt = 0.004 × 10 = 0.04, which is below 0.1, so R ≈ I × Δt = 0.04 is adequate. Step 2: the exact formula R = 1 − e−IΔt = 1 − e−0.04 = 0.039 confirms it: a risk of about 4% over 10 years. A rate is not a risk, because 0.004 is per person-year and must be combined with the time at risk; the rate is 4 per 1,000, not per 100, so 0.40 overstates the risk tenfold; and converting a rate in this way is exactly how a risk is estimated when it cannot be observed directly. (Section 2, 3.3 Converting a Rate to a Risk, Eq 4.7 and Eq 4.8, Worked Example 4.5 and Calculator 4.4; Objective 3.3)

7. A student writes: “The incidence rate and the prevalence both tell us how common a disease is, so they are two names for the same thing.” Which correction is best?

The incidence rate counts new cases over person-time and measures how fast disease arises, with units of 1/time. Prevalence counts every existing case at a point in time as a proportion of the population, with no time units.
The two definitions are reversed. The incidence rate concerns new cases per unit of person-time, while prevalence is the proportion of people who have the disease at a given time.
This is partly right: incidence counts new cases and prevalence counts existing ones. But prevalence divides by the population at that moment or period, not by person-time, so it has no time units.
The difference is not the multiplier. The two measures count different cases (new versus existing) and divide by different things (person-time versus the population), so they answer different questions.
Correct answer: the first option. The information needed is what each measure counts and what it divides by. The incidence rate counts only new cases and divides them by the person-time at risk, so it measures the speed at which disease arises and has units such as cases per person-year. Prevalence counts every existing case, however long ago it began, and divides by the population at the same moment (or during the period), so it is a proportion with no time units that depends on both incidence and duration. The partly right third option fails on the denominator, because prevalence divides by people, not by person-time, and the second option has the two definitions reversed. (Section 2, 3.1 Four Ways to Express Incidence, panel Incidence Rate (I); Section 3, 4.1 Point and Period Prevalence; Objective 4.1)

8. A new antibiotic cures a common infection in 1 week instead of 4 but does nothing to prevent new infections. If the incidence stays the same, what happens to the prevalence of the infection, and why?

Prevalence depends on both incidence and duration, not on new cases alone. With incidence unchanged and each case shortened from 4 weeks to 1, fewer people are ill at any one time.
Diagnosing and treating more infections does not add cases to the pool; the antibiotic shortens each case, so cases leave the pool faster and the prevalence falls.
The direction is right but the reason is wrong. The antibiotic cures infections without preventing them, so the incidence rate stays the same; prevalence falls because duration falls.
With the same incidence and a shorter duration, fewer people are ill at any moment. In the sink, the tap runs as before while the recovery drain opens wider, so the water level falls.
Correct answer: it falls, because each case lasts a shorter time. The information needed is that incidence is unchanged while the duration drops from 4 weeks to 1. Prevalence depends on both incidence and duration (P = I×D / (I×D+1) at steady state), so with the same I and a shorter D, fewer people are ill at any one time. In the sink, the tap (new cases) runs as before but the recovery drain empties the basin faster, so the water level falls. The option claiming that incidence falls is tempting, but a cure shortens illness without preventing it; this is also why a change in prevalence alone cannot show that a factor causes or prevents disease. (Section 3, 4.2 How Prevalence Depends on Incidence and Duration, Eq 4.10 and Interactive 4.1; Objective 4.2)

9. After a staff lunch, 90 people ate the sushi and 27 of them became ill within 48 hours; 40 people did not eat it, and 4 of them became ill. A colleague reports the attack rate for sushi as 87%, “because 27 of the 31 people who became ill ate the sushi.” What is the correct attack rate for sushi, and what does it mean?

27 / 31 divides by the ill people, so it gives the share of cases who ate the sushi, which would be high for any popular food. An attack rate divides the ill by everyone exposed.
An attack rate divides those who became ill by everyone exposed: 27 / 90 = 0.30, so 30% of sushi eaters became ill. Despite the word “rate”, it is a risk among the exposed.
Dividing by all 130 at the lunch mixes eaters and non-eaters. The attack rate for sushi uses only the 90 people who ate it in the denominator.
31 / 130 is the overall attack rate, but attack rates can also be calculated within each group: 27 / 90 among sushi eaters and 4 / 40 among those who did not eat it.
Correct answer: 27 / 90 = 0.30. The information needed is how many people ate the sushi (90) and how many of them became ill (27). An attack rate is the number who became ill divided by the number exposed during the outbreak, so it is a risk (a proportion) despite the word “rate”: 27 / 90 = 0.30, meaning 30% of sushi eaters became ill. The colleague divided by the ill people instead of by the exposed people; 27 / 31 answers a different question (what share of the cases ate the sushi) and would be high for any popular food. For comparison, the attack rate among those who did not eat it is 4 / 40 = 0.10, so the risk ratio is 0.30 / 0.10 = 3.0. (Section 3, card Attack Rate in 5.2.1 and the Attack rate tab in 5.2.2, Eq 4.14 and Worked Example 4.10; Objective 5.2)

10. Last year, 30% of all deaths in Region A and 20% of all deaths in Region B were from cancer. A news story concludes that residents of Region A are more likely to die of cancer. Which response is correct?

A larger share of deaths does not mean a larger risk. Proportional mortality divides by all deaths, not by the population, so a region where fewer people die of other causes will show a larger cancer share.
Proportional mortality is not a rate; its denominator is all deaths, not person-time or the population at risk, so it does not allow for the size of each population.
Because proportional mortality divides cancer deaths by all deaths, Region A’s share can be higher simply because other causes kill fewer people there. Comparing the risk needs cancer deaths divided by each region’s person-time.
Proportional mortality can be calculated for any cause of death, including cancer. The conclusion may be wrong, but because the measure’s denominator is all deaths, not the population.
Correct answer: the conclusion may be wrong, because the denominator is all deaths, not the population. The information needed is what proportional mortality divides by: deaths from one cause ÷ deaths from all causes. Because the population at risk does not enter the calculation, one cause’s share rises whenever other causes of death fall. For example, if each region has 100,000 residents and 300 cancer deaths, but Region A has 1,000 deaths in all and Region B 1,500, the shares are 300 / 1,000 = 30% and 300 / 1,500 = 20%, although the cancer mortality rate is the same (300 per 100,000 person-years). To compare the risk of dying of cancer, divide cancer deaths by each population’s person-time, ideally with age standardisation. (Section 3, card Proportional Morbidity/Mortality in 5.2.1 and the Proportional mortality tab in 5.2.2, Eq 4.17 and Worked Example 4.13; Objectives 5.1 and 5.2)

11. On a 10-day cruise, 2,000 passengers board in good health and all stay aboard. Over the cruise, 300 of them develop a norovirus illness that lasts about 2 days. At noon on day 6, 60 passengers are ill. What is the point prevalence at noon on day 6, and why does it differ from the 10-day incidence risk?

Point prevalence = 60 / 2,000 = 0.03, against a 10-day risk of 300 / 2,000 = 0.15. With a 2-day illness, most passengers who fall ill have either recovered or not yet become ill at any one moment.
The denominator of a prevalence is everyone aboard at that moment, not only the passengers who became ill. Dividing 60 by the 300 cases does not give a prevalence.
The value is right, but the reason has it backwards: prevalence counts every existing case at that moment, whenever it began. It is lower because the illness is short.
Point prevalence is a proportion with no time units, not a rate per passenger-day, and it can be compared with a risk; the comparison shows the effect of the short duration.
Correct answer: P = 0.03, lower than the risk because the illness is short. The information needed is the number ill at noon on day 6 (60), the number aboard at that moment (2,000) and, for comparison, the new cases over the whole cruise (300 among the 2,000 at risk). Point prevalence = existing cases at a moment ÷ population at that moment = 60 / 2,000 = 0.03 (3%), a proportion with no time units; the 10-day risk = 300 / 2,000 = 0.15 counts every new case over the period. Because prevalence depends on both incidence and duration, a 2-day illness leaves only a small share of passengers ill at any one time. The option saying that prevalence counts only new cases has it backwards: prevalence counts every existing case at that moment, whenever it began. (Section 3, 4.1 Point and Period Prevalence and Eq 4.9; Objective 4.1)

12. A public-health nurse follows the households of 40 children who caught pertussis (whooping cough) at school. These households contain 170 people in total, including the 40 primary cases, and 26 of the other household members later develop pertussis. Which statement correctly gives and interprets the secondary attack rate?

26 / 170 keeps the 40 primary cases in the denominator, although they were infected at school and could not become secondary cases, so it understates the spread.
Adding the primary cases to both numerator and denominator mixes cases infected at school with those infected at home. The secondary attack rate removes the primary cases from both.
26 / 40 divides by the primary cases, who are not the people at risk, and a secondary attack rate measures how easily infection spreads, not how severe it is.
Contacts at risk = 170 − 40 = 130, so SAR = 26 / 130 = 0.20: one in five household contacts of a child with pertussis caught it, a measure of person-to-person spread.
Correct answer: 26 / 130 = 0.20. The information needed is the number of secondary cases (26), the number of people in the households (170) and the number of primary cases (40). Step 1: contacts at risk = 170 − 40 = 130, because the primary cases were infected at school and cannot become secondary cases. Step 2: SAR = 26 / 130 = 0.20, the same as (all cases − primary cases) ÷ (people in the households − primary cases) = (66 − 40) / (170 − 40). In plain words, 20% of the household contacts of a first case became ill, which measures how easily the infection passes from person to person. Keeping the primary cases in the denominator (26 / 170) understates the spread, and dividing by the primary cases describes neither spread nor severity. (Section 3, card Secondary Attack Rate in 5.2.1 and the Secondary attack rate tab in 5.2.2, Eq 4.15 and Worked Example 4.11; Objective 5.2)

13. Over four years, 50 cases of occupational asthma occur among the staff of a bakery chain. Staff are hired and leave throughout; 1,000 different people worked there at some time, and together they contributed 2,500 person-years at risk. A manager reports the risk as 50 / 1,000 = 5% “over four years.” What is the main problem, and what should be reported instead?

A head count is the usual denominator for a risk only when everyone is followed for the whole period. In an open workforce, many of the 1,000 were present for only part of the four years.
With staff hired and leaving throughout, a head count does not reflect time at risk. The incidence rate, 50 / 2,500 = 0.020 per person-year or 20 per 1,000 person-years, allows for each person’s actual time.
The half-withdrawal correction is a small adjustment for a few losses from a closed group, not a fix for a workforce that is continually changing. Halving the whole workforce has no basis.
Dividing by person-time is right, but the result is a rate, 0.020 per person-year, not a percentage risk over four years. A rate is reported per unit of person-time.
Correct answer: report the incidence rate. The information needed is that the workforce is open (people joined and left throughout) and that the person-time at risk (2,500 person-years) is known. A risk assumes that everyone in the denominator was followed for the whole period, but many of the 1,000 workers were present for only part of the four years, so 5% has no clear period. Dividing by the person-time gives I = 50 / 2,500 = 0.020 cases per person-year, or 20 per 1,000 person-years, which allows for each person’s actual time at risk; it is a rate, so it is reported per unit of person-time, not as a percentage over four years. The half-withdrawal correction is tempting, but it applies to a few losses from a closed group, not to a workforce that is continually changing. (Section 1, Risk Period tab in 2.1; Section 2, Open Population tab in 2.2 and the box Reporting a Rate in Convenient Units in 3.2.3; Objectives 2.1 and 2.2)

14. During a study, an industrial town contributed 10,000 person-years under age 50 and 5,000 person-years at age 50 and over, and recorded 50 cases of a lung disease. The provincial (standard) rates are 1 per 1,000 person-years under age 50 and 6 per 1,000 person-years at age 50 and over. What are the expected cases and the SMR, and what does the SMR mean?

E = 40 is right, but 40 / 50 puts expected over observed and reverses the ratio. SMR = observed ÷ expected = 50 / 40 = 1.25, an excess rather than a deficit.
52.5 comes from averaging the two standard rates and applying the average to all 15,000 person-years, which ignores how the town’s person-time is split by age, the very thing indirect standardisation uses.
Expected cases = 10,000 × 1 / 1,000 + 5,000 × 6 / 1,000 = 10 + 30 = 40, and SMR = 50 / 40 = 1.25: about 25% more cases than the provincial rates predict for the town’s age structure.
E = 40 and an SMR of 1.25 are right, but an SMR is a ratio of observed to expected counts, so it has no units and is not a rate per 1,000 person-years.
Correct answer: E = 40 and SMR = 1.25. The information needed is the town’s person-time in each age group, the standard (provincial) rate in each group and the observed cases. Step 1: expected cases = the sum of town person-years × standard rate = 10,000 × 1 / 1,000 + 5,000 × 6 / 1,000 = 10 + 30 = 40. Step 2: SMR = observed ÷ expected = 50 / 40 = 1.25, so the town recorded about 25% more cases than the provincial rates predict for a population with its age structure. The value 52.5 comes from averaging the two standard rates ((1 + 6) / 2 = 3.5 per 1,000 × 15,000), which ignores how the town’s person-time is split between the age groups, the very thing indirect standardisation uses; putting expected over observed reverses the ratio, and an SMR is a ratio of counts with no units. (Section 4, 7.2.1 Indirect Standardisation, Eq 4.18 and Eq 4.19, Worked Example 4.15 and Calculator 4.14; Objective 7.2)

15. In one year, a district records 4 deaths from drowning at age 20, where the remaining life expectancy is 65 years, and 26 deaths from a chronic lung disease at age 85, where the remaining life expectancy is 6 years. Which statement about years of life lost (YLL) is correct?

YLL = Σ Nx × Lx gives 4 × 65 = 260 for drowning and 26 × 6 = 156 for the lung disease. Four young deaths cut off more years of life than 26 deaths in old age.
A death count treats every death the same. YLL weights each death by the remaining life expectancy at that age, so the 26 late deaths add fewer years lost than the 4 early ones.
YLL does not count each death once; it multiplies the deaths at each age by the remaining life expectancy at that age, so deaths at different ages contribute different numbers of years.
This multiplies by the age at death instead of the years remaining, which reverses the logic: a later death leaves fewer years lost, not more.
Correct answer: drowning, with 260 YLLs against 156. The information needed is the number of deaths at each age (Nx) and the remaining life expectancy at that age (Lx). Step 1: YLL = Σ Nx × Lx, so drowning gives 4 × 65 = 260 years and the lung disease 26 × 6 = 156 years. Step 2: the four young deaths cut off more years of life than the 26 deaths in old age, which a simple death count would hide. Multiplying by the age at death instead of the years remaining reverses the logic, because a later death leaves fewer years lost; a full DALY comparison would also add the years lived with disability, which would raise the lung disease’s total. (Section 3, 6.1.1 Years of Life Lost (YLL), Eq 4.11, Worked Example 4.7 and Calculator 4.7; Objective 6.1)

16. On a 10-day cruise, 1,250 passengers board in good health, and 150 develop a norovirus illness that usually lasts one to two days. To find the source, a colleague proposes comparing the proportion of passengers who are ill at 8 a.m. on day 6 among those who did and did not eat at the buffet. Which approach is better, and why?

Measuring both groups at one moment gives a prevalence, which depends on duration and on when people fell ill. It misses those who had recovered or not yet become ill, so the comparison can reflect timing rather than the buffet.
Raw counts of ill passengers depend on how many passengers ate at the buffet. Without dividing by the number exposed in each group, a larger count may simply reflect a larger group.
The share of ill passengers who ate at the buffet has the cases, not the exposed, as its denominator, so it would be high for any popular meal and cannot compare risk between groups.
An attack rate counts every new case over the voyage among all who ate at the buffet, and the same among those who did not, so it measures occurrence alone. Comparing the two, for example as a risk ratio, shows the association.
Correct answer: compare the attack rates. The information needed is what each measure counts. A day-6 prevalence depends on how long the illness lasts and on when people fell ill, so it misses everyone who had already recovered or who fell ill later, and a difference between groups could reflect timing or duration rather than the buffet. The attack rate in each group counts every new case over the voyage among everyone exposed (or not exposed), so it measures occurrence alone, and comparing the two, for example as a risk ratio, shows whether eating at the buffet was associated with becoming ill. Raw counts depend on how many passengers ate at the buffet, and the share of cases who ate there has the cases, not the exposed passengers, as its denominator. (Section 3, 4.2 How Prevalence Depends on Incidence and Duration and the Attack rate tab in 5.2.2, Eq 4.14; Objectives 4.2 and 5.2)

✦ Pass every section knowledge check with 100% before submitting